Death Row Doctor: Why I Take Part in Executions | Op-Docs
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 вер 2024
- Can the vow that doctors take to “do no harm” permit taking part in capital punishment? This week, the New York Times Op-Docs brings you “Death Row Doctor,” about Dr. Carlo Musso and his assistance with executions in Georgia. Directed by Lauren Knapp, the film challenges us to answer the question of whether having a doctor in the execution chamber is a perversion of medicine … or a common-sense act of mercy.
More from The New York Times Video:
Subscribe: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
Watch all of our videos here: nytimes.com/video
Facebook: / nytvideo
Twitter: / nytvideo
----------
Op-Docs is a forum for short, opinionated documentaries by independent filmmakers. Learn more about Op-Docs and how to submit to the series. Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram (@NYTopinion).
For those still confused /didnt watch the video: He doesn't agree with the death penalty. But he believes that someone who is about to be sentenced to death should have someone who knows what they're doing to take care of them so that their death is carried out properly and isn't done wrong so that theres a lot of suffering.
The documentary doesn't say that, those are your words. We still don't know what his role is. It may be simply pronouncing death.
David Marskell 3:00 he says he is not an advocate of the death penalty.
yes, but if he and all other medical personnel boycotted the process then there could be no executions
@@Mikee22ification that's where you're wrong. In many states doctors refuse because it goes against the hypocratic oath and so ill trained people who aren't doctors or nurses place the IVs it's lead to veins bursting and horrible deaths
@@Mikee22ification Zinnia is correct. You don't have to be a board-certified physician (medical personnel) to carry out an execution. If you had the choice of having your execution administered by a physician versus anyone else, you would choose the physician. Very few people would want to die painfully.
This guy has the most sad eyes
Keenan Johnston, I wondered if it was just me or would anybody else see that.
Keenan Johnston I see it too. It looks like despair
He feels the obligation to do it, but he definitely thinks the whole thing is rotten.
You would have sad eyes if you had to end someone's life
*Junko Enoshima wants to know your place*
I am very against the death penalty, but I support that doctor 100 % because if it was a family member or I who were sentenced to death, I'd want him there to make sure the correctional officers don't botch it!
Kyle Kriticos so if a guy kills a person he can’t be killed for taking another life? I respect your opinion but I just would like to know why you think it’s wrong.
You have such a negative view of correctional officers. They keep wolves from sheep like you.
I agree with you: If all doctors refused to do lethal injection, then the correctional officers would be there to go back to electrocution or some other form. Lethal injection is one of the more humane ways to perform the execution.
@@allenz7688 The most humane way for individuals who commit inhumane acts against humane individuals.
Oh please, this guy isn't just making sure it isn't botched. He's been accused of providing the drugs to the states, that they otherwise couldn't get. He is doing harm, taking part in harm. His hands are bloody, even if his conscience is blank.
Despite not necessarily agreeing to capital punishments, I still think the doctor's stance is quite fascinating.
For him, as long as executions are still going to happen according to law, he finds it responsible to be the one who perform those executions in ways that feel most peaceful and respectful to those prisoners. That is something I can agree to because this option is much better than seeing prisoners being killed disrespectfully or tortured in death. Most people take law as all or nothing, but in the transition period of the law to be change, this is the best option for the prisoners.
Have you ever heard about Hanna Arendt’s concept of “banality of evil”? On her book, Eichmann in Jerusalem, she understood that the nazis who executed millions weren’t psychopaths or monsters, they were farmers, bureaucrats, normal every day people. But they all had something in common: they were following orders. This also created the concept of “herd morality”, short speaking: people would do atrocities just because they were told so, without deeply reflecting about it. So I honestly think that doing something just because “it’s in the law” or it’s permitted doesn’t mean it’s ethical. Just something so you can reflect and think deeper about. Sorry for any misspellings, english is not my first language. Farewell!
The same argument can be made for the people carrying out the execution. "If executions are still going to happen, it might as well be that a person like me gets involved to make sure it goes smoothly for the benefit of the condemned." It is a slippery slope.
Victor
They would still want executions. Most people that are for the death penalty don't really want the process to be humane. They want the prisoners to suffer. So if there was no doctor to smooth the event over as much as possible, they would be totally fine with that. In my personal opinion, it's a sickening mindset to have, but many have exactly that.
@@AmbyJeans But Amby, some people carry out monstrosities whose only punishment is death. Or how would you punish someone like Kenneth Mcduff?
Gabriel Lessa there is also a fascinating documentary on this premise ‘Caring corrupted’ on YT about Nazi nurses who began with compassion which was eventually eroded by the regime
ua-cam.com/video/Rz8ge4aw8Ws/v-deo.html
The execution timestamps were both eye opening and chilling....
Yes
I would hate to see that if it was my own family member regardless of what they'd done.
Seriously! I couldn’t believe there were 5 minutes between the final injection and the pronunciation of death. It made me wonder what kind of suffering happens in those 5 minutes.
That part is what got me...
Lethal injection is a slow, terrifying way to go. But most of them are atleast treated better the days and hours before they go, which is often more than can be said for their victims.... if they have any that is. A lot of innocent men have died on death row. It's hard to grapple with.
Imagine a man walking into a room, looking him in the eyes and knowing you will be one of the last people they ever see
The guy on the gurney already knows that look. He saw it in the eyes of the person or persons he murdered.
Remember, those people are the for a reason.
Ask the inmate about to be executed, they’d know
This is true of any acute healthcare setting, though. The ICU, the ER? Medsurge? You may be the last voice they hear
@@MzShonuff123 agree. thats the reality of not only healthcare workers but on a larger scale, life. you never know when the person beside you (family or in public) would go
I am so intelligent and talented at watching disturbing things before bed
wait edit: finding this a year later I've never gotten this many likes
Gabriel Rader right on me too 😂
Yall not the only ones 😂
Just saw this on my recommendation page and I’m about to go to bed😆
@@lorimitchell9025 haha
I sleep too!
Showing compassion until the very end and having the self-actualization to know that the execution will take place with or without you, and making the choice to participate, and the compassion to make it as painless as possible, is heroic.
Unless Society needs to make an example of the condemned, it should be painless & quick. My grandfather wrote the medical protocols for treating concentration camp survivors for the US Army while serving in a Frontline Feild Hospital during WWII...
No member of the public has seen the footage of a concentration camp at the point of liberation, as all the footage is after a few days of burying most of the dead. One of my grandfather's fellow Feild Surgeons lost it during one of the camp liberations, took a short walk, and put his 1911 in his mouth and his family was told he was killed by a stray bullet. The US used an incompetent hangman for its executions after the Nuremberg Trials, so the Nazis kicked and gurgled for a while due to being given too short of a drop...
Our worst monsters need to have an example made out of them, to send a message to potential future monsters that we will have no mercy. Timothy McVeigh should have been given a very public execution and a short drop and being left up until the rope rotted, as he parked his truck bomb so that as many children in the daycare center would be killed as possible...
@@davidhollenshead4892 agreed
@@davidhollenshead4892an entirely different situation. No one needs to be executed in civil life.
You can see a lot in that man’s eyes.
You would feel the same if you had this job
yeah, it's called dollar signs, he's not a volunteer, he gets paid to snuff people out.
@@gibbsm he did say he wishes that he’s able to leave this profession. Is it so hard to believe a rich doctor also has a reason to maintain his moral beliefs? Wealth is not a guarantee of despicableness.
Yeah. He knows he’s a killer. He knows what he’s doing is wrong. You can see that.
Jeff Bozos out here killin the competition and innmates
lololololol
LoL
Just Jeff it.
Dr. Jeff* haha
Jeff Bezos killed my entire family in 2005
There's really not just between black and white. This is one of the profound greys in life.
no it's not. To put it very simple he participated in the killing of a person. To say if he hadn't do it, someone else would, is wrong. Under this premise you can do whatever you want. Given the limited number of qualified individuals and the fact that they are part of a group that took the Hippocratic Oath, it is possible that the state could not have carried out these death sentences. Take, for example, the case where the death penalty was skipped because Europe was not supplying the poisons needed for the trial.
@@genki2705 Just shut up
@@genki2705 well take for example when there are no doctors and they use bullets instead
@@LukasOHS Some people on death row would prefer bullets to lethal injection.
lets not lose track of the maths. every taxpayer and voter is involved in the systematic retribunal execution of another for reasons. reasons that i contend are bad. one's only option is to not feed the construct in every way that one does. you may spend a lifetime and not know all the ways that you contribute to anothers demise. gotta get yourself out of the matrix per say
He seems like a very caring and comforting person. If I were to die on death row, I would want someone like him. You can tell he cares. Sometimes it’s better for you to do the job so you know the patient is treated with dignity. As hard as that is
He has a really nice house too. Gotta pay them bills......
He’s just another killer.
@@peteconrad2077 😂😂 no he’s not. He’s helping people die with some form of dignity considering they were going to die anyway.
I don't like capital punishment. But I don't think he does either. And if it has to be done he's right about his role in the process. The death penalty places this burden on too many people.
Nobody likes capital crime.
@@Mr3344555 54% of people in the US approve of the death penalty.
I approve 😃
@@CIARUNSITE You may want to read Mr3344555's comment again. It doesn't say what I think you think it said. Your response was non-sequitur.
From my studies, people in death row are murderers. Most often serial killers in the US
Here’s a thought. If it weren’t a fully trained doctor overseeing executions, the procedure would be conducted by a lesser trained medical practitioner. That could in turn result in more botched executions. There is plenty of evidence to suggest that poorly employed executions result in needless suffering.
In effect, he could well be fulfilling his Hippocratic oath by ‘doing no harm’ by carrying out executions as efficiently as possible.
I don't really care because imo a botched execution by the state is just as unjust and wrong as a non-botched execution. Don't make it any easier for the state to take citizens life.
@@airhab You would care if it was you who's about to be executed. Take your false morality somewhere else.
NightMusic1 except they may not be.
@ excepte the one who are found innocent after their death
@ 4% of people on death row are likely innocent. That's not an insignificant percentage.
I think a life sentence in true solitary confinement like the federal Supermax in Colorado is worse than the death penalty well that’s my opinion
I agree. But I suppose the argument is that, well, what if new evidence surfaces and they are found not guilty? If they're in solitary confinement they can be released and compensated. If they got the death sentence, they're just dead. Nothing can be done anymore for them.
I don't disagree with capital punishment. Some people just don't deserve to live. Child molesters, rapists, murderers... they deserve to be put to death. However I do think the evidence should be overwhelmingly clear for a judge to sentence someone to death.
Sounds great, you can be the one to pay for his stay
aaron begon Life sentences are cheaper then death sentences due to the significantly longer legal process.
cost too much money to keep that many ppl
@@aaronbegon2092 ironically, it costs more to process an inmate for death row then to let them rot their entire life away...to include the trial, extra appellate processing, and facility maintenance.
The role of the doctor in executions by lethal injection should be to:
1. Check the dose of drugs
2. They have the right person
3 The right drug
4. The I.V catheters and monitors have been correctly placed by the Medical Technician
5. Certify death post execution.
As long as the medical technician and not the doctor administers the lethal cocktail; it's not unethical because they aren't giving it. They're reducing the chances of the condemned prisoner from suffering needlessly through an unintended error. It's more unethical to watch someone writhing and gasping for 45 minutes due to incorrect needle placement.
Frances Sweeney i agree but it is a brutal moral dilemma
A medical "technician" does not start IVs or give medications, including lethal injection. It would be the responsibility of a doctor and/or a nurse. The physicians are in fact the ones ordering the medications and assuring the correct doses are given, along with the nurse and a secondary physician.
Are these advocacy groups that protest this doctor protesting abortion clinics? If they are pro-life- okay. But if they are "pro-choice"- then they are hypocrites.
Idc about this ethical bs. They are all in the same boat. Death penalty should be abolished, consequences are far too severe if someone is sentenced to death but not guilty
@@MrGrasburg Yeah obviously dude, no one wants the death penalty. The problem is, even if you don't want death penalties to be a reality, the matter of fact is that it is and it will still happen regardless of your beliefs. Hence since death penalties remain, the doc wants to at least make it as swift and as painless as it can be for the patient. So instead of telling him to "stop conducting executions", which won't fix the issue at all, the focus should be on fixing the root of the problem, the fact that death penalties remain.
He is so haunted by what hes doing even though he wont admit one look in his eyes tells me all i need to know
Amen
He's right. If I had a family member being executed, I would rather an experienced physician were there than not.
So much trouble, so much suffering in this world. Somehow, the presence of someone experienced in life and death being present would make something horrible seem less chaotic.
That time count of sequence of events... Oosh it made me freeze in sadness. The sureality of the death penalty changed.
Holy crap...that puzzle.
My God the time stamp was depressing my thoughts just went sicko mode and made it 10x worse
Can i get a travy patty before i go sicko mode???
sucko mode
I was watching a video about using fentanyl to execute prisoners. In the comments people were saying how wrong it is that someone gets injected and then just drifts off to sleep, never to wake up.
It seems important to them the prisoner is awake and suffers. The whole system seems to be more about revenge for the victims family than a humane method of execution. If they want that then a family member should step up and press the button that starts the syringes pumping. I doubt many of them will be able to do it. It's not an easy thing to do killing someone.
I would, to the people who assaulted me, my mother and my friends. Easily. And why should the criminal not suffer the consequences of their action and go sleep-sleep easily but the victim has to live with therapy, drugs, trauma, depression for life and likely s**cide over the life long damage?
@@DivineLightPaladin I agree 100%. The original commenter likely hasn’t experienced anything severe enough to truly know what they’re saying here. I have no doubt that if I were murdered (or worse), any one of my family members would be happy to press the button. And I would for them
Much respect to this man for being a kind hand in a very difficult time.
I was a strong supporter of capital punishment until something my biology prof said made me really rethink my position. He said that you can never prove a theory, only disprove because you can never account for every variable. Apply that to legal. No matter how much we know and think we understand, we will never be able to account for every variable that was present when a crime was committed. Adding knowledge I have gained from having lived with a severe illness, I have seen on multiple occasions how disease process has progressed in me in ways experts said could never happen and can't be explained. Putting this all together my position has changed. We can never prove with 100% certainly that a person committed the crime. We can find beyond reasonable doubt and give a life sentence but I do not believe we should execute someone when 100% certainty can never be obtained.
It can be if they confess.
@@caitolent Confessing is famously unreliable, interrogators force confessions on the regular
What about video proof?
Meh. Then everyone should just get away with everything? Disagree still. So if you have a video of someone stabbing someone else and the victim says yeah that guy did it, is there still a chance he didn't do it? Yeah no.
You explained this beautifully and it's always been a strong belief of mine, but you worded it perfectly. For the same reason, I've never agreed with death penalty either.
I wasn't in the execution room, so I know there is no comparison, but just reading the timeline of events, I felt my heart racing.
I respect why he does his job. I absolutely cannot stomach the death penalty and I hope it goes away in my life time.
How do you feel about what murderers do? That all ok with you?
It is an interesting take. The way I view it, he is not performing and execution. He has been hired by the state to check a body for signs of life.
Every person involved is participating in a murder. They tell themselves lies to make themselves feel justified. At the end of the day, they’ve all done the same exact thing they say is “wrong”.
I have tremendous respect for this man.
He is obviously a deep, thoughtful and dignified human being who contemplates his actions and the consequences of his responsibilities but also understands the workings of the world and society.
A bit like oppenheimer in that regard.
Tough subject but beautifully done. I'm conflicted when it comes to capital punishment, wavering between agreement and disagreement on a case to case basis. Anything to do with murder of a child then I wholeheartedly agree but at other times I am in Incensed that a person has been executed on such flimsy evidence. Robert pruett is a good example.
From a utilitarian perspective - and one that I ascribe myself to - the wrongs of killing an innocent man far outweigh the rights of killing a bad man.
katie lister I am from a country that does not have capital punishment and sees it as barbaric. The way I see it is even the horrible murderers are in some ways getting an easy out by execution. Life long loss of liberty forces the person to reconcile who they really are and spend a life time facing up to it. There also are some murders where there is a reasonable shot at some kind of redemption.
The guy in this case confessed.
If you’re a liar and you believe lying is wrong, but you yourself lie due to the liar lying… makes zero sense. I totally understand the concept behind death penalty, yet in reality it’s just showing us that people say murder is wrong and shouldn’t happen, yet they’re ok murdering in return. Sends quite an interesting message.
I feel like you too, conflicted but crimes/murder against children and the elderly deserve capital punishment.
My sympathies are for the victims who in most cases suffered.
So many people care about the prisoner suffering. I care about the suffering inflicted on the victims.
@@jenv2402 ...... and do you actually believe their suffering is ended by the death of the prisoner? It most assuredly is not.
@@SpeccyMan the victims are dead. As far as their friends and family, no, their trama will never completely go away. I wasn't commenting on that.
Truth to that
I think that some people deserve to suffer for what they have done
I always thought a doctor couldn't take any part in execution because of the oath they take becoming a doctor.... I prefer a doctor to be there to see execution all the way through properly...
But there doctors who perform abortions, what's the difference?
If I had a loved one on death row facing the inevitable, I would want someone like him to be the physician. He may not agree but the man has heart. Could you ask for anything more in that situation?
If I, or someone in my family, were condemned to die, I’d want this doctor to be the guy to administer the drugs. He has a quiet dignity and I respect him very much. I’m a nurse from the Scottish highlands and we don’t have the death penalty over here.
Dude kinda looks like Jeff Bezos lol
You're a simp
AwesomeDude333 Only more compassionate.
Whole time I was thinking that.
Maybe he needs a side gig because of his divorce.
And looks like it two
It is the very same thing I thought as being an official veterinarian working in slaughterhouses...vets are not born to supervise death, but animals need to be protected from unnecessary cruelty and this is one of the reasons veterinarians NEED TO BE THERE...at least untill no more meat is wanted...
Those eyes. They have seen things.
I agree with Dr. Musso's stance, and would assist in executions as an RN if I could. Everyone deserves as peaceful a death as possible. I am not killing them, the state is. I am against capital punishment, but as long as it exists I want to ensure that the least harm occurs from it as possible. Like Dr. Musso, I hope very much that the law is changed so that his services are no longer needed.
What about a victim who's body is dismembered? Did they want to die that way or a peaceful way?
Hearing the protesters sing while the time stamps of the execution are shown made me want to cry
Why don't you read about the victim.
Agrees sickening isnt it the religion that says these scum will go to heaven but Dahli Lama suffers eternally
Legend has it... none of his death row patients have ever complained after their last visit
Changeling nerd
Federico Olivares lol 😂 that made my night
@Changeling sure buddy, whatever makes you sleep better
@@thelaniakean thanks!
That’s hilarious! 😂😂😂
Sadly these prisoners will get better medical treatment at the end of their lives than most 3rd world people ever recieve.
I confirm this
So
... or even working citizens of the US, for that matter. At least they get medical care. A person can work full time and still not be able to afford medical since all of that money goes to merely keeping a roof over their head.
In fact, people have gone to prison solely for the desire to get medical care.
The death penalty is the easy way out for them. It's the easier way out compared to what most of them have done to their victims.
If i was facing life in jail, i would want the death penalty too!
@Sophie S When people complain about taxes you sound not that educated. Where else do you think the money is supposed to come from? Also, it is cheaper to have someone locked up for life. Finally, can you explain how it is torturing society? No one really cares about the prisoner for their whole life.
@Sophie S The trial is much more expensive. Google it if you want more information but the trial is expensive because you have to pay for the judge, the jury, and if they are facing death their trial takes much longer.
@Sophie S that is kinda the point... and what do you mean in the long run. Court fees are more expensive. Google it all.
@Sophie S deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/costs just use this site. It explains everything. Also dont you think it is immoral to take someones life?
Sophie S It costs upwards of 50,000 dollars per year for a prisoner, and capital punishment trials are deciding weather if it’s life or death, so the cost is the same.
Odd that the same political party that is pro-life is also pro-death penalty.
Because they're pro-birth, not pro-life
@@a_grape_in_space1016 exactly
Not all of us feel that way. I am pro-life and also anti-death penalty. No one has the right to take someone else's life.
There are people on death row that are innocent.
Thats why we need to reform the prison/court system.
However, the truly guilty need to remain.
Then get your PATHETIC legal system sorted out
Did not expect to come out of this liking the doctor.
Living is more painful than dying.
That says a lot about society
Very negative mindset there, you doing alright?
Not true but ok
I can understand the doctor's point of view. He is OK in my book.
This reminds me of a poem my daughter wrote, many years ago.
Black and White
If he sees the ball as white
And your side's black as night
Let us turn the ball around
You'll find both black and white
Two sides there are to everything
So when you think you're right
Just put yourself within his place
You'll see that ball as white!
Thank you for accepting this responsibility
Without doubt this man has deep sadness in his eyes. I believe in his heart he knows he goes against the reason why he became a doctor in the first place and he is supposed to perserve life. Capital punishment I have never agreed with and believe 'life' should mean 'life behind bars' so they know everyday their liberty and freedom is no more. Executions set them free and they suffer no more, unlike the victims families and friends, who have to live on without their loved ones. No to the death penalty! Let them rot in jail til their end comes!
me as an M.D. would never be able the do this, I don’t and will never understand his arguments for doing so.
I know, it's a horrible situation. Although I do see where he is coming from, most prisons don't even have medically trained people administering the drugs so the executions are often botched. I don't think the doctor agrees with capital punishment, he just thinks that if it is going to happen then he should make sure the people aren't being tortured while being executed.
Bless that doctor. Heart goes out to him.
Why. Hes violated the hippocratic oath many times over.?
He's no angel...hes a disgrace to his profession
What gives anyone the right to condemn another creature to death?
You eat meat ?
What an interesting man
The puzzle on his pool-table is called Big Sky Saloon. I have it hung on my wall…
I was offered a similar position but refused. I can’t help but think it’s a dead end job.
Heh, that was kinda funny
Dead right
I'm quite surprised to see that nobody mentioned this: he is the head of a company that, apart from providing medical care to 40 jails and prisons in 4 states (as mentioned in the video), also provides these kinds of "medical" services. I can only assume that means that he is making money off of this sort of thing, whether he actually participates directly in all of the executions or not.
Yes, he's said that he is anti-death penalty, and he makes some good points about "I would rather a physician like me be present", etc. But you have to remember, this is his job, and not only his job, but his business. Of course he's not going to come out directly and say "I'm 100% for this, they deserve it". That would be bad for business.
I could be wrong but the fact that there's money involved beyond just his personal salary makes me quite skeptical. He didn't quite convince me.
idk i feel like thats a really hard job to have an he deserves to get paid well. i dont support the death penalty but in my eyes hes doing a humane service and it must be very taxing and he deserves to make a good living w that service. and him having a business that employs others to do the same, seems along the same vein of humanity.. to me sounds like his line of work is not the issue..
@@saradean6592 You might be right. I don't know. I just thought it was important to mention that it's not just his job, but his business, too.. That's another variable to consider. We may never know the ultimate truth about him
Since our legal system is based on how much money you have for your defemse its not that hard to realize there are some innocent people being killed. I wouldnt want that on my soul.
Criminals on death row gets more appellate review and scrutiny. Oddly enough, an innocent person on death row is more likely to be released while an innocent person without a death sentence is more likely to rot the rest of their life in prison.
@@allenz7688 agreed, my point is our justice system is based on how much cash you have to mount in your defense. If your poor you cant afford good legal consultation. Even tbough death row inmates get more chances to appeal their cases i still believe we execute a few innocent people that slip through the cracks. I oppose the death penalty because i dont think the justice system gets it right all the time and even one innocent person being killed by the state is to many.
@@freeplax17 I agree that money is a person's best defense, sadly. I oppose death row because it has become an absurdly expensive process. Unfortunately, that would mean that more innocent people rot away in jail, so I'm very conflicted. =(
@@allenz7688 At least life sentence give innocent people time for new evidence to arise, the death penalty is final no matter what arises later.
@@airhab And I wonder how this doctor would feel if he found out that he executed an innocent person, even if he did it in a way that reduced the person's suffering.
Good short documentary. I'm glad i live in a modern country without the Death Penalty.
@Jon Bradfield and we love u 2!
This would make a great doctor show on television. I'd watch it.
"Providing 'health care' in a prison environment." Hey buddy, let's call a spade a spade...
What do you mean? His company provides legitimate health care to prisoners, irrespective of his separate role with capital punishment.
Nobody can be forced to participate in capital punishment.
By working within the system you are preventing the solution of the problem, that being "there is nobody that will execute".
Executions only exist because there are still people fundamentally unethical enough to do them.
When the last 2 people with a medical license refuse, Georgia cannot execute someone anymore.
Thank you for being there. I also am not a proponent of the death penalty. It is a blessing a medical professional is there to ensure the penalty has been carried out and that it was done as humanely as possible, though there is no 'humanely' in taking a life..
It’s crazy how you commit a crime because someone else committed a crime, but trying to justify your crime for theirs😩😩😩
Capital punishment is morally reprehensible. But, those inmates on death row who have to suffer the horrors of capital punishment should have a right to a painless death and a trained doctor, even if the state doesn’t think they have a right ti live. Capital punishment needs to be abolished as soon as possible, but advocates for its abolition shouldn’t be trying to make the people they’re trying to save suffer in the process.
there's probably good money in it too since so few others are willing to do it.
I did some research, it's only between 39.000$-50.000$. Sure that's not nothing..but I thought it'd be more.
@@alessias.4733 per year? Per execution?
@@Bluyless Government employees are paid per year (no commission bonuses). $50,000 sounds way too low for a doctor's salary. According to glassdoor, doctor salaries are between $150,000 and $300,000 in Georgia. As it is a government job, he is likely on the lower end of that range.
@@allenz7688 He owns a prison healthcare company with multiple government contracts, the salary he gets for doing the injections would be nothing compared to the profits he makes off his company.
@@MikeY-iw3uy From what I see online and what was stated in the video, you are correct. He is President of a company called Triage Holding, Inc. which is part of a larger organization called CORRECTHEALTH, which he founded in 2000. Do you think delivering lethal injections helps or hurts his firm overall? He obviously had (at least some of) the contracts before he started doing the lethal injections.
What a beautifully articulated stance. 100% agree.
Imagine getting lethal injection by a random cop that doesn't know anything about heath.
🙏 no words...
How can it be correctional medicine to do this? You can’t correct someone if they’re dead
The process of such an execution should be juxtaposed by the details of the murders and rapes that led to it, in order to be put into perspective. There are monsters in human form on this earth who don't deserve pity and concern because they don't have any. They should be removed from it, clinically, without fuss or emotion.
Ban it. Now.
$18,000 per execution
Doctor says hold my beer
That's cheap compared to keeping these savages alive.
@@flippedoutcookie
You would think a country that wants to execute people with lethal execution drugs would at least manufacture the lethal execution drugs.
The United States doesn’t make anything not even lethal execution drugs.
Shameful
@@thedevilsadvocate5210 International banking is beyond any government and the US has fulfilled it's purpose of helping to rebuild the world after WW2 and is now being drained to industrialize other nations. If Trump is a liar then this nation is as doomed as before because if he won't bring jobs and industry back then the US will continue to be sold out. It is shameful, but these plans were laid out long before either of us were alive and there isn't a thing we can do except partake in rigged voting.
What a sad career to have. :(
I mean people receiving capital punishment are monsters, so maybe it’s kinda gratifying in that regard
Im saying!!!
@@ferkinderkin3165 The majority of the time yes but sometimes no, falsely convicted or mentally ill lunatics.
Executions are inhumane, barbaric, and cruel. The death penalty should be abolished for all crimes. We live in the 21st century, not the 14th century. Also, add in the fact that more than 190 people on death row have been found innocent.
What about terrorism? What if hundreds die what should happen to the inmate?
Oh and the murders are all fine than ?
The FACT that your legal system is corrupt and driven by even more corruption is what you should consider before voting
I agree with death penalty.
Me to
That makes you immoral and barbaric in my book. :(
You know, that innocent people have been executed, right? In your name.
My parents told me Cambodia doesn't practice killing a prisoner (capital punishment) like Vietnam because we have respect for other people and we have respect for human lives no matter what. I stand with that statement.
I rather a doctor be there than someone without any medical training butchering it, which has happened.
He seems like a caring and compassionate guy. He's bound by the duties of his job and medical ethics. I feel for him.
I am shocked you filmed the doctor’s home from the outside. You have highly increased his risks of altercations with death row opponents.
Death row opponents are against violence , I’d be more scared of pro death penalty ....
@@salvolondon smooth brain take.
Just so you know, this guy is running a prison medical care empire know for persistent malpractice. He is also being sued for illegally selling lethal injection chemicals to two states. He is a psychopath who is trying to defend his image. He loves this, believe me. No matter how you look at it, the death penalty is so messed up, with or without doctor death.
It is messed up because mericu is too thick to adopt sensible methods
He doesn’t agree with the morality however has searched his Soul and does his best xxx
MAN, I didn't even CONSIDER this as a specialty. I don't know if I could do it. I was trained in corrections. Getting to know prisoners really changed my mind about who we call "bad guys".😈Some of the men DID do evil things. However, it wasn't the totality of who they were as humans.
For those who believe the actual guilty should be sentenced, do you feel the risks of rarer incorrect sentencing outweighs the justice in correct sentencing?
I am not American so I genuinely apologize in advance if my point of view is flawed due to limited knowledge of the American justice system. The way investigations and technology have advanced, I believe finding the culprit has become much more accurate than it was some decades ago, especially with the advancement of DNA analysis and also I think (again, I might be wrong) trials nowadays drag over a longer period of time than they used to. Definitely at the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th, when death sentences were given out like Halloween candy, trials seemed to last for a short time and they often sentenced someone without much evidence and sometimes even based on faulty eyewitnesses and false confessions. But nowadays I think that is extremely rare.
Take Christa Pike's case - she killed a fellow teenager in the 80s and taunted and tortured her before she did so. All because she believed she was trying to steal her boyfriend (she wasn't). She got the death penalty and is still awaiting execution. Every evidence led to her and there was no denying she did it because she actually kept a piece of Coleen's (the victim) skull as a souvenir. Do I believe Christa deserved the death penalty? Yes.
Tiffany Cole killed an elderly couple that had helped her in the past because she wanted to steal their car and their money. The couple got buried alive. She denied having a big part in the murder (her boyfriend and another guy helped), but she spent the Sumners' money and then called their bank after a few days because the bank had put a hold on their credit cards, trying to milk that cash cow further. She was also the only one who personally knew the Sumners. There's no denying that she had a big part in the killings. Do I think she deserved the death penalty as well? Yes.
I am aware that incorrect sentencing happens, though I really want to believe it's much, much rarer nowadays than it used to. But would I want to be in the shoes of someone wrongly sentenced? No, not at all. See, it's a bit of a grey area here. I agree with the death sentence in the cases of violent and premeditated killings, serial murders, and child molesters. I also definitely agree with it if ALL evidence points to the suspect and they are without a doubt guilty. But I also know some things slip and innocent people can be wrongly sentenced. It's a very sensitive topic and I hope I have not offended you or anyone with what I have said.
@@floraflowers I agree entirely. Of course, I didn’t want to put my opinion in the comment for sake of being unbiased
2:45 I love the imagery of the twig & needles resembling barbed wire. Haunting.
I oppose the death penalty, but if it's being put into practice, it's best to have an experienced physician involved in the process. It's a grim job, but someone's gotta do it.
@Main Street Boxer Just because I prefer that executions be competently carried out rather than incompetently carried out doesn't mean I support the death penalty. It is not realistic to suggest that there could be a scenario in which everyone refused to perform the task of execution. If the death penalty is allowed by law, there will always be someone willing to do the job. It is best, then, to ensure that the individual in question is medically experienced and will perform the most professional, humane execution possible.
@Main Street Boxer Anti capital punishment is anti victim. You care more about the killer's life than the life they took.
He has such a valid point. Just because doctors are strongly advised against, or in some cases prohibited, from this prsctice, it doesnt mean the practice will end. It just means it will now be carried out by someone unqualified, who doesnt have the training or knowledge, and can cause forther harm to the prisoner before their death.
Doctors need to be present, bevause they know how to do the job with as little pain as possible, and with as kuch empathy and care as possible. You're condemned, but thst shouldnt mean you're tortured on your way to your sentence.
bill Murray with the hat on Jeff bezos with it off.
There are always victims who died horrific by bad people in worse ways so unimaginable it would leave you shakened with griefs. If one burn a child alive, why can’t it be done same way? Cruel and unusual punishment unlawful. Tell that to a burned child.
I am actually strongly against the death penalty but I understand what he is doing, he is a good doctor
Imagine getting brutally killed then when the guy that killed you finally gets justice their people outside crying and singing amazing grace hoping he doesn’t die
Even though a lot of people out there are real psychopaths , and have done some really sick things to people, i could not do this!!!
you americans are really something special you know
Doctors perform the most absolute form of compassion - and the greatest form of protest - by participating in the execution process.
This man is a hero 🤩
any developed country that still has the death penalty is barbaric.
100% disagree If someone rapes kids and then ties them down and then lights them on fire to be burned to death they deserve to die.
@@mattfishfrog5797 Yes, because comitting a killing cancels the other one out right? You know, that innocent people have been executed? In your name.
Have you guys ever heard about Hanna Arendt’s concept of “banality of evil”? On her book, Eichmann in Jerusalem, she understood that the nazis who executed millions weren’t psychopaths or monsters, they were farmers, bureaucrats, normal every day people. But they all had something in common: they were following orders. This also created the concept of “herd morality”, short speaking: people would do atrocities just because they were told so, without deeply reflecting about it. So I honestly think that doing something just because “it’s in the law” or it’s permitted doesn’t mean it’s ethical. Just something so you can reflect and think deeper about. Sorry for any misspellings, english is not my first language. Farewell!
However Doc seems to have made big money with his job
U really think anybody would take on hundreds of thousands in debt for 10+ long straight years if they weren't gonna make close to half a mil a year lmao. Pretty sure he's doing it for the public service student loan forgiveness program too
true, but it seems that he could have made even more elsewhere(as a doctor) in like a prestigious or private hospital
His company provides health care in 40 prisons in 4 states. Executions are just a small part of his work.
Remember one thing here the inmates who get lethal injection are receiving more peaceful and comfortable deaths than most people in the world have and certainly more humane deaths than their victims received. I only feel against lethal injection because to me it’s not real justice if a murderer gets put to sleep like a dog or cat when they butchered a person. If this country doesn’t want to distribute real justice to victims then the death penalty might as well be abolished and make the prison system more restrictive.
I support the death penalty for individuals who truly committed a horrific sight to be seen by any human.
HOW ABOUT HUMANS WHO HAVE PUT TO DEATH BY THE STATE "MISTAKENLY'? HAVE AN ANSWER TO THAT.
@@edwardjonez6615 Theres always a possibility in everything, but we're humans, there's bound to be some errors we cant really cover. Yes the so called "errors" are actually human lives, but dont just let unnecessary sympathy to cloud rational judgement. So if there's dangerous criminals that are far from repenting roaming around, but because some individuals are so stupidly sympathetic, the criminals get to roam freely ?
When you think about what these murderers have done they get away really easy . We are wimpy with the scum of the scum .