John Macarthur is wrong about Mary!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- this is a reaction video to a UA-cam video title John MacArthur Mary Mother of god?? refuting the falsehoods that John MacArthur puts forward about the Catholic church and the Virgin Mary
The problem with Protestantism is, even when you explain the doctrine of the Catholic Church regarding Mother Mary, their ears and mind are shut. They hear but never listen.
I love the Blessed Mother because Jesus LOVES His mother. Thank you Jesus, for giving us your Mother to love us. She is the perfection of humility, motherhood and womanhood. I love you Jesus, my Lord.
There is LITERALLY NOTHING in scripture that states that Mary is divine, sinless, or worth any prayer. Mark 1:43 states clearly when you add to scripture you nullify scripture. Thats what Catholic dogma does. Nullifies scripture with its nonsense.
@@BrotherMaverickCatholicism does not consider Mary to be divine, and you seem to be woefully ignorant of the theology surrounding intercessory prayer and it’s long history. The earliest liturgical prayer we have is actually a prayer to Mary, called the Sub Tuum Praesidium. You on the other hand are presupposing sola scriptura, which was invented back in the 1500s.
@@BrotherMaverick....and you just confirmed his statement that your ears and mind are shut..well done protester.
@@BrotherMaverickliterally proving the point of the post. Good job, Protty. Repent and rebuke your false Protestantism and accept the true and only Church, founded by Christ Himself.
@@BrotherMaverick
Nor have Catholics ever said she is divine, or worth praying to. Being sinless is evident but that's the least of your problem. Your problem is that you ( anti catholics) keep claiming we claim things that we actually never done. You need to lie about Catholics otherwise your theory wouldn't hold. That's why you don't want to comprehend what we say, because then you couldn't ignore it anymore.
Honestly where have you ever heard that we say Mary is divine?! Sources please!!!
John MacArthur is not alone for other Calvinists like James White think same way. I come a long way from Calvinist viewpoint of Mary to traditional Catholic viewpoint of Mary. I got the impression Calvinists hate Mary in their opposition to Catholicism. That is so sad and tragic.
Calvinism is false. Rooted in human pride.
@@prayerpatroller I agree with you, pride bred arrogance. I ask my Calvinist friends what if they are wrong in interpreting/understanding Scriptures? My friends insist they are right and refuse to admit possibility of mistakes. I myself admit and humble enough to say I make mistakes and willing to learn.
No they simply believe the Word of God as opposed to Roman catholicism , birthed by Emperor Connsatine who grafted in Judaism , and pagen idolatry mixed in with Christianity . Roman's 3 : 23 -- For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God , that is all of humanity JESUS was the only one who never sinned .
Luke 1 , 46:47 Mary says my soul magnifies the Lord , and my Spirit rejoices in God my Savior , why did Mary need a savior if she never sinned ?Of course Mary was blessed amongst all woman she bore the Son of God , but she knew she needed a savior . She was a virgin up until she gave birth to Jesus after which she had four sons , James , Joseph , Simon and Judus named in Mathew 13 , 55 : 56 also sisters not named . They are Mary's children not relatives .
Deuteronomy ch 5-6 1st commandment
You shall have no other God's before me . Deuteronomy ch 5-7 2nd commandent
You shall not make for yourself a carved image or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above , or that is on the earth beneath or that is in the water under the earth , you shall not bow down to them or serve them .
Your religion has removed the second commandment and split the 10th to make the total 10 .
The man making this video clip needs to remember the 9th commandment , Deuteronomy ch 5-20 Neither shall thou bear false witness against thy neighbour
He said John MacArthur and many others HATE Mary that is a lie from the father of lies . He would have been a good pharisee . Read the Bible for yourself , be like the Bereans examine the scriptures and the truth will set you free . NZ
Jesus gave the authority to interpret Holy Scripture to Peter, the Apostles and their successors not to protestants 15 centuries later.
@@Spiritof76Catholic
You are sadly so deluded , Jesus also said to Peter get behind me Satan . At Pentcost Peter was filled with the Holy Spirit and preached the Gospel of God up until his death , when Jesus said upon this rock He is referring to Himslf He being the cornerstone .
Throughout ALL scripture ROCK is allways indicative of our Lord . The church of Christ is built on Christ and Christ alone , no other name under heaven can we be saved . NZ
Jesus saved me from the false “word” of men like this guy and led me home to all truth in his One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Catholic Church. Excellent podcast.
Praise be to God!
Amen!!! Jesus started Catholic church
Welcome home 😊
You are led by Satan
When I lived my life as a Protestant, I had to first humble myself and surrender my will completely to Jesus before I could see clearly. After making up my own religion and conforming God to my will and self interpretation, I became an anathema just like apostle Paul said in Galatians 1:8. Pride is the sin I had in great abundance and I also see it in every one of my Protestant brothers and sisters. I wish I had humbled myself and asked God to guide me long ago. I’m now Catholic about to receive the Eucharist again. I’m so grateful to Jesus for instituting the priesthood and the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. I love you Jesus beyond words will all of my being! Jesus I love you, all that I have is yours, yours I am and yours I want to be; do with me whatever you will. Amen.
Jesus, on the Judgment Throne: So, John, what's this I hear you been saying about my mother?
The shogunate's probably in much better standing with jesus when compared to jmac😂😂😂😂😂
The Word of God is Jesus Christ! I Timothy 2:5 (ultimate author Jesus), "For there is one God and one Mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus..."
His tone of voice! Making fun of Mary. I wonder if John McArthur honored his mother? He acts like Jesus hates his mother! Sick!
Offspring of the serpent, clearly
I agree. He is no Christian in my eyes.
@@laurensgamaif demons hate her(i used too,thanks to my bastard of a high school teacher),and he hates her EVEN MORE,jmac's WORSE Than the FUCKING DEVIL
It does sound like a man who resents women.
C’est ce que je me suis demandé! Mais ce faux pasteur doit avoir un big problem avec sa propre mère, ce n’est pas possible autrement ! Avoir un pareil discours sur Marie, la Vierge Très Pure , c’est pure muflerie ! Avec de tels propos, il va se retrouver portes closes quand il se présentera devant la salle des noces où Marie est à la droite de Son Fils ! Ha , à lui les pleures et les grincements de dents !
The original Protestants like John Calvin, Martin Luther, etcetera had a really high regard for the Virgin Mary unlike the current-day Protestants. I suspect that this kind of view and evolution is still a result of the absence of awareness of church history pre-1500s in Protestant circles. Even as a non-Catholic, I am inclined to acknowledge the role of Mary as the Theotokos God-bearer instead of shying away from terms like that.
You are absolutely correct
And good for you
Back when I was a protestant, I remember being told that the Bible called Mary a sinner. Imagine my horror when I realized that the anti-Marian interpretation of Scripture actually made Christ out to be a sinner.
Thanks be to God, the Blessed Virgin led me from the darkness of heterodoxy into the light of the Catholic Church. She even made me a trad-Catholic.
Mary was a sinner, Mary had other children.
Matthew 13:54-57 says, “Coming to his hometown, he began teaching the people in their synagogue, and they were amazed. ‘Where did this man get this wisdom and these miraculous powers?’ they asked. ‘Isn’t this the carpenter’s son? Isn’t his mother’s name Mary, and aren’t his brothers James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas? Aren’t all his sisters with us? Where then did this man get all these things?’ And they took offense at him.” Although we are not sure how many sisters Jesus had, the fact that He did indeed have at least six siblings is indisputable (Mark 6:3).
@@RJ2878
"All these were persevering with one mind in prayer with the women, and Mary the mother of Jesus, and with his brethren. In those days Peter rising up in the midst of the brethren, said: (now the number of persons together was about an hundred and twenty:)..."
Acts 1:15
Unless you want to tell the Blessed Virgin had 120 children, it is indisputable that the word *adelphoi* has a broader meaning than our English 'brother.' In fact, it is an indisputable fact that in the Semitic language of the Bible, the term "brother" can and dies apply to a male relative or even a non-relative. For example, Abraham's 'brother' Lot was actually his nephew. They had neither the same father nor mother. Likewise the cousins of Moses and Aaron (Leviticus 10:4) are "brothers." Since St Matthew is reporting what Jews were saying about Jesus (and between in that same passage they call him the carpenter's son, so I assume you deny the virgin birth and divine filiation for the sake of consistency, right?) is probable that they are referring to Jesus's relatives.
Now to the indisputable evidence that Mary had no other biological children: The Gospel of St John records that as Jesus hung on the Cross he said to his Mother and St John, "behold your mother... behold your son." And Mary went to live with St. John after that. It would have been scandalous for her to do so if she had other biological children.
Luke 1 treats Mary as a new Ark of the Covenant. Just as the Ark was overlaid with pure gold, Mary "full of grace" was free from sin. And just as the Ark, after being used to contain the tablets of the law, the jar of manna, and the staff of Aaron could not be put to profane use, just so the womb that contained the Word made Flesh, the Bread of Life, and the Great High Priest could not have born other children.
Protestants who deny Mary's perpetual virginity and freedom from sin are simply ignorant of Scripture.
Please , explain Luke , 1 - 46 : 47 . Why would Mary need a Savior ? and explain Roman's , 3 : 23 ,
And please , please explain Deuteronomy , 5 : 7 ,
You know , the 2nd commandment .
" You shall not make for yourself a carved image or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above or that is on the earth beneath or that is in water under the earth , you shall not bow down to them or serve them .
One last thing , could you explain to me and this question is open to any catholic , what would you tell a dying person with only one or two minutes left to live as to how they can enter the Kingdom of Heaven . NZ
@@gerardo259
One of the problems with Protestantism is that you tend to think of salvation only in terms of forgiveness of sins. What you lack is the understanding that God also saves a person by giving him or her the grace not to fall into a particular sin (See Jude 24-25). St John the Baptist was freed from Original Sin at 6 months gestation (hence why he leapt for joy in his mother's womb). That was a work of God, not of St John. Thus when God showered graces upon the Blessed Virgin Mary, preserving her from both Original and Actual Sin from the moment of her Conception, He saved her "in a most perfect mode" [Pope Pius XII, Fulgens Corona]. Hence the Angelic Salutation "hail, Full of Grace."
Now to the Biblical passages you cite: for starters, text without context is pretext. So for starters, in context, Romans 3 deals with actual, personal, sin, not Original Sin. (That's Romans 5.) The word pas, (all) can mean several things: it can mean "a great many" as in "[Herod] was troubled, and all Jerusalem with him" (Matthew 2:3). It can mean "of every kind" - St. Paul's entire argument in Romans is that Jews and Gentiles are both in need of a Savior. What it cannot mean in this context, however, is "every individual *without exception*." Babies, for example, and the some disabled adults are not capable committing actual sins. What's even worse an overtly literal interpretation of *all* would include Christ! If we can make an exception for Him, we can make an exception for His mother also, who certainly would have fallen into sin absent the Grace of God.
Now to Dt 5:7-9.
The prohibition is not against graven images per se (Exodus 25:10-22 goes into detail describing the Ark of the Covenant, topped with the image of two cherubim); nor is the Commandment against venerating sacred images (just look at how David behaved before the Ark.) The Commandments forbids the *worship* of false gods and their images, that is, we must not attribute divinity to them.
Finally, what would I say to someone who is dying? I would urge an unbaptized person to be baptised; a sinner to make an act of contrition and I would place my rosary 📿 or my crucifix in their hands and tell them to rest in God's Divine Mercy.
@@carissstewart3211 God sat an the Ark. david wasnt dancing for a box. People couldnt go in and slobber on the cherubs like catholic file by and slobber on Jupiters statue in the Bascilica. You catholic idolaters have licked and slobbered on its foot so much it wore down the shoe laces.
So point out where god says it OK to make graven images as long as we dont worship them as god.
Woe to John MacArthur for his false teaching and leading the sheep astray
Implying that Jesus severed the relationship with his own mother is one of the most absurd things I've heard...i.e. "we no longer have the relationship that we had." And they have the nerve to accuse Catholics of reading things into scripture that aren't there 🙄
Anyway, happy Easter 2023 everyone.
Thank you for the excellent video regarding the Catholic teaching on Mary. I was a Lutheran seminarian and once lived in Germany. It's undeniably evident that this guy Macarthur is selling something. It was the Lutherans that taught me that the Greek word translated as "woman" is used ONLY in reference to Eve; therefore, Jesus was directly calling her the new Eve. At Cana, he used a Semitic idiom; and such simply do not translate... Water like chocolate, go fly a kite, etc. A more correct understanding of the idiom is: what happens to me, happens to you. In other words, Jesus was warning her that she would have much to suffer. If Mr. Macarthur is an actual biblical scholar, he would understand all of this and misdirecting people by misquoting the bible is a very grave sin. Thank you again for your efforts. Pax
Whether he knows he is misleading people or just ignorant, I don't think he cares. He is a businessman. Runs a christian show and whatever is popular he will perform. Just like many of those new protestant celebrity christian-showmen.
I think it's quite dangerous what they are doing.
Let’s pray and fast for John MacArthur to convert.
The false teachings of John MacArthur, have made me a stronger Catholic Christian! He is in my prayers as he journeys toward Truth! Peace always in Jesus Christ our Great and Kind God and Savior, He whose Flesh is true food and Blood true drink
We must pray that MacArthur finds the fullness of faith in the Catholic Church.
I like you more and more. I am a convert too who loves the Catholic Church. I love Mary and I know she loves me. Thank you for this. I hope this at least helps one person that is confused about catholic teaching about our Holy Mother, keep up the good work,.
she is dead and cannot love you.
She is alive just like Moses & Elijah whom Jesus spoke before his passion. The soul is eternal
@@wesleysimelane3423Voilà le pire des ignorants ! Il n’a jamais lu l’Apocalypse… et la prière des Saints ? Ce ne sont pas celles des morts ! Le mort dans ce cas, c’est lui, M. Wesley ! Lui va rester pour l’Eternité , dans sa tombe ou son urne ! Quand on meurt, on meurt avec son mental, mental mortifère chez lui! Bonne nuit M. Wesley, R.I.P
MacArthurs comments really put a new significance considering genesis 3:15. That he would put enmity between the devils seed and Mary’s seed. We can clearly see what team MacArthur is on.
I was thinking the same thing😂 They do say Pride is the hardest sin to overcome.
Wow, this interpretation of Luke 11 by St. Augustin is fascinating! I've never heard it before, thank you for sharing it.
Yes, more than once, after pondering a difficult theological problem, I've found a thoroughly convincing explanation in St. Augustine. Appart from a great saint, he was an amazingly learned and intelligent man.
Mama Mary actually followed the will of the Father by immaculately conceiving Jesus through the Holy Ghost. My 11 year old pointed that out without me prompting her whiles listening to this McArthur. Please observe the Five First Saturdays for the love of Jesus and for offences committed against the Immaculate Heart of Mary.
Jesus entrusted His mother to the disciple close to His heart. That is why you'll find Mary's icon in the homes of those Christian who treasure Mary like their own mother.
These 'preachers' who popped up a few years ago, who got hold of a bible, read it and interpreted it according to his own understanding hate Mary like the devil does. Because with Mary Christians get closer to Her Son.
@@normarosales1768 je vous suis entierement! Ces insanes discoureurs protestants osent affirmer que Marie n’est plus vierge. Ils croient qu’elle a eu encore plus de 4 fils apres Jesus et 4 garcons, en plus des filles Mais realisent-ils ,ces ignards, que meme aujourd’hui ce n’est pas possible! “L’Esprit Saint descendra sur Toi et la Vertu du Tres-Haut te couvrira! “ dit l’Archange Gabriel dans Sa salutation. Ces mal formes commettent un grave peche contre l’Esprit, celui-la seul qui est impardonnable ! Donc le pire blaspheme qui soit . En fait des ames deja mortes. Pauvres incapables, nuls en lecture et en math: en theorie, ils oublient sciemment l’ensemblr ZERO, zero frere… pour faire de Marie une femme pecheresse ! Incalifiables cretins.
John Mac, The Calvinist, Really hates Mother Mary so much ....
--- Thank you for this Video !!!
Man this was good! Especially the end that shows briefly and eloquently that Sola scriptura is indefensible.
There's only one thing that explains John MacArthur's preaching on Mary, it was inspired by the evil spirit. How does one slander Jesus, describing Him as hateful and disrespectful of His mother, just to discredit His mother. So according to him, the Lord disobeys His own commandment, He who is without sin, sinning? I cringed throughout the John McArthur clips.
Does this Macarthur love his own mother? Most importantly, how many virgins or women are said to be highly favoured by GOD such that they are given the opportunity to conceive "GOD" the son? It is common sense and moreso, wise to read more about Mary and her life in the bible to understand her importance and why she said "henceforth all ages will call me blessed in her song of praise! Maecarthur and the lot should stop misleading souls and pray for their own salvation because Sola scriptura is leading them astray, big time!!
The Scripture alone(by itself) proves mary
I can't believe John McArthur would resort to such blasphemy in order to deny the Catholic teaching on the Blessed Virgin Mary.
May the Lord Jesus have mercy on him 🙏
I can believe it.
I feel bad to those people who listened and followed this Protestant guy....he's leading their souls to distraction!
They certainly don't spend their church time worshipping Jesus, do they? Al they do is listen to the sermons (more like lectures) of an old windbag.
A fatal epidemic of itching ears.
Lord have mercy on his protest-ant soul. More reason to practice first Saturday devotions I reparations for these such blasphemies against the Blessed Mother 😢🙏
Mary can't listen now, she can't help anyone now, she Will be in heaven, but she is not a mediator, just Jesus.
@@goosemonroe2695
1. The angels in heaven can hear us and they rejoice every time they witness us repent.
“Likewise, I say to you, there is joy in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner who repents.” - Luke 15:10
How can the angels rejoice if they can’t hear us?
2. We are also assigned angels to watch over us. Jesus Christ our God says:
“See that you do not look down on any of these little ones. For I tell you that their angels in heaven always see the face of my Father in heaven.” - Mathew 18:10
3. The angels in revelations pour out the prayers of the Saints.
“And the smoke of the incense, with the prayers of the saints, ascended before God from the angel’s hand.” - Revelation 8:4
4. The people in heaven are more alive over there, than they are here.
“I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. God is not the God of the dead, but of the living.” - Matthew 22:32
6. Protestants love to read 1 Timothy 2:5
“For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus”
Without ever reading the verse before that 1 Timothy 2:1-4
“First of all, then, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all men, for kings and all who are in high positions, that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life, godly and respectful in every way. This is good, and pleasing to God our Savior, who desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth”
Mary does not intercede to the father, only Christ does. However Mary can intercede to Jesus.
Out of all the nonsensical misreping Macarthur imposes on the holy church, the idea of Jesus Christ the Son of God & His blessed Mothers relationship changing & for the worse, is abhorrent. He as others just build their house of cards over & over, & their heterodox doctrines are formed before exegetically evaluating texts. I will never understand the blatant disrespect for the blessed Virgin Mary..she is the mother of our Lord, is that not enough to honor her ? Grace & peace to like minded believers
Mary is blessed for sure. So am i. I want you idolatrous Mary worshipers to make a statue of me and bow down to it and carry it on your shoulders
@@peterzinya407 or you could actually not misrep & slander...idk maybe read the Catholic catechism you ding dong or you could read scripture w/out a heterodox bias lens if possible...Mary was full of grace even before overshadowed by the Holy Spirit, yet to be bearing the Son of God but full of grace, kept to bear the Son of God as the The Ark of the New Eternal Covenant...but don't honor her?? You all love your heretical Deformers, your pastors, your theologians & scholars so much maybe make your statues of them & bow down or you prob already do lol
@@J-PLeigh8409 You should read the book of Mormon, then you will know the truth.
@@peterzinya407 i hope your kidding, you should in all honesty read the Didache & learn the faith a bit more, it is from the 1st cent, by the holy apostles on how to live the faith
@@J-PLeigh8409 Did cardinal McCarrick read the Didache?
Thou Mother of Divine Grace
Thou purist Mother
Pray for us
She can't listen. Bible is very clear
The Greatest treasure in my life is The Blessed Mother, The Mother Of Christ. I love Her SO MUCH.
Well John isnt just wrong about Mary but about nearly anything
God have mercy. Never insult His mother, never. The audacity of this man. Mary is so important she will crush the serpent. All graces come through her, why? Because Jesus said so and wills it. He gave us Mary , as He was dying on the cross.
I know many 30+ year old men who will do whatever their mother tells them… they’re mostly Jewish.
Queen Mother, pray for us 😣
Either that or filipino
Mary did not even ask. She made a statement. And Jesus knew what to do.
Wow John. I'll ask our Blessed Mother Mary to pray for you.
Mary can't listen, she is not a mediator between God and men. Bible is very clear.
@@goosemonroe2695 what does it say?
Every King listens to one women….His mother. The queen is the single greatest influence of all Kings. The 1st century Jews would have seen this.
So true. 1 Kings 2: 19-20 is very clear.
Wow @ 16:40 ...I just verified the passage in my RSV Catholic Edition (St Benedict Press) and sure enough the translation reads "O woman, what have you to do with me?"
But I searched the same passage online from the Douay-Rheims translation and it reads "Woman, what is that to me and to thee?"
Such a shame that a "catholic," bible would have such a blasphemous translation included!!
I've heard a bit about John Macarthur on other sites. He's kind of a hero to a lot of people on the right because he kept his church open during the COVID lockdown. Props to him for that I suppose. This is the first time I've heard him speak and if the rest of his sermons are along these lines...wow. I've had protestants, especially Baptists, accuse us of being idolaters because we have statues of Mary and Joseph in our churches. I've even been told I was going to hell because of it. Then there are the Jehovah Witnesses who told me it was really Satan who appeared at Lourdes and Fátima as a way to have people publicly kneel before him.
But those comments came from members of the church. I've never heard a pastor hold our Blessed Mother in such contempt. I have heard he is one of the more outspoken anti-Catholic protestant preachers and maybe his disdain for Catholics is just being projected onto Our Blessed Mother. I never could wrap my head around the contempt protestants have for Mary. Another commenter pointed out that Satan also has a special hate for Mary. Maybe he's at work in them. Sort of turns that Jehovah Witness tale on it's head if that's the case. I don't hate them for it but I do feel sad for a guy like this. He's missing out a wonderful relationship. It was our Blessed Mother who helped lead me back home. Don't ask me how I know it, I just do. She loves us and wants us to be in union with her Son. Why that is a bad thing is beyond me. I'll be praying for ya Mr. Macarthur.
An excellent response to MacArthur's misleading and superficial attacks on Our Lady and her beloved Lord and Son.
This hatred of our Blessed Mother is heartbreaking and nauseating. Guess who else hates Mary? That's right, Satan and his demons. Who is acting like Satan now?
John macarthur is worse than satan,at least black metal is a thing,unlike sola pastorcuckae
Revelation 12:1-6
A great sign appeared in the sky, a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars.
She was with child and wailed aloud in pain as she labored to give birth.
Then another sign appeared in the sky; it was a huge red dragon, with seven heads and ten horns, and on its heads were seven diadems.
Its tail swept away a third of the stars in the sky and hurled them down to the earth. Then the dragon stood before the woman about to give birth, to devour her child when she gave birth.
She gave birth to a son, a male child, destined to rule all the nations with an iron rod. Her child was caught up to God and his throne.
The woman herself fled into the desert where she had a place prepared by God, that there she might be taken care of for twelve hundred and sixty days.
This idea of Jesus rebuking anyone who offers “suggestions” would make one quite hesitant to pray at all. It also makes no sense in the context of Scripture. What of all those who suggested/requested that Jesus heal them?
The devil hates Mary and so do his minions.
Protestants teach, don't talk to your mother and siblings; You talk only talk to your dad.
When Jesus called Mary as "woman" he identified her as the New Eve.
Continue this great work , this is an eye opener
Mother Mary is full of Love.❤
Lord have mercy. I’ve had issues with him ever since he called the stole of the priest who Chrismated Hank H. a “rag”…a “rag!”
Everytime I watch his video I feel the urge to comment I love this guy.
Great video; thank you. And I've never heard of someone saying that Jesus was trying to separate himself from Mary at the cross....wow..... I cannot stand John MacArthur. Hes full of contradictions, mental gymnastics, misinterpretations, and is unbelievably arrogant and patronizing.
He’s wrong about so much. Although when I was in these churches, I didn’t really know . I was ignorant about so much
The rosary is contemplating the life of Jesus from Conception to Ressurection. The first miracle of Jesus even if it was not His time to do miracle was through intercession of Mary. She will draw us more closer to her Son.
John Macarthur has made a very lucrative career for himself by distorting Catholic teaching. Fr. Chris Alar most recent explaining the faith series covers this very well also.
Yes lucrative. His net worth is $14 million.
@@Spiritof76Catholic
The pope controls the entire wealth of the Catholic church which is estimated at $ 200 billion people in glass houses shouldn't throw stones , lol NZ
@@pasttense942 They are only rich to what they own like cathedrals the vatican it's self is not that rich.
@Francis You do know that The Pope doesn't own The Vatican, right? Churches belong to all believers and are beautiful to glorify God. You don't get million heir priests in the Catholic Church, unlike some Protestant Pastors.
@Francis Yes !!! and the Catholics Feed the Poor at All Corners of the World with that money .....
Hearing people talk about Mary as if she means nothing to God is so painful. I can understand feeling nervous about praying to Mary and the saints, but to degrade her in that manner is completely unnecessary. 😢
10:43 and mary DID His FATHER'S WILL MacArthur,wtfh do YOU even WANT?
Very good defense of our Holy Mother. Thank you ❤
May God open the eyes of the misguided “evangelists”, who perpetrate such error. The Evil One smiles when men diminish and denigrate the Blessed Mother, because he well knows of Her God-given power to defeat him.
“Woman” was a term of respect in context, but MacArthur applies a modern interpretation, and concludes that Our Lord was talking down to His Mother.
Thank you for defending our Blessed Mother.
Well researched thanks for the video
Even the almighty God need mother to bring Jesus in this world to save the world. God teach us to be humble and love each other not to judge. For with almighty God nothing is impossible. If we ignore mary we ignore Jesus.
Thank you for being so clear on these important scriptures that have been obscured by McCarther!
John MacArthur statements are obnoxious in the way he is twisting scripture and suggesting that Jesus doesn't respect and love His mother as His mother and cared nothing about her. I don't know why John MacArthur is doing this. Perhaps John has mother issues and is taking them out on Mary and Jesus.
John Macarthur’s service is how i envision hell would be like.
At this point in history with the internet and how easy it is to find out what the Catholic Church actually teaches, I have very little tolerance for liars like MacArthur who twists the truth for his own evil purposes. He rebels against Christ's own Church like how Lucifer rebelled against God. He makes Jesus in his own image.
Doesn't take a genius to figure out who's pulling the strings. As always, continue to pray for our Protestant brothers and sisters to shed the scales covering their eyes and return home.
I think your vids on the monarchy are a bit wonky, but that's just my opinion. Apart from that, there are few who defend the faith better than you on UA-cam. You should have ten times the subscribers. I wish you would put out vids twice as often. Thanks and keep it up!
Nice.. Thats what im talking about. Good rebuttal my kind Sr.... Keep them coming. Poor john M. 🤦🏻 Haha. Pobre Hombre... Lol...🙌🏼🙏🏼👍🏼⛪⛪🥊🥊🥋🕊️🕊️
Powerful Video God Bless
Thank you ❤️
The way he talks about her It's pretty DEMONIC
Why would a sinless person need to be saved?
Luke 1:46 And Mary said, My soul doth magnify the Lord,
47 And my spirit hath rejoiced in God my Saviour.
Matthew 4:10 “Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.”
Revelation 22:8-9 “And I John saw these things, and heard them. And when I had heard and seen, I fell down to worship before the feet of the angel which shewed me these things.” Then saith he unto me, See thou do it not: for I am thy fellowservant, and of thy brethren the prophets, and of them which keep the sayings of this book: worship God.”
Romans 3:10 “As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one:”
She was saved by being spared from sin
She was saved from the stain of Original sin from the first instant of her Conception. See Genesis 3:15
He's not hearing the Holy Spirit, but a different spirit is talking to him. He tries so hard to dismiss OUR BLESSED MOTHER, but it will never happen 🙏🌹🙏
If she wasn't IMPORTANT, they wouldn't be trying to put her down so hard, BLASPHEMOUS AND UNHOLY to speak about OUR BLESSED MOTHER this way, I'm JESUS feels the same way 🙏🌹🙌📿
Well explained brother🙏👍
God bless
Fantastic.
Some people have this hatred or jealousy about the Catholic church. The Blessed Mother is to be adored and admired for what She did while here on earth. Nowhere is it written about worshiping the Blessed Mother. Only asking for intersession. The Hail Mary prayer, pretty much says it all. Obviously, John Macarther is not familiar with Mathew 7:1, Stop judging, that you may not be judged.
Yes, except that She is venerated, not adored.
John McArthur's tone when reciting scripture was condescending and venomous. He was taking the words of Christ and making them sound vitriolic. Absolute blasphemy. This is your mind warped by Protestantism.
Jesus also referred to the Samaritan woman in John 4:21 as "woman..." Is she also the New Eve? Jesus also noted in Mark 3:31-35 that his mother was the one who did the will of God as he rhetorically disowned Mary at the scene!
Well done!
John MacArthur is playing with fire. Gary Michuta has written a book titled 'The Gospel According to John MacArthur' in response to the latter's book 'The Gospel According to Rome' in which he decisively debunks all of MacArthur's major strawman arguments against the Catholic faith.
Alex, I was going to order the Michuta book. The book that I found is “The Gospel According to James McCarthy” by Gary Michuta. Thought you may want to know. Thanks.
@@w.bayless3162 Thanks for the correction. I confused the two, but their strawman arguments are similar. I read the book about 5 years ago and haven't kept the copy.
Mater mea, Fiducia mea.
I don’t get it , why would any Christian offer prayers to anyone other than God the Father through His Son Jesus?You don’t think he loves you enough to hear and answer your prayers? After all Jesus endured your punishment for you, He paid the price for your sins so any believer can obtain forgiveness. But he will not be your intercessor to the Father when you pray? Then to say Jesus will do whatever Mary will ask Him to do even if He doesn’t want to as if He doesn’t know what is best for us. He is God, He will preform His purpose in our lives.
Just sit around and wait for heaven if it requires no involvement on your part then. Oh, wait, is that not what is expected of being a Christian? You pray for one another and support one another and encourage one another and love one another? Why? Doesn't Jesus take care of everything?
Have you ever asked anyone for their prayers?
Please listen from 1:15 - its clear. No ambiguity.
What about prayers to Jesus or the Holy Spirit?
Please check out message from heaven by Rachel Lubbe and a lamp in the dark by Chris pinto and before the wrath by ingenuity films.
John is just pushing his followers into Her arms.
Good vid bro.I'd advice people to read the book poem of the man God by Maria Valtorta.
MacArthur was saying a bunch of lies I’m not even this perfect catholic but everything he said was not true
This kind of abject blasphemy brings out the worst tendencies of my older self. It takes everything in me to swallow my burning desire to liberate this blasphemous heretical soul from the mortal coil. How dare he speak so dishonorably and so disgracefully about not just The Blessed Virgin, but Our Lord himself.
I know it’s wrong, Lord knows how conflicted I am in the pit of my soul. For if Christ prayed for mercy upon those who drove the nails into his flesh and the perfidious people who sent him to his death, what right do I have to demand the death of any? I just can’t seem to stop myself, my love for God can so easily turn into a kind of horrifying merciless zeal. Lord have mercy.
The idea that somehow Mary is the "New Eve" and therefore without sin and divine is a RC innovation that is not biblical.
I beg to differ with you…John MacArthur does not put down Mary or her significance. The bottom line is what Christ said and people need only to go to Him for intercession because that is what He is doing for us. We, as Christians, are all saints and are being sanctified daily. Mary cannot intercede for me…Christ said…”I am the way the truth and the life…no one comes to the Father except through me.” I go to the Lord in prayer. I have great respect for Mary…she was chosen because she was a virgin AND in the genealogical BLOODLINE of King David. Joseph was also in the bloodline of King David but because of the curse Christ could not come from that bloodline. Christ receives the kingship through Joseph and the bloodline through Mary. That, I believe, is the main purpose of God choosing Mary…she fulfills that prophecy of Christ. She was also a sinner like you and me. Mary was a good woman who God chose because of her faithfulness and goodness. God blessed her. Why would I go to Mary to intercede when I can go directly to my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.
My conversion to the Catholic Church:
This is the shortest answer. Not using history or church fathers, since I come from a Protestant background let’s stick to scripture alone in which all Protestants are bound :
2 or three witnesses truth is is established. Explicit biblical epistemology no systematic theology can go around that
You can’t bear witness on your own. This is not my words
“If I alone bear witness about myself, my testimony is not true.”
John 5:31 ESV
Every revelation from God must have 2 or three witnesses:
Old Testament:
Then Moses and Aaron went and gathered together all the elders of the people of Israel.Aaron spoke all the words that the Lord had spoken to Moses and did the signs in the sight of the people. And the people believed;
Exodus 4
And Samuel said to the people, “The Lord is witness, who appointed Moses and Aaron and brought your fathers up out of the land of Egypt.”
1 Samuel 12:6 ESV
“He sent Moses his servant: Aaron the man whom he had chosen. He gave them power to shew his signs, and his wonders in the land of Cham.”
Psalms 104:26-27
Moses and Aaron
“A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed. Only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established.”
Deuteronomy 19:15 ESV
“And I will get reliable witnesses, Uriah the priest and Zechariah the son of Jeberechiah, to attest for me.””
Isaiah 8:2 ESV
Bind up the testimony; seal the teaching among my disciples.”
Isaiah 8:16 ESV
“To the teaching and to the testimony! If they will not speak according to this word, it is because they have no dawn.”
Isaiah 8:20 ESV
Uriah and Zachariah
New Testament:
There was a man sent from God, whose name was John. He came as a witness, to bear witness about the light, that all might believe THROUGH him. He was not the light, but came to BEAR WITNESS about the light.”
John 1:6-8 ESV
JESUS and John
“But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, that every charge may be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses. “If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector.”
Matthew 18:16-17ESV
“And he called the twelve and began to send them out TWO BY TWO and gave them authority over the unclean spirits.”
Mark 6:7 ESV
Paul:
“This is the third time I am coming to you. Every charge must be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses.”
2 Corinthians 13:1 ESV
“and what you have heard from me in the presence of many witnesses entrust to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also.”
2 Timothy 2:2 ESV
And finally in Revelations:
“And I will grant authority to my TWO witnesses, and they will prophesy for 1,260 days, clothed in sackcloth.””
Revelation 11:3 ESV
So I ask my Protestant brothers. Who is the witness to your gospel and only from the Bible alone.
Where lies the ecumenical council there lies the church
I IGNORE THESE KNOW IT ALL’S . Try to explain it to them and it’s like talking to a brick wall
I know. My wife's church is like that.
Projection of protestant pride onto Jesus. Jesus was only loving to his mother.
My point, the Catholics have given over emphasis on Mary, and the Protestants have over neglected Mary. Mary should be placed in her place rightly.
We can NEVER honor Mary more than God already did.
John MacArthur def put his own spin on this one. But the Catholic religion is unbiblical in so many ways! Praying to Mary and to saints is idolatry! Catholics always say “we aren’t praying to her, we are asking her to pray for us”, the say it’s no different than asking a friend to pray for us! Asking a friend to pray for you is not the same as asking a dead person to pray for you! And you are def praying to Mary when you say the Hail Mary! You fold ur hands, bow your head, yiu say the Hail Mary, then you say amen! When you ask your friend to pray for you, do you fold your hands and bow your head and say amen?? Some Catholics say that Mary intercedes for them, jesus tells us “I am the intercessor, the only way to the father is through me! Mary can’t intercede, only Jesus can! Praying the rosary is not biblical! The Bible never mentions anything about a rosary. When Jesus tells us how to pray he says “be straight forward, don’t babble or repeat yourself such as the pagans…” when you pray the rosary you are repeating yourself over and over and over!! Jesus was talking to his disciples, they were referring to spiritual teachers, Jesus said call no man on earth father, yiur father is in heaven”. This means dint call any spiritual teachers “father”, the Catholics call their priests “father”! On the cross when Jesus said “women behold your son, son behold your mother”, he wasn’t giving Mary to us as our mother! He was telling John to look after mary, and for mary to look after John! That’s why John moved mary into his home! Prayer is a form of worship, when we pray to God, we are worshipping him. When Catholics pray to Mary and to saints, they are worshipping a false God! Mary and the saints are not divine people. They are no diff than me and you! They can’t hear your prayers, much less answer them! The Bible also warns against trying to communicate with the dead! They believe that salvation also requires works, like continuously receiving the sacraments! That’s not biblical! They belive the Eucharist actually becomes the body and blood of Christ! At the last supper Jesus used bread and wine as a symbol of his body and blood! If the Eucharist actually becomes flesh and blood, then you guys are cannibles! You think you can turn a piece of bread into the flesh of the living God!?
I can't even find in scripture were Jesus and Mary got along all that well, and he did rebuke her.
For she refuses to realize the mother son relationship was over.
And Mary did not replace eve ,there is no scripture for this.
Hey what editing software do you use
Power director. The mobile app
How tragically sad , what are you so afraid of ? even dialouge , come on surely no one in today's climate is that fearful , it's obvious I am wrong .
You have accused John MacArthur of hating Mary on this podcast that is a lie and you know it , how could he hate Mary the mother of Jesus when he loves the Son of God or anyone who is a believer in Christ , that is total bigotry , He speaks truth from the Bible and that is what you are afraid of , and you should be . NZ
@@gerardo259 because he imagines Jesus as being disrespectful to his mom.
@@noahgaming8833
We spell it mum ,
just like GOD so loved her , he made her the mother of HIS only son 🙏🌹🙏🌹❤❤❤
A most excellent refutation of MacArthur.
I will accept any Catholic teachings as long as they don’t contradict what the Bible teaches. If when there are such contradictions EVEN TO THE CATHOLIC VERSION OF THE BIBLE, you still believe that’s a non-issue or the Catholic teachings supersede those in its very-own Bible then you can just stop reading further to save your valuable time. Otherwise, I would really like to know the justifications for the Catholic Church's teachings about Mary regarding the following specific points: (Please note: ALL the following Bible references are those of the CATHOLIC VERSION OF THE BIBLE - NOT Protestant's!)
1) Mary was a virgin all of her life when the Bible says Jesus had siblings. The typical Catholic response is the word brothers/sisters can also mean cousins. WAIT, NOT SO FAST, because most Bible scholars agree the New Testament was originally written in Greek, and like in English, there’s a word for brother (adelfos,) and there’s a word for cousin (xaderfi.) For example, ‘brother’ was used in Mark 6:3, while ‘cousin’ was used in Luke 1:36 and Colossians 4:10. So, it is NOT logical that the word ‘cousin’ was used in Luke and Colossians but not used in Mark. Here're more opportunities for the word cousins to be used MULTIPLE TIMES but wasn't used; instead, the word brothers was used - John 7, Acts 1:14, 1 Corinthians 9:5. If 'brothers' here can also mean cousins then does that mean EVEN THE CATHOLIC BIBLE has inaccurate translations?! So we should NOT trust EVEN THE CATHOLIC BIBLE COMPLETELY?! 😲😲😲
2) Mary was also sinless her whole life like Jesus when the Bible says all humans have sinned in Romans 3:23, “No distinction is made: all have sinned and lack God's glory.”
3) Mary is a mediatrix in addition to Jesus. (So Jesus alone is not good enough as a mediator even for what He had gone through and done for us?! Seems like a disrespect/insult to Jesus.) Bible says Jesus is the ONLY ONE in John 14:6, "Jesus said: I am the Way; I am Truth and Life. No one can come to the Father except through me." In 1 Timothy 2:5, "For there is one God, and one mediator of God and of men, the man Christ Jesus." Obviously, Mary isn't included as another mediator anywhere in the Bible.
4) Bowing/kneeling to the statue of Mary and praying to her instead of to Jesus and God directly for God's grace and help when one of the 10 Commandments forbids that, but was deliberately omitted by the Catholic Church’s version. Exodus 20:4-5, "You shall not make yourself a carved image or any likeness of anything in heaven above or on earth beneath or in the waters under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them. For I, Yahweh your God, am a jealous God and I punish a parent's fault in the children, the grandchildren, and the great-grandchildren among those who hate me." Regarding this commandment, the links below are only two of the many examples showing the Pope, the Catholic Church's leader and supposedly-INFALLIBLE Vicar of Christ is doing in response - HE DEFIES THE MOST-HIGH GOD’s commandment and risks GOD’s judgement on your Church! Isn’t that grossly irresponsible? How often do you see Catholics bow/kneel and pray to the statues of Mary? I have seen plenty - and that’s idolatry to me, which God has forbidden. So, WAKE-UP CATHOLICS! SNAP-0UT of your sin of idolatry by redirecting your devotion from Mary TO JESUS CHRIST instead. According to the Bible, He is the ONLY ONE who righteously deserves your devotion.
Above are some of the reasons I left the Catholic Church and converted to Protestant even though I was born and raised a Catholic.
images.app.goo.gl/UcSRzVMyr4sM3JpM7
images.app.goo.gl/G4EUw6CqRB5D8J6q6
It's interesting that the greek word gyne(Strong's G1135) can mean both woman and wife
Macarthur needs a therapist,somethings wrong with his childhood
I miss it too.
I always believed that at the 2000 years Mary is in heaven and don't you think by now God or our lord Jesus would have said hey stop doing that or stop saying that to people or telling the priests to stop praying to her?
If jesus want us to pray or go to his mother he said so in Luke chp 11,verse 27,28 for a woman said blessed is the paps that you sucked.
But what
t did jesus say ,did he say make images of her ,and bow down to her.
No he said blessed is he that keep the word of God.