India must avoid confrontation with Five Eyes. It’s an important counterterrorism ally
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 тра 2024
- Recent reports of alleged activities of Indian Intelligence Agencies, notably the Research and Analysis Wing, in countries as far away as Canada, the United States and Australia have brought to the fore the contentious issue of intelligence operations amongst allies. India, a pivotal player in geopolitics, finds itself in the focus of various intelligence networks, each vying for its collaboration and allegiance.
Among these the most renowned is the Five Eyes intelligence alliance, comprising the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, New Zealand and Australia. As India navigates its role in the global intelligence landscape, it faces a myriad of converging and diverging interests with Five Eyes. Former Indian Army Chief General Manoj Mukund Naravane(Retd) explains India's areas of convergence & divergence with 5 Eyes alliance in this week’s column
Read the column here: theprint.in/opinion/india-mus...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Not sure why the respected General is ignoring the provocation from the five eye members? They are openly allowing the Khalistanis to go around and beat Indian citizens and their own citizens of Indian origins who are against the Anti-India subversive activities of these Khalistani thugs. These Khalistanis are never held accountable for their criminal activities. While these countries are lying through their teeth about some imaginary activities of 'Indian agents'. I think General Naravane should let the people in office take care of things, while he should enjoy his retirement.
Does the general think people in security advisory team and MEA are less intelligent ? With no offence he goes down in the history as the general to have lost our soldiers to Chinese after 60 years if he is so intelligent in analysing the why didn’t he guess Galwan coming also I see he is reading probably someone from print would have asked him to read it. Why didn’t NSA take him to advisory board if he was a strategic expert. My view iam no expert, rather than 5 eyes India should build and invest more with Vietnam, Taiwan, Japan and south Asian countries. Rather than 5 eyes Bcose there are more intrusion in senkaku island than inside India how Japanese are handling them and building more with these South Asian countries help us rather 5 eyes countries. Isn’t Russia on upper hand in Ukraine going against entire Europe and US.
India must avoid confrontation but in some cases it is inevitable.
Military thinks in binary and only from the perspective of security. There are many other factors like political interference, illegal manipulation of elections, regime change seekers, supporting subversion, insurgency, country's pride/confidence in dealing with challenges that can not only affect security but a country's fate. General's view is unfortunately narrow and not in sync with bigger picture. It's the same policy that was guiding India for decades and what was the end result?
Yeah u definitely know more than him,he became top boss just like that
@@MithileshJha-tn3ksyes because promotion is based on seniority and not merit.
@@libshastrapromotion only upto Lt Col is guaranteed. Beyond that merit is all that matters. This is the Army, not the bloody IAS. Only 0.01% of officers become a Lt General at Pay level 16. Whereas 100% IAS officers reach that pay level. Learn something before commenting.
Come on General. Stop delivering the talk as if reading out of a script and that too a bad job at it.
You can watch kusha kapila for that
0. India's national interest are our first priority under any circumstances. Once this is understood clearly, any threat to it from anywhere in the world including from our so called friendly states, must be dealt with squarely. For this purpose, whatever is required to be done must be done, overtly or covertly. There cannot be any compromise on this. 1. As regards recent issues with Canada and USA, it is clear that despite lots of noises, neither Canada nor USA could not provide any proof so far of Indian Govt involvement in the incidents there. So noises coming from these countries are just noises and need to be taken as such. 2. A broader question to ask is how is that criminal elements from India get visa to Canada and USA!!! Further, how is that anti India elements are able to undertake anti India terrorism and other anti national activities there? These must be sorted out with these 5 Eyes countries. 3. Once this is sorted, rest of what General says is fine. Let us not get carried away by such ideas like India must avoid confrontation with 5 Eyes. If at all, these are countries who are creating confrontation using anti India elements supported and sponsored by them. 4. BTW, why is General getting into these geo political issues rather than issues of defense?
General Saab misreads very much. Shall we adopt ostrich policies when national interests are at stake? After all those long years of service General Saab, did fail to know the hidden hands behind international terrorism? A simple clue, General Saab - how come the ISIS use, brand new Toyota Land Cruiser Pickup trucks and shining M16 rifles with packing grease? Did the General know about the five eye's regime change agenda? The current Indian leadership is well capable of harnessing the five eyes, without divorcing them.
At stake with these countries?
Great
Sir , have you joined the print as I don't see a host here?
How did this man get into the National Defence Academy? Let alone become COAS? Even an SBI branch manager has more initiative and chutzpah. I keep repeating this: Thank your lucky stars Maneckshaw was chief in 71....imagine the result with Gen. Naravane in the hot seat. A surrender (by India) in Eden Gardens on Dec 16
Is this general saying uncle ajit doval is a bumbling old man who doesn’t know how to manage Indian intelligence- General should stop reading from a pre prepared statement openly in front of camera obviously someone wrote it for him to read out 😂😂😂😂
I am a lay man. But is it not true that another such an army man appointed by Nehru presided over When China defeated us in 62. With generals talking such what confidence even the military have when he was leading them? That too when we had legends like Sam Manekshaw.
It's just an opinion. People are acting like General is putting forward a diktat or something. He's much qualified to forward perspectives.
Very sane advice. India 🇮🇳 doesn't seek confrontation with any country.
You may not seek it, but others do. Do you really think the USA and Canada don't know what Khalistan is ? Who Pannu is ? What kind of videos he makes. I am a normal civilian and even I can do a google search and see his videos on UA-cam and website using a VPN where he openly calls for attacks on Indian soil.
Whether you like it or not, India is a important country and other nations especially the USA will try to interfere in our internal matters. It is in their nature.
They want to use us like PAWNs against CHINA like they used Ukraine against Russia, the Ukrainian youth has become cheap cannon fodder today. That could be us tomorrow.
I don't mind fighting for our country if need be, last resort. Man is born, man has to die. But I do not want to end up being used as cannon fodder for American interest.
Today China is a competitor so that are against them, tomorrow 10-15 years later India will reach China size, that time the entire WEST will eventually turn on us.
Mark my words.
Sir...
Please give some expressions..
It seems you are just reading something...
Sorry if felt bad ✨
Watch the video at 1.25x speed, it will be much more pleasant to watch. Thank me later.
How this man got army chief post?
Through the anti-national Congress Party I guess.
@@DipakBose-bq1vv he was appointed as army chief by Modi 😂
Sir aapko pension nahi aa rahe kya?
Dont exceed your body skeleton .Speak on army report card only .
We need people with multidimensional thinking in strategies with short and long term view .
A painful remembrance: 1962 Sino-India war and lessons India learnt commandant pandita
ua-cam.com/video/0zfieuXDomE/v-deo.html
Is it really counter-terrorism or old forced slavery for East India Company?
Thank you The Print for getting us such distinguished personalities to speak.
Very good topic 👏
But what should Ind do when 5 👁️🗨️ intentionally poke, defame Ind globally.
You can choose self respect or benifits sometimes both are opposites to each other.five eyes benifits comes with a cost that is khalistan.
@@abhisheksaini1964you can still get the benefit and come after Khalistanis. Force 5 eyes to accept that Khalistanis will not be tolerated. That's the long game.
...........take a nap or drink some coffee buddy.
He aint your buddy you c**t.
Good advice
So true. We do not know how to choose our battles. Thanks for the troubleshooter, Jai Shankar, and the way he deftly manages our recklessness.
Yes, Gora Saheb is always right. Be a good bootlicker like our ancestors were to the British for 200 years.
Abb Gora Saheb bole honge toh sahi he honga na bhai 🤡
@rohitsawant5805 Not true. I am not suggesting we lick boots but use our brains as, for some reason, the present dispensation prides itself to be a chanakya. Simply put, right now, if a full-scale war were to break out between us and China, we don't stand a chance in spite of all the tall claims BJP makes. Perhaps you have not heard of the saying, "your enemy's enemy is your best friend". Surprised by your choice of words. It is not civil.
Thanks sir,but today's Indian youth does not understand all this ,they already consider us some mega power and what not.
Unfortunately during last few years,being jingoistic is considered patriotic.
My countrymen never fail to amuse me. Keyboard warriors in the comments teaching a real warrior about strategy. This is what is wrong with us. In the words of Don Corleone ".... we talk when we should listen ". This is why people joke about us. Disgusting
By that same logic, Army General should stick to his defence domain then, why is he speaking on diplomatic matters and intelligence operations ( R&AW & IB ) domain.
Does he know more about diplomacy & foreign relations than S Jaishankar a lifelong IFS diplomat or he knows more about External intelligence than Ajit Doval a lifelong R&AW spy, who has literally done operations in Pakistan, gathered intel during operation Blue star and settle northeast conflicts by negotiating with rebel leaders.
Do you really think the US and Canada are not aware about Khalistan issue and what kind of activities Khalistani's are doing on their own soil ?
Are you ok with Khalistani's attacking our consulate buildings, pulling down Indian flags, harassing Indian diplomats on the streets and flying posters of kill India, dismember India on the US and Canadian streets ?
How did get into army!!! Ru really a army man. Because ur talking like a NGO which is on western payroll
Elaborate
why do you want to fight all 🤔?
@nithin909 mind your language, you should know about whom you are talking about.
He passed UPSC NDA / CDS. You are no one to question him w/ ur idiotic brain cells.
you probably need to find a channel where you have confirmation bias my friend, different pov topics is probably not for you 😅