I would be quite happy if they released the old poley skin. I used to have it and all my skins got reset for some reason. It would be nice to have it back.
One thing I want Minitoon to do is bring back the old seasons, like Mr.P’s lab and stuff. Some people didn’t get the chance to get the stuff so I feel like it would be nice to the newer players
I agree even though I have rare skins people event build mode events mean people are limited on creativity because they didn't do a event OR he could just bring back seasons in general
If they Didn't play the Event when it was ongoing That's on them I have no empathy For people who whine Because they didn't get a skin You Just have to Take that L
Actually, I think it should be the other way round. An edited version of Poley that bares similarity to an already existing skin for people with Poley would be cool. Maybe you could make it like the Heist Poley, including the old theme and no hat. If you wanna use a skin similar to that, use Officer Doggy.
Honestly, I feel like people don’t want Poley back just so they can flex on new players, a new cop skin would be cool but I feel like they should do both, maybe modify Poley a bit for the new player like for example have the one from the heist ending cutscene. Exclusivity shouldn’t exist in Piggy imo
I want Poley back because I had the skin, did the quest. But then I lose my account. So as much as I want a new skin, I want a chance of getting what I once had.
I know it’s not connected to this, but is it interesting that the world said that he would smash anything that Mr. P loves let’s say what if helicopters. What do he smash it?
I personally think the most prominent argument against bringing back Poley is more like we'd be missing out on a new character and players that already have it will have probably no reward when completing the event One could say that if they add a variant of Poley, they could have a reason, but it'd certainly be less appealing than a new character. Maybe some people just don't want a variant of Poley, leading them to not play the event
From both sides personally I can understand. It be nice to have the Poley Skin back because everyone wants it, But at the same time it Also makes it less special and rare Edit: personally i feel like its best to have both. If i were MiniToon i would bring back the Poley Skin alongside a new Cop Skin to bring in. Therefore new players can try and get it again while older players can feast on something new. It'll probably be a lot of work but patience comes first.
Too many people will cry but I agree with this. I was 2 months off from getting poley and if the people crying were 2 months off they would want him coming back. Their just biased.
Its still an collab special so it cant be brought back permanently so if it come back for like an week it should not be a big deal + rarity of the skins makes no sense since ot just gives you ability to laugh at New players for missing an event and nothing else litteraly since skins have no litterall value at all
I was playing when poley relased but i missed poley cause i was busy with school but i dont want poley to come back because it was a limited skin and i dont think i deserve that skin
I think they should bring him back but do a different harder event for him (cus the old one was too easy) but anyone who already has him gets a new way better skin (if they have poley)
It should be where there is a new cop or maybe prisoner skin up to date with the modelling but there should be an option to get pokey. As rare as it may be it’s really just a skin, not traceable and doesn’t make your account. Having the option to get a cooler skin will get people with pokey and new players happy while the poley skin will make collectors and perfectionists like me happy. It can also have some replay ability if you want both
While it would be nice, this is the same community that god mad about the prototype skin when its the newest skin we has in months so they wont be satisfied.
Also, there has been some rumors saying that Mr. Stitchy will be added back on Halloween, but Minitoon can't do that because if he adds Mr. Stitchy back then it's pretty much the same thing as adding Poley back, because Mr. Stitchy is also limited just like Poley and rare as well, so if he adds Mr. Stitchy back then people who have Mr. Stitchy and not Poley are going to get mad but people who have Poley and not Mr. Stitchy are also going to get mad, so the best solution would've been to either add both of them back or add neither of them back, and he said that he thinks its good to keep Poley rare, but then he can't add Mr. Stitchy back either because he would basically change what he said about keeping a rare skin rare.
I say you should just change up the skin a bit so the new people can get that one, so the og players can still have the rare skin while new players can get a similar skin
The thing is people really want poley back because it's rare and could be the only skin they are missing in their collection, changing it up slightly would be a new skin
They should make it like the distorted piggy skin where you could switch between the new and the old version, that way people who only got the new version technically still own the skin in their collection.
I hope they bring it back since when it was out i didn't manage to get it even after getting into the vault! It was super hard to do on a public server. They could also bring it back for the new piggy game :)
@@s_oterKeep in mind that Asimo did say that he had no problem with bringing Poley back, so there is still a chance that Poley could come back. 0:39
To be fair if we got a new skin more people will be happy about it and not just the people who need to get poley. A new skin we be great since Minitoon has gotten better at creating skin, also another point is we shouldn’t really be getting updates so the Piggy community should be grateful for Minitoon still caring for piggy.
I think they should forget these limited skins and just bring back anyone of the holloween event skin like they did with frostiggy and left the primrose limited
@@Seasy_The thing is that the Poley skin would lose its value and the original owners of Poley who got it back in 2020 would be very mad about it. Like what would be the point of doing the quest to get poley when you could just wait for it to appear on the shop and buy it ?
Honestly I think the best route is just to do both, it satisfies those who don't already have the Poley skin and gives the players who do have already have it something to do
The thing is, if poley comes back then minitoon might aswell bring back every season and skin because it'd also be unfair for people who didn't play at that time. Personally, I think a new skin would be better. Edit: I have to stick with a new skin. For old players who already have the poley skin, the whole event rewards nothing. Besides, new skins are much higher quality, so it'd be awesome to see a new one instead.
I've already said this in a reply to this but i personally think if poley comes back this would be a different version of poley which is from book 2 chapter 3's end cutscene and both skins would be separate so that way the original one still remains it's rarity but the people who never got him would be able to finally get him in some way
I really like poley skin and use it anytime I play piggy, one time this person asked me how to get it and I said they couldn’t anymore. As much as I feel bad I prefer that it stays exclusive to older players like Mr. stitchy.
Maybe they could make it so that the OG Poley owners would get the old music for the Poley skin whereas the new ones would get the music used currently
@@TheSeaGuardian1 then maybe make it so that the new ones get the Poley skin but with red instead of black whites for the eyes (so basically, the Poley we saw in the end cutscene of Book 2 Chapter 3)
I’ve already said this with the season build mode events, but Just add them back and give the ones that originally had it a alt skin of it, like it but remade to fit in with the other skins quality
I do agree that Poley isn't really well made skin like B2 ones. HOWEVER this is why it should stay exclusive. Because Poley is cool skin only because it's OG LIMITED skin. Poley was added like May 2nd 2020 I think... Next Secret, but not limited skin was Mr. P added to the gam 2 weeks later, but found month after adding Poley. Next Limited time secret skin was Mr. Stitchy, which got added 4 MONTHS after Poley.
I think they shouldn't bring the Poley back, it was the same situation with Brawl Stars, there was multiple ultra rare skin in Brawl Stars and the devs asked if they should bring them back, and the majority of the community said no, because, what's the point of getting a rare skin if it lose all its rarity? If the rarity just turn into dust, the OG players are gonna be really mad and frustrated.
As someone who used to own the Poley skin on their old account I think it would be nice to bring it back for not only the people who lost their old accounts but also the people who missed the opportunity to get the skin
minitoon should make it so if you dont have poley you get him but if you do you get a new skin that will bassicaly tell that you beat the og poley quest
i swear if they bring poley back i will spam use him i dont care if he isnt stylish, it just makes me remember when i used to start playing piggy. i think i played when the mr ps lab event only had 3 days left. i didnt get the poley skin since i sucked at the game but if they bring it back, i would start to probaly play more. Just so people dont get mad, minitoon can make the quest a bit harder so people dont get mad so eaisly. Maybe you have to do 3 things in mall and then move on to station and do 5 things there and etc.
I think it could be good if poley comes back because for one of the older skins its pretty cool looking and you could bring poley back but who got it when it was limited time you get like a little watermark to it
I'm annoyed by the second option being _new _*_cop_*_ skin_ If it's not gonna be SWAT (like Epic_Tank suggested) I don't wanna this to be cop at all. Why not Prisoner/Criminal skin?
Poley is special because hes rare, if everyone had gold, would it be special? And yes, I want it as much as the other guy, but for the community, we need it to stay how it is.
Why are people just mad over a skin?, there are so many limited skins and people are angry over some skin?, it’s like your mad over your favourite shirt or pants being gone, like bro chill it’s just a skin.
I don't play Piggy anymore after its huge craze in 2020 - 2021, but I feel as though Poley is the last bit of higher status and seniority over newer players that we can come back to and say "I was there for this". And with how much they've improved in making skins, it's probably better off they make a new skin anyway.
@@Elijahlikechicken In truth, I feel like it's ridiculous to have players do a one time only event, only for it to be completley worthless anyway if it was just going to return 4 years later anyway. And as per mentioned in the video, the design is not worth it anyway, so might as well just keep it as a collectible. A feature I would find interesting in regard however, is if Mini decided to add some form of trading to the game. Maybe that'd be pretty nice, allowing for Poley to remain its rarity, while still being technically accessible to newer players.
@@Foxolion I really don’t think we need a whole trading system in piggy, there’s just no point. And let’s be honest with ourselves, do we really care that much, if a piggy skin is no longer exclusive. I don’t see why it would be that big of a deal for the skin to come back to new players. I don’t think the 2 seconds of feeling cooler than 5 other people in the server is worth it.
@@Elijahlikechicken Overall, I feel as though it's kind of pointless to bring back Poley, seing as no one is gonna use him anyway with how outdated his skin is. Only reason people use him now is for his rarity. Otherwise, he just becomes a waste that no one uses, similarly to some of the older skins currently. At the very least, adding a new skin will allow a spike of further interest, and actually be a decent looking skin that players will use in-game. Poley should just be seen as a cool thing of the past, and nothing more.
@@Foxolion like I said, I think it’s better for a new skin. but I don’t see a problem with him coming back, it only benefits us, giving us more skin options. There’s no downsides.
Honestly, I don't like Poley to be back but rather a new police skin because Poley Is the rarest skin in Piggy for being one of the first limited skin events in Piggy. Not only that he must always belong with 2020 players, but other players are convinced they join in 2020. Poley is a sign of gratitude for the OG players. I don't care if anyone is starting to hate on me for not being on the side of Poley or saying “Poley isn't rare skin” I wrote this for my opinion and also I want this new police skin because there's a high chance that we are getting new lore to it and be part of the piggy universe just like Poley, Russel, ETC.
Look at it this way, if poley gets brung back then it loses rarity but if we get a new cop skin then not only will it most likely be as rare as poley - but in general we just get another modern styled skin
I think that it is an objectively better decision to pick the New Skin option, think about it, would you rather have an old, outdated skin that has aged kinda poorly, or alternatively, a brand new skin with drastically higher quality, design, and time put into it. Tbh, I don't really care which one is chosen over the other, ( as I already have Poley), but it is something to think about for those without it.
Either way, most people don’t care about old skins. I see most people wearing the recent skins like The Prototype and Duocara so the argument of players getting Poley doesn’t make sense., and due to this I think the community would be more satisfied with a new skin. Also, the Poley quest is super easy, you just do the mall obby once and then die.
A suggestion I have for the poley skin, if coming back, is to make an alternative skin of (poley from the heist) the Og's can have the skin with the tazer if that's the case, that will help stop the heated debate
if they really want to add the Poley skin again, I suggest they bring other event skins like Mr. Stitchy , that one penguin skin from Christmas and if the players don't like it since its RARE and not fair for og players, then I ask why the Poley skin would be excluded if they want to give everyone a fair chance then they should give everyone a fair chance for those skins Aswell if they disagree then they shouldn't exclude Poley.
I've been playing piggy since the first chapter (I have Poley on 3 of my accounts, I didn't realize the skin was rare at the time), personally, I wouldn't even care if Poley was even permanently bought back, its just a cosmetic that shouldn't mean anything to anyone. I'm honestly surprised players still think Poley is the rarest skin in the game considering how there are so many other skins that are many times rarer than it, probably just them clinging to Poley as any trump card in an argument because they don't have any rarer skin. But then again, there's already something in the mall vault (the prototype skin) so Minitoon has to probably find a different way to get the skin, there's also the fact that Poley wouldn't look up to par with current skins if he were to be bought back. A good middle ground would be to just remake the skin like minitoon did to the other book 1 skins, this way older players like me can enjoy the feel of a newer (and probably cooler) skin, while newer players get to keep the skin for their skin collection.
I do wish bringing back Poley won due to the fact I had him on an old account, I lost access to that account, and now I no longer have the skin. However, a new cop skin might be cool as well, and hopefully, I won't lose that one.
As a person who owns Poley, this is the most dumbest drama I’ve seen yet. Who even needs “Rarity” in Piggy? I don’t really see the issue besides people being butthurt that they can’t flex their skin that’s “rare”.
As someone who both own and doesn't own the skin (lost my old acc), I'm with Devoun on this one. Even back in the golden days I never used Poley despite knowing how rare it is, I'd rather main Robby or my Owell skin or something. Even now when I lost everything and started all over again 2 years ago, I never missed having Poley. The design was simple and the jumpscare always felt a little bland. It being the rarest skin was the only thing it had going for it, why take that away.
Personally, I voted Poley but I would want to see a new prisoner skin possibly. Let's say a dolphin in an orange jumpsuit that has their hands tied together with chains, these chains are a bit loose. Loose enough for the Piggy to kill the Player. Whatever happens I will be fine with it.
i was also around during the poley event, although, this was before i actually got into parkour on roblox, so i found it to be *really* hard for me to get this skin back then.
honestly, i would love if minitoon were to bring back the limited skins at least 1 more time cuz, what if someone were going through something and missed out on an event. for example, i was busy during the metallica event, so i missed the skin. so i think he should bring them back once more like he did with blatt.
I think the best solution here would be to do both, however make Poley a newer alt, maybe a Swat version. This way, we get the new skin, Poley is brought back as a new alt, so the people who want Poley back are happy, and the original Poley keeps its rarity, so the people who want to keep Poley rare are happy.
im actually glad we arent getting poley back. i personally dont have the skin (not because i wasnt there. i got the skin, but it was on my old account that got hacked because i fell for free robux, and when i got my current account, reobtaining poley was too late) which partially makes me want poly to come back, but i still think poley should stay rare. its always cool to point out that someone has the poley skin and i wanna keep that
I started piggy when carnival released and I do remember trying to get poley once but i wasn’t very good at piggy when i first started so I never got the chance to get it so I kinda want them to bring it back but if I already had it I wouldn’t want to bring it back since it would be rare
I have Poley. I hardly use him (apart from when I just want to jam out to his theme). It’s not like when others see the skin they start bowing down to me. I don’t care about the rarity. However, if they do bring him back, I’d be a bit annoyed that my only reward for completing a quest was a skin I already had. And it’s not even a very good skin.
Why dont they just rework the poley skin like hear me out the people who havent got poley yet could get it but maybe a lil modified and for those who already have the poley skin dont need to do anything and would you want to go do the quest again? now me i have never gotten the poley skin before ever thats because i didnt know there was an event back then, now people who want to get the poley skin, like what devoun stated no one used that skin before probably idk i havent seen one use that some people probably have but idk. now some people will probably disagree with me and thats fine i dont want to argue and for those who had read this thank you
If minitoon will even re-add Poley, another drama will happen on whatever reason:/ Despite me not having Poley, I don't really find it interesting to get, a new unique skin with good animation would satisfy players instead of a basic skin from 4 years ago (in my opinion). And what are the older players gonna do? We don't wan't another bloxburg like drama with the older players messing with the new players :/
As someone who doesn’t have the skin, they shouldn’t bring it back. I already have a sort of og skin (Mr Stitchy) and I would feel disappointed if he brought that skin back.
The skin is one of the first limited skins in the game, it's like a classic that reminds people about what the game was like then. And it's not that the skin is good, but the only reason people want it now is because its a rare limited. To bring it back would ignore the whole point of the skin being rare like it is currently.
As someone who has everything except poley, I am happy poley didn’t come back because if he came back that would basically be a slap in the face for the true og’s of piggy
Personally I'm on team Poley. Not couse of 'Omg I need it' but cause of the fact he's the only main bot in chapters that isn’t permanently obtainable Each bot in each other chapter has a permanent skin of some sort. but Poley was Limited time, and never got a varient either. Meaning Poley is the only Unobtainable Main bot skin you can't get to this day. An Poley remaster would be cool to see too lol. Can't wait to see Poley with a more accurate nose. (Anyways this is just a random Opinion.)
Getting a new skin is the way to go people can't always get what they want by constantly asking Minitoon for years (he has literally said for years that he wants to keep poley limited) plus bringing poley back only benefits half of the community where as if we get a new skin everyone gets something in the end
I mean it’s pretty much just people trying to gatekeep skins from other players because they want to flex that they are OG. As someone who owns the poley skin it doesn’t really matter to me if they make a new skin or bring it back (even though a new skin would be cool since i already have poley) but at the end of the day it’s a virtual cosmetic and it doesn’t matter that much, only these selfish gatekeepers are ones who don’t want it to be released again to stay “OG”.
The issue with bringing back Poley is that poley owners don't have any incentive to even play the collab. The best decision that isn't doing both at the same time is to do the new skin instead as both owners and players who don't own poley still have a reason to play the collab. A compensation alt skin for original owners just creates the problem again of new players being blocked from content by a time barrier(or losing the account that has it) which kinda sucks imo.
As a person who owns Poley, I don't want him back because if you have Poley, it shows that you are OG and have been playing I don't care if you don't have it. it is for people that have been playing the game from the very beginning.
If the new Poley replacement skin is better like a more detailed cop or a SWAT, then I would be satisfied enough.
SWAT or not cop at all imo
Yea
A SWAT skin would be amazing
“Swat skin”
Oh well then im FBI OPEN UP everytime i become piggy
SWAT skin would be awesome
Like imagine playing piggy book 1 on infection and seeing 3 SWAT piggy’s with rifles chasing ppl around the map
I would be quite happy if they released the old poley skin. I used to have it and all my skins got reset for some reason. It would be nice to have it back.
Also i found out poley got a new ost that i never knew about edit: or its been the same idk i haven't played in 2 or 3 years
It changed when Heist chapter realesed
It's fire
@@klakenkaiii oh
@@klakenkaiii og better
@@Din.Bin. fr
One thing I want Minitoon to do is bring back the old seasons, like Mr.P’s lab and stuff. Some people didn’t get the chance to get the stuff so I feel like it would be nice to the newer players
I agree even though I have rare skins people event build mode events mean people are limited on creativity because they didn't do a event OR he could just bring back seasons in general
i missed 3 event skins because i stopped playing some but its better to not bring them back and keep it for the people that got them
If they Didn't play the Event when it was ongoing That's on them I have no empathy For people who whine Because they didn't get a skin You Just have to Take that L
I think that there should be an updated variant for new players, but also an og variant with the classic design for the veterans.
Yes
Actually, I think it should be the other way round. An edited version of Poley that bares similarity to an already existing skin for people with Poley would be cool. Maybe you could make it like the Heist Poley, including the old theme and no hat. If you wanna use a skin similar to that, use Officer Doggy.
@@PoopyHeadGaming good idea
Watching Devoun at 3am is a vibe
yessir
Fr
true true
Agreed
Real
Honestly, I feel like people don’t want Poley back just so they can flex on new players, a new cop skin would be cool but I feel like they should do both, maybe modify Poley a bit for the new player like for example have the one from the heist ending cutscene. Exclusivity shouldn’t exist in Piggy imo
If the old players were a month - 2 months off from getting him, they would want him back too.
I want Poley back because I had the skin, did the quest. But then I lose my account. So as much as I want a new skin, I want a chance of getting what I once had.
Yes it shiould buddy not even an opinion
I WANT POLEY I HAD NO IDEA THIS WAS OUT BACK THEN BC I STARTED PLAYING PIGGY WHEN BOOK 2 CAME OUT.
VERY AGREEABLE THOUGH!!!!!
ima crash out if they bring him back (I haven’t played since 2020 💀)
I know it’s not connected to this, but is it interesting that the world said that he would smash anything that Mr. P loves let’s say what if helicopters. What do he smash it?
@@PiggyOGuser1I’d smash Mr p
SAME
This comment is genuinely amazing
I have xd (not tryna be rude)
6:17
“I personally love the fact that we can make children cry with it” - Devoun, 2024
I was going to say the same thing
Fr
lol
I personally think the most prominent argument against bringing back Poley is more like we'd be missing out on a new character and players that already have it will have probably no reward when completing the event
One could say that if they add a variant of Poley, they could have a reason, but it'd certainly be less appealing than a new character. Maybe some people just don't want a variant of Poley, leading them to not play the event
From both sides personally I can understand. It be nice to have the Poley Skin back because everyone wants it, But at the same time it Also makes it less special and rare
Edit: personally i feel like its best to have both. If i were MiniToon i would bring back the Poley Skin alongside a new Cop Skin to bring in. Therefore new players can try and get it again while older players can feast on something new. It'll probably be a lot of work but patience comes first.
Too many people will cry but I agree with this. I was 2 months off from getting poley and if the people crying were 2 months off they would want him coming back. Their just biased.
Fr we couldve have both
Its still an collab special so it cant be brought back permanently so if it come back for like an week it should not be a big deal + rarity of the skins makes no sense since ot just gives you ability to laugh at New players for missing an event and nothing else litteraly since skins have no litterall value at all
4:23 that was personal
It’s true tho
I would if I had it. Chartless Chase is a banger
Honestly I don’t mind Poley being back, used to use him all the time when I played Book 1!
Me too, I honestly don't mind!
I was playing when poley relased but i missed poley cause i was busy with school but i dont want poley to come back because it was a limited skin and i dont think i deserve that skin
I'm alright with that, but most of them going to not agree with this
I think they should bring him back but do a different harder event for him (cus the old one was too easy) but anyone who already has him gets a new way better skin (if they have poley)
I had that skin on an old account but my brother changed the password so on my new account, I don't have it even though the skin isn't that good.
Thanks for bringing in the real issues at the end.
It’s official piggy is back
When did it go away
@@Dustin_Probably last year
Because minitoon said that he would stop working on piggy
@@IsaacHarrison-cx9on on the main game. He stopped working on it to work on piggy intercity and also now we got a book 3 coming out
@@IsaacHarrison-cx9on But for majority of players, it's actually when Book 2 ended or when that last mansion chapter came out.
It should be where there is a new cop or maybe prisoner skin up to date with the modelling but there should be an option to get pokey. As rare as it may be it’s really just a skin, not traceable and doesn’t make your account. Having the option to get a cooler skin will get people with pokey and new players happy while the poley skin will make collectors and perfectionists like me happy. It can also have some replay ability if you want both
4:30 I don’t know about that one Devoun, I heard the Poley skin is bugged and can glitch through Vents just like TIO
"WE'VE GOT THE SCOOP TO KEEP YOU ON THE LOOP!" ahh video :D
nostalgia
I think a redesigned poley would Satisfy everyone.
Heck yea, it’s would be rare AND better so it will actually look like a rare skin
While it would be nice, this is the same community that god mad about the prototype skin when its the newest skin we has in months so they wont be satisfied.
Agreed
Good enough in retrospect
8:34 THIS would satisfy everyone. EVEN MORE SEXY POTATOES But..... MR P IS HOTTER!!!!!!!!!!!
Also, there has been some rumors saying that Mr. Stitchy will be added back on Halloween, but Minitoon can't do that because if he adds Mr. Stitchy back then it's pretty much the same thing as adding Poley back, because Mr. Stitchy is also limited just like Poley and rare as well, so if he adds Mr. Stitchy back then people who have Mr. Stitchy and not Poley are going to get mad but people who have Poley and not Mr. Stitchy are also going to get mad, so the best solution would've been to either add both of them back or add neither of them back, and he said that he thinks its good to keep Poley rare, but then he can't add Mr. Stitchy back either because he would basically change what he said about keeping a rare skin rare.
I say you should just change up the skin a bit so the new people can get that one, so the og players can still have the rare skin while new players can get a similar skin
Maybe make the bear a brown bear, or change up the uniform
agreed
The thing is people really want poley back because it's rare and could be the only skin they are missing in their collection, changing it up slightly would be a new skin
I also agree but it would make another war
They should make it like the distorted piggy skin where you could switch between the new and the old version, that way people who only got the new version technically still own the skin in their collection.
I hope they bring it back since when it was out i didn't manage to get it even after getting into the vault! It was super hard to do on a public server. They could also bring it back for the new piggy game :)
Nah minitoon already said no, its gonna be a new cop skin so cry about it
@@s_otercry about it is the worst comeback ever🤣🤣
@@Issacrobloxcontents yea lol
@@s_oter An updated Poley skin would look sick!
@@s_oterKeep in mind that Asimo did say that he had no problem with bringing Poley back, so there is still a chance that Poley could come back. 0:39
I would agree most of the new skins are 100x better and it would be nice having a new limited skin. But I wouldn't mind if Poley came back.
To be fair if we got a new skin more people will be happy about it and not just the people who need to get poley. A new skin we be great since Minitoon has gotten better at creating skin, also another point is we shouldn’t really be getting updates so the Piggy community should be grateful for Minitoon still caring for piggy.
I think they should forget these limited skins and just bring back anyone of the holloween event skin like they did with frostiggy and left the primrose limited
They should make an item shop for collab skins like Fortnite.
It swaps everyday
@@Seasy_The thing is that the Poley skin would lose its value and the original owners of Poley who got it back in 2020 would be very mad about it.
Like what would be the point of doing the quest to get poley when you could just wait for it to appear on the shop and buy it ?
@@ARedbirblike 90% of the original owners don’t even play the game anymore, and no one even uses that skin anyways
Honestly I think the best route is just to do both, it satisfies those who don't already have the Poley skin and gives the players who do have already have it something to do
The thing is, if poley comes back then minitoon might aswell bring back every season and skin because it'd also be unfair for people who didn't play at that time. Personally, I think a new skin would be better.
Edit: I have to stick with a new skin. For old players who already have the poley skin, the whole event rewards nothing. Besides, new skins are much higher quality, so it'd be awesome to see a new one instead.
It coming back doesnt justify the rest, tho, it should be the new cop skin. Minitoon is way better now than back then and Poley is mid either way
@@TeapotDude fr
@@TeapotDudefax
@@TeapotDude agreed
@TeapotDude i think i saw u in another video
I've already said this in a reply to this but i personally think if poley comes back this would be a different version of poley which is from book 2 chapter 3's end cutscene and both skins would be separate so that way the original one still remains it's rarity but the people who never got him would be able to finally get him in some way
I personally want the poley skin to come back, because I was playing piggy when it was available, I just didn’t know about it
I really like poley skin and use it anytime I play piggy, one time this person asked me how to get it and I said they couldn’t anymore. As much as I feel bad I prefer that it stays exclusive to older players like Mr. stitchy.
As an owner of Poley bring him back. But give the OG owners a rare cool variant that stands out
Yes. If poley comes back this should happen
Maybe they could make it so that the OG Poley owners would get the old music for the Poley skin whereas the new ones would get the music used currently
Small change thing but ok@@NotLancer2018
@@TheSeaGuardian1 then maybe make it so that the new ones get the Poley skin but with red instead of black whites for the eyes (so basically, the Poley we saw in the end cutscene of Book 2 Chapter 3)
No I want a new cop skin no offfense but Poley is basic and boring.
Never stop Devoun, you are one of my favorite YTbers.
We will have 3 police skins now if we get a new one
(Officer doggy, Poley, and new one if a new one comes)
[That'll be epic]
I’ve already said this with the season build mode events, but
Just add them back and give the ones that originally had it a alt skin of it, like it but remade to fit in with the other skins quality
I’m disappointed that he didn’t start with “Today on Roblox Drama” 😡
I do agree that Poley isn't really well made skin like B2 ones. HOWEVER
this is why it should stay exclusive. Because Poley is cool skin only because it's OG LIMITED skin.
Poley was added like May 2nd 2020 I think... Next Secret, but not limited skin was Mr. P added to the gam 2 weeks later, but found month after adding Poley.
Next Limited time secret skin was Mr. Stitchy, which got added 4 MONTHS after Poley.
I think they shouldn't bring the Poley back, it was the same situation with Brawl Stars, there was multiple ultra rare skin in Brawl Stars and the devs asked if they should bring them back, and the majority of the community said no, because, what's the point of getting a rare skin if it lose all its rarity? If the rarity just turn into dust, the OG players are gonna be really mad and frustrated.
What if you were a month away from getting it
Me when I gatekeep 😢😢😢😢
@@kingdarkness1166 I wouldn't care.
@@Kow386 cap
@@kingdarkness1166 I do like to wear caps, not you? And what the point of asking thşs question? You would answer "cap" anyway.
As someone who used to own the Poley skin on their old account I think it would be nice to bring it back for not only the people who lost their old accounts but also the people who missed the opportunity to get the skin
this is a poll for a piggy skin, not a “drama”.
Scroll through this video’s comment section for 5 minutes
I don’t mind, maybe they could make the OG owners of the Poley skin have a unique thing? Maybe the og owners would have the old music for the skin?
Or give everyone doing it this time th heist model and refinery infected eyes
minitoon should make it so if you dont have poley you get him but if you do you get a new skin that will bassicaly tell that you beat the og poley quest
i swear if they bring poley back i will spam use him i dont care if he isnt stylish, it just makes me remember when i used to start playing piggy. i think i played when the mr ps lab event only had 3 days left. i didnt get the poley skin since i sucked at the game but if they bring it back, i would start to probaly play more. Just so people dont get mad, minitoon can make the quest a bit harder so people dont get mad so eaisly. Maybe you have to do 3 things in mall and then move on to station and do 5 things there and etc.
I really hate limitation so it should deffinetly return
I think it could be good if poley comes back because for one of the older skins its pretty cool looking and you could bring poley back but who got it when it was limited time you get like a little watermark to it
If poley comes back I think he should rerelease the season skins as well
Bakari Is Too Good To Be Available For The Average Player Lol
I'm annoyed by the second option being _new _*_cop_*_ skin_
If it's not gonna be SWAT (like Epic_Tank suggested) I don't wanna this to be cop at all.
Why not Prisoner/Criminal skin?
Silly poley causing drama😂😂😂😂😂
Poley is special because hes rare, if everyone had gold, would it be special?
And yes, I want it as much as the other guy, but for the community, we need it to stay how it is.
Why are people just mad over a skin?, there are so many limited skins and people are angry over some skin?, it’s like your mad over your favourite shirt or pants being gone, like bro chill it’s just a skin.
@almomggamer5327 I am doing an example for the skin.
exactly, minitoon is bringing back mr stitchy and bess anyway. might as well add poley back.
poley isn’t even worth try getting (even if he is still free)
@@pancakesmollgoblin the theme is worth it(Chartless Chase)
@@speedattack that’s true-
Alright, hear me out. Minitoon adds a new skin in AND adds Poley, maybe Poley could be a skin you could buy for a limited time.
The poley skin is a og
But why do people want it back when we have officer doggy he’s a little similar
“we have poley at home”
@@TigryFromPiggypoley at home:
I don't play Piggy anymore after its huge craze in 2020 - 2021, but I feel as though Poley is the last bit of higher status and seniority over newer players that we can come back to and say "I was there for this". And with how much they've improved in making skins, it's probably better off they make a new skin anyway.
I’d want a new skin, but that reason is actually so dumb bro.
@@Elijahlikechicken In truth, I feel like it's ridiculous to have players do a one time only event, only for it to be completley worthless anyway if it was just going to return 4 years later anyway. And as per mentioned in the video, the design is not worth it anyway, so might as well just keep it as a collectible. A feature I would find interesting in regard however, is if Mini decided to add some form of trading to the game. Maybe that'd be pretty nice, allowing for Poley to remain its rarity, while still being technically accessible to newer players.
@@Foxolion I really don’t think we need a whole trading system in piggy, there’s just no point. And let’s be honest with ourselves, do we really care that much, if a piggy skin is no longer exclusive. I don’t see why it would be that big of a deal for the skin to come back to new players. I don’t think the 2 seconds of feeling cooler than 5 other people in the server is worth it.
@@Elijahlikechicken Overall, I feel as though it's kind of pointless to bring back Poley, seing as no one is gonna use him anyway with how outdated his skin is. Only reason people use him now is for his rarity. Otherwise, he just becomes a waste that no one uses, similarly to some of the older skins currently. At the very least, adding a new skin will allow a spike of further interest, and actually be a decent looking skin that players will use in-game. Poley should just be seen as a cool thing of the past, and nothing more.
@@Foxolion like I said, I think it’s better for a new skin. but I don’t see a problem with him coming back, it only benefits us, giving us more skin options. There’s no downsides.
oh no, drama again?
So true, I never see anyone use the Poley skin
I haven’t watched you in years 🥹
If you think about it, adding a new skin is the best way to engage old and new players instead of just newer players
Honestly, I don't like Poley to be back but rather a new police skin because Poley Is the rarest skin in Piggy for being one of the first limited skin events in Piggy. Not only that he must always belong with 2020 players, but other players are convinced they join in 2020. Poley is a sign of gratitude for the OG players.
I don't care if anyone is starting to hate on me for not being on the side of Poley or saying “Poley isn't rare skin” I wrote this for my opinion and also I want this new police skin because there's a high chance that we are getting new lore to it and be part of the piggy universe just like Poley, Russel, ETC.
Look at it this way, if poley gets brung back then it loses rarity but if we get a new cop skin then not only will it most likely be as rare as poley - but in general we just get another modern styled skin
And it looks way better
Actually bring back Poley but give a style or whatever for OGs that makes poley look like a more modern skin
I think that it is an objectively better decision to pick the New Skin option, think about it, would you rather have an old, outdated skin that has aged kinda poorly, or alternatively, a brand new skin with drastically higher quality, design, and time put into it. Tbh, I don't really care which one is chosen over the other, ( as I already have Poley), but it is something to think about for those without it.
Bring poley back with a new quest to get him, and give those who already got him in the past a cooler looking alternative, simple!
Either way, most people don’t care about old skins. I see most people wearing the recent skins like The Prototype and Duocara so the argument of players getting Poley doesn’t make sense., and due to this I think the community would be more satisfied with a new skin. Also, the Poley quest is super easy, you just do the mall obby once and then die.
i love your videos
“I personally like the fact that we can make children cry with it” I feel you I got it for that reason💀
I think it would be really cool if they added both!
A suggestion I have for the poley skin, if coming back, is to make an alternative skin of (poley from the heist) the Og's can have the skin with the tazer if that's the case, that will help stop the heated debate
As a person who doesn’t own poley I really want the skin
if they really want to add the Poley skin again, I suggest they bring other event skins like Mr. Stitchy , that one penguin skin from Christmas and if the players don't like it since its RARE and not fair for og players, then I ask why the Poley skin would be excluded if they want to give everyone a fair chance then they should give everyone a fair chance for those skins Aswell if they disagree then they shouldn't exclude Poley.
One of the major reasons I want Poley to return is his theme, IT’S FIRE
I've been playing piggy since the first chapter (I have Poley on 3 of my accounts, I didn't realize the skin was rare at the time), personally, I wouldn't even care if Poley was even permanently bought back, its just a cosmetic that shouldn't mean anything to anyone. I'm honestly surprised players still think Poley is the rarest skin in the game considering how there are so many other skins that are many times rarer than it, probably just them clinging to Poley as any trump card in an argument because they don't have any rarer skin.
But then again, there's already something in the mall vault (the prototype skin) so Minitoon has to probably find a different way to get the skin, there's also the fact that Poley wouldn't look up to par with current skins if he were to be bought back. A good middle ground would be to just remake the skin like minitoon did to the other book 1 skins, this way older players like me can enjoy the feel of a newer (and probably cooler) skin, while newer players get to keep the skin for their skin collection.
DEVOUN ITS ME FAKE DEVOUN
I do wish bringing back Poley won due to the fact I had him on an old account, I lost access to that account, and now I no longer have the skin. However, a new cop skin might be cool as well, and hopefully, I won't lose that one.
Same man.
As a person who owns Poley, this is the most dumbest drama I’ve seen yet. Who even needs “Rarity” in Piggy? I don’t really see the issue besides people being butthurt that they can’t flex their skin that’s “rare”.
roblox players when they can't flex their worthless items that mean nothing
I feel like a new cop skin would be cooler too, I got poley and I don't think I've ever used him
I want new skin but I still would not mind if poley came back
As someone who both own and doesn't own the skin (lost my old acc), I'm with Devoun on this one. Even back in the golden days I never used Poley despite knowing how rare it is, I'd rather main Robby or my Owell skin or something. Even now when I lost everything and started all over again 2 years ago, I never missed having Poley. The design was simple and the jumpscare always felt a little bland. It being the rarest skin was the only thing it had going for it, why take that away.
I definitely want a NEW skin. Mainly because it would be fun to think of another character's backstory.
i think you should keep it rare as it is a reward for those who played when the game was still new
Personally, I voted Poley but I would want to see a new prisoner skin possibly. Let's say a dolphin in an orange jumpsuit that has their hands tied together with chains, these chains are a bit loose. Loose enough for the Piggy to kill the Player. Whatever happens I will be fine with it.
As somebody who basically has none of the event skins, I’d be happy with either option being chosen
i was also around during the poley event, although, this was before i actually got into parkour on roblox, so i found it to be *really* hard for me to get this skin back then.
honestly, i would love if minitoon were to bring back the limited skins at least 1 more time cuz, what if someone were going through something and missed out on an event. for example, i was busy during the metallica event, so i missed the skin. so i think he should bring them back once more like he did with blatt.
I think the best solution here would be to do both, however make Poley a newer alt, maybe a Swat version. This way, we get the new skin, Poley is brought back as a new alt, so the people who want Poley back are happy, and the original Poley keeps its rarity, so the people who want to keep Poley rare are happy.
im actually glad we arent getting poley back. i personally dont have the skin (not because i wasnt there. i got the skin, but it was on my old account that got hacked because i fell for free robux, and when i got my current account, reobtaining poley was too late) which partially makes me want poly to come back, but i still think poley should stay rare. its always cool to point out that someone has the poley skin and i wanna keep that
I started piggy when carnival released and I do remember trying to get poley once but i wasn’t very good at piggy when i first started so I never got the chance to get it so I kinda want them to bring it back but if I already had it I wouldn’t want to bring it back since it would be rare
I have Poley. I hardly use him (apart from when I just want to jam out to his theme). It’s not like when others see the skin they start bowing down to me. I don’t care about the rarity. However, if they do bring him back, I’d be a bit annoyed that my only reward for completing a quest was a skin I already had. And it’s not even a very good skin.
Why dont they just rework the poley skin like hear me out the people who havent got poley yet could get it but maybe a lil modified and for those who already have the poley skin dont need to do anything and would you want to go do the quest again? now me i have never gotten the poley skin before ever thats because i didnt know there was an event back then, now people who want to get the poley skin, like what devoun stated no one used that skin before probably idk i havent seen one use that some people probably have but idk. now some people will probably disagree with me and thats fine i dont want to argue and for those who had read this thank you
If minitoon will even re-add Poley, another drama will happen on whatever reason:/ Despite me not having Poley, I don't really find it interesting to get, a new unique skin with good animation would satisfy players instead of a basic skin from 4 years ago (in my opinion). And what are the older players gonna do? We don't wan't another bloxburg like drama with the older players messing with the new players :/
As someone who doesn’t have the skin, they shouldn’t bring it back. I already have a sort of og skin (Mr Stitchy) and I would feel disappointed if he brought that skin back.
The skin is one of the first limited skins in the game, it's like a classic that reminds people about what the game was like then. And it's not that the skin is good, but the only reason people want it now is because its a rare limited. To bring it back would ignore the whole point of the skin being rare like it is currently.
As someone who has everything except poley, I am happy poley didn’t come back because if he came back that would basically be a slap in the face for the true og’s of piggy
Personally I'm on team Poley. Not couse of 'Omg I need it' but cause of the fact he's the only main bot in chapters that isn’t permanently obtainable
Each bot in each other chapter has a permanent skin of some sort. but Poley was Limited time, and never got a varient either. Meaning Poley is the only Unobtainable Main bot skin you can't get to this day.
An Poley remaster would be cool to see too lol. Can't wait to see Poley with a more accurate nose.
(Anyways this is just a random Opinion.)
I think minitoon should make a robber skin cause they already have 2 cop skins, so I think it would be cool for minitoon to add a robber skin.
Rash, billy
I definitely prefer the new cop skin, its also nice to know devoun still uploads about piggy.
Getting a new skin is the way to go people can't always get what they want by constantly asking Minitoon for years (he has literally said for years that he wants to keep poley limited) plus bringing poley back only benefits half of the community where as if we get a new skin everyone gets something in the end
ive always had a "you snooze you lose" mindset to these sorta things
I mean it’s pretty much just people trying to gatekeep skins from other players because they want to flex that they are OG. As someone who owns the poley skin it doesn’t really matter to me if they make a new skin or bring it back (even though a new skin would be cool since i already have poley) but at the end of the day it’s a virtual cosmetic and it doesn’t matter that much, only these selfish gatekeepers are ones who don’t want it to be released again to stay “OG”.
The issue with bringing back Poley is that poley owners don't have any incentive to even play the collab.
The best decision that isn't doing both at the same time is to do the new skin instead as both owners and players who don't own poley still have a reason to play the collab.
A compensation alt skin for original owners just creates the problem again of new players being blocked from content by a time barrier(or losing the account that has it) which kinda sucks imo.
As a person who owns Poley, I don't want him back because if you have Poley, it shows that you are OG and have been playing I don't care if you don't have it. it is for people that have been playing the game from the very beginning.
What if they played from the beginning but didn’t get the skin in time?
@@Seasy_ Well then it still stands
@@Noahstiever76what if you played piggy everyday but didn’t know anything about the event?
@@Spazy912 Well there's that but you can just get a new skin and that would be good
They're dangling him infront of our eyes in things like cutscenes, he must come back along with mr stichy if hes so lore-related.