Abbott and Costello - WHO'S ON FIRST? REACTION!! | OFFICE BLOKES REACT!!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 кві 2022
- linktr.ee/TheOfficeBlokes
Comment Below with More Reaction Ideas!
Show some support and sign up to our Patreon for exclusive videos not on UA-cam, Access to our Banned Videos and to guarantee we react to your request
Email - officeblokesreact@gmail.com
Link to original video: • Video
Recorded at Atlantic Podcast Studios: info@atlanticpodcaststudios.com
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
Widely regarded as the greatest comedy routine ever written. I cannot argue that myself, it sure has stood the test of time, and is just overall a unique piece of writing.
You absolutely nailed it.
I would add to that "overall a unique piece of writing and performance."
Bud Abbott's own brother thought it was the dumbest thing he had ever heard and told them nobody would ever laugh in it because it was just stupid 🤣
Bud Abbott and Lou Costello are the only 2 members of the Baseball Hall of Fame who are not associated with the sport be it a player, manager owner writer or other executive
Well they aren't actual members of the Hall of Fame, but this sketch is honored there.
The sketch plays on a continuous loop.
Who is the HOF?
@@imamisfit445 What is the HOF
Personally IDK he's on third
@@paulobrien9572 ha! ha,!ha!😆😆😆
Classic comedy bit. Still funny to this day. Their timing is impecable.
Timing is everything
Funny thing is that these 2 hated each other behind the scenes.
@@Duane_Grabert No they didn’t. A little bit later toward the latter part of their careers, yeah.
Much more so was Jerry Lewis and Dean Martin. Lewis was total jealous of Deans multi talents.
@@Duane_Grabert The partnership disintegrated when Lou Costello started insisting that he be paid more than Bud Abbot.
@@mmka1iirc, bud abbott also had trouble with alcohol
The fact that this has modern comedy fans genuinely laughing is such a testament to how well done this is.
It really is that it's "well done". The actual comedy of the writing wears thin after the first couple lines, yet the way they carry it throughout the act keeps you rolling in laughter.
@@Anubis78250 Yeah It did. I saw another versino of this, it says in the title "most widely known version" or some shit but the other one I saw was better actually I thought. Maybe it's just nostalgia bias since it was the first time I had seen the skit done for real. I've always known about it but never seen it until not that long ago actually.
Abbot and Costello is the best, and that’ll never change
@@djjazzyjeff1232 good comedy is good comedy regardless of when it comes out,
@@ggmm6182 Facts, same with good music, and good movies, but the problem is good movies and good music can be so dated feeling that it is a drawback, I was worried comedy is the same way.
The speed, the timing, the error free dialogue, the acting, all combine to make this a classic. There have been many attempts to replicate this routine but no one comes close to recreating this with all of the aspects done well. These two guys had been doing this routine for perhaps 30-40 years and it shows. Watch them do the routine "13x7 is 23" and "Dice Game". Classic bits done by professionals without profanity or sexual allusions.
One of the best aspects of this routine is that because it revolves around confusion and simplistic language, even if they mess up they can recover or improvise their way back on track rather effortlessly without tipping off the audience. Eventually they remember all the best bits and do it so often that they could probably do it in their sleep, but the pressure is way less for them because they still have the freedom to improvise new dialogue if they want/need to. This also makes it very difficult to replicate because if you try to do it off of a script then you confine yourself to a rigid dialogue that removes the freedom that the original performers had.
arguably Johnny Carson with his "President Regan & Jim Baker" Routine on his Tonight Show, came in a close contendor. (My opinion of course, but the original I stand by your thoughts)
@@lappingmatch Recently saw a rerun of the "copper clapper" bit Carson did w/Jack Webb. Back when late nite TV was still entertainment.
I wouldn't say that it's error free dialogue. Just about every version I've seen of this has been slightly different and that's it actually being Abbott and Costello. They just have free enough dialogue that any errors can be re-railed really easily. I've seen/heard versions where Costello is the one who starts on about the paychecks and others where it's Abbott instead. As you saw in this one, Abbott was attempting to start that bit, but Costello was on a roll, so he instigated it instead. I'm not saying you're wrong in anyway, they just have a clear routine and they have it down so well that they can afford to improvise as much as they want and they know the limits to when to stop improvising and get back to the joke.
The 13x7 is 23 is so funny!
This was done in front a live audience. One take, no cuts...pure genius!
Office Blokes React, love your reactions. FYI, Abbott And Costello made got their start in Vaudeville. they then went to radio from there, then finally the Silver Screen. Check out the contract scene between Groucho and Chico from "A Night At The Opera" and the Ma And Pa Kettle sketch 14x5=25. Pure Comedy Gold. I'll find more for you gents to enjoy. Cheers!
The amount of practice it took to be able to do this on stage had to be amazing. This still holds up after all these years.
They toured on the vaudeville circuit for decades before TV came around. They perfected this over hundreds of hours of performances!
This is a very old routine, originally from Vaudeville. Abbott & Costello perfected it. They performed it several times, live as well as on radio & film - this version is from the television series they had in the 1950s.
It was also in their movie, "The Naughty Nineties"
I'd suggest "performed it a thousand times or more. Maybe 2-3000..."
They played it around 30 times at this point. That’s a bit more than “several”.
This was comedy GOLD ! It's 70 years old (at least) and yet it's STILL hilarious!
That particular filming seems to be 50's quality.
@@williamjordan5554 yep I believe this was taken from their 1950's TV show
@@williamjordan5554 The hairstyles and their outfits all scream "50's" as well.
they'd probably been doing versions of it for close to twenty years when this was filmed, so they had it down pat by this point.
“7x13=28”’is one of my favorite Abbott & Costello skits.
These guys were huge back in the day. Universal Studios had their Monster Cinematic Universe, the equivalent of today’s MCU, and Abbott & Costello were so big that they did crossover movies with those movies.
Dude I hope they do that one next.
'Abbot and Costello Meet the Invisible Man' is comedy plantinum.
Meet Frankenstein was a favorite
"Smart Math" is my absolute favourite routine they have ever done, eith the craps routine as second. Whos on First is my third favourite.
A classic comedy routine.
Still gets me to this day
This has actually been put into the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, NY. They have a special screening room for this sketch at the HoF.
This is amazing 😂 I didn't know that, but I love it that that's a thing 👌
'Who's on 1st' is an exhibition in comedy timing. It's comedy stripped down to the chassis. It's an essential part of any comedy geeks toolkit.
Jerry Seinfeld speaks about this routine at length.
Abbott and Costello, Laurel and Hardy, The Marx Brothers, and The Three Stooges...all great old time comedy.
When in I was a kid in the 70s I watched 1940s Abbot & Costello movies every Sunday morning. They were incredible productions from comedy to musical acts. They even had a horror movie with the actual actors who played Frankenstein, Dracula and the Wolfman. Abbot & Costello meet the Monster.
I watched Abbot & Costello and the Little Rascals before school from 1st grade - to 4th grade almost every day. Was a great way to start the day.
I watch them on the weekend too-- loved those movies
Don't forget "Ma and Pa Kettle", "Francis the Talking Mule", Shirley Temple movies and Kukla, Fran and Ollie. Back then you only had 3 channels but they played great movies.
Slowly I turned, step by step........
@@traceythompson1092 It was in Niagara Falls, NIAGARA FALLS!
I’m around Dave’s age, but absolutely LOVE older black and white entertainment. Some of the best stuff ever made is from that era. Don’t sell it short.
I grew up watching the classic movie channels, and I still adore Danny Kaye as a comedic actor.
@@Oleandra-13 Jimmy Stewart is one of them for me. I remember when I was a kid, in my American History class around about grade 7, at the end of the chapter about Congress and filibusters and stuff our teacher showed that movie and I was like, "Oh great an old shitty movie." And even as an apathetic 7th grader I was like wait this movie is actually kinda good. Then I learned about the widespread love for It's a Wonderful Life and then some of his other movies, they just blew me away with how good they are especially when you think about the technology they were dealing with back then, or lack thereof, but anyway, I'm kinda rambling now. Lol
@@Oleandra-13 Speaking of Danny Kaye, The Court Jester is one of my favorite comedies, and probably is my very favorite musical.
@@devenscience8894 It was, to me, a masterpiece. It really had some great vaudeville flair!
@@devenscience8894 It was, to me, a masterpiece. It really had some great vaudeville flair!
"Now, that's the first thing you've said right all day."
"I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT !!!"
Bud and Lou are the only non-baseball players, commentators, managers ....ever inducted in the Baseball HOF in Cooperstown. Even after all these years,...it still makes me laugh!! They never break during the whole routine! This was done Live... in front of a studio audience as well as being on tv! They were masters of timing!
They were never inducted into the hall of fame. This sketch is played in the museum to honor its popularity and timelessness.
A Dodgers player in 2007 called Chin-Lung Hu made it to first!! life imitating art.and there have a been a few players name watt/watts, so watts on second must have happened.and there is a pitcher named Brandon Morrow. if his parents only had named him tom.
If only they had thrown the ball TO Morrow
GREAT comment !!! 🙌🏻
This is indeed true. Reportedly, the announcer said at the time that he had been waiting for decades for the opportunity to say, "Hu's on first."
Hu's on first?
@@oscarantoniomoreno5247 naturally
When I was a kid I watched this show religiously. It was all live. Two comic geniuses.
I'm a millenial that LOVES the old stuff. Intelligent comedy, hip hip hooray! 🎊 👏
You're a rare one! Most Millenials refuse to watch anything that was made before they were born. Very short sighted. You will end up being far more cultured than any of them.
Abbot and Costello, Laurel and Hardy all the 1 straight-man/one-liner comedy stuff is GOLD ✨ too me 😂 never ages! I’m crying laughing 🤣
They were the #1 comedy team of the 1940’s and big movie stars, they made a number of ww2 comedy war films helping the government sell war bonds to help fund the war effort, they also toured army bases to help boost morale. Check out Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein
I’m 32 years old and my Dad had a cassette tape of Abbot and Costello bits when I was a kid. He would play them when we were in his truck and I’d always make him play Who’s on First. I was probably 6 or 7 when I first heard it and some how I totally understood then everything they were talking about.
Abbot & Costello 7x13=23 is also a good one.
It's 28
Great pick! These guys are the GOATS with many routines no one else would even try because of the timing involved...!
Vaudeville. Comics acting out a routine, not telling a series of jokes. They were the best
This. They were almost more like jazz musicians improvising off each other, but using a handful of stock phrases. If one said the one thing, it cued the other to say the other - but you still recognize the tune. There are quite a lot of different versions of this routine out there, and they are all different from each other, although you will hear the same phrases used each time.
@@joeday4293apparently they never did it exactly the same way twice.
They must have practiced this a million times to get this down to perfection without stumbling on a single word. An absolute classic bit.
Never gets old 😂. While this performance was from 1953, they originally first performed it on a radio program in either 1940 or '41. Hilarious!!!
Vaudeville too.
@@steveo4749 Absolutely! Thanks for reminding me!
Yes, from their television show that aired from 1952 to 1954. 😁
Such a classic!!!!! Abbott & Costello are simply American classics. Thank you for the reaction!!
I grew up with Abbott & Costello, Laurel & Hardy, Dean Martin & Jerry Lewis and The Marx Brothers. So good to see you guys reacting to this. Brings back memories
Now you gotta do 13 x 7 = 23! Another Abbott and Costello classic skit.
Thats probably the most famous skit of all time. Its a classic!
A great comedy team! Abbott & Costello, Laurel & Hardy, Martin & Lewis, The Three Stooges, all great old comedians.
Never forget George Burns and Gracie Allen
My favorite part of this is as the routine goes on, they both say "third base" everytime one of them says "I don't know". Can't keep the other names straight, but always knows third base 😀
I grew up with a mom who was already in her early 50’s when I was a toddler so I watched this since I was a baby along with listening to the Beatles and such.
The first time they did this skit was on live radio, no cuts, just pure genius and talent.
Arguably the best bit of comedy ever written. As a theatre major I had teachers using this bit in lessons.
This one is sort of a part of American history, so you might like "13x7=23" even better. Another classic bit from them but without needing the layer of nostalgia for old-time baseball.
I'm 64 years old. Been hearing this all my life. Never gets old.
They and The Three Stooges were the best in that era. They did a lot of funny things back then.
Those comedians from 'back in the day' surely had it going on. You can listen to a Jack Benny radio show from the 30's and be laughing your butt off because his comedy is so timeless. Glad you enjoyed Abbot and Costello. I knew they would win you over.
The greatest and most popular comedy routine of all time.
Impeccable writing. It's a classic for a reason.
What makes this skit great is their timing and how they never stumbled or missed a beat.
In fact, chaps, Bud Abbott and Lou Costello are the only non-ball players ever to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, and it was on the basis of this sketch. It was also performed in one of their movies, made in the 40s, and many times on stage. It is a legendary piece of mid-century comedy and of American culture, and, i think it must be said, a must-know piece of humour. Absolutely Ronnies Corbett and Barker would have been intimate with this piece and with all their work. I have heard Ronnie Corbett discuss his awareness of American comics like Bob Hope and others, with encyclopaedic detail. He certainly knew Abbott and Costello.
Omg!!! I never thought anyone was into them like I am. I remember my great grandmother showing me these two when I was a kid and this was always my favorite skit!! Love you guys for this! Keep being awesome!!
The Sklar brothers are a standup comedy duo. Also, Keith and Kenny Lucas are also a twin standup act. And who could forget the Smothers Brothers?
Garfunkel and Oates
Genius... They dont make em like this anymore.
Another classic of theirs, "7×13=28". Must see
There are a hundred great moments in that bit. MY favorite part is when Lou joins in by saying "Third base" along with Bud, even though he doesn't know the reason for that. It's conditioning! ROFL. Just love this. Thank you!
My favorite part is that they do this so seamlessly and without laughing themselves.
Abbott and Costello are an absolute powerhouse of older-day comedy. I highly recommend watching any skits you can like "7x13", "Loafing," "The Lemon Game," and "Dice."
Classic! Those were the days of great comedy. 🤣🥰🥰
I can just imagine how difficult and coordinated they had to be to do this bit.
Having seen a few renditions of it, they actually wobble a few times (comparing the slight differences of a line here and there), but they are such pros and have this down so pat, they just repeat the setup again and fix it so smoothly you don't even notice.
I wonder how rigid it is or how much is left for improv. I'm guessing it's got an outline and they just sort of wing it and rely on their improv skills for the timing and how long to stay in which bit and stuff.
It’s a classic bit of comedy that still has me in stitches every time I watch it - and what’s really amazing is how long they can draw it out and still make us laugh!
The timing, the speed, the back-and-forth, it's a master class in comedy. Even if someone didn't find it funny (I don't know how), you'd have to be very impressed with the amount of practice and skill this took.
I was born in the 1970s but my parents were born in the 1930s...The Honeymooners, Albert and Castello, the Stoogies, all golden....almost forgot, Britains own Benny Hill.
Their best bit for me. Abbott and Costello,-(7x13=28). Keep up the good work 😎👍.
I was a big Abbott and Costello fan when I was younger. Of their theatrical films, this skit appeared in its entirety in only one, The Naughty Nineties (1945), though it appears in part in One Night in the Tropics (1940). My favorite skit of theirs was "you're 40, she's 10"
“Who’s on First” and “the Aristocrats” jokes are the best of all time in American comedy.
This is from 1952 I believe. And to think they did this whole skit in one take. Incredible!
This routine was perfected over many stage performances like this before they got into television and movies and made it big. Today comedians don’t have to work as hard at their routines before they get the big payday.
Mike, "I was in the audience"! LOL! I saw this a long time ago. Honestly, I forgot what a classic this skit was! Brilliant! 🌟
I believe the first time watching Abbott and Costello - Who's On First, was over fifty years ago. I laughed so hard then and though they are no longer alive I still laugh hard every time I watch it. Classic comedy.
I remember watching this as a kid on a Saturday morning, I'm not that old.
Abbot and Costello show used to play some of their best skits back in the sixties and early seventies.
Classic! If you wanna go deep into the old school comedy rabbit hole, check out Burns and Allen.
I've watched 12 straight different react vids to this skit and it's interesting how many didn't get the wordplay involved. And yes, I laughed at all 12 viewings because it's downright hilarious!
Great stuff from the classics. They actually did a few movies that were pretty good.
I’m a Brit living in the US. When I first heard this skit I knew nothing about baseball. Good comedy transcends countries and types of games an we are all one enjoying an incredibly well-written, well-rehearsed skit.
President Franklin Roosevelt's favorite comedy routine - left him roaring with laughter.
Classic comedy that stays funny no matter how many times you watch it. You don't need any curse words, vulgar gestures, or adult theme to get a laugh.
You got Abbott an Costello, Lauren an Hardy, Dean Martin an Jerry Lewis, the Three Stooges, Marx brothers, and my personal favorite Red Skeleton. They was the talented comedian stars of their time.
I love the Animaniac's parody of this "Who's on stage"; its how i first learned about this classic bit.
incredible performance by the blokes.
I've watched and/or listened to this routine hundreds of times and it is still funny every time!
This is the most genius, greatest comedy skit of all time, and is almost 100 years old.
I can't believe you didn't immediately think of KEY & PEELE when trying to think of double acts haha
You haven't live till you've seen Abbott and Costello Meet The Monsters. One of my all time favourites.
Dave's inner monologue: "I'm just gonna smile and pretend that I am entertained by this old man stuff"
Abbott & Costello were the ultimate expression of the old Vaudville 'bamboozle' - at least as it translated to radio, tv, & film. Unlike a baseball, they were seamless. tavi.
Part of the reason that skit is so good is that the audience actually gets anxious for Lou
This skit is so iconic that when I was in highschool in the early 90s this was in our literature textbooks as an example of classic American comedy. We would perform it in class every year. There is another version of this that's more up to date by Jeff Dunham called Peanuts Password Panic.
In the 80s I was sitting with another girl on the stairs when a teacher about 65 yrs old squeezed past us and headed down.
I said to my teenaged friend, "Okay let's go again" and we launched into this routine. For no reason. Just to amuse ourselves & each other. The teacher put on the brakes, backed up and turned to stare at us with his mouth open in astonishment. The look on his face was hilarious.
This skit is FAMOUS in the US.
That was the best comedy improv all time
As was alluded to at the beginning, they were doing this routine so fast. In conjunction with that, they never messed up their lines. I can't imagine how long they had to rehearse this routine before they were ready to do it for the first time on stage. Also, did you notice that there wasn't one time when a 4-letter word got into this routine? Those were the days.
Have you ever seen another of their routines--13 x 7 = 28? Also hilarious!
I grew up to Bud & Lou doing skits on shows and also their silly comedy movies as Abbott & Costello meets Frankenstein or the Mummy and many others.
I watched this stuff growing up, its amazing to see so many people still laughing at this ingenious skit !
I love this skit and have seen it dozens of times over the course of my life. It still makes me laugh, which is a sign of good and timeless comedy. Thanks for doing this one today!
A staple of American comedy 🙌
This has got to be one of the top ten comedy sketches of all time.
Abbot and Costello were the grandfathers of the "straight man/funny man" routine. They defined this style of duo act back then, and their influence can be clearly seen today.
Some things that are old are still fantastic.
Like mountains.
Those comics from the early-mid 20th century were the best.
Best comedy team in the US. They began in vaudeville 1936 as a team due to their need of partners and timing during performance.
They moved on to radio on The Kate Smith Show. She is famous for singing “God Bless America”. This is where “Who’s On First” was first heard across the country.
Later, Hollywood called to put the team in pictures. Buck Privates, In The Navy, Hold That Ghost, Hit The Ice, The Coeds, The Time of Their Lives, African Screams………and then Abbott and Costello Meet The Invisible Man, Abbott and Costello Go to Mars, Abbott and Costello Meet the Mummy, Abbott and Costello Meet the Keystone Cops, Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein. Plenty more pictures to list.
They split in 1956 due to arguments.
Lou Costello died in 1958 result heart failure.Bud Abbott died in 1974 due to age.
I still know this skit by heart and I was born in the 60's, 20 years after they first did it.
So good, the timing is impeccable, brilliant.
Greatness has no expiration date. This will be a top 10 comedy bit of all time in 4355. Amazing timing and talent
Buster Keaton and Charlie Chaplin were 2 acrobatic comedians of silent movies
The skit was performed in 1954 and the context of humor has totally changed
I have laughed a hundred time watching this! They were great.
Always loved this one. Classic. Perfect timing with each other
To put this in UK terms, Abbott & Costello were the 1940s US version of Fry & Laurie. This particular skit was from The Abbott & Costello Show episode "The Actor's Home" which by that time, the duo had performed the routine dozens of time including for President Franklin Roosevelt several times... and they rarely performed it exactly the same way twice