Reincarnation, scriptural evidence, and moral evolution
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 січ 2024
- Vimoh Live is a weekly call-in show where I talk with callers about religion, culture, and atheism.
Support the channel by clicking the JOIN button and becoming a member.
Or become a patron at / vimoh
Or make a one-time donation at www.vimoh.in
Want to create live streams like this? Check out StreamYard: streamyard.com/pal/d/61809340...
Dear vimoh , I am 69 years old , IAM a atheist from the age of 16 , lived like that without any issues , you r doing a great work wish you success, life is possible beyond religion and god , ✅🧬👍
Many thanks!
Awsome ... i am 55, former muslim since aroung 15 years ... thanks to my son, who said he no longer believed in god; it was a catalyst for my question and wihtin few months, i realised what nonsense is any religion ...
@yellareddy4321
"Dear vimoh , I am 69 years old , IAM a atheist [...] life is possible beyond religion and god"
======================================
I wish that I had opened my eyes and smelled the coffee at as early an age as you did.
I too wish Vijayendra Mohanty the best.
@@tariq_sharif
"Awsome ... i am 55, former muslim since aroung 15 years [...] realised what nonsense is any religion ..."
============================
So, did you become an atheist around your age of 40 years ?
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist Yes, that is about correct ... all religions endevour to provide comfort and "answers" to what happens after death... it is a scary thgought...
But what i do know is that once i die (hopefully in a long time and with not too much pain) the atoms that once made me, me, will return to the cosmos. To what future, no one knows, and i take comfort in that.. ... until then we have one life, one planet, and really need to preserve it for future generations.
How about you ?
Hats off to beerbiceps for single-handedly reducing the IQ for an entire country he needs a reward for this impressive feat
Earlier I use to watch standup comedy for daily does of entertainment.
Now I listen to people's paranormal experiences on vimoh's live stream for entertainment😂😂
Thank you for the free content vimoh :)
I do the same. Lmao 🤣🤣
Same here 😂😂
The first caller! Wow! Just WOW! One laughs when listening to the arguments but also feels sorry for the state of thinking people have in 2023.
Why Reincarnation doesn't happen among non Hindus. Because they do not believe
Feeling so bad for Vimoh that he has to deal with the likes of the first caller 😂
That dude was so confused even the last Saturday.
And also likes of blesson jacob
Muslims be rejecting hindu's scriptures and hindu's be rejecting muslim's sriptures and an atheist be laughing at this drama (also crying out of compassion for the miserable state of the other two)
❤🎉
@preetgamer1495
"Muslims be rejecting hindu's scriptures and [...] miserable state of the other two)"
================================
6:17 (presumably Haryanvi) HINDU Parminder Rana
34:04 MUSLIM Suhail
1:08:27 HINDU Mohit Rana
1:55:08 (presumably Malayalee) CHRISTIAN Blesson Jacob Sunil
*Imagine the outcome if these four try to discuss their beliefs amongst themselves inside a room!*
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist In a country like India I don't have to imagine. I just have to switch on a news channel :/ (sad reality)
Muslim belief : God by definition is uncreated, infinite, eternal, immortal, omnipresent, omniscient, most powerful, creator of universe, there is nothing like him (no idol or human).
If you believe in intelligent design that we humans are and other intelligent beings in the universe, then there is an "intelligent designer". Next question is - what does the intelligent designer wants from us? does he has will? does he communicate?...throughout human history scriptures are believed to be a communication from God. So now lets look into the scriptures and compare all the scriptures on following points -
"Concept and Nature of God, factual and historical evidences in/of scripture, moral values as preached and practiced by major religious figures in the scripture, consistency of the message, simplicity and unambiguity of the message, guidance for justice and equality"
Based on these parameters we find that Quran is the only true scripture.
Would love to hear from you. Thanks.
There is no God but...
This episode was fire 🔥. Especially, the first one. It means vimoh is getting popular. Congrats. This is becoming more like atheist experience. And i am loving it.
I'm sorry Vimoh you have to deal with these crazy people... lol
@vimohlive bro I take a bow out for your patience ❤
I have a lot to learn from you.
I've just discovered this channel... @vimoh has immense patience to deal with these debates in a manner without getting riled up... I'm getting riled just listening to some of these
Often I look at an avg hindu and wonder what has the society done with human's rationale ! And then I happen to encounter literally educated muslims (like sahil on this stream) and lose my mind.
Also, it brings a sense of fear in me as with the RSS in power and right wings heavy presence over SM we are heading towards the same path that made pakistan what it is today !
Hope scientific temperament increases in society with efforts of people like vimoh. Thank you sir for what you do :)
Religion leaves deep scars on ones mind. I wouldn't be too surprised if I ever encounter people like Sahil.
@@lasyak6355 haina ! It depends on how rigorous the social conditioning has been. The conditioning in conservative societies is intense hence the possibility of overcoming it is very less (and zero if the person is not exposed to a liberal environment)
@@preetgamer1495 Absolutely. I agree.
That's a fear I live with everyday 😢
No need to fear
great discussions!
"reed ki haddi ke niche garmi thi" 😂
Pehle wala mast tha guru, mere dost ka hua h reincarnation 😂😂😂
I can confirm ! I am that friend /s
@@preetgamer1495 apne friend ke maje mat le bhai 🎉😂
@@p9655 😂😂
😂
phla haryana ka tha.
So if someone goes to the reincarnation guy & says "I was your brother/sister/wife/husband in the previous birth, so now you have to give me a part of your inheritance or you owe me 1 Crore"
Will he give them?
Negative skepticism?
Isn't skepticism by definition questioning literally everything?
Bhai😆
I will go do that and get free 1cr rupees
Bro You are so underrated but this shows that how masses are mislead. If I ever become a billionaire then I'll be donating you millions man. Thanks for your work, Wish I had a few friends like you. Keep going.
If patience were a person it’s Vimoh.
Thanks!
Welcome!
First one is a LEGEND..
HE is a reader..
Love you Vimoh bhai ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
echolocation occurs when an animal emits a sound wave that bounces off an object, returning an echo that provides information about the object's distance and size. Over a thousand species echolocate, including most bats, all toothed whales, and small mammals
Request: Can you please add timestamps for each caller?
Thanks!
Bhai i am not atheist...but the logic comments that you give...maja aata hain..keep it up...not a sarcasm..we need pepole like you
The first caller was saying 'haan th chle jaao"...when vimoh said "main dusre caller ke pass ja rha hun"..
Bhai aap koi ehsaan nhi kr rhe ho vimoh par...aur audiences par...kya yaar...
Logical fallacies ke agar koi awards hnge then woh en mahoday ko diya jaega
Hi, Vimoh. This is my very first message to you. I am a fellow atheist. Have discovered your channel only a few days back. Great work, man. Keep spreading awareness. More power to you. Anyway, what I want to say pertains to the point the last caller made. Perhaps he didn't give the right example. But suppose, if instead of the maid stealing a mobile, she steals a spoon from a kitchen that has several number of same spoons and this theft would not be noticed by the owners of the house then would this act of theft not be immoral? (Remember according to your logic an act is immoral only if it hurts the others.)
Time is also a parameter in deciding morality or immorality I guess.
@@mrrahulkurup Absolutely. Time and place. Let's say context, as it includes both time and place.
Umm it is quite subjective in my opinion. It can vary from one person to other, if the maid feels like she is not doing bad it is not immoral for her, but for most people have an instinct that theft is totally immoral so that's how it goes imo
Wouldn't stealing a spoon hurt too. The spoon might have been bought from someone else with the exchange of currency, so it will hurt you economically. If not that, then it's a breach of contract/trust between the employer and the employee, that is immoral too.
In this hypothetical, we can add a hypothetical that let's say 5 years have passed since the spoon stealing incident. No one has died or gone bankrupt, not the thief or the victim. The thief has gone on to become a successful philanthropist while the owner is convicted of embezzlement. Now how will you say who is immoral?
Me: so doctor i was meditating in my sleep and i felt as if my right side got paralysed and when i tried to sit i could feel electricity running through my legs
Doc: you've had peripheral neuropathy sir, you should take these folate/vit b12 tablets.
Hahaha
Vimoh sir kaya logic Diya hai aap ne to mujhe nai cheej sochne ko majboor kar detein hai aap mai aap ko insta se follow karta hu ❤
It's true I myself since 8 years old I remember I felt like I was born in other country. I idealised that place, later when I gathered information about that country I became more specific that in my previous life I was there. After 13 I forgot all that and as became self aware I realised it was my fantasy🎉
I guess so many people do not have any idea about “Evolution- a long journey from single cell organism to an entire human being” which explains complexity of human body.
BTW screen wallpaper was so appropriate this time 😅
Don't panic! Haha! It was giving quite the opposite effect. An empty spooky room, where a ghost has written 'Dont Panic' on the wall and the letters are dripping down!
Isliye to Upnishad me Shloka hai...
"Ekoham Bahusayam"
Dear doctor without a creator human life existence is impossible. Worship the creator not creation.truth is always bitter than sweet lie.good luck😊
@@tasnimali5659 agar apki hi logic se chalen to Creator (Allah) ko kisne banaya ?😂😂 Aur agar wo khud hi aa gya to Puri Creation khud ba khud q nhi ho sakti?😀
@@tasnimali5659 the only reason why is it so important to study science
Super commander Dhruv? Damn, bachpan yaad agaya 😅
same here
vimoh plz make some videos on evolutionary biology na ! Trust me that subject opens up the minds of many theists !
Wow this was chaotic
First guy was high.☘️☘️☘️
Level of stupidity is great!!!! Super entertainment…keep up the great work!!! New subscriber here… you Meghnad and Pranav are the holy trinity of reasoning and rational thinking!!! 😄
The embroyology that is mentioned in Quran is copied from Aristotle. And many ancient egyptians knew these things way before Islam.
Your patience is amazing
I just wanted to ask that you refered a tribe in South america that doesnt believe in the concept of god can you please tell me what's the name of the tribe BTW love your streams and excited for your further plans ...
“Negative Skepticism” 😂😂😂
3:11 start
Vimoh had us in the first half when he said "Parwinder is a good person" 🤣
Once before going to sleep , I watched godi media, and when I woke up the next day - I reincarnated as an Andhbhakt.
Because my logic died the night I kept on binging godi news and well….the rest is andhbhakti 🤷♂️
First one is actually funny 🤣
🤡i was thinking that he would discuss some serious topic
@@aryanchandrakar699 same here 💀
It went downhill really fast!
To the incarnation guy - Are agar koi insaan ka ek sense nahi he to uske dusre sense jyada activate hota he. To obviously ek andha insaan ear ka jyada use kar sakta he jo normal insaan nahi kar sakta.
not only you, satyam jha also generously gives to human with science
Vimoh ,you can't wake a person who is pretending to be asleep.
I don't know why people don't believe that religion is created by humans.
Oh my god that one caller was so frustrating i could eat my fingers
Hey Vimoh. I think you should have pointed out the difference between a theory and a hypothesis while you had Suhail on the call. You guys were both saying that God was a theory and formation of a solar system and it's plantes is a theory. The latter is a theory while the former is a hypothesis.
For the formation of earth, we have a lot of evidence and models which provide examples using simulation which are verified through observations in other galaxies and within our milky galaxy in other more distant solar systems, who's light (from its formation) has just reached us now as they are further away from us.
Enjoying😂
The first 32 minutes honestly felt like two close minded individuals trying to convince each other. Hoping to see mutual openness to broader perspectives in the residual portion of this video 😔
Salute to Vimoh for grilling parminder very patiently
I don't agree with points of communism, but I agree to the points of vimoh regarding atheism and I am proud atheist.
First guy was so fun 🤣🤣🤣 मेरे दोस्त ने बोला है 😂
34:39 Looks like my friend 😊
Hey Vimoh ! What's your opinion on ACHARYA PRASHANT? Haven't found him propogating pseudoscience !
He often condemns superstitious practices, rituals and so called "hindu culture" too (he says culture is product of society and the society is ignorant hence their is nothing significant about culture). He called out this bageshwar baba too in an interview with newslaundry and asserted that nothing such as magic power/paranormal experiences/ghost etc exists ! He has also made videos on such topics and rejected idea of supernatural stuff or something like that.
In 2019 he made a parody video on sadhguru lol ! He exposed his many crap ideas like "water memory" and other stuff back in 2020. These days he often criticisez ISKCON for their "bhakti marg". He believes no methods like "meditation", yoga or ritual can get you liberation ! No merchandise as well .
He often emphasisez on developing critical mind and hence suggests to gain knowledge in these 4 fields : 1. Psychology 2. Evolutionary biology 3. Neuroscience 4. Phylosophy .
And no indifference to other communities as well ! He has many discourses on n no of sufi mystics, Quran, Bible explaining the verses (now that's rare in today's babas)
P.S: If you wish to then I will attach some links of these videos or you can check his one on one podcast with "Kunal kamra". And yeah he also rejected concept of "reincarnation". (btw vimoh sir , your accent is dope !)
He is damn fraud person in the name of spiritual.. Also promoting casteism and superstitions in another way possible.
30:00 this guy says without all the body senses he can see or feel the remote locations via spiritiual beings.
This is like 300 rupee smart watch which shows you spo2, steps, clorie count, without any censors.
I dont think even this guy will buy this watch 😂😂😂
Also according vedas and isckon gurus if you stare at the 300 rupee watch and chant radhe govind it predicts share market prices.
👍😅🙏
One Comment. It is not the mistake of young people. They lack scientific rigor because they are not taught that. A suitable training is required to differentiate between a rigorous scientific theory and a speculation.
Bro why didn't you took Lazy???
1:07:22 Josh gates really 😂 he is just a host for a show in discovery 😭😭
1:56:00 vimoah said that creator thing about remote control not God 😂😂
SC Bose: Tum mujhe khoon do
Vimoh: Aap mujhe proof deejiye
How times have changed
@Dontwatchyoutube
"SC Bose: Tum mujhe khoon do [...] Vimoh: Aap mujhe proof deejiye How times have changed"
===============================
Sensible people were willing to believe Subhas Chandra Bose because he was demonstrating his patriotism... in other words, he GAVE PROOF of his patriotism.
How blatantly people (like you) try to misrepresent facts,
How blatantly people like you try ad hominem attacks.
kya? Dude, I was making a joke. WTF did I just read@@ex.hindu.now.atheist
Now i am confused about what is more effective on this people epistemology or just pure facts and evidence...
I am missing amit tiwari sir here 😅.
Shyam manav unmulan work send this case their sir
Garam Energy😁Bijli ke jhatke jaisi.
😅😅😅😂😂😂😂
The last guy ended the call with his foot 😐
Dealing with atheistic morality, spirituality ,kundalini chakras and psedo-scientific theories and speculations is opening can of worms. How can anyone deal with all this :P
holy moly vimoh debating so.many delusional people.😮😮 its.amazing
1:07:39 seriously 🙂.. Kon se gola se aya h re tum.. Paise ko kon mna krta bhai 😭 impressive 🙌🏻
Ye Mohit naam wale ese hi kyon nikalte Hain 😭
Tu bhi esa hi tha kya?☠️
I KNOW THAT I KNOW NOTHING
FREEDOM FROM KNOWING EVERYTHING ....
Man Vimoh why would you turn away a cash cow like that theistic dude who kept giving you money while giving entertaining nonsense...
Feels wrong
@@vimohlive Integrity is rare, man keep it up.
@@vimohlive love you sir :)
@@vimohlive
"Feels wrong"
==========================
Vijayendra, there is NO NEED to feel bad about accepting that 'Jha' character's money.
1. You are not misleading him/her in any manner;
2. He/she KNOWS that he/she is giving money (towards work that questions theism);
3. Going by all available evidence, it appears that he/she is of sound mind at the time that he/she is sending money to you;
4. It is OBVIOUS that he/she is sending money because he/she feels that it would make you feel obliged to read out aloud, the accompanying comment that he/she posts-this point is ESPECIALLY important.
Therefore, there is NO NEED for you to feel bad and/or to dissuade him/her from sending money-unless he/she is laundering money!
गजब भाई , लव यू❤❤❤
साइंस जर्नी , रैशनल वर्ल्ड , ह्यूमन विथ साइंस की जय हो😊❤❤
Inko science ke bare me ghanta kuchh pata Hain. Arpit explain has knowledge about science and rationality.
Inko science ke bare me ghanta kuchh pata Hain. Arpit explain has knowledge about science and rationality.
Inko science ke bare me ghanta kuchh pata Hain. Arpit explain has knowledge about science and rationality.
@Vimoh what should we think of the lgbtq+ community ? Kindly present yr humble views 🙏
He support it
I'm not Vimoh, but Vimoh on multiple occasions has shown solidarity to the LGBTQIA+ community.
As it doesn't something that people can control, even if someone argues that they can control it and they are being like that on their own; eventually it comes down to wether they harm somebody or not, and my answer will be NO they don't harm somebody. So their action of being LGBTQ+ is out of the moral landscape, they are same as any other human being.
@@lasyak6355 i know he supports but he didnt elaborate on that right
@@factsunknown8275 I'm not Vimoh, but if possible, I would love to know what questions you have. I personally consider myself well read on this topic so I would love to provide my input if you want me to.
About the reincarnation conversation - anecdotes are not proof.
Note - I don't believe in reincarnation.(writing before anyone attacks me for this)
You can only have observations of reincarnation. There are many cases researched by Ian Stevenson though. And the new cases by Dr Jim Tucker. Both of them are scientists and have documented 2500+ cases and verified a vast majority of them.
Even the critics were saying that they are very careful in choosing to report and didn't report without solid evidence
I don't believe in reincarnation because that would fuck up our entire understanding of biology and we would have to formulate entirely new theories to explain everything
But I cannot ignore the evidence that they have presented either.
Although there were many critics saying that the children were lying about reincarnation but then, 2500 cases is a huge lot. And we need to study each one of them
@@RandomIndianUsingYT I would suggest you to research a little bit more about Ian Stevenson's work and don't just go on with what the first google search says. There is a whole pdf of his research work available on Google. Just go through it. His whole research only suggests that Reincarnation "May" exist. It's in no way an empirical proof. not even the evidence that reincarnation is possible in any way.
Also, just so you know that Dr. Stevenson himself emphasised multiple times throughout his work that his work "PROVES NOTHING". It only makes suggestions.
@@RandomIndianUsingYT😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂 bkwas h wo 😅😅😅
Sym.manav sir h .... Nagpur... Okk
25 lakh Ka prize❤❤🎉🎉
Okk
Re..... Birthday party😅😅😅... Nonsense h ...
Samjhe...
Sorry Vimoh, But Parmindar ne khub entertain kiya.😄😄😄
prashan is that you
You are mistaken bro@@cr8114
Parminder is very confused but it also shows how deep seated beliefs are so well rooted that he himself isn't aware of the flaws in his approach
Ye log Kapil Sharma ke comedy band karwakar hi rahenge 😂
How do you equate masturbating in public and wearing a certain kind of clothes? One is a purely sexual act, the other is not.
In both acts no one is physically hurting some but in both of them they are hurting the emotions of other people.
@@blessonjacobsunil4087 There are tribes in Africa where people don't wear clothes, so I guess they all are immoral atheists? Clothes are part of culture and can vary from culture to culture. Women get punished in Iran for not wearing Hijaab. So not wearing Hijaab is immoral? These are social rules made by "Man" (and I mean "Man" not humans). There are no rules in Atheism except that we dont believe in the presence of God. Morality has nothing to do with Atheism. The most corrupt people I have seen in my life are all also the most religious people I have seen. Whereas I who dont belive in God have never cheated or done anything wrong to anyone.
@@jaswindersinghnarula4379 Just because people are illiterate and live in there superstitious society does not mean they are right.There are several illiterate tribes that follow the traditions which are very dangerous for them and often die early because of that so you would are that they are also right because they are not aware or literate.That does not mean there are no objective moral law in there so society does they kill each other or masterbate in public no.They are doing so because they are unaware that they are wrong.
33:25 Jab camera off hota hai tab zyada aggression hota hai pata ni kyu. Try to understand it more. You may get some new information about self.
👍👍👍
See if we are going to have debates with children then I dont think it's time well spent watching Vimoh.
Now people are more religious less human
33:29 Haan
Pehle walo ko to sense kya hain wo hi nhi pta..wo to mujhe class 8 me hi PTA chal gaya.sayad us se pehle
57:25...bro he is just 17...
Don't give him 18+information....
Bhai wo toh pehele hi pad liya "reed ki haddi se sperm nikalta h"
Measurement of morality... What you do to others, are you okay if it's done to you?
If you hit your parents then will you be okay getting hit by your children. If not, then it's immoral.
What If someone says it is morally okay 😂😂 than will it be immoral according to you😅..it means morality is just subjective according to atheist 🤣
What If someone says it is morally okay 😂😂 than will it be immoral according to you😅..it means morality is just subjective according to atheist 🤣
Parminder se na ho paayega. Claims are not evidence. Lol.
Who is creater of Universe ?? Just simple answer -- No one can create Universe because everything living inside The Universe, just like a child never create own Mother living inside wombs.
No one can cross the universe because ending point is the starting point of A Zero ( Sunya) there is no ending point of Universe
First caller ...how badly a person could be irrational
Faith is not evidence , universe is not creation but exit and continue to change because of inter action of various natural forces
For dear sahil as Ricky Gervais said if you don't believe in other people's gods i just don't believe in one more .. ... 😊😊... I m somewhat religious but the argument that my god is better than yours is a stupid argument.... and they say they believe in one good... What about if the same god just experience differently to different part of the world .... Why can't we just respect each other and just move on with our life ..😃
Vimoh more hindi/urdu plz
that depends on his guests.
I know, but some of them are not fluent so start with hindi with them.
I do think you went a bit hard on the first guy. Perhaps a bit more empathetic de-escalation may've been more effective.
Mere dost se mene pucha toh wo bola wo bhi reincarnate hua hai😂😂
Mera dost ne bola she loves me to maine maan liya
😅
first debate 😂😂😂
Areee Baap re.. Kitna gadha aadmi h😂😂. now i understand MLM Mein kaise faste h log..
Dost bol rha h toh man jata hoon.
Koi jhooth kyu bolega.
Isne jisse Baat karwai woh khud Audi rakha h.
MLM wale k ghar walon ne bhi bola hamara beta hoshiyar h. 😂😂
Yaar 1st caller ne jaise hi bola reincarnation kaam khtm bhai last me to iss bande ne chupiyapa kr diya mujhe gussa aa gya ki wo Bewakoof insaan tha
This rebirth guy is so childish. His entire basis for believing anything seems to be "I like this person so I will believe whatever they say."
Ye kya UP ka koi machli bazaar hai kya? Why is he being so aggressive?
❤
Let's say what happened to him taken as true anyguy going so far to some village testing and finding it to be true whate er his friend said would surely believe reincarnation exist. Except that one can otherwise simply do few lie detector test on the friend.
@@priyaranjandash7527even lie detector won't work on delusions.
@@gamesong6600 Delusion of what??? He said his friend said something and he tested it in what way there can be delusion ??
@@priyaranjandash7527 his friend can be delusional. Lie detectors don't work if you truly believe in a lie.
2nd, 17 year kido have some sense of humour..😆
Hey hey hey vimoh. I will urge you strongly to not have a demeanor like that of matt dilahunty. Like not being warm, muting callers, or being just a little bit too blunt. I just got that vibe.
Saw your call show for the first time btw
Communism? Seriously?
How the fuck is communism coming into the picture?
Maybe he has watched a lot of Chrisitian Apologists calling Atheists as Communists.