American reacts to British SAS Soldiers vs US Navy SEALs

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 643

  • @helenwood8482
    @helenwood8482 Рік тому +397

    This is why other countries, including the US, ask to borrow the SAS when they want something done properly.

    • @harryjohnson9215
      @harryjohnson9215 Рік тому +56

      Or just ask them to train their troops
      Or help set up a special forces group.
      They did it for the:
      Americans, Polish, French, Finland, Egypt, and so many more

    • @WhySoSerious551
      @WhySoSerious551 Рік тому +18

      Every Nato country do joint military training exercises. Also a select few train together, Delta, Sas, add in Australia, Canada but no others. But no Delta operator has the privilege of the full Sas experience, and no Sas operator cares about not having the privilege of thr full delta training experience, since it not required. Back to the borrowing thing, it's like this, if a Belgian merchant ship is off the coast of Madagascar, and it has beed boarded, it is quicker to get US or British forces there than Belgian. If Islamic extremists take a school hostage in Sweden, who has more experience in a matter like this, swedish special forces, or British. Britain would offer their assistance, and it would be received.

    • @dorianwylie9000
      @dorianwylie9000 Рік тому +7

      or just go obi wan nairobi 🤣🤣

    • @broflo3875
      @broflo3875 Рік тому

      The US has never chosen another Special Operations group over their own to do anything. Every operation they have they want "done correctly". If they wanted the SAS for top operations then they would have been tasked to take UBL, Baghdadi, Saddam, etc. They weren't. They weren't even wanted by the guys of JSOC until they proved themselves.

    • @Cassy_mackay
      @Cassy_mackay Рік тому +3

      It's true

  • @adrianbland7656
    @adrianbland7656 8 місяців тому +29

    Seals have 1 week of hell. SAS has 6 weeks of hell before for the final part. that's why SAS is the best

  • @Dasyurid
    @Dasyurid Рік тому +273

    SAS stands for Special Air Service and is part of the British Army. The Royal Navy have something similar called the SBS, the Special Boat Service. Both are part of the UK’s special forces, though the SAS is probably the best known bit thanks in part to its very public successful hostage rescue / terrorist takedown operation at the Iranian Embassy in London in 1980.

    • @andrewwood8706
      @andrewwood8706 Рік тому +7

      beat me to it lol

    • @Mark-Haddow
      @Mark-Haddow Рік тому +6

      The SBS was founded by the Royal Scots of the SAS. The army needed a unit that could traverse shorelines, to attack shoreline targets.

    • @Thurgosh_OG
      @Thurgosh_OG Рік тому +13

      And the SBS is actually the more specialist unit of the two. You get to hear about SAS missions sometimes, you don't get to hear about SBS missions, except for the WWII ones.

    • @cybertrophic
      @cybertrophic Рік тому +6

      @@Mark-Haddow Nope, The SBS is largely formed of Marine Commandos who pass SAS selection then go on to specialist training. The SAS is largely formed of ex-Paras. My uncle was in the SBS.

    • @Mark-Haddow
      @Mark-Haddow Рік тому +1

      @@cybertrophic
      Yes, it is. Because any member of any service can apply to train and join. The RAF can join the SBS, the Army can join the SBS. Civilians can join the SBS, first via the reserve, then the company.
      The SBS is an independent unit that began with Scots Guards, exactly like the SAS. This is a fact. Instead of waffling, look up their origins.

  • @matthewwalker5430
    @matthewwalker5430 Рік тому +214

    The SAS aren't comparable to the Navy Seals though, not entirely. The SAS are a Tier 1 unit whereas the majority of Navy Seals are Tier 2. You could compare them more specifically to DEVGRU/SEAL Team 6, but not the Navy SEALs in general. Really, the SAS are the equivalent to America's Delta Force (or rather, Delta are the equivalent to the SAS as Delta was structured specifically on the SAS) and the SBS are more like DEVGRU.

    • @fredosinsemilla3896
      @fredosinsemilla3896 Рік тому +7

      You're pleb tier right?

    • @matthewwalker5430
      @matthewwalker5430 Рік тому +47

      @@fredosinsemilla3896 Why? Are you hoping for a promotion?

    • @Thurgosh_OG
      @Thurgosh_OG Рік тому +6

      SBS is actually the more specialist unit of the two.

    • @harryjohnson9215
      @harryjohnson9215 Рік тому +2

      ​@@Thurgosh_OG if i remember correctly they are a split of from the SAS
      Some point after major David sterling was captured.

    • @dee2251
      @dee2251 Рік тому +18

      @@Thurgosh_OGthe SAS has trained every allied special forces. There was no special forces until the Brit’s and then every country have tried to model themselves on them.

  • @CyberBeep_kenshi
    @CyberBeep_kenshi 8 місяців тому +47

    basically every western special ops base themselves on the SAS, and are trained by them. they really are the best

    • @mrmagic5990
      @mrmagic5990 5 місяців тому +3

      All special forces around the world are based on the SAS

  • @acechimera7394
    @acechimera7394 Рік тому +131

    It blows my mind that you haven't heard of the SAS, I didn't think there was anyone worldwide who didn't know that name

    • @xxyxnxwxaxx9724
      @xxyxnxwxaxx9724 Рік тому +5

      I think he was pissing on are back and telling us it's raining.

    • @barryetheridge6639
      @barryetheridge6639 7 місяців тому

      Do a piece on the sas and doesn't know who there are thick as shit

    • @Hew.Jarsol
      @Hew.Jarsol 6 місяців тому

      Yanks don't get very well educated. They're stuck in their own little echo chamber.

    • @paulbyrne8568
      @paulbyrne8568 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@xxyxnxwxaxx9724Classic lad great shout from Clint eastwood film Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining

    • @orangewarm1
      @orangewarm1 3 місяці тому +3

      Gen Z are very closeted.

  • @NavaSDMB
    @NavaSDMB Рік тому +67

    The people from Infographics are from the US, and generally so are their sources. While their material is interesting, it should generally be taken with generous amounts of salt. In this case they couldn't even get correctly what does SAS stand for...

    • @LG-cz6ls
      @LG-cz6ls Рік тому +2

      The Special Air Somethings?

    • @Hew.Jarsol
      @Hew.Jarsol Рік тому +2

      I know it's embarrassing!

    • @DJTheTrainmanWalker
      @DJTheTrainmanWalker 3 місяці тому

      It interests me that 'service'... got substituted for ''force'. The emphasis this places on the job they do, is completely different.

    • @noniousxltruffles7454
      @noniousxltruffles7454 2 місяці тому

      And yet the description of the basic training's pretty accurate.

    • @pseud420
      @pseud420 15 днів тому

      super army soldiers of course

  • @jezlanejl
    @jezlanejl Рік тому +29

    Lol. Literally the first sentence and this commentator is wrong, the SAS is the Special Air Service, there is no such thing as a Special air force in the UK unless you mean the RAF which are actually pretty special.

  • @Shoomer1988
    @Shoomer1988 10 місяців тому +14

    The fact that this video got the SAS's name wrong in the very first sentence should tell you all you need to know.

    • @Joe-fn9mi
      @Joe-fn9mi Місяць тому

      Doesn't reveal anything you 'need to know'. This is simply a random Americans reaction to a random UA-cam video.

  • @dogwithwigwamz.7320
    @dogwithwigwamz.7320 7 місяців тому +8

    I`ve only known one single chap that trained in the British Army and then ended up in the SAS. He was an quite extraordinary chap - in the sense of being a "weirdo."
    He`d come home to his parents house on leave from the Army and choose to sleep in the hedges and fields surrounding the town he and I grew up in.
    I remember one Bonfire Night in about 1971 : Us kids came about with fireworks whilst he ( Mick ) came out with a grappling hook - showing us how to scale the buildings around us whilst under fire.....
    He climbed cliffs as if they were rabbit hutches.
    Yep - Weirdo. `Though the last time I saw him he`d become a settled older citizen, poor Mick. I liked him.
    The SAS aren`t going to lose a Mission to anyone. They`ll get what`s coming and take what`s coming.
    That`s the way they like it !

  • @joannedelaney3866
    @joannedelaney3866 Рік тому +45

    Hi, Theres a tv show here in the UK , called Celebrity SAS Who Dares Wins, which puts mostly minor celebrities through a watered down, shorter version of some of the training that the SAS go through. Men and women are treated equally. It’s harsh ( but not as harsh as our SAS really go through) . If they don’t get kicked out by the real SAS instructors, a lot of the celebrities are injured in the process. In recent years the instructors have included ex American navy seals. You may want to google it.

    • @DrCookie6996p
      @DrCookie6996p Рік тому +2

      The ex us seals joined when they started the us version, both edited/produced from the same footage.

    • @BumblebeesEngin
      @BumblebeesEngin Рік тому +3

      i prefer the old show SAS: Are you tough enough. with former SAS soldiers doing the training

    • @gregorturner4753
      @gregorturner4753 10 місяців тому +2

      @@BumblebeesEngin they tried that here in Australia...from the press stories its not going so well.

    • @Yorci62
      @Yorci62 4 місяці тому

      Celebrity SAS Who Dares Wins is just a bit of a laugh for some celebrities, not exactly hard to do really. But I guess if you are a couch potato then it probably would be a bit of a difficult challenge. But otherwise it was just for TV for fun. You would probably find that the regular British army dependent on your unit, faced more challenging on annual battle field maneuvers/assessments.

    • @joannedelaney3866
      @joannedelaney3866 4 місяці тому +1

      @@Yorci62 Yes… hence why I said that it was a watered down, shorter version of the training. I’m extremely proud of our men and women serving in our British Forces, as we all should be 👍

  • @blackprince7510
    @blackprince7510 Рік тому +36

    There is a big difference between running 1.5 miles in full kit (uniform, boots, rifle, pack, etc) and running 1.5 miles in gym gear. In my basic training in my early 20s, I did a 1.5 miles in less than 10.5 minutes in shorts, t-shirt, and basketball court style shoes (what they issued us with) and was suffering from a mild case of pneumonia at the time.

    • @peterdawes1868
      @peterdawes1868 Рік тому +5

      1992. (Battle fitness test, Australian army). Run five kilometers in cam's with weapon. I was 32 and did the run in high summer heat. 17:05.

    • @gtd65
      @gtd65 Рік тому +2

      The slowest time I ever completed the BFT in (the return run) was 10:15. I was hauled in the troop office and roasted for not giving my all. In mitigation I explained that I was bursting for a shit and had absolutely stuffed my face with a full cooked breakfast, 2 bowls of corn flakes, 8 slices of toast and 4 cups of tea. That was finished roughly 5 minutes before the BFT as I thought we were having lectures that morning! 🤣 My usual time for a BFT was between 8:30 and 9:15 with a personal best of 7:40. These days I'm happy doing a 5k run in under 30 minutes! ☺

    • @jo.s7993
      @jo.s7993 11 місяців тому +3

      It's the basic fitness test to join the army in the first place & nothing to do with Special Forces.

  • @gregorturner4753
    @gregorturner4753 10 місяців тому +7

    One thing i like about the SAS is they respect those who help them. A good friend of my stepdad died a couple of years ago. He served in Vietnam on hueys in the 9th RAAF squadron, his role was winchman and was the guy who would be lowered into the jungle to pick up the SAS squads at the end of a patrol. For his wake they allowed the mourners access to the SAS mess at Swanbourne barracks some thing that never happens but because of what he did even though he wasn't SAS the respect he earned doing that job meant that it was the last and greatest honor they could give him for his contribution in saving SAS lives.

  • @Moorend_
    @Moorend_ 7 місяців тому +2

    15 min 1.5mile run might be slow if you are track running or running in a neighbourhood but these guys are doing it cross country, whilst wearing basic kit.

  • @jkasaunder228
    @jkasaunder228 Рік тому +21

    But you need to run 1.5miles ungeared in under 9mins to join the Paras.... Just the run. The british army doesn't mess about.

    • @johnvoncripps6158
      @johnvoncripps6158 Місяць тому

      Glad someone knows what they are on about. it's not like p company and para selection info doesn't come up on google

    • @jkasaunder228
      @jkasaunder228 Місяць тому

      ​@@johnvoncripps6158 I believe the 9min timer I gave was for young recruits looking to join before they are 18.
      If you search "Serve as a Paratrooper in the Infantry - Army Jobs" it will come up and give you all the info.

  • @annienonimus5236
    @annienonimus5236 Рік тому +21

    You should watch a video of the SAS storming the Iranian embassy.... The whole of the UK watched ..

    • @WithTwoFlakes
      @WithTwoFlakes Рік тому +3

      Yeah, I watched it live on the TV. I was hopping mad, it interrupted the snooker coverage. Sodding Iranians...

    • @scobra5941
      @scobra5941 Рік тому

      @@WithTwoFlakes Ah yes, snooker- I'd rather watch grass grow.

    • @Christine-jg2ch
      @Christine-jg2ch Рік тому

      It was incredible. I was supposed to be meeting a mate in the pub, we both turned up late😂

    • @stevenmcdonough2356
      @stevenmcdonough2356 7 місяців тому

      And if you listen to the claims of various ex-soldiers there were about 8,000 soldiers on the balcony that day. All of them went in first 😂

    • @johnberry8618
      @johnberry8618 7 місяців тому

      Crazy isnt it ? I dont remember that many being there when i went in second​@@stevenmcdonough2356

  • @meronr74
    @meronr74 Рік тому +14

    There's a BBC drama series called Rogue Heroes which is the story of the formation of the SAS in WWII. Their exploits were legendary. Worth checking out.

    • @neobliviscarisa650
      @neobliviscarisa650 11 місяців тому

      Actually rogue heroes was watered down . Real life, the hang grenade thrown on the pool table was a live one. Paddy mane ran back into a hanger after successfully blowing up the aircraft and threw a live grenade into Italians and in the middle of the barracks. something sterling never really got over

  • @thehappywerewolf
    @thehappywerewolf Рік тому +13

    There is a saying in the SAS the bad guys start it and they finish it.

  • @petebeatminister
    @petebeatminister Рік тому +20

    The guys from the Special Air Service are as tough as they come, even though they dont talk much about it. The closest comparison is probably a bunch of Ninjas.
    I once met a SAS guy, a captain, and you would have never guessed what he was. A totally nice and polite person. And yet he knows 5 different ways to kill someone with his bare hands.

    • @craigboden9455
      @craigboden9455 Рік тому +1

      i know an ex sas guy too that now runs charities for kids, i was in his house once and was looking at a sword he has on his fireplace with the sas symbol engraved on it and he told me he used to be sas and he got it when he retired from there. he never talks about to anyone and the only reason i know is because i was nosey that day.

    • @r0ky_M
      @r0ky_M Рік тому +2

      LoL, lots of fakes claiming to be SAS, so how do you know they were genuine SAS?

    • @petebeatminister
      @petebeatminister Рік тому +2

      @@r0ky_M He was in uniform, and I met him at a Div HQ - so I dont think he was a fake. :)

    • @r0ky_M
      @r0ky_M Рік тому +1

      @@petebeatminister
      Ok, that sounds real enough..😎

    • @gregorturner4753
      @gregorturner4753 10 місяців тому

      @@craigboden9455 cos many of these fakes don't know how to wear medals or uniforms etc and the real guys call them out as in Australia its illegal to imitate a serving member and can be prosecuted by the ADF. There used to be a website run by ex military who called out these guys and referred them to the relevant authorities sadly about 5 years ago they were shut down as one of the the 'heros' complained about being harassed. but you still see them in papers etc. with a chest full of medals, bizarre patches and talk of being in 'special operations' in vietnam and come up with some made up unit, claiming that they worked with the US Navy SEALS or the CIA etc. i love the american term for it as it rings true, stolen valor.

  • @bblake5116
    @bblake5116 Рік тому +21

    America has got soldiers here in Australia doing training exercises with our Aussie soldiers at the moment, during our winter. They would probably struggle in summer up here in far North Queensland. We have Australian soldiers in the SAS, the training here in Australia is horrendous.

    • @peterdawes1868
      @peterdawes1868 Рік тому +1

      Did the cater course in 1988. And you are 100% correct.

    • @WessexMan
      @WessexMan Рік тому +5

      Aussie and UK forces work together a lot. We just hate each other when it comes to Test Match Cricket (and even then we quite admire the other side, but would never say it out loud!)

    • @bblake5116
      @bblake5116 Рік тому +1

      @@WessexMan bloody cricket. 😂 I don’t like cricket and I’m a Pom born in Australia

    • @dfox4790
      @dfox4790 Рік тому +1

      The Aussies and the brits are cousins some fucking hard Aussies I’ll give you that

    • @neobliviscarisa650
      @neobliviscarisa650 11 місяців тому

      Special air service jungle training has now surpassed even New Zealand’s tracker course, according to Bellingham. SAS were doing jungle warfare in special forces units eight years before the Australians formed their SAS unit in Vietnam. Bread-and-butter in the British military

  • @timglennon6814
    @timglennon6814 Рік тому +15

    Special Air Force. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
    It’s Special Air Service.

  • @enemde3025
    @enemde3025 Рік тому +6

    SAS = Special Air Service. Part of the ARMY.
    The Navy Seal mile is NOT fully kitted.
    There is a Celebrity SAS show on British TV.

  • @Ingens_Scherz
    @Ingens_Scherz Рік тому +4

    The SAS helped to create US special forces in '62 after being invited by a legendary US Colonel (Charlie Beckwith) who actually served with the SAS for a while on secondment. I guess he was impressed ;)

  • @catherinewilkins2760
    @catherinewilkins2760 Рік тому +8

    There is the SAS and SBS (Special boat Service) . Elite forces.

  • @davidmcc8727
    @davidmcc8727 Рік тому +3

    The think about SAS training is there is no shouting or bulling from the trainers. You can drop out anytime you wish. It’s about mental strength and physical fitness

  • @CMOT101
    @CMOT101 Рік тому +25

    My friend is a Royal Marine Commando. He tells a story about Navy Seals coming over for some training British style. They thought they would 'show' the Brits and went out early to use the assault course and break a few "records"
    However they struggled really badly and praised the RMCs on how hard the course was. The RMCs pissed themselves silly and explained the course had been built for the local teenage Navy Cadets to use.
    Needless to say the Yanks couldn't get through RMC training.

    • @broflo3875
      @broflo3875 Рік тому +1

      Yea. That sounds like bullshit.

    • @CMOT101
      @CMOT101 Рік тому +1

      @@broflo3875 says the Seppo.

    • @britishpatriot7386
      @britishpatriot7386 Рік тому +1

      ​@@broflo3875it's actually true and happend a few times.

    • @broflo3875
      @broflo3875 Рік тому

      @@britishpatriot7386 Provide any sort of evidence that this took place at all other than "trust me bro".

    • @mustanggaming3018
      @mustanggaming3018 6 місяців тому +2

      Sounds about right my father was a para when he trained with Americans they could not compare to British troops they would struggle with British military training since the British military has a much higher standard when coming to training since they want quality over quantity

  • @marythomson8537
    @marythomson8537 Рік тому +4

    Try watching "Obi Wan Nairobi"2019.
    2000 - Operation Barras - Sierra Leone
    When British soldiers are held hostage, the SAS lead a daring rescue mission into the heart of the African jungle.
    2005 - Basra Rescue
    The SAS rescue 2 of their own held captive in Basra.
    Lots of other missions these are a few more recent ones that we got to know about.

  • @ThatCampingLad
    @ThatCampingLad 3 місяці тому +2

    The SAS is quite simply the best in the world. They make it so that only the best people with insane physical & mental strength make it through. What they go through during selection is just unbelievable. Not to discredit any other forces because they're all beasts but the SAS is just a different league.

  • @jamessaunders7931
    @jamessaunders7931 Місяць тому +1

    Defintely take a look at the part of the UK show SAS - Who Dares Wins. Puts 'regular' people through a semi-realistic course of SAS training. Its for entertainment, but gives a pretty good insight.

  • @alisonhill3941
    @alisonhill3941 Рік тому +5

    I'm twitching at the ostensibly British cartoon soldiers at 2:16 saluting as if they're either Americans or in the Royal Navy. The British Army and the RAF salute palms forward, not palms down.

    • @ac1646
      @ac1646 Рік тому +1

      Yes. 'Long way up; short way down.' Remember my late father (ex-RAF fighter pilot) showing us how to salute the RAF way. 😄

  • @doriantallbody1045
    @doriantallbody1045 4 місяці тому +10

    1:18 - NEVER LISTEN TO AN AMERICAN EXPLAIN BRITISH-RELATED STUFF, THEY ALWAYS GET IT WRONG. Immediately the narrator says the name incorrectly, which the reactor calls out quite rightly. It's only three words, for goodness sake. During WWII, the SBS (Special Boat Services) was created to perform 'special' military operations. Soon after, the SBS became the SAS (Special Air Service). They first came to public attention during the Iranian Embassy Siege, in London, on May 5, 1980.

  • @TheDoctorFlay
    @TheDoctorFlay Рік тому +6

    You make a good observation, but they picked the "Special Air Service" because they have heard of it.
    A more accurate comparison would have been with the SBS (Special Boat Service), who are the elite few selected from the Royal Marines of the Navy.
    This is why I don't rate those vids as the narrator doesn't know what thy are talking about.

    • @Thurgosh_OG
      @Thurgosh_OG Рік тому

      Actually, troops from both the SAS and SBS can come from any branch of UK military.
      You are right about 'That infographics show' channel; their research is pretty dire.

    • @TheDoctorFlay
      @TheDoctorFlay Рік тому

      @@Thurgosh_OG True they have free hand to recruit from anywhere, but my point is about the comparison in training to the US Navy Seals, as the SBS specialise in waterborne activities.

  • @WessexMan
    @WessexMan Рік тому +2

    The Infographics Show can often be wildly innacurate. Check out the Gritty Soldier doing the "Fan Dance" around the Brecon Beacons. Great video of an older chap, ex US Ranger, doing one of the challenges Brit SF forces go through. You may be in pain doing it, but the views are awesome!

  • @sorokahdeen
    @sorokahdeen Рік тому +5

    Like Dasyrid said, below, only I can add that there is a neat little history of the unit's WWII origins in Ben Macintyre's book, "SAS: Rogue Heroes."
    Good luck with your videos.

  • @raisinette35
    @raisinette35 Рік тому +3

    🤣Walk to the nearest bus stop, get on the bus, ride to somewhere where you can buy a 12 pack of beer in bottles, then return home via the same route to prepare! LMAO

  • @davidgilbert9917
    @davidgilbert9917 Рік тому +21

    When based in Hong Kong we had a master sergeant from the USA based in Korea to teach our troops which where being deployed for ceremonial duties for honour Guard in Korea as part of induction he had participate in our physical fitness training he turned up for a Combat fitness test in trainers as he said thats normal in the USA army as for our British troops we do all our combat fitness test in boots apart from gymnasium test i say no more

    • @broflo3875
      @broflo3875 Рік тому

      Former Marine here. We do our PT tests in the armed forces in "trainers", but we also train very often in boots in utilities. Long runs, ruck marches, etc. We had a group of Rpyal Marines show up to CAX at 29 Palms in July of one year and we were laughing at them falling out of the exercise due to their inability to withstand the heat.

    • @rimskykorsakov2892
      @rimskykorsakov2892 Рік тому

      @@broflo3875 Yeah I smell BS

    • @Yandarval
      @Yandarval Рік тому

      @@broflo3875 I doubt your Marines would do to well when The Royal Marines go and exercise in the middle of the Norwegian winter. Horses for courses.

    • @broflo3875
      @broflo3875 Рік тому

      @@Yandarval We do our winter warfare training in Alaska. Also many of our Marines and soldiers come from places in the US that get far colder than any place in the UK so I don't think your assessment on what US Marines can/can't do is entirely too accurate.

    • @neobliviscarisa650
      @neobliviscarisa650 11 місяців тому

      @@broflo3875 however, climate in Wales and Scotland is far more difficult than Alaska.. Poor visibility, wet as well as cold and very muddy to operate..Dry cold and with the right kit and expertise, more bearable

  • @anethers7545
    @anethers7545 10 місяців тому +1

    The US was offered the SAS to ‘resolve the Iran Embassy’ issue in 79, the US said their guys were good enough - look what happened

  • @robertsmith4681
    @robertsmith4681 Рік тому +15

    SEALs were basically created as a carbon copy of the British SBS, the 'naval" component of the SAS. the Army's Green Beret special forces are modeled after the SAS.

    • @Thurgosh_OG
      @Thurgosh_OG Рік тому +1

      Not a carbon copy, just a copy. The SBS is the most elite British unit, topping even the SAS.

    • @biker3762
      @biker3762 Рік тому

      david goggins is more discpplined and mentallly then any sas soldier

    • @jo.s7993
      @jo.s7993 Рік тому +2

      SBS are Tier 1 SEALS are Tier 2. There is absolutely no comparison between them.

    • @WhySoSerious551
      @WhySoSerious551 Рік тому +2

      SBS/SAS Training is much the same. Except the SAS do not do underwater demolition

    • @neobliviscarisa650
      @neobliviscarisa650 11 місяців тому

      @@jo.s7993 I think the person is referring to Devgru Tier 1 SEALS

  • @anglosaxon5874
    @anglosaxon5874 Рік тому +8

    We have a SBS too [Special Boat Service] - a part of the Royal Navy.
    The SAS [Special Air Service] is mainly from the British Army [not Air Force].

    • @Mark-Haddow
      @Mark-Haddow Рік тому +2

      The SBS were army originally. They're not navy, but rather a special unit for marine/water operations. The Royal Marines and Marine Commandos are navy.

    • @anglosaxon5874
      @anglosaxon5874 Рік тому +2

      @@Mark-Haddow The SBS is Navy. I used to be in the RN

    • @Mark-Haddow
      @Mark-Haddow Рік тому +1

      @@anglosaxon5874
      OK dokey, no, it isn't. It's an independent unit of the British military, and its origin is the British army, via the Royal Scots Guards, who also created the SAS. The Royal Marine Commandos are the navy special forces.

    • @anglosaxon5874
      @anglosaxon5874 Рік тому

      @@Mark-Haddow Yes it is! Look it up!!!!

    • @Mark-Haddow
      @Mark-Haddow Рік тому +2

      @@anglosaxon5874
      Why would I look up what I already know.
      The SBS was an offshoot of the SAS. The Scots Guards founded both. One to attack inland targets like airfields, and the other shoreline targets, like radar installations. This is a fact, not opinion. You can volunteer for SBS training from any branch of the service, likewise the SAS.

  • @denisesf5
    @denisesf5 Рік тому +18

    Ummmm... you mixed up the drunk driving part hon. The guy got drunk and died crashing his car. Nobody hit him. The training drove him to drinking.
    Oh... and most mothers would pass either British or American test easily: being sleep deprived for YEARS on end, carrying heavy kids/equipment/groceries/laundry for YEARS on end whilst living on table scraps wolfed down quickly before navigating complicated, poorly given directions to countless soccer/football/hockey/competition events while suffering ear-splitting music/sibling- rivalry noise.... makes us more than capable to excel in these macho tests of will and strength. But we're just too smart to try. I mean seriously...who wants to live on military food and have to wear those crappy colored uniforms after all that effort?😁

  • @Jee123123
    @Jee123123 Рік тому +4

    Bad comparison, would have been better if it was Delta Force, DEVGRU (SEAL Team 6), 24th Special Tactics Squadron or the Army Ranger Regimental Recon Company.
    possibly compared the US Navy SEALs (not DEVGRU) vs Royal Marine Commandos.

  • @lem01uk
    @lem01uk Рік тому +5

    Check out the SAS ending the Iranian Embassy siege.

  • @cybertrophic
    @cybertrophic Рік тому +2

    the SEALs run is not kitted. The SAS run is carrying 40lb backpack, plus weapon and other kit

    • @neobliviscarisa650
      @neobliviscarisa650 11 місяців тому +1

      SBS them then carry a very heavy Klepper over 10 miles and a 25 mile kayak in the North Sea.. not to mention Clothing at all rigs with 13 stone of kit in the middle of the night in the rough cold water!
      yes SBS do more or less the same as the SAS, plus the water-based, a harsher environment

  • @idontsignin
    @idontsignin Рік тому +3

    There was a tv show in the uk called SAS who dares wins. Watch that and you'll see. It wasn't the entire SAS programme, but the people went through hell.
    No wonder there's only a select few that actually make it.

  • @andys7314
    @andys7314 Рік тому +3

    To date there isn’t a single female that has passed UKSF selection in regards to SAS/SBS
    Further more the BFT hasn’t been a part of UKSF selection since the early 2000’s so this video is already well outdated

  • @BumblebeesEngin
    @BumblebeesEngin Рік тому +1

    if you're interested in the SAS training, there was a cool show about it. called "SAS: Are you tough enough" with some rather famous SAS members (and one who will most likely be recognized by his looks)

    • @jo.s7993
      @jo.s7993 11 місяців тому

      I remember that, with Eddie & Mac!

  • @mickeyboyk
    @mickeyboyk Рік тому +2

    I don’t know if you can read, but you could look up Special Air Service.

  • @olalundqvist3080
    @olalundqvist3080 Рік тому +3

    If you want to see sort of a "stripped down" version of what the SAS soldiers go through in training, you should go watch the show "Who dares wins" (it's here on UA-cam). 👍🙂

  • @AlteredBuzzard
    @AlteredBuzzard 2 місяці тому

    Special Air Service tend to be from Army and RAF. The Navy and Royal Marines (Who are their own special operations unit), have the SBS, Special Boat Service.
    No, they're not an A and B grade services, they go though the same courses and have to meet the same requirement. It means their main form of deployment, SAS by Air, SBS by Boat.

  • @DeDaanste
    @DeDaanste Рік тому +3

    Have lived in Senegal and worked at a off grid campsite/bar/restaurant/motel. Every other mo the or so the frebch foreign legion would come by which was always amazing. One day I was told that the next month h they would come with Americans that came over to do some training with them. They would stay 3 week. There where American legionnaires also, you could always picked them out even before they had said a word in French. A month later they called, saying that the Americans wouldn't come with them. I asked why and the guy laughed, saying it was too hard on them and they had keft after a week. Turned out they weren't as fit and well trained as they thought. Oh, and a group of C.I.A. Would come now and then. That was a shocker... Never seen so many complete morons. Loud, obnoxious, rude etc. We started to help them more reluctant and slow. Finally they gave up, complain to the wrong people and never came back..

  • @BudBurner420
    @BudBurner420 8 місяців тому +1

    No mate, the british equivalent of the U.S navy would be......... ready for it?....... the Royal Navy!!!

  • @TheMancalorian
    @TheMancalorian 16 днів тому

    I remember back in the 90's training at altcar, I went on a hike with a squad and was the only one with my Berghaus Bag full of house bricks. All I had was my water bottle, mesh tins, my knife and rifle. I loved training back then from all areas but by then end of it, cleaning my rifle was satisfying.

  • @6mojo
    @6mojo 10 місяців тому

    Recruits have died during long marches across Dartmoor in England…it’s the fog that suddenly appears so getting lost & being a victim of exposure is easy..I COMPLETED the Commando Course when I completed my Royal Marines Boot Camp training back in 1964..did my 9 years voluntary service ,mostly with 42 Commando after which I joined the UK Police…after a few years I emigrated to be a cop in Canada…great times…the secret is to make training FUN!
    Train HARD so we can FIGHT easy!

  • @pseud420
    @pseud420 15 днів тому

    A huge amount of soldiers who make it to the rainforest phase of SAS Selection end up out due to injuries caused by falling deadwood or other rainforest dangers. Those places are hellish and out to kill you.
    There have been many deaths in SAS selection and many more in active service, but they are quite literally as elite as it gets. The majority of special forces around the world have learned from each other, but the Brits pioneered most of what SF do today.
    If you wanna learn about some really special people, look into John Mcaleese (Mac) and his team who responded to the Iranian Embassy Siege. They based Captain Price in Call of Duty on Mac. He's a true badass. We unfortunately lost Mac in 2011, but his legacy will never die.

  • @stephendukes6582
    @stephendukes6582 4 місяці тому

    It's the Special Air Service and in 1941 they were called the LRDG Long Range Desert Group. The navy equivalent is the SBS Special Boat Service.

  • @Garland042
    @Garland042 Рік тому +1

    The fully geared part is very important...i did at 15years old 3km in terrain in about 11-12 minutes...but when in my full combat gear during my military training it easy put another 4-5 min on the same length.

  • @jonsmith1809
    @jonsmith1809 7 місяців тому

    Fun fact: if you fail selection for the SBS you can apply for the SAS but if you fail selection for the SAS the SBS wont accept your application.
    Also the screening process, 1.5 Mile's in 11 minutes etc... Will come after about 2 hrs sleep and spending most of the day doing hard work.

  • @terryarkle7477
    @terryarkle7477 Рік тому +10

    special air service

  • @carlb401
    @carlb401 2 місяці тому

    He forgot to mention that with SAS selection they generally have around 200 candidates at a time, of which usually only 2 or 3 actually pass, plus there have been selection courses where no one has passed the course. Unlike in the general army Regimental training/ US forces training the staff in the SAS do not shout at/ encourage you etc they are there just watching you, you have to motivate yourself.

  • @OriginalOwner777
    @OriginalOwner777 Рік тому +1

    They got it wrong about the first woman ever to join the SAS she was badged and it was in the early 1990's. However not long after being badged she quit after a tour in ireland.

    • @jo.s7993
      @jo.s7993 Рік тому

      No women have ever been "badged", somebody's pulling a fast one on you.

  • @rivernova4464
    @rivernova4464 5 місяців тому

    Special Air Service (SAS), elite British military force organized and trained for special operations, surveillance, and counterterrorism, also sas has the thouthes training.

  • @ITzDaveXD
    @ITzDaveXD Рік тому +2

    it's not a 10 minute mile since they run a mile and a half a 10 minute mile would get you disqualified

  • @Scr4ndalf
    @Scr4ndalf Рік тому +4

    Im pretty sure i remember being told the original training for the SAS back in ww2 included being thrown out of a moving car in the desert for something to do with parachute training 😂

    • @LG-cz6ls
      @LG-cz6ls Рік тому +1

      Off the back of a Landy to learn how to fall, IIRC

    • @gregorturner4753
      @gregorturner4753 10 місяців тому

      @@LG-cz6ls long range desert group and yeah they took a bunch of jeeps or landrovers and would drive them into the desert full of fuel, water ammunition and explosives and scout out the enemy and destroy things like stores to harass the enemy

    • @anethers7545
      @anethers7545 10 місяців тому

      They were also buried on the Brecon Beacons for a couple of days - just to see how they’d handle it, I remember my dad joking about it, saying he just had a nap.

  • @Yorci62
    @Yorci62 4 місяці тому

    The regular British army had a Basic Fitness Test every 6 months, or at least they use to - wearing boots and tee shirt we ran 1.5 miles as a squad in 15 minutes for a warm up, then 1.5 miles as a best effort but must be under 11.5 minutes, it was like a mad race.
    Then in the 90's this was changed and we could run it in trainers, but the time of the second half was dropped to 10.5 minutes. I guess too many namby-pamby's joined the army and the boots hurt their delicate feet!
    We also had a Combat Fitness Test once a year with was just 8 miles in two hours over uneven ground carrying 35 pounds plus your 9 pound rifle, then at the end you had to carry a buddy 10 meters with their kit, I can't remember what the time for that was, sometimes it was done wearing a respirator (gas mask) depending on which unit you was with. Then a simple exercise afterwards like lifting some sand bags in to the back of a lorry.

  • @lemsdarkapprentice2535
    @lemsdarkapprentice2535 10 місяців тому

    SEAL's running 1.5km in 11 minutes are without any kit, so it isn't faster at all. Plus, kit (especially boots etc) isn't exactly designed for sprinting or running those kinds of distances. If you want another comparison: most US Marines or Rangers cannot complete standard UK army assault courses, cos it's too hard for them.

  • @bremnersghost948
    @bremnersghost948 2 місяці тому

    around @7:10, Not just a 25kg Pack, Water, Weapons, Rations and everything else in Webbing & Beltkit too, Most of the time a British Squaddie never mind SF are carrying close to their own Body weight in Kit if not more.

  • @jensenrowley2398
    @jensenrowley2398 Рік тому +1

    SAS special air services and well SAS is ranked first in the world of spec ops i believe but honestly every country has a specialist in one way

  • @davidbettney785
    @davidbettney785 6 місяців тому +1

    Special Air Service "SAS" (are SOLDIERS from the ARMY) the air bit just denotes that they first formed as a parachute regiment, with behind the lines capabilities. Today, they insert by land, sea and air (but they are all BRITISH ARMY...Not Royal Navy, and Not Airforce)

  • @robertofraser101
    @robertofraser101 Рік тому +2

    Navy seal Ryan I right you sure Ryan? really 😊 yea tough guys eh hope it brings success too them both have a good weekend mr Ryan cheers 🍻 as allways enjoyed and like the light hearted attitude cheers

  • @sethtiffany984
    @sethtiffany984 Рік тому

    As a former us soldier, being fully kitted during a run/march is different from special forces. An average military service member may have a certain standard, but af standards are so much higher.

  • @Living_the_Scottish_Dream
    @Living_the_Scottish_Dream Рік тому +2

    A shotgun is very useful for destroying up close threats and restrictions. Flesh or structure will be blown away if needed!

  • @philipsmith4849
    @philipsmith4849 3 місяці тому

    SBS is more akin to navy seal sea team. SBS stands for special boat service. SAS is special air service. They are both the elite. SAS recruits mainly from the paras and SBS recruits mainly from the royal Marines. Hope this gives you some insights into what's what.

  • @robertfyfe3848
    @robertfyfe3848 8 місяців тому +1

    Get facts right The Regiment is the best in the world fact you have to serve 4 years first in any regiment

  • @ianjardine7324
    @ianjardine7324 Рік тому +1

    Americans have a long and storied history of using shotguns. The Germans protested their use and tried to label it as a war crime. But for trench warfare or combat in enclosed environments a short range directional area affect weapon is pretty handy. No need to stick your head around a corner and get it blown off just point the old war crime stick around an make everybody round there take cover or have a bad day.

    • @gratmatassa5432
      @gratmatassa5432 Рік тому

      good for shooting door hinges off as well

    • @bigmacntings7451
      @bigmacntings7451 Рік тому

      that's why the SAS have carbines!.
      pistols not enough grunt. shotguns too slow to move under pressure.
      pistols still used as a sidearm not primary weapon.

  • @nickphipp1949
    @nickphipp1949 Рік тому +5

    A family friend was in the SAS and served in both the Gulf War and Iraqi War. He recounted to me how they arrived in the middle of nowhere wearing olive drab uniforms, which made them stand out in the sandy desert 'like rose bushes'. To remedy this, one night they 'borrowed' more suitable uniforms from a nearby US equipment and logistics depot, along with enough equipment to start WW3.
    He was shot in both wars. The second time, he was transported more than 200 miles overland, across the desert, in a stolen pickup truck by his comrades, dodging Iraqi positions and ultimately leaving Iraq for Jordan. He was immediately operated on and airlifted back to the UK, where he spent just 2 weeks recovering before returning to his base - on crutches.

    • @LG-cz6ls
      @LG-cz6ls Рік тому

      Your friend needs to read better fiction.

  • @judsdragon
    @judsdragon 2 місяці тому

    some of that information was incorrect at the start, the SBS or Special Boat Service came first in 1940 a year previous to the SAS, there has never been a female SAS or SBS recruit that passed the first stage

  • @aanunkitch2426
    @aanunkitch2426 2 місяці тому

    I've heard it from many SAS hopefulls. They would rather be in Norway in the cold or Belize in the hot and dry but nothing is worse than running up a mountain in Wales. Lol. RESPECT !!!

  • @bremnersghost948
    @bremnersghost948 2 місяці тому

    Main difference between British and US SF is that most British SF have already served 3+ years in the "Regular Army or Marines" and are NCO's before they even go for SF Selection.

  • @jamesford7182
    @jamesford7182 7 днів тому

    Shotguns are effective on hinges and door locks. Not at all uncommon for breaching.

  • @TheFriendlyIntrovert
    @TheFriendlyIntrovert 5 місяців тому

    Ok, so there's a basic difference between the SAS and the SEALs. Well, there are many, but I'm going to highlight one in particular. Military groups are broken down into 3 Tiers for ease of reference. Tier 3, is your basic infantry. Then Tier 2 is Green Berets, Navy Seals, and Rangers on the US side, with the Royal Marines and Parachute Regiment for the Brits. Then you have Tier 1 units, which is Delta Force and Seal Team 6/DEVGRU as well as a few others for the US, while the Brits have the SAS, SBS, and SRR. So, the SAS is Tier 1, while the Seals are Tier 2, except for Seal Team 6, which regular Seals can apply to try out for. That means that the training is different, the mission sets are different, and the capabilities are different.

    • @GazT-i8b
      @GazT-i8b 4 місяці тому

      What about uk ranger regs ?

  • @Richard-s6q2s
    @Richard-s6q2s 11 місяців тому

    Its Bollocks mate, our normal army runs a mile and a half in 10:30 or under, our airborne is mile and a half in 9:30. SAS doesnt need to run in 15 mins, it would be under 10:30 as a basic entry to the course.

  • @rubenbooth5927
    @rubenbooth5927 4 місяці тому

    SAS stands for Special Air Service it's apart of the British Army, and they are tier one special forces.

  • @andrewmcewan8081
    @andrewmcewan8081 Місяць тому

    sas ,special air service, equivalent to delta force in the usa . delta developed their training from the sas system.

  • @kallumleader9110
    @kallumleader9110 Рік тому +3

    Trench warfare for shotguns, right? be a b*stard to carry all that stuff though 😅

  • @Beefadin
    @Beefadin 10 місяців тому

    The Special Air Service (SAS) and Special.Boat Service (SBS) are seen as equals as they do.thw same training. The only difference is SBS include maritime warfare and SAS doesn't. If a mission is mainly at sea then the SBS goes in and vice versa

  • @Jrichards30
    @Jrichards30 Місяць тому

    Nobody ever asks the SBS to advise them. But they work with others as they aren’t independent, experienced or reliable enough

  • @DreadEnder
    @DreadEnder Рік тому

    The SAS fitness test isn’t 50 lbs, it’s an extra half your body weight or twice your body weight

  • @silverbackakasherby2033
    @silverbackakasherby2033 Рік тому +1

    No, the Tier 1 Soldiers work together very closely and respect each other. They always have each other's backs and pool as joint Ops on many occasions.

  • @francessweeney2308
    @francessweeney2308 8 місяців тому

    Special Air Service.SAS. Women worked in Northern Ireland as covert operatives gathering intelligence on known IRA players This was as part of 14 sqn(detached) SAS.

  • @ShepherdMills-ec1rs
    @ShepherdMills-ec1rs 2 місяці тому

    Lindy beige a historian on youtube does the best account of how the sas was formed, including Winston Churchills son going on a mission and some stories that are just jaw dropping. I've listened to it about three times it's that good

  • @RedEyedJedi
    @RedEyedJedi 5 місяців тому

    1.5 miles in 11 minutes was not fully kitted. 1 mile in 15 minutes was fully kitted and the amount of weight they have to carry is insane.

  • @thefishdog
    @thefishdog 3 місяці тому

    I was a British soldier and with airborne para Royal engineer support and worked a lot wit the royal marines, We had training swaps with USA forces. Different level of fitness and agression heart, USA have all the gear and no idea, Not very good in the dirt and a bit lazy carrying equipment on foot for miles

  • @helenroberts1107
    @helenroberts1107 Рік тому +1

    Again America and guns. Yes the soldiers are highly trained and hopefully stable. The weapons should be kept at a base where they are guarded.

  • @damonkfist
    @damonkfist Рік тому

    The SAS is more comparable to SFOD-D (Special Forces Operational Detachment Delta aka Delta Force/CAG/The Unit) in the US as they are based on the SAS. Both Tier 1 units specialising in hostage rescue and counter terrorism. SBS is more closely related to DEVGRU (Seal Team 6) as they are a tier 1 unit specialising in water bourne operations.

  • @mariuscheek
    @mariuscheek 9 місяців тому

    This is why at any given time, there are ~200-250 members of the SAS, vs ~2K Delta Force, and ~2.5k SEALs.

  • @BeyondGodLike89
    @BeyondGodLike89 Рік тому

    As we heard, most people fail at the running in the beginning, just go out running and don't stop until you fall to the ground, because your legs can't do it anymore - it'd be the same thing...

  • @RCXDZz
    @RCXDZz Рік тому +1

    The SAS are one of the last prides of Britain, they are the most professional fighting force on the planet

  • @allanfreeman4267
    @allanfreeman4267 Рік тому

    from what i know the term sas (special air service ) was devised during the second world war to confuse the enemy as it did you ..into thinking they were royal air force not army the germans had very good radio spies

  • @JasonJones-e2v
    @JasonJones-e2v Місяць тому

    Every time I jumped forward to a different spot I landed on him talking

  • @GlenDiG1970
    @GlenDiG1970 Місяць тому

    British SAS are formidable but not much is known about its sister squadron in Rhodesia ( Rhodesian Bush War) and then another SF unit which were World renowned were the Selous Scouts. Formed by a former SAS soldier. Worth reading up on.