Field testing: Who has the most productive spray drone? || Hylio vs. DJI vs. XAG

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 30

  • @GordonMcCreadie-zh4bi
    @GordonMcCreadie-zh4bi 11 місяців тому +7

    This is amazing. By far the most comprehensive test of spray drone capability I’ve seen carried out. I heard about this test and think it’s pretty gutsy to bring in your competitors and experienced pilots to put forth their best work. It shows that Hylio has confidence in a great product. I’m looking forward to see what’s coming from them!

    • @Hylio
      @Hylio  11 місяців тому

      Thank you for the kind words, Gordon! We will keep trying to learn more and improve our products.

  • @neilflanagan202
    @neilflanagan202 11 місяців тому +7

    Great job Hylio. I'm a customer of Hylio and couldn't be happier. Can't wait to put our 272 to work. The Hylio family is the best. Thanks, Neil

    • @Hylio
      @Hylio  10 місяців тому

      Glad to hear it, thanks!

  • @joea.o2438
    @joea.o2438 5 місяців тому +3

    I'm only new to drones as a hobby. Great video and results! So, I hope you don't join Skydio and other companies in lobbying the US government to make a law banning DJI drones.

  • @tunintunin3417
    @tunintunin3417 8 місяців тому

    Did anyone do any testing in vineyards, orchards spraying?

  • @SHADY-ut5tw
    @SHADY-ut5tw 10 місяців тому

    Great Work 🫡, Good Job 👍, Awesome 👏

  • @loganl.andrew4459
    @loganl.andrew4459 11 місяців тому +18

    Bad results. DJI's flight speed at 2 GPA is almost double what they were tested at. Neither DJI nor XAG had product experts on hand so they weren't represented accurately, yet this video and PDF are presented as scientific and authoritative. C'mon! Y'all need to upload a rematch. All ag drones are similar in capability at this point. If Hylio wants to stand out to customers and investors y'all should prioritize credibility.

    • @Hylio
      @Hylio  11 місяців тому +2

      We appreciate the input. Hylio did not operate the DJI drones in this study; operators from Rantizo with a lot of experience on the T30 and T40 platforms were running them. As far as we understand, the DJI software chose that flying speed for this field based on the 2GPA target. Please share if you have had different experiences.

    • @loganl.andrew4459
      @loganl.andrew4459 11 місяців тому +5

      The Rantizo Rep admits they aren't familiar with the processes on the T40 (10:39). They are not DJI experts, which taints the results. Hylio makes competent drones. There's no need to fib with the fine print.

    • @Hylio
      @Hylio  11 місяців тому +3

      While the Rantizo pilots are not direct DJI employees or product engineers, they are very skilled and have used the T30 and T40 platforms extensively for commercial applications. Based on what we saw in the field, it did not seem like there was much they could do about the DJI flight software locking them into those settings for that target dosage on that area in this test. The experience showed us that while there are positives to the DJI software, it can also be somewhat confusing and unintuitive, even for very skilled operators. @@loganl.andrew4459

    • @LandViewDrones
      @LandViewDrones 10 місяців тому +5

      @@HylioI was impressed with the AG-272 at the field day at the conference last week, but that was not an apples-to-apples comparison. At 2 gpa and 11-12’ altitude, the T40 should be flying at 20 mph with an effective swath of 28’ or more. Always happy to see development amongst all companies, but clearly the operator was not familiar with that aircraft.

    • @hehe-mq2bk
      @hehe-mq2bk 9 місяців тому

      agreed

  • @divingfalconfpv4602
    @divingfalconfpv4602 10 місяців тому +3

    This is why i don't get dji fanboys that composing about ban saying there are no American drones ant where near close to dji. Cause they don't even know commercial drones or even searvh anything but dji. They didn't even know mainstream drone companies i named.

    • @infoxic
      @infoxic 9 місяців тому +7

      Completely wrong.

    • @hehe-mq2bk
      @hehe-mq2bk 9 місяців тому +7

      I am a DJI fanboy because they simply make great (and in most cases, superior) products. Their American counterparts tend to be pricier and less developed

    • @ZinnNasty
      @ZinnNasty 7 місяців тому

      ​@hehe-mq2bk in the spray drone industry this isn't true. The Hylio can out spray DJI and while they might be a bit more price wise they are upgradeable with the new technology and the value stays with the drone. Where the DJI drones get phased out and worthless in a couple years. Also the Chinese gov subsides this market and that's why they are cheaper, not necessarily the best or the best value.

    • @EduruChan
      @EduruChan 7 місяців тому +6

      @@ZinnNasty nope..nobody subsidize this industry and hylio are just using the old tech from dji and xag…

    • @ZinnNasty
      @ZinnNasty 7 місяців тому

      @@EduruChan Lol, says the person that's never been around a Hylio drone and paid by DJI to spread misinformation.

  • @ziprline
    @ziprline 7 місяців тому +1

    I love that the Cattle were calm around them. I think Cattle herd spraying can be another application.

  • @infoxic
    @infoxic 9 місяців тому +5

    XAG is garbage. We had one and it was worst POS we ever had. We decided to buy another drone but this time we bought a DJI T40 and it was a night and day difference. The XAG is collecting dust.

    • @bradmclelland9715
      @bradmclelland9715 9 місяців тому

      P100 or P100pro? I heard the same thing but with people switching from DJI to XAG. I’m just trying to research and decide which drone I want. What chemicals are you applying and could you just give me any advice? Thank you!

    • @loganl.andrew4459
      @loganl.andrew4459 9 місяців тому +3

      @brad I don't know anything about XAG except they look much less advanced than Hylio. If you have flat or undulating terrain, Hylio is the king of speed. They'll go 30+ mph. Hylios are now legal to swarm, which we've done, and a few on a field will haul massive ass. Incredibly productive on non-technical terrain. If you have terraces or technical obstacles nobody matches DJI's safety systems, and nobody comes close to DJI's manual control. The software on the T50 is the best yet and with the extra sprayers it can do 5 gpa at 22 mph. The most productive on challenging terrain.

    • @Alex-wo9mz
      @Alex-wo9mz 8 місяців тому

      DJI is Garbage. Our DJI became a celing Fan

    • @ziprline
      @ziprline 7 місяців тому +7

      @@Alex-wo9mz That's an ignorant and ridiculous comment.

    • @Alex-wo9mz
      @Alex-wo9mz 7 місяців тому

      @@ziprline Not if im telling the truth, i know quiet a few people's DJI became a Ceiling Fan