Offshore and off limits: Australia's refugee centres - The Listening Post (Feature)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 93

  • @ftg1992
    @ftg1992 8 років тому +21

    And Australian journalist criticised other neighbouring countries like Malaysia and Indonesia on treatment for refugees. How ironic. So busy to bother other countries and forget to mind their own flaws and mistreatment of refugees. Totally a shame!!

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 5 років тому

      Mehmed Faiq Hassin the mistreatment is a myth. Refugees self harm start riots and fights within detention centres.

    • @kim-rz8rk
      @kim-rz8rk 4 роки тому

      @@MelaniaRose it really isn't a myth

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 4 роки тому +1

      k bye really ? Free wifi, food, shelter and medical attention ? All provided by the Australian taxpayers! Where are these people own government?

  • @Thefaithcamille
    @Thefaithcamille 8 років тому +19

    why isnt UAE helping... omg. they are one of the richest country in the.world.

    • @baburaj6266
      @baburaj6266 5 років тому

      uae heat area and not easy jobs

  • @joxp6971
    @joxp6971 4 роки тому +6

    If people come by boat without a visa is illegal for anybody and even Aussies will not get in without a passport.

    • @joxp6971
      @joxp6971 4 роки тому

      However we do need to help people in need.

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 4 роки тому

      JoxP69 Their countries embassies can assist them.

    • @joxp6971
      @joxp6971 4 роки тому

      No they can't the Aussie government decides who comes to Australia not foreign embassies

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 4 роки тому

      JoxP69 Well obviously the Australian government isn’t taking them in. Their countries are responsible for their own citizens and liaise with the Australian government.

  • @Itag0d
    @Itag0d 8 років тому +49

    Great work Australia a system that works

    • @moniho6907
      @moniho6907 3 роки тому

      Australia will fall some day

    • @Itag0d
      @Itag0d 3 роки тому

      @@moniho6907 all countries will fall one day

  • @VBEd666
    @VBEd666 8 років тому +38

    Australia's hard line policy has reduced to a trickle the flow of refugees . Europe should take notes.

    • @hecticgerva1192
      @hecticgerva1192 8 років тому +3

      i agree, why dont they just go to Europe or other countries instead of our Country.

    • @socialistsolidarity
      @socialistsolidarity 7 років тому +2

      lol Aboriginal people thought the same and look what happen.

    • @tinsaemelese4113
      @tinsaemelese4113 6 років тому

      Gerva Rod u beach

    • @hismajestyericcartmanthese5755
      @hismajestyericcartmanthese5755 5 років тому +3

      Tell that to the dumb Australian Greens

    • @AmirKhan-cy8rr
      @AmirKhan-cy8rr 5 років тому

      Oh Good. But for how long those hard liners would enjoy in this world.....!!!!???
      Life expectancy is 100 but in other words it keeps no calender ...
      So Death is ahead and they will die like stray dogs!!!!!!

  • @abechill4859
    @abechill4859 8 років тому +15

    It looks a lot better of how Bahrain treat foreign workers

  • @richiesworld1
    @richiesworld1 4 роки тому +6

    Some people really lack humanity. Just look at the comments below.

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 3 роки тому

      These refugees receive free resources from host countries, humanitarian aid, lawyers, charities, religious groups and supporters.

  • @hhansen3120
    @hhansen3120 7 років тому +7

    Every country has rules and regulations that must be obeyed, war apart, Iv'e seen people from Iran [eg] along with other nationals, who was offered asylum in Cambodia supported by UNHCR do you know what they did? they boarded a plane back to Iran etc, they weren't seeking safety, they wanted to go to a rich country

  • @patc7573
    @patc7573 8 років тому +9

    Europe needs to do this now!!

  • @bodhisattva99
    @bodhisattva99 6 років тому +6

    Why don't they appeal to India for asylum? It is an emerging economy.

    • @gauravbalouria9913
      @gauravbalouria9913 6 років тому +1

      We too don't want any illegal immigrant. We have an immigration policy follow it and anyone is welcome. Inddians always follow other countries law when it comes to immiggration and we expect the same.

    • @jacobmark4496
      @jacobmark4496 5 років тому

      @@gauravbalouria9913 shut up when countries are talking Indians don't talk your stinking country without no toilet.

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 5 років тому

      They want Australia dollars

  • @jameswinnaing7714
    @jameswinnaing7714 7 років тому +4

    every human have their country and Embassy talk to their country.

  • @gubroojatt
    @gubroojatt 8 років тому +9

    Qatar is the richest country by far with a tiny population. They can take these refugees if they are so worried about them. We dont want them here, we already have a Muslim problem because of the thankless Lebanese, Iranian and Afghan, Somali refugees that Australia took in earlier decades.

  • @bonkbonk02368
    @bonkbonk02368 5 місяців тому

    Watching this for Australian yr 12 english class. I'm glad my teacher is getting us to learn abt this, especially considering how diverse Australia is

  • @genutomas1216
    @genutomas1216 5 років тому +6

    Why they can Sent them to any arab rich countries?

  • @SuperBjanka
    @SuperBjanka 4 роки тому +1

    Hope there is being doing a lot for health issues, such as H1N1, Covid19, or measles. Which is a boiling kettle for spread and rise in deaths. shouldn't there be done something to prevent further contamination? because this will certainly increase the panic throughout media, which is the worst fear making institutions. I do appreciate the value of knowing. but there is a fine moral line which has been crossed to make more money and panic to make people look the other way form real issues around the world.

  • @jeannebrandon318
    @jeannebrandon318 Рік тому

    Send them back!!!!

  •  7 років тому

    Democratic elections are a 1 man 1 vote system. Let in too many refugees/illegals and you risk being outvoted. Remember... they will reproduce too. Also... if terrorists and criminals are hidden among refugees, they could gradually increase in numbers and vote their agents into your government. This causes social problems which in turn ruins your economy too.

  • @Finn-no8kh
    @Finn-no8kh 6 років тому +2

    Jeez, this comment section is filled with way too many uneducated people on this subject.
    EDIT: I’m Australian

  • @samueljetkins3896
    @samueljetkins3896 6 років тому +5

    Send them to Qatar

  • @jhlords2
    @jhlords2 4 роки тому +1

    This is why things are expensive in Australia

    • @wommy1732
      @wommy1732 3 роки тому +1

      coke is sooooo expensive, i read 1g 200$ or more

    • @jhlords2
      @jhlords2 3 роки тому

      @@wommy1732 bruh

  • @johnraymund2655
    @johnraymund2655 4 роки тому +1

    Send them to china

  • @stopbbs6973
    @stopbbs6973 5 років тому +1

    Human all of us same

  • @dylanw815
    @dylanw815 8 років тому

    Ofcourse there are combatants in the crowds!

  • @mohammedshahjahankhandakar8638
    @mohammedshahjahankhandakar8638 3 роки тому

    The lawyer might be comes from Greece origine

  • @austinwright3400
    @austinwright3400 5 років тому

    Goose is a good duck

  • @tendies
    @tendies 8 років тому +4

    Disgusting

  • @georgiojansen7758
    @georgiojansen7758 8 років тому

    nice islands

  • @mihriomar5158
    @mihriomar5158 5 років тому +1

    Shame on you Australia

    • @MelaniaRose
      @MelaniaRose 5 років тому +2

      Mihri Omar there are rules for every country and Australia did the right thing ! If you decide to come illegally then that’s you’re fault if you end up in detention !!

    • @antton77
      @antton77 5 років тому +2

      Go back you Muslim we don't want you people in Australia

    • @richiesquest3283
      @richiesquest3283 4 роки тому +1

      These people are illegals so what's your point ?

    • @kim-rz8rk
      @kim-rz8rk 4 роки тому +1

      @@antton77 you don't even know if he's a Muslim? Don't judge people by their name and opinion.

    • @jaicotterill5226
      @jaicotterill5226 4 роки тому

      Australia is smart for creating these camps

  • @jaberettaieb
    @jaberettaieb 5 років тому

    Stop this

  • @gurubajsingh1695
    @gurubajsingh1695 3 роки тому

    haii

  • @jmc1908
    @jmc1908 8 років тому +2

    When you look at the beautiful tropical paradise in which the refugees live, the money they paid the people-smugglers is money well spent. The rapes and assaults the refugees carry out on each other is indicative of what Australian citizens have been spared! If Tony Abbott only accomplished one worthwhile cause during his term, it was to protect his country. I wish the new Lib. government had kept him on as defence minister

  • @hannahcorrigan8472
    @hannahcorrigan8472 8 років тому

    The criminal abuse of people and of intl law and Human Rights in these camps will end. There are many groups from all sectors of society here in Aus activly working hard to end it. Unfortunately as you can see we have at this time, a far right wing government and a racist xenophobic sector of our society that has temporary power and control, no clue, no comprehension of what they are allowing and little humanity left. #CloseTheCamps

    • @jphillips3571
      @jphillips3571 8 років тому +3

      It's lying activists that have created this propaganda in the first place

    • @reportnews9890
      @reportnews9890 7 років тому +2

      Hey if enjoy living around people who believe in a religion, which being the reason for them fleeing, than move to their pedo praising society.

    • @pugthepug7910
      @pugthepug7910 5 років тому +2

      Hannah corrigan u pay for all of them then and u take them into your own home, ur stupid liberal name calling words have no effect and if u dont like this country then get out

  • @paulwhite8493
    @paulwhite8493 6 років тому

    Allahu Akbar!! Muslim will never loose!!