Legal Victory of the Philippines | What makes China's WPS CLAIMS Invalid?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 бер 2024
- China's "SCS claims are Invalid according to UNCLOS on a legal victory for the Philippines over China.
China reaffirmed its claim over the disputed Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea after the Philippine government removed the floating barrier to prevent Filipino fishing boats from entering the area. Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin said the shoal and its adjacent waters are China’s inherent territory, and therefore Beijing has indisputable sovereign rights in the disputed waters.
The Chinese claims are mostly based on its historical rights during the Han Dynasty, dating back over 2,000 years ago. In modern history, China backed its sovereignty claim and related rights over this territory following the 1943 Cairo Declaration and the 1945 Potsdam Proclamation. After World War II Japan returned to China the Chinese territories it had occupied, including Taiwan and the Penghu Islands, the Xisha Islands, and the Nansha Islands.
However, the 2016 Arbitral Tribunal under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea invalidated China’s historical claims over the disputed waters of the South China Sea.
The tribunal dealt with the question of whether China’s claims to historic rights within the nine-dash line, now the 10-dash line were in conformity with UNCLOS. It was first observed that this area - in which China claimed rights, formed in the long historical course, to living and non-living resources like fisheries and petroleum resources - partially overlaps with areas that would otherwise comprise the exclusive economic zone or the continental shelf of the Philippines.
In the view of the tribunal, Unclos establishes a comprehensive maritime zones regime and allocates rights in these areas to the coastal state and other states. In the areas of the EEZ and the continental shelf, the coastal state enjoys exclusive sovereign rights to the exploitation of living and non-living natural resources.
Concerning the rights of other states in these areas, the tribunal found that Unclos does not permit the preservation of the historic rights of any state within the EEZ or the continental shelf of another state. Therefore, after the entry into force of Unclos, the historic rights that might have existed for China within the nine-dash line in areas that would otherwise include the EEZ or the CS of the Philippines were superseded by the maritime zone’s regime created by Unclos.
That means the pre-existing historic rights no longer exist as they are not compatible with UNCLOS. Accordingly, the tribunal concluded that China’s claims were contrary to UNCLOS and exceeded the geographic limits imposed by it.
The award addresses three main substantive issues first the so-called nine-dash line and China’s claim to historic rights in the South China Sea. Second, the status of certain maritime features in the South China Sea, and Third the legality of Chinese activities in the South China Sea. Because of jurisdictional limits, however, the Arbitral Tribunal did not deal with matters related to territorial sovereignty over the disputed maritime features between the parties.
That means that the tribunal did not decide who owned the maritime features in the South China Sea, such as the Spratly Islands, claimed by China and the Philippines or any other coastal state in the region. Similarly, the tribunal did not delimit maritime boundaries between the Philippines and China in the South China Sea.
The tribunal also ruled on the legality of the activities of Chinese officials and Chinese vessels in the areas of the South China Sea located within the Philippines’ EEZ and continental shelf. It concluded that China breached the provisions of Unclos, in particular by temporarily prohibiting fishing in areas of the South China Sea falling within the Philippines’ EEZ.
Failing to prevent Chinese vessels from fishing in the Philippines’ EEZ at Mischief Reef and Second Thomas Shoal, and preventing Filipino fishermen from engaging in traditional fishing at Scarborough Shoal. Regarding China’s construction of artificial islands, installations, and structures at Mischief Reef - an LTE that is part of the Philippines’ EEZ and continental shelf - without the authorization of the Philippines, the tribunal also found China to have violated UNCLOS.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @aseananalytics
from 9 they now made it 10, I mean, how much of a liar can one get
U got $9 cannot make to $10 it's greedy , hahaha my toes laughing .
China is not only a liar but also a dumb country. China owns only 12 nautical mile of the sea bordering on China. But it claimed it owns hundreds of miles of a sea bordering on a remote country the Philippines. Let us repeat. China obeys the UNCOS to own only 12 nautical miles of the sea bordering on it, but wants to own hundreds of miles of a sea bordering on the Philippines a land thousands of miles away.
Greedy
the real history we havs old history we have old map to proved the Chinese claim are invalid because our old map created near 3000 years ago..even thier land they used to make artificial island from land in the Philippines thats iligal..
Their brains are backward...talking about history..it's 2024 now..they are not moving on...they still thinking about the planet of the Apes era. So ignorants.
Who is loosing ethics and morality? Is it right to DISRESPECT the law?
Is GREED the new superpower?
See China, you've own nothing in this earth.. So Zi look after your own China people, and families.😂😂😂
U are so naive....there is no such things as morality in geopolitics only self interest and Philippines is also greedy
like national greed corp 40 percent own by Chinese
@@Anakborneo-nh7nh Your comments are out of line. You could be in an essay contest or writing comics.
Baseless claim by china that is 2000 yrs old,,,😅what a jerk
Philippines must Stop Corruption for our food and Weapon and Hopefully our Politician must stop politics for their own benefits.
Thank you USA ,Thank you USA .
USA is our ALLiED COUNTRY of the Philippines since 1898 until now and Former Common Wealth of USA, We have 1951 treaty to protect each other we are close Family.
China took illegally 9 islands of our Country. China has no right within 200 nautical miles of the Philippines. We won in UNCLOS China must learn to respect International Law.
salamat Pres. Marcos Jr.
@@punsalanedmon4537Ibalik ang bitay para mawala ang corruption
😂 Since "anciet times"😅😅😂
We are being bullied by China, our fisherman is being harassed in our own exclusive economic zone, our coast guard is being shadowed in our own territory. Remember our National Anthem - Lupang Hinirang. Bring back Mandatory ROTC. Strengthen our military alliances with USA, Japan and Australia. We need to have permanent US military bases in the Philippines.
Dahil yan sa secret deal ni duterte at china. Bininbenta ni duterte ang pilipinas at gustong gawing probinsya ng china. Gusto rin ni duterte na ihiwalay anh mindanao sa pilipinas, baka gusto nyang siya ang hahawak ng mindanao
Nice idea
China, please listens and be civilized!
....please listen , walang s ..
They eat human Fetus don’t they??
So are they civilized?
Why should china listen haha
CHINESE ARE KNOWN FOR UNFAIR AND ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES.
Philippines should learn history and be educated!!
Vietnam also protest of China beacuse Gulf of Tonken being grab by China
Chinese thinks they still using horses and swords going to war
..what a primitives people....Back to the future or planet of the Apes?
Philippines must Stop Corruption for our food and Weapon and Hopefully our Politician must stop politics for their own benefits.
Thank you USA ,Thank you USA .
USA is our ALLiED COUNTRY of the Philippines since 1898 until now and Former Common Wealth of USA, We have 1951 treaty to protect each other we are close Family.
China took illegally 9 islands of our Country. China has no right within 200 nautical miles of the Philippines. We won in UNCLOS China must learn to respect International Law.
salamat Pres. Marcos Jr.
JUST CALL IT ASIAN SEA! NOT SOUTH CHINA SEA!! I HATE SEEING "CHINA" AS A NAME OF THAT SEA!!! IT IS A SEA FOR EVERYONE, NOT ONLY CHINA!!
Free the world from the greed of china.
Just claim usa belongs to philippine would be most beneficial to Philippine
I like SEA Sea 😉but I admit Asian Sea is the best name.
@@jacksonwong90 USA belongs to Philippines? It's more like the other way around but still a big NO. It's allied nations. Not belong to anybody's nation. It's more like a friendship than slavery.
@@coujo65 who cares what u call it
Filipinos use reason as power, Chinese use power as reason
Filipinos ask for charity in the UN, Chinese decides decisions in the UN
@@alexhu5491greedy chinese dont have an inch of PH territory! You can claim the hell greedy chinese. You have already a big land but bcoz the WPS is rich in natural resources YOu claiming not even yours in the first place. Just the greediness and you chinese people believe it lies!
Greediness...
CHINA has no right to claim the whole south China, including west Philippine sea!
But your henri sy selling manila bay to china 😂😂😂
I mean sold 😂😂
They have all the right
Do you know why you are crying? Because your country is too weak 🤷
China, Mongolia called to announce that they intend to reclaim all lands held by them in the 14th century by historical right.
Chinas claim is fake and invented the phillippines has a old Spanish map that the Sproatley island is Philippine territort
Sana lahat ng vlogger ng Pilipinas magkaisa at mag-vlog against sa China..
Magkano ang katapat niyan binanta ang pagkatao nila.
Sad but true
Impossible masyadong matatapang mnga dds eh mnga vloger nila nakakasira sa gobyerno
Philippines must Stop Corruption for our food and Weapon and Hopefully our Politician must stop politics for their own benefits.
Thank you USA ,Thank you USA .
USA is our ALLiED COUNTRY of the Philippines since 1898 until now and Former Common Wealth of USA, We have 1951 treaty to protect each other we are close Family.
China took illegally 9 islands of our Country. China has no right within 200 nautical miles of the Philippines. We won in UNCLOS China must learn to respect International Law.
salamat Pres. Marcos Jr.
Greed.
1734 PHILIPPINES VS. 1945 CHINA
1734 Philippines no longer exists, colony 🤣
China since ancient times.@@alexhu5491
@@alexhu5491 nice TRY WUMAO en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
@@alexhu5491 but your 1947 originally 11 dash line has no clear area of scope or even exact coordinates of claims.
@@alexhu5491be civilized..your out of your great wall of tufo.
Every island in the WPS should bear the Philippines flag, wether inhabited or not should there be a Phil. Flag.
Thanks for watching, stay connected to more related content.
Please like, share, and comment on our videos
We should start calling it ASEAN Sea
Tahimik nga asean Pinas Lang maingay susol ng kano
Where is the Green peace int’ about the destruction of reef? By China 😂😂😂
Just show the legal claims that we won in Hague We won legally.. don't compare the claim of china that lost and not accepted by United Nation Convention on the Law of the Sea ( UNCLOS) because we also have our historical claim since 1734.
China does not have historical claim either. It’s the Philippines who have the historical claim from the Valerde Map of 1734, not China. China has justifications from lying China trolls like you.
@@wionporky9937, you may laugh now, but you’re not getting a drop of oil from the Spratly Islands. The Philippines will soon be ready with Brahmos missiles.
@@wionporky9937 Shameless. A quick Google search will tell you that "The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is the principal judicial organ of the UN. The Court has two functions: To settle, in accordance with international law, legal disputes submitted by States, and. To give advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it by authorized UN organs and specialized agencies. 8 Mar 2024".
But the Chinese water 💦cannons are so powerful 😩
@@wionporky9937 only strong in a weak country like the Philippines. but that has no strength in countries that can fight like Japan or others 😭
Just being greedy
Greedy like a pinoy maid?
UNCLOS Article 298, paragraph 1, allows States and entities to declare that they exclude the application of the compulsory binding procedures for the settlement of disputes under the Convention in respect of certain specified categories kinds of disputes.
UNCLOS defining EEZ superseded any historical claim by any country… all unclos signatories or UN member states must respect the 2016 final and execuotory ruling of the International Arbitral Court created under the UNCLOS Intl Treaty
Perhaps that Dash Lines are old Trade Routes of ChiNakaw.
China please use the word ashame😂
PBBM must invoke the mutual defence treaty now.
Yeah invoke MDT, that is what China to Show how China and its people will react !
Yea we are next Ukraine
😂😂 understand what is the details of MDT.
Respecting EEZs which is worlwide recognized, & the UN Arbitral ruling, by China is key to peace in WPS.
God bless the Philippines Republic of America.Thank you, US Navy, for protecting us.
GOOD JOB! ASEAN Analytics! This is very informative. 🎉
Philippines must Stop Corruption for our food and Weapon and Hopefully our Politician must stop politics for their own benefits.
Thank you USA ,Thank you USA .
USA is our ALLiED COUNTRY of the Philippines since 1898 until now and Former Common Wealth of USA, We have 1951 treaty to protect each other we are close Family.
China took illegally 9 islands of our Country. China has no right within 200 nautical miles of the Philippines. We won in UNCLOS China must learn to respect International Law.
salamat Pres. Marcos Jr.
Translate to Chinese So Chinese President can understand.
They Understand but Chinese Communist act like a dumb stupid
Looool 9 dash line belongs to china
Do you know why you are crying? Because your country is too weak 🤣
Is he was illeterate?
@@ryuhayabusa5935 loool says someone who uses his grammar as "is he was" hahahahahaha
Laban tayo pilipinas kaya natin to kong mag samasama tayo huwag tayong duwag para hindi tayo apijin ..binomba tayo ng tubig tapatan natin ng bala dahil yon ang kailangan nila ...action speaks lauder than the word
West philippines sea is certified of the phillippines.
Of course it is invalid how come you claim the territory of others if you only claim it after the WW2 😂 the only territory Japan return to China was paricel and Taiwan not the spratlys and Scarborough 🤣 and Even in history China does not have old map to prove the claim how come you draw 9 dash line now 10 dash line at the shorelines of other nations shameless drawing really? Very near to coastlines?😂
We call that CCP greediness 😂
Never mind.
China is famous for counterfeiting and fakes.
They can always produce a map. 😂😂😂😂
just an excuse that resonate with certain groups at very minimal cost. Spain is claming Atlantic Ocean as we speak and they have actual maps. Just serving their "national interest." Very simply CCP has always adhere to laws of the jungle and they are showing their fangs now they are big and strong.
@@tommohsien888 law of barbarian law of ice age law of pre historic people as if they are people I preferred calling them Winnie the Pooh 🤣😆😆
Getting Crazy this is so Sad 😢
China can claim all the dumplings and peking duck thats is.
To clarify, the Philippines' claim on Spratlys (aside from a few natural islands) are not territorial, but simply in context of an EEZ. An EEZ is not territorial water, but enforcement of international laws is within the obligation of the nation or nations controlling an EEZ. If two nations have overlapping EEZ's, then it is their obligation to talk in relation to sharing of resources within the shared EEZ. China, in this regard, is regarded by UNCLOS as an outsider in any such talks regarding Spratly's. The only ones who can are the Philippines, Malaysia, etc, who shares the overlapping EEZ. In regards to Scarborough shoal which is not part of Spratlys, the claims of China (and by extension, Taiwan) was also effectively rejected by the same court ruling. The Philippines is the sole legal claimant of the said shoal, and anyone else is basically an illegal settler.
Also, speaking of natural islands, China doesn't even control ANY natural island in the Spratly group of islands. Even Taiwan is ahead of them in terms of controlling a natural island so they are relegated into destroying coral reefs to have some semblance of a claim. And that's the contentious part since reefs cannot be considered as territory, but falls under an EEZ and extended continental shelf which can only be exploited by the nations surrounding it.
Taiwan controls the largest island, Vietnam controls 9 large islands, the Philippines controls 7 islands, and Malaysia controls 1. China's claims is basically flimsy. If the Philippines is as aggressive as China, then we can easily militarize any one of those islands. But we're a peace loving country
#2
Any such historical claim has already been addressed in the UNCLOS decision. It's all basically a bunch of story of Chinese tourists setting up camp, alluding to an ambiguous island, and not even claiming that those belongs to China. By that very logic, then Ancient India belongs to China just because they visited it, which is absurd. In regards to the islands, the CCP throughout the decades kept moving which island is which based on convenience. Even the so-called observatories were never found and could never have possibly existed due to size on the rocks (this one specifically referring to Scarborough Shoal, where the CCP claims to have built an observatory in Ancient times) that China has been claiming. As I have said, China neither owns nor controls ANY natural island in the area. What was clarified in the 2016 ruling under UNCLOS, which China is a signatory of, is that a country can only claim territories based on NATURAL ISLANDS. The Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia and Taiwan are the only ones who controls natural islands in the Spratlys and therefore are the sole countries with legal claim to an EEZ within those territories. China, in effect, is an illegal settler. China's claim of ownership over the sea itself has also been overturned by UNCLOS due to its incompatibility with modern international treaties, laws and agreements. Not to mention, what's been stated in history as part of China's seas has been ambiguous at best, and could also have been simultaneously claimed by any of the other nations. That doesn't make it a valid claim in any modern internationally recognized world order.
UNCLOS does not deal with the sovereignty issues. That's why Manila cannot move forward with its EEZ claim
UNCLOS does not deal with the sovereignty issues.
@@wangchung7599 Noynoy didn't know. The $30m spent on the PCA ruling was not a good investment.
@@osmanzng8065 Vietnam is the other country that has sovereignty claim over the entire Spratly islands. Philippines can't go ahead to claim EEZ as the dispute between China and Vietnam is not resolved yet.
What a long essay of crap 🤣
From UCLOS it’s valid.
Maraming salamat sa pag bigay ng maayus at malinaw n paliwanag sa bagay n yan , kami man din dito pinas eh na hihirapan sa kung anong kalalagyan or magiging kahihinatnat sa hinaharap ng mga na kakabagabag n bagay n yan, Nais Lng nmin mabuhay ng matiwasay ng walang tinatapakang kapit bahay n may maayus n daloy s pakipag ugnayan sa mga karating bayan, salamat sa Vietnam, Brunei,Malaysia, Indonesia n nka antabay sa kung ano man ang sapitin ng bansang ito , di nmin alam kung papano nmin ipag tatangul sarili nmin sa mga hindi kana is Nais n bagay n pwede pang gawing ng dragon ng hilaga n hindi nmn nmin itinuturing n kaaway Pero ma Sindhi pa doon ang ipinaparamdam nila saamin, mahabaging panginoon naway wag kami pabayaan ng international community ounce nag nasimula na ang gyera ang aming kaalaman bilang Isang reservist ay hindi pa sasapat sa lakas at higante nming makakasagupa naway wag kaming matulad sa Ukraine at sa Palestine n dinurog durog ng mga makapang yarihan nilang kapit bahay kung ano man ang kapalaran ng bansang ito , kayo n po mga tao ng daigdig n ito ang makapag sasabi kung karapat dapat bang ipag tangul kami or pabayaan ng international community, hindi nmin kayo ino obliga Pero salamat sa mga nag papakita ng pakikiramay at pang damay at handang ipagtanggul sa aming kinakaharap ng suliranin.
Thanks for watching, stay connect to more related contents.
Please like, share and comment to our videos
Chinese pirates
Actually they indiscriminate our environment destroying the precious corals and marine animals including large clams
I heard from a documentary that China Ruler precolonial Manila respected Philliphines right and did not interfere .
However today China government is not like their ancestor in respecting Sovereignty of Philliphines
That adjustable nine dashed line map is a treasure map. They based their claim and assert using harassment and intemedation is unacceptable this create provocation then trouble in this region.
Keep up the spirit Mr Xi,💪💪💪
Philippines historical, legal rights and sovereign claim dates back during Israel's King Solomon's reign,, where he described the Philippines as the isles of land of gold and precious gems in the Far East.
While the neighbors were shouting and waving their fists at each other over an empty lot between them, some criminals decided to sneak past the people fighting and just moved in and installed some shacks and other amenities, mowed the lawn, and got phone and electrical connections. Now the fighting neighbors have taken notice and are outraged.
Actually they only needed to revive everything rather then rush to collect!
They practice the cold war tactics by the former Soviet Russia during cold war with any nation they encounter
China has no right to claim it
at all. The International Law must
change it to Asean Sea bcoz its
also claimed by several Asean
country nearby.
The asean members state who refused to accept the ruling of the international law unclos and the arbitration made in Hague should be ashamed. You are members of UNCLOS why not respect the rule of law. If you have anything to prove your claim it should be filed in the court of law and let it follow legal process under UNCLOS. WE HAVE LEGAL BASIS TO CLAM AS SUCH! WE WON THE ARBITRATION IN HAGUE in 2016 UNCLOS.
UNCLOS Article 298, paragraph 1, allows States and entities to declare that they exclude the application of the compulsory binding procedures for the settlement of disputes under the Convention in respect of certain specified categories kinds of disputes.
Philippines should be kicked.out of Asean
Other Asean countries are all smarter than pilipines
The best way to counter china is deterence. Neighbors can build up their navies & ally together with the threat of not only trade embargos & etc. Once the deterence is obviuos to china, table, negotiate peace treaties based on international law. Alliance & military power, In my opinion, is the best way to force any neighbor to abide by international law. As much as we hate to use force, it can be used to maintain peace & order in the seas.
China itself was enslaved by Manchuria, a Mongolian tribe, till 1911.
BRAVO PHILIPPINES CHINA THE LOSSER
Yet now Philippines is the loser cos china is controlling those area hahaha
Seems like China's claim of South China Sea is based on the it's land size compare to Philippines or other countries near SCS,since their Northern side of the country has no water.😂
OMG China greeeeeeeddddddddyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
It is just a barbie map😂😂😂
West Philippines Sea Not china😊🎉❤🎉
When was "West Philippine Sea" established?
That's different. The West Philippine Sea is our immediate nautical area. The contested waters is the Philippine EEZ.
@@wenchen8870
When was the Chinese Communist Party established?? 😂😂😂
@@wenchen8870 the west Philippine sea was already in our map since 1734 by the Velarde map,The World Digital Library describes it as the "first and most important scientific map of the Philippines".it is frequently referred to as the "Mother of all Philippine Maps"the china only claimed the west Philippine sea 1947,we have a claim since 1734, spanish era,the arbitration accepted the velarde map when the Philippine won the arbitration,the arbitral tribunal adjudicating the Philippines’ case against China in the South China Sea ruled overwhelmingly in favor of the Philippines, determining that major elements of China’s claim-including its nine-dash line, recent land reclamation activities, and other activities in Philippine waters-were unlawful.
@@wenchen8870 PH and China are signatory of UNCLOS so all historic claims from that area are invalid
a court rulling without being enforced it is nothing more than useless mumbojumbo craptalk🤣🤣🤣 wishfull thinking at its best
China get out pls respect Philippines eez
Just wait for the right moment.
Thanks for watching, stay connect to more related contents.
Please like, share and comment to our videos
Most probably the dispute can only be determined by war
Everyone is a loser when this happens.
United Nation should b in this complic should tell china stop their claims.
Stopped them claim or as member should follow whats tribunal decision.
Yes it's about time
Yes that is invalid claim,over lapping claim they know that...but they keep ignoring the law
If China claiming the south china sea because of what it called then India can Claim the Indian sea 😂
South China Sea was called EAST SEA and Indian Ocean was called WEST SEA , both belonged to China . until Vikings of England came robbed both away . please read history on Admiral Chenhe Voyages 600 years ago
😂😂😂😂
Respect to maritime international law
falsified historical narratives fed as propaganda to chinese citizen, you're brainwashed by your overlord ccp@@chuakl1
You greedy chinese government! You wanted to grab everything you can because you have the power and mean. Sorry for your small neighbouring country they can’t resist your bullying, what a shame! Greedy country!
America and Israel make it happen the oil exploration to start in the Philippines. China claims the 9-10 dash line is invalid, illegal, not according to international laws.
Lol if Philippines acknowledge the 9 dash line and work with china...u might get some share of the oil deposit ....if not Philippines will end it not having a single drop 😂
@@Anakborneo-nh7nh 85% of the world will not acknowledge China invalid claims and bullies interest.
@@emillimsiaco4255 loool I don't know where u get the 85% but even 95% won't change the fact china is still in control and u can't do anything...do u guys really wish to go battle ? And think ur papa US will really fight alongside u when the Time comes ? Hahaha
@@emillimsiaco4255 oh from my viewpoint it is Philippines greed that is bringing up the tension in the scs
From Malaysia 🇲🇾
Ohh really? U must be a Chinese 😂😂😂😂😂
China is always invented the hestory and even the 9-line is also chines invented by china.
The Philippines must strongly assert its rights in WPS with the backing up of all major allies which are the law enforcers of the UNCLOS.
WEST PHILIPPINES SEA IS BELONG TO THE PHILIPPINES. NOT WEST PHILIPPINES SEA BELONG TO CHINA 😂😂😂😂😂😂
There is no such sea name
China get out our EEZ
Cry louder haha
When the time is ripe, the Yanks will invoke the mutual defence treaty and the Philippine soldiers will fight for Uncle Sam.
For sure.
Will China fight if the odds are made even? 😂😂😂
@@baldeagledelta3482 When Uncle Sam wants Philippine help, she must oblige. That what the mutual defence means. Philippines is a client state.
painful truth, chinese heed, china's claim in the west Philippines sea is fueled by greed, ask mao zedong! 😂😅😂
中國要單獨一國擁有整個南海，不但不合國際法，也不合自然法。根據國際法，任何國家只能擁有12海里寬的一小塊海洋。而中國卻要擁有上千海里的南海。根據自然法，凡多國接壤的海洋，皆由多國分別擁有該海洋。南海既然接壤多國，遂自然而然的由多國分別擁有。而中國卻違背自然法要他一國獨自擁有整個南海。
China has violated both the man-made law and the nature's law.
Cambodia will support their kind, China.
island is for pilipino people..any friends country are welcome to island except china
Vietnam also hold claim to those areas near the spratly island and Paracelsus
Thanks for watching, stay connected to more related content.
Please like, share, and comment on our videos
China why not claim the whole world?
China just like what they made. . . . Below standard. . . . .
It should include Sabah
Brunie
Borneo not Sabah sorry
Looool come and get it if u dare 😂
NONE dash-line
Changing the rules in the middle of the game. Forget it.
Respect UNCLOS china so that your small neighboring countries will also respect you
1 acronym for CN: unclos
Thanks for watching, stay connect to more related contents.
Please like, share and comment to our videos
Dapat uniteam d ba
488 Million Chinese TROLL in Social Media and many of them are here 🤡
Don't insist on the right that you don't have
Thanks for watching, stay connect to more related contents.
Please like, share and comment to our videos
In history never Ang china naging colonizer so why they insist in thier historical rights which is not mostly barter trade no colonization so meaning they are not the owner because they did not colonize it and beside that they try it in Vietnam and succesful Sila kaya they continue to occupy including the Philippines west Philippine sea that's why?
Its clear atin ang west philippine sea
The South China Sea islands belong to China. This is a territory that China received after World War II with a clear legal basis. The territory of the Philippines is stipulated by treaties, and these Chinese islands are not included in the treaties. Filipinos can look at the map from the independence of the Philippines to the 1970s. These islands are clearly not included in the map. Even the Zhongye Island occupied by the Philippines was seized from the Taiwan garrison in 1971. The essence of the South China Sea dispute is the problem caused by the overlap of exclusive economic zones, but the Philippines deliberately does not mention the sovereignty of the South China Sea islands, and blindly uses the exclusive economic zone of its own island to fool the people.
How about Hawaii, Guam, Mariana, nuru away from USA but owned by USA?
So???
Is that China’s excuse??
The USA is doing a wrong thing so if you follow a wrong process that makes it right?? 😂😂😂😂
@@baldeagledelta3482 What is it that U S can do but China cannot do?
And they are living in a peaceful place.
👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👍🏿👍🏿🇵🇭🥰🥰🥰
China massive 100-ton Stealthy Unmanned Surface Vehicles flooded up SCS, ECS. & WPS.
The stealth unmanned vehicle has diverse capabilities, including hunting and engaging nuclear submarines, air defense reconnaissance, patrol, mine clearance, and anti-ship operations. China's unmanned vehicle technology has progressed rapidly, equipped with advanced weaponry, such as a vertical launch system and torpedo launch system, the unmanned vehicle can actively engage in naval battles.
Alongside with Swarm after swarm of China's New ASCMs Missile Hard to detect, Hard to intercept.
Target enemies bases near & afar , include flotella strike groupe.
Those like to wegde in for interference may sure to doom.
malaysia,indonesia,vietnam,brunei,
didn't realize that, if phillipines give up thier rights to west phillipine sea
they will also lose thier right to thier own eez. because china will claim all as thier own.
It’s 500 kms away from china, it’s claim is absurd and outrageous! greediness of china is out of this world
IF HISTORICAL rights is the argument of china.. then the AMERICAN INDIANS.decendants . should be rich people by now... EUROPEANS and immigrants should pay the original owners of USA continent. the American indians
This is an old ruling. This is old news.
Thanks for watching, stay connected to more related content.
Please like, share, and comment on our videos
There's no country such as china..it's just a region of Philippines
#CHINASTOPAGGRESSIONTOTHEPHILIPP8NES...
Thanks for watching, stay connect to more related contents.
Please like, share and comment to our videos
This video based its arguments on the Tribunal rulings but the UN says the Tribunal has no jurisdiction in the dispute or it is legally binding because it was arranged and funded by the US after China refused to participate in the Permanent Court of Arbitration case. Every member of the UN Security Council dismissed the Tribunal ruling as invalid, including the US.
The Tribunal was also THE UNCLOS, they are one.
The Tribunal uses UNCLOS in its rulings but UNCLOS does not allow any Tribunal to decide disputes without consent of the parties involved and China did not give consent.
China is signatory of the UNCLOS
Then why china refuse to participate?
Because it goes against international laws; PH refuses to abide by its own and China's treaties governing SCS that predates UNCLOS.
BORDERLESS FREEDOM land/water/sky for democratic NEW ERA ONE GLOBAL BODY of mortal mankind inhabitants..
GREAT DIVINE universal resources ENDOWMENT for PEACE, PROTECTION and PROSPERITY. Very pleasing and lovely given by GOD for anyone else needs for life.
NOT FOR DEADLY SIN FOR GLUTONY AND GREED.
CCP please bug off at WPS, EEZ and it is not your play ground nor have right to dwell and berth in that sea area. Follow and observe the UN agreement, ruling of UNCLOS. Respect the prevailing law of the sea. Be a gentleman.
RESPECT EEZ ALL COUNTRY ❤🎉🎉
WERE IS HARY ROCK?
China must pay thier elligal activities in the south china sea and west Philippine sea