लहूलुहान विभाजन के लिए सिर्फ अंग्रेज और जिन्ना जिम्मेदार नहीं थे, बल्कि नेहरू और गांधी भी उतने ही जिम्मेदार थे। लेकिन इतिहासकारों ने उनकी इन गलतियों को ढक दिया।
Srimaan Chandrachur Ghose has done a very brilliant job by bringingout this book.....he is a very captivating speaker and very well read and knowledgeable person... Anuj Dhar ji is a regular visitor to our channel.good wishes for the success of this wonderful book
This is one episode that I wish had lasted at least another 2-3 hours. There is so much information. The episode is a lexicon in and of itself. Thank you so much for hosting Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur. I'm hoping to hear from them again soon.
I had a compulsory full paper titled Gandhianism in fy senior college and hated it! Used to argue with my professor who could never convince me. In the end he pleaded that I should just write the stuff in my exam to pass.
मेरे साथ भी हो चुका है यह सेकंडरी स्कूल की हिस्ट्री क्लास में😂 हमारे अध्यापक खुद गांधी के विलोचक थे। स्कूल के बाद विज्ञान प्रवाह ले लिया था सो गांधी की हिस्ट्री पढ़ नही पाए
Wrong historical narratives were imposed on the generations but due to social media these fake narratives are being exposed. There are many people who were forced to study the wrong narratives.
PR hai yaar ab saaree duniya connect kar tee gandhi se to humein gandhi ko sir pe chadana padta hai , non violence wale masterstroke ne gandhi ko poster boy bana diya post ww2
@@NativeVsColonial aur kya bhai goro ko kahan chanakya samjha payenge yeh log kabhi promote kiya hai enho ne kabhi gandhi easy choice hai aur aap chinese ko dekho saree duniya ko pata su tze aur conficius ke bare mein
As a nation, we have invested too much in Gandhi. Hence there is no going back. When one cannot shorten the length of a line, we draw a bigger line next to it. Hence, the statues of Patel and Bose at strategic places.
Unfortunately patriots like Bose n Savarkar who contributed most were sidelined. Policy of non - violence was proved utter nonsense n stupid idea ever...
*_Excellent interpretation, analysis and lessons for all Bharatiyas. But we grossly underestimated the devilish plan of Britain Leaders, who wanted to India to perish at every step._*
सर् एक ऐसा एपिसोड बनाइए... 1947 से 2014 तक शांतिप्रिय कौम के लिए स्पेशल कौन कौन से कानून नीति बनाई गई,सुविधा दी गई... हिन्दुओ को दरकिनार कर के... ऐसा एपिसोड हम हररोज शेयर करेंगे
My late father, Maj. Gen. Gurdial Singh KCIO, was getting his pension from 1952 until the mid 60's in £ sterling. It changed to rupee payment after that. Harpreet Singh Sandhu.
अनुज भाई कांग्रेसी कोई freedom FIGHTER तो थे नहीं जो रीढ़ की हड्डी दिखाते। नेताजी और INA की वजह से लुटेरों को भागना पड़ा तो जाते जाते वो अपना गुर्गा बैठा गये। नेहरू उनका गुर्गा ही था और गुर्गों से स्वभिमान (sovereignty) की उम्मीद कैसी?
All the minority are enjoying the true freedom here.Minoritarian know Nehru comes from Gaysuddin gazi family,so jawahar is a minority.Indra Gandhi name was Maimuna begum, again she is a minority that's why she ordered to shot Sadhu and suppressed Hindu , added "secular" in constitution , imposed emergency .In this hierarchy Rahul and Varun are also minority that's why they hate lord Ram / Hindu and are liked and voted by minority 🐕
Because of these reasons, the naxalite moment also rose, as people were still were getting the same treatment as they were facing under the British rule.
There was no rehabilitation plan for Sindhi refugees either! Entering into Rajasthan by trains they moved through multiple cities to find accommodations.
Interesting topic. Please share references to have discussions with friends.If you read UA-cam of Dr Istiaq Ahmed his mindset cannot be changed bore and raised in Pakistan.He always had mindset calling “our muslims were saved by Gandhi and Nehru”. He has huge regards for Mulana Azad.
Sanjay sir, @24:50 other nation achieved freedom while india got dominion status. My question is here, how many British colonies achieve freedom on its own and how many nations were dominions?
कहीं अंग्रेजों ने भारत नेहरू को ही दे दिया हो यह जांच कर लें। यह परिवार किसी को देश चलाने नहीं दे रहा। कोई राज तो जरूर है चीन पर इनकी विशेष श्रद्धा भी एक बड़ी सोचने वाली बात है
After hearing you gentlemen ,one can simply conclude that SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE MOST CAPABLE LEADER OUT OF WHOLE LOT.SUBHASH WAS GREAT ORGANIZER.HE WAS ORIGINATOR OF ,FIVE YEAR PLAN. REGARDING NEHRUS LOVE FOR CHINA,WAS IT SOMEHOW RELATED TO NEHRUS BIGGEST WEAKNESS?
संजय साब, आप दुसरे व्हिडिओ मे, Dr अंकित को please बोलने दिजिए। आप उनका बोलना, बिचमे काटने से हमारा सूनने का लिंक टूट जाता है. हम व्हिडिओ देखते है, वो Dr अंकित को सुनने के लिए। Hope, you will take it in right spirit
Till today We All Know That 15 August 1947 is our Independence Day 😢 and after making an Islamic Nation of Pakistan we decided not to throw out All the Abrahamic Religions followers and declare India a Hindu State. Every government in Office kept on bowing down to the Islamist, Christians and Leftist Communist ideology and kept on pushing and crushing the Sanatani ideology…
Nehru is not much different from Bhutto, the same fuedalistic mindset and we wouldn't have been much different from Pakistan today if other organs of constitution didn't work and other leaders of Congress were not patriotic and put their foot down. Even institutions like IITs may have been somebody's brain child and Nehru took the credit for it, I think.
It took 70yrs to know this,All the white file lying there should be explored, credit should go to real hero's,Lokamanya tilak,Veer sarvarkar,Subhash Chandra Bose etc.Also make how they inherited the sur name of Gandhi.
muslim apne chhote bachcho madarsa me islam padhate hai christian apne bachcho ko missionary school me christianity aur hindu apne bachcho ko convent school me christianity and secularism ant nishchit hai hamari
Guided constitution was immitating british means narrow or small parliament size that was apt for london but not to delhi. They all missed the population quotient as well as the geographic size quotient. This is just like we had hardly 500 medical seats for the entire population of our country to produce doctors. This led to great demand, psychophancy, and corruption of educational institutions because of the artificial demand creation for doctors through very limited seats. We all in fact took pride in passing these exams as a coveted achievement in our family little realising our poor planning vision for our future of Medicine or health sector in 1947.
Clement attlee the then british PM admitted that its because of Bose that they acceded to quit india and not because of congressor gandhi or nehruddin. He wrote on his memoires written afterwards on retirement. JAIHIND
The biggest lie told to us was that Gandhi was ahimsaavaadi. Gandhi's ahimsa doctrine was that Indian lives can be lost for the British cause but never for our own cause.
लहूलुहान विभाजन के लिए सिर्फ अंग्रेज और जिन्ना जिम्मेदार नहीं थे, बल्कि नेहरू और गांधी भी उतने ही जिम्मेदार थे। लेकिन इतिहासकारों ने उनकी इन गलतियों को ढक दिया।
Srimaan Chandrachur Ghose has done a very brilliant job by bringingout this book.....he is a very captivating speaker and very well read and knowledgeable person...
Anuj Dhar ji is a regular visitor to our channel.good wishes for the success of this wonderful book
Both Gandhi and Nehru appeased Muslims at the cost of Hindus and tried their level best to make India an Islamic state after partition in 1947.
Jai Sanatan Hindu rastra, vande matram,, All Hindu's should read this book ( understanding Mohammad by Ali Seena ) From Pakistan....
Ali s3na is Persian not paki
He's from Iran not from Pakistan and settled in Canada.
Hearing this anyone can understand that Nehru was a fool who had no quality to be a PM of a free India.
Nehru did not have any quality of being any party president even! How can he be a PM?
भारत को आज़ादी मिली ही नहीं। पहले एक East India company थी और आज भी हज़ारों अंग्रेज़ी company भारत पर राज कर रही है। काहे की आज़ादी !
What an interesting and eye-opening discussion this was. 👏 👏 👏
Nehru and Gandhi were British agents. All awards conferred upon them be called back
This is one episode that I wish had lasted at least another 2-3 hours. There is so much information. The episode is a lexicon in and of itself. Thank you so much for hosting Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur.
I'm hoping to hear from them again soon.
sir, Gandhi was not a mahatma nor nehru a patriot. दोनो हिन्दु और भारतीय संस्कृति के विरोधी। इन दोनो के बारे मे बहुत देर से पता चला।
Sir, kindly coordinate with like-minded people in authority and seek full DISCLOSURE about Netaji in Special Parliament Session
Ye kitab har ek supreme judges ko gift karo.
I had a compulsory full paper titled Gandhianism in fy senior college and hated it! Used to argue with my professor who could never convince me. In the end he pleaded that I should just write the stuff in my exam to pass.
मेरे साथ भी हो चुका है यह सेकंडरी स्कूल की हिस्ट्री क्लास में😂 हमारे अध्यापक खुद गांधी के विलोचक थे। स्कूल के बाद विज्ञान प्रवाह ले लिया था सो गांधी की हिस्ट्री पढ़ नही पाए
Wrong historical narratives were imposed on the generations but due to social media these fake narratives are being exposed. There are many people who were forced to study the wrong narratives.
Nehru -
The First Muslim PM of India
Please don't insult Pandits by continuing to refer Nehru as
Pandit Nehru
Don't use PANDIT
for Nehru
His mom married a malm and faroq abullah was his bro.. that's why he worked so hard to make him king of separate Kashmir.
NEHRU was a great WOMANISER
and indira was momina begum
Not Jawaharlal but Jaharlal Nehru
Unless & until the masses (public) knows, both these hindu drohi will be eulogiesed.
सारी बातें जानकर ऐसा लगता है कांग्रेस को पावर से लगाव था देश के साथ कोई प्यार नही था। ..... Congress का यही सही चरित्र था।
What Nehru did was to re-establish Delhi Sultante. We are living in Sultante 2.0.
We have to request hon'ble PM to stop calling Gandhi as"Pujya Bapu".
PR hai yaar ab saaree duniya connect kar tee gandhi se to humein gandhi ko sir pe chadana padta hai , non violence wale masterstroke ne gandhi ko poster boy bana diya post ww2
@@anishwingerToh BJP ko Gora validation chahye?
@@NativeVsColonial aur kya bhai goro ko kahan chanakya samjha payenge yeh log kabhi promote kiya hai enho ne kabhi gandhi easy choice hai aur aap chinese ko dekho saree duniya ko pata su tze aur conficius ke bare mein
@@anishwinger Toh iska matlab hum british ke dalle gandhi apna bapu bana le? Kuch saram kar le yaar! BJP ka har kaam Masterstroke nahi hota.
We should stop calling Gandhi a mahatma, and Nehru a Pandit.
Absolutely 💯 agreed 🙏 they were the worst things that happened to us and we're still paying the price for their misdeeds
NEHRU was a great WOMANISER
Should have been done many years ago!
"DURATMA"
Absolutely
How naive of us , common people of India ! How we failed to see Jawahar becoming zahar for the premature nation !
Gandhi and Nehru were unapologetic British collaborators who have been painted as India's independence heroes.
🤣🤣 aapki bas umar badhi hai...
with all due respect.
The partition of India is failed.....because partitions means all Muslims must go to Pakistan and all hindus must come back to India..
RULE OF CONGRESS IS JUST THE EXTENSION OF ANGLO- MUGHALAI RULE ..!!!
Recommended reading for everyone:
"Nehru's 97 Major Blunders" by Rajnikant Puranik
A new version has came of this book. The title has been changed to 'Nehru's 127 major blunders'
As a nation, we have invested too much in Gandhi. Hence there is no going back.
When one cannot shorten the length of a line, we draw a bigger line next to it. Hence, the statues of Patel and Bose at strategic places.
Thanks Anuj ji so raising the question that whole expense of WWI and 2 were transferred to public of india through RBI in the form of debt...
Why Rahul Gandhi has become the mouth piece of Anti India forces ?
Today I.N.D.I.A alliance dmk party in my state Tamilnadu said we should eradicate sanatan dharma a direct call for genocide most are angry here
@@mukundha7621Is it because they are afraid of Annamalai ?
It is in there blood.
Unfortunately patriots like Bose n Savarkar who contributed most were sidelined. Policy of non - violence was proved utter nonsense n stupid idea ever...
If lehroo-gandy gang were such anti-brit freedom fighters, why did the brits NEVER lock them up in kala paani?
@@Tcee420Because they were British agents acting as Congress leaders
@@vedantt9928
.... and even today their descendants are agents of the british.....videshi aurat ka chakkar hai babu bhaiyya😉
This happens everyday, actual workers do not have time for politics
@@Tcee420bad shah khan was locked in kalapani
*_Excellent interpretation, analysis and lessons for all Bharatiyas. But we grossly underestimated the devilish plan of Britain Leaders, who wanted to India to perish at every step._*
P00⁰ⁿ
P
India got true Independence only with Modi
🙏🚩 सत्य सनातन वैदिक धर्म की जय 🚩🙏
सर् एक ऐसा एपिसोड बनाइए... 1947 से 2014 तक शांतिप्रिय कौम के लिए स्पेशल कौन कौन से कानून नीति बनाई गई,सुविधा दी गई... हिन्दुओ को दरकिनार कर के...
ऐसा एपिसोड हम हररोज शेयर करेंगे
My late father, Maj. Gen. Gurdial Singh KCIO, was getting his pension from 1952 until the mid 60's in £ sterling. It changed to rupee payment after that. Harpreet Singh Sandhu.
Because he worked for the crown at that time
अनुज भाई कांग्रेसी कोई freedom FIGHTER तो थे नहीं जो रीढ़ की हड्डी दिखाते। नेताजी और INA की वजह से लुटेरों को भागना पड़ा तो जाते जाते वो अपना गुर्गा बैठा गये। नेहरू उनका गुर्गा ही था और गुर्गों से स्वभिमान (sovereignty) की उम्मीद कैसी?
Namashkar Anujji 🙏
nehru was a muslim. why dont people understand this. he was no pandit.
आधुनिक भारत के इतिहास की अनेक परतें अनखुली है इन्हें खोलना जरूरी है ये बात सबको पता होना चाहिए कि 55 तक नेहरू सरकार ने अंग्रेजों को वेतन और पेंशन दी
The effectiveness of ibharatiya knowledge lies in its efficient administration. After 2014 we are seeing this.
3 BRILLIANT PEOPLE imparting real knowledge and educating us. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
How a defeated man become the prime of India. We have to teach the school children about this.
Nehru's Grandfather was Muslim.
Gayasuddin gazi
All the minority are enjoying the true freedom here.Minoritarian know Nehru comes from Gaysuddin gazi family,so jawahar is a minority.Indra Gandhi name was Maimuna begum, again she is a minority that's why she ordered to shot Sadhu and suppressed Hindu , added "secular" in constitution , imposed emergency .In this hierarchy Rahul and Varun are also minority that's why they hate lord Ram / Hindu and are liked and voted by minority 🐕
प्रखर श्रीवास्तव द्वारा लिखी पुस्तक "हे राम" का विश्लेषण करने की कृपा करे
Heer- Ranjha
Shiri-Farhad
Laila-Majnu
Mirza-Sahiba
Sassi-Punnu and the most important and immortal pair....
NEHRU- EDWINA😂😂😂🙏
😢both of you are right
Because of these reasons, the naxalite moment also rose, as people were still were getting the same treatment as they were facing under the British rule.
सुन्दर और ज्ञानवर्धक विमर्श।
Seriously, How do we erase the memories of Gandhi and Nehru from our minds?
By telling the truth. Firstly by removing his ugly mug from our currencies.
Iske liye angrejo ki dhurt shiksha vyavsthaa ko khatam karnaa hogaa, tabhi jhooth ko sach banaane se rokaa jaa saktaa hai
Yes, Gandhi was Hippocrate
ईश्वर का आभार मनाओ कि एडवीनास्तान नहीं बनाया लेहरू ने
Got a copy of the book and read upto 25 pages ( Sen Joseph )
Can I get a pdf of this?
There was no rehabilitation plan for Sindhi refugees either! Entering into Rajasthan by trains they moved through multiple cities to find accommodations.
Thanks for this beautiful presentation with Chandrachur Ghosh and Anuj Dhar 🙏
आदरणीय दीक्षित जी कृपया चंद्र चूड़ घोष जी से अनुरोध करें कि अपनी पुस्तक का हिंदी संस्करण भी उपलब्ध कराने का प्रयास करें
Ultimately, Mohan Das Gandhi was responsible for concentration of FULL powers under jawaharlal Nehru UNDOUBTEDLY.
Bharat Mata ki Jay
Awesome disscus congratulations ❤❤❤❤❤
Jaiprakash Narayan was too much impressed with Gandhi and finally surrendered to him after sacrificing his wife to MKG for his Experiments Of Truth😂…
Interesting topic. Please share references to have discussions with friends.If you read UA-cam of Dr Istiaq Ahmed his mindset cannot be changed bore and raised in Pakistan.He always had mindset calling “our muslims were saved by Gandhi and Nehru”. He has huge regards for Mulana Azad.
Both Gandhi and Nehru lacked character
Sanjay sir, @24:50 other nation achieved freedom while india got dominion status.
My question is here, how many British colonies achieve freedom on its own and how many nations were dominions?
Domain nations are
1 New Zealand
2 Australia
3 Canada
कहीं अंग्रेजों ने भारत नेहरू को ही दे दिया हो यह जांच कर लें। यह परिवार किसी को देश चलाने नहीं दे रहा। कोई राज तो जरूर है चीन पर इनकी विशेष श्रद्धा भी एक बड़ी सोचने वाली बात है
Absolutely correct
Naman to three different sarathis of the new age Indian narrative.
Kis baat ka Mahatma tha Vo ?
Brahcharya hota hoga .Jiska sach poore Desh ko pata hai .
Great sir. We need more books.
After hearing you gentlemen ,one can simply conclude that SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE MOST CAPABLE LEADER OUT OF WHOLE LOT.SUBHASH WAS GREAT ORGANIZER.HE WAS ORIGINATOR OF ,FIVE YEAR PLAN. REGARDING NEHRUS LOVE FOR CHINA,WAS IT SOMEHOW RELATED TO NEHRUS BIGGEST WEAKNESS?
I hv seen the partition part in Jaipur Dialogues with Chandrachur Da n Anuj Dhar Sahev
Sir actually "HISTORY DOESN'T TELL LIES " hence the reality comes out later. 😅😅😅😅🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
संजय साब,
आप दुसरे व्हिडिओ मे, Dr अंकित को please बोलने दिजिए।
आप उनका बोलना, बिचमे काटने से हमारा सूनने का लिंक टूट जाता है.
हम व्हिडिओ देखते है, वो Dr अंकित को सुनने के लिए।
Hope, you will take it in right spirit
Till today We All Know That 15 August 1947 is our Independence Day 😢 and after making an Islamic Nation of Pakistan we decided not to throw out All the Abrahamic Religions followers and declare India a Hindu State. Every government in Office kept on bowing down to the Islamist, Christians and Leftist Communist ideology and kept on pushing and crushing the Sanatani ideology…
#RemoveGandhiFromCurrency
श्रीमान् जी क्या यह पुस्तक हिन्दी मे मिल सकती है।
I feel one person if included inpanel ,Dr Ranganathan might have made discussion more absorbing and informative.
Awesome 🙏👍
Great 👍
So true
Nehru is not much different from Bhutto, the same fuedalistic mindset and we wouldn't have been much different from Pakistan today if other organs of constitution didn't work and other leaders of Congress were not patriotic and put their foot down. Even institutions like IITs may have been somebody's brain child and Nehru took the credit for it, I think.
Why vallabhai Patel cannot be made first indipendence PM of india came out with truth 👀my humble request 🙏🌹🕉️🇮🇳🚩🔱
due to gandhi, he asked for his resignation
राम राम सा संजय जी
हरहरमहादेव
It ain't Pandit Nehru...it's PETTY NEHRU.
TQB Lehru....
The Quentesesential Bstrd 🦧
Pappuswami being the Last of The TQB.🔥
We should move on and forgetting the deciet of the British Agents Gandhi Nehru n their congress.
JAI BHARAT🎉JAI SRI RAM🎉JAI SRI KRISHNA🎉
Sanjay Dixit Aise act Karte Hain ki bahut bade mahanubhav vichari Purush hai
It took 70yrs to know this,All the white file lying there should be explored, credit should go to real hero's,Lokamanya tilak,Veer sarvarkar,Subhash Chandra Bose etc.Also make how they inherited the sur name of Gandhi.
muslim apne chhote bachcho madarsa me islam padhate hai
christian apne bachcho ko missionary school me christianity
aur hindu apne bachcho ko convent school me christianity and secularism
ant nishchit hai hamari
CHACHA NAHIN- CHICHCHA NEHRU.
Tharki ch....Bhagat tha
Namaste Sanjay Sir
@25:00 Nehru's India was from Delhi to prayagraaj,
Like Shah Alam
Namaskar Anuj daa
Guided constitution was immitating british means narrow or small parliament size that was apt for london but not to delhi.
They all missed the population quotient as well as the geographic size quotient. This is just like we had hardly 500 medical seats for the entire population of our country to produce doctors.
This led to great demand, psychophancy, and corruption of educational institutions because of the artificial demand creation for doctors through very limited seats.
We all in fact took pride in passing these exams as a coveted achievement in our family little realising our poor planning vision for our future of Medicine or health sector in 1947.
Clement attlee the then british PM admitted that its because of Bose that they acceded to quit india and not because of congressor gandhi or nehruddin. He wrote on his memoires written afterwards on retirement. JAIHIND
Vision tha subhash chandra bose k paas jinhone azadi dilwayi... na ki nehru k paas... bose ko to gayab karwa diya gaya tou kaise karte...
Sir all this happened becuase south africa returned baristar, somebody named him mahathma, like somebody rightly named nehurkhan as chacha
Msjor Sargent mohan das karam Chand
Transfer of powers are applicable to oweners only never invaders and colonization. We accepted this for personal interests /chairs.
True, both Nehru and Mohandas were collaborators with the British, so sad.
The biggest lie told to us was that Gandhi was ahimsaavaadi. Gandhi's ahimsa doctrine was that Indian lives can be lost for the British cause but never for our own cause.
Can v get this book in Hindi
India: emotionally enslaved ....
Don't trust on Pakistani Muslim and Indian Muslim......Dono ek hi hai
Afterall they got 'deeni talim' from a 'badi kitab'
Tagline of today's session " Is Gandhi a Gandhian ? "
Bharat mata ki Jai