What Does it Mean to "Deliver Someone to Satan"?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 лип 2024
  • To be delivered unto Satan means you are kicked out of the church. Why? The church is holy ground. It is a new Israel. The church is the place where the presence of God is. In the case of one who is expelled, the destruction of the flesh (1 Corinthians 5:5) could mean lots of things, it doesn't mean he's instantly going to be killed. It just means that if he's left to his flesh, and he's out in the world, where there's no sanctifying influence, this very well could lead to physical destruction. But if he wants to be there, if he doesn't want to come back, then it can even be more, it can mean like he has given himself over to darkness, and that could have even more than physical consequences. Check it out!
    Are YOU ready for a paradigm shift in the way you study theology and see the Scriptures? Are YOU prepared to recover the supernatural worldview of the Bible? If you want to have access to the complete lesson, make sure to sign up for the upcoming UNSEEN REALM 101 and 102 Course beginning soon at The Awakening School of Theology & Ministry!
    Learn more here: awakeningschooloftheology.com/
    Sign up here: awakeningschooloftheology.com...
    RESOURCES ⬇️⬇️⬇️
    drmsh.com/
    www.miqlat.org/
    nakedbiblepodcast.com/
    WHAT I DO AND WHY ⬇️⬇️⬇️
    www.miqlat.org/about-us.htm
    SUPPORT ⬇️⬇️⬇️
    www.miqlat.org/about-us.htm#do
    #Bible #Theology #MichaelHeiser

КОМЕНТАРІ • 260

  • @DRMSH
    @DRMSH  Рік тому +6

    Hi everybody!
    I want to remind everyone to join our DRMSH exclusive community. We are going to have tons of exclusive content like weekly live sessions, protected articles, and more. So, sign up now!
    community.drmsh.com/

  • @issacdhan
    @issacdhan 3 роки тому +54

    Nice line : We don't earn God's favour. We live in a certain way that tells, God is the object of our loyalty.

  • @sumerandaccad
    @sumerandaccad 2 роки тому +17

    It's a pity churches didn't deliver their abusers unto Satan but just moved them to another church to continue their activities

  • @habaconia
    @habaconia 3 роки тому +88

    Though it’s not the main point, I appreciate that he made clear that the person is expelled WITH THE HOPE AND DESIRE to bring him back in.
    Compared to other families/communities where the person is “considered dead” to the rest of the people, never to return. Gospel community is built different.

    • @lauraowen8142
      @lauraowen8142 3 роки тому +2

      Yes, indeed! Amen.

    • @Mark-yb1sp
      @Mark-yb1sp 3 роки тому +1

      My wife and I were ones who were expelled and a letter was sent to all the church. 😕

    • @habaconia
      @habaconia 3 роки тому

      @@Mark-yb1sp sorry to hear it. I’m guessing it was a mutual split (heart-breaking as it may be)?

    • @stefaniamirri1112
      @stefaniamirri1112 2 роки тому

      Look if this is not the same happened to Adam and Eve..? It is like the Bible is a continuous parallele between big/general events that than are applicable alao to specific people or to us.
      The human being wasnt cast out from the garden of Heaven with the hope of our repent and came back? Still there we are.. Sadly even after the Lord came Himself to rescue us, we are still so much self comprises to do not beable to repent and follow...

    • @scionconflict4541
      @scionconflict4541 2 роки тому +5

      @@stefaniamirri1112 The flesh cannot inherit the kingdom of heaven. God made a sacrifice for Adam and Eve before he kicked them out of the Garden. He clothed them in the skin of an animal, which is a covering. That is what the blood of Christ does, is that it covers our sin with his righteousness, so that our nakedness is not seen. Even though we are saved, we all still need to die because the flesh is inherently sinful. Our hope is in the spirit not the flesh. Until God makes all things new and incorruptible, there will continue to be a cycle, even up to the end of the millennial kingdom when people will rebel against Christs rule even though they have seen God.

  • @seventhunder777
    @seventhunder777 3 роки тому +25

    Thanks Dr Heiser, what a great insight. It is not Yahweh’s desire that a sinner would perish, but to repent and be saved.

  • @mrstrypes
    @mrstrypes 3 роки тому +31

    This caused me to think of people who WILLINGLY choose to stay away from community with other believers. How sad. But this is a fantastic teaching on why it is so crucial to stay in fellowship and why it is so dangerous to stop meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing.

    • @skeetabomb
      @skeetabomb 3 роки тому +7

      And during this evil that has been foisted upon the world against our will and when our so called leaders are actively preventing us from meeting as a community? What do we do about this mess?

    • @mrstrypes
      @mrstrypes 3 роки тому +10

      @@skeetabomb Amen! Following this hypocritical shutdown (I live in California), where leaders told everyone to stay home and then went out and lived their lives as they would normally, it is important to recognize our true enemy. More importantly, "devote ourselves to prayer, being watchful and thankful."
      (Colossians 4:2)
      Blessings, bro. The mess will not last forever. Thank God! (Literally)

    • @skeetabomb
      @skeetabomb 3 роки тому +8

      @@mrstrypes Please God, bring an end to this terrible evil that is trying to take over the world and kill us all off!

    • @P.H.888
      @P.H.888 3 роки тому +4

      Your first point ~ people willingly staying away from community with other believers?
      So they are believers and coming together for fellowship! Just because they have left 1 group that isn’t falling away! We are supposed to be free in The Holy Spirit

    • @mrstrypes
      @mrstrypes 3 роки тому +2

      @@P.H.888 I never said anything about people who leave 1 group (to presumably explore or attend others). I'm talking about the millions of believers who have chosen to position themselves outside of the community of God's family and simply be "at-home Christians".

  • @dannymack9636
    @dannymack9636 3 роки тому +16

    The good shepherd will leave the 99 sheep for the one lost sheep. Once found there will be rejoicing.

    • @wk1810
      @wk1810 2 роки тому +1

      "Good shepherd" being the operative words here. There are pastors who let the one sheep go, never so much as to even attempt to call them back to the fold.

    • @dannymack9636
      @dannymack9636 2 роки тому +1

      @@wk1810 yeh sad to say your right. But Jesus is not like that, your talking about priests and ministers and pastors.

    • @wk1810
      @wk1810 2 роки тому

      @@dannymack9636 yes, so glad Jesus isn't like that!

  • @ThebossaruChamp
    @ThebossaruChamp 3 роки тому +21

    A crucial piece for making any sense of this phrase is to read the immediate context: Paul did this to save the man's spirit. That's the best commentary I know for sure.

    • @shaunhunterit342
      @shaunhunterit342 2 роки тому +2

      Interesting to consider that he was LESS likely to be saved by remaining in the church community. A strong statement on the damage the church can do by enabling sin.

    • @ThebossaruChamp
      @ThebossaruChamp 2 роки тому

      @@shaunhunterit342 True. It is sin. However, how does the devil help save them?

    • @disguisedcentennial835
      @disguisedcentennial835 Рік тому +1

      @@ThebossaruChamp when you give someone over fully to their sin, the sin is able to do the full damage it’ll do and that will hopefully break the person and have them come running or crawling back

  • @theophilus5132
    @theophilus5132 3 роки тому +49

    I'm not sure if anyone noticed this, but I thought I'd point out that the reference that Dr. Heiser is using in Logos is the Baker Exegetical Commentary of the New Testament. Even if you don't know any greek, it is an amazing commentary set. It is not cheap, but it is very insightful.

    • @dubletar7351
      @dubletar7351 3 роки тому +4

      Thanks!

    • @lizpurtell7203
      @lizpurtell7203 2 роки тому

      Lol

    • @selectamark
      @selectamark 2 роки тому +3

      Will check it out thank you 🇬🇧

    • @johna3322
      @johna3322 2 роки тому

      Hey theo. If someone does a ceremony outside of the orthodox church such as a civil marriages or baptism of a child in another church, its said that they lose their rights to the church. Is this what Michael is talking about here? Maybe my wording isn't correct but I guess losing rights and being excommunicated is along the same lines? Can you add anything to this?
      Is this the scriptural reference to support this?

    • @amiller5885
      @amiller5885 2 роки тому +2

      Thanks for your input. I'm going to check it out.

  • @kimpaschal4263
    @kimpaschal4263 3 роки тому +8

    He (God) is to be the object of our loyalty! I love this true concept! Thank you Dr. Heiser!

  • @veronicapace7198
    @veronicapace7198 3 роки тому +4

    God loves us so much that He will allow whatever it takes to get us back on His path. If things are getting rough, ask yourself if there is something not right in your life. I know by experience.. unfortunately. God bless Dr. Heiser for his truth teachings.

  • @Notacessasionist
    @Notacessasionist 2 роки тому +4

    The treatment of the sinner was appropriate, due to the heinous nature of the sin he was involved in.

  • @stephanieferrell6171
    @stephanieferrell6171 2 роки тому +3

    I am addicted to your teaching! I can't wait to watch another episode. So enlightening! Thanking the Lord for your ministry!

  • @merkavah8075
    @merkavah8075 3 роки тому +2

    I was just reading this passage and it was somewhat confusing to me. This helped a lot Thank you Dr. Heiser!

  • @libraryfiles4470
    @libraryfiles4470 3 роки тому +2

    Very insightful

  • @maryhernandez3117
    @maryhernandez3117 Рік тому

    Eye opener! Thank you!!

  • @jasonmiller1910
    @jasonmiller1910 3 роки тому +4

    I love your videos because they're very well done and education. Ecclesiastical (church)

  • @Musick79
    @Musick79 3 роки тому +15

    I’ve always felt sorry for the “scape goat”...

    • @chrisd755
      @chrisd755 3 роки тому +10

      The feeling is the sorrow and deep, abiding regret we should all learn to feel for our own sin that makes it necessary for the death penalty to fall on the guilty or on the sacrificial substitute in the first place. Even though it's pleasant for a season, sin is ugly and nasty business. It's end is always death. Praise God forever that He made Himself to be the final scape goat!
      For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.
      Romans 6:23

    • @fritzreimer7933
      @fritzreimer7933 2 роки тому +2

      Scapegoat is symbolism of what's to come. Leviticus chapter 16. . 16:10, 16:26.
      Some translations, ESV. NLT. Wilderness = Azazel, name of a fallen chief Angel to whom all sins of men are ascribed for he is held responsible for causing the people to sin. The scapegoat delivers the blood to him, to say you Azazel are guilty for these sins.
      Later, God made Jesus to be the scapegoat for all sins He took on Himself.

    • @Roseredeemed
      @Roseredeemed 2 роки тому +2

      @@fritzreimer7933 God didn’t make Jesus he gave himself up willingly.

  • @mccalltrader
    @mccalltrader Рік тому +2

    Wow, 1 cor 5:5 really blasts Calvinism away doesnt it?
    If the man is a brother, that is given over to satan…then it is someone who lost their salvation…but, he might come back, meaning he has free will
    Beautiful

    • @kristenspencer9751
      @kristenspencer9751 2 місяці тому

      no. you cannot lose your salvation. Saved, "born-again" people still sin in numerous ways. Baby Christians for example who still have a lot of the world's ideas. Mature believers can fall to temptation. King David sinned, but didn't lose his salvation. But God did not allow the child he had with Bathsheba to live. Sinning isn't losing salvation OR absolute perfection would be keeping it. Good grief!

  • @travisandrews4181
    @travisandrews4181 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you

  • @MikeMatkin-of9iy
    @MikeMatkin-of9iy 3 місяці тому +1

    WARNING! Most churches do not practice discipline. That being said, we can fall under chastisement from the Lord. I believe we can be delivered unto satan (that is, into the world and punishment) and out of the church even if we are still attending. I experienced it. I couldn't serve and couldn't even make friends . It was as if I was fighting an invisible force. And I was. Because God knows your life even if no one else does.

  • @joyalways1179
    @joyalways1179 3 роки тому +4

    The church today, does some counsel and gives the guy the Sunday morning pulpit, i.e. Todd Bentley, very sad story.

  • @geraldjohnson8871
    @geraldjohnson8871 3 роки тому +4

    Once delivered to the world for your Sins, So be it, lf you truly Repent
    So be lt. Your choice decides your Fate. A Freewill choice of the Heart given by The Lord Jesus Christ.

    • @CatarineausArmory
      @CatarineausArmory 3 роки тому +1

      Ducks have free will. They can quack, walk, swim, or fly, but they will never knock on the flight deck door and ask to sit in the jumpseat for a ride south. Freewill will only allow you to do what your fallen nature will allow. I do not think free will will allow a man to choose Christ in a fallen state.

    • @rjabraham
      @rjabraham 3 роки тому +1

      @@CatarineausArmory no other creature has been created in the likeness/as the image bearers of God. None else has the level of responsibility on the earth as well as in his kingdom than humankind does.Believe it, humankind was and is the crown of his creation & though he knows when a sparrow (or a duck) falls or is sold, humankind is still worth more than many of them put together. (Luke 12:7). I will not entertain your analogy any further, no matter how cute you may think it is. We are still "the apple of his eye". We have features & benefits no other creature has. Period.
      Yet there is another couple of truths to observe, IF you're truly interested in the ministry of reconciliation.
      #1 Not one of us are reconciled or redeemed, if not for being sought for by One Shepherd who then instructed others to do the same and imitate his unconditional love for us to others in sacrificial ways as he did in word (preaching/teaching) & deeds (healing/feeding etc), up to the cross.
      #2 Hardness of heart in its varying degrees from unintentional to deliberate is what keeps a human in a fallen state. NOT the inability to choose. Is there a remedy to the hardness of hearts? Yes. Jesus' ministry of redemption and reconciliation. See #1

    • @geraldjohnson8871
      @geraldjohnson8871 3 роки тому +1

      @@CatarineausArmoryNB
      We are Not talking about ducks that already know God we are the ones that Get
      to exercise freewill and That is the problem people encounter thinking about ducks instead
      Of making an intelligent choice with their Freewill. That is Our Time to choose when we were born in a fallen State of our forefathers.*Freewill*
      *To Choose Good* *over Evil i.e.God* *Ways over Satans* *Ways.*

    • @CatarineausArmory
      @CatarineausArmory 3 роки тому

      @@rjabraham How about this for "cuteness"; Is not "#1 Not one of us are reconciled or redeemed, if not for being sought for by One Shepherd" a direct and unreconcilable contradiction to "#2 Hardness of heart in its varying degrees from unintentional to deliberate is what keeps a human in a fallen state."??? And as a follow up would you say that pork eating, Sabbath breaking, pagan holiday worshipping "23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity." non-followers of Jesus' commands are in a temporary state of #1 or permanent state of #2? Which state do you want to be in?

  • @neilmurray9523
    @neilmurray9523 3 роки тому +3

    I think its like the parable of the prodigal son ,he was delivered unto Satan and got roughed up pretty bad and went home to his father and repented .Delivered to Satan is the same as being delivered to the secular world which is his domain

  • @jimmybates8742
    @jimmybates8742 3 роки тому +12

    Why don't we do this today? We should, but we're to worried about inclusion.

    • @ShowCat1
      @ShowCat1 3 роки тому +4

      If we did, I think there would be a lot of empty pews.

    • @headlinenewsrant5134
      @headlinenewsrant5134 3 роки тому +1

      It's probably because the law is said to be a burden, by most. This practice is based in the Torah.

    • @reverie_song
      @reverie_song 3 роки тому +2

      Who would care? In the US at least, it would be easy to just join another church if you want to.

    • @jimmybates8742
      @jimmybates8742 3 роки тому +2

      @@reverie_song The point is to keep "your" church as pure as possible. People need to know there's a difference between spirit filled teaching and non spirit filled teaching.

    • @jimmybates8742
      @jimmybates8742 3 роки тому +2

      @@ShowCat1 Indeed. That's the point. Quality not quantity.

  • @stephenmichaels6682
    @stephenmichaels6682 3 роки тому +1

    According to our apostle paul’s ministry,today we are only saved by BELIEVING The Gospel of Jesus Christ,1st Corinthians Chapter 15 verse 1-4.Jesus Christ died on the cross,was buried and rose again on the third day.Jesus Christ Shed Blood is what saves you when you believe this plan of salvation with your heart.

  • @TheLookingGlassAU
    @TheLookingGlassAU 3 роки тому +1

    Would this be like a trial by ordeal idea similar to Leviticus style ordeals?

  • @jasonmiller1910
    @jasonmiller1910 3 роки тому +3

    Is there anyway you might do a video on how to cleanse the temple as described in the old testament?

    • @margaretclarke3643
      @margaretclarke3643 3 роки тому +1

      As born again followers of the Lord Jesus Christ, we become the holy temple in which God dwells through the Holy Spirit. We were cleansed by the BLOOD OF JESUS (the Messiah, the Annointed One).
      The Temple and everything in it was also cleansed by the sprinkling of blood from the sacrificed animals.

    • @P.H.888
      @P.H.888 3 роки тому

      Get a lot a clean pure perfect animals with NO flaw not 1. Then get a trained priest to sacrifice them
      YHVH is showing the importance and cost. The ultimate price has to be paid death to physical life.
      YHVH is Spirit

  • @olivermakower2479
    @olivermakower2479 Рік тому +1

    I just imagined Micheal Geeking out in heaven. If you think he geeked out on Earth, I totally believe that it is likely he geeks out even more in Heaven.

  • @simscity4561
    @simscity4561 2 роки тому

    What does that have to do with the destruction of the flesh ? Or being handed over to satan or when the power of the spirit is present .

  • @Gutslinger
    @Gutslinger 5 місяців тому

    1:46 Really?? 🤔
    I recently finished Exodus, and I'm currently 12 chapters in to Leviticus. I thought I read about the sin sacrifice for the commoner. I don't remember it being released. Did I miss it or misinterpret it?

  • @nikloff1815
    @nikloff1815 Рік тому +1

    I was a Jehovah Witness and they practiced disfellowshipping baptized members who fell into practicing serious sins like sexual immorality. No one in the congregation would speak to this person or have any association with them until they stopped the behavior and demonstrated repentance. I'm not aware of this being done in other Churches. This practice is I believe mostly condemned in most of Christendom.

    • @Christine-vt5fi
      @Christine-vt5fi 6 місяців тому

      Can you talk about this more? Do other things happen to the person who was cast out? When they repented did those things stop? Thanks

    • @nikloff1815
      @nikloff1815 6 місяців тому +1

      If a person was disfellowshipped it would be announced at the ministry school meeting attended mostly by only JW members to inform them and they would be shunned by all members. The decision is made by a committee of Church elders after meeting usually several times with the person. Usually if the person was repentant and stopped practicing the sins they would be reproved instead of disfellowshipped and not shunned but would have privileges removed like going in the public ministry, commenting at meetings or having any other positions of responsibility at meetings. In either case the disfellowshipped or reproved member could make appeals periodically to the elders and or the elders may meet with the member to see if they were doing works like studying, attending meetings and were truly repentant recognizing the seriousness of their sins. If it was determined the member was repentant they would be reinstated and the members would immediately stop shunning them and welcome them back into fellowship. This could take significant time depending on the seriousness of the offense.

    • @Christine-vt5fi
      @Christine-vt5fi 6 місяців тому

      @nikloff1815 Thankyou for your answer. If the person did not repent properly, did they get stalked and harassed by the community? Were their ruined and Could they still repent?

    • @nikloff1815
      @nikloff1815 6 місяців тому +1

      @@Christine-vt5fi No they were just shunned by other members both at the Kingdom Hall or if they saw them in public. No one harassed them in any way. They just didn’t talk to them or acknowledge them. If a disfellowshipped person no longer attended meetings they could be gone for years and they could return at anytime express a desire to return to good standing and if after some time the elders felt they had shown true repentance then they could be reinstated and be in good standing again. They would announce at the meeting that the person was reinstated. The congregation would clap and at the end of the meeting people would congratulate, welcome them back and resume fellowship with them. Now if a member stopped attending meetings and were suspected of falling into practicing serious sin the elders may call on them and seek them out to address why they stopped going to meetings or if they have fallen into a a problem with sin. This could be harassment. Also there was a culture of reporting to the elders if someone witnessed another member engaging in what they would classify as serious sin. Like adultery, fornication, drug use, cigarette smoking, drunkenness…It’s a cult that uses fear, guilt, isolation, brainwashing and punishment to keep members under control.

  • @xBurzurkurx
    @xBurzurkurx 2 роки тому +2

    Trivial question; does anyone know (hopefully Dr. MSH himself can answer) how Baal ended up all the way in Carthage? I can't find anything through Google, and I'm having trouble understanding if the Canaanite Baal and Carthaginian Baal Hammon are the same guy? And if so, does that mean the Canaanites were culturally intertwined with the rest of North Africa? Maybe I just need to read some more history books. Thanks for these vids Dr. God bless you

    • @kmc6506
      @kmc6506 2 роки тому

      Carthage was settled by Phoenicians. Phoenicians were a Canaanite people.

  • @ronpatton5721
    @ronpatton5721 3 роки тому +3

    It’s ok to say your not sure…since not everything in Scripture is so cut and dry, easy to chew. Some of Paul’s writings were not easy to understand (2 Pet 3), this may be one of them.
    Whatever it means, it was “sufficient” for causing the man to turn away from his sinful behavior, and it was done in such a way as to cause him to want to return (2 Cor. 2:1-11).

  • @jarrettesselman8144
    @jarrettesselman8144 Рік тому

    All main stream believers left church centuries ago. The first fellowship of believers sold all their earthly possessions, gave all they owned away to the poor, moved outside of the city and formed their own community, meeting their own needs. They did not get absorbed by a giant empire and then act just like the world.

  • @lucillepiktelis4331
    @lucillepiktelis4331 3 роки тому +1

    This happened to my husband because of the life that he had chosen, he went on a path of destruction on to death

    • @2Chor5_13
      @2Chor5_13 Рік тому +1

      Hello! Hope you dont mind me asking you, but how did he or you know that he was turned over to satan? Did the Holy Spirit depart from him? How did your husband become? DId he become loveless, hard, etc? Asking bc the Holy Spirit departed from me in 2017. And I´m calling out for help but only faith of the word people has "helped". And their doctrine is cheap grace etc..and maybe it is Gods will to not help me. I don`t know.

  • @purplestarowl89
    @purplestarowl89 3 роки тому +3

    💖💜💙🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @georgechristiansen6785
    @georgechristiansen6785 4 місяці тому

    Sadly, most people wouldn't know the difference aside from missing the services.

    • @kristenspencer9751
      @kristenspencer9751 2 місяці тому

      many congregations today are giant mega churches. You really can't know anyone Sunday to Sunday unless you join a small group Bible Study.

  • @investfluent4143
    @investfluent4143 3 роки тому +7

    New Israel? Replacement theology... Wha? Paul who prefaces every letter with a reference to himself being an Apostle to the uncircumcision as opposed to the other Apostles who prefaced their letters to the twelve tribes scattered abroad? Why a separation if the church replaces Israel?

    • @danielamallette4733
      @danielamallette4733 3 роки тому +7

      Replacement theology is a false doctrine.

    • @patrickfosterstudio
      @patrickfosterstudio 3 роки тому +3

      Dr. Heiser doesn't adhere to replacement theology. It's more a matter of symbolism. The church is to function in the same way that Israel was MEANT by God to function. One doesn't usurp the other.

    • @scottenosh4548
      @scottenosh4548 3 роки тому +1

      I dont think this is Replacement Theology. Had he said the Church is 'THE new Israel', then ya. But he didnt.

    • @investfluent4143
      @investfluent4143 3 роки тому +1

      @@patrickfosterstudio Thanks for clearing that up.

    • @Baltic_Hammer6162
      @Baltic_Hammer6162 3 роки тому +2

      Heiser does NOT subscribe to Replacement Theology. The "new Israel" caught my ear also. Not sure if he misspoke but I know from following him for five years he did not mean the church replaced Israel.

  • @thelthrythquezada8397
    @thelthrythquezada8397 Рік тому

    It’s this where the term “go to hell” comes from?

  • @jesusisourpassoverlamb2145
    @jesusisourpassoverlamb2145 3 роки тому

    What’s your opinion Dr.Michael Heiser on Dr. Margaret Barker and first temple mysticism?

    • @donaldmarshall7894
      @donaldmarshall7894 3 роки тому

      You can either get out of Babylon the Great or you can remain. It's your choice.

    • @Baltic_Hammer6162
      @Baltic_Hammer6162 3 роки тому

      I doubt Heiser will respond to a question like that. He is an Ancient Near East scholar, a "text man" in his words. He doesn't get involved with giving opinions on persons or specific groups, etc.

    • @jesusisourpassoverlamb2145
      @jesusisourpassoverlamb2145 3 роки тому

      @@Baltic_Hammer6162 I’m sure he has an opinion on the subject, I’ll ask him on his podcast. First temple theology is based on the text in the ancient near East.

    • @TheWazil
      @TheWazil 2 роки тому

      Curious thing for you to look into:
      Is it true that almost every late 19 th century and early 20th cult was founded by women?

  • @b4its2l83
    @b4its2l83 Рік тому

    How can being delivered to satan "save" someone ?

  • @likeabellthruthenight754
    @likeabellthruthenight754 3 роки тому +2

    More than anything I desire to finish an accredited college degree in study of these subjects, instead of just being a socially odd, hardcore hobbyist in my spare time.

    • @ken440
      @ken440 3 роки тому

      you be better off socially odd hardcore. I have found it more rewarding and useful than a traditional brainwashing.

  • @JackOutLoud
    @JackOutLoud Місяць тому

    the problem with this entire thinking is that the word church is pagan and the word Ekklesia is not. Our understanding of what this even means is very from what we portray it as. You can cast out demons and heal the sick but you throw people out for having sin?

  • @garysweeten5196
    @garysweeten5196 3 роки тому +2

    Destruction of the “flesh”. Does that mean “Destruction of my fleshly ways”? Not “Body” but my sinful pursuits.

  • @pasangsherpa5769
    @pasangsherpa5769 Рік тому

    Salvation can be found within the church not outside...Those who do not go to church are lost then...

  • @robertlangford5732
    @robertlangford5732 3 роки тому +4

    However..Paul tells them in the second letter to forgive this guy and let him stay.

    • @thesmiffs2006
      @thesmiffs2006 3 роки тому +6

      AFTER he repented. They didn’t overlook his overt sexual sin and excuse it.

  • @Spartan_N7
    @Spartan_N7 3 роки тому

    I don't think that Dr. Heiser meant the Church as being the... well, the Church which we know of today. We believers are called the "church", but that word isn't the best translation, the word itself comes from the greek "ekklesia" which means congregation/assembly of believers worldwide that are YAHWEH's people.
    Other than that, thank you for these amazing insights, Dr. Michael Heiser, I can listen to you all day long.

    • @ken440
      @ken440 3 роки тому +1

      yes, an Ekklesia means a "group" and not a religious institution.
      A bikers gang is an ekklesia.
      you are right, it means the group of believers.

  • @calebstone22
    @calebstone22 3 роки тому +1

    Before they stupidly asked for a king like other nations it seems like the kind of community I long for today.
    An almost anarchy/voluntary State.

  • @prommebosken6454
    @prommebosken6454 4 місяці тому

    Flesh is not body. Flesh is the ego, and I think Paul hopes that the flesh is destroyed

  • @wk1810
    @wk1810 2 роки тому

    So, is the "kicking out of the church" and "handing over to Satan" only on the basis of sexual sin?

    • @forwardsdrawkcab
      @forwardsdrawkcab Рік тому

      It can be.

    • @GraceContemplating
      @GraceContemplating 11 місяців тому

      In Timothy Paul says the same consequence is for false teachers.

    • @wk1810
      @wk1810 5 місяців тому

      So, disagreeing with the pastor isn't grounds for kicking someone out of the church?

  • @mondesalive
    @mondesalive 3 роки тому

    Dr. Heiser: love your views sir. do you ever consult the Ruach hakodesh to help you in your views? If yes/no, kindly expand on your answer please

  • @grandpahonestyguy8978
    @grandpahonestyguy8978 Рік тому

    THE CHURCH
    IS NOT A GREEK LECTURE HALL MEETING..
    IT IS AN INTIMATE CLOSED MEETING... WHERE THE MEN ADMIT THEIR FAULTS AND THEIR FAMILIAR DEMONS...! And where the communion happens which is the presence of Christ!!

  • @radgnarsurfsk8
    @radgnarsurfsk8 Місяць тому

    So...is the social credit score system, jesus' rod of iron?

  • @brucebraddock
    @brucebraddock 2 роки тому

    The little flock with Pentecost would be the New Israel. Paul's Gospel is the Body of Christ...we are not the New Israel! I would love for someone to show me how I am wrong!

  • @margaretclarke3643
    @margaretclarke3643 3 роки тому

    The CHURCH IS THE BODY OF CHRIST, therefore it IS HOLY!
    1 Cor 6:15 Do you not see and know that your bodies are members (bodily parts) of Christ (the Messiah)?
    1 Cor 3:16-17 Do you not discern and understand that you (the whole church at Corinth) are God's Temple (His sanctuary), and that God's Spirit has His permanent dwelling in you (to be at home in you, collectively as a church and also individually)?
    If anyone does hurt to God's Temple or corrupts it (with false doctrines) or destroys it, God will do hurt to him and bring him to the corruption of death and destroy him. For the Temple of God is holy (sacred to Him) and that (Temple) YOU (the believing CHURCH and its individual believers) ARE.
    Praise the Lord for His LOVE and MERCY!

  • @lukewagner8871
    @lukewagner8871 3 роки тому

    Doctor, your Old Testament description of the day of atonement sacrifice does not line up with the description in Hebrews.
    Hebrews 13:9-14 KJVS
    [9] Be not carried about with divers and strange doctrines. For it is a good thing that the heart be established with grace; not with meats, which have not profited them that have been occupied therein. [10] We have an altar, whereof they have no right to eat which serve the tabernacle. [11] For the bodies of those beasts, whose blood is brought into the sanctuary by the high priest for sin, are burned without the camp. [12] Wherefore Jesus also, that he might sanctify the people with his own blood, suffered without the gate. [13] Let us go forth therefore unto him without the camp, bearing his reproach. [14] For here have we no continuing city, but we seek one to come.

    • @ifeawosika966
      @ifeawosika966 2 роки тому

      The day of atonement is different from other days when individual animals were sacrificed for sin. Two completely different things.

  • @akaKRANNI
    @akaKRANNI 2 роки тому

    Are you attempting to justify the statement of "delivered unto Satan" because Paul said this, or is there another witness in scripture that backs this claim up?

    • @akaKRANNI
      @akaKRANNI 2 роки тому

      @Meshach Kanyion that's IF you accept that Paul is speaking of this when he said what he said.
      I do not. Paul is a liar. He is THE wolf is sheeps clothing. He is THE False Prophet. I believe he meant what he said.

  • @essardaudinett6934
    @essardaudinett6934 Рік тому

    But jesus came to pay for our retribution. So we can do as we damn well please.

  • @CCSI322
    @CCSI322 2 роки тому

    I think I need to get expelled from church and see if I come back around. Sometimes I don't think I ever was really into it but that's probably not true. I just have a hard time genuinely connecting and plugging into a local new testament church and so I feel like I live two lives somehow as one im not sure.

  • @timkelly6496
    @timkelly6496 3 роки тому

    Your thumbnail is click bait

  • @6Strings2.0
    @6Strings2.0 Рік тому

    A building is not holy ground. Your body is the new temple. Not a building. Weird take.

  • @Unknown2Yoo
    @Unknown2Yoo 3 роки тому +1

    I find that "new Israel" description troubling. Based on what I've heard from Dr. Heiser so far, he doesn't appear to be an advocate for replacement theology. I would expect him to say the Church is the new Temple, and his exegesis would be able to flow from that in the same way. Clearly, based on Romans 11, the Church is grafted into Israel, rather than a new Israel. However, we are the Temple of God per I Corinthians 3:17.

    • @jsharp9735
      @jsharp9735 3 роки тому

      Replacement theology ?

    • @Unknown2Yoo
      @Unknown2Yoo 3 роки тому

      @@jsharp9735 Yes, it's the doctrine that the Church has replaced Israel in God's prophetic plan and purposes, and from Jesus on any mention of Israel is actually speaking of the Church. This is false because the Church is grafted in (and can be cut out), not taken instead of the natural branches, and the "natural branches" may still be added to the tree again (see Romans 11). Additionally, God has many promises yet to be fulfilled that are directly to Israel, and he would be a liar not to fulfil them. In short, in order to maintain his integrity and be a God worthy of worship, the Church and Israel must be separate entities, and God must have a plan for one individually. One hasn't replaced the other.

    • @jsharp9735
      @jsharp9735 3 роки тому

      @@Unknown2Yoo I see. When you say church doctrine, do you mean Catholics ? If not what church and what or who's doctrine ? I agree with your thinking that the church is superimposed rather than transposed. Old testament is never irrelevant to our understanding.

    • @Unknown2Yoo
      @Unknown2Yoo 3 роки тому

      @@jsharp9735 Different denominations may take the replacement position from what I've seen/heard. I hadn't specifically studied which one does. I'm sure there are synopses about the Internet that articulate that. I primarily concern myself with whether or not it's false i.e., disagrees with Scripture, rather than who holds the doctrine. If a doctrine is false or true, in the end, it doesn't matter who espouses it, haha!

    • @Baltic_Hammer6162
      @Baltic_Hammer6162 3 роки тому

      Heiser does NOT believe Replacement Theology. Not at all. Been folllowing him and his books for five years. Not sure why he chose the words since he knows how people like to jump on every misspoken word and blow it out of proportion.

  • @bobweird655
    @bobweird655 3 роки тому

    Are you a Replacement Theology proponent?

    • @Kilo_of_Milk
      @Kilo_of_Milk 3 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/zp-9zssh9eE/v-deo.html

  • @DRMSH
    @DRMSH  2 роки тому

    Don't forget to attend today's WEBINAR, March 21, at 8:00 p.m. (ET) on this UA-cam Channel
    THERE WILL BE A SPECIAL LOGOS DISCOUNT FOR WEBINAR ATTENDEES - BEST PRICE OF THE YEAR.
    Simulcast:
    Facebook: facebook.com/DRMSHPhD
    Don't forget to join the DIVINE COUNCIL WORLDVIEW - Bible Discussion Group
    facebook.com/groups/393777644878175

  • @7outofthebox747
    @7outofthebox747 2 роки тому +1

    I am Greek. It's pretty clear that Paul is telling them to pray with one heart and voice to God so that He will allow satan to effect the body of the guilty man with pain, sickness, disease, so that he may repent and stop his sin; if he didn't he would eventually die and end up in hell. This is a measure to protect the Church, give it an example to follow via participation in this measure for a member of the Body, and to help the man repent and not lose/forfit his salvation.
    There is no other meaning to the passage.
    Remember, 1)God gave Saul a demon so that he be tormented.
    2)Apostle Paul himself had an angel of satan punching him (I personally knew a brother that had the same thing...Yep.)
    --It makes sense, that Paul having such experience with a demon given to keep him in sanctification, would see such a measure something useful for other brethren as well. Think about it.

    • @yungspaghetti1685
      @yungspaghetti1685 Рік тому

      What happened to that brother ?

    • @7outofthebox747
      @7outofthebox747 Рік тому

      @@yungspaghetti1685 We are not told. Most likely he was tormented by a demon of satan so that he repents, knowing it's the prayer of the church manifesting upon him so that he does.
      We don't know the outcome.

  • @VFXShawn
    @VFXShawn 6 місяців тому

    Dr. Heiser has many brilliant insights, but "the church is the new Israel" is simply false. Israel is fallen (Romans 11:11), we are the Body of Christ, a new creation made in Jesus Christ during Israel's fall. We are not a nation to rule the other nations (Deuteronomy 15:6 You will rule over many nations but none will rule over you.), we are a spiritual body made to sit in heavenly places and judge angels (Ephesians 1, 1 Corinthians 6:2-6). Israel is God's means to have dominion over the earth, the Body of Christ is God's means to have dominion over the heavens. How did Heiser miss this?

  • @Howie47
    @Howie47 3 роки тому

    Paul only said to deliver them to Satan because they were "boasting" openly about the license they took in the newfound freedom that Christ gave them. Which as Paul said was causing those weaker in the faith to stumble and fall away. And being delivered unto satan just meant to have the protection of the Church and the Spirit of God that surrounded it and protected it from the destruction of Satan, to be withdrawn from this mother and son. The key reference for my opinion. "Keep your belief about such matters between yourself and God" Romans 14: 13-22 By the way. Wasn't Paul himself delivered unto Satan when he was killed? Don't we all still die at the hand of Satan? For which we receive a greater part of the inheritance of Christ.

  • @fatarsemonkey
    @fatarsemonkey 3 роки тому

    It's also to deliver you up to the old high priest with his pitchfork, to the kingdom of the flesh rather than the kingdom of the spirit, there is no actual dude called "Satan" satan is a description.

    • @drummerboy737
      @drummerboy737 3 роки тому

      Satan enters hearts. Why?

    • @fatarsemonkey
      @fatarsemonkey 3 роки тому

      @@drummerboy737 The word demon means a distributor of fortunes, a poker machine is a mechanical demon, because you use it to seek a fortune, you go to fortune tellers to find out if you will have good or bad fortune, to be possessed with daemon is to be crazy with seeking the fortune of self, the finger of God casts out daemon, the finger of God writes the law on the fleshy tables of the heart, the love of God is to keep his commandments. There is only the seed of the serpent which are descendants of a race of people. No flesh can inherit the kingdom of heaven, the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be.
      The demon is you without God. It is you seeking the will of the flesh.

    • @drummerboy737
      @drummerboy737 3 роки тому

      @@fatarsemonkey I don't think that answers my question. I'm not saying I completely disagree with some things you have relayed. Whether or not it fits with the entirety of scripture is basically what I'm questioning..

    • @drummerboy737
      @drummerboy737 3 роки тому

      @@fatarsemonkey for instance: Matthew 25:41
      King James Version
      41 Then shall he say also unto them on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels:
      Angels don't belong to me.. I don't think the view really fits from what I see. It seems like a clear personification. And as I previously stated that there are instances where Satan enters individuals. Revelation also has references to Satan so I disagree for now.

    • @fatarsemonkey
      @fatarsemonkey 3 роки тому

      @@drummerboy737 Angel just means messenger.
      Ezekiel 29
      3 Speak, and say, Thus saith the Lord God; Behold, I am against thee, Pharaoh king of Egypt, the great dragon that lieth in the midst of his rivers, which hath said, My river is mine own, and I have made it for myself.
      Revelation 11
      8 And their dead bodies in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified.
      Revelation 12
      13 And when the dragon saw that he was cast unto the earth, he persecuted the woman which brought forth the man child.
      14 And to the woman were given two wings of a great eagle, that she might fly into the wilderness, into her place, where she is nourished for a time, and times, and half a time, from the face of the serpent.
      Judea interbred with the Ed oh Mights around 150 BC (can say the real word on yudentube or the comment gets removed), They were never in bondage.
      John 8
      44 Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it.

  • @d3gig490
    @d3gig490 2 роки тому

    Through the church I learned the following: My life is not worth living because I am too different. God's promises apply to everyone except those who care. Without your problems, pastors and chaplains would have nothing to talk about to others. There's no place in heaven for me, because I'm too baptist for charismatics and too charismatic for baptists. I'm going to hell because I married a woman whose skirt is NOT dragging on the floor ... I was apparently seduced by Satan because I heard Freddie Mercury. I am the last of the scraps because I believe every word, live every word and experience every word EVERYWHERE except in church. The Church is not a reservoir for pedophile hypocrites, but the fact that there are people who, even though there are only two or three of them, become one and respect each other more than themselves. One of the things that keep me "alive" is the fact, that I don't want to fulfill their filthy dream, by cutting my wrists and going to hell, because otherwise I could meet their true God there: Martin Luther. ALL praise to Yaweh!!!

    • @leo777za
      @leo777za 2 роки тому +1

      @Amaliel these are heavy statements. I am sorry to hear the obvious difficulty you have experienced. I pray that someone in your area of influence will take the time to listen to the pain of your heart. May you find encouragement...

    • @betrion7
      @betrion7 7 місяців тому

      Maybe it's time to find a church with some deeper roots. Visit Orthodox or Catholic church in your area and talk to someone there.

    • @Christine-vt5fi
      @Christine-vt5fi 6 місяців тому

      Hi, how are you doing now?

  • @3r2w1c
    @3r2w1c Рік тому

    Sad to see Mike mock the flat Earth in another video I was watching. That scriptural TRUTH has led more people to repent tance and faith in Jesus Christ than any book or lecture he will ever imagine is more important than the plane truth. Plato's in Greek. Breath of the Earth. Mike needs a little counseling. Better you take a back seat and wait to be called to the front. than make your uninformed opinion of scientific facts like flat water which means flat Earth. That's just the way it is that you refuse to give God credit for and open your eyes and see.

  • @kimvenezia6903
    @kimvenezia6903 3 роки тому +10

    The Church cannot be the "new Israel". That is replacement theology. There are promises yet to be fulfilled to Israel. "All Israel will be saved", is in reference to the Remnant that God will indeed save. Unless you are only referring to 'Israel' the actual land 'Eretz' for the purpose of sacred space in comparison to the Church, you are promoting replacement theology. This should be made more clear if that was what you meant.

    • @jaysonzenden3280
      @jaysonzenden3280 3 роки тому +3

      100% agreed

    • @patrickfosterstudio
      @patrickfosterstudio 3 роки тому +4

      He's not vague at all if you read more of his works.

    • @danielamallette4733
      @danielamallette4733 3 роки тому +1

      @@patrickfosterstudio He is vague here. One doesn’t have to read all of his books to understand what he means.

    • @kimvenezia6903
      @kimvenezia6903 3 роки тому +1

      @@patrickfosterstudio I have read many of his works and love them, even I would say life changing. But, on this point about the Church being the "new Israel" he is stepping into the realm of Replacement Theology. It might be that he was only inferring that the Church is the new sacred space vs. Israel (the actual land or real estate, Eretz in Hebrew) but it is not clear, to give him the benefit of the doubt. And even then, Jerusalem the New Jerusalem will be the throne and head of the government of the Most High.

    • @YophiSmith
      @YophiSmith Рік тому +3

      Mountains from mole hills. If he is vague on the topic, let’s not assume the worst of him in it.

  • @anthonym2499
    @anthonym2499 2 роки тому

    I would propose that when we first met Paul, he was delivering Christians unto Satan "for the destruction of the flesh"; and that he never really stopped doing that ...

  • @jameswarinner9515
    @jameswarinner9515 3 роки тому

    To escape the comming doom Do Leviticus 23 on the lunar calendar as put forth in Genesis 1:14 , Deuteronomy 28. In the Authority of EOHVAH it is done. I am Deuteronomy 18:18. I am The last Prophet.

    • @dl812
      @dl812 3 роки тому

      If you keep any part of the law, then you become subject to the whole law. We do not live by the law, but we have grace through Jesus who perfectly kept the law. If you seek to go back to Old Testament law then you are responsible for the whole law. If you break any part of that law then you will never be with God after this life. Accept Jesus and his death and resurrection. Live under grace and not under the law. Read Romans and Galations in the new Testament. You are not a prophet, but I pray you will know the truth of Jesus and that Jesus will set you free.

    • @TheWazil
      @TheWazil 2 роки тому

      The last prophet: My, aren’t you full of yourself!!!
      Pride goes before a fall.

  • @pendragon15
    @pendragon15 3 роки тому

    Jesus the Christ is screaming....(Mic 3:10-12 KJV)
    it might be like this..... Gluttony has more than one form.
    "Please Don't Judas Me"
    Please don't judas me, Treat me as you like to be treated
    Please don't blacklist me, Leave me as you'd wish to find me
    Don't analyze me, sacrifice me
    Please don't judas me
    Please don't chastise me Show me just one shred of kindness
    Try to help me see, Guide me in my eyes of blindness
    Don't despise me, categorize me
    Please don't judas me
    No, no don't judas me
    No, please don't judas me
    Please don't head shrink me, Don't disguise your innuendos
    Give no lies to me, I can see the way the wind blows
    Don't deface me, annihilate me
    Please don't judas me
    Please don't number me, Don't betray my trusted promise
    Please don't anger me, I find it hard to bear no malice
    Don't frustrate me, manipulate me
    Please don't judas me
    No no don't judas me
    No, please don't judas me
    From the Royal WE

  • @akaKRANNI
    @akaKRANNI 3 роки тому

    once again, when you don't ID Paul as The False Prophet, you end up defending crap like this.
    "....and if the blind lead the blind..."

    • @bettymobley763
      @bettymobley763 3 роки тому +1

      Why are you saying Paul was a False Prophet?

    • @youknowwhatyouhavedones7044
      @youknowwhatyouhavedones7044 3 роки тому +2

      Heresy, you briefly look and decide. Deadly pride.

    • @akaKRANNI
      @akaKRANNI 3 роки тому

      @@youknowwhatyouhavedones7044 ...says the person who knows nothing about me... has no idea I grew up in church and my Dad is a retired Southern Baptist Minister, in the doors every time they were open... been investigating Paul for over 5 years as a candidate for The False Prophet... made multiple 3-ring binders slap full of notes on this....kept my mouth shut the whole time, until I was sure... amassed literally 100-200 places where Paul twists scripture... all this leading even to answering the riddle of 666...
      ...then this guy, after hearing not one reason for me thinking the way I do, nor asks, says and quote, "...you briefly look and decide." This guy won't even respond with sarcasm and ask me "ok the, what's the answer to 666?"
      Deadly Pride.

    • @akaKRANNI
      @akaKRANNI 3 роки тому

      @@bettymobley763 you ma'am, did the right thing in asking. Whether I be right or wrong, you ma'am, did the biblically prescribed thing.
      Well done... give me a little bit, let me get some kinda response prepared for you.

    • @jandshatton331
      @jandshatton331 3 роки тому

      You wanna explain? I hear this in other circles that don't understand old and new testament. I'd like to know why if Paul is a false teacher that no one ever corrected him or wrote letters to churches warning of his heresy?

  • @thejukeboxhero6387
    @thejukeboxhero6387 2 роки тому

    Michael the ones who be driven out are wicked spirits in the heavnly places which are the churches that the devil highjacked centuries ago which I believe you are a part of . I know this because I'm Geo the one u refer as geographic in your sermons I also know that you hating on me is putting yourself in the way of God's wrath.
    You seem like a smart guy let me ask you if the world hates me what does that tell you? This mercy for the ignorant and no mercy for the ones in the know.

  • @TheWhyisthatso
    @TheWhyisthatso 2 роки тому

    Paul is saying that this man has no will (spirit) to overcome his flesh.
    Our physical bodies and everything that is this physical creation ( "world " /COSMOS )
    IS OUR "ADVERSARY" ( Satan ).....because this is Satan's world....Satan's creation.
    "DO NOT LOVE THE WORLD or anything in the world (COSMOS / PHYSICAL CREATION )
    For the desires of the flesh, the desires of the eyes, and the pride of life (this FALSE life)
    is of the world and NOT OF THE FATHER.
    If any man loves the "WORLD" ( COSMOS / PHYSICAL CREATION ) the love of the FATHER
    is NOT IN HIM "
    The world ( COSMOS / PHYSICAL CREATION ) is passing away ( being consumed ) but
    whoever does the will of God ( the FATHER ) abides forever "
    ( 1 John 2:15-17 )
    THINK GNOSTIC !

  • @jackalsgate1146
    @jackalsgate1146 3 роки тому

    What does it mean to deliver someone unto Satan.? Just ask a Christian; for, they are constantly trying to win souls for Satan.

  • @robertwhitright9816
    @robertwhitright9816 Рік тому

    The church is the body of Christ, that is born again believers. Not a building. There is no such thing as Holy ground after the new covenant. Get off u tube.