I’m grateful that even after her passing Goo Hara’s brother still stood up for her and fought for her wishes to be respected. Even through his pain of losing her and the added pain of their mom’s lawsuit, he still didn’t let it break him and focused on what would best protect her dignity and legacy.
I really hope her brother is okay after that. Or will be okay. I can't imagine how exhausting this must have been. It would suck all the life out of me for yeaaaars. (or even decades)
this comment right here!!! i cannot stress how much I agree with this, because where I live, kids are taught at a young age to ALWAYS respect your parents solely just because they gave birth to you, and no matter what they do, even if they abandon you, because they had their “reasons” to abandon you.
Upsetting and embarrassing. People had to DIE for the government to actually do something about this problem that's been going on for a long time already.
I know right. AND THEY STILL HAVEN’T EVEN DONE ANYTHING! None of the laws that would and should have protected them were passed. It’s just a publicity stunt to them to make it seem like they care and they are doing something but in reality, it’s disappointing to say, those government officials probably agreed with the haters about these girls. It’s really embarrassing. The girls are gone and they STILL aren’t doing anything about it. Absolutely shocking 😡😡😡
Hara always has a special place in my heart...I listened to Kara ever since they came out in Japan because I was walking past Shibuya tower records & saw this amazing album cover that made me buy it. Rest in peace Hara my dear xx
Sulli and Goo Hara were two beautiful talented down to earth young women they deserved to be properly protected by their company from the unnecessary malicious messages and comments being said towards them. Mental health still needs to be further discussed in the Korea and other countries around the world
I can't even imagine how Hara's brother is feeling, seeing abusive people around your sister walking free must've been so disgusting, I hope he finds happiness as much as how Hara wants him to have.
But Media or Sole family members he has no contact with dont get it they see not the person who died but the money Dollar eyes money pioson the personality
I cried (again and everytime) watching the Hara & Sulli case... I've been into kpop for about 15 years and back then I looooved KARA and literally knew F(x) since their debut; both girls were part of my bias line. Their deaths broke my heart and until this day I cannot think of them without crying and wanting to fvcking punch some ppl in the face. I cannot believe even after Jjong and Sulli's death, Korean laws hasn't been changed to prevent this situations to happen again.
I feel the same. Sulli was my 1st bias when she was in FX. When I hear the update on her, I was shocked it was her comminting suicide. I still can't get over it & GooHara was her best friend & died just weeks later. So sad.
Same, I know her through hara through her friendship with jackson wang in show roommate 8 years ago. I fell in love with her and her personality. I watch over her through over years with little time I have since I was a kid with limited screen time. Just to be told she died. I wish I gathered all the money I have, learn Korean language and go to her and say " everyone loves you, everyone wish foe your happiness, you deserve it. You are the most beautiful, unique and funny person in the world. No one can replace you. No one but you. Love you".
Grow a pair and get over it, whats the point of crying for someone you dont even know. We only knew about their fake personalities a facade through tv shows. Saw Hara for the first time in Invinsible youth such a nice show but IY 2 is straight garbage. Feels like yesterday when the 2nd generation idols burst into the scene 1 by 1 straight fire and unique now they all look and sound the same no uniqueness. I am not trying to be rude Im just stating the bitter truth.
So frustrating that online bullying is not being stopped in S. Korea. A volleyball player and Twitch streamer Jammi decided to depart from this world because of it. Their stories are so heartbreaking. Jammi's mother did the same before her because she couldn't take seeing her daughter go through all this... These netizens need to be convicted of manslaughter IMO.
@@est727xx5 No it's not too far. In the US, in some states one can be convicted of manslaughter if one knows that they can push someone to kill themselves. www.cga.ct.gov/2020/rpt/pdf/2020-R-0197.pdf I think honestly that it's not just the words, but the on-line stalking. I do see it as manslaughter/murder if the end goal of the netizen is to kill. No different from pulling a trigger.
I would just blocked and deleted the comments or not even read what strangers write to me bullying gets dangerous if you get physical attacked than its a crime körperverletzung in germany
@@cassiel_07 i dont be little nothing suicide and mental heath struggle are serious matter i was once depressive with anti deeprisiva pills Tabletten its a headache and feeling empty Down a sadness without Bottom im thankfully better now
Although the laws changed in a positive light, its sad that it took their deaths for these changes to happen. R.I.P to these beautiful angels, may you rest in peace. For the rest of us who are still alive, let this be a lesson for us to be better people
Tell me why these change has come now ?? ls your President Mr moon still there or do you have a new president in South Korea?? Just ask what took so long on these changes??
@@hyacinthmcdonald3706 if you know what happen to Kim Garam these past few months, you will realize that Sulli law is useless..What happened to Hara and Sulli did not change anything on koreans cancel culture and mass bullying attitude..
It's extremely sad and disappointing that even after the passing of sulli, go hara and jong hyun online bullying and hate comments haven't stopped at all. To this day many kpop idols still go through hate for no reason. Idk how many idols will have to give up their lives before people realise that their words carry alot of weight and can literally push someone to give up their lives.
like come on why koreans are so weak? and they cant handle stress ? like even a celebrities the professor that requires some kind of thick skeen like most koreans are not confident in themselves and do not have mental toughness imagine someone started sanding this messages to Bella Hadid or dua lipa they would probable just ignored maybe its about idols start ignoring hate comments?
@@allenk6373 Saying other people that you dont know weak for finally lost in the battle of their own minds is not a wise thing to say and is very insensitive; not just for the Koreans that you mentioned but for all those people in the world who struggled mentally. Just because you dont know the live that they lived along with the "stress" they been enduring, doesn't give you the rights to call them weak. If those people finally lost to depression and decided to take such extreme decision, the most we can do as a decent human being is just pray or wish that they'll find their peace; not calling them weak. What is even the definition of 'weak' ? I hate that word so much because a lot of people always call others that they dont even know with "weak" as if they're the strongest and unbeatable in this world and everyone else is the weakest and not capable of handling "stress". "Oh stress is not a big deal, is it? It's just stress~ it'll pass. Duh!" You won't ever know what's going on in other people's lives, what kind of "stress" and troubles they face each day, what are the situations they're in that make them unable to find ways to cope and help themselves; heck, you dont even know that they had probably been strong, fighting and seeking for help; seeking for ways to get out from the "hell" they had been living in but they unfortunately couldn't find the ways. so just be nice and be a decent human being; i believe you're a strong person yourself, and a strong person shouldn't have called others weak for failing to save themselves out of their ""stress"".
@@marriageisaslowdeath well a week ago I was watching a interview of Graig Harrison he is a British sniper that was serving in afganistan and I think I dont need to tell you that p=being in places like afganistan will ruing your mental state forever but he told that he trying to live again and be happy despite how much blood and death he saw in afganistan so if person like these that survived hell can be happy why the hell these idols cant? thy live in supper safe country yes they have haters, but so many people who love them and will kiss their feets if they ask them they never been in places like Craig did so they need to reflect on certan things
@@allenk6373 sigh. you don't compare people's lives with each other's. just don't. we shouldn't do that. you dont need to put so much 'care' into "why these idols cant survive their stress" then draw conclusion that they're so weak. whatever decisions they took, whatever those people (idols and those people you mentioned above) went through; we dont have anything to do with it. its their own lives. just be sympathetic to everyone. its really easy. even if you cant be sympathetic, then ignore it. focus on yourself, be thankful about things in your own life and be mindful. my point is not to defend those idols from your opinions, but to tell you that we cant try to be "smart" about someone else's life and judge them. you cannot, i cannot. we dont live their lives. be kind.
People said Sulli wasn’t a good role model, but I think we can all agree that her outgoing nature, independence, creativity, and more are very inspiring and beautiful. Sulli always wanted to be a mother, and I think she would’ve been an amazing mother had she gotten the chance. She deserved so much better. Sulli was a wonderful artist who didn’t want to be afraid to express that artistry in ways her country tried to shame her for. I hope every single individual who harmed Sulli have received karma, and fully understand what they did to such a gorgeous human. It’s just awful and heartbreaking that Hara is also gone. They were best friends and found solace with each over during their hard times. Hara was also a beautiful artist with so much creativity, and loved being able to perform and make people happy. She was always supporting her friends, and even though she was hurting, she still tried her best to keep everyone happy. That piece of trash ex-boyfriend and selfish mother didn’t deserve Hara’s kind heart. Hara was already in a very fragile state, and once her best friend was no longer on this earth, she just couldn’t handle it anymore. Hara promised to try to stay strong and live for Sulli, and she did her absolute best, even if it wasn’t for as long as she wanted. I hope the two of them are at rest now.
This really broke my heart because the suicide took place place within the same year. Whenever I hear IU's song Eight I feel like it's written from them
Go Hara had it worst than we could have thought from that smiling face on stage. She had a good brother who cared so much. He got her som justice. Her and Sulli really was so sad they were hurt so much. Missing them always.
Sulli, Hara. You will always remain in our hearts, for the impact you made both before and after your passing. May you Rest In Peace, and be at ease. We wont ever forget you, you beautiful stars 🌟♥️
Sulli and Hara's passing made me really sad bec they are truly beautiful inside and out. All they did were being themselves and speak their mind. They are a role model those aniti fans just hate life. Korean gov need reintroduce the Sulli law. The harassment, the attack, verbally abused which all push all the celeb to commit suicide. The gov needs to care for the celeb since they made Korea famous worldwide and brought in so much money. Please so sad seeing so many suicidal bec they felt like no one can help them
I left the kpop scene for a while and didn't even know Hara passed till now. She was such a sweet person, who didn't deserve all the horrible things she went through.
In the case of sulli what really riles me up is that after her death millions of fans came out in her support, the whole of Korea mourned her passing and this and that….everybody talked about her in a good light and how they would miss her as though there was never a single hater out there to begin with. WHERE WAS THAT SUPPORT WHEN SHE WAS DEPRESSED AND GOING THROUGH HATE!?!?!?!? WHERE WERE THE FANS!?, WHY COULDN’T IT HAVE BEEN THE SAME WHEN SHE WAS ALIVE!?….NONE OF THEM DESERVED SULLI, OR JONGHYUN OR HARA NO ONE!.
The JYJ law made me remember Ailee's case. When she made a comeback with 'Room Shaker' in 2019, I always wondered why she doesn't have any music show cb videos like in Inkigayo. Turns out that YMC blacklisted her from promoting her album 'butterFLY' when she left the company, so she had to promote and busk by herself with the little resources she had at the time. But I'm glad that she's back on the scene when she had her 'Don't Teach Me' cb. It's either YMC doesn't have the influence anymore or her and her current agency had to do some legal work bts.
"History is a voice forever sounding across the centuries the laws of right and wrong. Opinions alter, manners change, creeds rise and fall, but the moral law is written on the tablets of eternity." - James Anthony Froude
I started researching the first two deaths when I heard about Sulli’s death. I saw she was in a couple dramas she was in. I wasn’t a fan of either, but it’s really sad. No one should have to go through this crap.
Sulli's case isn't completely over yet. The fight of legal suit against online hate comments is continued by a member of her group's brother group. Heechul is quite a stubborn and straightforward person, so even if it seems to have cooled down a bit, I don't think he's done with it. And seriously, having lost two colleagues/siblings because of hate comments, and receiving quite a few himself, during his 17 years in the spotlight, why should he?
Guhara and Suli, Thank you for all that you have done while you were here on earth and after your passing. I pray that you can rest in peace. I hope that the Suli Law will help to protect other idols and celebrities that deal with cyberbullying. God Bless and rest in peace young angels 😇 🙏.
The fact that people cry and beg for people to stop bullying idols online and saying that it’s not fair for these people to die, are the same ones who go on Twitter and cancel idols without any preamble or their own research is baffling to me. It’s ridiculous that people actually do this. It’s like they’re self-proclaimed judges.
Its just sad that it takes someone to die in order to change something. Like they were sacrificing to make a change... i miss them. Sulli was so bubbly especially on fx reality shows and hara on invincible youth, the laughter that she gave me when im at my lowest.. g7 forever.
Rest in peace Hara and Sulli, good people know that your suffering was unjust, we will never forget. And if there is something as afterlife, i hope you are on the best spot imaginable and happy forever.
Seolli, Hara, and Jonghyun’s deaths were the breaking point for me and K-pop. I left after that. I know I’m an insignificant grain of sand in an ocean of fans but I didn’t want to see more of my idols die because of this. It isn’t fair for them, and nobody should maintain a system that causes people to die.
Still surreal. Grew up with FX & Kara, and when they both passed away, was hard to grasp. With celebrities, we get the honor of continuing to remember them through their art. Still makes me cry.
I am so happy you added the JYJ law. I am fan of TVXQ have been since their debut JaeJoong is my favourite so I follow JYJ a bit more than TVXQ. But their treatment was so unfair, and the fact that even after the law was passed SM was still trying to black list them, this made me really hate SME for what they did, I dont hate the idols that come out of the company.
Except in 2017, declassified Court Documents showed JYJ was exposed as being liars, and that SM's Contracts were not unfair, and TVXQ was paid really well, which is why the other 2 stayed. And Investigations show that SM has not "blacklisted" JYJ at all. These Court Documents turned Public Perception upside down. JYJ's Case did change Contract lengths forever, thats true.
@@lunarsoulz The source for your information comes from TVXQ's DC Inside gallery. SM was absolutely caught going to broadcasting stations behind the scenes, preventing JYJ from appearing on broadcasts. It was in the news, and the Fair Trade Commission had to be involved. If SM's contracts were not unfair, there would be no reason to cut them to the standard of 7 now, from the 13 that it used to be, nor invalidate their contracts at the time. The amount TVXQ was paid has also improved over the years. Even after improvements, SM remains one of the lowest paying companies within the Big 4. The other 2 stayed because they wanted to.
@@predatorontheprey6275 SMs contracts were completely legal at the time, however they felt that 13 years was too long and they changed future contracts for Kpop Trainees to be 7 years. Kpop Artists, especially SM Artists (SUJU, SNSD, f(x)), signed pre-2010 have confirmed their Contracts were still the standard 10 years, because they were still legally binding contracts. The reason why they nicknamed the rule change to the "JYJ Law" because they didnt want to name it the "Hangeng Law" and name it after a Foreigner as Hangeng rightfully won his lawsuit and the actual stipulations in that Law Change were for helping Foreigners in Kpop. JYJ had to pay SM $2 Million in damages just to get out of their deal. Years later JYJ was formally banned by the High Court because they tried to pull this Contract stunt on their current Agencies, eventually proving SM's "innocence" those years ago, and that TVXQ OT2 were the "victims" who did the honorable thing all along by staying and respecting their Contracts. SM is not an innocent company at all, but they have only truly lost 1 actual lawsuit in the eyes of the Court and the Public, and that was against Hangeng, which is why Hangeng was never "punished" in any way, and respectfully still has allies within SUJU, and SM. The rest tried to go "scorched earth" against SM and their own groups, and failed, because they had no legal ground to stand on. All SM really ever cared about is Artists respecting their Contracts once signed, like any real Corporation. SM had many Artists who quietly did their thing and respectfully bowed out once their Contracts was up, and moved on in good faith. SM is the only one in the Big 4, who has Artists who are still with them after 12+ years. But no one likes talking about those Artists. People just like focusing on the negatives.
You're right - SM's contracts were considered legal, and the norm at the time. And SHINee, Suju, SNSD etc had those long contracts too. But like you said, the court did agree 13 (10 + 3) years was too long, and their contracts were then ruled to be valid up until the lawsuit was filed - this would not have happened without JYJ and Hangeng's lawsuits. JYJ had to pay damages for the losses SM suffered when they refused to do activities during the lawsuit, not because SM won. Iirc, no side "won". Jaejoong and Junsu have good relations with their current agencies. The other member I do not follow anymore, after finding out the things he has done. It is not dishonourable to want to get out of a 13 year contract that they signed as teenagers - this is something we would never accept in a normal workplace setting, and seeking to change that is not dishonourable. The fact that they were eventually changed - whether you believe it is due to Hangeng, or otherwise, is proof enough of it being too much, despite being legal at the time. Jaejoong and Junsu too, are on friendly terms with some Suju members. Jaejoong specifically over the years has also been in contact with members of Red Velvet, SNSD, and recently NCT. SM has had most of their early artists leave - H.O.T, Shinhwa, S.E.S, Fly To The Sky, most of TVXQ. It is very telling that they all left, and some have gone on record to say it was specifically because of their disagreements with SM that they disbanded, split, or left . It is the later artists that have stayed, and I can only hope it's because SM has started to learn their lesson, after their earlier artists chose to leave. JYP and YG both have artists (2PM and Bigbang) that have stayed with them for 12+ years. That's all I'll be saying on this for now, as while we do not entirely disagree, I see we will not see eye to eye. Have a good day!
it’s sad, till this day it takes a death of a celebrity for the knetizens to “talk” about the issue but then is forgotten by a week and they start to attack celebrities again -.-
Sulli was my childhood idol and now she’s gone😢🥺🥺. And her best friend pass along with her. May these idols Rest In Peace, why can’t people leave idols alone and wear what they want! She didn’t deserve that disrespect and no one does.
11:35 Even if it was passed, the members themselves would decline the offer. If anything: Their injury history will be monitored to see if they can serve on active duty.
When tragedies like Sulli and Hara happen I have the feeling that after the first moments of pain and emotion in the practice not much change to prevent them from happening again! We continue to witness the spread of hatred by people who harass idols every day , they want to destroy them and try to get inside their minds to make them feel wrong, ugly, inappropriate and if they succeed it is dangerous! Why are these abusers not seriously prosecuted in Korea? Aren't they real crimes? We don't want what happened to Sulli and Hara to happen again! NEVER!
The death of these idols give me shiver and im not going to forget it but companies have to stop malicious comments bcz we dont want to lose other lifes like them
Goo hara mum should have got ANYTHING AND HIS B.F..SHOULD HAVE GOT A LONGER SENTENCE AND SULLI was a beautiful talented Young woman, some peaple were too good for this world
I feel for Seungjae, most probably killed by her controlling girlfriend at the peak of his career and she didn't even pay for her actions..Korean law please do better!
JYJ and Jessica both blacklisted. SM is such a pig! What I will never understand is people taking SM's side and blaming Jessica for everything. Don't they know what kind of rotten company SM is.
SM did not ban JYJ or Jessica. The kpop entertainment industry chose not to work with them because they felt it would interfere with their business with SM. SM did not go around telling businesses or channels (some of them bigger and more successful than them) not to work with JYJ or Jessica. Its was/is about money and these companies don't want to lose money working with people that have problems with their business partners. This sort of thing happens across all industries not just in the entertainment industry around the world.
@@Siimwe Of course they didn't literally go around telling businesses or channels not to work with JYJ and Jessica. They were more discreet and sneaky about applying pressure. You don't seem to understand the relationship between SM and the 3 major channels here in Korea then, SM had the upper hand. The way they boycotted Music Bank for a month for wanting to do the performance lineup by chart rankings, but SM would not have that their artists always had to take the finale.
Why did government gave goo haras mom was given half of the money when she sould of not bean allowed to be given anyting at all why after death her mom came back when she did noting for her
Those are not just netizens. They're Scandal makers, making a mountain out of every molehill. I cant believe how the korean idols get treated like items. Just shocking to watch.
People who leave hate & bullying messages tend to be straight up ugly, their comments tend to be a direct description of who they are. I dare all of them to post a picture of them without filters & makeup and stop hiding behind fake names. But because they hide behind their keyboards they are just cowards that can’t and won’t be honest with the facts about the celebrity’s they attack. They refuse to stop saying horrible things about others and they should be exposed for their actions. SMH
Oct.14th is my bday & I remember the day Sulli passed, I woke up & my bf asked if I knew who this kpop idol was that just passed away(he knows i'm very into kpop), he told me her name & I started balling, she didn't deserve any of those hateful comments, miss Sulli😭
I'm honestly scared other idols will end up like Sulli, tortured by hate comments. Like Wonyoung gets hate literally for anything she does and she's still a child. Or Chan that is one of the most hated idols and leaders, I think he's becoming more and more depressed over the years
I'm recently digging up the dark side kpop has and honestly some terribly upset me. The way hara and sulli had to earn justice (well still couldn't properly) at the cost of their lives is so disgraceful. U'll be in our hearts forever queens. Also, fans need to stop being so overbearing on their idols. Considering artists as their private property, claiming absolute hold on them, argh stop it fr now.
SME has to have the worst management istg... Jjong, Sulli, JYJ all of them were associated to SME and they failed to protect these artists... It seriously breaks my heart that their behaviour still hasn't changed because SME is still not doing anything about the false accusations against Lucas(NCT)... I' so sick of literally making Lucas vanish... For god's sake SME should extend more support and reliable for their artists!!!
Not to forget jTl, the group that broke off from H.O.T, and Shinhwa too, both of whom suffered because of SM. They had a terrible record of retaining artists early on - H.O.T, S.E.S, Shinhwa, most of TVXQ. Those are all legendary groups that SM screwed up. They have gotten a little better now, as more artists choose to stay. Not to mention the treatment of foreign idols, which forced Hangeng, Tao, Luhan, etc to leave.
Sm makes me sick to the stomach, and I want nothing but misery for the ceos of the company. I can't stress enough how disgusted I am that they dont give a shit about their idols mental or physical health. I miss jjong daily. Hes one of the only people who provides real comfort to me. Onew is being so mistreated. This year, he literally paid by himself for editors to edit his "behind" videos, Dice release was supposed to be out last year, and now he said that he HIMSELF is looking for stadiums to celebrate his birthday with fans bc sm doesn't wana help him. And I've gone mentally insane with this lucas scandal. Sasaengs are clearly an advantage to sm somehow bc they dont want to help lucas clear his name. Now that ot6 wayv are having a comeback, they're not getting their teasers out (and ot22 still blame lucas for this long hiatus as if sm hasn't been mistreating them this whole time)
i honestly think BTS should serve in the millitary. All other major bands have done it and BTS has to do it too because no matter how much international fame they get...they are still citizens of korea. Also sulli and hara were so so so amazing Like I'm a 2nd gen kpop fan so i know them very well....it's so sad to see some netizens being so toxic.....
The stuff that these idols go through even til this day is absolutely disgusting. The public and the companies are way too hard on these idols. They're human beings ffs, usually very young as well.
Funny how people create laws to protect but never think what could be done that starts within the self. In the first place these horrible decisions may not even cross the celebrities' minds if only people would think and not post unhelpful, mean/hate comments. Jonghyun, Sulli and Hara were my biases yall 💔💔😭😭
Although you can understand the good intentions, it's a good thing that the Sulli Act did not pass. All governments throughout the history of the world have long exploited disasters and tragedies to expand their powers to persecute dissidents and activists who challenge hierarchical and oppressive structures. For example, post-9/11, the US government used the tragedy to pass all kinds of laws that stripped people of their fundamental rights, expanding the power of the state and government to commit all kinds of abuses and crimes-like t0rture, war crimes, etc. Imagine how such a law could have been weaponized by wealthy and political elites, like Samsung, or other powerful actors, who have every interest in silencing criticism and activism against their corporation. Already in other countries, like the UK, you have outrageous libel laws that have been used by corporations and government actors to target activists and smaller businesses. There's also the misconception that passing laws changes society. That isn't true. Rudolf Rocker eloquently said: _“Political rights do not originate in parliaments; they are, rather, forced upon parliaments from without. And even their enactment into law has for a long time been no guarantee of their security. Just as the employers always try to nullify every concession they had made to labor as soon as opportunity offered, as soon as any signs of weakness were observable in the workers’ organizations, so governments also are always inclined to restrict or to abrogate completely rights and freedoms that have been achieved if they imagine that the people will put up no resistance. Even in those countries where such things as freedom of the press, right of assembly, right of combination, and the like have long existed, governments are constantly trying to restrict those rights or to reinterpret them by juridical hair-splitting. Political rights do not exist because they have been legally set down on a piece of paper, but only when they have become the ingrown habit of a people, and when any attempt to impair them will meet with the violent resistance of the populace. Where this is not the case, there is no help in any parliamentary Opposition or any Platonic appeals to the constitution.”_
I remember an interview where Hangeng mentioned SM giving him a contract written in Korean, they didn't have a translator, he's Chinese so he was asked to sign a contract legally binding him for 10+ years when he couldn't even read it... as the first Chinese kpop idol that was only the beginning of the problems, the company clearly wasn't prepared.
Sigh... The incident with Goo Hara I remember long ago when she was getting hate about a time she didn't want to talk about something on a talk show when it was something sensitive and that sensitive thing was about her ex boyfriend and whatnot. It urked me so much that people would just blindly start hating on her without knowing her story and look what happened. That very thing that was hurting her and destroying her mental health resulted in her death. I hope all those haters realized what they've done and said and reflect cause they're part of the negative energy that fueled the fire to Goo Hara's unhappy life. This is why I would hate to be famous. It's sad events like this.
![[ENG/JPN] Inside the dorm life of K-POP's largest girl group with 24 Members! #TRIPLES](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/65dNQF5IfoY/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m grateful that even after her passing Goo Hara’s brother still stood up for her and fought for her wishes to be respected. Even through his pain of losing her and the added pain of their mom’s lawsuit, he still didn’t let it break him and focused on what would best protect her dignity and legacy.
Exactly!! he did better then me.. if it was me my mom would be dead.
We make Testaments before Hand to not get into a situation like this with wishes how to have a urne or grave
But no one knows than they die im sad for everyone children young adults teens older once who die younger than 98 or 100
I really hope her brother is okay after that. Or will be okay. I can't imagine how exhausting this must have been. It would suck all the life out of me for yeaaaars. (or even decades)
her brother is a real one.
Parents, just because you gave* birth to a child, does not entitle you to absolutely anything if you didn’t bother to raise or be present for them.
“Every child deserves a parent,but not every parent deserves a child”
@@ikiasoul exactly
this comment right here!!! i cannot stress how much I agree with this, because where I live, kids are taught at a young age to ALWAYS respect your parents solely just because they gave birth to you, and no matter what they do, even if they abandon you, because they had their “reasons” to abandon you.
@@seoshi8755
Know you deserve better.
Atleast one person (her brother) stood up for her. i see all the family wants all everything, now things change
Upsetting and embarrassing. People had to DIE for the government to actually do something about this problem that's been going on for a long time already.
sulli act situation proves dying ain't enough
I know right. AND THEY STILL HAVEN’T EVEN DONE ANYTHING! None of the laws that would and should have protected them were passed. It’s just a publicity stunt to them to make it seem like they care and they are doing something but in reality, it’s disappointing to say, those government officials probably agreed with the haters about these girls. It’s really embarrassing. The girls are gone and they STILL aren’t doing anything about it. Absolutely shocking 😡😡😡
The government usually just does this for face, but unless they execute the law, it's practically meaningless
And korean netizens are still very toxic and rude up to this day
Unfortunately that is one of humanity's biggest flaws in my opinion: we are not proactive, but reactive.
Hara has been through a lot I don’t always see people talking about her she’ll always stay in our hearts
Rest In Peace Hara and Sulli.
agreed
Even after death, haters couldn’t let her be. I hate how the industry killed them
@@sexyangel072 yea your right
@@sexyangel072
Not to mention how someone broke in her backyard
Hara always has a special place in my heart...I listened to Kara ever since they came out in Japan because I was walking past Shibuya tower records & saw this amazing album cover that made me buy it. Rest in peace Hara my dear xx
Sulli and Goo Hara were two beautiful talented down to earth young women they deserved to be properly protected by their company from the unnecessary malicious messages and comments being said towards them. Mental health still needs to be further discussed in the Korea and other countries around the world
Exactly how I feel this whole time. It's frustrating. Loosing all innocent and talented women.
I agree and their sacrifices will not be in vain.
I'M STILL CRYING FOR THEM 😭💜.
@@piyushyadav2829
We all do and i won't ever get silenced
@@gettingcalledoutontwitteri1882 yeah 💜.
I can't even imagine how Hara's brother is feeling, seeing abusive people around your sister walking free must've been so disgusting, I hope he finds happiness as much as how Hara wants him to have.
He wants his sister rest in peace
But Media or Sole family members he has no contact with dont get it they see not the person who died but the money Dollar eyes money pioson the personality
I cried (again and everytime) watching the Hara & Sulli case...
I've been into kpop for about 15 years and back then I looooved KARA and literally knew F(x) since their debut; both girls were part of my bias line. Their deaths broke my heart and until this day I cannot think of them without crying and wanting to fvcking punch some ppl in the face. I cannot believe even after Jjong and Sulli's death, Korean laws hasn't been changed to prevent this situations to happen again.
meh, sounds like the sulli law is just an attack on their free speech.
I feel the same. Sulli was my 1st bias when she was in FX. When I hear the update on her, I was shocked it was her comminting suicide. I still can't get over it & GooHara was her best friend & died just weeks later. So sad.
Same, I know her through hara through her friendship with jackson wang in show roommate 8 years ago. I fell in love with her and her personality. I watch over her through over years with little time I have since I was a kid with limited screen time. Just to be told she died. I wish I gathered all the money I have, learn Korean language and go to her and say " everyone loves you, everyone wish foe your happiness, you deserve it. You are the most beautiful, unique and funny person in the world. No one can replace you. No one but you. Love you".
Grow a pair and get over it, whats the point of crying for someone you dont even know. We only knew about their fake personalities a facade through tv shows. Saw Hara for the first time in Invinsible youth such a nice show but IY 2 is straight garbage. Feels like yesterday when the 2nd generation idols burst into the scene 1 by 1 straight fire and unique now they all look and sound the same no uniqueness. I am not trying to be rude Im just stating the bitter truth.
I did an article for sulli case in an editorial it made me realise she really had a strong opinion miss u sulli 😭😍
I know this is old but you have a share link for it.thank you.
So frustrating that online bullying is not being stopped in S. Korea. A volleyball player and Twitch streamer Jammi decided to depart from this world because of it. Their stories are so heartbreaking. Jammi's mother did the same before her because she couldn't take seeing her daughter go through all this... These netizens need to be convicted of manslaughter IMO.
Sorry but that last part is to far.
@@est727xx5 No it's not too far. In the US, in some states one can be convicted of manslaughter if one knows that they can push someone to kill themselves. www.cga.ct.gov/2020/rpt/pdf/2020-R-0197.pdf I think honestly that it's not just the words, but the on-line stalking. I do see it as manslaughter/murder if the end goal of the netizen is to kill. No different from pulling a trigger.
I would just blocked and deleted the comments or not even read what strangers write to me bullying gets dangerous if you get physical attacked than its a crime körperverletzung in germany
@@jasminkrieger8228 girl.... not you belittling mental health when the people mentioned in the video literally suffered & committed suicide.
@@cassiel_07 i dont be little nothing suicide and mental heath struggle are serious matter i was once depressive with anti deeprisiva pills Tabletten its a headache and feeling empty Down a sadness without Bottom im thankfully better now
Although the laws changed in a positive light, its sad that it took their deaths for these changes to happen. R.I.P to these beautiful angels, may you rest in peace.
For the rest of us who are still alive, let this be a lesson for us to be better people
people that commit suiside are going to hell
Tell me why these change has come now ?? ls your President Mr moon still there or do you have a new president in South Korea?? Just ask what took so long on these changes??
@@hyacinthmcdonald3706 if you know what happen to Kim Garam these past few months, you will realize that Sulli law is useless..What happened to Hara and Sulli did not change anything on koreans cancel culture and mass bullying attitude..
@@allenk6373
You can’t even spell.
It's extremely sad and disappointing that even after the passing of sulli, go hara and jong hyun online bullying and hate comments haven't stopped at all. To this day many kpop idols still go through hate for no reason. Idk how many idols will have to give up their lives before people realise that their words carry alot of weight and can literally push someone to give up their lives.
like come on
why koreans are so weak? and they cant handle stress ?
like even a celebrities the professor that requires some kind of thick skeen
like most koreans are not confident in themselves and do not have mental toughness
imagine someone started sanding this messages to Bella Hadid or dua lipa they would probable just ignored
maybe its about idols start ignoring hate comments?
for some reason Koreans have this national victim mentality
@@allenk6373 Saying other people that you dont know weak for finally lost in the battle of their own minds is not a wise thing to say and is very insensitive; not just for the Koreans that you mentioned but for all those people in the world who struggled mentally. Just because you dont know the live that they lived along with the "stress" they been enduring, doesn't give you the rights to call them weak.
If those people finally lost to depression and decided to take such extreme decision, the most we can do as a decent human being is just pray or wish that they'll find their peace; not calling them weak. What is even the definition of 'weak' ? I hate that word so much because a lot of people always call others that they dont even know with "weak" as if they're the strongest and unbeatable in this world and everyone else is the weakest and not capable of handling "stress". "Oh stress is not a big deal, is it? It's just stress~ it'll pass. Duh!"
You won't ever know what's going on in other people's lives, what kind of "stress" and troubles they face each day, what are the situations they're in that make them unable to find ways to cope and help themselves; heck, you dont even know that they had probably been strong, fighting and seeking for help; seeking for ways to get out from the "hell" they had been living in but they unfortunately couldn't find the ways.
so just be nice and be a decent human being; i believe you're a strong person yourself, and a strong person shouldn't have called others weak for failing to save themselves out of their ""stress"".
@@marriageisaslowdeath well a week ago I was watching a interview of Graig Harrison
he is a British sniper that was serving in afganistan
and I think I dont need to tell you that p=being in places like afganistan will ruing your mental state forever
but he told that he trying to live again and be happy despite how much blood and death he saw in afganistan
so if person like these that survived hell can be happy
why the hell these idols cant? thy live in supper safe country
yes they have haters, but so many people who love them and will kiss their feets if they ask them
they never been in places like Craig did
so they need to reflect on certan things
@@allenk6373 sigh. you don't compare people's lives with each other's. just don't. we shouldn't do that.
you dont need to put so much 'care' into "why these idols cant survive their stress" then draw conclusion that they're so weak. whatever decisions they took, whatever those people (idols and those people you mentioned above) went through; we dont have anything to do with it. its their own lives.
just be sympathetic to everyone. its really easy. even if you cant be sympathetic, then ignore it. focus on yourself, be thankful about things in your own life and be mindful. my point is not to defend those idols from your opinions, but to tell you that we cant try to be "smart" about someone else's life and judge them. you cannot, i cannot. we dont live their lives.
be kind.
"Those we love never truly leave us. There are things that death cannot touch."
- Jack Thorne
"Gone too soon but always in our hearts."
Goo Hara has an amazing brother
People said Sulli wasn’t a good role model, but I think we can all agree that her outgoing nature, independence, creativity, and more are very inspiring and beautiful. Sulli always wanted to be a mother, and I think she would’ve been an amazing mother had she gotten the chance. She deserved so much better. Sulli was a wonderful artist who didn’t want to be afraid to express that artistry in ways her country tried to shame her for. I hope every single individual who harmed Sulli have received karma, and fully understand what they did to such a gorgeous human.
It’s just awful and heartbreaking that Hara is also gone. They were best friends and found solace with each over during their hard times. Hara was also a beautiful artist with so much creativity, and loved being able to perform and make people happy. She was always supporting her friends, and even though she was hurting, she still tried her best to keep everyone happy. That piece of trash ex-boyfriend and selfish mother didn’t deserve Hara’s kind heart. Hara was already in a very fragile state, and once her best friend was no longer on this earth, she just couldn’t handle it anymore. Hara promised to try to stay strong and live for Sulli, and she did her absolute best, even if it wasn’t for as long as she wanted. I hope the two of them are at rest now.
Kim Sung Jae’s passing makes me sad. He deserves justice.
It's sad to think people only change when they're no longer around
This really broke my heart because the suicide took place place within the same year. Whenever I hear IU's song Eight I feel like it's written from them
It is written for them :))
@@jisooturtlerabbitkim8699 no its not
@@kittenyuuuu
How you know
@@gettingcalledoutontwitteri1882 bc I know the lyrics and it's not
@@kittenyuuuu yess it's for them.
Go Hara had it worst than we could have thought from that smiling face on stage. She had a good brother who cared so much. He got her som justice.
Her and Sulli really was so sad they were hurt so much. Missing them always.
Sulli, Hara. You will always remain in our hearts, for the impact you made both before and after your passing. May you Rest In Peace, and be at ease. We wont ever forget you, you beautiful stars 🌟♥️
Sulli and Hara's passing made me really sad bec they are truly beautiful inside and out. All they did were being themselves and speak their mind. They are a role model those aniti fans just hate life. Korean gov need reintroduce the Sulli law. The harassment, the attack, verbally abused which all push all the celeb to commit suicide. The gov needs to care for the celeb since they made Korea famous worldwide and brought in so much money. Please so sad seeing so many suicidal bec they felt like no one can help them
I left the kpop scene for a while and didn't even know Hara passed till now.
She was such a sweet person, who didn't deserve all the horrible things she went through.
Go hara is an angel
In the case of sulli what really riles me up is that after her death millions of fans came out in her support, the whole of Korea mourned her passing and this and that….everybody talked about her in a good light and how they would miss her as though there was never a single hater out there to begin with. WHERE WAS THAT SUPPORT WHEN SHE WAS DEPRESSED AND GOING THROUGH HATE!?!?!?!? WHERE WERE THE FANS!?, WHY COULDN’T IT HAVE BEEN THE SAME WHEN SHE WAS ALIVE!?….NONE OF THEM DESERVED SULLI, OR JONGHYUN OR HARA NO ONE!.
The JYJ law made me remember Ailee's case. When she made a comeback with 'Room Shaker' in 2019, I always wondered why she doesn't have any music show cb videos like in Inkigayo. Turns out that YMC blacklisted her from promoting her album 'butterFLY' when she left the company, so she had to promote and busk by herself with the little resources she had at the time. But I'm glad that she's back on the scene when she had her 'Don't Teach Me' cb. It's either YMC doesn't have the influence anymore or her and her current agency had to do some legal work bts.
"KPOP Idols Who Changed Korea's Law Forever"
But at what cost... =(
Their Lives
Their own lives
"History is a voice forever sounding across the centuries the laws of right and wrong. Opinions alter, manners change, creeds rise and fall, but the moral law is written on the tablets of eternity."
- James Anthony Froude
Thank you ☺️ 😊
I love it when you post, you always give me the tea and i love listening to you explain everything
I started researching the first two deaths when I heard about Sulli’s death. I saw she was in a couple dramas she was in. I wasn’t a fan of either, but it’s really sad. No one should have to go through this crap.
Sulli's case isn't completely over yet. The fight of legal suit against online hate comments is continued by a member of her group's brother group.
Heechul is quite a stubborn and straightforward person, so even if it seems to have cooled down a bit, I don't think he's done with it. And seriously, having lost two colleagues/siblings because of hate comments, and receiving quite a few himself, during his 17 years in the spotlight, why should he?
okay, but, Heechul is not that type of person it seemed. js
I love Heechul, he’s protective of the ones he cares about and fiercely loyal. I’m proud to be an ELF with him watching over his members and juniors.
Guhara and Suli, Thank you for all that you have done while you were here on earth and after your passing. I pray that you can rest in peace. I hope that the Suli Law will help to protect other idols and celebrities that deal with cyberbullying. God Bless and rest in peace young angels 😇 🙏.
The fact that people cry and beg for people to stop bullying idols online and saying that it’s not fair for these people to die, are the same ones who go on Twitter and cancel idols without any preamble or their own research is baffling to me.
It’s ridiculous that people actually do this. It’s like they’re self-proclaimed judges.
Its just sad that it takes someone to die in order to change something. Like they were sacrificing to make a change... i miss them. Sulli was so bubbly especially on fx reality shows and hara on invincible youth, the laughter that she gave me when im at my lowest.. g7 forever.
They are angels
😭R.I.P
Rest in peace Hara and Sulli, good people know that your suffering was unjust, we will never forget. And if there is something as afterlife, i hope you are on the best spot imaginable and happy forever.
Seolli, Hara, and Jonghyun’s deaths were the breaking point for me and K-pop. I left after that. I know I’m an insignificant grain of sand in an ocean of fans but I didn’t want to see more of my idols die because of this. It isn’t fair for them, and nobody should maintain a system that causes people to die.
It is so sad that change only came after the K-pop idols death
“What is grief, if not love persevering?”
- Vision
You are really dedicated to your user 😭
Still surreal. Grew up with FX & Kara, and when they both passed away, was hard to grasp. With celebrities, we get the honor of continuing to remember them through their art. Still makes me cry.
I am so happy you added the JYJ law. I am fan of TVXQ have been since their debut JaeJoong is my favourite so I follow JYJ a bit more than TVXQ. But their treatment was so unfair, and the fact that even after the law was passed SM was still trying to black list them, this made me really hate SME for what they did, I dont hate the idols that come out of the company.
And ppl are querying EXO-M's lawsuit against SM, Burning Sun scandal, etc. Korean entertainment industry is really dark & dirty.
Except in 2017, declassified Court Documents showed JYJ was exposed as being liars, and that SM's Contracts were not unfair, and TVXQ was paid really well, which is why the other 2 stayed. And Investigations show that SM has not "blacklisted" JYJ at all. These Court Documents turned Public Perception upside down. JYJ's Case did change Contract lengths forever, thats true.
@@lunarsoulz The source for your information comes from TVXQ's DC Inside gallery. SM was absolutely caught going to broadcasting stations behind the scenes, preventing JYJ from appearing on broadcasts. It was in the news, and the Fair Trade Commission had to be involved. If SM's contracts were not unfair, there would be no reason to cut them to the standard of 7 now, from the 13 that it used to be, nor invalidate their contracts at the time. The amount TVXQ was paid has also improved over the years. Even after improvements, SM remains one of the lowest paying companies within the Big 4. The other 2 stayed because they wanted to.
@@predatorontheprey6275 SMs contracts were completely legal at the time, however they felt that 13 years was too long and they changed future contracts for Kpop Trainees to be 7 years. Kpop Artists, especially SM Artists (SUJU, SNSD, f(x)), signed pre-2010 have confirmed their Contracts were still the standard 10 years, because they were still legally binding contracts. The reason why they nicknamed the rule change to the "JYJ Law" because they didnt want to name it the "Hangeng Law" and name it after a Foreigner as Hangeng rightfully won his lawsuit and the actual stipulations in that Law Change were for helping Foreigners in Kpop. JYJ had to pay SM $2 Million in damages just to get out of their deal. Years later JYJ was formally banned by the High Court because they tried to pull this Contract stunt on their current Agencies, eventually proving SM's "innocence" those years ago, and that TVXQ OT2 were the "victims" who did the honorable thing all along by staying and respecting their Contracts.
SM is not an innocent company at all, but they have only truly lost 1 actual lawsuit in the eyes of the Court and the Public, and that was against Hangeng, which is why Hangeng was never "punished" in any way, and respectfully still has allies within SUJU, and SM. The rest tried to go "scorched earth" against SM and their own groups, and failed, because they had no legal ground to stand on. All SM really ever cared about is Artists respecting their Contracts once signed, like any real Corporation. SM had many Artists who quietly did their thing and respectfully bowed out once their Contracts was up, and moved on in good faith. SM is the only one in the Big 4, who has Artists who are still with them after 12+ years. But no one likes talking about those Artists. People just like focusing on the negatives.
You're right - SM's contracts were considered legal, and the norm at the time. And SHINee, Suju, SNSD etc had those long contracts too. But like you said, the court did agree 13 (10 + 3) years was too long, and their contracts were then ruled to be valid up until the lawsuit was filed - this would not have happened without JYJ and Hangeng's lawsuits.
JYJ had to pay damages for the losses SM suffered when they refused to do activities during the lawsuit, not because SM won. Iirc, no side "won".
Jaejoong and Junsu have good relations with their current agencies. The other member I do not follow anymore, after finding out the things he has done. It is not dishonourable to want to get out of a 13 year contract that they signed as teenagers - this is something we would never accept in a normal workplace setting, and seeking to change that is not dishonourable. The fact that they were eventually changed - whether you believe it is due to Hangeng, or otherwise, is proof enough of it being too much, despite being legal at the time.
Jaejoong and Junsu too, are on friendly terms with some Suju members. Jaejoong specifically over the years has also been in contact with members of Red Velvet, SNSD, and recently NCT.
SM has had most of their early artists leave - H.O.T, Shinhwa, S.E.S, Fly To The Sky, most of TVXQ. It is very telling that they all left, and some have gone on record to say it was specifically because of their disagreements with SM that they disbanded, split, or left . It is the later artists that have stayed, and I can only hope it's because SM has started to learn their lesson, after their earlier artists chose to leave.
JYP and YG both have artists (2PM and Bigbang) that have stayed with them for 12+ years.
That's all I'll be saying on this for now, as while we do not entirely disagree, I see we will not see eye to eye. Have a good day!
Sulli hara jonghyun always in our heart
it’s sad, till this day it takes a death of a celebrity for the knetizens to “talk” about the issue but then is forgotten by a week and they start to attack celebrities again -.-
i'm happy Goo Hara's brother were there for his sister, and their dad to give his share to him to start the foundation
It’s just so sad, rest in piece Goo Hara & Sulli. 💔
Sulli was my childhood idol and now she’s gone😢🥺🥺. And her best friend pass along with her. May these idols Rest In Peace, why can’t people leave idols alone and wear what they want! She didn’t deserve that disrespect and no one does.
I always have fun and good memories for every Hara appearance in Tv Shows. Wish Hara & Sulli Rest in Heaven
11:35 Even if it was passed, the members themselves would decline the offer. If anything: Their injury history will be monitored to see if they can serve on active duty.
I am so glad that goo hara brother was fighting for her justice.
When tragedies like Sulli and Hara happen I have the feeling that after the first moments of pain and emotion in the practice not much change to prevent them from happening again! We continue to witness the spread of hatred by people who harass idols every day , they want to destroy them and try to get inside their minds to make them feel wrong, ugly, inappropriate and if they succeed it is dangerous! Why are these abusers not seriously prosecuted in Korea? Aren't they real crimes? We don't want what happened to Sulli and Hara to happen again! NEVER!
So many unfair cases so infuriating 🤦🏻♀️
Suili and hara rest in paradise ➕you will always be in my heart 💓
The death of these idols give me shiver and im not going to forget it but companies have to stop malicious comments bcz we dont want to lose other lifes like them
Goo hara mum should have got ANYTHING AND HIS B.F..SHOULD HAVE GOT A LONGER SENTENCE AND SULLI was a beautiful talented Young woman, some peaple were too good for this world
Damn I'm actually tearing up for Goo Hara
I will never ever be over Sulli's death. Ever. It pains me to this day and it will pain me forever.
I feel for Seungjae, most probably killed by her controlling girlfriend at the peak of his career and she didn't even pay for her actions..Korean law please do better!
Hopefully their souls are resting peacefully now…Rest In peace for them
JYJ and Jessica both blacklisted. SM is such a pig! What I will never understand is people taking SM's side and blaming Jessica for everything. Don't they know what kind of rotten company SM is.
Yeah and Jay park kinda blacklisted too by jyp. I mean he did appear on music shows nyt never at the same time as 2pm and rarely.
Jessy is anyway a nasty woman.
Thank you! SM stans are weirdoes
SM did not ban JYJ or Jessica. The kpop entertainment industry chose not to work with them because they felt it would interfere with their business with SM. SM did not go around telling businesses or channels (some of them bigger and more successful than them) not to work with JYJ or Jessica. Its was/is about money and these companies don't want to lose money working with people that have problems with their business partners. This sort of thing happens across all industries not just in the entertainment industry around the world.
@@Siimwe Of course they didn't literally go around telling businesses or channels not to work with JYJ and Jessica. They were more discreet and sneaky about applying pressure.
You don't seem to understand the relationship between SM and the 3 major channels here in Korea then, SM had the upper hand. The way they boycotted Music Bank for a month for wanting to do the performance lineup by chart rankings, but SM would not have that their artists always had to take the finale.
I miss Sulli a lot, seeing her again makes me want to cry. Rest in peace.
The people dying because of bullying is sad. They didn't deserve it.
Why did government gave goo haras mom was given half of the money when she sould of not bean allowed to be given anyting at all why after death her mom came back when she did noting for her
Those are not just netizens. They're Scandal makers, making a mountain out of every molehill. I cant believe how the korean idols get treated like items. Just shocking to watch.
Goo Ho In did what he had to. Goo hara never deserved this, may she and all the other idol who has passed Rest In Peace, we love them all.
SM still skirted the law after JYJ because EXO is stuck in their 10-year contract thanks to that “foreign promotions” clause.
I think that you are a huge fan of sulli because u also added her in your daily video and I am so happy to see that people still remember her
People who leave hate & bullying messages tend to be straight up ugly, their comments tend to be a direct description of who they are. I dare all of them to post a picture of them without filters & makeup and stop hiding behind fake names. But because they hide behind their keyboards they are just cowards that can’t and won’t be honest with the facts about the celebrity’s they attack. They refuse to stop saying horrible things about others and they should be exposed for their actions. SMH
I DISAGREE WITH YOU.
Im just thinking of LE SSERAFIM right now. If that the Sulli Act actually passed, the girls would not be in that situation.
It hurts to hear that our idols had to die to finally get justice 😢
#SaveOurKpopIdols✊🏿
Oct.14th is my bday & I remember the day Sulli passed, I woke up & my bf asked if I knew who this kpop idol was that just passed away(he knows i'm very into kpop), he told me her name & I started balling, she didn't deserve any of those hateful comments, miss Sulli😭
What all female idol is wearing now was what sulli was wear that time that they hate and cyber bullying her may her soul rest in peace 😢😢😢
SM is STILL blacklisting former artists. I never see Jessica Jung on Korean shows.
I'm honestly scared other idols will end up like Sulli, tortured by hate comments. Like Wonyoung gets hate literally for anything she does and she's still a child. Or Chan that is one of the most hated idols and leaders, I think he's becoming more and more depressed over the years
Always in our heart.....
Jonghyun was the one who open the eyes of the Netizen and others about importance of mental health everyone were in shock
my life changed when jonghyun died. the greatest thing that roamed the earth was plucked away just like that...
Sulli's case get's me teary every single time
I'm recently digging up the dark side kpop has and honestly some terribly upset me. The way hara and sulli had to earn justice (well still couldn't properly) at the cost of their lives is so disgraceful. U'll be in our hearts forever queens.
Also, fans need to stop being so overbearing on their idols. Considering artists as their private property, claiming absolute hold on them, argh stop it fr now.
SME has to have the worst management istg... Jjong, Sulli, JYJ all of them were associated to SME and they failed to protect these artists... It seriously breaks my heart that their behaviour still hasn't changed because SME is still not doing anything about the false accusations against Lucas(NCT)... I' so sick of literally making Lucas vanish... For god's sake SME should extend more support and reliable for their artists!!!
Not to forget jTl, the group that broke off from H.O.T, and Shinhwa too, both of whom suffered because of SM. They had a terrible record of retaining artists early on - H.O.T, S.E.S, Shinhwa, most of TVXQ. Those are all legendary groups that SM screwed up. They have gotten a little better now, as more artists choose to stay. Not to mention the treatment of foreign idols, which forced Hangeng, Tao, Luhan, etc to leave.
Sm makes me sick to the stomach, and I want nothing but misery for the ceos of the company. I can't stress enough how disgusted I am that they dont give a shit about their idols mental or physical health. I miss jjong daily. Hes one of the only people who provides real comfort to me. Onew is being so mistreated. This year, he literally paid by himself for editors to edit his "behind" videos, Dice release was supposed to be out last year, and now he said that he HIMSELF is looking for stadiums to celebrate his birthday with fans bc sm doesn't wana help him. And I've gone mentally insane with this lucas scandal. Sasaengs are clearly an advantage to sm somehow bc they dont want to help lucas clear his name. Now that ot6 wayv are having a comeback, they're not getting their teasers out (and ot22 still blame lucas for this long hiatus as if sm hasn't been mistreating them this whole time)
Its just heartbreaking about Sulli and Goo Hara and all the other Kpop stars gone too soon. But I still love Kpop.
The brother is such a champion 🏆
🙏🙏 :( this is just too heavy and hard stuff.. to even try to think about it and try to solve/come to terms with.. heartbreaking :(( R.i.P
hara is so lucky to have her brother that really fought to push thru the Goo hara act.
Wherever they are now, hop they are in more peace🕊🕊
i honestly think BTS should serve in the millitary. All other major bands have done it and BTS has to do it too because no matter how much international fame they get...they are still citizens of korea. Also sulli and hara were so so so amazing Like I'm a 2nd gen kpop fan so i know them very well....it's so sad to see some netizens being so toxic.....
The members have made it very well know that will be serving in the military, even if they get waived
they only changed it to age 30, so bts are still going to the military
@@Oliviakhouk yesss and that's what I love about them! They think of the nation first!
@@Mmjj07
Hero complex so weird
@@gettingcalledoutontwitteri1882 u done? 😒
Hara’s brother needs to get a best brother award
The stuff that these idols go through even til this day is absolutely disgusting. The public and the companies are way too hard on these idols. They're human beings ffs, usually very young as well.
You are a great presenter. I really enjoyed listening to you. Goodluck with your channel😊❤❤❤
Funny how people create laws to protect but never think what could be done that starts within the self. In the first place these horrible decisions may not even cross the celebrities' minds if only people would think and not post unhelpful, mean/hate comments.
Jonghyun, Sulli and Hara were my biases yall 💔💔😭😭
RIP to Go Hara and Sulli i miss them
i loved them so much :’) and jonghyun too
Although you can understand the good intentions, it's a good thing that the Sulli Act did not pass. All governments throughout the history of the world have long exploited disasters and tragedies to expand their powers to persecute dissidents and activists who challenge hierarchical and oppressive structures. For example, post-9/11, the US government used the tragedy to pass all kinds of laws that stripped people of their fundamental rights, expanding the power of the state and government to commit all kinds of abuses and crimes-like t0rture, war crimes, etc. Imagine how such a law could have been weaponized by wealthy and political elites, like Samsung, or other powerful actors, who have every interest in silencing criticism and activism against their corporation. Already in other countries, like the UK, you have outrageous libel laws that have been used by corporations and government actors to target activists and smaller businesses.
There's also the misconception that passing laws changes society. That isn't true. Rudolf Rocker eloquently said:
_“Political rights do not originate in parliaments; they are, rather, forced upon parliaments from without. And even their enactment into law has for a long time been no guarantee of their security. Just as the employers always try to nullify every concession they had made to labor as soon as opportunity offered, as soon as any signs of weakness were observable in the workers’ organizations, so governments also are always inclined to restrict or to abrogate completely rights and freedoms that have been achieved if they imagine that the people will put up no resistance. Even in those countries where such things as freedom of the press, right of assembly, right of combination, and the like have long existed, governments are constantly trying to restrict those rights or to reinterpret them by juridical hair-splitting. Political rights do not exist because they have been legally set down on a piece of paper, but only when they have become the ingrown habit of a people, and when any attempt to impair them will meet with the violent resistance of the populace. Where this is not the case, there is no help in any parliamentary Opposition or any Platonic appeals to the constitution.”_
Can we try harder
I am so sorry for her.
I remember an interview where Hangeng mentioned SM giving him a contract written in Korean, they didn't have a translator, he's Chinese so he was asked to sign a contract legally binding him for 10+ years when he couldn't even read it... as the first Chinese kpop idol that was only the beginning of the problems, the company clearly wasn't prepared.
Theres a lot of things tht country need to change. Now i rlly see wht country it is..i nvr rlly want to go there anymore.
Today is the 3rd year death anniversary of go hara.....rest in peace angel Go Hara...... we still love you♡
And a lot of people still loves korea
Japan banned wild hair colors in the 1960s,until 1996 they dyed their hair various shades of blonde,red or blue-black
Awe I’m glad he fought for his sister
Sigh... The incident with Goo Hara I remember long ago when she was getting hate about a time she didn't want to talk about something on a talk show when it was something sensitive and that sensitive thing was about her ex boyfriend and whatnot. It urked me so much that people would just blindly start hating on her without knowing her story and look what happened. That very thing that was hurting her and destroying her mental health resulted in her death. I hope all those haters realized what they've done and said and reflect cause they're part of the negative energy that fueled the fire to Goo Hara's unhappy life. This is why I would hate to be famous. It's sad events like this.
funny how these netizens like starting things soon after the idols pass away.... hypocrites to be honest. Rest in peace to all the idos we have lost