I've read much more about this subject, and here's what is clear: these metal balls are not traditionally natural, as they contain no nickel (nickel is found in every natural alloy in our solar system). However, the possibility that these tiny spheres were man-made, from right here on Earth, is entirely likely. Apparently there was a general dredging of the sea bed, and these were found. Thus, there isn't yet even any hard evidence that they definitely come from space. If they do, they are probably interstellar in origin, and in any case do not fit into our current understanding of naturally-occurring metals or alloys.
Agreed, but did they say extra terrestrial? Or just not man made. Like most of the UAP news, they usually don’t specifically say extra terrestrial, just “non-human”. I think everyone assumes these unusual phenomena are space related. I think it’s far more likely that we’re discovering intelligent entities from the worlds oceans.
I agree with ur skepticism as it's sound in logic ..... It's just more fun to think alien tech was just discovered and we'll soon be able to skip centuries of scientific discoveries once we learn to harness this....whatever we call it
Have we not established the laws of physics are the same throughout the universe? We have the same elements here as 1000 galaxies away. Meaning the process of these elements naturally occurring is the same. Interstellar or not.
@@kevinpetroff5486thats a very ignorant and naive statement. Intelligence is measured in dozens of different ways. That Harvard grad is smart in some ways, but that average joe youre talking to is also smart in other ways that the Harvard grad would be lacking in.
As a man who had tons of packages not delivered by FedEx because I "wasn't home" even though I was, I am appalled at their confidence in sending interstellar material, and possibly alien technology through them.
It’s not a matter of how. It’s a question of will. Many countries have it. The problem isn’t professors, but lobbyists who bribe politicians on behalf of billionaires and corporate boards who are preventing you from getting it. Oh, and voters who call it “socialism.”
Everything before 2020 was the prologue. We’ve been living in a sci fi movie for the past 3-4 years. The pandemic, black mirror technology, and now public upheaval of evidence regarding extraterrestrial life. This is crazy
He is saying it could be something used by aliens as technology. He said that the material was stronger than any other rock they had found, which makes it plausible that it’s artificially created. A spacecraft/satellite type technology would be made out of a strong material. The fact that it’s the only object we know of to crash land from another solar system says that’s not likely to happen on accident either. I think there’s probably more reasoning for the leap in thinking, but seeing as I’m not an expert, I might not know about or think of those things. However, the leap makes sense to consider.
Right? Who would have thought Fed Ex travels to the ocean floor for pick ups. Totally joking of course, but I thought the Fed Ex thing was pretty funny.
Dude had to try so hard not to say “thingies”…like I was right there with him “tell me about the little marble thingies” but he is a professional and caught himself at the very end, and found the word objects. Much respect 😂
Is there any doubt as to whether any defense lawyer is the stereotype of "an irresponsible person", especially "a principled one"? (For example, Mechanics are "on the other side of the courtroom", so to speak.)
@@nickbuis3307 I find it telling that the US Govt agency in charge of delivering the mail is not qualified to deliver secure government documents, but a private business is. Why do we allow the government to run anything of importance?
They found tiny fragments in the bottom of the sea and traced it to a small meteor that exploded over the ocean 9 years ago. Wow, that is a greater feat!
There was a very tiny nuclear or radiation type capsule that was lost in transport a little while back, but also makes me wonder why NASA or the Government did not stop this "Alien" material transport.........
I saw a thing where some idiotstick sent a $500,000 bank draft that was his inheritance and ups lost it. Bank wouldn't give him another one unless he put down 500k deposit as the original was still out there, and ups told him to get bent because he didn't insure it. I don't know wtf is wrong with people. If I have a piece of paper that is worth $500k, I'm bloody well taking a plane with it strapped to my body
I saw a thing where some idiotstick sent a $500,000 bank draft that was his inheritance and ups lost it. Bank wouldn't give him another one unless he put down 500k deposit as the original was still out there, and ups told him to get bent because he didn't insure it. I don't know wtf is wrong with people. If I have a piece of paper that is worth $500k, I'm bloody well taking a plane with it strapped to my body
Exactly, and I would think the more prudent chain of custody for such material would be a small inconspicuous specialized bonded secure carrier, bit I'm no Harvard scientist.
A miniature flying saucer probe breaks out of the box as he's about to hand it over. And the delivery guy runs up and trips it, saving the world from alien death. FedEx...we save you from alien invasions.
True. A proper scientist wouldn't make this kind of "guessing" available to the public without at least some certainties. He's clearly looking for some quick cheap fame...
Yep the spherical shape was not the point. If you listened, he clearly was talking about the concentrations of elements in the melted and reformed spheres that was "unusual". Nobody said that's irrefutable proof of aliens, it's a possibility that's being investigated.
@@arjun.cheeroth I typed my original comment when I was still listening to the video. If it's Iron the only reason we have trouble finding pure iron on earth is due to oxidation. If the metal had originated in an environment devoid of oxygen or H2O it could make it pure.
@@Grunt9207 he didnt say he 100% believes its from intelligent life, but that its a theory among many. in science you theorize things and try to prove them wrong then go to the next theory. hes a smart guy and its not like hes going to die on that hill if they conclude that its natural
@Grunt9207 sure . . I was replying to your original comment. also the point of the research is to look into whether there is an unusual concentration of ferrous metals which is not just iron. Iron or other ferrous metals are by no means the most abundant elements in the universe. Even if they find an unusual concentration of ferrous metals, that on its own doesn't prove anything.
Not correct. They started analyzing these materials immediately. A key aspect found was a complete lack of nickel, which is found in every single cataloged meteorite until now. This complete lack of nickel in the iron alloy found also does not occur anywhere on Earth that we know of. There is a fairly extensive amount of analysis they’ve already shared that you probably shouldn’t expect to be present in a 5 min news clip.
@@noumenon3020 The only issue is that we have yet to have any hard evidence that what they found even came from space. What information is out there does not include such evidence. So we need to determine if these metal balls even came from space to begin with, before we start to call them interstellar.
@@mattroberts86 Ah, no. Sadly, we have no hard evidence that this material is from a meteor. I've read a number of articles about this, and apparently there was a general dredging of the sea bed where the meteor fragments were believed to be located, but that is the full extent of the evidence we have for the origin of the contents found. Thus, we don't at all know if the balls came from space.
@@alexanderespinozaall the things in the Universe is God design. It’s not that ppl use the same logic. Information laws codes complexity point to intelligent mind. Always.
At least they have a physical object which they can test. Christians often say to test if it is a message from God, you have to _compare it with scripture_ . Regarding "Information laws codes complexity point to intelligent mind. Always.". No, that is an assumption. Science does not work by assuming what you are trying to prove. That's circular. You have to have actual evidence, not just a theory.
@@jdos5643 maybe..or maybe by higher live form from different dimension with ability to create everything in our universe but their orgin still unknown and might not have anything seems remotly like god design, or it is created by a powerful diety that has nothing to do with whatever god your religion is from..or other possibilities, and that is if its actually itnelligent designed..but seems that way doesnt necesary mean so, there are too much we still dont understand
Same guy that speculated ʻOumuamua was an interstellar solar sail craft. His excitement about using a microscope makes me feel he lost his marbles - and thinks he might finally have found them. 😂
Given how cynical and skeptical our society has become, it seems premature in the extreme to go public with something so tenuous when the cost to personal, professional, and organizational reputation is so self-evidently huge. All this does is help further erode public confidence in academia. Harvard needs to teach a course in circumspection and restraint to Harvard professors.
For some people, anything to get onto mainstream media is all that matters. "Elvis is alive, and I have proof" is definitely the style and motif for most individuals. Popularity and recognition is everything. Even if it's negative.
We know very little about interstellar material and this stuff doesn't match metorites that come from within the solar system, yet he comes to the conclusion that it's not natural for stuff outside the solar system? Sounds like a "I want to believe" mentality to me which is an antithesis to science.
@@soulextinguisher While the concentration of nickel in iron meteorites is typically 5-30% for meteorites that originate in our solar system, we shouldn't assume that the same would hold for meteorites that originate outside our solar system.
"We found something unusual; not sure how it came to be " = page 11 news. "We found possible alien technology" = front page news. That's some Harvard level PR.
Well, you see what happens is.. you find a guy with the adjectives “Harvard Professor” in front of their name, and it seems to automatically imply that whatever they say should be deemed scientific and accurate.
He specifically discussed not knowing what they are, and not ruling anything out. He was just saying that they seem more likely to be artificial than entirely natural, based on what he knows so far.
Avi Leob is a spook who constantly put out unfounded stuff, just like the so called "whistleblowers" are spooks. If it's real than he needs to publish it in a peer reviewed scientific journal...but watch, he won't
I liked the analogy of Voyager arriving in another solar system and burning up in the atmosphere. What would those aliens infer from its constituent materials?
That’s an interesting question. I assume the answer would change according to where that life lies on the scale of civilization. Some would worship it as a God. Some would regard it as atavistic trash.
The nearest star is 25 trillion miles away. Assuming that Proxima Centuri has a planet in its Solar System that is or was capable of and actually did sustain life capable of creating the Voyager, it would take it 73,000 years to get here. If, the Observable Universe is at least 26 billion years old, enough time certainly has passed for such a civilization to develop, if not in the Alpha Centuri, then somewhere else,and for such a craft to have travelled hundreds of millions of years finally reaching Earth. But, just because the specimens don’t appear to be natural does not mean that they were manufactured by extraterrestrial life.
The government of Papua New Guinea claims that the artifacts recovered by Loeb’s team are stolen, and is under pressure to abandon a new security agreement with the U.S. as a result.
This didn't do anything to underscore anything. They inferred information from a report. They collected a metallic material that demonstrated signs of melting upon entry and suddenly cooling as it entered the water. They haven't studied any of it with any depth other than to look at it under a microscope. He says they need to study what they collected because they haven't yet properly analyzed it. Everything they talked about was inference, speculation, or hypothesis... with zero fact to support the headline. This is a sensational headline by CBS for views. This is a sensational interview by the professor to gain or secure funding. What they found was the debris of an object of unknown origin that seems to be from outside our neighborhood. That's it.
And he was just roaming around the volcanic ash field around a volcano and studying the ash to study what exactly, impacts? Well now. Why did he go to a volcano ash flow site to study impacts? What drove him to that site?
@@xmarine73 What law says a volcano cannot melt metal and eject that? So where was this found? In volcanic ash. And there is a reason he was hunting volcanic ash. After all, where would you go to study impact events? Volcanoes? Since when?
I agree...the more attention he gets (which he seems to just love) the more desperate & ridiculous his claims & theories will get...coinciding with credible professors & institutions distancing themselves from him. 😅 Also, his mischievous grin does not help his case.
I wouldn't trust a guy whose office is filled with articles, posters, pictures of himself all over. That normally means that he's always seeking attention, and will come up with grandiose claims that no one can dispute in order to get that attention.
What is amazing is that Avi and his team are exploring ever new methods of investigating and searching for evidence and signs of extraterrestrial material and life. Avi is so innovative, articulate and determined and his work is captivating.
It looks like the typical welding spatter that was quenched when it hit the water. This would explain its hardness. Today, I was welding in my shop over a puddle of water that had collected in a dip on the concrete floor and I noticed these exact same tiny spherical droplets of iron at the bottom of the puddle. It was probably extraterrestrial. Ivy league schools produce guys like Avi Loeb and Stockton Rush.
Was my immediate first thought when I saw it too. Looks like spatter from welding or cutting with a gas axe. Maybe ET listened to it sizzle in his ear canal while he was installing flowmasters on his space ship
he said it was melted material. coming from an interstellar object suggests it may have been made by something somewhere maybe over a billion years ago.
It would be great to be able to use this material to future our own space programmes. Being able to harness this alien technology, replicate it or repurpose it as a protective layer around our space explorers and or craft would be ideal.
I think we have it they just aren't willing to expose it to the public. Notice the sightings and stuff about ufos are getting more often in the news? They are gradually exposing us so we dont' freak out to much when we find out they have had craft for decades. You can't just tell people everything at once or there would be pure chaos.
If this transpires to be bs, then his employer should fire him - we have enough noise and disinformation to deal with. Good research is published in prestigious journals science nature etc not media...so frustrating
So alloys count as technology, it got their attention because of how fast it was going, so much so that they went out and searched the ocean floor for remnants. It's stronger than anything we have collected from space so far and possibly came from another solar system . . . yeah this dude is high on his own hype in my opinion. It is special enough with just the facts, no need to mystify it further.
Yeah just the fact that a rock from another solar system crashed into the earth with a massive atomic-like explosion is pretty mind blowing, and scary lol imagine one hits a city jeeez
Noumenon (@noumenon3020) is correct. These are not traditionally natural, and are not just a metallic meteor, as they contain no nickel. However, the possibility that these spheres were man-made, from right here on Earth, is just as likely. Apparently there was a general dredging of the sea bed, and these were found. Thus, there isn't yet even any hard evidence that they definitely come from space. If they do, they are certainly interstellar in origin, and do not fit into our current understanding of naturally-occurring metals or alloys.
I don't know who or what country this prince Rupert fella you speak of is from, but this professor is just out looking for grant money or he has a book coming out. Heck! I've seen these spheres when I drop molten sand in water. Nothing new.
Because being "cool" doesn't make something sound science. He makes wild claims based on tenuous evidence, and ignores obvious explanations in favor of unprovable "what-ifs". ...but mostly because this is the kind of "scientist" who erodes trust in the process itself.
@christopherg1288 for example, ignoring the fact that oumuamua's acceleration could be explained by simple ice. Speaking on the event horizon podcast loeb insisted it couldn't possibly be ice, while offering no explanation for rejecting the hypothesis. Aliens are more likely than ice to him. Now he's found evidence of a harder than average meteorite. Instead of considering natural explanations such as a survivorship bias in interstellar meteorites, he's suggesting aliens. Wishful thinking isn't how science works.
I love this stuff, and I really hope we find we are not alone. Especially if it means we will advance as a species to get waayyyy past where we are now. Because where we are now, and where we are headed, is not a good place.
Considering space has a tendency to make things round, I don’t think I buy it. Seems like some space/pearl situation. Some kind of element under so much pressure that it becomes a sphere over time.
would be nice if the general mass-media would cite their references (or at least show the chosen expert's name in the damn video for more than 2 seconds). the world-wide "web" is just a bunch of isolated islands with each native trying to tax your attention and convince you that their island produces the best content
We are definitely not alone. Every star you see in the sky at night represents one of our suns. And most if not all have solar systems like ours.. its only logical for there to be planets like ours with similar lifeforms on them. I imagine that aliens most likely look very similar to us, if not exactly the same.
Life is an anomaly. A series of very specific events that happened at just the right time, in just the right conditions, for billions of years, to transform inorganic matter into microbes. All those stars you see are only because you are aware. For the rest of the universe, it's an endless void where nothing exists.
I agree, especially with the first three sentences. As you are an intelligent person, corrections for the benefit of yourself and anyone else reading: An ellipsis is 3 dots, "...". 2 dots isn't anything in English. But a period is the correct punctuation there anyway. Also, "it's" is the contraction for "it is". "Its", without an apostrophe, is possessive. Corrected: "... solar systems like ours. It's only logical...".
"Every star you see" *doesn't* "represent one of our suns" (only about 20% of the stars we see are like our sun). "Most if not all" *don't* "have solar systems like ours" (observations suggest only around 10-15% of solar systems are like ours with smaller, rocky planets nearer the star and gas giants further away - a surprising number for instance have gas giants the size of Jupiter orbiting _very_ close to their star, closer even than tiny, rocky Mercury is to our sun). Of course that still means _billions_ of stars like our sun and potentially _billions_ of solar systems _similar_ to ours. The bigger problem is we just don't know if complex, intelligent (let alone humanlike) life has a 1 in _10_ chance of occurring in Earth-like conditions (so statistically highly likely in our galaxy) or a one in _1000 billion_ chance (so highly _unlikely_ statistically), nor do we know how sensitive the development of such life is to even small differences in e.g. solar/planetary mass, planet/moon positions etc. We can't even reliably estimate this because we only have one instance in the whole universe of it occurring (i.e. us :). Meaning your conclusion emphatically _isn't_ "only logical" but is instead statistical speculation based on a sample size of one (your conclusion _may_ still be right of course - none of us knows - it just doesn't follow from your reasoning).
What is zero times infinity? That is the likelihood of opeople like us exstign out there, based on current understandign of the universe and evolutionary biology. The universe is almost limitless in size, while the number of coincidental accidents that occurred and got naturally slected and passed on to the next round of evolutionto create us is almost impossible. As for looking like us, that's an even harder thing to accept. Just look at the diversity of life on earth. Plants and animals share much in common, but are still very different. How much different will something that started with completely different building blocks than us look than either a person or a tree? Or a spider?
He found metallic marbles that he lost somewhere along the way. But careful, he may not be that crazy. He wants funds for a research that he knows very well has no end.
It is alien tech, and uh, is found in volcanic ash, not just mud crap on the sea floor. Well, that is a big problem, as the ash is from a volcano. Impact events and volcanic events get mixed together all the time, even calling volcanoes, impact sites. Or say, all the meteorite fragments found down wind from the Morocco Atlas mountain volcanic field. Or the impact glass tektites found near the Philippines international airport with a volcano nearby. The confusion about volcanics is apparently endless.
Yeah, I get that. And my bet is that these spheres are show to be from here. I know we're all pondering and very curious; but I think this might be another red herring. At least, in the search for alien life, we are leaning more about our planet.
Nope. Geologists and paleontologists have been studying the layers of the ground for centuries now. They reached to the deepest and they found the fossils of the most ancient and simplest creatures, microbes. That has made possible to create a tree of the interconnected living species of the planet, both extinct as well as current ones. There are no signs of any creature that had been able to create any kind of advanced technology until us. And you can see that the ecological impact of industrialization is very noticeable. So, no. No ancient civilization before our ancient civilizations. The Earth is witness. I highly recommend you a channel called PBS Eons. It's all about paleontology, the geological eras, and the study of fossils. You'll see they are serious people studying the stuff.
Ah, that would be interesting. Imagine that humanity is a cycle. *shrug* There is so much we don't know. But I DO know we are not alone in the universe. Yes I've seen them too, but close up. I have NO interest in calling scientists to dissect them and somehow use it for political use. Leave them BE, they are not hurting anyone. You don't meet someone new with a loaded weapon in your hand. Consider this: though "weapons" are big in our culture; there remains the possibilty that they don't consider them necessary or desireable. If they can fly from there to here; they've got us beat, yes? We can't do that. They have knowledge we do not. We should be meeting them with open hands and "HOW do you DO that?" Followed, likely with "What do you like to eat?" and "What do you do for fun?" Yes, I'm a simple person.
I've read much more about this subject, and here's what is clear: these metal balls are not traditionally natural, as they contain no nickel (nickel is found in every natural alloy in our solar system). However, the possibility that these tiny spheres were man-made, from right here on Earth, is entirely likely. Apparently there was a general dredging of the sea bed, and these were found. Thus, there isn't yet even any hard evidence that they definitely come from space. If they do, they are probably interstellar in origin, and in any case do not fit into our current understanding of naturally-occurring metals or alloys.
Agreed, but did they say extra terrestrial? Or just not man made. Like most of the UAP news, they usually don’t specifically say extra terrestrial, just “non-human”. I think everyone assumes these unusual phenomena are space related.
I think it’s far more likely that we’re discovering intelligent entities from the worlds oceans.
I agree with ur skepticism as it's sound in logic ..... It's just more fun to think alien tech was just discovered and we'll soon be able to skip centuries of scientific discoveries once we learn to harness this....whatever we call it
Have we not established the laws of physics are the same throughout the universe? We have the same elements here as 1000 galaxies away. Meaning the process of these elements naturally occurring is the same. Interstellar or not.
Click bait if you ask me
@@MastaShredduh
Real sure about everything, eh?
How do you know if someone you just met went to Harvard? He will tell you very shortly after introducing himself.
They are branded products
They’re also much more intelligent than you are.
@@kevinpetroff5486thats a very ignorant and naive statement. Intelligence is measured in dozens of different ways. That Harvard grad is smart in some ways, but that average joe youre talking to is also smart in other ways that the Harvard grad would be lacking in.
@@3rdreichball525 I agree. That average joe is very good at lynching blacks, raping women, and murdering gay people.
Or he’ll scoff, shake his head near violently, and say “NO, No, no, I went to Princeton.”
As a man who had tons of packages not delivered by FedEx because I "wasn't home" even though I was, I am appalled at their confidence in sending interstellar material, and possibly alien technology through them.
ikr I would've thought some Army vehicle was used to transport said Alien tech...
How much alien tech is sitting in some FedEx delivery driver's garage?
Lies again? Fight Pass Fake Professor
OMG, staying home from work because you know FedEx will deliver and it's getting late, you check outside and see a sticker on your door.. pure BS.
I fckin hate fedex.
Ugh I'm tired of this. Just give me affordable healthcare. Why can't a team of Harvard peoples tell Congress how to do that
They're too busy chasing aliens.
Because that involves giving money away which to politicians is essentially an alien concept.
It’s not a matter of how. It’s a question of will. Many countries have it. The problem isn’t professors, but lobbyists who bribe politicians on behalf of billionaires and corporate boards who are preventing you from getting it. Oh, and voters who call it “socialism.”
Here Here! Good Comment
Ah grow up, space aliens are just more fun.
Everything before 2020 was the prologue. We’ve been living in a sci fi movie for the past 3-4 years. The pandemic, black mirror technology, and now public upheaval of evidence regarding extraterrestrial life. This is crazy
I was literally thinking that too
people have already been talking about alien era after covid in 2020
I mean we all really believed in life before the announcement
No. We are living in a Simulation.
@@ibringthelastwords1358 I honestly wouldn't be all that surprised if we were.
From spherical metal to alien tech is an awfully big leap.
yeah I think prof is a kook, can't believe Harvard grants him money to study this
He is saying it could be something used by aliens as technology. He said that the material was stronger than any other rock they had found, which makes it plausible that it’s artificially created. A spacecraft/satellite type technology would be made out of a strong material. The fact that it’s the only object we know of to crash land from another solar system says that’s not likely to happen on accident either.
I think there’s probably more reasoning for the leap in thinking, but seeing as I’m not an expert, I might not know about or think of those things. However, the leap makes sense to consider.
@@spacedaze1860still a leap -could be one of many things
I agree, he didn’t really answer the question of “what makes it technological” he just swerved the question, it’s far to big a leap.
He's the guy who's been saying Oumuamua is an alien probe.
This guy got "alien technology" fedex'd to him, wild 😂😂😂
He’s lucky a porch pirate didn’t steal it😂
Right? Who would have thought Fed Ex travels to the ocean floor for pick ups. Totally joking of course, but I thought the Fed Ex thing was pretty funny.
@@BigHogg🤣
Might wanna splurge on the insurance and ship it certified. 😅😅😅
I mean I would drive there and bring the object myself n
I love that he has a poster of himself in his office
Yeees😂
And a vile of weed too
Holy crap, he does!!!!😂😂 This guy is arrogant BS all the way
Lmfao
The narcissists always do.
Aliens : throws toilet papers
Human : TECHNOLOGY!!!!!!!!
It's probably alien poop. And he thinks it's technology
@@Stalkerx13 The professor later said, "Well, it smells like technology to me."
Glad to know FED EX was in charge of the sensitive material.
LoL😂😂😂😂😂
After watching Castaway I now have great faith in FedEx 😂
Dude had to try so hard not to say “thingies”…like I was right there with him “tell me about the little marble thingies” but he is a professional and caught himself at the very end, and found the word objects. Much respect 😂
Could have done us all a solid by establishing thingies as the correct nomenclature. Definitely a missed opportunity 😂
I was literally in that moment thinking “say thingies! Say thingies!” 😆
Is there any doubt as to whether any defense lawyer is the stereotype of "an irresponsible person", especially "a principled one"? (For example, Mechanics are "on the other side of the courtroom", so to speak.)
Thingamajig
If he is dumb enough to believe in ET's, then saying "thingies" should be no surprise. Most likely he's just an agent though.
- We've got possible first contact evidence.
- Just FedEx it.
- 😮
Lmao imagine if they lost the package
Wow, FedEx it cuz it's safe to do so with your alien technology.
FedEx is actually approved to deliver classified documents while the United States Postal Service is not.
@@JamesMcNamara-j1g Buzz Killington
@@nickbuis3307 I find it telling that the US Govt agency in charge of delivering the mail is not qualified to deliver secure government documents, but a private business is. Why do we allow the government to run anything of importance?
They found tiny fragments in the bottom of the sea and traced it to a small meteor that exploded over the ocean 9 years ago.
Wow, that is a greater feat!
He actually went and got it finally. I'm impressed.😊
This is career ending material.
Should be...these days it could be launching his new career as a UA-cam alien guru & peddler of woo
Alien Medicine Man
Side note: could you imagine if FedEx had lost this package?!
There was a very tiny nuclear or radiation type capsule that was lost in transport a little while back, but also makes me wonder why NASA or the Government did not stop this "Alien" material transport.........
I saw a thing where some idiotstick sent a $500,000 bank draft that was his inheritance and ups lost it. Bank wouldn't give him another one unless he put down 500k deposit as the original was still out there, and ups told him to get bent because he didn't insure it. I don't know wtf is wrong with people. If I have a piece of paper that is worth $500k, I'm bloody well taking a plane with it strapped to my body
I saw a thing where some idiotstick sent a $500,000 bank draft that was his inheritance and ups lost it. Bank wouldn't give him another one unless he put down 500k deposit as the original was still out there, and ups told him to get bent because he didn't insure it. I don't know wtf is wrong with people. If I have a piece of paper that is worth $500k, I'm bloody well taking a plane with it strapped to my body
@@xaero76oh shut up
Most likely they would be switched
To find intelligent life in outer space, we must first discover intelligent life on earth.
😂
🤣
Yes very true, from the comment section it seems intelligent people are rare.
sounds like an einstein quote
Consider the sloth
Imagine being the FedEx delivery person who unknowingly was holding potential alien technology in their hand 😯 Sounds like a good ad campaign 😅
And like in the old space movies when he turns into a hideous creature after unknown exposure to something called Q waves!
@@theblade9024 alien , when that thing jumped on buddies face
That was my sperm
Exactly, and I would think the more prudent chain of custody for such material would be a small inconspicuous specialized bonded secure carrier, bit I'm no Harvard scientist.
A miniature flying saucer probe breaks out of the box as he's about to hand it over. And the delivery guy runs up and trips it, saving the world from alien death.
FedEx...we save you from alien invasions.
It's the smirk on his face that kind of gives him away.
I think Harvard needs to up their standards
lol too many woke people
Harvard . Suspect right there. A regular marble identifying as a interstellar rock.
True. A proper scientist wouldn't make this kind of "guessing" available to the public without at least some certainties. He's clearly looking for some quick cheap fame...
Forget Avi and Harvard - CBS News needs to up their journalistic standards.
Yeah, this guy talks like a grant money ambulance chaser
Doesn't liquid metal when rapidly cooled in water form spherical shapes?
Yep the spherical shape was not the point. If you listened, he clearly was talking about the concentrations of elements in the melted and reformed spheres that was "unusual". Nobody said that's irrefutable proof of aliens, it's a possibility that's being investigated.
@@arjun.cheeroth I typed my original comment when I was still listening to the video.
If it's Iron the only reason we have trouble finding pure iron on earth is due to oxidation. If the metal had originated in an environment devoid of oxygen or H2O it could make it pure.
@@Grunt9207 he didnt say he 100% believes its from intelligent life, but that its a theory among many. in science you theorize things and try to prove them wrong then go to the next theory. hes a smart guy and its not like hes going to die on that hill if they conclude that its natural
@Grunt9207 sure . . I was replying to your original comment. also the point of the research is to look into whether there is an unusual concentration of ferrous metals which is not just iron. Iron or other ferrous metals are by no means the most abundant elements in the universe. Even if they find an unusual concentration of ferrous metals, that on its own doesn't prove anything.
@@arjun.cheerothoh those mysterious elements that have yet to be named
Avi dragged magnets on the sea floor, marbles found,
Baby Alien's tears, marbles lost in the deep.
So basically they have no clue what it is because they haven’t analyzed it yet
Not correct. They started analyzing these materials immediately. A key aspect found was a complete lack of nickel, which is found in every single cataloged meteorite until now. This complete lack of nickel in the iron alloy found also does not occur anywhere on Earth that we know of. There is a fairly extensive amount of analysis they’ve already shared that you probably shouldn’t expect to be present in a 5 min news clip.
@@noumenon3020 Thank you sir.
@@noumenon3020 The only issue is that we have yet to have any hard evidence that what they found even came from space. What information is out there does not include such evidence. So we need to determine if these metal balls even came from space to begin with, before we start to call them interstellar.
@Ahjile from a meteor that fell in 2014, so yes from space.
@@mattroberts86 Ah, no. Sadly, we have no hard evidence that this material is from a meteor. I've read a number of articles about this, and apparently there was a general dredging of the sea bed where the meteor fragments were believed to be located, but that is the full extent of the evidence we have for the origin of the contents found. Thus, we don't at all know if the balls came from space.
Secret agents outside his house: we found alien technology
Remember the first rule of exobiology. It's never aliens until it's aliens.
You should simply ask my wife. She thinks she knows everything.
😂
😂😂😂😂🤭🤭🤭🤭
"I don't understand something then it could be alien technology" is wishful thinking.
Well, it "could" be. This interview however, wasn't at all convincing.
People love using the same logic for god existing
@@alexanderespinozaall the things in the Universe is God design. It’s not that ppl use the same logic. Information laws codes complexity point to intelligent mind. Always.
At least they have a physical object which they can test. Christians often say to test if it is a message from God, you have to _compare it with scripture_ .
Regarding "Information laws codes complexity point to intelligent mind. Always.". No, that is an assumption. Science does not work by assuming what you are trying to prove. That's circular. You have to have actual evidence, not just a theory.
@@jdos5643 maybe..or maybe by higher live form from different dimension with ability to create everything in our universe but their orgin still unknown and might not have anything seems remotly like god design, or it is created by a powerful diety that has nothing to do with whatever god your religion is from..or other possibilities, and that is if its actually itnelligent designed..but seems that way doesnt necesary mean so, there are too much we still dont understand
Imagine being the fedex person delivering alien technology unknowingly haha
I think it’s a huge leap to just even say it may be technological. He wanted his face on tv. Twice actually.
And he wanted to tell us he’s a Harvard professor.
Quite the leap to alien technology there doc.
His career is over.
@@cstuartdcclearly listening is not your best quality.
Leaps are necessary in science given that he’s commenting based on the data so far.
I think about how they dropped liquid lead from towers during the civil war to make musket balls. Yes in free fall liquid metal cools into spheres.
Same guy that speculated ʻOumuamua was an interstellar solar sail craft. His excitement about using a microscope makes me feel he lost his marbles - and thinks he might finally have found them. 😂
Given how cynical and skeptical our society has become, it seems premature in the extreme to go public with something so tenuous when the cost to personal, professional, and organizational reputation is so self-evidently huge. All this does is help further erode public confidence in academia. Harvard needs to teach a course in circumspection and restraint to Harvard professors.
There should be no confidence in government academia. It's designed to brainwash and enslave you.
For some people, anything to get onto mainstream media is all that matters. "Elvis is alive, and I have proof" is definitely the style and motif for most individuals. Popularity and recognition is everything. Even if it's negative.
😂😂
The dude is just another guy trying to get rich off sensationalizing a subject. He's the Harvard version of Billy Mays.
He did the same thing with sensationalizing the oumuamua comet and claiming that was also alien technology.
So there is absolutely no reason to think that this is anything unnatural at all
There is no reason to believe some goober in the comment section that its not.
We know very little about interstellar material and this stuff doesn't match metorites that come from within the solar system, yet he comes to the conclusion that it's not natural for stuff outside the solar system? Sounds like a "I want to believe" mentality to me which is an antithesis to science.
it's because they contain no nickel
@@soulextinguisher While the concentration of nickel in iron meteorites is typically 5-30% for meteorites that originate in our solar system, we shouldn't assume that the same would hold for meteorites that originate outside our solar system.
Your statement is exactly why the public education system needs to be ended. Basic science is dead.
Why not mass spec the samples? And links to the scientific journal of this research, please.
"We found something unusual; not sure how it came to be " = page 11 news.
"We found possible alien technology" = front page news.
That's some Harvard level PR.
They have to come up with fresh, new, crazy ideas to justify their exorbitant tuition!
How do you go from unknown material to concluding it's alien tech, exactly? Have they conclusively ruled out other possibilities?
They haven't concluded
Well, you see what happens is.. you find a guy with the adjectives “Harvard Professor” in front of their name, and it seems to automatically imply that whatever they say should be deemed scientific and accurate.
@@HiThisIsMineall hail the Meritocracy!
He specifically discussed not knowing what they are, and not ruling anything out. He was just saying that they seem more likely to be artificial than entirely natural, based on what he knows so far.
Avi Leob is a spook who constantly put out unfounded stuff, just like the so called "whistleblowers" are spooks.
If it's real than he needs to publish it in a peer reviewed scientific journal...but watch, he won't
When I closed my eyes , I felt that it was Gru from the film talking about aliens 😂 . That’s convincing
I can imagine the aliens laughing at us in case those spheres where like the trash they throw out of their ships.
Alien kidney stones
alien hairballs.. AREN'T EVEN HAIR 👽
Cybernetic dingleberries
one's trash is another's treasure :p
Lol space poop.
I dont trust Fedex with my sneakers. This guy sent interstellar space material through Fedex 😂
Alien dad: Son, we found your marbles. its with those pesky humans.
A Harvard education isn't what it used to be
Says the smart person comment on youtube
@@WildlifeWarrior-cr1kkimagine defending these quacks. 🤡
you are completely right, I know an idiot who goes to Harvard
I know absolute geniuses who go to North Carolina and Michigan
@@epimoni5705 Imagine being a flatearther. 🤡
@@epimoni5705 Imagine using a stupid clown emoji
I liked the analogy of Voyager arriving in another solar system and burning up in the atmosphere.
What would those aliens infer from its constituent materials?
That’s an interesting question. I assume the answer would change according to where that life lies on the scale of civilization.
Some would worship it as a God. Some would regard it as atavistic trash.
Twinkie remnants 🤣
Maybe their government would try to dismiss it as "homemade"
@@shobitz For sure those Aliens would be sceptical about aliens!
The nearest star is 25 trillion miles away. Assuming that Proxima Centuri has a planet in its Solar System that is or was capable of and actually did sustain life capable of creating the Voyager, it would take it 73,000 years to get here. If, the Observable Universe is at least 26 billion years old, enough time certainly has passed for such a civilization to develop, if not in the Alpha Centuri, then somewhere else,and for such a craft to have travelled hundreds of millions of years finally reaching Earth.
But, just because the specimens don’t appear to be natural does not mean that they were manufactured by extraterrestrial life.
The government of Papua New Guinea claims that the artifacts recovered by Loeb’s team are stolen, and is under pressure to abandon a new security agreement with the U.S. as a result.
He needs to go back to Harvard for a few years.
Wow! This finding underscores the importance of scientific discovery and exploration and education.
Yes, but this professor could be holding an incurable disease in a bottle in his room. Very dangerous.
This didn't do anything to underscore anything.
They inferred information from a report. They collected a metallic material that demonstrated signs of melting upon entry and suddenly cooling as it entered the water. They haven't studied any of it with any depth other than to look at it under a microscope. He says they need to study what they collected because they haven't yet properly analyzed it. Everything they talked about was inference, speculation, or hypothesis... with zero fact to support the headline.
This is a sensational headline by CBS for views. This is a sensational interview by the professor to gain or secure funding.
What they found was the debris of an object of unknown origin that seems to be from outside our neighborhood. That's it.
And he was just roaming around the volcanic ash field around a volcano and studying the ash to study what exactly, impacts? Well now. Why did he go to a volcano ash flow site to study impacts? What drove him to that site?
@@xmarine73 What law says a volcano cannot melt metal and eject that? So where was this found? In volcanic ash. And there is a reason he was hunting volcanic ash. After all, where would you go to study impact events? Volcanoes? Since when?
@@xmarine73 What metal debris, exactly? Oh, he does not say.
Wow. What utter twaddle. Thanks, @CBS.
This is getting interesting...I like how excited the guy is about it.
I feel really sorry for Harvard University...What an embarrasment this guy must be😮
I agree...the more attention he gets (which he seems to just love) the more desperate & ridiculous his claims & theories will get...coinciding with credible professors & institutions distancing themselves from him.
😅
Also, his mischievous grin does not help his case.
Nope. Just balls of metal.
This is the same chap who said the 'Oumuamua' asteroid was an alien spacecraft?
If nothing else, I admire his imagination.
He's in the publicity game, nothing more. He's an embarrassment.
Oumuamua was an interstellar object and still hasn’t been identified conclusively as an asteroid, therefore making it alien in nature.
@@ArL467
We don’t have answers
Therefore…answer.
Where did they get him from? I want to get paid for playing with sea glass, I mean alien artifacts.
It’s true. I’m an alien and I’ve lost my marbles.
I wouldn't trust a guy whose office is filled with articles, posters, pictures of himself all over. That normally means that he's always seeking attention, and will come up with grandiose claims that no one can dispute in order to get that attention.
Aliens are gonna hate us so much, lol....
If aliens had pets, their poop would be amazing to us....
What is amazing is that Avi and his team are exploring ever new methods of investigating and searching for evidence and signs of extraterrestrial material and life. Avi is so innovative, articulate and determined and his work is captivating.
(examines under a microscope) "Another Fine Product of Sirius Cybernetics Corporation"
Laughingstock
Space balls!
This guy has balls
Except he doesn't know what they are 😮
And he doesn't know what they are for😮
Sounds like nothing but speculation and wishful thinking.
If you actually watch its not speculation on the data they have
I love how the U.S. government finds alien tech and amplifies it into warfare military use
"Everybody don't worry about it, just a weather balloon there are no aliens here to see. Move On...." - US Pentagon
It looks like the typical welding spatter that was quenched when it hit the water. This would explain its hardness. Today, I was welding in my shop over a puddle of water that had collected in a dip on the concrete floor and I noticed these exact same tiny spherical droplets of iron at the bottom of the puddle. It was probably extraterrestrial. Ivy league schools produce guys like Avi Loeb and Stockton Rush.
Was my immediate first thought when I saw it too. Looks like spatter from welding or cutting with a gas axe. Maybe ET listened to it sizzle in his ear canal while he was installing flowmasters on his space ship
he said it was melted material. coming from an interstellar object suggests it may have been made by something somewhere maybe over a billion years ago.
It would be great to be able to use this material to future our own space programmes. Being able to harness this alien technology, replicate it or repurpose it as a protective layer around our space explorers and or craft would be ideal.
I think we have it they just aren't willing to expose it to the public. Notice the sightings and stuff about ufos are getting more often in the news? They are gradually exposing us so we dont' freak out to much when we find out they have had craft for decades. You can't just tell people everything at once or there would be pure chaos.
My question is: what kind of “technology” is it? A tracking g chip, weapon, or just some type of alloy?
Melted iron
Space Ben Wa Balls! Don't kink-shame me!
Apparently just an alloy, at most.
If this transpires to be bs, then his employer should fire him - we have enough noise and disinformation to deal with. Good research is published in prestigious journals science nature etc not media...so frustrating
Harvard professor + found aliens = Avi Loeb. You'd think that they would have disowned him by now.
Shout out to FEDEX for not miss placing the package lol.
it could just be a very rare rock from the early universe. it beat all the odds and made it to us.
Translation: We are running out of funding for needless research, so "This might be alien technology".
That's it exactly $$$ cha ching😅
So where’s the results? Still waiting…
How is this not making bigger news?! These finding are big deals!!
“Oh my gods it’s full of stars “✨
Yep
Lol He used Fed Ex to ship it. 😂😂
So alloys count as technology, it got their attention because of how fast it was going, so much so that they went out and searched the ocean floor for remnants.
It's stronger than anything we have collected from space so far and possibly came from another solar system . . . yeah this dude is high on his own hype in my opinion.
It is special enough with just the facts, no need to mystify it further.
Absolutely agree
Yeah just the fact that a rock from another solar system crashed into the earth with a massive atomic-like explosion is pretty mind blowing, and scary lol imagine one hits a city jeeez
@@blakeross9556 The Tunguska one would have hit St Petersburg if it came in a few hours later lol
The guy said US Goverment way too many times to be an independent scientist.
4:23 he says, from Havard Universitor. 🙂
It’s just a metallic meteor that went through the Prince Rupert effect.
Prince Rupert effect would explain the shapes found but not the unique alloy composition of these fragments.
Noumenon (@noumenon3020) is correct. These are not traditionally natural, and are not just a metallic meteor, as they contain no nickel. However, the possibility that these spheres were man-made, from right here on Earth, is just as likely. Apparently there was a general dredging of the sea bed, and these were found. Thus, there isn't yet even any hard evidence that they definitely come from space. If they do, they are certainly interstellar in origin, and do not fit into our current understanding of naturally-occurring metals or alloys.
I don't know who or what country this prince Rupert fella you speak of is from, but this professor is just out looking for grant money or he has a book coming out. Heck! I've seen these spheres when I drop molten sand in water. Nothing new.
As a state college graduate my theory is that these are pieces of metallic junk that the ocean currents have ground down to little spheres.
And that logic would definitely prove you are going to a state college.
BRILLIANT!
It was such gtreat fun to see the smile of overwhelming pleasure and pride on the Prof to be telling you what he is telling you!
"Soooo..we have this alien technology, aaaand you want me to post it with Fedex?"......"yep. It'll be fine"
don't underestimate an alien's desire for a small metal ball
How can you not like Avi Loeb. His umuamua hypothesis is so cool
Because being "cool" doesn't make something sound science.
He makes wild claims based on tenuous evidence, and ignores obvious explanations in favor of unprovable "what-ifs".
...but mostly because this is the kind of "scientist" who erodes trust in the process itself.
@@xjunkxyrdxdog89 what obvious explanations might these be.
@christopherg1288 for example, ignoring the fact that oumuamua's acceleration could be explained by simple ice. Speaking on the event horizon podcast loeb insisted it couldn't possibly be ice, while offering no explanation for rejecting the hypothesis.
Aliens are more likely than ice to him.
Now he's found evidence of a harder than average meteorite. Instead of considering natural explanations such as a survivorship bias in interstellar meteorites, he's suggesting aliens.
Wishful thinking isn't how science works.
i use those things to for fishing, it keeps tension between the hook and the bobber.
Damn aliens better not fish to close or I’m casting a lure into their boat 😂
I love this stuff, and I really hope we find we are not alone. Especially if it means we will advance as a species to get waayyyy past where we are now. Because where we are now, and where we are headed, is not a good place.
❤ I agree with you
Won’t help unless people change their attitude about each other
its been know for thousands of years why do you need the NEWS media to aknowledge it their the 4th branch of goverment
Let's hope the aliens are not hostile lol
@@WhySoSeriousHmmm only some species operate on the physical plane and lower planes but ya I'd rather be free of those entities
Considering space has a tendency to make things round, I don’t think I buy it. Seems like some space/pearl situation. Some kind of element under so much pressure that it becomes a sphere over time.
Avi is the personification of the „It was Aliens“ meme better than the „It was Aliens“ guy.
Was there any doubt that it would JUST SO HAPPEN to be Avi Loeb's research team that JUST SO HAPPENED to "discover alien technology"?
It seems to be a case of "I don't know, therefore aliens".
Who else is doing this level of field research with this level of funding and technology? Oh right, no one. Literally no one.
@@corwinzelazney5312 Maybe there's a reason for that, champ. 😉
Niel Patrick Harris does news? 😮 Also, that guy providing commentary is a G for doing the interview with TWO pictures of himself in the background.
We are not alone....we are surrounded by demons pretending to be aliens.😅
It’s safe to say that professor has become alien technology.
"This object was moving faster than 95% of all stars in the vicinity of the sun?" After that single statement, I'm out..
Very neat!
would be nice if the general mass-media would cite their references (or at least show the chosen expert's name in the damn video for more than 2 seconds). the world-wide "web" is just a bunch of isolated islands with each native trying to tax your attention and convince you that their island produces the best content
His name is Avi Loab. They mentioned it a couple times. Also displayed it a couple times. There's also a back button and pause. As well as Google..
@@guitarandmore69 ...and i quote "show...for more than 2 seconds"
@@arizvisa If you can't figure out how to get/use this guys name, you have bigger problems than correcting semantics...
@@guitarandmore69 not correcting the semantics of my text (as it's pretty clear), simply highlighting the parts that you misread.
@@arizvisa Ok. Lol
We are definitely not alone. Every star you see in the sky at night represents one of our suns. And most if not all have solar systems like ours.. its only logical for there to be planets like ours with similar lifeforms on them. I imagine that aliens most likely look very similar to us, if not exactly the same.
Life is an anomaly. A series of very specific events that happened at just the right time, in just the right conditions, for billions of years, to transform inorganic matter into microbes. All those stars you see are only because you are aware. For the rest of the universe, it's an endless void where nothing exists.
I agree, especially with the first three sentences. As you are an intelligent person, corrections for the benefit of yourself and anyone else reading:
An ellipsis is 3 dots, "...". 2 dots isn't anything in English. But a period is the correct punctuation there anyway. Also, "it's" is the contraction for "it is". "Its", without an apostrophe, is possessive.
Corrected: "... solar systems like ours. It's only logical...".
"Every star you see" *doesn't* "represent one of our suns" (only about 20% of the stars we see are like our sun).
"Most if not all" *don't* "have solar systems like ours" (observations suggest only around 10-15% of solar systems are like ours with smaller, rocky planets nearer the star and gas giants further away - a surprising number for instance have gas giants the size of Jupiter orbiting _very_ close to their star, closer even than tiny, rocky Mercury is to our sun).
Of course that still means _billions_ of stars like our sun and potentially _billions_ of solar systems _similar_ to ours. The bigger problem is we just don't know if complex, intelligent (let alone humanlike) life has a 1 in _10_ chance of occurring in Earth-like conditions (so statistically highly likely in our galaxy) or a one in _1000 billion_ chance (so highly _unlikely_ statistically), nor do we know how sensitive the development of such life is to even small differences in e.g. solar/planetary mass, planet/moon positions etc. We can't even reliably estimate this because we only have one instance in the whole universe of it occurring (i.e. us :).
Meaning your conclusion emphatically _isn't_ "only logical" but is instead statistical speculation based on a sample size of one (your conclusion _may_ still be right of course - none of us knows - it just doesn't follow from your reasoning).
We only have one sun. What he meant is, "Every star you see in the sky at night is a representation of our sun."
What is zero times infinity? That is the likelihood of opeople like us exstign out there, based on current understandign of the universe and evolutionary biology. The universe is almost limitless in size, while the number of coincidental accidents that occurred and got naturally slected and passed on to the next round of evolutionto create us is almost impossible. As for looking like us, that's an even harder thing to accept. Just look at the diversity of life on earth. Plants and animals share much in common, but are still very different. How much different will something that started with completely different building blocks than us look than either a person or a tree? Or a spider?
"Came from a meteor" "We fished with a magnet"
He found metallic marbles that he lost somewhere along the way. But careful, he may not be that crazy. He wants funds for a research that he knows very well has no end.
Exactly as I have said all along $$$ cha ching...😅
Fake
It is alien tech, and uh, is found in volcanic ash, not just mud crap on the sea floor. Well, that is a big problem, as the ash is from a volcano. Impact events and volcanic events get mixed together all the time, even calling volcanoes, impact sites. Or say, all the meteorite fragments found down wind from the Morocco Atlas mountain volcanic field. Or the impact glass tektites found near the Philippines international airport with a volcano nearby. The confusion about volcanics is apparently endless.
Yeah, I get that. And my bet is that these spheres are show to be from here. I know we're all pondering and very curious; but I think this might be another red herring. At least, in the search for alien life, we are leaning more about our planet.
This video has been renamed to " professor from once respected university admits to being completely insane"
😂😂😂
i'll never get these 3 minutes back
Key word "MAY", Watch it be some interstellar alien poop 😂😊
Its possible this couldve been space junk from a previous, long gone (universally speaking) civilization.
yes it is possible. could be many other possibilities though
Nope. Geologists and paleontologists have been studying the layers of the ground for centuries now. They reached to the deepest and they found the fossils of the most ancient and simplest creatures, microbes. That has made possible to create a tree of the interconnected living species of the planet, both extinct as well as current ones. There are no signs of any creature that had been able to create any kind of advanced technology until us. And you can see that the ecological impact of industrialization is very noticeable.
So, no. No ancient civilization before our ancient civilizations. The Earth is witness. I highly recommend you a channel called PBS Eons. It's all about paleontology, the geological eras, and the study of fossils. You'll see they are serious people studying the stuff.
@@pondlakesnope
Just imagine how that would change how we view the universe lmao
Ah, that would be interesting. Imagine that humanity is a cycle. *shrug* There is so much we don't know. But I DO know we are not alone in the universe. Yes I've seen them too, but close up. I have NO interest in calling scientists to dissect them and somehow use it for political use. Leave them BE, they are not hurting anyone. You don't meet someone new with a loaded weapon in your hand. Consider this: though "weapons" are big in our culture; there remains the possibilty that they don't consider them necessary or desireable. If they can fly from there to here; they've got us beat, yes? We can't do that. They have knowledge we do not. We should be meeting them with open hands and "HOW do you DO that?" Followed, likely with "What do you like to eat?" and "What do you do for fun?" Yes, I'm a simple person.