I Paid Game Developers on Fiverr to Make the Same Game
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Start your free trial on GameMaker Studio 2 here: opr.as/BadGameDev
Thanks to YoYo Games for sponsoring the video!
I Paid Game Developers on Fiverr to Make the Same Game
In this video, I pay three different Game Developers on Fiverr to make the same game. I send all game developers the same game brief, and they try to make the same game in this Fiverr Game Development challenge.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
My Patreon:
/ badgamedev
Follow Me:
TikTok: / badgamedevyt
Dragon Ball Channel: / maddbz
Minecraft Channel: / madmaker7
Twitter: / badgamedevyt
Instagram: / badgamedevyt
Contact: badgamedevbusiness@gmail.com
Start your free trial on GameMaker Studio 2 here: opr.as/BadGameDev
Thank you guys for watching the video!
Can I expand my expired trial there?
I will post on fiver to make a game 2d simple, for 1$, cause i new user on fiver and beginner of game development 😁🙏🙏
Check out core engine bro.
@@spoon8994 hehe yaa :(, i set 5 dollars on fiverr, but without fiverr, i can make for 1 dollars😅
Any chance you might be able to let us know who the artists are? I'd love to hire the creator of the 2nd game for a project.
That second game was really good honestly
honestly, even the first game is worth a little more than 10$ (not talking about copy-paste the same idea over and over,but as is , it's worth a little more, maybe like 15-20$)
for the second game, u can notice the nice art style,its simple but u can tell it's made by an expert artist that gave u what u paid for, even more, and u can notice the colors has been chosen wisely, also u can tell he could make the gameplay smoother but he didn't, for that price, it's worth at least $45
lastly, for the last game, he is a good creative programmer, but not an artist, the game mechanism is more complicated compared to the last 2 games,he is not an expert artist, even so, he is smart bcz he knows how to make a good simple design with no effort or advanced art skills
i think they used free art assets from the internet but yeah it actually had meaningful level generation and points so it’s good
The second one definitely worth more than 10 $ you are right
The second game is maybe too good for 10$ and one week of work.
Everything is way too polished, I mean he implemented :
A really great procedural generation for the map generator
Animation on basically everything which needs a lot of time to polish
Effing parallax scrolling for the background
A fully fledged UI system that seems to be working
I really doubt that the game was made in one week by one person from scratch, either he started with an already existing project and tweaking some things or he is a god of game jams.
Wanted to like your comment, but it's at "666".. But I definitely agree! It looks fun.
2nd developer should charge WAY more than 10 bucks
fr
Every one of them should charge way more
@@NaejDoree The reality of fiverr is: you simply can't charge more since there are many other talented people charging pennies for their work, usually from Pakistan or India. Fiverr is just horrible.
@@juliand3565 depends where you live,i get paid ~1250€ net every month at my job. 45$/h is 7200 a month with a 40hrs week job... That's a fuckin lot.
@@juliand3565 and that's the problem,for YOUR area. My gross salary is 1650€.
I feel bad for the 2nd game dev, for only being paid 10 bucks.
You really are the BadGameDev.
they accepted it :shrug:
@@randomperson-wx5do yt emojis doesn't exist anymore 😞
@@randomperson-wx5do How does that make it okay? He could have started at 30 dollars at least.
@@muslim_1866 i was the first person to discover it.. like 4 or 5 months ago
@@Ihopeyoudislocateyourarms Nani?
Man the Second guy deserves so much more. As a developer, i am shocked how he made all those animations, just for $10, that's insane. I really hope he succeeds irl.
Probably was just an asset pack he bought, nonetheless, it's still credit programming the game and getting it for under $25... He should've at least be credited
nah fr im hoping its some random talented teen who didn't need the money and does it as a hobby... even so, they deserved credit
you really managed to pay your devs less than Blizzard does! That’s gotta be an Xbox achievement or something lol
That's hillarious and cruel at the same time
nah bro this is EA, the devs pay HIM for the publicity.
You made my day
@@strategypoint8258 nope cause thier names were not mentioned. they didnt get any exposure from this
Fiverr is insane people will literally recreate the mona Lisa 1:1 for like 50 bucks on there
I feel really sorry for whomever made the second game. They sold themselves short. I mean, you don't owe it to the developer, but it would be really cool if your worked with them to make it a full release. If they're interested. Also, could you give these devs a shout out?
Agree. 10 bucks? Omg, it’s a shame.
@@zainkhalid5393 which part of Fiverr are you in
@@maruf7956
I'm a coder.
@@zainkhalid5393 Which language and what service
@@maruf7956 This isn't an interview.
I cant believe that this guy was SPONSORED and somehow got away with paying a person 25 dollars at the most for a game, and had the gull to not credit them. This feels so wrong. They got no reward, not even credit and a shout out, for their work. The cherry on top of this mess is the clickbait title.
No reward?? They got paid for the amount they asked for. If the devs wanted more money they should have charged him more, it’s not his fault. The only thing I agree with is the credits. If they added there names to the games that’s fine. But he payed for those games and that’s now his, he doesn’t need to credit them in the description
@@Omar-sl2tp It's still a very shitty thing to do
The worst is the clickbait thumbnail.. I really was expecting a 1000$ game..
@@st.altair4936 boo fucking hoo 😂. He literally asked for royalty free assets and or created assets he has the rights too, they knew that the game would no longer belong to them. Plus I’d reckon he never paid anyone on fiver in the first place he probably made these games himself
@@ftgodlygoose4718 It's still a very shitty thing to do
i’m so glad others are noticing the lack of well deserved credit
And it's worrying, depressing and disappointing yet not unexpected that this bastard isn't even deleting the criticism comments.
these prices should be a crime honestly, especially for a sponsored video.
that's Capitalism
It’s the price they agreed to, yes they should have charged more
@@shadowfax3505 yeah like 10.000 dollars
Fiverr is fucked, some devs need 5 stars for the algorithm to push them higher up. So take some lower end jobs...
@@GameDevUE yup.
Mad respect to the unnamed developers who got paid next to nothing and made decent and functioning games in one week. Only for them to be used in this clickbait and money grabbing video.
The games were worth that amount of money though
@@theoneandonlydoge2267 work all day or maybe even for days for $5 oh ya totally fair meanwhile the UA-camr made hundreds of dollars off this vid
@@Criteon Those games were probably premade games that the dev already sold to someone else for a higher price
@@theoneandonlydoge2267 hell no
@@Criteon yes no way they made these games just for this
Give each of the devs 10% of the earnings by this video as bonus. You still get to keep 70% for the work they did without even getting credit for their work.
Yes. Seriously. If he did this I might consider subscribing
The idea of making this video came from the person who uploaded the video, He got paid for the views his idea brought. The game devs got paid for their work, now, I'm not saying it is fair this guy made more money than the people who worked to create the videogames, but that's where you should consider, Did I study 6 years in game development to get paid 10 dollars for my work ? I'm pretty sure game developers can do a lot better than that. And I mean it, you are like gods, creating worlds and molding them to your desire....I wish I could do that so don't work for 10 dollars ever.
You should 100% Credit the devs in your description. It's mind boggling that you haven't done it yet, especially with how little you paid for the games. It makes it looks like you just used them for your own profit without any respect for the craft.
Yeah this guy is a prick. There's no way he hasn't seen all the comments demanding that he credit the creators, yet he still doesn't bother to. Would literally take him 5 seconds to send some business their way, if not less.
Yeah I will leave my dislike
I mean wtfh people.There are no abused devs here.He paid exactly 0$.The reason he does not link the devs is that he just made 3 mini games himself and he is using the fiverr trend on youtube to get views lmao.
It's almost like he did do it for the profit look man Devs got paid he got his product he in no way needs to credit anyone unless he feels like he should or the Devs wanted to be credited as part of there agreement people seem to forget that both parties hold Equal power the seller more so actually
retweet!
How dare you not even link the people who made the games to give them some increased business traffic after a job well done. a very VERY underpaid job well done.
The video concept was intriguing and you very well knew that. This video was gold in a bottle and you knew it and didn't even decide to pay them well. The fact you have the audacity to put in your thumbnail a large sum of money vs a low sum and then just pay them all pocket change is deplorable.
And the fact that this video was sponsored which gave you a large cash sum upfront before the video was even out is just the extra slap in the face to everyone involved.
Absolutely Disgraceful.
I will use your comment as a dislike button for the video. Very well said
I agree. I would have loved to have seen another game at a much higher price point and the people who made these nifty games for pocket change deserve some credit.
This is just terrible. 10$/hour would've been ok. It's just theft.
LOL
these games would probably be free on any platform anyway, unless they put more polish into the games they are just unfinished prototypes. $10 is generous for a game that should be free. you also assume that these people are full-time game devs that have no other source of income. however, I do agree with your point that it is dirty to show in the thumbnail large sums of money while only paying small amounts. He should at least link these peoples pages so that they can thrive in the game dev community.
If I had created the second game, at least I would have charged 100 bucks.
It was amazing for $10.
ua-cam.com/video/DHgj5jhMJKg/v-deo.html&ab_channel=CodingWithRuss
is just the basic tutorial to create a shooter game xD he just change the color of the people XD
@@Dexjet that is literally a completelety different game. It just uses the same assets, which is ok as said.
@@Contendo1 nobody said that he didn't do a good job. It was funny to me that he used the basic tutorial graphics to make a commission work. Chill
@@Dexjet He was told to use royalty free graphics or graphics he made himself, which I don't think anyone, anywhere, would do for $10.
@@Dexjet the 10 dollars is unthinkably low for a game. there is no reason to complain
Give the developers a shout out so they can be rewarded for their efforts. You got a lot of value for their hard work.
Why not credit the devs? I know you paid them but still they did a good job for how little you paid
Ikr like at least put their username in the description
I mean tbh, he did underpay them. I may be overpricing but I think the second game was worth atleast 50$.
@@bup2 ok but the second guy said he’d do it for $25 it’s not like he haggled them or anything lmao
He payed them what they asked for and nothing else, stop crying😂
@@lrkiller9227 i'm not crying but ok :v
Why not mention the devs’ names? Give them some credit at least.
Why put credits ? He paid them, you don't need to credits when you paid for a service
@@zanguusu you don’t need it when you pay them
@@zanguusu also, every game have credits for it developers. Even a big one. They don't just say "made by company" they mentioned every developer which been involved. Even if they already been paid.
some fiverr game developers are ghost developers but yeah he doesn't need to credit them but it would have been nice to credit them lol
He does not need to
1. The thumbnail is complete clickbait, showing a completely different style of game with a COMPLETELY different $ amount.
2. Almost 20% of the video is sponsored content, and it looks like all the effort went into the ad.
3. You didn't credit any of the devs, and still haven't in the description or comments weeks later (but you did make sure to comment another link to your sponsor).
This video looked like a cheap, rushed cash-in on a popular Fiverr video trend. Sorry to be blunt, but that is the what I see here, and after 14 years on this site, I can tell when there was actual passion put in the content.
Actually true
I was looking forward to seeing the games in the thumbnail, although I knew it wouldn't be $1000
Same
Only part i disagree with is 3, unless in the agreement he does not owe anyone to put a link to fiverr in the description.
@@Disatiere Why? This is about doing what's right not what's stipulated in the agreement, just because you can get people to work for shitty pay doesn't mean that it's okay because this isn't exactly just a simple transaction, it's someone's income that they need to survive.
I feel bad for the devs who got paid pennies to do a week's worth of work... and not even get any credit in the description.
He's not obligated to shout them out. That's not the point of the video. The point was to see what projects he could do with the amount of money and the goal he set out to do. We also don't know if these games were prototypes (copy/paste). Besides everyone should be grateful to be able to get a prototype for that amount of money, imagine if you was trying to create a full game experience $10 or $25 would add up since you have to keep spending money to create a full on experience. If you spend $200 for a prototype then you will never have money to really create a full on game. Just Think!
@@kelvin303 yeah but the least he could’ve done was shout them out. He didn’t make the game they did. So go somewhere else Kelvin.
@@kelvin303
Kevin... "obligated"? Who cares! Be a good person. I am glad we're not friends.
@windrose5988It's actually pathetic how everyone is offended on someone else's behalf. The devs accepted the payment, they weren't forced to. The dude that made the video isn't obligated to shout them out (could he have? Sure, but it isn't a must). This hive mind comment mentality is literally pissing me off, everyone is saying the same thing like a bunch of sheep.
These games are worth what they were paid for (i'd even say the third one is worth less than $25, seems rather half baked and pretty much got smashed by the 2nd game).
@kelvin303 FR! I keep seeing these people saying, "Give credit or pay them" more or something even though that was not the point of the video.
$10 game dev is a crime, they deserve at least a shoutout exposure
I thought the same
What is "Something a millennial would say " Alex.
@@johndorian4078 Are you actually upset these people got paid less than a grocery store's run in order to make a full game? You're delusional, John
@@johndorian4078 Oh so... No one else believes in being fair and providing a living wage... Oh wait... 1886.... Those wouldn't be... Millennials.. would they?
They do it for the 5 stars dingbat they don't care
I really, REALLY hope this gets backlash. Those devs deserved to be at least credited.
They could have asked and they got paid boo fucking hoo tough shit for them then they should have spoke up
@@asap6763 Who's this kid talking to?
@@asap6763 “it can’t be exploitation because they got paid a meagre amount”. I guess slavery was fine too because they gave them a place to live and fed them?
@@rainbowevil bro they literally offer to create a game for $10, it’s their choice. It’s not like homeboy was forcing them to make him a game
@@rainbowevil Lmao mans comparing slavery to game making when he legit offered 10 bucks
I scammed 3 different programmers and THIS happened!!
Srsly tho this is a sign the market is getting oversaturated. I'm hoping the programmers were either highschoolers or just grabbed a template off an asset store to get a quick addition to their portfolio.
@PrimeVids Yeah Indians pay like $20-50 a month for rent in some areas, which is crazy. No wonder they undercut every market. Granted their standard of living is pretty low.
@@brandonporter6223 its not likr 20-50 dollars ..the rent in an indian city is around 100 dollars to 150 dollars
@@ishansingh2391 I guess those the prices I saw were outside of a larger cities? I'm not sure, but those were the results I got. Either way $100-$150 is very cheap. My home is NYC and we have to pay over $1000 for a normal sized apartment. I wouldn't be able to compete with an Indian on these freelancing websites, it would just not be feasible.
@@brandonporter6223 yes I agree
@@ishansingh2391 you can't compare an NYC apartment to the places you are talking about in india.
Paying someone 10 dollars-or even 25-to make a game should be a crime.
They do it for experience. Awesome way to get it.
@@Tab54o Nah, they do it because they have no choice
Ikr!
@@tonirak241 no
They do it to get a good rating on fiverr, which allows them to charge more next time... but it doesn't work, because there are always new people who need to do the same thing.
The first game felt like a flash game, the second felt like a full release, and the third felt like one of those Unity games with fun physics.
Overall, The thumbnail was not only clickbait, but those 3 poor devs were definitely heavily underpaid for their work. I don't think I would be happy only giving them so little money for their work, and not even giving them credit either.
That's the worst part about it, he didnt even bother to credit them. It would have take like 5 mins if that to add their fiver account name over the gameplay and analysis of their game... At least then he would ad least be giving them some kind of "exposure." He better have given them a five star review though to help boost them on the website.
@@Alice-si8uz add to that that the first 2 minutes of the video were about sponsored content.
I know he's not obliged to do it, but I was hoping he would tip them after mentioning his raving reviews... Even other "I paid people on Fiverr for X" videos that paid a cheap base price for entertainment remember to tip them, especially for the ones underselling themselves.
If I got taken advantage of, I wouldn't want my name plastered online to shame me.
@@EdKolis They did good deeds, thinking they were doing him a favor- as he wanted a game done but lacked the funds. That's commendable, if anything.
This was an unusual video, usually these fiverr videos follow an increased price format where the freelancers are priced in an increasing manner, ie. $5 - $50 - $500.
The most unusual part is that you had a sponsor and yet you decided to lowball the devs and didn't even credit them. Kinda scummy if you ask me.
Agreed
the second dev scammed himself honestly i fell like he should've gotten 50 dollars MINIMUM! For that game the game was fully polished and as far as i see has no bugs
He should get 50
Every one of them should get AT MINIMUM 50
A game is very hard to make, and these guys, basically made a game for NOTHING
@@LaelGames7913 Even 50€ would probably not even be a 10/h wage.
I wish they would've gotten some more recognition from the video, like a link in the discription to their gigs ,or like, anything. He doesn't owe it to them but as a gamedev himself he should know the struggle.
Depends on how much of the work was done for the client.
Or was the work done for another client who paid for it and it was just reskinned and re-sold.
Funny thing about the internet, you probably have no idea the real story.......... so why assume other peoples business.
They do it like that for the ratings that's how you get 5 star reviews don't care about the price they pay just aslong as they rate good
@@johndorian4078 No one is assuming anything, people are just demanding fair payment for fine work. You're the only one here making up stories to justify under paying these people.
This was a fun video, but I gotta say you kind of ruined it for me with that click bait thumbnail, making it seem like you would be hiring someone for $1000 and also that it would be 3d games
EDIT: I think some of the comment's under this are overly harsh, I don't think there is any need to throw this youtube channel under the bus, I was trying to give some constructive feedback.
I feel the same too... clearly a bad use of click bait.
Exactly my thoughts
came here to say this. not a good first impression i got from this channel
Was looking for these comments. Felt the same way.
Alright guys! Let’s give the thumbs down!
It feels really weird to me that you did not credit these creators. You should at the very least put their username in the description.
I agree. They’re already selling themselves short.
I thought the same thing at first, but I am also kind of afraid if he did credit them a lot more people would be offering $10 to make a game thats worth a lot more than 10 dollars.
@@agafaba nah, they would raise the price in an instant. Basic supply-demand stuff. It will always be a great thing for them to get publicities like this, so it's a shame he didn't put credits.
@@tessellationarts2971 I was thinking more like they would get spammed with junk requests.
@@agafaba that's what they wanted in the first place by taking crap pays. Literally the first step on how to increase your prices = get demands up
I can understand people being upset about the lack of credit whatsoever. But outside of that, the rest were all the developers' choices. They set the price. They made their bed.
The second one is what happens when the game developer falls in love with an idea and ends spending way too much time developing lol
the second one is a copy and paste of a UA-cam tutorial...
@@baeuti4934 okay
@@baeuti4934 didn't know that thanks for letting me know can you give me the link?
@@HelamanGile ua-cam.com/video/DHgj5jhMJKg/v-deo.html
@@baeuti4934 That's just using the same pre-made graphics, not the same game.
The fact he mentioned turning the second game into a full game just pissed me off so much. I hope your sponsor drops you.
The results are actually insane for what BadGameDev paid, even if the games were built with boilerplate/template code and free assets. Anybody thinking otherwise has, in my opinion, no clue of what it takes to develop something comparable to the games in this video.
Honestly, I wouldn't even start my IDE for those prices. People seem to have unrealistic expectations because of all the competitive platforms like fiverr where developers work for way too little money.
What language or framework is used for the first two games tho. I can tell the last one is likely unity.
I am not sure about the pricing part. I might accept the first project for 10$ using python pygame. Tho not the second one.
@@ashrafibrahim4934 the technology would depend on what the creator offers and what BadGameDev specified in his request. If no technology was mentioned, it wouldn't be strange for a creator in this price range to choose whatever they like. A creator in a more realistic price range should ask for more information.
Where I'm from, a software developer charges 50 - 150 euro per hour, depending on education, function and experience. If, for the sake of this argument, we take 50% of the lowest rate, we'd have an hourly rate of 25 euro. Which means that the total development time (including the art etc.) has to be 24 minutes (= 60 ÷ (25 ÷ 10)) to be profitable for a developer where I am from that charges 10 euro. This is also not taking into account that the developer also has to interpret the request and chat with the client.
In my opinion and based on where I'm from, the developers did an amazing job, even if most of the code would be available on github or UA-cam videos. It fulfilled the needs of the client for a low price.
*edit: Added the calculation for the 24 minutes.
That is what I think. Just starting Unity and dealing with emails back and forth from a customer is $10.
Yeah I am amazed any of them accepted. The only reason I would accept it is if I had a template ready to go that I could modify a bit with some free assets and send within 30 minutes to an hour and even then I would want at least $20
To be honest all of those Devs deserve to be paid way more. I can't believe people would make a game for 5$ and I hope you tipped them well
Ikr, I was literately waiting for him to give the developers way more money at the end. But it never happened.
Nice pixel art profile and banner btw. XD
the first game wasnt worth a single fucking dollar tho tbh
@@diaco3798 You clearly have never made a game or have never tried Fiverr
@@jijigri9224 i actually have made games before bucko. the first game is literally google's dino but worse. anyone who has even the smallest amount of experience with game development can make something like that in 20 minutes. the whole code is just "make this box appear at random places and disappear when its out of the screen and end the game if the player's hitbox hits the block", i bet the whole thing didnt take him more than 5 minutes to make.
you're the one who clearly has never made a game, only people who dont know anything about game development would think that game's dev has put any sort of effort in the game
as a fiver seller , i recommend the people that did the games not to price themselves for that again , and to the client not to be a cheap rat.
Yeah, even if it is just copy and pasting assets there is still to consider when it comes to making some like this... Just because your skill level means it doesnt take as long to do a task doesnt mean you should charge less for it due to that.
It might have taken them only a few minutes to make these, but I agree on the price being too low.
@@SC-dm1ct maybe it did take a few minutes to make ,, but remember it can take years of studying and experience to do that ina a few minutes
@@marambaia2002 Oh, I agree. But that's true for most trades/professions. It's easier to sell a finished product than the labor that goes into it.
I wanted to make a game and in my mind I'm like I need to have 1 mil us and here this guy paying 10-25 usd... dang lol
Beside I had thought to get a game like these will range from 100- upward
2 of the 3 devs didn't even fulfil the request, i.e. didn't include enemies that were shooting back. Fiverr creators ignoring basic instructions is super common on the platform.
ok i could actually see the 2nd game being a decent quality mobile game, or just a quick flash game, the 2nd one was by far much more high quality then needed
Metal slug vibes ngl
@@justamanofculture12 yeah, put levels (campaign & free run), shop system, upgrade system, a little story, voila a casual mobile game
4IA01_Hisyam Rahmadian I think it would work better as an arcade style game
I love how he was sponsored and only paid 35$ and under paid 🙃
A low life youtuber
You should credit the fiverr artists that made thsese game, they actually made playable stuff for 10 bucks, so the least you could do is to credit them
The third game would have been a lot more interesting with one change. The platforms are hexagons, much smaller, and with several more of them on screen at once. So that you're always in danger of falling into a hole, and not exactly sure where the path is going.
Furthermore, after reading several other comments, I agree about crediting the developers. However, everyone needs to realise that the prices were agreed upon before development, and the prices were integral to the experiment. If the developers were not OK with the amounts they were paid, then they wouldn't have accepted the job.
He bargained to a lower price than what the standard is. Like the guy said in the video, they will typically run you 1k. This man paid 1% of the typical price for these games. This just shows how desperate these fiver devs are.
@@rosslewerenz9360 10 dollars is a lot in three world countries.
this is an insult to devs. $10 for that much work is just a spit in the face, even if it took them an hour (which i doubt it did) it's just pocket change.
and like a lot of others have commented, the least you could do (cuz i guess you can't pay them more) is to give them a shoutout
He can pay them more. He just doesn't want to. Literally just not eating out a single MEAL in the U.S.A. would give him $15-$80 extra to tip them.
Don't forget there's also a 20% fee on workers so he gets paid even less.
that not hes problem that the developer price theres nothing he can do about it
@@randomyoutuber3355 Fiverr allows tipping, iirc
for 10 or 25$ literally anything would be great, I hope you at least gave them a big fat tip. They not only worked on these games for a laughable amount of money, probably in the hopes of getting future business with you, but also provided you with the entire content for your sponsored video.
Honestly, probably didn't. Their link isn't even in the description, there's no credit. Agreeing to $10 and $25 is severly underpaying these people who probably just don't know how to price their own work.
@@liviasurjadi6705 law of supply and demand. If they start getting more offers, they will simply stop accepting 10$ and demand more
@@kartman146 Ah yes, the free market. The perfect excuse for exploiting people without feeling remorse. How about a little empathy, you realize there are humans behind these accounts right?
@@TackerTacker most sellers on fiverr live in poor third world countries, so $20 is a lot for them
@@oooooba8343
Sounds like "No, these people are from poor countries so they don't deserve more money.".
don't know of any country were 20 dollars in a week is a lot of money. Also, how is that an excuse not for tipping or linking to their fiverr page?
Bro first low balled these guys so hard and the fact that the video was sponsored too so he could’ve paid these artists the money they deserved is just upsetting. And then to make it worse he didn’t even credit them.
Thumbs up for the developers in your video, thumbs down for you not giving them the exposure they deserve.
He bought the game
@@blizzard4551 but at what costs!!?. The youtuber just paid penny and took benefit of some game dev poor condition and himself did a sponser video getting hudred of dollars
@@gameginger5529 look here if that guy was an amatuer the game dev would have gotten a real job experience which he can add to his portfolio for more jobs, honestly you can make this game like its a hobby as well and you don't even know the game devs situation for you to look out for them.
@@blizzard4551 he underpaid the game
@@blizzard4551 you have a different opinion against everyone, thats fine so just be what you want i guess, but still, the youtuber should have give credit to the game devs to help their reputation and make them grow famous which will be a win win situation
That second game has a LOT of potential, I would contact that developer and continue with further development, give them $1000 and see what they can do with it.
Should ask them if you can link their fiverr on the vid. Gives them some extra traction. Especially nice since they did it for such a low price.
Epically the second guy. He deserves more than 10 bucks.
Honestly that's a bit like responding to the observation that you're selling products at a loss, but are going to make it up in volume.
They do it for the low price because they need the ratings that's how it works on fiver you low ball yourself after you get a decent amount of 5 stars you can up your price
@@oguzkaan8908 second guy just remodeled a already existing tutorial on the exact game but alrigjt
For how much you paid, you should’ve at least credited them for their work!
You should make the Fiverr devs easily known so that you can help drive up their business especially dev #2. I looked in the description hoping to learn more but was disappointed to see no reference to them.
I dont know why dev 2 is getting so much love, is it the stock assets?
Are people really not understanding the simple nature of it?
Are they just overestimating the amount of work 2 put in?
Like as someone whos worked on games im honestly confused what draws people to the second one.
@@Disatiere It just looks fun to play lol
@@User7624name I guess? but considering that there isnt any more to it the replayabality is incredibly low.
This is why these kinda endless runner game susuallly share elements with rogue lites where you can upgrade stuff or even a variety of levels and enemis
Or even just powerups that can spawn alongside enemies.
@@Disatiere You know how when you were a little kid and you played stupid flash games and shit for hours? Like that, there isn't anything other than yeah that looks fun
We got monkey brains bro lol big number = fun
@@User7624name And those games had exactly the kind of replayabality valuable i am bringing up, at least usually.
And were still a lot more complex than that. On top having custom made graphics
I really hate seeing a developer lowballing other developers. It’s like you have no respect for the craft.
Honestly it would be great if you had showed who those sellers are by maybe showing their usernames? Or linking it in the description
True could've helped their businesses more
Agreed, I think they deserve recognition
@@imannatasha3302 oooooor it can help BadGameDev's businesses by NOT showing devs names?
10 dollar one should be paid more
both of the 2d games were 10$
@@fyoozhn i meant 2nd one
@@petar14 bro
he copy pasted code why are u acting like he poured his heart out into that fiver gig worth 10 $?
The second game was incredible - it looks like a game from a commercial studio in the mid-90's like the ones I grew up playing. Add a couple of selectable weapons, different enemy types and a soundtrack and you've got a real game there.
All the fiverr devs definitely deserve shout outs but especially the middle one.
people would like to shout out their middle finger to the youtuber because the devs didnt get any credits
The second game is honestly better than most mobile games made lately. I can't believe someone did that for $10! You should pay them more and see what they can do with their talent.
Your thumbnail is misleading. No $1000 budget and no first person shooter (YT actually has an option to report the video for this)
You didn't even put the fiverr profiles of the developers in the description which is the LEAST that you could do after promoting basically slave labor paying them $10 bucks for a full game.
No wonder this video has such high amount of dislikes
I would pay more for the second game on steam than he paid to have it created. It looks so impressive
Love how literally the 3rd dev took the term “platformer”
I am disappointed you did not offer more to the devs for this. Or at LEAST give them credit. These games are all worth more than $200 bucks in time alone. How much did you make on this video? Thought so.
They agreed to the price, it was their choice. Most likely to get experience and a good rating on fiver
the 2nd one was so good how was that 10?
@@Haidderispro Don't you dare fucking try defending him Ali. 10 dollars is nothing, literally nothing and just pure exploitation on a video that I'm certain got him at least a thousand dollars because of it's sponsorship. You can get someone whose starving or broke to agree to a LOT of things. That's why it's exploitation.
@@MissyMona the devs set the price, it’s a sellers market. That’s be like if I sold you something for 10 bucks and then asked for 190 more.
2nd dev way undersold himself. that is so close to a full release of a game. its quite frankly amazing, the thrid game is an interesting prototype and quite unique.
Here are two alternative titles:
"I scammed Fiverr Game Developers to make me a game for 10$" and "Fiverr Game Developers Have no Self-Respect"
Shame offering that kind of prices.
I hope that you gave the 2nd guy a generous tip and a good review. His game is worth way more than 10$. Rest of them are pretty much what you would expect for so little money and the 25$ guy didn't even put in any effort lol
tb that is below minimum wage pay. None of it was any less than 50.
How can you consider a working prototype no effort? Do you think games make themselves?
Just getting to a minimum viable product for an endless runner and having the game function as intended take hours. Even that first game probably took about 10 hours to make
The $25 one is actually decent for the price. It's the second guy that just amazing lol
If you say that then you obviously never worked on a game. Don't assume things if you don't know what you're talking about.
People getting mad in the comments for him not paying them a lot. He didn't have a big budget to begin with, and they agreed on the pricing. However, he should give credit where credit is due.
If you've just clicked on the video, pass it up. The highest he pays is $25, not $1000 like implied in the thumbnail.
Also as mentioned by many comments, he doesn't shout out any devs, which he's not obligated to do... it's just shitty. So yeah, spend your 10 minutes elsewhere and please don't support this morally inept content.
man at least give credits to the people that designed the game
I'm a developer myself. I see one of two possible scenarios that happened here.
1. Developers had a highly similar project on hand which they previously abandoned and it only required a minimal amount of effort to meet the brief. Perhaps the developer was working on a side scrolling platformer and only had to make it move automatically or something small like that. The small amount of money gained is therefore for the little amount of effort needed to adjust it, and the existing project, which might have taken substantial effort, would not have earned the developer anything at all otherwise.
2. The prices quoted are hourly rates, not for the project as a whole. Even so it's pretty low, but I can imagine some developers working for those rates.
Nobody in their right mind would build any of these games from scratch for $25.
for 25$ MAYBE i can turn on my computer
They wouldn't build them from scratch, they would use an engine, such as the one advertised. They were all made in less than a week. People do game jams all of the time for free and create cool games in a short time for fun and the experience.
@@DanielDroegeShow I assumed using an engine, most likely GameMaker as mentioned. Building it with pure OpenGL/DirectX/Vulkan/whatever and not using any engine or frameworks would be a much taller order.
I still think there's a huge difference to doing a game jam, or working on a volunteer project, to working on a project for an extremely low fee - I mean, why work on a paid gig that isn't worth your time rather than working on your own project, or some community project that you believe in? There are certain responsibilities that come with accepting payment.
@@lionelpinkhard6509 This is the way the fiverr marketplace (or any freelance site) works. You have to develop a profile of happy customers with glowing reviews or you can't charge the going rate. To do this, you have to intern for awhile doing dirt cheap projects and build up rapport in the community. The best thing he could have done for these people were hire them (at the rate they accepted) and review them highly.
@@DanielDroegeShow If that’s your reasoning, I can only imagine the devs must have the same reasoning. There are two alternatives that would likely also work - 1) do extremely small jobs for many people, for reasonable prices, or 2) charge less but still substantially more than this. $1000 is still pretty cheap, $500 even cheaper, dropping to $25 is a bit extreme in my opinion. But you’ve made your point because the fact that it seems okay to you in itself means some people are willing to accept it.
I'm pleased to see the comment section calling you out for not mentioning the developers. That's not right.
That second game was so good! It was exactly what was asked for and it was executed really well. It looked well made and I would totally play it. Definitely worth way more than $10.
Turn the second game into a full game for us
But with coperation with the og dev.
*Pay the original developer the $1000 that appeared in the thumbnail but are nowhere to be seen in the video to turn it into a full game for us
Guys I don't think he meant to hurt these devs he loved all of their games and said great things about them. And the developers are the ones that accepted the small wage. Yall need to chill.
damn that second guy did a great job on the game, if you do turn it into a full-er game you should make sure to credit him so other people know about how good his work is.
The 1st and 2nd game feels like they could be minigames in a larger first person game. The third feels like a more modern mobile game, they all were really good for the price, they really put respect to the craft.
I was very confused when the video ended and i figured out, that the thumbnail (the reason i clicked the video) had nothing to do with the actual game...
Second one was definitely the best, honestly with a few updates to design , ui and the background this could be a top tier mobile game, the background could change to a crystal cavern at a higher lvl and the enemies could change later lvls.
Alternative title: "I try to rip off indy game devs until someone agrees to work for a price below their value and I'm not even gonna credit them at all but make sure to check out my sponsor!"
That makes 0 sense. If someone agrees, then it is their value. Everyone finds their own value this way.
A good/interesting video that would work just fine without the lie. That's not even clickbait, you straight up bullsheetted in the thumbnail. This is the first, and last time, I watch you. I did enjoy the video tho. A shame it ended like that.
You cant just pay devs 10 dollars for a game. You are really underpaying them, please pay them more in the future!
They literally accepted the price, it's truly up to them 😆anyone who spends that kind of time to make $5 is a tit
This video feels kind of scummy for some reason. I feel bad for all those devs and something rubbed me the wrong way about none of them being credited.
Maybe he made it himself and just lied
@@fkalanzay "Maybe he's a liar" also feels scummy
@@ashmasterc yeah,
He never even showed the fiverr website even though everyone shows it so I don't know what to say
Better title: "I Took Advantage of Game Devs"
Seriously bro. You as a dev yourself ought to realize how much time it takes to make a game. Divide the ridiculously small amount of $10 you paid by that time and they're looking at PENNIES per hour. What's wrong with you? You didn't even shout them out either.
@Lars Liam Vilhelm yea they literally did why does everybody say he’s in the wrong?
@@lDontExist cuz people don’t think for themselves and just follow what everyone else is saying.. business is business.
i honestly feel like these game makers shouldnt charge any less than 100 for even simple games
Game 2 definitely worth 100$ and and 3 definitely worth 130$
Fiverr artists, STOP UNDERSELLING. That second game was easily $500 worth of labor, even with prefab assets. You are literally sabotaging your own labor market by accepting this work for $10. Say what you want about the lack of this guy's judgement with this video, let this be a lesson for how easy it is to let yourself be taken advantage of. The appropriate response to this request was 3:30.
Please credit the developers at least the last two they deserve it
They all deserve it
No need to. Doesn’t take anything away from this man. Actually he’s giving is free content.
Basically you paid people to give you games they already developed and half of the video is an ad.
The second game was extremely creative! It also sort of triggered some of those nonstop levels from Mario in my memory. Those things used to be terrible to try to beat
As an accomplished UE4 artist, the idea of people putting together little games like this for so little money is appalling. I make in an hour, the amount these people received combined. Game dev is no joke, and its heavily undervalued by most people who are not involved in the industry. There is a reason why AAA games cost millions of dollars to develop. You may as well have just asked around on Fiver for people to make everything for free, because that's basically what you got. These small games are not complicated projects, and the time that went into them was likely minimal, but its simply a matter of principle.
The 2nd one seems the funnest and most complete. For $10 that was a great deal.
The 3rd one I think did something unique, and given your request to 'please be creative', a isometric(?) semi-3D endless runner game seems to fit the bill. I think it was a little sterile in its current iteration, but it had something a bit unique compared to what is typical for the genre, and that I think that creativity is worth something.
Took that Fiverr sponsor money, spent $30 & pocketed the rest. Absolute scallywag
I disliked the video, because you didn't mention who created the games... Mainly because you paid $10 for an entirely week of work... The least you could do to give back, was to publicize the participants.
Same.
Game 1 seemed like a game that only cost 10$ to make. Game 2 looked actually well designed and like you said, polished, worth way more than 10$. I got really interested in the style of Game 3, and started to imagine different enemies, weapons, and a recharging ammo counter that could all make it get progressively more complex, as opposed to the simple "get faster".
You could port all 3 of those games to PS4/PS5, make it an easy platinum and those trophy hunters would buy it.
These 3 developers should group together to make a indie game lol
Someone needs to start a go fund me for these devs, they deserved so much more than what this video gave them.
1st one is a scam
@@Itz2wice second one is a scam too, its a copy and paste of an online tutorial
Tus mamadas van acá abajo carnal
Are you going to share the names of the creators on Fiverr who supplied these games to you? Surely that would be more valuable to them in terms of future business than just reviewing them anonymously....
I feel bad for the 2nd dev, that deserves a minimum 100-150 dollars
But he accepted it tho…
No credits to those that made the game? And you paid them so little too, this is so underhanded mate.
It makes sense why this video is getting so many dislike, truly disgusting.
It pretty much sums up how the game development field is, low wage for a lot of work and it's very competitive.
@@DKYtut couldn't have summed it better myself. :/
Exposure should never substitute actual fair payment but to get scrap change and no credit? Disgusting.
@@YoBoyRona o shut up
It's a cool video idea but you should've considered promoting their gigs (or at bare minimum the one who did the best) especially since you negoitated lower prices for their time.
He doesn't have to do anything, he paid for what he wanted.
@@Ideal_ideas your right, but it’s basic human decency to credit an artist atleast. This is a sponsored video and he said in the thumbnail 10v$1000 when 1000 was never paid.
Bad game dev indeed, no credits to anyone's work, all about your money, your judgement, your video content and your sponsors.
This was work for hire, so no credit needed as he owns all the rights.
@@justinwhite2725 there's a difference between legal need and ethical need
Second game is so polished. 10$ is so low for this talented developer.
Because it's stolen from the Pygame Scrolling Shooter tutorial here on youtube by Coding With Russ.
Bro the second one was really polished! Great art and snappy movement! Like you said, would be perfect for an arcade game!
Unity gives away a lot of games like that for free.
This video is disgusting. This guy got sponsored to pay 3 devs ans only spent a total of $45 to make 3 games. Basically underpaying these devs. He compliments them yet there is no credit and we can’t find the devs. So he’s just exploiting people who don’t know their value to make more money on youtube. Theres a reason why he said it was hard for him to fins people to make the games