Ep 193: Redbreast 12 Irish Whiskey Review and Tasting with Jameson and Green Spot Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 сер 2024
- Today we do a review and tasting of Redbreast 12 Year Old Irish Whiskey and compare it to Jameson and Green Spot.
Check out the Instagram account @whiskey_marketing_school
** Can I donate a whisk(e)y for you to review in The Whisk(e)y Vault?
Of course! If you’re interested in making a tax deductible donation towards our whiskey selection, head on over to:
austinwhiskyvau...
** What's with the necklaces?
Rex is a whiskey mooch. His necklace is a manifestation of pure glory - forged from the irradiated bones of eagles and wolves. Also a tube sock.
See the origin story here: goo.gl/JMc2Hr
Daniel is a whiskey sommelier. His necklace is a token of his sommelier level, and he trains whiskey sommeliers at The Whisk(e)y Marketing School in Austin Texas.
**A Whisk(e)y school?
Yup. Here are a few things we believe.
** You don’t have to be a snob to appreciate and love great whiskey.
Whisky and Whiskey (it depends on where it’s from) have been an important part of cultures around the world from time immemorial. Whiskey is a part of the very fabric of Western society, and in most places, is as common and accessible as beer.
Like Jazz and wine, snobs have predictably hijacked whiskey appreciation, spoiling our natural, common connection with it and creating a false dichotomy of “good whiskey” and “bad whiskey.”
It’s time to break through the emotional bias with facts and science. That’s what this school is about.
** The only valid definition of “good” whiskey is “whiskey you like to drink.”
Learning how to share your love of whiskey in a way that connects people to the history and the story has more to do with public speaking and storytelling than it does with facts and tests.
The best way to learn about whiskey and share that love is to drink whiskey and talk about it with friends. Study the history, find the stories, and discover the culture and the methods that have been developed over hundreds of years. That’s what you’ll do when you attend The Whisk(e)y Marketing School.
** You don’t need a marketing degree to learn how to share your love of whiskey with the world.
There's an old saying, "In business, it's not what you know... It's who you know."
Regardless the industry you're in, most people are clumsy and ineffective when it comes to "networking" because they ignore a very important rule - Relationship First, Business Second.
There's a tremendous amount of curiosity about Whisk(e)y today. It's a great excuse for you to gather a group of people who want to have fun and learn something new. The Whisk(e)y School teaches you how to tap into that curiosity, and share your love of whisk(e)y in an unpretentious way. You're demonstrating knowledge, expertise, and an engaging personality - things valued by every gatekeeper, in every industry.
Or would you rather hand out business cards and cross your fingers?
Learn more at www.whiskymarke...
![Top 10 Irish Whiskeys for Advanced Whiskey Drinkers [Crowd sourced From Whiskey Lovers]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1a6CMX5EPcI/mqdefault.jpg)
![Top 10 Irish Whiskeys for Advanced Whiskey Drinkers [Crowd sourced From Whiskey Lovers]](/img/tr.png)
![Top 10 Whiskeys for Beginners [Crowdsourced From Whiskey Lovers]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PoeIPrIXUOw/mqdefault.jpg)
You guys inspire me to be an alcoholic.
They should inspire you to have good friends who can laugh and enjoy different experiences together, while thinking carefully about them and discussing them openly-- and make money while doing it! They should not inspire you shell out your hard-earned money to get drunk all alone.
Jesus lads don't piss the bed. It was a jesting throwaway comment. Chill...
JOHNOOH -I, for one, support your potential alcoholism. These guys have been at the heart of my current fascination and appreciation of whisky in all it’s forms. I’m really liking scotch right now and look forward to appreciating Irish.
@@cowboyflipflopped I'm going to go out on a limb here and suggest Roy C was being facetious
@@chairmanmeow3693 The humor of alcoholism increases with your distance from it.
I'm drinking a dram of Redbreast while watching you two go on. That makes the experience even better!
Redbreast is my all-time favorite Whiskey, period.
Never tasted anything like this whiskey perfect 👌
I’m looking at 10 excellent scotch single malts next to it, and I want the redbreast... I guess I’m broken too.
Is it smooth enough for a beginner?
@@NorthernAnt Oh yes redbreast is smoooth
@@markanders567 thanks I will try this
I got a bottle of red breast for Christmas and I didn't cut it with anything and just sipped it all day and I tell u I love it......
What Dan said about it being widely available is balls on. The first time I had Redbreast was with an army buddy who had come into town. We went for a slice of pizza at Shakespeare's (Columbia Missouri) and while we were waiting we looked at the top shelf of the little bar, sitting right on the end was Redbreast. My buddy asked if I had ever had it? I hadn't. After a wee taste we bought the bottle! Easily my favorite whiskey... damn, it's good!
Just purchased a bottle of Redbreast 12 and Highland Park 12 this week. Two classics. Love them both.
i think the $15 range is a good place for that glass, i wouldnt pay more than $20 for one though. also side note, this episode was especially enjoyable. something about your guys' mood or something. just the banter was great and you talked A LOT about the whiskey. 10/10 and i cant wait to buy a glass or two
Or $20 for a set of 2👌
7,20€ in my local bar.
Max, I would pay $20 for one, $15 ea. for two ($30 total). I would prefer lower than that, but I see this as supporting you guys and I do not mind paying more for that.
Tried Red Breast for the first time. WOW such an easy,smooth, delicious whiskey. The wife is becoming a whiskey whisky drinker with me because of red breast. We combined drank half the bottle tonight because we couldn’t get enough of the taste. I played a trick on her, I poored her a sip of Johnny walker platinum. She was like what happened? Lol. We learned we can’t drink the two at the same time. Red Breast is my new go to whiskey. Thanks guys
Hey guys, I've been a drinker for years but recently discovered my love of Whiskey. I've noticed among whiskey reviewers that if a bottle of Hibiki Harmoney was there it was usually almost finished. So I went and bought a bottle and wow. Now I just need a proper Glass to drink it from. Kepp up the good work
"Send us your whiskey, you're broken." I lost it lol
A true mooch knows what to say??
i laughed way too loudy.
Well it's about time! Requested this back in June, well done gentlemen. Did get a bit excited when the notification popped up. Cheers.
One thing that always amazes me everytime is how fast your channel grows every day.
us too
You just missed the 20k band wagon, you better start planning for the 30k subscriber celebration!
I've tried a lot of the whiskeys on this channel. But this is the episode that inspired me to start my own collection. I appreciate your banter and whiskey knowledge.
I have spent the last week or so, binge watching your channel, and i literally just bought a set of Glencairn glasses this morning. I then visited your website from another video and found you sell glasses. I will have to buy yours as well some day, but i just bought $80 worth of Whiskey last night without the wife's approval, so I need to lay low for a few days... I love your channel and the Whiskey Biscuit channel. I look forward to visiting some day when the distillery is open.
Just picked up a bottle of RB 12. I have a nice selection of whiskies, but didn't have any Irish. Picked this up at our LCBO on sale. It's amazing. Great vid here guys.
If we have all learned nothing else from this channel we have learned this.... "For those glasses I would happily pay $100 ... of Daniel's money! " (credit Rex the Almighty)
King Rex Rex.
Red Breast 12 is one of the bottles that I keep on my shelf all of the time. There is something very comforting about it. I do recommend that you get your hands on a bottle of their 15, I believe it to be the best "expression"
Way to be a positive influence in the local market. My #1 point of acquisition has got to be in tune with the Whisk(e)y Vault's reviews. More than once I have found a new offering, within a week of the UA-cam upload....your either making my life easier, or just more expensive!! Thanks for this new problem.
I'm okay with both of those problems. :-)
Just bought my first Irish Whiskey…Red Breast 12….extremely pleased with this! I’ve been hunting mainly bourbons but when I need a break….I’ve enjoyed Balvenie 14 and Glenfiddich 14 bourbon barrel. I’m loving this buttery smoothness in this Red Breast! Very nice
Picked up the cask strength version of Redbreast 12 and a bottle of Green Spot last weekend.
No matter which episode I watch I always laugh a bit and you can tell how much fun you all are having, and I love it! Keep doing what you do.
I've tried now the 12, the 15 and I'm starting a dram of the lustau. I love the 12 best
Recovering Know It All me too. The 15 held no mystery for me the 12 hadn’t solved
I've gotten a couple glencairns from distilleries and they tend to go for $10-12 a piece, which I think is fair. If you can make them for something close to that, I'd definitely pick a couple up (assuming I don't lift those 2 next week).
who said anything about being fair? (im secretly a level 90 wallet mooch). if you lift anything next week, i get a cut. ya know... for science.
This was the range I am in for it too. I was thinking 20 for a set of 2.
You can get a 2 piece gift set from amazon for $12
I concur.
So many t-shirt possibilities. "Whiskey mooch" would be amazing.
YESSS! I've been planning on buying this one by the end of this week and BOOM! You guys drop a review
Just bought this and watching this video whilst I watch it… the nose is quite different to the palate. The biscuit notes are stronger on the nose than palate. It’s a great dram. Rich and full of flavour.
If you like GreenSpot, check out Greenspot Chateau Louisville Barton, *finished in Bordeaux cask or in October there is a white wine cask Green spot being released. A Californian vineyard- unsure which vineyard... in the irish market- unsure about international release. Green spot for me is the quintessential Pot Still- vanilla, cinnamon, clove with a long smooth finish... the Bordeaux cask only heightens this will the introduction of fig, red grape and claret.
I absolutely love Redbreast.. that being said.... here is your dad joke of the day.
I had a dream that I was a muffler last night. I woke up exhausted.
As always great video and I would love to get one of those glasses.. or a set of 4
james vinson not sure if I invited you m.facebook.com/groups/2553688224951169
Hehe
Stephen Hill well done sir..lol
I can't imagine anyone who likes whiskey not liking this. There is literally something for every type of whiskey drinker in Redbreast 12.
The sparkles in Daniels beard made my day.
Hell yea I'd buy a glass or two if somewhere under $20 ea. Great episode. I love Red Breast enough that I didn't remember if I still had some so bought a bottle then got home and found I still had one, score!
Redbreast 12 is incredible. Absolutely beautiful
I am a whisky fan and has most whiskeys I see you guys having. Still I like to get whisky from my collection and ship same whisky you reviewing. I love your knowledge and admiration towards whisky. While watching video show mention of ardbed 10 which is my best whisky till now.
Tasting Redbreast 12 right now for the first time, looking forward to some Greenspot
Green VS Red
Jameson has been my only Introduction to Irish, looking forward to grabbing a bottle of Redbreast 12 to expand a little bit
I never had a glass of Whiskey in my life, but you guys are really fun to watch.
Great episode! I'll be celebrating my 22nd birthday today with a brand new bottle of Glenfiddich 12 while I wait out yet another hurricane. A whiskey vault glass sounds great, I would love to get some for me and some friends. I would definitely pay anywhere from 10$ to 15$ for it.
1st of all along with the tribe this is easily my favorite source for whisk(e)y knowledge and reviews! Also wanted to know if there is any chance we'll get a Redbreast 27 review in our future?!
The 27 is to die for!
Cookies and biscuits are objectively different things, something that a lot of people don't understand. Biscuit means cooked twice, cookie means cooked once. If a biscuit is only cooked once, it's a cookie. If a cookie is cooked twice, it's a biscuit. Nowadays, biscuits are hardly ever cooked twice, so most things you'll come across are actually cookies.
In which hellhole do they cook biscuits or cookies
You want us to buy glasses without whiskey in them?!.....8 bucks....10 with a hands free, quick release Rex harness that can mount to a mooch necklace or a belt.
My birthday is coming up on the 23rd and she who must be obeyed said I could spend $75 for my birthday. I ended up getting a bottle of Hibiki Harmony based on your review of it. Upon discovering I had enough for a budget bottle, and decided to take the plunge in to the Islay region on Daniel's recommendation and got Black Bottle. After tasting Black Bottle I must say I am now ready to see what the smoke monster of the Islay region has to offer
Heck yes. Great journey
Here is how I rank them: Jameson = mix with ginger ale; Green Spot = rocks only; Redbreast = neat only. I love them all and all are in my cabinet. But, all of the Redbreasts are special especially 12 yr CS!
Second! The beard sparkle is strong with this one!
3:11, Classic
I must be pissed tonight, I missed it damnit!
Have only tried Jamesons as far as Irish goes, but I think Irish is my favorite category. Watching this to make sure Redbreast or Greenspot is what I want for my birthday.
You guys are awesome. This has become like drinking with friends.
We agree. Thanks for hanging out!
"I'm used to waking up with a mouth that tastes like someone shit in it while I was sleeping"
He's on to you Rex...
Hi guys. Just cracked open a bottle of this last night. Not sure what to make of it at the moment. I wasn't too impressed. Unusual cos I love Irish whiskey. It's very light and virtually no alcohol burn and the finish is gone immediately. I love the powers 12. Maybe it will improve with some time.
You learned me on the whisk(e)y. I'll try on the pricing of the glasses.
Cost of glass +
labor rate (divide your hourly rate for labor by the number of glasses an hour you can make) +
profit margin (how much money you want to make) =
total cost for consumer.
Before anyone starts waving their arms about like an orangutan, please put your current glass down. Spilled whisk(e)y isn't fun. The final number is completely flexible based on how much they really want to make versus what they think people will pay. I don't see it as "hey I'm going to buy these to drink all my whisk(e)y" but more as "I want to support these guys and the channel".
I bought Teeling rum single batch, and oh what a whiskey... Rex, you look lovely today
shoot... i was going for adorable. but thanks anyways.
I started on Rum and then moved to Scotch. It was tough to make that switch but then tried Bruichladdich Port Charlotte and I absolutely loved it. I found out that I apparently love sweetness (Rum in abundance there) and smoke (Islay). I'm hoping to try Redbreast now and see if I like that too. Trying to make my way into Irish Whiskey, then on to Japanese.
I got a bottle of Redbreast 12 last night with my first bottle of Laphroaig and wow. There's too much to say about that. I'm down with peet/dirt/moss though so I'm good.
My dad, who's not a fan of whisky, told me about a whisky he had in his youth. It was called Mac Scot, it is no longer available. He and his friends called it ''nackskott'', which in swedish means ''neckshot''. Referring to execution by shot to the back of the head. It was the cheapest whisky available, and it was supposedly really bad.
Do you have any whiskies you avoid at any cost?
So I recently became aware of a whiskey named Sierra Norte. What's so particular about this whiskey and what got my attention is that is the first whiskey on the market coming from Mexico. They have three different products each made with different corn: White corn, yellow corn and black corn. You guys should review it if you can find it.
New to this channel. I can't get enough. You guys are very lerned, but don't come off snobbish in the least. Thank you for expanding my whisk(e)y pallet and keep up the good work!! P.s. Green Spot is the nectar of the gods
Only 9 months old? It feels like I've been watching for a year at least...
It feels like we've been shooting it for two
Finally! Really like it and cannot wait to try the Lustau edition I have stashed. I prefer Green Spot but only slightly, however Yellow Spot, in my humble opinion is not worth the premium.
I totally agree. I prefer Green
I was excited for this episode since I bought Redbreast 12 earlier this year and enjoy it. I look forward to trying Green Dot. As for the glasses, put me down for a couple at $12-15
You could add "team biscuit" or "team cookie" for addl $3. You'd probably sell more. Lol
Superb Irish whiskey. You will never mistake Irish whiskey for anything but Irish whiskey. Candy, honey, vanilla, spice. Beautiful. Not for everyone, though. An acquired taste for sure.
Definitely prefer the Red Breast to Green Spot. I get too much peat from the Green Spot
I drink Red Breast in fall/winter and green spot in spring/summer.
Very cool idea with the glasses. I vote charging a little extra and throwing lids in.
Two glasses for $15 would be fair depending upon unit cost/etching plus shipping.
I would be happy to pay 25 to 30 for a pair. Especially if it keeps you doing what you do. Thank you for the knowledge and the entertainment.
$10 - $15 I think is the usual going price. Don't take too long though, need to get my brother some for the holidays.
Absolutely love Red Breast. My top Irish of all time.
As for the glassware, ~$9 per or $30 for 4?
$10 per and $28 for four?
Powers John's Lane bests it easily imo
Drinking my first Redbreast 12. At the moment, this may be my favorite non-peated whisky.
I just picked up a bottle of Red Breast 21 over the weekend. I have the 12 cask strength and the 12 Lustau. I really like the Red Breast brand.
Tom R m.facebook.com/groups/2553688224951169
Great review! So far my favorite Irish is the Redbreast 12yr, but it was interesting to see it compared to Greenspot (not yet tried)...nice to know that there are interesting differences/nuances to be explored in the Irish genre, and slightly less of a task than with Scotch. Cheers from Austria!
Just got a bottle of this and drinking a dram now. Very complex, like a scotch. I do kind of miss the coconut notes I get from Jameson, though. The sherry is light, but comes through nicely. Overall, I’d definitely buy again. Up to this point, my only Irish experience had been Jameson, so it’s interesting to see where else they can take the category.
I’m still working on getting both redbreast and green spot. Can’t wait to try both!!!!!!!
Funny note speaking of Shortbread Biscuits. The Walkers Shortbread factory is less than a mile from Aberlour distillery. Is this some whisky biscuit conspiracy?
Just started enjoying bourbon and Redbreast 12 was my 4th purchase and it is smooth on the nose and smooth going down. BTW I purchased one of your Glencairn Magnificent Bastard glass. Love it!
Glencairn glasses are generally around $8 online, and etching probably costs you virtually nothing (not counting the cost of the etcher. I'm assuming you invested in that for another purpose), but you obviously have a distinctive brand that's unique and worth something, so I could see paying between $10-$13 per glass. Maybe $11.99 each, or 2 for $20?
Powers John's Lane is my fav Pot Still. Magnificent whiskey.
RB 12 Cask Strength is so delicious
hell yes! i was wondering when you would get to it. I actually bought redbreast 12 a few weeks ago cause I remembered Daniel pouring it for the modern rogue people and i wanted to style an irish whiskey made the old style irish way. thats when I realized you never did video on it. and it hurt pouring my self a $60 whiskey so I bought normal jameson for every day. so this episode was basically a mirror of my nights after work. of course till the mooch mentioned green spot. as for the classes i would pay up to but not exceeding $8 per glass plus tax and shipping and handling. i would want set of 4 and not want to pay more than $40 if possible. $45 if i had to.
Update on a purchase, I did manage to find Laphroaig Lore at my local liquor store. Dads birthday is in November so I have hid it in my apartment away from my other whisky to avoid any confrontations while I am not looking.
Lorensoth3, good thinking. They are notoriously feisty.
Hey guys, I'm from Turkey and love the show, last day I was wondering if there was any turkish whiskey distilleries and I encountered, the only and the last, one called Ankara Viski owned by a Turkish tobacco and alcoholic beverage company named Tekel in 1963. The funny story behind is that when it was first produced in the capital, the board of the institution invited a well known and reputable whisky expert from Scotland. When the test was asked, he replied as “Very complex. Nice drink. But totally not a Whisky, let me ask which type of spirit is this?”
Disappointment :(
Well dang! Hopefully you can get your hands on some other whisky!
Happy International Talk Like a Pirate Day! Also, it's my birthday and I've spent way too much time drinking whiskey today.
I know you "gentlemen" are not fans of "Top 10 lists" with taste being subjective.
Being new to whiskey my personal goal to starting a collection is to start with a bottle sample from each region/style.
I would love to see a series of videos in the nature of a "top 3 (------) whiskeys". Covering bourbons, ryes, highlands, islays, etc.
You guys create great videos thank you.
PS - biscuits is to cookies, as football is to soccer
Now that I've seen what I wrote down.... that kinda how your videos end up.
Keep up the good work!!!!
You Magnificent Bastards:
My friends, for once I'm going to have to disagree with you. I just tasted 4 Irish Whiskeys (Red Breast 12, Green Spot, Jameson, and Slane), and I have to say that Red Breast 12 took home the prize for me. Green Spot is a damn fine whiskey, but being how I am typically a Bourbon drinker and prefer deep and oaky whiskeys, Green Spot is just a little too light and bright for me when compared to Red Breast. I remembered that you all did a comparison video with RB 12 and GS and Jameson together, and watched this as I was tasting. But anyways, cheers mates, to long life and happiness !
What did you think of the Slane I just bought a bottle a couple weeks ago and that is probably one of my favorite Irish whiskeys that I have ever tried
What has a narrower flavor profile, American or Irish whiskey? Or should I ask bourban or Irish whiskey to make it a better defined question?
Please keep reviewing more Irish and Japanese whiskey!
I think Irish is narrower, but mostly because there's less happening right now.
just Ordered a bottle of Redbreast 12 and a Lagavulin 16... I'm a beginner in whiskey, the only one i drank and liked is the classical Jameson
recently tried the Chivas Regal, but damn that's strong, i hope these upcoming 2 bottles will be for me. if not, then maybe whiskey is not for me
I tried different whiskeys. American, just no. Jameson was something I always went back to, but I'll try Redbreast 12 and Green Spot.
Just has a sip of the redbreast 12 .... OMG! freaking amazing!
I bought a glass from A. Bowman Smith Distillery for 7 bucks if I remember correctly. I remember thinking it was not over priced at say 15. I guess you need to factor shipping and packaging. Mine was wrapped in paper and I carried it out in a bag, no box.
You should try green spot with redbreast 21. I get a lovely coconut flavor from the 21. Might make for a better comparison
Here I can get an non graphed glencairn glass for 6 euro, so I would pay 10-15 for a graphed one. Also a whisky suggestion from me to review is the Benriach 16 ;) cheers
Did anyone else see those sparkles at 3:11? Lol
Since Daniel mentioned he smokes cigars, I'm curious which ones are his favorites. The Arturo Fuente Hemingway line is pretty good, but for me it has to be the maduros. I prefer the Oliva Serie V line. (The Melanio and Melanio Maduro are excellent in my opinion.) One other is the Blanco Nine, by Blanco Cigars. (toro, robusto, double corona, the JT Limitado is really good.) The Nine goes really well with Flor de Cana 7 year old rum, from Nicaragua. Sad thing is it's almost impossible for me to find where I live.
Hemingways are my number 1 favorite non-cuban. Flor de las Antillas "My Father" series is pretty cool too.
I would pay around 10$ per glass easily. Its unique, you're not going to get it on amazon or something. Especially to help support you guys and this cool channel, I'll pay whatever within reason. Cheers.
Daniels beard at 3.10/3.11... sparkly... By the way, RB12 is and always will be pure pot still delicious. Thanks for the reviews dudes.
I would absolutely buy some glasses. I saw it in the comments somewhere but I agree with the 15 for one 25 for two price point
Purchased my 1st bottle of RedBreast 12...gonna enjoy some by the campfire next weekend. Hope it's as delicious as you guys say!
My vote is 20 per glass because we can support ya like good people, and free for those who donate whiskey, if that's not illegal.
Not sure if you saw my comment a few posts back but I have something to practice your blending skills. Recently had a friend over for an Irish whiskey tasting with Green Spot, Red Breast 12 and Connemara Single Malt. At the end I mixed them together and it was pretty amazing. Not sure of the exact proportions but believe it was around 1 to 1.
Must be done!
You may have to mess with the proportions bc the glasses were all different levels and I didn't measure before dumping them in one glass. But in theory it was prob close to about 1-1. You won't be disapointed. It's all the great things about Green Spot and Red Breast, but with a kick of peat from the Connemara.
Laghroig 10 was my entry level scotch and from then on. i was hooked on the stuff. Glasses are great. I would pay 12 or 13 for them.
Would love to see bottom shelf whiskey comparisons or like a best quality for price (I know its subjective but would love to hear your opinions)
Very time I watch an episode another whiskey goes on the list, I first started with makers mark and then moved on to tomintoul 10 and laphoraig I currently have Benromach 10 which you really need to review !!! Next on the list is Suntroy Hibiki Harmony.
How about $24.95 a pair. That seems to be close to the going rate online at other places. You'd most likely have to find a source for the glasses to make it doable. Just think ahead....you can also do your distillery name on some Glencairn glasses once you get it up and running.