I just like a Gaga song the first way she presents them to us, it's different than seeing it later on. the aura of the song changes. And that snl Moment is "Why Did You Do That" in it's best form.
I know this was supposed to be the "bad" song from the movie, but it's literally everything we ever wanted haha. Along with Heal me, Hair Body Face and is that alright.
I will be honest, when i was a kid i didnt like lady gaga, i thought she was so weird and out of this world🙈 Now i see her with a completely different way and i think she is one hell of a human being with a pure heart and kindness she is just pure passion.I am so sorry Lady Gaga!! (Please dont hate i had to share)
iliana Santo SAME when I was like idk 9 or something, I always disliked her because of these "satanic" things people called, yet I still lowkey bop to Bad Romance and Poker Face Until recently I tried getting into Artpop and i was shocked. Then I listened to Joanne (Now my 2nd Favorite album of all time) then BTW, etc. Now I'm a really huge fan of her, she's very talented, very loving, and very accepting to people. Now I know why many people loves her.
I know the song and the entire performance is supposed to make us really sad that Ally lost what made her original and has turned into a "generic pop artist" - but let's be real, this is an amazing performance, way better than most of the actual snl performances
I don’t think we are supposed to feel sad. We are to understand that she is just getting started in the business. She has to become popular in order for her to actually do the songs that are authentic to her. I think back to 2008/2009 and The Fame came out for Lady Gaga. Those songs were made to reflect an artist first coming out. It wasn’t until we were a few albums in and a lot of live performances of her oh the piano in order for us to understand the depth that she brings. I love this song because it’s a great starting point for a new artist that we know has the depth to continue sharing more of her story
Diane Warren co-wrote the song and defended its lyrics, noting that it was not meant to be a "bad pop song", but rather a fun, light-hearted track to emphasize that Ally's career was on the rise as Jackson's was declining.
Ken Alexandre Meridi They said RIGHT NOW. Those albums you mentioned are iconic, but they came out a long time ago. I don’t really think today’s music sucks, but it’s hard to find artist that got me feeling the way Gaga did in the 2010s lol.
I realize this song is meant to be “shallow” (pun) & the pop manufacturing of her label, all not true to her real voice. But this song is literally what the gays throw down for and wanted from this soundtrack.
i really love that type of jokey/sarcastc/ironic pop songs and i cant think of many other than This one, intuition, on a roll and most of what poppy makes
I really like this song, it sounds like a first single for a nighties’ girl pop group and I’m weak for it. The percussion gets me every time. It’s not true to Ally’s voice at all but I love it.
Lady gaga deserves the recognition that Beyoncé gets. Being so versatile with her style in music and then her multiple talents. She can sing, dance, play multiple instruments, speaks multiple languages, acts exceptionally well, and most importantly stays true to herself beyond everything else.
While the production is just supposed to be generic pop-trap style of today's music...her voice and pitch control is just outstanding. Thus, makes it a bop to me. A lot of new singers out now rely on so much auto tune and her vocals have so much raw emotion in them, even in a song like this.
there’s a huge undertone of sadness in this song despite being a generic pop single and i think people often pay attention to the simplicity of the lyrics but not the emotion behind it which for me hits home in terms of emotional relationships
I mean the song follows every generic pop song criteria, trap beat, vocals follow percussion, no hint of actual instruments, over saturated bass that overthrows vocals in chorus, repetitive chorus
the song isnt meant to be "bad". its meant to be lyrically superficial and not true to Allys voice, which was a key point in the film.
David Kang it still sound catchy as fuck
I think it’s meant as a mockery to current artists that try to be “relevant”
@@chrisavenport6456 so true omg
Perfectly put!
I wonder what ally thinks of GaGa lmao
This sounds like something she'd release on the fane
When the ironic song is still better than most of the songs on the radio these days. Lol the irony.
just gaga effect..lol
Yes.. better than all the speaking song right now..
I don't like this song, too shallow. ;) But the rest of the soundtrack is killer
So true
If you think that this is good, then you're precisely what this film's making fun of.
I really wish it was just the snl performance as the video instead of movie clips getting in the way
They have one on YT and its only like 2 minutes of the song or less
Maybe they’re just trying to avoid the copyright infringement and that’s why they did this
I just like a Gaga song the first way she presents them to us, it's different than seeing it later on. the aura of the song changes. And that snl Moment is "Why Did You Do That" in it's best form.
zawodnik This is Lady Gagas channel, she can’t copyright her own movie
leavebritneyalone Yeah I realised
Please Give Lady the Oscar 🏆
🙏🏻
Trueeeee
Andrea Watson Mmmmm I don’t think so.
Her acting sucked
Andrea Watson For original song 🙏🏼
I love how this Is supposed to be the "not her style" song of the movie, and still Is a hit.
I know this was supposed to be the "bad" song from the movie, but it's literally everything we ever wanted haha. Along with Heal me, Hair Body Face and is that alright.
This is the pop-drought people, we're dying of thirst here. We need everything we can get.
I don't think it was supposed to be "bad", it was supposed to be comercial which doesn't really equal to being bad
y'all are tasteless AF
This actually reminded me of her song Telephone
Gregory Pabst hair,body,face do it for yuh triple threat😭
Awesome song and video. All of the songs on "The Star Is Born" album are Amazing.
Agreed. They are so addictive.
Watched movie 5 times and bought it love Lady - Stephanie and Bradley aka Ally AND Jackson Maine😍😍😍💎👍💃
True
butterfly girl
Damn right
Andrea Watson
Lucky😇😇😇
why did you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me ?
why did you release a song I can't get out of my head ?
😆
foiv1 me toooooo
same gurl!🙉🙈
I will be honest, when i was a kid i didnt like lady gaga, i thought she was so weird and out of this world🙈 Now i see her with a completely different way and i think she is one hell of a human being with a pure heart and kindness she is just pure passion.I am so sorry Lady Gaga!! (Please dont hate i had to share)
Gaga's career is a long metaphor of dont judge a book by its cover lmao. She is amazing
@@vince1679 So true😊
Same with me!
iliana Santo SAME
when I was like idk 9 or something, I always disliked her because of these "satanic" things people called, yet I still lowkey bop to Bad Romance and Poker Face
Until recently I tried getting into Artpop and i was shocked. Then I listened to Joanne (Now my 2nd Favorite album of all time) then BTW, etc.
Now I'm a really huge fan of her, she's very talented, very loving, and very accepting to people. Now I know why many people loves her.
Same here,, when i was a kid, i thought she is bad because of media,,
I wish she released this and Heal Me as singles.
yes Heal me pls
IliberTV
The cure
Heal me
Why did you do that
Ill never love again
Heal me yes
No ???? Thats superficial and the lyrics are so dumb
@@LizVictory It's made for clubbing, it's supposed to be light and carefree. Not everything has to be the deepest.
I know the song and the entire performance is supposed to make us really sad that Ally lost what made her original and has turned into a "generic pop artist" - but let's be real, this is an amazing performance, way better than most of the actual snl performances
Honestly
The last time saw a truly memorable SNL performance like that was when she performed “Gypsy”
I don’t think we are supposed to feel sad. We are to understand that she is just getting started in the business. She has to become popular in order for her to actually do the songs that are authentic to her. I think back to 2008/2009 and The Fame came out for Lady Gaga. Those songs were made to reflect an artist first coming out. It wasn’t until we were a few albums in and a lot of live performances of her oh the piano in order for us to understand the depth that she brings. I love this song because it’s a great starting point for a new artist that we know has the depth to continue sharing more of her story
@@akanniayodeji7881 that’s how I felt too! Gaga truly loves fun pop music, I don’t think she would do a movie that puts it down
The funny thing is how this is Gaga the way we met her beginning and era
Lmao this was supposed to be 'bad', but its actually really catchy
I actually love this song right under Shallow, it's good imo
It's not supposed to be bad, it's supposed to be superficial and betrayal of the character's more mature songwriting
Catchy doesn’t equate good.. lol
Totally love the melody...Catchy AF..cant get this song outta my friggin head...So if they were trying to make the audience unhappy?didn't work
So bad it's catchy, lol
She is the only _true_ rockstar of our generation.
Christopher.A.B rihanna too
ariana grande
Marcos Smith nope
Ldjsiwbsje Sisbye js nope
Dustin Telefoni lady gaga and ariana grande are the only people doing shit in music right now so, yes.
I'm sorry but this is my favorite song of the album
I like Hair Body Face a lot too!
Luv it too! 😊
디마스타 Arizona Sky is mine.
Shallow by far, but this is still a bop! 😁🤟🏼 #lg6
디마스타 you should be sorry fool
Diane Warren co-wrote the song and defended its lyrics, noting that it was not meant to be a "bad pop song", but rather a fun, light-hearted track to emphasize that Ally's career was on the rise as Jackson's was declining.
This isn't Lady Gaga this is Ally!
...and who is ally?
David M. Pereira the movie character
Nope she can't act
@@ΔημήτρηςΤουντούρης bitch are you like... dumb?
omg thanks
why is this my favorite song from a star is born
SAME
Always remember us this way is ten times better
@chepalle1621nah, we just like pop music
'My name is Lady GaGa, I'm here to just dance. Pop music will never be low brow' - Lady Gaga 2008
Pop music is actually pretty low rn if you ask me
@@DRXSSYOUUP Ray of Light, The Fame Monster, The Velvet Rope, Butterfly, Like a Prayer, Purple Rain & In The zone all say hi
Ken Alexandre Meridi They said RIGHT NOW. Those albums you mentioned are iconic, but they came out a long time ago. I don’t really think today’s music sucks, but it’s hard to find artist that got me feeling the way Gaga did in the 2010s lol.
Ken Alexandre Meridi They said right now. Not older iconic songs.
@@DRXSSYOUUP I think she meant it as it will never die off. Right now there's still pop like Ari, and Halsey. It's just not as good as Gaga, Rih, Bey
They did terrible making this song “bad” because it’s great when Lady G sings it. Anything she sings turns into gold
This Ally girl has a good and strong vocals... reminds me of Lady Gaga
This song is so basic, yet it's better than half of the music in the charts today.
This simple mediocre pop song of Ally can easily kill all the trashy pop songs today. Thanks to Gaga, she has no plans to release this as single.
Kzar DS lmao this song is supposed to be a “trashy pop song”. It’s easily the worst on the soundtrack
@@josemedina7773 when the worst song on the soundtrack is a bop that's saying something
I don't think so...I think it's terrible."Heal Me" could have been a better option..
you joking this song is actual shite
it's shitty as hell
This song is such a bop. Ally snapped
This kind of music reminded me of her early 2000s The Fame era. Can't believe how far she's come now 😭
The fame came out in 2008 but ok...
@@discomillennium she had music before 2008
no it doesnt 💀💀💀
Jackson died for this! It needs to go platinum
This is genuinely one of my favorite songs on the soundtrack. It's a certified BOP.
Listen to brand new music from Bradley Cooper & Lady Gaga from the 'A Star Is Born' Soundtrack: smarturl.it/ASIBSoundtrack
U are amazing! 1st comment🙌
GaGa Brazil te ama sz
Segundo a comentar ;)
It's a beautiful song gaga. Can I get a heart from you, please..... Please
Cool
You’re telling me they had Gaga do a whole routine to this song on a set and didn’t film all of it?????
In this film, even the music made to be bad can be incredibly nice 😂
Unfortunately
I realize this song is meant to be “shallow” (pun) & the pop manufacturing of her label, all not true to her real voice. But this song is literally what the gays throw down for and wanted from this soundtrack.
I love that they made a song and a part of the movie that shows how the music industry change the concept and personality of a singer, like Ally.
This is the point I got really exited about Ally, clearly becoming a superstar 😍
She brings such joy to me , unbelievable voice and talent
Wow thank you !!!
i really love that type of jokey/sarcastc/ironic pop songs and i cant think of many other than This one, intuition, on a roll and most of what poppy makes
I really like this song, it sounds like a first single for a nighties’ girl pop group and I’m weak for it. The percussion gets me every time. It’s not true to Ally’s voice at all but I love it.
This song should be in a workout class or video
this song is a bop but who else prefers her in the emotional, deep-slow, heart wrenching songs?
That's the point. This song is supposed to be the opposite of her character's usual type of songs
@@ollakinanti9070 i know that's what's supposed to be i'm just saying i prefer her in the other songs, simpler but better.
Probably the GP. Not me tho. I prefer the Pop Bops
Bad romance, poker face, Venus, just dance, government hooker,
All that jazz
@@kenalexandremeridi i still jam to those songs too but if i had to choose, i would've had her in the emotional ones any day!!
JisooKomBlackpinkKru did jackson maine ghostwrite this comment
Lady gaga deserves the recognition that Beyoncé gets. Being so versatile with her style in music and then her multiple talents. She can sing, dance, play multiple instruments, speaks multiple languages, acts exceptionally well, and most importantly stays true to herself beyond everything else.
Ik this is a total dig at today’s pop music but I’m actually addicted to this 😍❤️😂
While the production is just supposed to be generic pop-trap style of today's music...her voice and pitch control is just outstanding. Thus, makes it a bop to me. A lot of new singers out now rely on so much auto tune and her vocals have so much raw emotion in them, even in a song like this.
I love this song! It should have been a single, and I love her hair red for some reason.
Ally Maine coming for Lady Gaga's wig
yuor stopin wig fas
Love to hear her sing in person oh my God , thats pitch perfect 🥰
U enrich my life thru your music !!!
Nu
Hehe gagas natural era. I already predicted this will happen. Slay as always
Everthing she does Turns to Gold !!!!
I know Bradley Cooper's character was disappointed by this song in the film but we need to admit... Its a freaken BANGER!
Idk Gaga is Gaga, no matter what...
She’s good at everything🤘😌✨
Kinda dancing too this 💃😅 having that Gaga feels 💙🔥🔥
Why is this not the biggest song in the world?! So good!
wow...without the the makeup and having brown hair she looks...AMAZING
Damn GIRL, you really can do it ALL!!!
Been listening to Lady Gaga since I was kid. I love this woman so much✨
Am I the only one that thinks Gaga looks so much better with orange hair??😅
It’s her best song and I’m not kidding
yeeeees, im obsessed
this lowkey a bop tho. I can’t get it out of my head 😂
Utpyoy
This needs to be her new era idc if its "generic" everyone's trying to hard to be different.
I felt so sad when I first heard her sing this in the movie - now I absolutely love it 😍 Lady gaga is a queen 👑
Give them the Oscar already ....they deserve it
there’s a huge undertone of sadness in this song despite being a generic pop single and i think people often pay attention to the simplicity of the lyrics but not the emotion behind it which for me hits home in terms of emotional relationships
Wonderful and catchy song. 🎶 Epic Movie!🎥
*GAGA IS SO PRETTY OMG* 🤩
Love this song only Lady Gaga can make this song what it is 😊
She is the musical icon of our generation
Thanks so much for this video
This is amazing ❤❤🙏
I seriously can’t over this song !
I’m seriously in love !
In theatres i was super cringed out but this song is a banger
This song is honestly awesome IMO
2 years later and it’s still a bop
The verses remind me of the melody in Destiny Child’s “Bills Bills Bills”
Omg yess
This is STILL a bop.
I workout to this 💪🏻
This and Hair Body Face are legitimately superb pop songs, honestly
This song is a Bop I don’t care what the movie wants you to think
Who Remembers When She Perforned Judas On Snl? That Was An Iconic Performance As Well. ❤️
Amo está canción,Gaga la real reina del pop
Damn it’s 2020 guys... I wan’t stop the time and see this movie again and again in the cinema
I worked in this scene:) You can see the back of my head right as Alec enters :P lol
Lucky you
i still wonder about the full performance, the full choreo
Haha nice!! 😂
wow that's actually amazing, did you get to meet Lady GaGa?
How did you get there
At first, this song feels like, "nah." But when I listen to it more, this is a BOP. Gaga, thank you.
Igoyiuou
Eu tô apaixonada por todas as músicas desse filme ! ♥️♥️
SO MANY GOOD SONGS IN THIS MOVIE!!!
This song never lose it magic
Why do i love that song so much???
Gaga is awesome!
You can loose control and still be free baby. I have completely lost control.
It's strange because the lyrics are so superficial, yet she sounds so passionate singing it, the "why did you do that'" really sounds like agony lol
The performance and song reminds me a little bit of alejandro and bad romance
when everything you touch only turns to gold
This song is supposed to be vapid sell-out generic pop yet it's a billion times better than anything on Katy Perry's 143
I mean the song follows every generic pop song criteria, trap beat, vocals follow percussion, no hint of actual instruments, over saturated bass that overthrows vocals in chorus, repetitive chorus
Taste of Love Teaser:
Issa bop... jack is just jealous
Did anyone think this song is a premonition to the rest of the movie?
WOW!!! Love this song 🎵.🥰😁
I will forever be a little monster, cause even when they meant to make this a generic pop song, she can’t make a bad song 😭
Still listening to this
ally queen of pop
The irony of this song being a total smash and proving the point of the movie that shallow music rocks more than deep music nowadays.
What does it say about me if this is my favorite song from the movie
I’m obsessed with this song. I loved the movie.
Ahhhhh Why did you do THAT to me??? Holy Jackson they are so in love!!
This is Awesome!!! Love it so much... Gaga!!! You should give us a whole album as ALLY... BRAVO!!!