a bunch of source i saw say the koalitsiya sv has a max firing range of 70 or 50 whit the rocket boosted shell and 80 km or even 70 km seems unlikely as the round is smaller. also most sources except for wiki say it has a max rpm of 10 not 16
80 km is often written as being due to the Krasnopol smart projectile (modification for this self-propelled gun), but the range of conventional projectiles is 70 km. I have almost never seen or heard of 50 km anywhere, most likely the Ukrainian side is writing this with the aim of belittling the data of the Russian Howitzer for propaganda, since I can no longer justify the 50 km, which even Wikipedia does not write about.
Even the Russian defense unit claims 16 rounds per minute, not sources that can write about anything. 16 rounds per minute is true, they also say about the fully automatic loading. But as for the range, many do not see the difference between a rocket/guided projectile and a regular high-explosive fragmentation projectile.
@@bigwillyj4083 Longer barrel, Polish ballistic computer. Polish FCS/quasi BMS Topaz. Electric turret drives - not hydraulic. It is not entirely a hybrid, because the Krab chassis was initially a modification of the SUM-Kalina chassis with elements of the PT-91 Tank - UPG-NG. Only after the defeat did HSW look for a replacement, so the optimization was not towards creating an AS90 or K9 hybrid.
@@bigwillyj4083 The work is progressing. In addition, one of the key subsystems of the artillery division are command and command-staff vehicles. Polish. If someone does not understand their presence and role, they are ignorant. Additionally, the Topaz system is integrated with Fly Eye drones. Which were successful in Ukraine. If someone does not understand their role, they are ignorant.
Less than a month ago, a Krab was burned in the border area of Sumy Oblast by a strike drone; many self-propelled guns of this type were destroyed before. The PZH-2000 was destroyed only thanks to counter-battery fire after being hit by a 203mm shell from a “Malka”, especially since it sometimes withstood a drone hit.
@@isadanjan4762 now compare the method and frequency of servicing, especially the barrel in PzH2000 and and compare it with the technical requirement of Krab. I'm not saying that Krab is the best in the world... but not a word about it - that's a scam
This is not a K-9 variant. The Krab uses a Korean chassis. You could just as easily say that the Singapore howitzer is a variant of the M 109. It also uses the same chassis.
Why are towed artillery still in use? I know they are cheaper but are they still effective in modern warfare, they cant move as fast as self propelled howitzer in case of counterbattery fire.
@@scothf1273most are being replaced by wheeled vehicles with a mounted gun. As a truck is needed to move a gun, one mounted on it is the more obvious choice with modern counter battery capacity.
Where is Polish AHS Krab? One of the most potent and easy to use SPHs?
Krab is a variant of k9
@@VTUGYT No The Krab has a chassis from the K9 and the turret is an upgraded version of the AS-90
@@VTUGYT Only podwozie
@@lisekpl123that is the definition of a varient of...
krab in its place - in a scrap yard
Polish AHS Krab counts, the rest are wrecks - and not a word about him here
wrecks is a bit too much
Polish Krab missing - almost indestructible barrel
Artillery is the king of battle.
Since Napoleon era at least
pretty sure the m109 has a max rate of fire of 6+ per minute because i saw a video of them shooting 6 rounds in 1 minut
a bunch of source i saw say the koalitsiya sv has a max firing range of 70 or 50 whit the rocket boosted shell and 80 km or even 70 km seems unlikely as the round is smaller. also most sources except for wiki say it has a max rpm of 10 not 16
80 km is often written as being due to the Krasnopol smart projectile (modification for this self-propelled gun), but the range of conventional projectiles is 70 km.
I have almost never seen or heard of 50 km anywhere, most likely the Ukrainian side is writing this with the aim of belittling the data of the Russian Howitzer for propaganda, since I can no longer justify the 50 km, which even Wikipedia does not write about.
Even the Russian defense unit claims 16 rounds per minute, not sources that can write about anything. 16 rounds per minute is true, they also say about the fully automatic loading. But as for the range, many do not see the difference between a rocket/guided projectile and a regular high-explosive fragmentation projectile.
Whaatttt, no Polish Krab ???😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 Shame of you.
You mean the K-9 AS-90 hybrid. It isn't a separate design. It is just another version of the K-9 or AS-90 depending on who you ask.
@@bigwillyj4083 Longer barrel, Polish ballistic computer. Polish FCS/quasi BMS Topaz. Electric turret drives - not hydraulic. It is not entirely a hybrid, because the Krab chassis was initially a modification of the SUM-Kalina chassis with elements of the PT-91 Tank - UPG-NG. Only after the defeat did HSW look for a replacement, so the optimization was not towards creating an AS90 or K9 hybrid.
@@solutioco7059 come back when you have your own design. Subsystems that are basically licensed to you aren't Polish.
@@bigwillyj4083 The work is progressing. In addition, one of the key subsystems of the artillery division are command and command-staff vehicles. Polish. If someone does not understand their presence and role, they are ignorant. Additionally, the Topaz system is integrated with Fly Eye drones. Which were successful in Ukraine. If someone does not understand their role, they are ignorant.
PzH2000 has wore durability than AHS Krab, Ukraine vrified that Krab is better
He'll tell you anything for a piece of Polish bacon
Less than a month ago, a Krab was burned in the border area of Sumy Oblast by a strike drone; many self-propelled guns of this type were destroyed before. The PZH-2000 was destroyed only thanks to counter-battery fire after being hit by a 203mm shell from a “Malka”, especially since it sometimes withstood a drone hit.
@@isadanjan4762 now compare the method and frequency of servicing, especially the barrel in PzH2000 and and compare it with the technical requirement of Krab. I'm not saying that Krab is the best in the world... but not a word about it - that's a scam
@@baszta1000Nope. PZH more range, armor and finding per minute.
Everyone who is saying polish ahs krab is Missing it is a variant of k9 only original systems are mentioned in the list
This is not a K-9 variant. The Krab uses a Korean chassis. You could just as easily say that the Singapore howitzer is a variant of the M 109. It also uses the same chassis.
SSPH-1? That's too much.
❤❤❤
Turkish Fırtına
Where is india K9 vajr
K9 vajra is just the Indian variant of K9 thunder😂
In the Marine Corps, I served on an 8 inchM110 an M109 self-propelled like it a lot better than the towed systems
Why are towed artillery still in use? I know they are cheaper but are they still effective in modern warfare, they cant move as fast as self propelled howitzer in case of counterbattery fire.
@@scothf1273most are being replaced by wheeled vehicles with a mounted gun. As a truck is needed to move a gun, one mounted on it is the more obvious choice with modern counter battery capacity.
You should have added the South African G-6 Rhino SPG, to the list.
❤
❤😂😂🎉🎉😢😢😢😮😮😮😅😅😅
Wear is Serbian Nora, Aleksandar, Perun, Sosna ....?
G6 Rhino from South Africa should be on list and number one, mobility and firepower max distance. the best.
This Channel doesnt have a clue of what there talking about!!
Το γερμανικό είναι το καλύτερο αυτοκινούμενο πυροβόλο των 155mm
Looking at problems nato arty faced in ukraine since they are not developed for an intense combat its a pretty weird list..
US M1299 Missing
It was cancelled
and Russian/Chian SPH????? R U Joke? 🐜
where is Turkish fırtına 1-2?
It is considered as a derivative of K9 (Yes, the turret is a Turkish design)
Once you design something yourself you will be mentioned.
@@bigwillyj4083 hahahah
You are god damn right
@@bigwillyj4083 If you got Fiat Regata in your list, you don't mention Tofas Sahin.
Where Type 99😅
Copy of Russian sv