The Biggest Mapping Mistake of 𝗔𝗟𝗟 𝗧𝗜𝗠𝗘

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 4,8 тис.

  • @johnnyharris
    @johnnyharris  2 роки тому +685

    Hey thanks for watching!
    A couple things:
    I have a patreon where I share map backgrounds from videos as well as the actual scripts, you can find that here: www.patreon.com/johnnyharris
    I had custom presets & luts that I use to color my videos and photos. I developed them over a year with a professional colorist. In incase that’s interesting to you, here they are: store.dftba.com/collections/johnny-harris/products/johnny-iz-luts-and-presets
    Lastly, let me know if there is a video you’d like me to make, I’m always on the lookout for ideas and want to know what you’d like to see: www.johnnyharris.ch/submit-ideas

    • @Tobycalous
      @Tobycalous 2 роки тому +3

      Cool

    • @Jokingparrot
      @Jokingparrot 2 роки тому +3

      2nd

    • @admo001
      @admo001 2 роки тому +3

      ok

    • @bradavon
      @bradavon 2 роки тому +2

      Can you leave the text on screen for longer or make it snappier please. Keep having to pause the video.

    • @bradavon
      @bradavon 2 роки тому +5

      Israel/Palestine. We keep asking :)

  • @theo8023
    @theo8023 2 роки тому +3165

    After some of Johnny‘s last videos received criticism for oversimplifying historical events, I really like how this video responds to that by providing sources and including disclaimers! I think that makes those videos even better, good work!

    • @Tylru
      @Tylru 2 роки тому +66

      Still a long way to go, to be honest - Lots of incorrect statements (with and without disclaimers). Also, nobody reads disclaimers.

    • @pablocardenas3448
      @pablocardenas3448 2 роки тому +135

      @@Tylru I read disclaimers

    • @ellishaindobo1794
      @ellishaindobo1794 2 роки тому +2

      Brooo

    • @Tylru
      @Tylru 2 роки тому +9

      @@pablocardenas3448 That makes one of us

    • @davidanderson_surrey_bc
      @davidanderson_surrey_bc 2 роки тому +17

      @@Tylru Actually, that makes two of us.

  • @GoatAmv
    @GoatAmv 2 роки тому +2700

    When did California stop being an island?
    It took more exploration, but by 1747 King Ferdinand VI of Spain was convinced. He issued a decree stating that California was -- once and for all -- not an island. It took another century for cartographers to completely abandon the notion.

    • @dcshooters
      @dcshooters 2 роки тому +31

      That is the limit of psychic thought at the time but the whole west coast was infact an island and resembled California. No need to hate, thumbs down.

    • @johnl.7754
      @johnl.7754 2 роки тому +53

      and then the long awaited 10+ San Andre earthquake hits and California actually becomes an island and Las Vegas has beach front property

    • @BudOnTheLeaves
      @BudOnTheLeaves 2 роки тому +34

      Well that just saved me 25 minutes lol

    • @AirFuzz
      @AirFuzz 2 роки тому +1

      Did he call the police?? 😆

    • @Hunter-tn7og
      @Hunter-tn7og 2 роки тому +10

      100 years? 1847 was when they stopped? that's the dead middle of the Mexican American war in which America took California, the California and old Spanish trail were like 15 to 20 years old by then.

  • @realFranklinfurter
    @realFranklinfurter 2 роки тому +9581

    Johnny Harris: used to be 19 year old Mormon missionary, now just wakes up random guys on the train to tell them about the video's sponsor 🤣🤣🤣

    • @TorturedMongoose2003
      @TorturedMongoose2003 2 роки тому +710

      Let's face it that guy was extremely patient.

    • @andrewmcglashan9770
      @andrewmcglashan9770 2 роки тому +419

      I changed this comment so you won’t know why it was liked so much

    • @Ninten007
      @Ninten007 2 роки тому +285

      Now I’m just going to be hyper-aware whenever I’m on the metro in case Johnny wants to tell me about sponsors.

    • @realmless4193
      @realmless4193 2 роки тому +187

      5:10 is super fitting for a former Mormon missionary to do. Props to the guy.

    • @santoshdoifode7410
      @santoshdoifode7410 2 роки тому +215

      He was Johnny Harris cameraman 👍
      Logic guys 🔥

  • @eduardof7322
    @eduardof7322 Рік тому +109

    Good moment to remind you all that the original California is actually Baja California. American California was originally called Higher California for being the territory north of California, but since it became the popular one, the old California changed its name to Southern California. The California that all those legends and myths refer to and the one that was mistaken for an island for centuries, is actually Baja California.

    • @kimiside
      @kimiside Рік тому +1

      ., а нупту##(ЖЖ

    • @nicolasblume1046
      @nicolasblume1046 Рік тому +9

      Not quite, the fake maps showed ALL of california as an Island. It was shown much bigger than Baja california, so I think they meant that the whole of it was an Island

    • @Violet-qf8dr
      @Violet-qf8dr Рік тому +15

      California being an island once would explain why Death Valley is lower than sea level. It would also explain the Salton Sea, a salt water lake that is below sea level, also located in the former channel.

    • @igotthejuice2090
      @igotthejuice2090 Рік тому

      Baja California isn’t an island soooooooo what’s your point

    • @jessbawoke
      @jessbawoke Рік тому

      ?Legends and myths? Not factual evidence? Like misinformation, not latent lies? Troll...

  • @tomaikenhead
    @tomaikenhead 2 роки тому +1530

    I studied Californian history in college. I had one excellent class that was centered on the idea that California is, in fact, an island, in spite of being quite firmly attached to North America. Politically, historically, culturally, ecologically, geologically, it is separated from the rest of the continent. It was home to far and away the most cultural and linguistic diversity in pre-contact North America. It’s home to a dizzying array of endemic and unique species. It’s charted a separate political course since joining the Union. And it’s hard to get to. California is an island, even though it’s also not.

    • @anonimushbosh
      @anonimushbosh 2 роки тому +29

      You just described the USA, but left out the bit about unifying such a motley crew of disparate regions into one whole.

    • @cheskolpz3907
      @cheskolpz3907 2 роки тому +46

      As an Inhabitant of lower California I can confirm that even in the Mexico side is an Island. Everything is too far away.

    • @fallencielo2701
      @fallencielo2701 2 роки тому +24

      @@anonimushbosh Remember he is from the U.S. so basically he focus this topic more into the U.S perspective. When he talks about California fever, it’s gold, and innovation, etc it mostly focused towards the California of the U.S. “Part of the Alta California region of the past” rather than then Baja California and Baja California Sur.

    • @ilhamrj2599
      @ilhamrj2599 2 роки тому +6

      bro, Johnny talked about Island as in geographically… Not politically or something intangible.😅
      of course

    • @jk484
      @jk484 2 роки тому +5

      And you can only enter it by land at seven places

  • @chymaneYT
    @chymaneYT 2 роки тому +4441

    That sponsorship section though. The guy looked so confused then just kinda accepted it. 🤣🤣

    • @Makker_1
      @Makker_1 2 роки тому +324

      Yeah that was so not needed! XD

    • @kumbaya497
      @kumbaya497 2 роки тому +146

      it got my attention :D

    • @notafantbh
      @notafantbh 2 роки тому +43

      Genius

    • @louchis-8814
      @louchis-8814 2 роки тому +192

      Yh, one of the only times I didn't skip.
      I mostly skip because it is mostly better help and nord vpn

    • @azurict
      @azurict 2 роки тому +68

      i didn't skip it, you're a genius Johnny

  • @smax4895
    @smax4895 2 роки тому +617

    The fact that he can tell such interesting stories through the lens of cartography is amazing to me.

  • @berklia
    @berklia Рік тому +110

    The map is not entirely a mistake since the today's California entire Central Valley was once one of the largest lakes on the continent. If explorers saw this lake (which was brackish in some parts) they could easily have thought that California was an island. Though this large lake is almost completely gone today, it's remnants & deposits are why California is the most agriculturally prolific land in the world today.

    • @prometheus8010
      @prometheus8010 Рік тому +9

      Time to unblock the dams

    • @jennyanimal9046
      @jennyanimal9046 Рік тому +3

      The California basin has been filled 15 times in a certain amount of time, I forget how long it was. As a Californian I find it interesting.

    • @clayton19931
      @clayton19931 Місяць тому +2

      Before the dams were built the whole valley would flood during years of heavy rainfall

    • @surfernorm6360
      @surfernorm6360 Місяць тому

      Good news there are many youtube reports that the lake is reemerging due to climate change and just to spite Chump and make into the fool he appears to be.

    • @siliconvalleymobileevcharging
      @siliconvalleymobileevcharging 25 днів тому +2

      Best comment, facts!

  • @mitkoivanov3399
    @mitkoivanov3399 2 роки тому +455

    Love to see that he included a full google doc of the sources 'cause now I kinda wanna read some of the old books and letters that show how california was portrayed in the past.

    • @jafrazer
      @jafrazer 2 роки тому +13

      I love that the first video that sources have appeared on is essentially about how misinformation can spread! 😄

    • @michenerkruse
      @michenerkruse 2 роки тому +2

      Yep, really awesome sourcing!

    • @BlackOwnedSoulSistah
      @BlackOwnedSoulSistah 19 днів тому

      An island ran by indigenous woman. One of the most famous Queen Kalifa

  • @nunnaurbiznez8815
    @nunnaurbiznez8815 2 роки тому +737

    So, if you're a map guy, I know that you know that cartographers were notorious for cheating by copying other cartographer's maps. It only took one guy to accidently get it wrong,(or lie). Who can afford to go check? They eventually started placing islands that didn't exist so they could see who was copying their legit work. #sandyislanddoesntexist

    • @chelloho
      @chelloho 2 роки тому +77

      Fun fact: cartographers still do that to this day, but with fake parks, streets, sometimes entire towns.

    • @GeographyGeek
      @GeographyGeek 2 роки тому +51

      There were no copyright laws during the Island of California days. It's not that they cheated as much as professional cartographers were not typically explorers and so they relied on the accounts of others which included from other nations and maps. Sometimes they were not sure was correct but went with what seemed like the most credible theory. It wasn't brought up in the video but it's common to see the same cartographer have maps published in the same few years that actually contradict each other.

    • @ColFlustered
      @ColFlustered 2 роки тому +17

      @@GeographyGeek the fact that these guys could roll up to the edge of a place and draw it out baffles me. I so often want to live without all of the perks of technology, but then I realize I'm literally incapable. 🤣 I have no useful skills so people who do are incredible to me.

    • @ailo4x4
      @ailo4x4 2 роки тому +27

      @@ColFlustered As sailors (I'm retired Navy) we know our navigation extremely well. That means we can sail along the coast of somewhere and take sightings. We know where we are so we can tell where something else is if we can see it. By plotting those sighting out we can create maps. Not only did those sail era sailors plot the land, they also charted the off shore soundings (depths) and seabed material (for anchoring). It's just hard work but very doable if you got your navigation skills. Fair winds!

    • @sabersin5368-c2c
      @sabersin5368-c2c 2 роки тому +3

      *You’re

  • @vyperz6946
    @vyperz6946 2 роки тому +1054

    This guy just talked about geography for 24 minutes and I was entertained the entire time

    • @stephonriley7491
      @stephonriley7491 2 роки тому +5

      same

    • @adm8849
      @adm8849 2 роки тому +40

      because geography is interesting

    • @243wayne1
      @243wayne1 2 роки тому +17

      I fell asleep, only to find California is located in the same place it always was. Class dismissed.

    • @dianaroach3093
      @dianaroach3093 2 роки тому +2

      My husband surveys for a living. I love it. ❤️.

    • @MindMagick222
      @MindMagick222 Рік тому +1

      I was enthralled, his story telling is epic! Felt like I was on a treasure hunt with him!

  • @arjun_dixit
    @arjun_dixit Рік тому +9

    Johnny, your chosen topics are a smash hit even before the quality of your videos and content. Always. Thanks for continuously satisfying my constant hunger to learn new stuff. :) I'm glad we have your YT channel out there. Keep going my friend, power to you.

  • @itsarnieho
    @itsarnieho 2 роки тому +365

    Love the addition of the notes and sources. This is why I’m a fan of Johnny. He is genuine and listens to his audience

    • @vegacito9889
      @vegacito9889 2 роки тому +8

      "Fray" Antonio...means "priest" Antonio in Spanish, it's not his first name;) Amazing video by the way!

    • @tearman005
      @tearman005 2 роки тому

      @@vegacito9889 you are completely wrong dude. the word fray doesnt exist in spain

    • @markroche9812
      @markroche9812 2 роки тому +1

      @@tearman005 yes it does, although it means “friar” and not priest, but close enough

    • @jbvideoshow
      @jbvideoshow 2 роки тому

      Oh really? See my research please.

    • @abrehamt.379
      @abrehamt.379 Місяць тому

      ​jbvideoshow
      Where are the Subs?

  • @AmogusPhage
    @AmogusPhage 2 роки тому +877

    It’s good to see Johnny listening to criticism and providing annotations when he simplifies history.

    • @bengiyardimli1925
      @bengiyardimli1925 2 роки тому +7

      Seems a little passive aggressive though.

    • @mothralord1709
      @mothralord1709 2 роки тому +42

      @@bengiyardimli1925 isnt it just self improvement to be a more reliable source of info

    • @kingace6186
      @kingace6186 2 роки тому +7

      @@bengiyardimli1925 Very passive-aggressive, indeed. I swear, hella people on the internet just want him to make videos on their whims.

    • @Gdsamplify
      @Gdsamplify 2 роки тому +8

      All re tellings is history are biased anyway

    • @perspicacioussimpleton7288
      @perspicacioussimpleton7288 2 роки тому +5

      @@kingace6186 How is it passive aggressive? Is it not immediate improvement and self correction? Like, that's how I go about self reflection and improvement. What have I been doing wrong?

  • @miguelrodriguez-df8ww
    @miguelrodriguez-df8ww 2 роки тому +416

    that man looked so confused during the ad break lol. if he was faking it he played his part well.

    • @KarimKhanZ
      @KarimKhanZ 2 роки тому +37

      That’s how you make and ad break so people don’t skip it

    • @tsuol7296
      @tsuol7296 2 роки тому +43

      i felt uncomfrotable watching that lmao

    • @K3rrJu5t1n
      @K3rrJu5t1n 2 роки тому +5

      That guy: "W h a t"

    • @JustFrago
      @JustFrago 2 роки тому +7

      @@tsuol7296 I felt uncomfortable on his behalf 😆

    • @johnmichaelgalgana5637
      @johnmichaelgalgana5637 2 роки тому +10

      that was the cameraman

  • @phoenixthottam5793
    @phoenixthottam5793 Рік тому +1

    Thanks!

  • @chymaneYT
    @chymaneYT 2 роки тому +346

    Love that the sources and disclaimers are added to the video this time around. Great video👍👍

    • @ko_tech
      @ko_tech 2 роки тому +4

      Johnny has probably taken an inspiration from his previous video :D

    • @girlsquad224
      @girlsquad224 2 роки тому +2

      IKR. As every content creator should. It's taught in school, and must be applied in real life.

    • @damunzy
      @damunzy 2 роки тому +3

      @@ko_tech yeah, he did a horrible job on his China video and got called out on it. Made me question his ethics especially since he wasn't citing sources or disclosing all sources of funding.

    • @FirestormX9
      @FirestormX9 2 роки тому

      @@damunzy rubbish. Dude, anyone who believes into that kind of shit is not seeking real knowledge at all. They're just looking to make themselves believe they're already aware or highly intelligent by having their biases confirmed. When it's not, they go on a tirade. Laughable

    • @damunzy
      @damunzy 2 роки тому +3

      @@FirestormX9 calling him out for lack of citing is rubbish? You know he acknowledged that and has made improvements on his latest video. Don't be a knee jerk apologist for Johnny. Keeping UA-camrs honest by calling them out is a great thing!

  • @biolrodrigo6137
    @biolrodrigo6137 2 роки тому +48

    Bittersweet feelings from this video. As a Mexican with great memories when I lived in Ensenada, Baja California I really enjoyed understanding why the peninsula was drawn as an island for so long. I was first introduced to it in a historical museum in Ensenada and I couldn't understand how Baja California passed from an island to a peninsula to an island again. On the other hand, kinda sad that these feelings of the "magic" land of success are associated nowadays only with American California. Don't get me wrong. Baja California is a beautiful place. I felt in love with all it's ecosystems. However, passing the border from Tijuana to San Diego always left me with a kinda sad feeling. Baja California and California split exactly the developing countries of Latin America and the first world. You can feel the economical consequences of history right there.

  • @Thebreakdownshow1
    @Thebreakdownshow1 2 роки тому +606

    It’s a good day when Johnny comes out with a film. One of the reasons I started making films.

    • @tranbaohoangvu9464
      @tranbaohoangvu9464 2 роки тому +2

      ...hm...

    • @K3rrJu5t1n
      @K3rrJu5t1n 2 роки тому +5

      1:46 "Luckily I lived in DC"
      IRS: "Man, what a lucky day!"

    • @Andrew19ao
      @Andrew19ao 2 роки тому +3

      or UA-cam videos too

    • @Thebreakdownshow1
      @Thebreakdownshow1 2 роки тому +1

      @@Andrew19ao LOL fair enough youtube videos as well.

    • @TOMINTOM-si8hd
      @TOMINTOM-si8hd 2 роки тому

      D E F U Baby de la misma o de los de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de la comisión de

  • @zestartist
    @zestartist 2 роки тому +47

    I loved how you seamlessly integrated the sponsorship plug into the journey, waking up some random guy and him slowly being intrigued just by your word of mouth plug of story blocks. First time I didn't skip ahead, but actually enjoyed this sponsorship part of the video play through

    • @bartclaeys
      @bartclaeys 2 роки тому

      You forgot the subtle product placement of MacBook and Peak Design backpack.

    • @Krumm420
      @Krumm420 2 роки тому +1

      I wanted more after that, the look on the random dudes face. Like, did Johnny just get up and walk away, was there some funny banter afterwards, wtf I need to know

    • @iamtonu1425
      @iamtonu1425 2 роки тому

      What the hell does Elizabeth Anne Holmes have to do with the Islamic "Queen" (intersex) that used to rule Khalif-Ornea before the CATHOLIC Spanish tricked her and murdered her people? You think it's coincidence that CALIF=KHALIF and a large MASONIC hotel has a room dominated by a mural of this Khalif? Means: religious leader of a Muslim state considered to be a representative of Allah on earth.

  • @leoschenk2118
    @leoschenk2118 2 роки тому +217

    Living in DC, even as someone who watches Johnny, if anyone woke me up on the metro like that, sitting next to me on an empty train, I think that face that guy made is the best case response I could possibly be expected to do

    • @nikoskoufos2588
      @nikoskoufos2588 2 роки тому +2

      I would be surprised I'm not being asked for money on the metro

    • @leoschenk2118
      @leoschenk2118 2 роки тому +4

      @@nikoskoufos2588 funnily enough, that's never actually happened to me like ON the metro, occasionally around it like outside of union station or whatever

  • @realFranklinfurter
    @realFranklinfurter 2 роки тому +43

    Johnny "Do you mind if I chat with you about something?"
    Sleeping guy "Yes"
    🤣🤣🤣🤣
    @5:02

  • @plar6045
    @plar6045 Рік тому +1

    Ok I'm in!
    I just subscribed!
    I totally enjoy your videos!

  • @michelekendzie
    @michelekendzie 2 роки тому +346

    I spent the first 29 years of my life in California so I was already aware of the name origin, but this added so much detail. Wonderful storytelling!

    • @roquesanta9769
      @roquesanta9769 2 роки тому +4

      So what’s the origin of the name?

    • @DRACULA-SS
      @DRACULA-SS 2 роки тому +1

      @@roquesanta9769 @7:34

    • @roquesanta9769
      @roquesanta9769 2 роки тому +1

      @@DRACULA-SS that is actually incorrect, the meaning of California is Cali=Hot Fornia=Oven describing the original Californias down in Baja, where it’s boiling hot

    • @grimaffiliations3671
      @grimaffiliations3671 2 роки тому +8

      @@roquesanta9769 Source? Because google says it comes from that novel

    • @roquesanta9769
      @roquesanta9769 2 роки тому

      @@grimaffiliations3671 that’s the problem with random Google, the name comes from the ‘Latin’

  • @dansanders9121
    @dansanders9121 2 роки тому +16

    One thing I love about your videos, is that you also have a deep seeded appreciation for maps, both as objects by which we teach other aspects of history, culture, etc. but also as objects of artistic beauty by themselves. From one map lover to another, I salute you sir.

  • @CalumRaasay
    @CalumRaasay 2 роки тому +91

    Beautifully shot and edited as always Johnny. Love it.

    • @Rileysworld727
      @Rileysworld727 2 роки тому +3

      Good to see you here, i love your videos

  • @CKLoving
    @CKLoving Рік тому +1

    THIS IS The Video that convinced me to subscribe to your channel! I have loved geography and maps - globes -and pirate movies since I was about 8 years old.
    And you with your amazing ability to use history and storytelling have reignited all of that in an ultimately fresh way. Truly epic!

  • @tiffanylee3634
    @tiffanylee3634 2 роки тому +259

    As a Californian, who went to the CSU system, this was fascinating to learn about my state's history. It kind of felt like an odd love letter to CA and I'm here for it. They don' call it California Dreamin' for nothing.

    • @hoosierbaddy3052
      @hoosierbaddy3052 2 роки тому +2

      “On such a winter’s day”. Is how the song goes. Yep. Dreaming about warmer weather was the point of the lyrics. If I lived in a colder climate I’d be fantasizing about warmer climes too. Calida Fornax. The Latin words that became California. It means hot furnace. And boy is it! I’m a native Californian. Witnessed all kinds of weirdness associated with a beachy state. The Sun bakes folks’s brains. We’re the shake n bake state. I’m old enough to remember Northern California wanting to secede from Southern California. 😅Two very different political and life views. Conservative north and liberal south.

    • @sriharshacv7760
      @sriharshacv7760 2 роки тому +6

      Tbh, the USA part of California is not really a part of the 'island'. They just call their coastal state by the name California for historic reasons. Technically the real 'California' would be Baja California of Mexico.

    • @asphyxiafeeling
      @asphyxiafeeling 2 роки тому +1

      I'm a CSU grad too. California history was some of my favorite things to learn about while studying there.

    • @peeko_luxx2873
      @peeko_luxx2873 2 роки тому +1

      @@hoosierbaddy3052 I feel your sentiments. Born and raised in Florida and the sun really does get to people down here too man! Cheers

    • @vogelvogeltje
      @vogelvogeltje 2 роки тому +2

      @@hoosierbaddy3052 San Francisco is 80 miles west of where I am. I can very safely say that there are a lot of liberals in NorCal

  • @nimrozs1948
    @nimrozs1948 2 роки тому +193

    Been watching Johnny forever those borders days!!! Glad he getting so much respect now! Excited for this!

  • @verdaderoken
    @verdaderoken 2 роки тому +45

    This is not just another UA-cam content. It's crazy how these contents are free and the fact that they're also well-presented makes these videos more entertaining. Great vid as always, Johnny! Cheers!

    • @damunzy
      @damunzy 2 роки тому +1

      They're only free because of the ads through UA-cam and integrated ads. His videos, while entertainingly made, really aren't that good in the information department.

  • @kalli4231
    @kalli4231 2 місяці тому

    *Very much the ice wall and outsider continents conspiracy 16th century equivalent xd*
    *LOVE UR VIDEO!*

  • @Doggieman1111
    @Doggieman1111 2 роки тому +530

    The genius of this video is that is that it realizes that California is not a geographical feature but an existential fantasy. A dream. Always has been and always will be.

  • @GreatRustavo
    @GreatRustavo 2 роки тому +172

    What a story! Seriously, let’s get more content like this. This is a history lesson that can definitely teach a lot about our population today

    • @iamtonu1425
      @iamtonu1425 2 роки тому

      What the hell does Elizabeth Anne Holmes have to do with the Islamic "Queen" (intersex) that used to rule Khalif-Ornea before the CATHOLIC Spanish tricked her and murdered her people? You think it's coincidence that CALIF=KHALIF and a large MASONIC hotel has a room dominated by a mural of this Khalif? Means: religious leader of a Muslim state considered to be a representative of Allah on earth.

    • @suomeaboo
      @suomeaboo 2 роки тому

      What a story Johnny!

  • @Hloy_Boy
    @Hloy_Boy 2 роки тому +143

    I remember actually doing a project on this in school. Did not get to the part where it got spread by pirates in my paper, so its nice to see the whole story, which I had just completely forgot.

    • @chrisp7110
      @chrisp7110 2 роки тому

      Johnny Harris is propaganda and you need ot get you facts straight. His son is also just as bad as he is. He should stop making videos because doesn't know facts and all his findings are on some western media propaganda.

    • @sophiarichard2101
      @sophiarichard2101 2 роки тому

      How are you doing?

    • @Hloy_Boy
      @Hloy_Boy 2 роки тому

      @@chrisp7110 Chris P is propaganda and you need ot get you facts straight. His son is also just as bad as he is. He should stop making videos because doesn't know facts and all his findings are on some western media propaganda.
      ...

  • @MukiBlalock
    @MukiBlalock 2 місяці тому +1

    Killer story bro! 😂❤🎉 Great job!

  • @achtube85
    @achtube85 2 роки тому +103

    What an amazing storyteller you are, Johnny. You (and your team) have the skills to make any topic extremely interesting. I am never disappointed with you all.

  • @N4K3DN1NJ4
    @N4K3DN1NJ4 2 роки тому +242

    As a critic of your second to last video, I would like to say thank you for making the improvements to your storytelling process. I know firsthand the importance of making relatable and interesting stories to help get people to learn history, and I also know how hard it is to make sure things are as accurate as possible considering that. Thank you for being willing to change to create better, more accurate, and highier quality videos. Please keep up this progress because we definitely appreciate it!

    • @daniel5610
      @daniel5610 2 роки тому +1

      I agree

    • @thisiscrazy4122
      @thisiscrazy4122 2 роки тому +7

      Hear hear, I was also impressed by that he added the sources for the video. I'm loving it !

    • @obscurehero
      @obscurehero 2 роки тому +4

      Except after saying that they have no evidence that Cortez is reading this book... The storytelling hinges on Cortez reading a book there is no evidence to suggest he read.
      I'm not sure why he can't tell an interesting story without needing to make things up...

    • @Oddricm
      @Oddricm 2 роки тому +16

      @@obscurehero He named it California without reading the book?

    • @McMurica
      @McMurica 2 роки тому +5

      you guys are sorta lame... it's youtube entertainment not a doctoral thesis

  • @SomeOne-wj3ti
    @SomeOne-wj3ti 2 роки тому +55

    I love how you use social media jargon to explain maps of all things. You'd be a great teacher Harry. I bet lots of kids would remember their classes to the T if they were told in a similiar fashion, adults included of course. Cheers!

  • @adrianasoldevila630
    @adrianasoldevila630 2 місяці тому +2

    Love the graphics 💫✨

  • @k.o.l2887
    @k.o.l2887 2 роки тому +40

    The music, the visuals, the maps and most importantly the superbly delivered information!! This is why I enjoy Johnny Harris videos especially as a Geography student.

  • @Akatsuki1289
    @Akatsuki1289 2 роки тому +74

    Would definitely be an interesting follow up video to explore how San Francisco and the Bay Area as a whole evaded the Spanish and other explorers for the longest time because of the fog.

    • @jbvideoshow
      @jbvideoshow 2 роки тому +1

      I have done extensive research.

    • @kingbobacs
      @kingbobacs Рік тому +1

      I definitely learned this during culinary school I think around the 1600s no?

    • @Caligrapher88
      @Caligrapher88 Рік тому

      How would that be? Im pretty sure they experience fog on their travels and it's not like it's foggy all day

  • @AndreeMon8
    @AndreeMon8 2 роки тому +79

    I live in Mexicali which is Baja California’s capital city, and from a very young age we are taught that the Californias will end up becoming an island in the future. I remember feeling scared that one day I would wake up to find the state broken off the continent and my house surrounded by the ocean 🤣 little I knew that event will happen millions of years from now… Hope I’m prepared by then…

    • @amatiste
      @amatiste 2 роки тому +4

      CA will shift north over time. Long after the cities have ground o dust, what was once LA will be a suburb of Seattle. But yeah, for a long time people thought it would separate, but the faults are wrong for that. San Andreas is a transform fault, with right-lateral strike slip, ie, its shifting along north south axis, with the pacific plate shifting northerly along the slower moving NA plate. Unlike the movies, we wont become an island.
      Caveat: there is some geological evidence that Baja may split off as there is a smaller fault with an east/west bearing around the salton sea spreading center. This could force baja to split away from CA itself

    • @BlueTyphoon2017
      @BlueTyphoon2017 2 роки тому +2

      @@amatiste oh damn that sucks, I still want Baja California to be attached to California.😢

    • @amatiste
      @amatiste 2 роки тому

      @@BlueTyphoon2017 unless something really big happens, you will be :) that kinda siesmic event is unlikely anytime soon

    • @Ignaciombr
      @Ignaciombr 2 роки тому +2

      hey, I'm from Tecate :)

    • @AndreeMon8
      @AndreeMon8 2 роки тому +1

      @@Ignaciombr Holaa jaja no creí encontrar a alguien tan cerca viendo videos de Johnny Harris 😅

  • @Green_Leaf
    @Green_Leaf 20 днів тому +1

    What is the possibility that Ancient Lake Corcoran and Lake Cahuilla (Salton Sea) were adjoined and adjoined into the ocean by the San Francisco area and San Diego area’s?
    I recall reading about Lake Cahuilla and that it did have ocean access at one time, hence much of its salt content.
    Maybe the Gulf of California did once adjoin with the two aforementioned Great Lakes?

  • @chancetroughton1821
    @chancetroughton1821 2 роки тому +10

    Very Entertaining and informative!
    Awesome work!! Your in-depth knowledge and storytelling capabilities are so good. Inspiring to see your work over the years .❤

  • @Mr_M_History
    @Mr_M_History 2 роки тому +231

    The internet can take all the potshots they want. They've never had to make informative and entertaining content regularly. It's good to have Johnny Harris doing what he does best!

    • @jackmiller1561
      @jackmiller1561 2 роки тому +3

      Love your history stuff and would love to see you collab with Johnny Harris!!

    • @garrywallah4966
      @garrywallah4966 2 роки тому +4

      Mitch give us the history of Dan Andrews and his war against sky news

    • @feelincrispy7053
      @feelincrispy7053 2 роки тому +1

      You’re freaking everywhere I go on the UA-cams

    • @upvotecomment2110
      @upvotecomment2110 2 роки тому +10

      "Entertaining" yes
      "Informative" that's debatable, selective history perhaps
      but yeah good to have a content creator like him. I like your channel too!
      Can't stand the west, love to see you guys succeed

    • @AceGigalo
      @AceGigalo 2 роки тому +9

      By potshots do you mean showing damn near everything he says is wrong? Lmfao

  • @patrickjdarrow
    @patrickjdarrow 2 роки тому +135

    It’s well documented that central California used to flood with some degree of seasonality. I’m curious if this has played into any hypotheses as to why California was perceived as an island by some but not others.

    • @sophiarichard2101
      @sophiarichard2101 2 роки тому

      How are you doing?

    • @r.m.strong
      @r.m.strong 2 роки тому +9

      If you speak with " listen " to indigenous oral history.
      There is record of California's desserts being flooded by ocean .
      There is even stories of spanish ships sailing in , them becoming grounded and stranded .

    • @JeffAboularage
      @JeffAboularage 2 роки тому +1

      The journals of the old Vaqueros chronicled pastures in California as green as Europe in the 1500 and 1600s. They literally sat around all day while the cattle grazed, no migrating, no looking for water. It is said, that the Spanish were able to make a good horse because of this.

    • @shells500tutubo
      @shells500tutubo 2 роки тому +4

      The San Francisco Bay went further east than it does today and actually connected with the central Valley.

    • @JeffAboularage
      @JeffAboularage 2 роки тому +3

      @@shells500tutubo Yes the Remnants can be seen in the landscape around the delta. The soil is definitely that of an ocean floor that existed not too long ago.

  • @adamf4196
    @adamf4196 Рік тому +1

    i have a small framed print of the California island map that piqued your curiosity. You have answered many of my own questions about it. I too like to study historic maps as a hobby. Well done video.

  • @josecurielm
    @josecurielm 2 роки тому +25

    Johnny's video-editing skills continue to amaze me with every single video! I'm sure it's a great inspiration for future video creators.

  • @anushkasingh9470
    @anushkasingh9470 2 роки тому +25

    I absolutely love watching your videos, Johnny! There are so many things that we do not know about and I appreciate your time and effort in making us understand them in such a simple and fun way. Thank you so much! Always looking forward to your videos :)

  • @DenDave_
    @DenDave_ 2 роки тому +61

    I've seen the maps of island-California before and never thought much of it. Just thought; ''ah so the early cartographers got it wrong, so what'', then you started giving the years the maps were made and i was astounded by how far apart they were. Then to think somehow before that there was actually an accurate map too is even crazier.

    • @DenDave_
      @DenDave_ 2 роки тому +1

      Additional comment; the fact that it was the people of my own country (the Dutch) that re-created the myth of it being an island is amazingly funny.

  • @SkaterStimm
    @SkaterStimm Рік тому +4

    I moved to California in 2004 at 24 years old, and I left everything and everyone to come here. Yes I did have a fantasy that California was going to be this mystical place where beautiful woman and jobs grow on trees, although it wasn't exactly what I was dreaming of it was way better than where I was coming from. It was the best decision of my life. Yes it was a struggle but I did it, now raising a native born Californian.

  • @kingace6186
    @kingace6186 2 роки тому +46

    This was surprisingly one of Johnny Harris's most entertaining videos.

  • @danherrick2310
    @danherrick2310 2 роки тому +15

    the real hero is public transportation man at 6:00. what an absolute champ

  • @sm11199305
    @sm11199305 2 роки тому +27

    Johnny is a Venn diagram intersection of intrigue and hard work. This was awesome!

  • @mattr8090
    @mattr8090 13 днів тому +1

    The Central Valley of California used to be a giant lake that’s why the farm soil there is rich and great for farming. Do it could have looked like a lake.

  • @mithunnair8587
    @mithunnair8587 2 роки тому +85

    The amount of curiosity Johnny has for maps is so interesting to see 😂

    • @goosenotmaverick1156
      @goosenotmaverick1156 2 роки тому +3

      I really enjoy looking at maps when I come across them, but this story may stem a whole new thing for me, as if I need something new to collect 🤣

  • @sarahwatts7152
    @sarahwatts7152 2 роки тому +96

    I'd love to see Johnny do a deep dive on how different video games make maps

  • @tarafrancis8160
    @tarafrancis8160 2 роки тому +17

    I love how John Townsend is in the boat with all the other explorers 14:25

  • @CasualCatOfficial
    @CasualCatOfficial 2 місяці тому +3

    5:03 my social anxiety skyrocketed 😭

  • @MR.CLEAN777
    @MR.CLEAN777 2 роки тому +21

    6:17 Bro doesnt give af

  • @adityabhosle9499
    @adityabhosle9499 2 роки тому +21

    The amount of research and effort you and your team put into a video is nothing but respectable.
    You've gained a new subscriber sir!

  • @samthesomniator
    @samthesomniator 2 роки тому +24

    I lOVE this retro style of editing and video design you use and share with channels like Vox so much! 🥰 The organic motion graphic, the analogue visual style elements. Just everything.

  • @shilacrabtree1998
    @shilacrabtree1998 21 день тому

    Wow, the title on this video totally captured me, feeding into my innate fear of earthquakes.
    TOTALLY enjoyed this video journey so much so that I liked and subscribed. Well done, especially that twisted the end.

  • @DavidBennettPiano
    @DavidBennettPiano 2 роки тому +16

    9:28 Hogwarts is actually in Scotland, not Wales. FACT-CHECK NEXT TIME JOHNNY OMG!!1!

  • @keagaming9837
    @keagaming9837 2 роки тому +31

    17:13 There is a strait and northern passage above North America that can be navigated to get to Spain, it is called the Bering Strait and the Arctic Ocean. Though it might be a bit unuseable during most times of the year.

  • @kylepickus5712
    @kylepickus5712 2 роки тому +106

    10:20 Looking at the Native description of the “island of women with gold,” from an anthropological perspective it is not absurd to think about. Men and women in many tribal societies tend to live separately from one another, and linguistically speaking it is not rediculous to think the word they may have had for separate could’ve bore some semblance to a word for “island,” as an island is by definition separate. And hey, they were right about the gold too.

    • @Enyavar1
      @Enyavar1 2 роки тому +7

      they had realized what the Spaniards wanted, and told them where they "knew" that stuff was located... "over there where the unfriendly neighbor lives, go away and bother THEM".
      The Inka and Aztecs would have been _fine_ if they had disabused the Euros of that "gold" fixation from the start, and entire nations wouldn't have uprooted themselves for a promised land.
      "No, what little gold we have took centuries of mining and washing, and all of us work very hard (you should try that too) and my daughter is already promised, as well".
      On a second thought... would that have worked on fanatical people who had just invented the inquisition to get the answers they want through torture??

    • @trinchuzosparty
      @trinchuzosparty 2 роки тому +6

      @@Enyavar1 wow. You twist history in a very propagandistic way. Congratulations on your skill.

    • @blugaledoh2669
      @blugaledoh2669 2 роки тому

      Why do men and women live apart?

    • @kylepickus5712
      @kylepickus5712 2 роки тому

      @@blugaledoh2669 it is actually very sexist. Many tribes believe that men and women are inherently different, and once a boy reaches a certain age, being raised or simply being around their mother and other women would make him unable to become a man. Usually there is a massive coming of age ceremony and from that point forward they may never see their mother again. After they reach another age, they are only able to go over the the woman’s section when they are ready to reproduce. This isn’t all tribes, and it wouldn’t be fair to generalize all tribes as doing this, or for this to be every tribe’s motivation for why they do do this, but it is a relatively common explanation.

    • @Enyavar1
      @Enyavar1 2 роки тому

      @@blugaledoh2669 They live apart... in different houses of the same village. "Men-houses" and "women-houses". That much is well documented.
      That they'd live in different villages is to my knowledge unprecedented.

  • @lilliancastillo642
    @lilliancastillo642 21 день тому +1

    The old maps are most likely true. I live by Sacramento and the elevation is 23 ft from sea level. Also, when the gold rush happened in 1849, Sacramento had canals and you had a boat to get around the city. The Old Sacramento had to be built up 20 feet from the original landscape. Some major dams were built-Folsom, Oroville, and the San Luis reservoir and changed the landscape. There’s also the Yolo bypass thats looks like an ocean every winter. You should probably research flood zones and study California history to understand this better. California is also a major exporter of rice and rice grows in wetlands.

  • @RnBaas
    @RnBaas 2 роки тому +9

    I don't know how you do it but every single one of your in-depth videos catch and hold my attention from start to finish.
    So much respect for your work.

    • @johnnyharris
      @johnnyharris  2 роки тому +1

      That means a lot. Thanks for sharing

  • @FindingFlorida24
    @FindingFlorida24 2 роки тому +16

    " I swear California does this to people, it makes them ignore reality in the name of a big dream..." man if you didnt hit the nail on the head there, esp in todays world.

  • @sajichengannur
    @sajichengannur 2 роки тому +6

    What a great content creator you are man... you are actually setting up Benchmarks!!! I can see you putting your heart and soul in your content.. keep it up man..

  • @otterconnor942
    @otterconnor942 Рік тому +1

    That ad at 6:00 made it really obvious that you were a missionary

  • @ConcerningReality
    @ConcerningReality 2 роки тому +8

    You did a much better job than I did at covering this a few years ago. Amazing video as always!

  • @NowIKnow8
    @NowIKnow8 2 роки тому +36

    Incredibly videography as always. Just wondering were you aware of this?:
    The name of Calafia was likely formed from the Arabic word khalifa (religious state leader) that is known as caliph in English and califa in Spanish. Similarly, the name of Calafia's realm, California, likely originated from the same root, fabricated by the author to remind the 16th century Spanish reader of the reconquista, a centuries-long fight between Christians and Muslims that had recently concluded in Spain

  • @VinnCon
    @VinnCon 2 роки тому +21

    Hey Johnny, I was wondering if you ever heard of the mythical Irish island of Brasil (sometimes Hy-Brasil), which is allegedly unrelated to modern day Brazil, but which was also included in some maps as being a real place? If not, you could also check it out, especially the book "Hy Brasil: The Metamorphosis of an Island: From Cartographic Error to Celtic Elysium" by Barbara Freitag

  • @90210julius
    @90210julius Рік тому +1

    This is by far my favorite video ❤️ great job once again Johnny! Awesome work with the effects, side notes, jokes, and of course detailed content. 🎉

  • @daufderheide9352
    @daufderheide9352 2 роки тому +54

    I’m from California and as soon as I left at 18 (because I was not / am not a multi-millionaire) and moved to Florida, I understood why people flocked to Cali, particularly SoCal.
    I miss what was my home state ~30yrs ago, but given what it has become both in reality and in perception by most of the country, I’m not so sure I would move back there (taxes alone would make that decision).
    It’s such a shame because it really is a wonderful and beautiful place to live, but I’ll just have to remember it in my California dreams…

    • @BobectorGamesBobector
      @BobectorGamesBobector 2 роки тому +4

      Grew up in Nor-Cal. When it's not burning it's beautiful. Like you said not a millionaire. That seems to be the problem nowadays with California's population going down. It's just way to expensive

    • @kimberlykees9163
      @kimberlykees9163 2 роки тому +1

      I spent years believing I’d eventually move there. I’m in Az. Now I’m so glad I never pulled the trigger on that! We need to flush that shit away and you can come see me in Arizona Bay!

    • @ChicanoOne760
      @ChicanoOne760 Рік тому

      @@kimberlykees9163 that's a far fetched fantasy. In the meantime AZ is still 120 degrees.

    • @kimberlykees9163
      @kimberlykees9163 Рік тому

      @@ChicanoOne760 it’s funny you would mention that bc we have had such a surprisingly cold Jan and Feb. You’re damn straight though….. it’s hot AF here most of the time….that saying “but it’s a dry heat” does have meaning. We’re actually more like 115F here….120F is more a Palm Springs thing

    • @nvalles2565
      @nvalles2565 Рік тому

      Move to Roserito, MX and live fifteen mins from SD.

  • @michelledenise5096
    @michelledenise5096 2 роки тому +31

    First, I love the map guys at LOC! Second, I saw a similar map last week and have a note to figure it out…then this vid popped up! Yay!

  • @handlemonium
    @handlemonium 2 роки тому +31

    Johnny Harris, you are like Atlas Pro, Vox, and The New York Times with a giddy obsessive flair all rolled into one! Keep it up!

  • @ivanz2709
    @ivanz2709 Місяць тому

    We really need more cartography/history videos like this. Honestly could watch this stuff for hours

  • @eduardouribealbarran6415
    @eduardouribealbarran6415 2 роки тому +14

    I currently live in Bakersfield CA (central valley California) and we use to be underwater at point. But the the central Valley was once an ancient giant lake that spanned from Sacramento to us here in Bakersfield.

  • @crzydwrf
    @crzydwrf 2 роки тому +26

    The editing in this vid is sooo sick, well done johnny!!

  • @jaydenmocke8029
    @jaydenmocke8029 2 роки тому +13

    6:12 I would've died if he said
    Okay but who asked 💀

  • @DashFlashTheLife
    @DashFlashTheLife 2 роки тому +2

    Imagine writing a book so good people MAKE it real.

  • @garrywallah4966
    @garrywallah4966 2 роки тому +30

    It’s a great day when Johnny comes out with a new informative video

  • @WatchingLakersBasketball
    @WatchingLakersBasketball 2 роки тому +13

    This channel is better than PBS and national geographic stories from the 90s and early 2000s growing up as a kid. When Johnnie drop a video the topics be all over the place like I've never seen content that is always different almost everytime I don't think no one else was doing this in the 90s. Glad you tube allows creators to post whatever they want.

  • @extofer
    @extofer 2 роки тому +27

    I grew up in California and sometimes it feels like its own island

    • @hoosierbaddy3052
      @hoosierbaddy3052 2 роки тому +1

      Me too Chris. I was expecting a fair amount of California haters to sound off in the comments section. It’s a new video tho. The haters are building their hate arsenal. Just jealous really. Cuz I wouldn’t wanna live in any other state than California. Even tried Florida. Hail to the No on that state! 95 degrees with a 95% humidity is too much! Random loud thunderstorms move thru there during the summer. Indeed. One day I had my ac and windshield wipers on full blast in my car. Buh-bye oldies but Goodies state. 👋

    • @extofer
      @extofer 2 роки тому

      @@hoosierbaddy3052 I live in North Carolina now but all my family still live in CA. I will never hate on CA. It will always be home to me. I also like NC a lot but can do without the humidity and bugs everywhere. Thing is I’m not about to hate on NC though the way that people tend to hate on CA. I just chalk that kind of hate up to ignorance. Thanks for the reply!

    • @sophiarichard2101
      @sophiarichard2101 2 роки тому

      How are you doing?

    • @TavoLL1511
      @TavoLL1511 2 роки тому

      I find interesting how American states have a sense of individuality or personality. In Mexican California we know we're Mexico and Mexico is us as well.

  • @EthanCortezBarrandey
    @EthanCortezBarrandey Місяць тому

    Bro i love your investigative documentaries... Ur narration is on point. Love what you do. keep up the good work

  • @moretao9837
    @moretao9837 2 роки тому +58

    Absolutely loving the sneaky boat appearance from 'Townsends' at 15:25 ! Well played Johnny.

    • @GrigoriRasputin
      @GrigoriRasputin 2 роки тому +7

      Yay, found someone who caught that too!

    • @Elyvana
      @Elyvana 2 роки тому +3

      I really scrolled down this far trying to figure out if that was actually him.

    • @Zigzag_artichoke
      @Zigzag_artichoke 2 роки тому +1

      Yay I’m so glad someone caught that haha

    • @ericschalalala4940
      @ericschalalala4940 2 роки тому +1

      Thought the face looked familiar, then realized it was probably Townsends and wanted to see if someone else actually noticed :D

    • @cecilelebleu5984
      @cecilelebleu5984 2 роки тому +1

      Hahaha I loved this little detail.

  • @tommykelly1221
    @tommykelly1221 2 роки тому +4

    Thanks for coming back strongly and sticking to what you do best with such an interesting video after the hiccup on the last map video you have redeemed yourself better than ever! Classic Harris jokes had me in stitches I love your sense of humour. Looking forward to whatever is next keep doing you and that's more than enough my friend. All the best. Love from Dublin Ireland

  • @StefanMilo
    @StefanMilo 2 роки тому +10

    14:31 Not old John Townsends 😂 He'd be a good fit for a 18th century mapping expedition.

  • @xav5376
    @xav5376 Рік тому

    -Good editing
    -AWESOME ILLUSTRATION
    -bro spoke for 24 mins but i still didnt get bored through the end.
    -BRO LITERALLY CYCLED THROUGH SO MANY MAPS

  • @Arca7
    @Arca7 2 роки тому +9

    Bro
    This series is insane
    You're so good in maps and story telling!

  • @jimjimsauce
    @jimjimsauce 2 роки тому +47

    love love LOVE all the annotations and sources. so sick to see that johnny truly cares about his content and his audience. nailed this video out of the park johnny boy, keep it up

  • @FisforFenton
    @FisforFenton 2 роки тому +32

    I remember in school when I was learning about history of Utah when they first found the great salt lake they thought it was an arm of the ocean so there are maps with huge parts of the ocean that go into Utah.

    • @ajrobbins368
      @ajrobbins368 2 роки тому

      Notably, Lake Lahontan and later Lake Bonneville once existed within the Great Basin. Today the Great Salt Lake is a relatively small reminder of the water present in the region.

  • @darrellanderson9024
    @darrellanderson9024 Місяць тому +1

    Holy Cow! Majority still wishes CA was it’s own totally separate island!

  • @GoatAmv
    @GoatAmv 2 роки тому +8

    It is a state where fact and myth often overlap. According to some geologists when one of the big quakes comes, California will break off from the mainland and become an island.

    • @tomtaber1102
      @tomtaber1102 2 роки тому

      No real geologist ever actually said that.

  • @jaridkeen123
    @jaridkeen123 2 роки тому +6

    I love the "Townsend" UA-cam Channel Easter Egg at 14:50

  • @earthmotionchannel
    @earthmotionchannel 2 роки тому +10

    How convenient, literally made a video about this a week ago haha!

  • @_GRAVYC4K3S_
    @_GRAVYC4K3S_ Рік тому +5

    That poor dude on the subway