Watch again: Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov speaks at geopolitical conference in India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 бер 2023
- Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov speaks at geopolitical conference in New Delhi.
Watch more on Independent TV: www.independent.co.uk/tv/news
Click here to subscribe to The Independent: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Independent
About The Independent:
Making Change Happen. The Independent is the world’s most free-thinking newsbrand, providing global news, commentary and analysis for the independently-minded.
Connect with The Independent:
Check out our full video catalog: / theindependent
Videos, daily editorial and more: www.theindy.com
Click here to get the best of The Independent daily: www.independent.co.uk/newslet...
Like The Independent on Facebook: www. TheIndependentOnline
Follow The Independent on Twitter: / independent
Follow The Independent on Instagram: / the.independent
Download the iOS & Android app: www.independent.co.uk/subscri...
Help to support truly independent journalism. Every dollar you contribute will directly fund additional special reports and investigations from a free-thinking, award-winning newsroom you can trust - www.independent.co.uk/donations
Subscribe to Independent Premium for exclusive content & live events: bit.ly/2MiOONB
I think India has lots of better interviewer in the country
True he's the worst intrvieuwer I heard
Then why dont use them?
The Indian interviewer apparently was sweating and feeling hot under the collar because afterwards he need to report to the US that he tried his best to push the questions which was dictated to him by the Americans.
@@vincentho3964 Well, It was a monologue on Lavrov part. He did not answer a single question, just making monologues. I understand, Russia position is undifensible , but I think this reflects very well that country attitude toward dialogue: crush Your enemy, who cares to talk?
They are collaborators
Shame that we made this guy ask questions. Without having a proper back ground!!
There are many media & think tank people like him on American pay rolls in India & around the world!!
It's a shame that you let him sit there and lie to you. What, do you think the audience was laughing at Orc Lavrov at 28:26 because he's funny? No...because he's a liar and he sat there and lied about everything. How do you know Lavrov is lying? His lips are moving.
Can't blame the interviewer - he was just given the questions and ordered to ask them...
@@meziahdanieljolley8842 NO, they were laughing because they agree 100% with Lavrov. For the first time the US mainstream media do not have the monopoly. It is the WEST that have been lying.
Painfully obvious that the Indian host failed to do his homework and sounded incredibly naive. Then again India is now in bed with Russia resultant from discounted oil.
India's High Contracting Party status to the Genocide Convention should now be challenged for subsidizing Russian war crimes and genocide in Ukraine.
welcome to the multipolar world with a little bit of US influence
This is a case of a dwarf interviewing LAVROV. Well done Independent for airing the masterpiece. 😊
Yes he didn't get past the whatabouts - not 1 answer. But we know the answers. Genocide is genocide. "Liberating" people by totally destroying their towns and villages, torturing, raping and conscripting them forcing them to kill their neighbours and relations is a contradiction in terms.
@@W_Bin You correctly described what Elensky does!
@wbin4242 Your impish squeals are all "Fallacies of Begging the Question" (Google, then click, "Examples") You use fallacies because you're habituated to thinking with them. Obviously. You're beliefs are irrational.
Yes true..the host is no match..he got destroyed by Lavrov
@@0legmakarenk0 There is no such person, so what are you even talking about. Level of children. Did you learned in Russian schools?
Check out 28:29, everything is clear from there!
😂
Yes, exactly😂Russian are clowns and liars
28:29 Yes! 😆😆
what a laughing stock. Total embarrassment!
He is so miserable
I wish they had selected Palki as the interviewer
Palki hates the west… not an unbiased journalist
Palki is a Hindutva propagandist and you are probably one of the fooooooooooool believe her
@@bazlur-Vancouver 😂😂😂👍
Even if Subhash Chandra Bose had been interviewing Lavrov, he would have been more respectful.
@@bazlur-Vancouver what makes you believe that?
Thank you India for opening a way for a glint of light in the dark :)
Russian propaganda was great.
Ukraine is an independent country who is free to decide its own future : democracy, language, association with the European Union, and join NATO (you see why).
Ukrainians have been attacked for hundreds of years from the corrupt tyrants Russian dictators.
In 2014, they got rid of the Russian puppet (Yanukovic), Putin didn't like a free Ukraine, so it started a war and stole Crimea from Ukraine.
Now Ukraine, wants all its territory back and put many Russians in jail for the war crimes they are committing in Ukraine.
Last Putin/Russian invasions :
1992 : Moldova
1999: Chechnya
2008: Georgia
2014 : Crimea
2022 : Ukraine
Yes me too, but Russia isn’t listening.
yeah he 30 min in a straight face complained why west don't let russia to kill ukrainians freely. What a terrible injustice. Brilliant glint of light in the dark. :D
@@ThePedroski007 Of course are they not listening to US command. China, India and a lot of other countries won’t listen either. Those proud countries can't stand the US bully and its vasal dogs from EU and GB. I hope that Africans, Hindus, Chinese and others will judge them for all they've done to them, and that they will demand reparations, else… no ressources will be sold to those bullies.
@@ThePedroski007 Ps. Your side is the dark in this room.
i wish and like to see you do this kind of questioning when you talk with Biden US .... thank you ....
The US will shed more light on Russia. We begin bombing Moscow in 15 minutes
biden will just get up, shake hands with air/ghost and walk away...
Russian invasion of Ukraine has nothing to do with Biden ...Lavrov is a delusional propaganda monkey ..
You're so right. I feel ashamed for India to allow such guy on TV. It is obvious that someone asked him to talk like that. It's again a shame for india to allow such person to represent it.
@Doudou Elias too India it is all about 🛢 oil? And do not care about the people that Died because of that??.
“The Americans will definitely suggest some questions you can use” that was hilarious 🤣
It wasn't, it's disrespectful, India allowed him to hold a speech and he says something like that. In the west nobody listens to this clown anymore. And if anything, the one who suggests something, it's Lavrov's master Putin that suggests his answers! Well dictates fits better!
Nope
*Slava Russia* 🇷🇺
Christians ✝️ and Muslims should reject Zio nist backed West.
They just don't invade us they ruin our culture and integrity.
Can you imagine they teach our kids that there are 35 genders in schools?
They are spoiling the whole mindset of the humanity.
@@hassanrafi5887 You don't have any culture in first place 🐵
At least the Americans suggest questions, Putin commands his lap dogs to use his rhetoric.
The truth has been said "blackmail" God bless you guys
What BS. The lying Lavrov has you suckered... 28:26
what kind of journalist can ask Lavrov why Russia wont negotiate when everyone knows UA officially refuses to negotiate with Moscow
Bellendsky made a law that nobody must negotiate with Russia, death penalty
Lavrov is a treasure. Funny guy, too, at times. The bold untruths being told these days in diplomatic circles visibly offend him. He belongs to a different time, and Russia is incredibly lucky to still have him. He must live in a steel box until he goes on stage. US secret services must hate the guy with a passion.
He belongs in a back street comedy club
It’s so obvious that he doesn’t believe anything he’s saying.
@@jillfeatherman5523 like many polticians generally
@@jillfeatherman5523 just like most US politicians
@@jillfeatherman5523 really I didn’t get that from what he was saying. What do you know?
They are so used talking without anyone questioning it.
He didn't even flinch when people laughed at the idea that Ukraine started the war. A true professional... 🤔
If you question something, you should wait for the answer to finish. It is called manner.
@@tanvirkabir4960 No one interrupted him. Far from it: "Never interrupt an enemy when he is making a mistake."
Exactly, it took a Russian diplomat to put an end to their propaganda
Yeah. Here's the question: If the U.S. did what Ukraine did, declared independence from the influence of it's largest minority, whose side is Justice on -- African Americans, or independence? Tough one, uh?
Well spoken and we'll explained Minister Lavrov sir
Can you imagine a U.S. minister speaking at a conference in fluent Russian?
Russian is too unimportant as a language for outsiders to learn it.
@@terribrad24 He was talking about diplomacy and the skills of Russian as the tool for them.
There are American ministers, journalists and foreign ministry officials that speak fluent Russian even though Russian is NOT a major world language
@@stephenhickman304 Most of them speak on the middle school level. It is not enough to see Russian's logic
ELE É OBRIGADO A FALAR INGLES. SE NÃO FICA A VER NAVIOS.
True talk
India is a democracy, I can't understand their position on this war.
Its cause of what they can get from russia!!! They would deal with the devil is they got a good deal!!!
The same democracy was once under the threat of nuclear attack from USA and UK.
India does India first. Russia is a neighbour and they’re getting cheap gas and oil now
Long history but there are events that happen in that side of the world which other democracies have been ignoring, infact the other democracies supported dictators against Indian democracy and has continuously ignored issues on that side of the world. Indias position is well justified by Indias perspective and experience.
Pakistan is not still gets free f 16. And india gets us carrier strike group threatening to attack it
In this family you have a right to fight for whatever you believe and those citizens agreed the fire truck still pulls up
Lavrov is the sharpest knife😂
The man dropping truth bombs. Interesting how Western MSM drags this speech saying people "laughed" at Lavrov. I see they are laughing, and sometimes applauding, in appreciation of what this man has to say. Respect to Lavrov and impressed with his English. Wish we in the US had diplomats like this.
What the US has is Lavrov's counterpart, Anthony Blinken, possibly the worst secretary of state in US history, and certainly a stupid, arrogant, reckless, fraudulent, morally bankrupt, psychopathic criminal and terrorist (as proven by the Nord Stream sabotage). The difference is like light and darkness.
Good try, Boris. Fulfilled your quota today?
People like you russians call usefull idiots. So cangrads ;)
Who are you , NATO troll?
@@katong1953 Amen, Sir!
min 28:30 finally this comedian got a laugh.
😆😆😆😆🤡🤡🤡🤡
unbelievable
Triumph of russian diplomacy 😆😆😆
He is actually right clowns are the ones who laughed
@@SanilAbrahamdontstop should I give you a link to a Putin’s speech when he stated that “I made a decision to start a special military operation”? Or should I give you a link to a Blinken’s speech where he stated that Russia is planning to invade Ukraine In February?
What Lavrov is saying is that if the former Warsaw Pact is entitled to security guarantees, so is Russia.
The security guarantees that Russia has is that no one (except perhaps China) wants to invade Russian territory.
Putin has this twisted mindset that the West wants to invade Russia! Putin's mindset is to bring back the Soviet Empire and Ukraine is the first step on that road. Putin has deliberately agitated the Russian people living in Ukraine against the Ukraine government.
At the end of the day, Ukraine has the absolute right to determine who they wish to gorhe alliances with. Lavrov's line about Ukraine not being able determine it's own security at the expense of Russia's is a red herring.
Are you ok, Boris? No one invaded Ruzzia. That looks like a security guarantee.
@@W_Bin Who invaded USA during caribian crisis in 1962? Why USA was ready to invade Cuba? And why USA don't leave that plans even this days??
Who is attacking Russia a huge nuclear power, a country that has forces in numerous countries ?
@@gfan83 Because Russia was putting atomic weapons on the island of Cuba ....that was a serious provocation to the USA
Jaishankar - Lavrov. Same subject. What a debate that would be!
debates are cancelled these times,you must follow the US (jew) narative
Thank You for this revealing interview.
Interview is full of whataboutism
India with Russia always
@@L_MAO_ look 28:29 ... HAHA
@@L_MAO_ in UN Resolution India don't vote for Russia 😉
@@Globetrotter193 Western media people are laughing not Indians.....
Also 22:12 'he is our man.He is from Russia...'
Whatever Indians publically say or do, deep inside we Indians arealways with Russia...
Omg mr lavrov is no joke
He is a joke actually… he should join the Russian circus 🤡
Lavrov is a much better statesman than Putin. Putin is just a self promoted KGB thug.
he lies
@@stephenisom6089 All politicians lie, and OK he may be the worst one ever (except perhaps for Putin), but that is his job, to deceive people.
The Questioner asking so many daft questions. Unbelievable.
The lack of understanding in this interview, I feel ashamed. Two nations that can end humanity with the press of a button. You should be careful what you ask. I wish more Intelligent people did this interview with the proper questions that would makes sense to the world what fukkery is going on with this War and what it's true intention is. Gosh we have become so dumb.
Agree. Just following the human-herd only leads to the river of crocodiles.
The questions were good.
Most were, but some need homework to be done as suggested by FM.
Listen the more we reduce hypocrisy the more we can implement democracy/diplomacy
yes we we all live in fluffy rainbows russia is killing thousands its not like nato because nato go..russia occupy steel and keep..
thank you from canada
The hard hitting Sergei Lavrov. He never disappoints.
Lie and false rhetoric will not help Russia.
Never disappoints to put on a clown act
But Lavrov. I thought your president said it WASN’T a war. It’s a special military operation.
Out of the window he goes...
15 years in prison to a russian, for saying "WAR" instead of special military operation. It is new law in Russia.
As long as Ukraine looses that’s all that matters.
Really? You're THAT ignorant -- you don't know why? Did Ukraine declare war?
@@HegelsOwl what happened to the news reader who held up a sign behind her colleague when the news was being read? (How’s your boss Yevgeniy Prigozhin doing?).
Go Rusia go, all latinamerica supports you!
When lavrov talked about "what if Belgium prohibited French" he should have said "what if India prohibited Islam" and audience would relate much better :)))
bullshit
If Belgium prohibited French there would have been an uproar, but France wouldn't have invaded Belgium because of that.
@@seb8905 Perhaps they wouldn't wait till their citizens had been shelled or 8 years before they invaded though
Nah, India prohibiting a religion is not happening anytime in the foreseeable future
@@fenrir834 yeah, but neither is Belgium anywhere near prohibiting French
00:28:29 laughter is still the best wepaon against hipocrites ; )
You mean western journalists/stenographers at the back?
Can you imagine any western leader answering hostile questions in such an accomplished and professional way?
👍
@@galahadthreepwood A full audience of "journalists/stenographers" : )
He has been making them laugh the whole night with his quips. They love him. The west is mad.
I think they laughed because they are agreeing with Lavrov 100 %
Minister Sergey Laughoff
🤣
He finished by admitting Russia and the EU were fooled by the US, Putin should have ignored the US and Nato expansion and focused on the EU only dealing with the EU to find a solution to Ukraine's problem with the separatist, knowing that the EU needs Russia resources more than they need US dollars and weapons he should have played his cards right,
...um, that's EXACTLY what they did. The Minsks agreements happened with the participation of Germany and France and the US was not involved.
But the Europeans soon caved and submitted to US demands of arming Ukraine while using the Minsk Agreements to hide under.
Exactly. And that’s why you know this mess is not about NATO at all. The NATO border even increased.
Exactly. The US stopped caring about Russia a long, loooong time ago. The cold war is (was) over. The US "pivot to Asia" is real. Ironically, it seems that the end of the cold war is exactly what spurred Putin into invading. "Oh the US doesn't care about Europe anymore, time to invade!"
Except that now we have found out the truth: Ukraine's "problem" was created by the Kremlin. It was supposed to make an excuse for invasion. But it backfired really badly. After all the lies were exposed. The world was fooled for years, but only fools are fooled, now the truth about what Kremlin did is all over the internet.
And Ukrainians, who in 2014 wanted friendly relations with Russia, now hate them. For destroying their homes, their jobs, their families and their country. They don't even want to speak russian any more, they are all learning their country's language, which Russia tried to destroy.
the EU are intelligent people.. they chose not to do Business with Russia because russia has shown time & time again it can’t be trusted. Putin said Europe would freeze this winter… guess what, it’s almost springtime and Europe is doing fine. European countries and most of the world will continue to reject Rzzn oil and gas. Rzza will sink back into the dark ages where it belongs!
Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
The amount of sarcasm in the comments 😂
Did you not learn how to finish a sentence in elementary school?
Why are you being so polite? I'm not being sarcastic. Am I?
@johnsmith1474 Better look at your own grammar, first, then stick your thumb back in your mouth.
@@HegelsOwl he's a hypocritic troll
John Smith - Haven't you learned that the Internet is not the school? You can't even speak English grammar correctly, what a fail 😂
sergei 🔥🔥
Russian also promised not to attack Ukraine in return for giving up its nuclear weapons.
Russia has been taking over Ukraine piecemeal since.
You can have anyone you like in charge so long as we approve them.
So both are equal. West doesn't follow their commitment, Russia doesn't follow theirs. so west needs to stop preaching.
Ukraine never had nuclear weapons, child. The soviet union had and they left it.
You are the typical Nazi PR bot who repeats braindead bullshit.
ukrainian promise to be neutral
The communist they says thing and do the opposites,why because the tongue have no bones ,thats why??
Mark, Correct! 😱 This most important issue is conveniently never mentioned. NATO and the US have betrayed Ukraine. Why oh why did Ukraine discard its nuclear shield! And a bitter lesson is being learnt by other nuclear wannabes! 😱
l love the moment when people laugh at the lie about "war against Russia" xD
P.S. 28:30
Clowns that laughed were mostly foreign journalists. The war shouldn't stop untill all these ukro Nazis are made fertilizers
@@chills097 Those Nazis... Are they in this room right now?
What a liar_ clown ha
@@vladick1993 OKAY DOG
There is no lie in Lavrov's words. And what you call "people" are a handful of Western journalists sitting in the hall. "Western journalist" and human in the vast majority of cases are diametrically opposed concepts.
Much Love from Serbia to Mr. Lavrov!
Lol Serbia ! 😂
Well explained.
03:00 8. Each participating State has an equal right to security. We reaffirm the inherent right of each and every participating State to be free to choose or change its security arrangements,
including treaties of alliance, as they evolve. Each State also has the right to neutrality. Each participating State will respect the rights of all others in these regards. They will not strengthen their security at the expense of the security of other States. Within the OSCE no State, group of States or organization can have any pre-eminent responsibility for maintaining peace and stability in the OSCE area or can consider any part of the OSCE area as its sphere of influence.
Mr Modi, what part of invading Ukraine is "They will not strengthen their security at the expense of the security of other States."?
Lavrov can confuse a lot of stupid people. But why are you supporting him? Do you really think you can/will benefit from supporting genocide?
Yip. Istanbul, 1999. Lavrov reading white, then saying it is black. Funny the crowd didn't laugh at that.
Q How do you know when Lavrov is lying?
A When his lips are moving. He's paid to lie. That is his job.
So, Mr. L is lying about lying. True Russian "brilliant mind"...
28:30. Не дякуйте
А в чем он не прав?
@@rudolfzemm aahhhaha
The BS really flowed from this point. Lavrov wouldn't know the truth if it hit him in the face but he has to follow the script or could find himself flying out a window!!
@@serbarkis that's a very good argument.
I have no words.
For the first time without any interpreters Russian Federation represented by the Honorable Foriegn Minister has spoken out with clarity and openness, witty with a sence of humour and of cause with fascinating facts to substantiate Russia's claims, that many could have been mislead by the western media's interpretation.🙋♂
You are on the side of a militaristic, authoritarian propaganda state that has a history of attacking or annexing it's neighbors, has been condemned by the overwhelming majority of the UN, has killed millions of Ukrainians, has killed millions of their own people and is led by someone who has his political opponents assassinated or imprisoned
Honorable? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Lies and says UKRAINE ATTACKED RUSSIA 28:26 Are you so dumb? 🤡
@vick mesh - Absolutely agree !!
Friend, sharing views should not be taken on personal grounds. Acting emotionally may be a poor reflection to, nevertheless respect shoud be viewed objectively.😊🙋♂
The questioner seems to have his own agenda.
Yeah, what is the end game here so we can stop this war. What a nerve…
Ah he did mostly ask how to end the war, but he did not understand that he has to ask this the USA like in Vietnam , Korea, Kuba, Irak, Iran, Venezuela, Lybia, Georgia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Syria, Palestina , Republic China, South China Sea, ......... ask the USA why they do not want to end their wars around the world not Russia, its not Russia to end something they never started.
@@user-ck8pb2np5w The person he was talking to was Russian so he asked the Russian question. Should he have asked Lavarov why America doesn't end the war?! 🤡
@@StinkPickle4000 Yea like I said the moderator might have good attentions , but to ask Russia to end to Western Colonisation in East Europe is what they try to do, ...
it is very clear that by destroying the bufferzone by the USA and EU that East Europe will be war ground as long as the colonist, puppet governments and the NATO bring their war and their weapons to the Russian boarder.
Yea so he should ask Russia how to help to get the Pufferzone reestablished, but to end the war is only a question to the USA and their colonization plans right in front of russia now since decades, Russia always ask since decades the west to stop their colonisation and to stop destroying the bufferzone, Russia ask this by destroying Lettland, Litaun, Estland, Georgia with Abchasien and Südossetien, Kachastan, Belarus, Moldavia with Transnistrien and Gagausien., Ukraine many years since the revolte and civil war , making the president flee ukraine and established puppet government, Russia did try to find a way for peace and to keep the bufferzone intact since deacdes its not Russia which can bring peace because they have no attention for a war like they said over 1000 times to keep the bufferzone intact for peace and stopping the colonisation there..
You can also not ask China to stop a war, they are surrounded by the USA and even already on their own ground, so you can not ask China to go home and stop the conflict, they are home, the USA is not home in China and not in the South FChina Sea at all, like the Names say it does NOT say the Republic of USA not USA Kong and not the South USA Sea , this is China not the USA, so you can not ask China to end there a conflict, its not China threaten someone and not somewhere else with their army in the world , its the USA who is in China not China in the USA.
The same for Iraq, Venezuela, Syria, Afghanistan, Haiti , Pakistan, Lybia, Germany, Korea, .....
@@user-ck8pb2np5w Russia is colonizing and imperializing Europe! US is supporting its allies.
China is provoking all its neighbors I've seen this first hand. The Vietnamese will welcome America back to help defend its lands before letting its aggressive neighbor take it from them.
Mr. Labrov, a sovereign state can cancel whatever its people want and its none of your business. Deal with it and go back to Russia.
What if Irish prohibited the English language to the British living in southern Ireland and shelled them for 8 years forcing them to live in basements and torturing them? Would the UK just stay home and not provide them any support?
@@ahenstew8586ver 30% of Ukrainians speak Russian as their first language. None of them were oppressed to speak the language. But Russia has been trying to oppress and squash the Ukrainian language for over a century! They’ve banned Ukrainian language and culture in Ruzzian occupied regions including Crimea.
Also explain why Civilians in Debaltseve being bombed by DPR forces and now in Mariupol , Severdonetsk, Lysychansk, Kherson, Izium and Kharkiv?
@@ahenstew8586 You've got it wrong, Boris, you need to stop listening to Putin's propaganda and start reading what actually happened.
"Pro Russians" suddenly appear in 2014, and start killing their neighbours??? Why? After 25 years of living happily together??? BECAUSE they weren't Ukrainians, they were Russian mercenaries sent across the border by Putin. Igor Girkin, their leader and many other Russians have openly said this, since 2015.
"if Irish prohibited the English language to the British living in southern Ireland" - nobody would care. Some might leave. Some might learn Celtic. The government might get voted out. Nobody would be bombed.
Hard for trolls to understand, I know.
@@ahenstew8586 What the heck man, UK invaded Ireland in the past and they haven´t returned part of it yet. So yeah, good analogy. I do think Ireland should get back the north, and Russia should return Crimea and the rest of the invaded territories, and if that requires some shelling let it be. For the rest they are a sovereign country.
Right on
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Lavrov was trying to answer the interviewer's question but the interviewer didn't want to listen what was being said, so he kept interrupting Lavrov with the same question.
What about the time when Lavrov lied through his pig face about Ukraine attacking Russia? 28:26 The audience isn't stupid. They know that Russia attacked Ukraine illegally and unprovoked.
Probably because lavrov kept lying and talking utter rubbish
is Russia not violating any agreement?
Oh, really ? Strange, I found the exact opposite.
Many Indians dont seem to realize that their accent in English is very strong. They tend to talk fast with that strong accent and expect everyone else to understand them. I've told my Indian friends many times to practice speaking clearly or slow down if they can't speak without that heavy accent. That's clearly demonstrated in this dialogue
yes, but Lavrov's accent is not better ))
Slow down the video
How is your accent when you speak Indian dialects? Or do you ...............
Ok boomer
@@yelenastrylchuk5679 The difference is that Lavrov knows that and he slows down in English so that everyone can understand him. The Indians on the other hand seem to think their English is perfect because they were colonized by Britain
I can't understand the one on the right,he forgot to bring an interpreter ?
Though some statements mr. lavrov was definitely a politicians response. We all could tell. I do agree no treaty of Versailles, which actually caused a greater conflict farther down the road. Though whatever agreement that is agreed upon by UKRAINE & RUSSIA, that deals with Ukraine must be iron clad. The only thing the US & EU can agree upon with Russia are issues that are 3rd party and are not the international legal jurisdiction of Ukraine.
They already had a treaty. It's called the Budapest memorandum. 1994. Russia guaranteed Ukraine's borders and sovereignty. In return for Ukraine giving up the third largest nuclear arsenal in the world.
What happened to Russia's guarantee of Ukraine's borders and sovereignty?
@@W_Bin Thank you all the propogandists should answer this question.
First question is a very good question... Troubled neighbourhood does not mean we need to go into war. That's why diplomacy is there
Russia has no respect or regard to any country
Troubled neighbourhood is a chance to exploit the situation. "Never let the good crisis go to waste!"
All questions were incredibly stupid. My respect for Indians has dropped. The US can and does create “trouble” in many “neighborhoods” around the world. Are you going to limit yourself to diplomatic means, when presented with a military threat? Good luck surviving!
@@user-qv1wq6kn6k Russia is military threat to everyone! Where are Circassians now? Where are Karelians?
@@user-qv1wq6kn6k No, you defend yourself. On your side of the border. And if you're really so concerned about Russian-speakers in Donbass not speaking enough Russian, you use your permanent seat on the Security Council to bring attention to the issue. You don't limit yourself to 435 days of military failure on the behest of a certain short Stalin-wannabe.
Maybe spoke to soon for once he is actually speaking, like a normal person making points explanations. Pity he is not like this all the time this type of communication is good for everyone whether people agree ir not it's a much calmer situation..
America trying to used Ukraine to destroy Russia but Russia is a hard nut to crack
He is like this all the time . Western journalists don’t allow him to speak properly or finish answering the questions.
Instead what the western media and journalists who are part of the government’s political and military wing, ..ask the question and then answer the questions they asked. Expressing there opinion and governments agenda.
Have you not noticed the western media, when they ask a question, they give the guest about 8 seconds then interrupt with the answer of the question the asked.
He is like that all the time. Calm, professional.
Lavrov forgot why Soviet únion collabsed. Why Czechoslovakia, Poland, Latvia, Bulgaria, atď. entered EÚ, and majority inhabitants work, study, háve hollidays in Western countries, EÚ, United štáte of Amerika, not in Russia.
You think your media shows how he is all the time? Or just out of context snippets?
4 minutes in to the speech he said this
He never stop to talk
The interviewer I am very sure has not done his homework at all before this interview. I am 100% sure Palki Sharma Upadhyay would have done a proper justice for this 🤦♂️ you got one opportunity to show why India is neutral and you blow your balloon on your face 🤦♂️🤦♂️
If you are interested in justice and neutrality Palki Sharma Upadhyay is the last person to conduct an interview with Lavrov. During her time at WION her anti West bias was plain to see. She was highly unprofessional, she was meant to be reporting news but she was acting like a Putin mouth piece at every opportunity.
@@bw6524 There is nothing called correct or wrong in geo politics. What exists is the perception of a country. In this case, what we as a country think. If you consider Palki, yes she has done a good job in calling hypocrisy of the west towards India. If that fits to what Putin says, can't help it.
Now if you are a kind of a person who think if Russia stops fighting war ends and if Ukraine stop fighting Ukraine ends, then I think our perceptions are different and I am happy with mine 🙂
@@bw6524 I've never see that in Palki. She is very professional. Criticizing the West from time to time, isn't "unprofessional," it's the definition of professional, when appropriate. India is effectively neutral in all this (somewhat leaning to the West). Acknowledging real politics is not "anti-US."
I've seen dozens of clips of her hating on what Russia is doing. Some of her clips about the Russian invasion have been down-right damning of Russia.
Milky would have done worst as she is Putin follower.
neutral ??????
28:29 sums all up ! Lavrov is a 🤡
BOT
@@Lancer1333 Why would a Russian bot point that out?
@@nightspade5 ты почему не в окопе укропчик?
@user-yp7xq1zw7t russhist troll, we've recognised you! You're leaving the same 💩 in every forum!
Good morning, sirs.
Just because they are speaking YOUR mind, doesn't mean they become more intelligent.
Indians know that west always uses what's the best for their own even if it means stomping on others. India would never do that.
Lavrov is not wrong in saying that the west is uring this conflict as a means to establish dominace in eastern europe! And putting gun on Ukraine's shoulders to fire at Russia!
Well, if the West is using this, then they need to thank Russia for starting the war of aggression. Unless I'm mistaken, the borders of Ukraine are agreed upon by all nations of the world. Russia violated those borders. Russia is guilty of war crimes. Whether or not the US or others in the West are guilty too HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS ISSUE. Russia must be stopped and thrown out of Ukraine.
and why is india now buying lot of cheap oil from russia ????
Your propaganda reality is not reality
@@etiennebaree6176 Why is so called democratic US led west in bed with autocratic China for the last so many decades??!!
I’m not sure you know what’s happening here . Russia is bombing women children and old people in Ukraine . It’s destroying water supplies and electricity power stations and rape is wide spread . Unarmed civilians are being shot . Putin is a coward and a thug . There is no freedom of speech in russia and dissent is oppressed . The west isn’t perfect i agree but do you really think the slaughter in Ukraine is justified ?
The interviewer is extremely disappointing. An embarrassment to Indian media and once again revealing The Independent as a propagandist rather than bringing out the truth to an extremely complex problem. Russia's concern is with its existence and survival and that will override the opinions of other countries. It was a pleasure as usual to listen to the views of Sergei Lavrov and the manner in which he so respectfully, firmly and clearly articulated them.
Nothing to do with survival, they were surviving just fine. They literally just sent their people to be slaughtered in Ukraine. So that they could expand Russian borders.
Russian leaders care about drawing a bigger map where they can write Russia on. We know this because they have done it before to other countries.
Listening to Lavrov is no pleasure at all, knowing that he is responsible for such horrible crimes. It is actually terrifying that he is allowed to sit there and speak without being served his deserved punishment.
@@MoonFella It appears you are confusing the USSR with the Russian Federation. Russia has not done anything like this to any other country particularly since 1990. So please check your facts.
It is Ukraine that is overflowing with a Neo Nazi leadership and armed forces. It is the Ukrainians not the Russians that are the ones committing massive war crimes.
@@guruwonder9626 These are just different titles, yet the same people, same values, and same culture.
Did you buy the Russian propaganda about neo-nazis in a country that has a Jewish president? Do you understand how little sense this makes? Not even Russians believe this neo-nazi propaganda that they are feeding.
It is terrifying to think that after all the destruction and killing that Russians have done, supported by evidence from countless sources, people can still ignore all that and even have some kind of respect for Russian autocrats.
Siberia is vey rich in gas but just 18% of population have gas in home 😁
What lies are you talking about? Provide source or proof of this statement. I can also say in the UK only 5% have running water in their houses...
@@ahenstew8586 well, dont know about all siberia, but krasnoyarsk dont have gas. 1 million town on coal. One of most dirty town in world in terms of air
USA is the most rich country the human history has ever seen. Yet 30% of it's population is poor. 🤔
And they steal Ukrainian toilets when many of them don't even have indoor plumbing.
@@markalexander832 They also said Russians raped children and their moms right in the kindergarten. But when EU was about to initiate tribunal, it found out those were just fakes and all ukrainian ministers who spread it were fired. You ppl there are openly id*ots lol
LAVROV 🌺HERO
"wait a second, wait a second!..."
"One second, one second, one second!.."
Journalist - Why Russia attacked Ukraine?
Lavrov - USA attacked Serbia, Iraq and Afghanistan.
Journalist - you attacked Syria, Georgia, Moldova
Lavrov - Its Russia's internal affairs.
Lavrov will attack others rather than speaking to the context of the questions.
and Lavrov is right. And Russia did not attack Moldova. Russia intervened in Georgia because of an internal conflict. In Ukraine, too, there was a long civil war, after the coup d'etat in 2014 with the help of the hands of the US
@@dekonluxe 💩in 🧠
You will attack Lavrov rather than listening to the context of his answers.
He clearly spoken about how Russia's concerns were ignored, how "western friends" fail to stick to the agreements. Thusly the point: diplomacy is blocked by the west.
Then another major point: Ukraine's attacks drastically increased starting from 17th Feb 2022, which is documented by OSCE.
In a perfect world Russia would have played by the rules and asked for justice in UN for example, but who can promise that in the meantime US wouldn't nudge Ukraine into fully winning Donetsk? They can even blame everything on Russia or Donetsk while keeping the narrative favourable to them in mass media. And we all know they can: look at Iraq and Syria for example.
You can agree or disagree. Wholly or partially. But stating that he evaded the question is either an ignorant act or trolling
@@dekonluxe 2014 Russia invade Crimea, and try to do the same with couple of other Ukraine territories. So, of course problem in US) Donbas has nice train comunication with Russia, thats why "civil war" happened there. All these "civil wars" was possible on the territory where Russia was bordered with Ukraine. And the main evil is US if course))
@@zaikapobegaika7379 Don't try to lie to me. I live in the Crimea, no one invaded here. Under the UN Charter, peoples have the right to self-determination. We chose Russia after the coup d'état in Ukraine through a nationwide legal referendum. No Russian invasion was required ..
Sunjoy Joshi sounds like a pacifist at any price. Why are his questions not directed at Ukrain's Zelenski as well, or even the EU and US?
"... we do not go to war over it"
Meanwhile in Kashmir...
History will never change.
History is changing
I love the reaction of the audience when he talks about the war that was launched »against Russia using the Ukraine«
@@andrewblair4863 Apparently the people to whom he was speaking agree with you too, that's why they laughed right in his face .
It's funny
He's not wrong though... Is everybody just playing dumb?
What is the rebuttal to the points the Russians have always made about what happened during the maidan, and during the Donbass war?
It used to be we'd get called Putin stooge conspiracy theorists for suggesting American spooks were behind the violent coup - now Western officials brag about having done it. We used to be called Putin stooges for saying it was the West and Zelensky who repeatedly failed to abide by the Minsk agreement, and somehow it was Putin and the separatists violating the peace accords - now both western leaders and the Ukranian nationalists brag about how Minsk was always a fake-out so they could arm up to fight Russia... We were told it was conspiracy theory that US was setting up bioweapon labs in Ukraine; then Nuland admitted to it congressional hearings...
And now we have found out that Nordstream was blown up on Biden's orders (no surprises there, but we were called conspiracy theorists for calling that one as well...) and the operation was set in motion before the Russian invasion specifically and deliberately to prevent Germany from turning the taps on if things got too hairy in their energy sector (as they have done now..).
Lavrov is correct that the bombings in Donbass were escalated right before the invasion. He also didn't mention, but it's very relevant, that Zelensky was floating the idea of getting nuclear weapons to point at Russia months before the invasion. There was also a (probably US backed) coup attempt in Belarus right before Moscow decided to invade.
And are we to believe that it's a lie that the post-Maidan junta regime banned the Russian language throughout Ukraine - including all the regions currently being fought over that were populated primarily by Russian speakers who overwhelmingly voted for the guy the West and the nationalists violently overthrew in the Maidan coup? The very same people who tried to succeede rather than live under this new regime, and many of whom see Russia as liberators in this war?
Is it not true that Russia has made their conditions clear and has been the one open to peace talks this whole time, while the West staunchly refuses unless Putin is overthrown (lol) and while Zelensky repeatedly states he'd rather see his country burn than enter into peace talks before they retake the separatist regions (never gonna happen)?
I just don't get what the pro Ukraine argument even is... It seems to amount to what Kamala Harris said in that radio interview when asked about the war, something like "well Ukraine is a small country that was invaded by big bad Russia and that's bad, and we support DeMoCrAcY so we back Ukraine"
What possible right does the West have to threaten Russia like this, or for that matter what right do the nationalists in the west of Ukraine have to oppress and abuse the Russian speakers in Donbas and Crimea? Do they not have a right to self determination? Newsflash - given the option, the population there overwhelmingly sides with Russia (duh) and not the neo nazis who openly and brazenly refer to them as sub-human dogs and "orcs" who must be put down and subjugated as enemies of the state...
What's the answer to any of this?
This orc not interested in India guys questions… just wants to lecture bs.
Well, he's not wrong tho.
@@krevetka9744 😂😂😂
This man lavrov is so wise that he made the west look stupid
You are the stupid here if you belief in his fables.
And in a proses of making the west look stupid - he made the west to laughing at him. What a legendary move!
He made the Big Asia laughing on the West. Great move.
Utter crap, he backs the invasion of a sovereign nation. How can you say that is wise? Moron.
And again a oneway dialog by a marionet of a dictator regime - which has been guilty of a "special operation" that roughly has killed more than a quarter of a million humans in the last 12 months. Only a psychopath would think this is funny.....
Truth
Lavrov is a real man, a great man, which the west do not have.
22:01. Another gross lie from Lavrov. Zelensky has never sign any "statement", criminalizing negotiation. What President Zelensky had said is - "It would be a crime against people of Ukraine to have any negotiation with Russia before the last Russian solder is out of our country". Who can disagree with such a statement?
Everything Lavrov said was a lie, or a distortion at best. But yeah... I noticed that too. As if Zelensky would "outlaw" himself, HIMSELF from the possibility of negotiating with Russia!
Lie or no lie Russia has every right to protects its security as much as USA,if USA went to Iraq and killed the president of a sovereign country then why not Russia!? NATO is a threat to Russia we all know that,so don't pretend like Ukraine are so innocent in this.
@@heimkon7236 That's exactly what Putin was saying at the announcement of his aggression against Ukraine. Do remember that. Next thing you know - you are a threat. So will someone else tell to the community. And you will be put in jail. On what charges? No charges. Just on hearsay by someone, who is stronger than you are.
@@Jagonath May by accepting that law in 30 of September 2022 Zelensky veiledly hinted that he does not be able to solve anything and taken hostage by USA or ...?
U 🐑🐑🐑🐑
How to negotiate after the annexation of the territories?..
Ha-Ha the all Ukraine was annexed in Sovied Union and devide on the promise of US for no NATO gonna come to the Russian borders,so quickly eveything can be back re annexed !
I stopped the WAR ! If you give me the peace,s of lands that I stole from you!?.
How Serbia has to negotiates about Kosovo? According to our constitution it is part of our country. So if EU and US want negotiations they could easily "tell" Zelensky, just like they are forcing negotiations about Kosovo (independence, UN membership etc), thus it can be done. Ukraine has few reasons to speed up negotiations because of: a) destruction; b) people are getting killed; c) refugees. We here had many, many refugees. And let me tell you very simple fact of life: once people are not in their country for some time and settle somewhere and begin new life, they are not going back. People will continue to leave Ukraine even if war ends tomorrow. Demographic data are available, see for yourself how many people Ukraine lost before any war.
@@jacksimon3472 ...before you stole them from me !
Ask India since they host this show .... maybe when India vs China start, then they should ask Ruzzia to host the show...
He forgot to mention Russian invasion of Afghanistan, Chechna, Georgia. Guessing that was just an oversight on this jokers part.
22:38 "please sit down, I have not taken your question"
- " why not?" 😂😂😂😂
The interviewer embarrassed himself repeatedly. Who let him interview Lavrov?
He sounds like he was coached to frane questions to put russia in a bad light, which lavrov properly contextualized and then obliterated him. Shame on them.
Lavrov- a clown …absolute
I love lavrov
One of few top diplomats around
Tough watch.
Good usefulll speech
Zelenski signed a decree banning negotiations with Putin when Putin Forcefully and arrogantly annex Sovereign territories of Ukraine and incorporated it into Russia - A feat that was never performed in any of the Countries invaded by USA that Lavrov referred to ; Yes Putin has a right to criticize what is happening in Ukraine but no right to Forcefull annex it’s territories and incorporate it into Russian state ; For crying out Loud Donbas and Crimea is Ukraine (Not Russia)irrespective of the language they speak period !
🤣🤣So just because it was never done by the USA then it's prohibited!? Double standards period!!
@@heimkon7236double standards all you want, Lavrov condemns Us in Iraq but thinks it’s okay for Ruzzia to invade a try to destroy Ukraine and kill thousands of civilians and throw conscripted Russian troops to certain death. Now that’s hypocrisy and double standards
@@heimkon7236 And here he is once again with another buffett off bullshit..
@@heimkon7236 That's not double standards. Annexing another country is not allowed in international law.
US/NATO took Kosovo and Metohija from Serbia. Of course, that all was for "humanitarian reasons".
This character from India interviewing Lavrov seems to be dense or delusional. His questions and persistence over issues that have been carefully explained is remarkable. He seems to simply think he has a high ground: "war is bad" via which to talk down to Lavrov. Even a simple-minded amateur geo-politician understands that war is monetarily expensive, costly in human lives, and is not no done for glory or no reason. What is it this character THINKS was the Russian motivation? Just to isolate itself?
When you know the difference between an answer and evasion, you might be able to make a worthwhile comment.
28:42 "come on" 😄
I must say I'm surprised to hear Lavrov speak English so well. I only ever heard him speak Russian and with an interpreter at hand. And did I hear him say 'that does not mean Russia is right about the war in the Ukraine'?!
🤣 Smarter than the interviewer but not as forth coming! Dodgy and seems like what ever the Americans can do they will do!
Yep I heard that too!
He cited someone else. The ambassador of France in Israel.
Lavrov, as Putin are both polyglots. Actually many members of the Russian government and high ranked officials are polyglots.
Putin - English and German
His spokesman Peskov - English and Turkish
Lavrov - English and ... I forgot the Asian language he speaks also well. Tolstoy, Piotr Tolstoy, the grandson of the famous Russian writer Liev Tolstoy - French and English
......
And the list is far from being completed.
On the contrary of the western governments, where any idiot can become who he wants if his party won the elections, Russia has a very conservative approach. Only people with huge experience and a strong background can rule, because they know what they are talking about and clearly understand their vis-a-vis.
Lavrov's comedic touch is commendable!
yeah he 30 min in a straight face complained why west don't let russia to kill ukrainians freely. What a terrible injustice.... Brilliant comedian :D
Lavrov the paid lackey Putin puppet has NOTHING LEFT but comedy to offer!!!!
"because you did something wrong, I can/do it too" "good excuse" "good example"
Its more if you're that bothered with what we are doing now, Why wasn't you bothered before when someone else was doing it. Especially with the frequency the other side has done it.
He is asking to do not disturb russians when they kill ukrainians.
No! NATO is in breach of Article 2 of the UN Charter, Ukraine is in breach of international law (cultural genocide), Putin made the intervention under Article 51 of the UN Charter. Your simplistic understanding of the situation is on the level of a brute!
@@kenji170 You mean the frequency the Russian side has done it. There is whole Wikipedia page of "List of wars involving Russia" and it ain't short.
@@ninjashinobi2413 You made up that story yourself? Don't answer, it is rhetorical question, of course not.
Can someone ask Lavrov about war practices? bombing civil targets, driving nuclear threats, torture. Why?
Laughrov! 😂 The statesman who became a comedian. In Ukraine: A comedian who became a statesman.
Lavrov cites western opinion (or near consensus) that Russia has to be militarily defeated for this war to end, without accounting for why this is. He knows. What alternative is there? How can any of its neighbours -- including Belarus -- trust Russia? What drove NATO expansion? Russian aggression, the deliberate targeting of civilians and civilian infrastructure, forcing millions to flee, turning cities to dust. He has the cruel arrogance to laugh, to wag his finger at Europe and North America who help defend the victims. Such temerity to defend war crimes while telling others to "educate" themselves. He deserves to stand trial with Putin.
Putins Russia is applying the same logic as used in Grozny and Syria: just obliterate everything. Lavrov, the ultimate gaslighter .
Did you study the root cause or you are just plain and simple hypocrite.
@@PETE4955 haven't you watched how america bombed Vietnam,laos, Cambodia, serbia, Libya, somalia, Afghanistan and Iraq?
@@jamesgo2014 "Joined a year ago" and a lot of whataboutism...
Ukraine is not the US. Nothing rectified Russia to start an invasion of Ukraine. Because neither Ukraine nor any of its big supporters trust Russia, and Russia isn't open to any negotiations, there is currently no other than a military solution for peace.
@@jamesgo2014 you need to study again ....
Russia should expand to Mexiko. Lets see what Biden says. :-)
Sunjoy is a disgrace to India, i m not sure if money is involved.
Americas arrogent dominance should go for world peace..
Want to listen to ignorance? Then keep listening to lies after lies! How do you know Lavrov is lying? His lips are moving! 28:26
And that's why Russia said "hey, let's invade a country and kill thousands of innocent civilians"
It’s not America’s fault former Soviet satellites don’t want anything to do with Putin and Russia. That’s not arrogance, Rani. Most Democratic countries do not attack one another. Look at Western Europe and how long there has been no war there.
@@terryjames548 thats ok but they cannot ignored russias security demands either, they have also their right to live the way they want..if they dont like each other, then they can live with a buffer zone..and that buffer zone is the border countries...whats wrong in that..?
@@jasbirde That’s like saying in 1939, that we should let Hitler have his way. Russia . Buffer zone? We currently have a “buffer zone” in Korea where people are starving to death and are threatened if they try to leave. Bad idea, Rani.
It’s a success🤣🤣🤣
Mocking our old leaders for there age is absolutely a rude thing
11:05 he nailed it ❤
28:30 comedy at it's finest.... what a clown 🤡 he nailed the laughter 😅
Każdy kto kocha rosje powinien tam zamieszkać na pewien czas to się z tej miłości wyleczy.
United States of racism, homeless people, mass shooting, inflation, unemployment
Polish fascist you polish fascist are the most racist people in Europe without the European Union you would be like Ukraine Slava russia 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
One hundred 💯 percent!!. On top of that! Help Putin invaid ader County's yes??.
Ignorant Nazi you love NAZI TERRORISTS, THEN, GO BACK TO THE HIGH HEELS DANCER 👠 WAR CRIMINAL NAZI TERRORIST GENOCIDAL LUNATIC, CHILDREN KILLER ZELENSKY, ASKED HIM WERE ARE THE 60 THOUSANDS CHILDREN YOUR EVIL REGIME KIDNAPPED FROM THEIR PARENTS?? WHY YOU KILLED THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS CHRISTIANS AND INNOCENT RUSSIANS FOR 9 YEARS?? WHY YOUR BURNED PEOPLE ALIVE AND GAS TO DEATH??? WHY USE CIVILIANS AS HUMAN SHIELDS??? WHY YOU DESTROY UKRAINE AND KILLED UKRANIANS?? ASKED YOUR NAZI LEADER !!YOU EVIL DEMON! Be
@@jacksimon3472 To begin with, I firmly believe that war is never a solution to any problem, as it simply determines who will oppress the other's problem.
My issue lies in the fact that the West portrays Russia as the sole perpetrator, killing and bombing people just for their own enjoyment. The situation between Russia and Ukraine is not as straightforward as it is being made out to be. There are valid arguments on both sides of the matter, and the West is biased towards Ukraine, casting Russia as the villain. This is not a productive approach.
While I acknowledge that Russia could have taken more diplomatic steps to resolve the issue with Ukraine before resorting to war, it is difficult to ascertain which side is correct and which is incorrect
Sikorsky: thank you, USA
Why moderator disturb when the minister talk
Lavrov graduated from the "Baghdad Bob" school of diplomacy.
There were many "Baghdad bobs" during the Iraqi invasions, Colin Powell included, the others so abusive that their military graduated from their obscene behaviours to carry out atrocities as if it was the wild west.
Who is this idiot called Marty ?
Marty Dumb
Mr Marty Mc Fly sit down and shut up
Bloody murderers! What a shame
But usa and west wasn't there . They were busy giving freedom to other countries.
So what are u talking about?
USA and western Europe by far the two most bloodiest murders in the history of mankind.they have colonised, killed, occupied half of the world