Historian predicts how Russia's war in Ukraine could end
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лют 2023
- As Russia's invasion of Ukraine enters its second year, war historian and University of Rochester professor Hein Goemans paints what a potential end to the war could look like.
#CNN #News
![[실시간] 전철에서 찍힌 기생생물 감염 장면 | 기생수: 더 그레이](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4nkFvwxGAfA/mqdefault.jpg)
I wish the interview hadn’t ended so quickly. He seemed insightful, made a lot of sense, and was interesting. Please have him back .
He was going to talk about the end of the afghan war campaign, so he needed to be cut off. He may not come on again.
He did not mention nukes it is some kind of propaganda I think
@@ruslankbr5243 Why state the obvious? But the stupid thing is, that if Russia wanted to stop Ukraine from joining NATO because it would come to close to their borders, then they are failing. Finland and Sweden have since then applied for membership. Even if Sweden is not allowed, Finland will. Thus making the border way longer and Finland have a massive army to defend against the Russians.
Nukes are not important. Why? If one goes off we will all die.
Some will die fast and they will be the lucky ones, some will survive and die slowly because of radiation, disease, lack of food, lack of water, plunder and killings
His hypothisis is faulty . WW2 ended with total defeat of Japan and Germany .
@@smek22071975 I think Biden or Macron stated that they will not use nukes if Russia will use it in Ukraine. And you quite don’t understand Ukraine importance for Russia this is not Finland or Sweden. Ukraine consists of territories which were part of Russia and there are as many Russians as Ukrainians in those regions, using these territories as a base for NATO is absolutely does not suit Russian interests. You know that USA stated in 2008 that Ukraine WILL BE member of NATO, how do you think where should Russian naval Sevastopol base should be removed in case of Ukraine NATO membership? That is why Russia annexed Crimea.
Too sad that his very important statements were cut short by the show host. He had much more to say.
💯
I agree 100%
Yeah he only made it past points one and two; what was three and four??
that was frustrating. you could see him getting warmed up then cut short
Because he told the truth and CNN likes to cut those who speaks about reality on the ground.
Why the interview ended so quickly? This guy is the man to make a whole segment with. Very knowledgeable. Someone i would love to sit and talk about this war issue.
Yes, he did not come to the scenario where the citizens come to the conclusion that they are betrayed by NATO, EU, UK, Kolomoisky and Zelenski. That Zelensky promised to make an end to coruption and the troubles in the Donbas, and did neither. That the Minsk 2 accords were much better than this war. That the two "revolutions", the "Orange" one and the "Dignity" one, - sponsord by CIA and US oligarchs, - were done by bad loosers in Presidential elections. That they are much better of by letting tthe pro-Russion parts become independent and stay neutral.
This man either knows nothing at all or he is paid to propagandize and lie to you. You know that, right? He could not have been more wrong. I don’t think he’s ignorant; just a liar.
@@jpalmiotti "My source is that I made it the fuck up" 🤡
@@jpalmiotti Few people in the world are better qualified to speak on the subject than him. Least of all you.
@@jpalmiotti bot
Fast forward Feb 2024
- Russia has captured Bakhmut and Avdiivka. Other smaller towns being captured on weekly basis.
- Western Aid is dwindling.
- Internal friction between Zelensky and military commander.
Maybe this war will end not very long.
61 billion. That is more then all the other packages to ukraine combined.
Fascinating. Bring Professor Goemans back for more detailed discussion. Need more of him.
Worm in Ukraine never end.
NOT REALLY. HE IS ANOTHER PUPPET.
Yeah
@Eduado Oliveira .
Now try it IN intelligible ENGLISH .
@@wieslawmaciag2142 😂
Bring this man back please. Just give us 20 minutes of him talking about this war and his ideas about it because he really seems like he knows what hes talking about
“Putin is trying to target civilian population” 😂 - what an Idiot should be this stupid war expert to say such a bullshit ?!
cnn would never do that. just like they cut him off right before he got to speak reason, they will never let reason be on air.
@@Voidroamer this wasn't the first time he appeared on CNN 🤣
It's crazy how well the Manufacture of Consent still holds true. Chomsky and Herman said it 4 decades ago.
The gues started laying out how Russia can not surrender, but it takes too long to explain the implications of this so before that can sink in let's go to a commercial break!
@@lg8587 right, have you seen Michael Smerconish "interview" Roger Waters? i do not agree with Walters on everything, but that amount of condescending was unwatchable
Very interesting interview to watch a year later. It clearly highlights how bad your research can be if you feed your academic work with propaganda.
Bro studied history so much he became historic
Finally a real historian who understands how wars work and how history repeats itself.
And thats why this war is so fucking tragic. Dictators keep on dictating. Civilians keep on dying.
Why? WHAT EVIDENCE do you have that THIS particular historian has ANY more predictive capabilities than ANY OTHER historian on the planet? There's nothing wrong with the guy, or even giving his informed best decision.
But the way UNCRITICAL IDIOTS take his PREDICTION OF THE FUTURE about NONDETERMINSTIC EVENTS - what humans will choose to do - as "absolute gospel" destroys your and his credibility.
You essentially just want to hear how every war is going to end in a glorious climax like ww2 don’t you?
@@jackbedle569 history repeats itself. Also, Jesus never existed and marriage has never been traditional.
You must be joking here !
This man is an "Ass Hat" he knows nothing about the History of War.
How did the western powers stop Imperial Japan in WW2 ? Not by
negotiation that's for sure.
You stop fanatics who refuse to surrender one way my friend..
Hiroshima. Nagasaki.
Next, will have to be Moscow.
This is the kind of guy I prefer to listen to for over an hour rather than four minutes. I know that’s not realistic on CNN, but even in a short period of time, the professor made a very sound case.
I love hearing Don lemon talk about women in their prime...
@@SeanD808 👍🤣🤣🤣👍
4 minutes is enough coz after 4 mins you'll start hearing lies
He made a case for what? He says it’s going on for years and will end in negotiated settlement but problem is Russia isn’t credible, Russia could go after Moldova, or Putin’s death if he loses?
But realistic on FOX, didn't know that there were so many JOKERS on earth. Anyways, no SOUND MINDED person would accept going on FOX.
This aged like Milk😂
Yep
I have studied History and economics for 40 years . I greatly appreciate your guest and his summary of what war is. It was short factual non-political and more important accurate.
I don't comment on CNN much but you should have this guest back, he is worth the time to listen to.
The brain dead may like it but some of us prefer the truth.
He started by saying war don’t end with someone loosing…..I guest Germany didn’t loose or Japan didn’t loose ? He is clearly clueless.
Why such silence about Putin’s nuclear Arsenal updating, NATO evil plans and Armageddon? i live in the capital of the Federation and iam HONESLTY afraid i do not have a bunker, and iam afraid it can affect the planet
iam shocked i think I’ll never feel the same until today after i saw the video ‘NATO and Russia nuclear war’
don’t say all of this is Not Real
My heart is broken, but.... I WON’T DIE
@@luly2323 He said "very few wars end in total defeat...." See that? "Very few wars...." He never said that no wars end in total defeat! Work on your reading skills.
@@luly2323 your ears connection to your brains needs patching.....he was accurate and precise...watch it again and finish the sentence....
the one time a person speaking about this war isn't labeled an expert and actually knows what's happening.
How do you know that he knows what`s happening? Please give arguments. What certain part of the interview gave you this certainty? I`m very interested. All folks around here seem interested and give him credits for being phenomenal...only war experts around here, or maybe they like BS? Most probably the latter.
@@GeorgeIllustrationsRight on. Exactly the same thing I was going to write.
he is an expert...: )...reason he was interviewed... this is a different angle that is most certainly more accurate and precise due to his academic knowledge
@@atta1798 Degree, not knowledge
@@tubebreguet Academics in this case is based on history that is knowledge he acquired through a degree and years of research to develop an expertise gaining the knowledge...... this is a known fact and very distinct Aaa Bbb... just differentiate and learn what I am telling you... the reason he drew the possible outcomes......same for GeorgwV.....it is not about arguments or proof ...this is no different from the financial institutions they have a risk asset department they use math to predict an outcome on finances to make the money..... in this case... to have the ability to give the outcomes based on knowledge .. ...like in Linear algebra and graphs....you take progression of numbers to predict the possible outcome to a certain degree of probability.... in this case based on the knowledge he acquire though his degree, he outlines possible scenarios ... this is a common practice in most professions that rehire a certain level of expertise.... and that knowledge....read the rise and the fall of powers....the book correlates thru the last 200 years+ what took empires to fall down based on common patterns and their policies, spending, systems...etc...... This professor is the best feedback there is so far in the media non biased and based on the facts.....no different from historian...in this case knowledge = based on past history, he draws possible outcome .....I hope this helps you and GeorgeV
I wish cable news was always this informative
Huh? How was this informative? He didn't tell us anything.
@@hughjass1044 Hard of thinking?
@@jeffsuter344 How so? The headline reads "Historian predicts how Russia's war in Ukraine might end?" He never told us that. Did I miss something?
He told us several things which would never be acceptable to each side; all of which we knew, so what is his prediction? Enlighten me.
@@hughjass1044 he mentioned a few. You just want a simple, definitive answer. The real world isn't one of your Bible fantasy storied pal.
@@mwfmtnman My, my, my.... aren't we the bitter, hate filled little person all chock full of assumptions and insecurities? My you don't be sticking your toes into any swimming pools there Sunshine, lest they become vats of battery acid.
There needs to be a WAY longer interview with this man.
He isn’t saying things CNN wants him to say. 😂
@@kylint7683 the most important thing, which he of course is not able to say is that this war was a long-term american deep government project. First step was to make ukrainians hate russians, raise new generation, who will be grown up in hate to russians, set pro-western government in Ukraine. Next step is to make instigate Putin to start war invasion through agents (treasoners, who still sit in russian government and sabotage to make sure Russia won't win ) and making threats of placing NATOs military bases in Ukraine, the main goal is redistribution of ecomonical sphere of influence , making money on killing people in Russia & Ukraine, the more and the longer the war will go on, the more benefits America will get
Another CNN video that has aged gracefully....
More of professor Goemans please. He is absolutely brilliant and certainly knows his field of expertise.
@@hughbarr8408 also shows that you are an Internet troll.
"We're still here ... We are not going anywhere." ~ Native Americans 😔
Native Americans: Our Native American population in our motherland, the Continent of America before the European Colonizers arrived, was around 15 millions, while the European population in their motherland, the Continent of Europe was around 25 millions.
Today, Native American population is 15 million, while the European population, in the Continents of America + Europe, is a staggering 'TWO BILLIONS'! A shocking sad truth. 😔
Prof Goemans: It's about time to decolonize the Colonized lands, and return it to rightful owners Native American people.
Notorious global cardinal crimes the West has committed, and benefited a great deals, such as Slavery & Colonialism had long been over, why on earth is notorious Colonization still lingering on? 😔
Native Americans: We're still here. We are not going anywhere. 😔
@@doubtingthomas9612 Your post is NONSENSE. Those deaths of natives Americans were 99% from disease. LOTS of Europeans died from disease transmitted by native Americans to Europeans and visa versa. Do you blame Asians for way more transmitted disease deaths? We already know from ancient that second waves of new native Americans who came to Americas 12,000 years ago decimated populations that came 18,000 years ago
This guy is nothing more than another Fake News, globalist shill. His lies are now on the record.
Well he does, but I think he had to say some things in order to get on CNN, which tend to obscure the situation.
First of all, while NATO cannot trust Russia, it is clear Russia cannot trust NATO either. It is obvious that the revolution or coup in 2014, changed NATO and Russia's thinking. And while excuses can be made, pretending that the overthrow made no difference, they are ridiculous. Agreements were broken on both sides. But most importantly, Russia fully expected Ukraine to vote pro-Russian. That was why the USSR put Crimea with Ukraine in 1954. To make it more Russian. It was essentially Soviet gerrymandering.
Disavowing the large, and very probably majority Russian and pro-Russian people in the claimed territory of Ukraine is nonsense. The idea that Russia is trying to conquer Ukraine is risible; so is the idea that Putin will abandon over 10 million people that are Russian citizens and consider themselves Russian, with no desire to be at war with Russia at a minimum. There is at least one area (Crimea) where these people make up a sizeable majority.
The real miscalculation in the war is with NATO. The politicians really thought that Russia was weak and that they could bully Russia into letting go of Ukraine entirely. This was a way of NATO using their vastly superior military to impose on Russia, without a direct war that might trigger a global or nuclear war. As it turns out, a combination of the inefficiency of a proxy war, and the unexpected strength of Russia's relatively low-tech army, has surprised NATO.
NATO also somehow miscalculated the strategic and commercial importance of Crimea and Eastern Ukraine to Russia, and failed to appreciate how much the Russian people would support Putin in retrieving it, once it stopped respecting democracy. Russia's miscalculation was the strength of Ukrainian nationalism and the feeling of ownership Ukraine has for the historically Russian territories. They feel that these areas were "given" to Ukraine as a nation and they have every right to kick the Russians out.
However, he is correct. The only solution now is a negotiated settlement, and that has to start at a minimum with Crimea conceded to Russia. However, I fear that the USA and NATO need Russian war reparations in order to pay for the war, preferably paid in oil. I don't think there is any way NATO and the USA, can afford to stop the fighting, concede any territory to Russia, and still have the money to rebuild Ukraine and avoid a financial collapse. NATO has put itself in a position that they can't afford anything other than an unconditional surrender by the Russians, and that, as Goemans correctly IMO points out, is historically very unlikely.
The interview is very short yet fascinating
take your meds its just propaganda . has nothing to do with reality. gay is a moron with a title
Very insightful thank you prof
Four months have elapsed, and the opinions of the professor have gotten ever more convincing
Yep. It's up to the Russian people to rise and remove him. The Russian security service can't wait til it happens.
Most sense I've heard since this war started.
This professor knows what he's talking about. Please put him on longer.
However, the professor failed to acknowledge the ageing European continent. The projected age of Ukraine in 2025 is 42.8 years. An ageing population is detrimental to war.
@dan mac 42/43(age) is too old for population replacement.
He doesn´t. The Romans and the Mongols targeted civilians and it worked, This guy is an idiot.
@dan mac No, I am not Russian. However, I do love Russians, and Ukrainians. I'm just an old African American praying for an End to all WARS.
@@teenahweenah2608 The only end to war is the end of aggression...Russia is the aggressor state here. Age has no bearing on it....only the will to survive. Ukraine isn't interested in you bleeding hearts, that want to try and force your opinions on them, they are interested in a lasting peace only...for them and all around them for them to survive. For that to happen, then Russia must be broken up into smaller manageable independent states, rather than left as the Great Russian empire, the soviet Union or the Russian federation. The name changed regularly in History, to counter the historical memories, but the actions remained the same through each period.....mass destruction, war and complete obedience to the master race. Why are they like this, simply because they are built on the slav`s..... the slave people who have a burning desire to turn the table on the rest of the world. This is turning into a war to protect Ukraine and will grow to include the EU and or NATO as a means to protect the future for what you claim....an end to war. Heroyam Slava Ukraini!
CNN: can you tell us that we are right and we will win?
Random historian: okay
Best explanation of the current situation I have heard to date.
Then you need to stop watching propaganda, bud. Every bit of it was either a lie or him just guessing wildly (and he knows this; I don’t believe he’s dumb).
Very good analysis, wishing to hear from the professor more often.
He didn’t tell how the war will end CNN is biased
Really? As a Dutchman, I am glad that he is teaching in the USA. He really thinks that Putler has the possibility to liberate Moldova? How!? This professor discredited himself as far as I am concerned. Besides this, he didn't say anything new or interesting.
@@dougveganparadisebuilder5808 Did he say Putin has the ability to “liberate” Moldova? No, he said that Putin may _try_ to invade Moldova as a way to sell the war to Russians at home as a victory (and therefore “justify” the tremendous loss of life).
If the professor is correct that Putin faces death if Russia loses, it’s rational and makes perfect sense that he’d consider all options to allow him to claim “victory”.
D
This is not a war, this is called special military operation AKA Russian Aggression.
An example of war is two or more countries fighting each other by bringing their army into each other's land territory. Ukraine is not taking its army to Moscow or invade Moscow.
WW II was a war because Germany brought their Army to other territories and fight England, France and others then US brought their Army to Germany and Japan, and Japan to Pearl Harbor. That's why it was called a "war".
I called this a Land Grabbing through military force by invasion.
Ukraine is simply defending a territory and is not declaring war against Russia.
A boxing match is like a war because two opponents agreed on a fight. A burglary or rape is like an invasion. Consensual f*ucking is sex.
Again, this is not a war.
*Stay Strong Ukraine!!*
You should go fight with them! But please leave my tax dollars HERE
@@24jamesblablabla
This worm in Ukraine never end.
Why should we fund Ukraine it's not NATO
@@24james when russia eventually ends up in a shooting war with nato, you'll wish alot more of your tax dollars went to Ukraine...
and this is what you call a professional, historian, and a man of much experience? Well, allow me to highly disagree
Gee, let the man talk!
RIP to all the innocent lives lost because PUTIN wanted more land.
Check out russian polls. War support from the ordinary russians didn't change since Feb 24, 2022 and its at 80%
Putin is for ukr demilitarisation, not the land
@@user-fz6wx2zk6p to bad that military is stronger and more intelligent then Putin thinks.
👌🏿
Rip to the 2 million civilians in Vietnam who died because US wanted to flex their powers
*Long Live Ukraine!!*
@Randy Watson they do. Their newest job is killing Russians.
@Randy Watson oops I farted
@Randy Watson 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 I'm dieing right now!!! 😆 🤣 😂
*Ukrainian Bakers, Teachers, Fishermen, Waiters, Farmers, Students,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,etc!! Have a Job Already!! They're Valiant Soldiers!!*
@@tombstoned8023 I support your comments ☺️👍💯 Slava Ukraine 🌻🇺🇦
The problem with intellectuals is that they intellectualise. As far as his claim that wars don’t usually end in victory for one side and defeat for the other is about as wrong as you can be.
As a Dutch speaker I am amazed as how well the interviewer pronounced the name of the professor
She is a Dutch citizen of Morrocan origin.
They’re both Dutch, you can hear their accent brah
Dat dacht ik ook zij heeft eigenlijk niks van een buitenlands accent
Very insightful. Thank you.
Don't cut this man short...he knows this subject!
Why interrupt him, the stupid network time limit.
He was daydreaming his predictions.
I think he was right, if he loses the war, then he will be killed. However, it will not be Putin but Zelensky who will jump over the window.
Putin better stay away from tall buildings.
Come over here, just look at the view from here.
And stay away from open windows too!
Why?
I love listening to professors talk about the possibility of Pootin being thrown out of a window. It's my favorite thing.
haha 🤣 ... one of the little joys of life
i think you should by a parachute and ware it at all times you might be first out the window🤣
Should be best spelled poo-tin!
@@2012isnear-my-my-my you would fall out even before poo-tin or anybody else 🤪! At least I hope so!!
you might spell Xoxol also
Where can I get the full interview?
Why is this guy not on EVERY SINGLE DAY?!?!?!? Give this guy 20 minutes 5 days a week!!! Give him his own show!!!!!
Relax.
I only want him in cnn
Everyone is predicting but nobody really knows ….
Exactly
@ Marcus Kuhnert S P O T O N !!
No shiz...
Chicago song lyrics spring to mind:
"As I was walking down the street one day
A man came up to me and asked me
What the time was that was on my watch, yeah
And I said
Does anybody really know what time it is
(Care) Does anybody really care
(About time) If so I can't imagine why
(Oh no, no) We've all got time enough to cry
And I was walking down the street one day
A pretty lady looked at me and
Said her diamond watch had stopped cold dead
And I said
Does anybody really know what time it is
(Care) Does anybody really care
(About time) If so I can't imagine why
(Oh no, no) We've all got time enough to cry
And I was walking down the street one day
(People runnin' everywhere)
Being pushed and shoved (don't know where to go)
By people trying to beat the clock (I don't know where I am)
Oh no, so I just don't know (I can't see past the next step)
I don't know, I don't know-ow
And I said
Yes I said
(I don't have time to. I don't have time to look around)
(I just run around everywhere)
(I don't) Does anybody really know what time it is
(Care) Does anybody really care
(About time) If so I can't imagine why
(Oh no, no) We've all got time enough to die
Everybody's worryin'
(I don't care) I don't care
(About time) About time
(Oh no, no) I don't care"
Good interview, yes, have him back on!
they should’ve let him keep going. 🙏🏼 I love historians.
They're so old school though
@@colindyer450 facts are facts. you want them dressed up and repackaged with a woke ribbon?
@@rickmorgan1441 no, we want it to wear a maga hat :P
Very interesting, thanks CNN! ❤But please have a longer Interview with Prof Goemans (4 minutes is a bit short for such an important question). Praying for the people in Ukraine 🇺🇦
What about Palestine? Not trying to spread hate against Ukraine but..
"But please have a longer Interview with Prof Goemans (4 minutes is a bit short for such an important question)"
Did you get bumped on the head? 4 minutes is long enough considering the war started only a year ago. Also idk if its just me but it feels like people like you only support Ukraine because its trending (at the moment thanks to Biden). Let me mind you Ukrainian people are actually suffering, and it's not like the dead civilians can respawn after they die.
Protest in Berlin over arming Ukraine against Russia draws thousands..
@@backup_almeknassi9824 Palestine is a another whole kettle of fish that is decades old. Thanks to the British after withdrawing from the area left a bloody mess. Also there is a religious clash which always heightens any conflict.
@@michaela4024 Just because how long its been going on doesn't mean it doesn't deserve attention. The commenter probably doesn't care about Ukraine anyway. Or any war. Just a measly reaction ngl.
This is a very dangerous situation for desperate war mongers with nuclear weapons
A man with nothing to lose is the most dangerous
Yes, thats why ruzzian sympathizers and other scum should be scared
Great analysis!
@@patm6704because they’re fighting the Russians. The end my of my enemy is my friend ? Not everybody in Ukraine gets along but they’re all Ukrainians fighting against the same enemy.. does it not make sense to join forces ? Are you a thinking person…??? 🤨 such a simple answer.
@@patm6704also because they started fighting the Russians in 2014.. do you really believe that nobody has the facts ? You’re either a Russian troll or an American Republican.
Glory to the very brave little Ukraine.
Ukraine is NOT little ! It's a huge country.
Second largest country in Europe. Condescending AND Misinformed.
Little like Texas. 😊
You probably couldn't find Ukraine on a map before they got invaded. You probably still can't 😆 🤣
... yes ... let's support the most corrupt country in the galaxy! ... yay for corruption on a massive scale!!! ...
How something "could" end is not a prediction. If I flip a coin, the result "could" be head or tail. Every idiot can "predict" that.
CNN host wanted to imply that CNN time was precious; but in reality, the outstanding performance of the guest speaker showed the contrary - the guest's time was more precious.
It’s great that CNN brought this guy on, but I wish they’d let him talk longer.
Agreed. CNN wastes so much air time filling dead space. Here you have a real expert. Let him talk.
They dont wanna hear more because it is the truth
They should allow him to have more airtime. He on point in his view.
Oh yeah, to spread more BS
He didn't answer the question
Great explanations by the expert professor, however, seems strange that he disregards the fact that Russia already won.
Don't you love it when an interviewer interrupts the speaker just as he gets to the point where he is about to state how he thinks the war will end? So damn frustrating.
Yes, I was getting interested during the later part of the conversation but unfortunately, it got cut ...please add more of it.
the type of guests we need on the news.
very good analysis!!
Really interesting. I'd like to hear more of what he has to say.
Give him more time ! I want to know all his points and ideas !
People on Moldova 🇲🇩 must be prepared
Good interview👍
Watching from afar.History has shown time and time again what happens to evil Dictators.
This time footage must be in 3D, and in high resolution.
In the past, these evil dictators didn’t have Life threatening weapons on standby, by the thousands. This guy could end civilization, or so they say. Really hope I’m wrong tho
@@isaacgloria9963 unless he gets ☠️ and the next person in the pecking order decides he wants peace
@@MikeR2111 that’s a big what if, who’s going to kill him? Hate to talk so dark man but after all the war crimes he’s committing he deserves it
@@isaacgloria9963 So, you are not among those invited to the underground bunkers, are you? Fifteen years and everything will be normal on the surface: clean air and water, normal atmosphere....and no other humans or dictators. AI robots will ensure all pockets of enemy resistance are eliminated, just like in the prophecies.
"...war provides information..." Such a straightforward statement (amongst others) from him. Realistic or deeply embedded regional security and sovereignty concerns appear to always have been a legitimate enough reason to go to war, sooner or later.
It's a fascinating thought, believing that Putin was terrified of Ukraine suddenly invading Russia. And worse, perhaps NATO nations like Canada sending their armed forces to join in the NATO support for that unprovoked attack. It's clear why Putin had such enormous regional security and sovereignty concerns faced with a threat to Russia like that.
Same as in Georgia and Chechnya previously, apparently.
@@AirborneMOC031 The idea that Ukraine would invade Russia is preposterous. No, this is a war of choice driven by greed, misplaced pride and nostalgia for faded glory.
@@jasonlatour3403 it was engraved in the Ukrainian constitution that they would retake Crimean peninsula. So seeing Ukraine being armed and trained by NATO Putin made a decision to intervene before Ukraine gets stronger to attempt retaking the Crimea.
@@jasonlatour3403 You might want to try reading what I wrote again, before whining about what I wrote. I essentially posted what you're now repeating: the idea that Putin actually feared invasion from Ukraine with NATO nations like Canada sending their troops to fight a land war across Russia is indeed ridiculous.
But... thanks for coming out.
Well, not wishing to support nor oppose the viewpoints expressed under this thread, all I can suggest is that most people love a good old scrap (often to the death or the bitter end), especially in so far as it pertains to ideas or belief regarding religion, race, territory, perceived identity, perceived justice or just plain old fear of missing out on something or somebody. Not a lot different to what we see on a day to day basis within so-called "civilized" societies really.
As a former chef assistant at a local restaurant in my town I can confirm this man is a genius
This smart man is from the Netherlands.
Why do announcers always ask stupid questions and prevent us from hearing those people who actually have something to say (i.e. the interviewed experts).
Most announcers are either pretty faces, smart mouths, or a combination of the two. They aren't the smartest people out there and most of the time they do as they are told, which is "Get on with it. Next."
It’s the producer with a stopwatch, nothing to do with the host.
Interesting point of view. Thanks for your interest in our problems. Greetings from Ukraine
Our (the world interest) is what keeps you Ukrainians alive. If they were only “your” problems Ukraine wouldn't exist anymore.
@@NewBeginnings413 maybe we shouldn't give up nuclear weapons in 1994 to don't make troubles for any other countries. I hope you aren't suffering so much after this great deal with pr. Clinton and russia.
@@minoramare5829 it was the Russians that made Ukraine give back “soviet nukes” to Russia when the soviet union collapsed and Ukraine claimed independence. Don't try to rewrite history.
@@minoramare5829 if you believe you would stand a chance without the west (training, military equipment, intelligence, money....) then stop begging and protect yourself alone. Write your president if you are that ignorant.
Tell Zelensky to go neutral and stop this war before all are dead!
He looks exactly like i imagined.
considering the station this is on, i wouldn't believe a word he says. RU is using pre WW2 shovels and UA is wining remember!
Rememba
Exactly. So many lies...
A historian should be aware that the first anniversary of the war was a long time ago. It's been ongoing for 9 years.
Exactly! Thank you.
Not a war special military operation
@@hotsAUc33 No, when one country invades another, it is a war.
@@StormsparkPegasus think it was a sarcastic comment
But It's a historian from USA invited by fake news
I wish she wouldn't have interrupted him. I was listening intently to what he was sharing.
You are winning son?
Absolutely. Historians know what's up
Putin learned how weak he is and how strong Ukraine is.
but the strong Ukraine can't win.
So we don't need to give Ukraine more weapons
I would willing to hear more from this fella.
I would like to hear more from him.
Great insights
He hadnt finished answering the question as she buts in and diverts him to another......
@Sonomacats yeah, but if you dont let him finish his answer, where the "bite"? Its nuts!!!
thank you Ukrainian heroes for defending our values and freedom.We will always be in debt to you
... defending your values? ... you mean you want your nation to be the most CORRUPT nation in the galaxy instead of Ukraine? ... hmmmmm ... what a goal!!! ...
Oh yeah, you and who exactly are forever going to be indebted to them?
@@creedbel8328 🇺🇸
You mean they will be since they owe us money for equipment lol
Ugly troll pro war detected 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Why don’t say that Palestine suffers! They don’t care!
Why so short?????
They should not have limited this man's time on TV, probably so they can show commercials.
“Because you can't intervene everywhere, you don't conclude you can't intervene anywhere.” - Zbigniew Brzezinski
thanks Mika
@@wobu5361 Daughter of a War Criminal, Mika is a $M-heiress Media icon. Wow.
@@wobu5361 What did your dad do?
Drive truck?
Where was BBC & other News outlets when Western Ukraine was bombing Eastern Ukraine citizens for 8 years since the CIA COUP in 2014? The pictures then of the Donbas area and other areas of Eastern Ukraine between 2014 & 2022 are little different from these from Western Ukraine bombing their own Russian Speaking citizens. Western Ukraine has lost their right to govern Eastern Ukraine. Seek Peace. Grant Independent Country Status to Eastern Ukraine States protected by Russia until they are fully established countries.
There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know we don't know.
Donald Rumsfeld
I'd love to hear more of his thoughts but I cannot find his name on the internet.
"Predicts"and "could" cannot stay on the same sentence.
god i could just keep listening to him they need to give him more time stuff like this is hard to explain briefly
Just wish peace for Ukraine, freedom and democracy not only for Ukraine but around the globe. Victory be with Ukraine 🇺🇦
shut up.. Russia will win this war
Democracy is a scam. Look at Nigeria, it’s just a means of western manipulation
BS you don't wish for democracy around the world
Lol 😆 🤣 Ukraine back to the stone age . But victory to Ukraine ahahhahaha
Very Insightful! As many have already stated, I would like to hear more from him.
Man’s predicted the rise and fall of Alexander the Great
He has NO idea what he's talking about, does he? First, Russia did guarantee Ukraine security and Ukraine was secured. It was the West/NATO that broke the agreement, that started putting weapons right next to Russian borders and even then Putin warned them repeatedly to come to a negotiated settlement. London, Paris and Washington, as usual, mocked him.
2ndly, this historian says NATO is the only part that can guarantee Ukraine safety. Lol...no it can't. NATO is the ONLY reason why Ukraine has now been bombed and destroyed!
It was the US and NATO that repeatedly lied and broke the agreement. And now Russia is winning the war. Ukraine is about to run out of money and it also has not many troops left after so many deaths. Ukraine has already lost.
Watch how deceptively the liars of London, Paris, Washington and Zelensky now do a face-saving exercise and come to a negotiated agreement within the next few weeks (which is what Putin was asking for in the first place).
Need to hear more from this man please.
Because it fits the fake news false narrative sheep like you have been conned on?
Exactly 💯👍 Slava Ukraine 🌻🇺🇦
@@suzanneforasiepi3942 It is a shame that the interviewer stopped the guy talking more! There are not many good interviewers around as is demonstrated in this video again.
Such wisdom from Prof. G needs to be given extended time. God bless 🙌 him more!
Cold war already on.
The war will never end.
China is looking n learning for a bigger war.
The war will have more supporters.
North Korea if they start who can stop them.
With china as the big brother will also get involved.
China is the instrument for creating a world war.....
Lol wisdom?! Y’all are brainwashed. That man just lied and speculated for 4 straight minutes and you call that wisdom?! lol
@Alex Humble you’re wasting your breath. These people are either not real or brainwashed. It is so sad…
@Alex Humble then china support ????.
Biological warfare!????
CNN does not know how to handle independent thinkers. I would love to watch him on thr “Joe Rogan” show for a couple of hours.
I would not be surprised that it's going to go on for years
Even longer war? More anniversaries? So sad. So much suffering. Still, a realistic evaluation about likelihoods is helpful.
I was thinking I could have listened to this guy go on for the next hour, then I found his interview with Silicon Curtain. Fascinating.
Really nice and interesting interview, he truly knows what he is talkong about
He is a great war analyst. God bless him for saying the truth.
Finally, someone speaking out of facts and past experience/history.
None bias 💯 pure insightfull information 👌
Facts on CNN?😂😂😂😂😂
Wrong