Shame on you for not confronting this idiot who thinks her country’s laws apply to people in an entirely new country. The UK is a democracy not an authoritarian regime.
There were other Japanese people there with a tv crew and he thought this Chinese crew was with them. It was an innocent mistake. This girl has already been exposed as a liar and deleted some of her posts that blatantly lied about what happened. Can't trust a word she says. And honestly don't trust this host either.
I know her in real life, not familiar though.. I am humbly sure that there is a 95% chance that she has no any cooperative relationship with the Chinese government or CCP… So I'm confused if she's lying or trying to clarify
The actual video defies what she's saying. She told him to stop filming. There was a Japanese film crew and he thought they were with them. Perhaps British girls are more fun. No privacy in public and if you don't want to be filmed don't walk up to a camera. She's trying to portray herself as a victim and plainly he is the victim here.
Japanese are discriminated in china that is why it is an insult if you call a Chinese as “Japanese”. You have to know their logic to understand their behavior
She is nitpicking. The main issue was about filming. They didn't want to be filmed, which is legal in a public area. Brendan said this is not communist China; that is not racist.
I come from Taiwan and back in Australia plenty of people thought I was from Thailand. Never found it offensive , what’s so bad being Japanese? No even in Taiwan people think I’m from Taiwan and I get called Korean a lot 😂😂😂😂😂
Could you ask the Chinese group whether they have an approval from the station management to do filming? According to the HS1 website, an application is required to do a small scale filming at the St. Pancras station. The approval comes with a number of conditions, one of the conditions is the consent of intellectual property rights of third party.
Didn't Brendan ask if these Chinese people were Japanese only once? That's all I heard on Brendan's original video and this one. So why was the female in this video trying to exaggerated the matter, and why should this be such a big insult/issue anyway? And I couldn't see any evidence of Brendan trying to 'make' another of these chinese females 'dance with him'; he simply asked from a more-than-polite distance if she wanted to dance (by herself?) to which she simply said 'no' and that was apparently the end of the matter. If the female in this video wanted distort this incident or maybe get herself off some kind of hook (in her own mind?) she should at least have presented evidence that backs her up. None of it does.
The Chinese hate the Japanese. That is why it is an insult. Ironically they called him racist. I am Irish and have been called Jewish German American and I could care less. Of course I don't hate any of those groups so it is easy to not take offense.
I actually watched this live. They had played the piano,they had been dancing so what is their problem. I would suggest you look at the profiles of the people involved. Enough said.
I think the CCP are trying to distance themselves from the shouty man. I'm not sure he will be appearing on Chinese TV anytime soon. Over 500 comments on this video with only 10,000 views, that's a bit odd 😑
The aggressive Chinese guy immediately jump on the “racist “ bandwagon, skin colour wasn’t mentioned by anyone but he knew if he called dr k a racist the police would immediately be on his side, that was a dirty sly move by the Chinese guy and he should be ashamed of himself, it tells us what type of man he his.
Did you ask Dr. K not to film you or not? Did you tell him you have image right or not? You didn’t answer the key questions! Miss, you are evasive! Host should ask above questions to Miss Liu and Mr. Leng. I am thinking you are here try to clean up the floor for them.
The girl already had danced in the earlier positive interaction before the attitude of the Chinese changed. Just explain that it was a misunderstanding and move on.
Gated piggy is absolutely eating farmers' food only. The original video showed the fact for the whole world, any post explaination cannot alter the fact.
So are you British?The British are proud of this culture? Is it British culture to be easily angry? Is it part of British culture to like to call others communists?
Well, most Asian look alike. It's even difficult for an Asian to tell the difference between Chinese, Japanese, Korean, let alone a Westerner. It's an honest mistake that Dr. K made.
Luke, your yt blurb says you’re living in Shanghai. Did you gain any social credits by curating this interview to provide a sanitised version of reality?
Ms. Liu takes offence at being called Japanese, thereby implying that being called Japanese is an insult, so Japanese should take offence. Ms. Liu also takes offence at being called a communist, thereby implying that being called a communists is an insult, so all communists should take offence. But this is also very illogical. Even if she doesn't herself work for the communist Chinese government, her friends Newton Leng and Ms. Zhang certainly do, and presumably she knows about it. Plus they are all PUBLICLY waving the official communist Chinese flag in a time when there is great tension between China and Taiwan, between China and the US, and maybe even between China and the EU, a fact which is all over the news for anyone with half a brain, so that waving the flag PUBLICLY certainly has some political significance. Ms. Liu even complains that Brendan is not nice when he says that British girls are more fun. Firstly, in a free country it is his right to think or feel however he feels whether someone is fun or not. Secondly, even in saying this he did not disparage them in any way: he just said British girls are "more" fun, not that she and her friends were not fun at all. Does Ms Liu believe that she has the right to be considered the most fun by everybody she meets? Ms. Liu is just digging a deeper and deeper hole for herself as she makes more videos like this.
Clearly the lady has to learn more english language skills on how to approach people politely to people...explaining what her intention is. Clearly she started out straight about they don't want to be filmed without explaining why and this made Dr K think they are quite unreasonable as if they are imposing rules on him...and things went out of control after Newton Leng shout out... If she could explain better of her intention in less straght-forwaed manner, this incident would not have happened!!
The truth is , British is a free country and Chinese group have no right to stop them filming. On the other hand , the Chinese group make themselves an international famous joke . Now even come with the songs ! Dr K 1, Chinese team 0
If Newton Leng hadn’t reacted the way he did then this would not have been an issue. I think the girl came across as a really nice girl but it’s not her you should have been interviewing as she wasn’t really the problem. To be more balanced I think your video should have also made clear that Dr. K did stand aside with the intention of letting them play the piano even if this was misunderstood. I look forward to your balanced interview with Newton Leng, perhaps you could even invite both Newton Leng and Dr. K to a joint interview, this will give them a chance to shake hands and move on.
crazy comments aside here - this group blew up a simple case of someone playing the piano in a public place in a western country. Later YT researchers shown all the all the links back to the cccp party (spies outed by M15) - double standards on their part and general crazy shouting by the chinese group (lets face it just for effect)- its not just a case of cultural bias or misappropriation. I dont see any fault from BK side - he is edgy to get views but that's not a crime - what is bad attitude is feeling entitled to start the argument - if you were planning to play the piano for your private yet soon to be public release of video and BK jumped in before you- go have a coffee and come back later when no one is watching your escalation. The chinese party is distancing itself from them and their cccp group. And of course they have a right to other side of the story but look at general people watching this and all thinking the same thing - Not least many chinese people in CCCP social media posts by this group against their approach to what happened and escalating things - even when their comments could be subject to affecting their social scoring in CCCP. or other measures. They still feel strongly enough to criticise in their own country.
British are know to be humorous. I feel its very very normal infact. At least he does not give stony stares, in fact he is very opposite and engaging this whole time
The real question is… why is this girl the one going public? Out of everyone , I feel like she’d be getting the least pushback. She tried to be polite in the stream and it felt more like a misunderstanding of the laws in that specific location. It was the newton guy that actually sparked this situation off, and so, why is this girl the only one making videos and tweets and spurring this situation on?
Given Ching Kui Lee, someone labeled as a spy by MI5 is in the background of the video. She is possibly working for the CCP and doing just about the worst possible job of trying to hide that and save face. If she just apologized and didn't post her propaganda video, this would have faded away to nothing, and she wouldn't have had any backlash. Talking with a Wumao on UA-cam doesn't help.
Are you confusing her with Adelina? One was polite to him and the other was "fake nice". The polite one was wearing very elegant clothing and even had a go of dancing with Brenden. This one came up afterward and started the entire thing by telling him he cannot film them, in a public domain. She acts nice, but her intention certainly was about controlling other people and what they'll do, no matter where she is. Seems like she felt privileged to me lol Ps. I'm Genuinely curious, not trying to be mean to you.
@@HomeByTheSeas yes, and you can see her boyfriend (Davis Kuma) in the back smiling all wierd the whole time, he even sort of laughs when yelling guy yells. They all seem really unhinged!
This women is a nice polite woman.You avoided the main issue, here.If the communists did not want to be filmed.....FFS WALK AWAY. All these excuses about being called Japanese. In fact, Branden ASKED them if they were Japanese, & was actually he meant another Japanese film crew. FFS all these perthetic excuses. SO EFFIN WHAT if he called you Japanese. There should be a public apoligy from shouty guy, for his abismal perfaormance for & rudeness & bad manners. He has offended many thousands of westerners from around the world. If some western guy had performed like him in a public place in China, I wonder what would have happened?? Michael NZ
You don't have to wonder. The interviewer is in China himself. He should go out to a public piano in Shanghai and tell people not to film him while he waves a British flag and see what happens.
This wasn’t racist. he made a genuine mistake due to an expected Japanese filming in that area. This woman won’t take any accountability and is absolutely manipulative.
Why has Liu Mengying had her Twitter account suspended? I looked at her small number of tweets, all made since this started, and there's nothing "illegal" I can see. WTF is going on?
Typical Chinese sensitivity. They are chasing this to 'save face' from what they perceive to be 'uncomfortable'. There were no insults or derogatory comments directed at them. What is strange, is that all of these Chinese 'complainants' have been living in the UK for a long time. They should be aware of English culture, humour and laws.
Like it or not, show your face in public and you cannot demand privacy. This is not difficult to understand, add in the arrogant attitude and that is why she is now 'in' famous online.
4:40 she says the guy Jim was from a Japanese tv company, but complains that Brendan said he's there with a Japanese tv crew? Make it make sense, trying to save face in this situation is just dumb, we've all seen what happened and to go out and try to shift the narrative is just dumb from my perspective.
@@mattiassvensson8203 The piano player mentioned that right at the beginning. The group wasn't offended. One of the chinese guys took off his coat and played the piano. The lady who was dressed so oddly actually danced next to Kavannagh! It is a joke how they behaved afterwards!
there is no point that she was instructing others not to do this nor that, and it is very impolite and very rude and what we know from her action that she get orders usually asking her not to do this nor she have to do anythin, and she take the same view for the others, and that s her fake. and what ppl found that it is very funny that she didnot recognise her country or communite, and she keep saying she is chinese or china citizen, and we are interest how can she work or invest in england without a british citizen but a chinese, and that is her advertise for her company misleading others to go england without givenup chinese id.
I think there are not only differences in language but also in Chinese and Western culture. Most Chinese people are relatively conservative and not very open, so if you ask her to dance in public, they may feel offended, but in the West It may seem ordinary to people. Various misunderstandings caused this incident, but it was originally fine. It's a pity that the man named Leng messed up everything.He cannot represent all Chinese people.
If someone asks me to dance, I used to be shy because I can’t dance, but I can behave funny, if you accept being funny is dancing. Now I would probably do some moves, because the older I get, the less embarrassed I feel. I just want to give a friendly gesture.
The woman Brendon asked to dance had already danced beside Brendon, as can be seen in a separate video which was taken just before the live stream started.
Agreed. Many Brits could not tell the difference between a Chinese and a Japanese, which is pretty common. There is no reason why she felt uncomfortable. The yelling of 'Don't touch her' and 'You are not in the same age' are racist statements actually, trying to portray Dr. K as a dirty old man. I still could not understand why being a communist was considered as a racist statement. Should it be a compliment instead?
Actually, the chinese commise also want to film their commercial and propaganda by using the piano and film other people in station.so why the have right to do that but Dr K couldn't.
ACTUALLY, I can't image this story could become a national news in France (DUE TO THE PORTRAIT IMAGE RIGHT) ! Having viewed these comments as follows, could I understand that the subsided social rules impose on the real laws in UK?
@@luigicirelli2583 cherry picked “legislation”: ironically Julian Assange is held as prisoner on the very same soil for his “freedom of speech”. The piano man could had been a good ambassador to represent his country and showed to in this case, Chinese tourists, that the British are warm and welcoming people regardless of political differences. Instead, Chinese visitors are a target now.
@@billinsf88 legislation does not work all the time, even when it applies and one fights hard for it; but let that legislation work when it is fully applicable and allowed, this is a victory for freedom of speech!!!
@@luigicirelli2583 cherry picked to when to let it “work”. Can you even compare this piano incident to a man in prison for so many years that the “freedom of speech” is supposed to protect him? As we can see, protesters for peace in Gaza have been censored as well. Make “freedom of speech” meaningful and impactful instead of playing games with tourists. Otherwise, it’s just BS.
so basically "we didn't like him" ....which gives them the right to demand that he stops filming, even though you're right there DOING EXACTLY THAT. On her other "explanation" video i counted i think 13 blatant lies in about 4 minutes of her bullshit. Haven't watched this one with much attention yet.
This is getting so ridiculous now. First of all, Mr Kavanagh didn't play the piano for very long. We all saw the original livestream and he only played for 9 minutes. And the other girl was actually dancing before the incident happened and they were all having fun together. Also, you have to remember that to most Europeans all Asians look the same and most Europeans can't tell the difference between Chinese, Japanese, Koreans etc. And because Mr Kavanagh had been expecting a Japanese film crew, he got the Chinese mixed up with the Japanese, so why make such a big deal out of it? The same thing happens to me sometimes as well when I have contact with Asians, but I just get laughed at. Kavanagh didn't discriminate against anyone. Actually a lot of foreigners have fun with him as you see in his other videos. The only one who was completely out of line was Mr Newton Leng. He's the one who needs to come out publicly and apologise and say he's sorry for blowing the situation up. The point is: if you don't want to be filmed in public, you're free to walk away. No one would have even noticed the Chinese in the video if they hadn't caused such a stir. But now they're famous, and it's all their own fault. PS: Regarding the flag, when Mr Leng said that Mr Kavanagh should educate himself: Mr Kavanagh made a factual statement. This flag is indeed a communist flag. In fact, it is the most communist flag in the world. Perhaps Mr Leng needs a bit more education himself.
stop spreading your lie. it's not a communist flag. it's national flag of China. you live in a free country don't you? don't you have the internet? google the national flag of China and the chinese communist party flag.
seems like it is people like you can't stand the truth. google the national flag of China and the flag of the Chinese Communist Party. you need to be educated more.
Now she accuses the he played paion for too long..... If thats the case, when you talk with him, you should just point this out: could we use the piano now?
This interview seems extremely biased to her. How about interviewing dr. K afterwards? If you want to be unbiased and neutral about it, then you would have no problems allowing Dr k to speak on your platform too right?
Ok, if she is just a normal chinese person (along with her group that time), why... does the group telling dr k to stop recording? This obviously made people think that theyre from ccp (knowing ccp has strict rules and stuff)
They didn't ask him to stop recording. They asked him to edit them out of his footage, because they didn't know he was live streaming. They didn't want their images to be spread over the internet before their Chinese new year's greeting program is aired in a month's time. CCP would be too busy to mind this kind of small stuff, come on. They are even not Chinese citizens any more.
@@JAG.65 I'd take it as a massive compliment, personally. Mistaken for someone belonging to a technically advanced, democratically free country?! CLASS!!
Why she never mentioned in first place that they need use the piano to Dr K..... simple solution. She thinks she is nice person but a liar, their TV channels paid them for making its video, ask her how much she received
OK, Mengying, I watched his side and I watched your side. I finally think I understand the situation... You (Mengying) and your friends Adelina and Newton were filming a Lunar New Year's greeting for a Chinese TV channel. It was being filmed before Lunar New Year so it was supposed to be a surprise. So, either you and/or your friend signed a Non-Disclosure-Agreement (NDA). However, you realized that you were already caught on film! OOOPS! So you tried to get Brendan to stop recording or to cut you out of the recording or whatever. Newton came up with empty legal threats and shouted at Brendan to not touch Adelina, when he was touching her flag. That is not her. You and/or your friends also called the police on Brendan which escalated the situation. The thing about the empty legal threats: they were baseless. Brendan was not party to your NDA. He was in a public place. As far as I know, the train station had no rules against filming or even a specific prohibition on filming that specific day (to protect your NDA) or any indication that they were asking people not to film. (If they did, you would have mentioned it.) It seems like neither you nor Brendan had any "filming permit". Again, this wouldn't be necessary, because, generally, you are allowed to film in a public place unless the place expressly forbids it. But perhaps if you had gotten some sort of "filming permit" from the train station, they might have reserved the piano for you, cleared the area, explained to passerbys that you might be filming them and, most importantly, prevented others from filming you, so you didn't breach your NDA. But you didn't. You and your friends also brought up "image rights" which are a concept in Chinese law but not British law. So, y'all were threatening him with Chinese law, even though y'all were in the UK. He was quite right to remind you of that y'all were not in Communist China, since y'all were ignorant of British law and seemed to assume Chinese law applied to the UK. Long story short: YOU and your friends screwed up! You were caught on camera, in a public place, thus violating your NDA that it was YOUR responsibility to uphold, not Brendan's. Your friend then tried to threaten Brendan with empty legal threats, shouted at him and called the cops on him. He needlessly escalated the situation. If it wasn't for that, the TV production company would probably not have noticed that you violated the NDA, but now, they most certainly would have! Lookup "Streisand Effect". Your friend, Newton, is clearly not the sharpest tool in the shed!
![What Does Democracy Mean To The Chinese? [Street Interview] | ASIAN BOSS](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nl59t---30g/mqdefault.jpg)
After accepting my interview, Newton hasn’t responded so looks like we won’t get his interview sorry guys!
Shame on you for not confronting this idiot who thinks her country’s laws apply to people in an entirely new country. The UK is a democracy not an authoritarian regime.
There were other Japanese people there with a tv crew and he thought this Chinese crew was with them. It was an innocent mistake. This girl has already been exposed as a liar and deleted some of her posts that blatantly lied about what happened. Can't trust a word she says. And honestly don't trust this host either.
How can you ask the question Do you work for the government? Do you really expect an honest answer? Of course she's lying.
I know her in real life, not familiar though.. I am humbly sure that there is a 95% chance that she has no any cooperative relationship with the Chinese government or CCP… So I'm confused if she's lying or trying to clarify
Some will knock on her door in the night.
She said they work for one Chinese TV channel.
@@jasonz2714 in another word, for the CCP
All tv in china is controlled by the CCP
You're living in Shanghai, that explains it😂
The actual video defies what she's saying. She told him to stop filming. There was a Japanese film crew and he thought they were with them. Perhaps British girls are more fun. No privacy in public and if you don't want to be filmed don't walk up to a camera. She's trying to portray herself as a victim and plainly he is the victim here.
He doesn’t care who you are Japanese or Chinese, he just wants to have fun!
brendon can't tell the difference between japanese, chinese, korean etc. 80% of england can't!
@@digiswitch Agreed
maybe it's not always fine to have fun with some girl when there is a guy. Altho, I'm fine.
Japanese are discriminated in china that is why it is an insult if you call a Chinese as “Japanese”. You have to know their logic to understand their behavior
@@digiswitch As if you could tell the difference between a Danish, German or French person by just looking a them.
She is nitpicking. The main issue was about filming. They didn't want to be filmed, which is legal in a public area. Brendan said this is not communist China; that is not racist.
I come from Taiwan and back in Australia plenty of people thought I was from Thailand. Never found it offensive , what’s so bad being Japanese? No even in Taiwan people think I’m from Taiwan and I get called Korean a lot 😂😂😂😂😂
You were filming for Chinese TV, which airs commercials and is therefore commercial filming, whether you are personally getting paid or not
Could you ask the Chinese group whether they have an approval from the station management to do filming? According to the HS1 website, an application is required to do a small scale filming at the St. Pancras station. The approval comes with a number of conditions, one of the conditions is the consent of intellectual property rights of third party.
Didn't Brendan ask if these Chinese people were Japanese only once? That's all I heard on Brendan's original video and this one. So why was the female in this video trying to exaggerated the matter, and why should this be such a big insult/issue anyway? And I couldn't see any evidence of Brendan trying to 'make' another of these chinese females 'dance with him'; he simply asked from a more-than-polite distance if she wanted to dance (by herself?) to which she simply said 'no' and that was apparently the end of the matter. If the female in this video wanted distort this incident or maybe get herself off some kind of hook (in her own mind?) she should at least have presented evidence that backs her up. None of it does.
Actually, Adelina was happily dancing with Dr K at the beginning while her male colleague was playing the piano.
Have another look at the video
They are trying to twist lives when the live stream is up there unedited. They aren’t going to win.
He did but he still went on to call them Japanese in the longer video. Hence that's ignorance on his part.
The Chinese hate the Japanese. That is why it is an insult. Ironically they called him racist. I am Irish and have been called Jewish German American and I could care less. Of course I don't hate any of those groups so it is easy to not take offense.
Perhaps apologising for making a grave error in assuming a 'Right To Privacy' in a public place....and moving on..
Won't someone please think of the Japanese! We've been pulled into this diplomatic incident between a screaming simp and mr jazz hands.
Apparently, calling them Japanese is an insult. WTF? Japan needs to sue them for racism.
Why didn’t you ask about shouty guy ? 7:52
She’s smiling while saying”I felt helpless”?
Is she quoting what Dr. K said in his video, or was she able to hear his comment from such a distance away? 🤔
I actually watched this live. They had played the piano,they had been dancing so what is their problem. I would suggest you look at the profiles of the people involved. Enough said.
She should be ashamed and so should you.
piano kept saying in the original video that she is british! now she says she is a Chinese national
Also respect freedom of speech and freedom to film anywhere in the UK. 🔥
I think the CCP are trying to distance themselves from the shouty man. I'm not sure he will be appearing on Chinese TV anytime soon.
Over 500 comments on this video with only 10,000 views, that's a bit odd 😑
This whole episode just seems completely blown out of all proportion
The aggressive Chinese guy immediately jump on the “racist “ bandwagon, skin colour wasn’t mentioned by anyone but he knew if he called dr k a racist the police would immediately be on his side, that was a dirty sly move by the Chinese guy and he should be ashamed of himself, it tells us what type of man he his.
These Chinese are also violating what you said by conducting business next to the piano.
Exactly! Hypocritical little pinks!
Did you ask Dr. K not to film you or not? Did you tell him you have image right or not? You didn’t answer the key questions! Miss, you are evasive!
Host should ask above questions to Miss Liu and Mr. Leng. I am thinking you are here try to clean up the floor for them.
The girl already had danced in the earlier positive interaction before the attitude of the Chinese changed.
Just explain that it was a misunderstanding and move on.
Gated piggy is absolutely eating farmers' food only. The original video showed the fact for the whole world, any post explaination cannot alter the fact.
Come on this is British culture … this woman doesn’t know us so well n can’t criticize on British people just go away if u don’t like it here
So are you British?The British are proud of this culture? Is it British culture to be easily angry? Is it part of British culture to like to call others communists?
Well, most Asian look alike. It's even difficult for an Asian to tell the difference between Chinese, Japanese, Korean, let alone a Westerner. It's an honest mistake that Dr. K made.
Yep! And how many westerners are mislabelled daily in China, with the assumption being that white = American…
@@jjsamuelgunn1136 - No - he did not. That is NOT true. Watch the raw unedited video footage.
Luke, your yt blurb says you’re living in Shanghai.
Did you gain any social credits by curating this interview to provide a sanitised version of reality?
Brendon was very confused, he kept thinking they belong to the Japanese team, asking them to dance.
Ms. Liu takes offence at being called Japanese, thereby implying that being called Japanese is an insult, so Japanese should take offence.
Ms. Liu also takes offence at being called a communist, thereby implying that being called a communists is an insult, so all communists should take offence.
But this is also very illogical. Even if she doesn't herself work for the communist Chinese government, her friends Newton Leng and Ms. Zhang certainly do, and presumably she knows about it. Plus they are all PUBLICLY waving the official communist Chinese flag in a time when there is great tension between China and Taiwan, between China and the US, and maybe even between China and the EU, a fact which is all over the news for anyone with half a brain, so that waving the flag PUBLICLY certainly has some political significance.
Ms. Liu even complains that Brendan is not nice when he says that British girls are more fun. Firstly, in a free country it is his right to think or feel however he feels whether someone is fun or not. Secondly, even in saying this he did not disparage them in any way: he just said British girls are "more" fun, not that she and her friends were not fun at all. Does Ms Liu believe that she has the right to be considered the most fun by everybody she meets?
Ms. Liu is just digging a deeper and deeper hole for herself as she makes more videos like this.
Clearly the lady has to learn more english language skills on how to approach people politely to people...explaining what her intention is. Clearly she started out straight about they don't want to be filmed without explaining why and this made Dr K think they are quite unreasonable as if they are imposing rules on him...and things went out of control after Newton Leng shout out... If she could explain better of her intention in less straght-forwaed manner, this incident would not have happened!!
She said I didn't really stop him filming is incorrect. He told Dr. K "you are not allowed....".
I feel all this is intolérance ignorance and fear.
@@dennisyip - He threatened legal action, too.
The truth is , British is a free country and Chinese group have no right to stop them filming. On the other hand , the Chinese group make themselves an international famous joke . Now even come with the songs !
Dr K 1, Chinese team 0
I think i know which group you belong to.
Softball questions and this video will be use in Chinese Social media for their narrative.
She has been quite successful in garnering some publicity.
Don’t want to be film in the public but still going to the public?
If Newton Leng hadn’t reacted the way he did then this would not have been an issue. I think the girl came across as a really nice girl but it’s not her you should have been interviewing as she wasn’t really the problem.
To be more balanced I think your video should have also made clear that Dr. K did stand aside with the intention of letting them play the piano even if this was misunderstood.
I look forward to your balanced interview with Newton Leng, perhaps you could even invite both Newton Leng and Dr. K to a joint interview, this will give them a chance to shake hands and move on.
A boxing ring on the undercarriage of joshua ngannou lol
@submariner99 , I really not believe the capability of this guy name Luke is able to do as what you proposed!
No way Newton Leng is going to show up again.
Keep dreaming. This guy is a CCP troll. He knows the Shouty boy is a loose cannon and won’t be interviewing him anytime, soon
Newton guy has no grounds for any debate except only to apologize
I my country Japanese and Chinese are the same for us 😂😂😂
well calling a Chinese Japanese is like calling a Jew German, thats the point
crazy comments aside here - this group blew up a simple case of someone playing the piano in a public place in a western country. Later YT researchers shown all the all the links back to the cccp party (spies outed by M15) - double standards on their part and general crazy shouting by the chinese group (lets face it just for effect)- its not just a case of cultural bias or misappropriation.
I dont see any fault from BK side - he is edgy to get views but that's not a crime - what is bad attitude is feeling entitled to start the argument - if you were planning to play the piano for your private yet soon to be public release of video and BK jumped in before you- go have a coffee and come back later when no one is watching your escalation.
The chinese party is distancing itself from them and their cccp group.
And of course they have a right to other side of the story but look at general people watching this and all thinking the same thing - Not least many chinese people in CCCP social media posts by this group against their approach to what happened and escalating things - even when their comments could be subject to affecting their social scoring in CCCP. or other measures.
They still feel strongly enough to criticise in their own country.
British are know to be humorous. I feel its very very normal infact. At least he does not give stony stares, in fact he is very opposite and engaging this whole time
Camera tell the truth !
Luke. You didnt even watch thw whole video.
Don’t touch her !! Don’t touch her !! Stop touching her!!
Don't touch CCP !! Don't touch CCP !! Stop touching CCP !!
The real question is… why is this girl the one going public? Out of everyone , I feel like she’d be getting the least pushback. She tried to be polite in the stream and it felt more like a misunderstanding of the laws in that specific location. It was the newton guy that actually sparked this situation off, and so, why is this girl the only one making videos and tweets and spurring this situation on?
Everyone was getting along very nicely until she appeared, figure that one...
Given Ching Kui Lee, someone labeled as a spy by MI5 is in the background of the video. She is possibly working for the CCP and doing just about the worst possible job of trying to hide that and save face. If she just apologized and didn't post her propaganda video, this would have faded away to nothing, and she wouldn't have had any backlash. Talking with a Wumao on UA-cam doesn't help.
Are you confusing her with Adelina?
One was polite to him and the other was "fake nice".
The polite one was wearing very elegant clothing and even had a go of dancing with Brenden.
This one came up afterward and started the entire thing by telling him he cannot film them, in a public domain. She acts nice, but her intention certainly was about controlling other people and what they'll do, no matter where she is. Seems like she felt privileged to me lol
Ps. I'm Genuinely curious, not trying to be mean to you.
@@derekl190 PC Kerry didn't help with the situation either.
@@HomeByTheSeas yes, and you can see her boyfriend (Davis Kuma) in the back smiling all wierd the whole time, he even sort of laughs when yelling guy yells. They all seem really unhinged!
This women is a nice polite woman.You avoided the main issue, here.If the communists did not want to be filmed.....FFS WALK AWAY. All these excuses about being called Japanese. In fact, Branden ASKED them if they were Japanese, & was actually he meant another Japanese film crew. FFS all these perthetic excuses. SO EFFIN WHAT if he called you Japanese. There should be a public apoligy from shouty guy, for his abismal perfaormance for & rudeness & bad manners. He has offended many thousands of westerners from around the world. If some western guy had performed like him in a public place in China, I wonder what would have happened?? Michael NZ
You don't have to wonder. The interviewer is in China himself. He should go out to a public piano in Shanghai and tell people not to film him while he waves a British flag and see what happens.
This wasn’t racist. he made a genuine mistake due to an expected Japanese filming in that area. This woman won’t take any accountability and is absolutely manipulative.
Chinese got a saying 越描越黑。。the more you touch things up the darker it gets. Only makes matters worse.. so. 不要再讲了！ make friends, not enemies.
Just continuing to dig a whole for themselves ......
Why has Liu Mengying had her Twitter account suspended? I looked at her small number of tweets, all made since this started, and there's nothing "illegal" I can see.
WTF is going on?
I think he is against the ccp. The Chinese were appalling! Finally demanding that Dr. K take down his video and apologise for touching a flag.
Everyone should be. The CCP is toxic to everyone
Check out this little pink, do they pay you to betray your ancestors?
Ah Shame.... she plays the victum......
When are u interviewing the other party?
Typical Chinese sensitivity. They are chasing this to 'save face' from what they perceive to be 'uncomfortable'. There were no insults or derogatory comments directed at them. What is strange, is that all of these Chinese 'complainants' have been living in the UK for a long time. They should be aware of English culture, humour and laws.
Puff piece.
Like it or not, show your face in public and you cannot demand privacy. This is not difficult to understand, add in the arrogant attitude and that is why she is now 'in' famous online.
There's always a traitor or two who have yellow fever.
CCP…. STOP! 👎🏻
I’m Australian & I can’t tell the difference between the English & the American people 🤔🤣
My support to the pianist, I see the full video you can lie but the true will be alwathe true, play victim but you glass baby
4:40 she says the guy Jim was from a Japanese tv company, but complains that Brendan said he's there with a Japanese tv crew? Make it make sense, trying to save face in this situation is just dumb, we've all seen what happened and to go out and try to shift the narrative is just dumb from my perspective.
I think you got it wrong, brenden is saying he is here with Japanese TV, not you guys.
Lady, you are just making yourself look worse. You should just let this go away naturally, and stop threatening legal action.
Little pink!
Look guys a real life Commie 😂
what does a commie look like?
What is so offensive about being called Japanese?
I wouldn’t be at all bothered if he said I was Japanese.
if you are japanese in China, you are discriminated in daily basis. This is why they got insulted
@@mattiassvensson8203 The piano player mentioned that right at the beginning. The group wasn't offended. One of the chinese guys took off his coat and played the piano. The lady who was dressed so oddly actually danced next to Kavannagh! It is a joke how they behaved afterwards!
there is no point that she was instructing others not to do this nor that, and it is very impolite and very rude and what we know from her action that she get orders usually asking her not to do this nor she have to do anythin, and she take the same view for the others, and that s her fake. and what ppl found that it is very funny that she didnot recognise her country or communite, and she keep saying she is chinese or china citizen, and we are interest how can she work or invest in england without a british citizen but a chinese, and that is her advertise for her company misleading others to go england without givenup chinese id.
I think there are not only differences in language but also in Chinese and Western culture. Most Chinese people are relatively conservative and not very open, so if you ask her to dance in public, they may feel offended, but in the West It may seem ordinary to people. Various misunderstandings caused this incident, but it was originally fine. It's a pity that the man named Leng messed up everything.He cannot represent all Chinese people.
Are you serious? This very girl’s IG page is full of photographs of her and her boyfriend being touchies feely in public 😂
If someone asks me to dance, I used to be shy because I can’t dance, but I can behave funny, if you accept being funny is dancing. Now I would probably do some moves, because the older I get, the less embarrassed I feel. I just want to give a friendly gesture.
The woman Brendon asked to dance had already danced beside Brendon, as can be seen in a separate video which was taken just before the live stream started.
Yes, absolutely right. I saw that video. & they were all enjoying themselves. Oh how that shouty guy f...ked it up for every one.@@danielclements8739
Agreed. Many Brits could not tell the difference between a Chinese and a Japanese, which is pretty common. There is no reason why she felt uncomfortable. The yelling of 'Don't touch her' and 'You are not in the same age' are racist statements actually, trying to portray Dr. K as a dirty old man. I still could not understand why being a communist was considered as a racist statement. Should it be a compliment instead?
why you lie you work for ccp how much they pay you to act like this
Actually, the chinese commise also want to film their commercial and propaganda by using the piano and film other people in station.so why the have right to do that but Dr K couldn't.
ACTUALLY, I can't image this story could become a national news in France (DUE TO THE PORTRAIT IMAGE RIGHT) ! Having viewed these comments as follows, could I understand that the subsided social rules impose on the real laws in UK?
Lesson learned: be careful people you meet in different countries, with different culture expect different experiences.
not culture: laws!! freedom of speech is acts of legislation, I repeat acts of legislation!!
@@luigicirelli2583 Trump： ？？？
@@luigicirelli2583 cherry picked “legislation”: ironically Julian Assange is held as prisoner on the very same soil for his “freedom of speech”. The piano man could had been a good ambassador to represent his country and showed to in this case, Chinese tourists, that the British are warm and welcoming people regardless of political differences. Instead, Chinese visitors are a target now.
@@billinsf88 legislation does not work all the time, even when it applies and one fights hard for it; but let that legislation work when it is fully applicable and allowed, this is a victory for freedom of speech!!!
@@luigicirelli2583 cherry picked to when to let it “work”. Can you even compare this piano incident to a man in prison for so many years that the “freedom of speech” is supposed to protect him? As we can see, protesters for peace in Gaza have been censored as well. Make “freedom of speech” meaningful and impactful instead of playing games with tourists. Otherwise, it’s just BS.
You don't need to say that you don't work for Chinese government. If they say you are a member of CPC, so what. Don't need to be so defensive.
It's effing ccp
@@fcukccp No
Here is a solution return home, no one is asking them to stay in the UK.
Her friend looks like he played the piano first.
Don't worry, Dr K has deep pocket (he is a millionaire), should have enough money to pay for damages due from defamation suit.
so basically "we didn't like him" ....which gives them the right to demand that he stops filming, even though you're right there DOING EXACTLY THAT.
On her other "explanation" video i counted i think 13 blatant lies in about 4 minutes of her bullshit. Haven't watched this one with much attention yet.
How much?
This is getting so ridiculous now. First of all, Mr Kavanagh didn't play the piano for very long. We all saw the original livestream and he only played for 9 minutes. And the other girl was actually dancing before the incident happened and they were all having fun together. Also, you have to remember that to most Europeans all Asians look the same and most Europeans can't tell the difference between Chinese, Japanese, Koreans etc. And because Mr Kavanagh had been expecting a Japanese film crew, he got the Chinese mixed up with the Japanese, so why make such a big deal out of it? The same thing happens to me sometimes as well when I have contact with Asians, but I just get laughed at. Kavanagh didn't discriminate against anyone. Actually a lot of foreigners have fun with him as you see in his other videos.
The only one who was completely out of line was Mr Newton Leng. He's the one who needs to come out publicly and apologise and say he's sorry for blowing the situation up.
The point is: if you don't want to be filmed in public, you're free to walk away. No one would have even noticed the Chinese in the video if they hadn't caused such a stir. But now they're famous, and it's all their own fault.
PS: Regarding the flag, when Mr Leng said that Mr Kavanagh should educate himself: Mr Kavanagh made a factual statement. This flag is indeed a communist flag. In fact, it is the most communist flag in the world. Perhaps Mr Leng needs a bit more education himself.
stop spreading your lie. it's not a communist flag. it's national flag of China. you live in a free country don't you? don't you have the internet? google the national flag of China and the chinese communist party flag.
dont cry troll
seems like it is people like you can't stand the truth. google the national flag of China and the flag of the Chinese Communist Party. you need to be educated more.
get educated yourself.
Just as an apologize. Very simple. If self defence, public surely don't like it
Now she accuses the he played paion for too long.....
If thats the case, when you talk with him, you should just point this out: could we use the piano now?
Lol ccp apologist
This interview seems extremely biased to her. How about interviewing dr. K afterwards? If you want to be unbiased and neutral about it, then you would have no problems allowing Dr k to speak on your platform too right?
they were so very rude and bought it all on themselves
There was a Japanese crew earlier. Who cares if he thought they were Japanese.
Ok, if she is just a normal chinese person (along with her group that time), why... does the group telling dr k to stop recording? This obviously made people think that theyre from ccp (knowing ccp has strict rules and stuff)
They didn't ask him to stop recording. They asked him to edit them out of his footage, because they didn't know he was live streaming. They didn't want their images to be spread over the internet before their Chinese new year's greeting program is aired in a month's time. CCP would be too busy to mind this kind of small stuff, come on. They are even not Chinese citizens any more.
Everyone has privacy right, and if people do not want to be filmed, this right shall be respected and protected under the law.
1st of all, from nationality perspective, some of them are British Chinese. 2ndly, personal privacy right shall be respected and protected by law.
were u even listening to her explanation?
Look forward to the interview With the “angry guy” from her group.
Sorry, I don't buy anything.... Who is going to tell everyone that they will tell that they are working for the ccp
So being called Japanese is an insult???
Yes, for a Chinese citizen it is a major insult
Stunning stupid defense, no?
@@JAG.65 I'd take it as a massive compliment, personally. Mistaken for someone belonging to a technically advanced, democratically free country?! CLASS!!
I guess it must be… sounds racist to me
when you were corrected the person several times but the person keeps calling you 'japanese', you know he's mocking you.
说白了我都懒得看他们瞎编下去了
"Damage Done"
- and the wheel rolls on
Also, hwhat TV channel were y'all working for?
Why she never mentioned in first place that they need use the piano to Dr K..... simple solution.
She thinks she is nice person but a liar, their TV channels paid them for making its video, ask her how much she received
You work for CCP ??????
so they didn't know him before , they didn't know it is legal to film in public and now try
OK, Mengying, I watched his side and I watched your side. I finally think I understand the situation...
You (Mengying) and your friends Adelina and Newton were filming a Lunar New Year's greeting for a Chinese TV channel. It was being filmed before Lunar New Year so it was supposed to be a surprise. So, either you and/or your friend signed a Non-Disclosure-Agreement (NDA). However, you realized that you were already caught on film! OOOPS! So you tried to get Brendan to stop recording or to cut you out of the recording or whatever.
Newton came up with empty legal threats and shouted at Brendan to not touch Adelina, when he was touching her flag. That is not her. You and/or your friends also called the police on Brendan which escalated the situation.
The thing about the empty legal threats: they were baseless. Brendan was not party to your NDA. He was in a public place. As far as I know, the train station had no rules against filming or even a specific prohibition on filming that specific day (to protect your NDA) or any indication that they were asking people not to film. (If they did, you would have mentioned it.) It seems like neither you nor Brendan had any "filming permit". Again, this wouldn't be necessary, because, generally, you are allowed to film in a public place unless the place expressly forbids it. But perhaps if you had gotten some sort of "filming permit" from the train station, they might have reserved the piano for you, cleared the area, explained to passerbys that you might be filming them and, most importantly, prevented others from filming you, so you didn't breach your NDA. But you didn't.
You and your friends also brought up "image rights" which are a concept in Chinese law but not British law. So, y'all were threatening him with Chinese law, even though y'all were in the UK. He was quite right to remind you of that y'all were not in Communist China, since y'all were ignorant of British law and seemed to assume Chinese law applied to the UK.
Long story short: YOU and your friends screwed up! You were caught on camera, in a public place, thus violating your NDA that it was YOUR responsibility to uphold, not Brendan's. Your friend then tried to threaten Brendan with empty legal threats, shouted at him and called the cops on him.
He needlessly escalated the situation. If it wasn't for that, the TV production company would probably not have noticed that you violated the NDA, but now, they most certainly would have! Lookup "Streisand Effect". Your friend, Newton, is clearly not the sharpest tool in the shed!
All lies!