Honest Review Of Carnival Phantasm
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 чер 2024
- In This Video, I will be giving my honest review of the Anime Carnival Phantasm, and ranking the characters on a tier list! This will be part of a multiple-part series where I go through as many of the Fate series until I lose my mind. My content is satire in nature and while it may sound like I disliked the anime it's mostly bad jokes. I will be talking about what makes it one of the greatest animes of all time... by insulting everything about it. Season one of this anime was released on August 12, 2011. There are currently many more branches but this series has not been confirmed for a season 4 but does have other branches. There is a game that can play (Fate Go) it, so I recommend reading it even though I have no idea what happens. This video contains Slight spoilers, so be aware if you plan on watching the anime or reading the manga. If you do happen to read this much by some miracle, I am always open to suggestions, whether new content or problems with the videos. There Is no English dub of this anime available I think
#carnivalphantasm #Fate #Animereview
0:00 Intro
0:39 Synopsis
2:35 Characters (Tier List)
7:01 Final Comments & Rating
Socials:
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / lunarequinox
Tik Tok: / itslunarequinox
Instagram: / lunar.equinox
Music: www.epidemicsound.com/ - Фільми й анімація
"There is no Tsukihime anime"
This man is now one of us.
Why is that is the anime bad or something?
@@JAI_SHREE_RAM12337 Sorry friend but We don't talk about that...... 😄
@@JAI_SHREE_RAM12337 What anime? I only know of a really good soundtrack for an anime that was never made.
Okay, I guess there was this one product that was more like a picture slide-show than actual animation going by how many still-frames it used, which was horrible on every conceivable level except the OST and maybe the voice-work... but surely nobody would ever call that piece of trash anime, right?
There is however the visual novel and a remake of said visual novel. Plus of course Melty Blood which is the continuation of the original visual novel, albeit focussing on other characters. For starters the VN has 5 routes and with the exception of one they all have two possible endings (or in my opinion three for route 3), so nailing down a canon one is problematic. Also... other reasons that will become abundantly clear if you actually read the VN.
@@JAI_SHREE_RAM12337 if it existed, yes, it would be pretty awful
@@Norbert_Sattler and also kagetsu tohya
All it took was Fate/Zero, and this man has entered the realm of the unreturned
"Gift that he doesn't deserve."
-
Nah the Kitchen Wife definitely deserves to get a gift from the Husband.
Also with the gift he can make better food for her, so did she really make a gift to him, or to herself there? :P
Don't say that, or else Merlin will get ideas
4D chess move to gift him a Pressure Cooker.
Lancer dying is tragic and all but the death of Aibou and assassin was a real tear jerker.
the best part is the track song Assassin plays. I looked it up, and the song is actually sung by the director lol
DOKO MADE MO .
He'll be fine, he has Guts
If you cry, you are jerk.
Fun fact, in Japanese both Lancer and Kenny from South Park share the same voice actor. They even made a reference to south park when Lancer dies and they say the same thing as Kenny's death.
I'm surprised you didn't mention Rin's absolute meltdown and inability to use technology.
It was in the script originally but when I did the part it was just so bad I had to cut it out… that’s why I actually had the phone clip of rin originally
@@LunarEquinox now put a shorts for it
Man fr on that fate grind
No way to escape that fate.
Once you start the Fate path, forever will it dominate your destiny
Lancer dying all the time is something that does happen in the original visual novel.
In every route, there will be characters that will live or die but the consistent one is Lancer. So it becomes a massive meme, aside from the "mana transfer", "defenseless", and "Tsukihime" memes.
Caster dies in every route too, but i suppose people just wanted to see her happy ever after with Kozuki
It does not matter if Shiro deserves the gift, because it is a gift that helps him cook good food. And who will eat most of that good food? Saber!
So in essence she made an indirect gift to herself. :P
Good point
This series shows how broken Zelretch and the 2nd Magic, Kaleidoscope is.
The show itself is canon because of the fact that the Ahnenerbe cafe is one of Zelretch's creation.
And Type-Venus appearing in the final episode when Angel Notes is set thousands years into the future. Which is a big gap compared two the other works that's included here(FSN, is 2004, Tsukihime is 2000, KnK and Zero is 1990s, while Melty Blood and Hollow Ataraxia are sequels of taking place just a few years after Tsukihime and FSN)
tsukihime is 1999 i think
Honestly the 2nd magic is the best since it's the simplest one to explain
@@trinity_frost and if it brings us shit like this it's the most fun too.
None of those words are in the bible
If you didnt know carnival phantasm saber was the love interest for the studio dean version of fate/stay night. That is why she likes Shirou more in it. Great video btw!
"who is satsuki?"
Nasu himself forgot back when he released tsukihime and he still hasn't remembered yet.
Isn't it sad sacchin?
Satsuki route will be included as part of the new Tsukihime remake.
@@gilgameshlfx7006 Oh I'm aware and very happy ;)
I love how in writing, a lancer character type is one that exsists to loae to the main character a lot, and chu culain in myths died epically but gruesomely, and fate decided to capitalise on it by making him a lancer archetype into an actual lancer character, and making him die in literally everything he’s in constantly
What's especially ironic is that there has actually been a SINGLE Lancer who managed to canonically survive and win a Holy Grail War.
And that is a Nazi-supported Lancer Fionn Mac Cumhaill
Grail mandated nazi
For some context for the other half of the cast, just read the Tsukihime manga. It's really short and definately one of the best adaptations of any Typemoom work.
yeah you should since there really isn't any other way of experiencing the story not in VN form
Ah, yes, the show that got me into Fate.
I regret nothing.
Same
“I see saber I watch anime” my thoughts exactly
I would say keep in mind that each route of fate stay night the characters are a bit different in personality.
And Sakura sucks in all of them.
yeah i can imagine how little sense many things in this make if you haven't played the vns and Melty games, though for Tsukihime you can read the manga which adapts the first route fairly well and should give you a basic understanding of it
Saber in this anime actually acts only different from her ufotable versions, this is how she is in the vn, especially Hollow Ataraxia
also Grand Carnival is technically the third season of the Carnival series, Prisma Phantasm, the Carnival Phantasm for Kaleid, is the second season so to speak (all of them are fairly self contained of course), though to get that one you of course should read the Kaleid manga first which i'd recommend anyways as it's imo the third best written Fate title, right after Stay Night and Hollow Ataraxia
I stayed up until 11am because of this even though i have school tomorrow if i look like death in school im blaming you lunar
I think one should watch this after they've played the tsukihime vn and watched or played the fate stay night series. The jokes from tsukihime are just as good and if you don't know about them you miss out on half its potential. Still, I also watched it after I watched only Fate stay night, so who am I to judge
My man fully becomes a “fate fan”
I’m so proud of him.
"I see saber, I watch anime", its a lifestyle at this point
Hey I like Lunar's video, especially the outro part where he looks completely dead inside after making the analysis of all these anime so we don't have to suffer
I feel dead inside one day got to re record it
When people ask which fate to watch first, this is one I tell them 😏
If you want a quick synopsis on the tsukehime story, check out otaku dai kun's explanation.
It's got a few parts and are quite long but it's almost like speedrunning the whole game
But don't hit up the ones for the re-make by accident. That was only made well after Carnival Phantasm came out and they have some rather drastic changes. For example Nrvisk... or however the guy with the animals sitting together with Caster's master is spelled was replaced with a different character for the remake for some reason.
@@Norbert_Sattler The remake did give ciel a better ending though.
@@Norbert_Sattler then suddenly he appeared on tunguska sanctuary
Could u review the Kara no Kyoukai movie series? Watch it on release order from 1-8 and Mirai Fukuin btw rather than a chronological order (the movie series isn’t linear but you will began to piece it together the more you watch it, theres usually like a interlude sprinkled around parts of the movie announcing the date). It also takes place in the same universe as Fate but theres technically trivial crossovers between them so KnK is technically a standalone but still inhabit the same universe as Fate. KnK is a gem imo wish more people would react and review it.
Straight up my favorite anime of all time
after that -> Garden of the sinners. it is also in the fate universe and is a very good one if one can understand the story
*Weird confession:* This OVA series was practically my introduction to the Fate series. I was literally more knowledgeable about Tsukihime before watching it, via the “Tsukihime anime doesn’t exist” memes online. Along with reading the manga for a bit (I need to try catching up with it lately) and watching Melty Blood let’s plays.
Despite that I still loved watching it. I guess Carnival Phantasm is one of those series where it can be funny even for people who haven’t seen the media it parodies. Finally watching the main 3 Fate show routes mostly made me get the lore jokes.
I have been waiting for this video since I discovered your channel
New fans debate which is the best route, but old fans unanimously agree that Carnivals is the best Fate route
6:09 I love how you can faintly hear the chanting "one of us" in the backround
Damn i can't believe i miss out on the best fate review on youtube
"I am but a simple man. I see Saber, I watch anime."
Ah, I see you are a man of culture as well.
I'm so happy like 5 years after first reading fate/stay night I waited to watch/play everything it's referencing before watching it. Fate/Stay Night, Fate/Hollow Ataraxia, Fate/Zero, Tsukihime, Tsukihime + disc, Kagetsu Tohya, and Both Melty Blood stories. The sense of accomplishment I felt while getting pretty much every reference was unmatched. Also it's peak and hilarious
There is a scene where caster is buying groceries and two of the items that flash by on the screen for like a tenth of a second are turtle and curry which is a reference to one scene in Kagetsu Tohya where Ciel makes curry with turtle meat for Shiki
Carnival phantasm is awesome
because we get a 5 second slide of butler nanaya and that's peak
You’re slowly becoming one of us
Thank you yes my very favorite Nasuverse entry and just about the only one I call canon myself (the cooking show is good too) and its the only true portrayal of Gilgamesh the simp. He is so cute that way (Don;t be jealous, Rin!)
Also FGO Grand Carnival is also great and really worth the watch
IM NOT MISSING ANY AND IM GONNA SUB!!!!
There's no coincidences, you releasing that video just after La Creatura is made playable in Melty Blood must be a sign of Neco-arc messing with the timeline again, nobody's safe.
Nasu is Zeltrech's puppet fr
With every moving series your opinion is getting postive on this series
Lol because I love dumb fun animes like this it’s why Gintama is my favorite anime
We did it bois we got him. Now we wait and see if he ever does a review on the Kara no Kyoukai and Mahoyo movies
Ritsuka seeing Shiki and Shirou: Amateurs!!!
Isn't it sad sacchin?
Well, you watched every great anime about Fate. Now it's time to watch THE greatest Fate anime... Prisma Ilya!
(sponsored by "also read tsukihime remake visual novel and watch Garden of Sinners" foundation).
Not gonna lie, the season 3 manga is fucking amazing
The Mangaka is the god level hands that is why we get everything that never ends I wonder if he is inspired by oda
Prisma Illya, oh god...Is that police sirens?
@@noobynoobyesucks4935 it's good
I love the south park reference during the race episode. XD
what did you think about the short commercial they did for fate prototype?
i belive its somewhere in the last episode like a 12 minute part which is just a long trailer of something that we never know if it will get made
I LOVE THESE
I’m glad
3:46 Aka Neco-Fran(the Neco in grand carnival basically told us who voiced who in this ova)
I heard the word doujin neurons activated
Looking forward to Grand Carnival!
Despite your inexperience, glad you enjoyed
You got to your goal of CP. I guess if I ever need to know the watch order to get here I'll check your videos lol
I loved this so much lol, but now review the sequel
I just finished watching all the other fate reviews then this vid shows up
Read the Tsukihime VN
Nice!
question for Lunar: will you watch Lord El-Melloi next?
no I plan on doing it 3 fates
Yooooo this video is so damn good bro hahahaha. I can't stop laughing 😆
Do Grand Carnival Next haha
0:30 don’t forget Kriemhild love is war
i fucking love this anime, truly one of the animes of all time
“Getting used to the grail war grind…..”
I miss that opening
"Super Affection"
Bro can u make a video on danmachi and by the way love your video
This was how I discovered fate and I don'tregret it at all. Also tsukihime is really good
new video let's goooo
Kinda sad you didn’t mention the caren left part but oh well rider always has to get treated poorly somehow
Saber ripping her ahoge off is what got me to watch this
Do monster plz :)
Question for you Lunar!
If you're interested in Tsukihime, will you read the original VN or the new one? Both are equally amazing imo.
I might pretty unlikely at the moment though
I guess the only problem with the new one is that it's still incomplete, at the very least the translation is coming fast tho.
@@ShotterGames true. But then there’s also the fact that Far Side still isn’t released and we’d have to wait for that to be translated…
At this point I just recommend the OG
the best way to enter the Nasuverse. Carnival Phantasm!!
I swear to God I didn't notice the lancer joke until watching this one. And me too one of those that didn't get the joke half of the time since my backgrounds only Zero and UBW.
Shirou wants to be a hero, for everyone. Everyone
5:33 this why her sisters love to tease her😓
Saber is so cute and sweet, that she can cause diabetes :3
now review that one novel nasu wrote like 20 years ago that is somehow canon
Hey lunar. How long has it been since you’ve seen an anime that made you cry? Bc if u want to see another, I have suggestions should you request them. Besides that. Great video! And remember [there is no Tsukehime anime]
I have been thinking about doing a sad Sunday but the animes don’t really fit my style for videos
Only need to finish all the melty blood games other than Type Lumina to watch this.
I watched Carnival Phantasm with zero knowledge and I found it funny, then I rewatched after I played every Melty Blood game and understood the story of Fate Stay Night and Tsukihime and now I understand every single detail nod and joke and it's a day and night difference, and it was worth it.
*in monke voice*: where rin?
Don’t worry, Lancer died in real life too. It wasn’t a false representation of him. Cu Chulainn died in a fight years after murdering his own son. Maybe it’s better he died by getting murdered in a rocket ship than the irl version.
Do Garden of Sinners!!!!!
neco arc and tsukihime carries this show
Lol made me remember how much i laughed when i watched this show like the friendmaker part
God I love this show, it cured my depression
HE IS TRULY ONE OF US!!
Also based this is truly the best anime
but what about fate kaleid hmmmm
Honestly the best anime thats in the fate timeline its s2 of the cooking anime. 11/10 anime and lancer can get folded more than shirou and berserker combined
Best part of carnival is that we found Gil is M
Man being unable to watch the last two reviews sucks since i havent watched those side series yet-
Its Sad that when they did the grand order version, it only got like 2 episodes, i was expecting dounle the fun but i guess this will remain the best thing
Is it not ongoing I saw the episode was released a few weeks ago so I just thought it was still being made that sucks
there is a third episode already but nobody ever subbed it so no website uploaded it afaik, it's not finished yet either anyways i think
Carnival Phantasm is not being released like the whole thing together, you know? First season is on August 12, 2011 and the last is on July 7, 2012, with each season has over one or two months gap while the second last to last one over 7 months gap.
Do you happen to be making a review on Fate Prisma Illya?????
I am
That cats name is neco arc bubbles
Also you haven't done the Fate Spinoff "The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II".
It stars an adult version of Waver from Fate/Zero. I loved the vibes, music, and cameos of the show but I personally wasn't a fan of the magic-mystery plots.
I absolutely adore this one. Its such a gem and so funny
Just a shame Grand Carnival doesn't live up to its predecessor, although it's still good
Nah Grand Carnival is better you just dont understand some of the references
How dare you not like
H O L Y S H I T T O
@@jonnymarcia4403 Grand Carnival's biggest sin is being just 2 episodes long. For real, there's A LOT to work with, why make it so goddamm short.
@@jonnymarcia4403 based
So, are you gonna do a video about Lord El-Melloi II?
Yes
@@LunarEquinox 👍
I dare Lunar to actually watch Illya series now.
Doing it rn
@@LunarEquinox Good but be aware of FBI
perfection...
Watch Grand Carnival next.
1:48 so is fate but oh well
the worst part of this, we have to wait till 2031 for us to finally get season 3 😭😭😭😭
Carnival phantasm is sssss tier
Carnival Phantasm. The reason we will never get a Hollow Ataraxia anime