Israel accused of 'war crimes' over Gaza displacements | LBC analysis
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 лис 2024
- James O'Brien speaks to Human Rights Watch researcher, Nadiah Hardman, who accuses Israel of war crimes for the forced displacement of Palestinians.
The report investigates Israel's evacuation orders in Gaza, describing them as a campaign of forced displacement that violates international law.
It also details the haphazard and unsafe nature of these orders, which have left civilians with 'inadequate time and support to relocate safely'.
Hardman criticises the lack of secure evacuation routes and even emphasises the use of starvation by Israel as a tactic.
She calls on the International Criminal Court to examine forced displacement as a crime against humanity and urges immediate action to support Gaza’s civilians.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalp...
#jamesobrien #Israel #LBC #Gaza #netanyahu
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
Netanyahu should be behind bars
Same goes for all the Western media that helped spread the Zio lies and couldn't stop talking about Israel's right to self defense.
It's sure is nice to see that LBC woke up to reality after a year of slaughter. Didn't they have a female reporter who was onto this stuff months ago?
Along with Kia Starver
Far worse!!!!
with you
These Nazis must be stopped.
That's exactly what the IDF are doing, I assume you've never even heard of the grand mufti of Jerusalem...???
@@americo7965 Hamas?
Shame on humanity 😢# free Palestine 🇵🇸
@@irmafox8706 free the hostages
@@jamjam2833 - so you’re with the state founded by violent illegal immigrants who bombed British soldiers, police and civilians? Would you support that in the UK?
Israel has never allowed Palestinians the right to return, which is their right under international law, ever since 1948.
@@RosaThomas-u3q
When do Jews get the Right to Return to Baghdad, Alexandria, Marrakech, Tunis, Algiers, Sanna, Damascus, Beirut or Benghazi ?
No Justice for the Jewish Nakba = No justice for Arab Nakba.
@@victormeidan1062 Perhaps listen to historian Avi Shlaim (originally from Iraq).
@@victormeidan1062Are you for real?
They are welcome back to all of these countries, when they accept their sovereignty, and respect other people's Wright and dignity. @victormeidan1062
@@victormeidan1062 Hahahaha! That fits the Israeli plan by wanting to steal them all as they've done in Palestine.
International community has failed Palestinian people
Mostly the corrupt or evil politicians!
Their elected leaders have let them down and continue to do so.
Oh shut up. They’ve poured billions into Gaza.
@@abdullahomaryassen747
The international community does not really support the Jihado-Naatsee logic of international Palestinianism.
they kicked off this war .... propaganda alone isn't going to be enough to convince normal people
“God’s chosen people” doing ungodly things.
Like trying too get there citizens back
They are not coming back - have you not heard of the Hannibal Directive?
@WilliamHunt-jf4bm Getting their citizens back does not mean that the slaughter of other innocents is justified. A child is still a child, whatever the race, and they are defenseless.
@@WilliamHunt-jf4bm and there’s the rub. Don’t tell me you actually still believe that goal? I mean, really?
@@WilliamHunt-jf4bm How many innocents have to die for that? The Israelis do not want their hostages back as their propaganda value is very high as they are.
It is so important to let the world know what is happening in Gaza. Thank you.
What 😂 what has LBC been doing for 400+ days AND nothing has changed. 🤔
One of the few wars where residents are blocked in by all neighboring countries. If residents were not allowed to flee Syria, it would've been a bigger mess. It's a war crime to NOT let refugees in from a neighboring country that's literally being shredded.
Ya and the world keeps on not caring. Gaza is finished.
@@Norman-j7m Why?
@@jamespaul6315 And it shames us all.
We have said it all along he just wants the palastinians gone from Gaza…. Simple as that and Netanyahu doesn’t care how he does it!!!!!
Same in Lebanon and the West Bank to!!!
Thank you so much for your relentless coverage on Gaza
I mean he's covering it, relentlessly I'm not sure
Didn't they sack a female reporter months ago for talking about this exact same stuff?
@@Bndghhjii Sangita Myska was the presenter on weekends ..... she was fired by LBC for calling out 🇮🇱 lies and seeking to get the truth out to her audience.
@@BndghhjiiYes. James defended her sacking too.
Free palastine from Hamas
If there is no such thing as a Palestinian then why did Herzl write 'the Jewish State inside Palestine, will be Europe's bulwark against Asia'?
If there is no such thing as a Palestinian, why did Golda Meir PM say I am Palestinian, from 1921-1948, I carried a Palestlinian Passport?
If there is no such thing as a Palestinian why did the Balfour Declaration state "His Majesty's Govt views with favour the establishment of a national home in Palestine for the Jewish people,..."?
"There was no such thing as Palestinians. When was there an independent Palestinian people with a Palestinian state? It was either southern Syria before the First World War and then it was a Palestine including Jordan. It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a Palestinian people and we came and threw them out and took their country from them. They did not exist." Golda Meir. Maybe there's simply no such thing as an honest Israeli leader.
In London there's even a memorial giving thanks to Palestine during the war
@@MartianTom
Your a martian from mars
Is that why you can't understand the Balfour declaration and the reference to Palestine
And
The reference to Palestine by Golda Meir and her holding a Palestinian passport
We all know you stole Palestinian land, and will have to leave one way or another like all the other crusaders did, it's just a matter of time
@@samchris3793 There's also a memorial to Deir Yassin Palestine Massacre of 1948, in memory of the victims of 9th April, 1948. The stone was laid by Glasgow Lord Provost and is behind Kelvingrove Museum.
Still going on about the same argument? We see with our eyes what’s happening. We see with our eyes who are being bombed and harmed. Too much debate and talk. Time for action to make this stop.
I just saw the international surgeon telling about hw it is to work there, Its heartwrenching whats going on in Gaza. BIden and Blinky : shame on you .
And shame on all our European "leaders" who still refuse to condemn Israel actions and take legal sanctions against it. Not even that, many EU governments (such as Germany) made it illegal to publicly critisize Israel and banned all events related to the defense of the Palestinians basic human rights.
@@ninsemor where did you see that? as long as they have hostages they can carry on
If you think they were bad just wait until you see Trump once he takes over
@@tommyswayze2168Search politics Joe. It's on there.
@funkydisciple I think if they just release the hostages it will stop but Hamas an Iran dont want that
It's nice to hear this now. gotta be honest though i'm missing Sangita Myska who was ontop a lot of this stuff. I wish she were back on.
There are offshore gas fields of the coast of Gaza. This is a resource extraction war.
Theft of land, Theft of resources, Theft of the right to life.
When Hong Kong demonstrators throw stones at the police in Hong Kong that's considered heroism in the American press.
When in Myanmar demonstrators throw slingshot stones at the army, they're considered to be heroes in the Western press.
When Palestinian children throw sticks, stones and rocks at the oppressive Israeli army, they're called terrorists.'
- Dr. Gabor Mate.
👍
Yes, such hypocrisy..
@Hastheworldgonecompletelymad Thanks for further highlighting the repugnancy of the Jewish supremacist mindset
When have kids throwing rocks and stones been called terrorists? Not sure if I have misunderstood the statement (if so, please forgive my ignorance). Hamas are labelled as terrorists and if you look up the definition, that is what they are. This doesn't mean their cause, i.e. what they are fighting for isn't valid, but they are in fact terrorists by definition regardless. They openly and in many video's I have seen, joyfully 'attacked civilians, in the pursuit of political aims.' You could argue that is what Israel is doing (or wanted to do), but Israel would not have been allowed to do what they are doing now if Hamas hadnt of done what it did on October 7th, simple as that. Hamas gave Israel a legitimate reason to target them and Israel argue that is what they are doing. Hamas have hid behind the civilians of Gaza and knew what they were doing when they built bunkers/tunnels under civilian areas, anyone who claims otherwise is a liar. On October 7th, did Israeli military targets hide behind the civilians slaughtered, no they did not. Had Hamas not targeted innocent civilians, I think less people would have been able to justify supporting Israel in their actions since.
@@Hastheworldgonecompletelymad That is just so low. Laughing at 💀 kids.
How could any country or society be held accountable when Israel has made a mockery out of international law on so many fronts for so many years!
It was a joke to begin with and one simple question proves it “how would a head of government get a fair trial?” Who decides if he’s guilty? And if they left it to a international body of judges which countries judges? Then you have the issue of a sovereign country recognising another court before their own also ask yourself which country do you think would tell their leaders to bend to international law please name one ☝️
Hamas made more of a mockery, why do Israel get held to such high standards but Hamas get no condemnation whatsoever, it’s wild
WITH THE HELP OF ANOTHER ???
@theequaliser420 total nonsense. Stop playing victim and stop blaming resistance for israeli crimes.
@theequaliser420 can't tell if you're joking...let's compare numbers. Rus got 600 kids in 2 years. Isr got 15000 in 1 year. The most moral army In the world seems to unalive a lot of little ones!
"Humanitarian evacuation" translates in modern Hebrew as "death march"
Is that what your mum taught you
@@tzvischonthal6589 That doesn't even make sense
@@tzvischonthal6589 What use is history unless we try and learn from it?
@@tzvischonthal6589- did you finish school?
Just sad. I don't understand what happened to isreal. Nation of love needs to go back to been this way. Praying 🙏
Absolutely disgusting.
Israel should be forced to pay reparations to the Palestinians.
Im so fed up of this world. The political class are going to do whatever they want, all this talk of international law is just gaslighting
But you listen to james o brian .. wakey wakey
Someone needs to see humanity. This is not the way of the bible
On top of the many other war crimes already
Yes, the October 7 Jennoside is unimaginably evil.
@@StevefromPR by hamas
@@jamespaul6315Lol sure buddy
@@StevefromPR yes. If you dont like it, go tell the idf yourself to their faces. Stay mad
@@jamespaul6315 What war crime hasn't the IDF committed?
With a Trump president imminent they're going to be even bolder.
I think with trump , all gloves are off .
And Ukraine may have to give up its sovereign land, oh the irony
@@Sam88-l4kIrony?
@@honved1 those uk trump supporters are all about sovereignty, arnt they?
@@Sam88-l4k Yeah, just for them it seems.
Just so I'm not going mad, if Hamas sent out leaflets on Oct 6th, would that have justified their actions on Oct 7th?
If you listen to JoB and take anything he says seriously you're already insane
@@j7ech402and yet here you are
@@j7ech402 W⚓
@@Andyreally I think you touched a nerve.
@@Badgerbeard thank you, in which case mission accomplished.
I find it difficult to understand the concept of following and commenting on someone that you obviously dislike.
Surprised James hasn't been fired yet.
@@Norman-j7m Truth
Well he fully supported it for long enough 🤷♂️
@@Norman-j7m The objective truth, though it still took him too long to reach that point
@alansmith4655 - Why?
@@Norman-j7m If you feel so confidently about your position, pick any topic you want, literally any, and let's have a debate.
James, there is regular comparison between the level of bombing in Gaza vs Iraq, Syria etc.
Does anyone ever consider how tiny Gaza is when compared to those countries?
65000 bombs dropped on Iraq can surely not be comparable to 65000 bombs dropped on Gaza? Gaza is 360km2. Iraq is 437 072km2.
Thank you for following this relentlessly.
Creating living space. Mowing the lawn, an abhorrent terminology, was only the start. Wakey, wakey, folks.
More sick euphemisms - "Where's Daddy"
Thanks to groups like Human Rights Watch documenting and calling out the war crimes, of which there are far too many!
Human Rights Watch should defend the human rights of the Israeli victims. Instead of defending the rights of the Jihadi Death Cult Activists.
Sad indeed in 2024.
And which UK bombs are helping them do that
Not sure if the UK is providing bombs but there very much involved in the manufacturing process of the jets dropping those bombs
@@andyisabeast7782 And the intelligence flights and logistics from RAF Akrotiri in Cyprus.
@@Badgerbeard oh amongst a great deal other things we just don't know what most of it is and I don't think bombs are something we know about but the UK could well be
Among the things the events leading up to WW2 appear to have taught Netanyahu is 'Lebensraum'.
I have been saying this all a long
I'm stunned by the slow motion pace of knowledge the UK is moving at with this crisis. This has been clear for months now and its only just beginning to creep into the mainstream.
I've watch Medhi Hasan, The Rational National, Secular Talk, The Majority Report... Numerous outlets presenting this information in greater detail since, maybe, last Christmas.
Most English people don’t care?
@@Bushwacker-mb6hwoh but this country does care
Why are you stunned by the slow motion pace. That implies there's a plan to speed up. There isn't any plan and it's deliberately so.
I think Netanyahu should have been replaced, Palestine has suffered greatly at his hands. There should have been peaceful negotiations made before the tremendous loss of life& cruelty.🇨🇦
Accused? We are way passed accused...
Forced displacement seems to reminded me of eighty plus years ago in Europe.
@@terrytopliss9506 Yes.
Like the Millions of Germans being thrown out of Prussia by the Red Army in 1944, the same thing is now happening to militant Izlaam.
An excellent point, there !
What an eloquent and heart wrenching testimony
Thank you James. This is horrendous
When the French resisted Hitler’s occupation the world saw it as heroism, not terrorism. We need to correct our perspective on this.
💯
🇵🇸 FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
Not only did the US government not act against Israel breaking the 30 days, they said that Israel hadn't contravened anything.
Evil Is Real
Is-rael
Uninhabitable and mass starvation etc yes, for what reason? To create conditions for an exodus
"The Palestinian struggle is not just a cry for justice. It’s a blistering battle for the most fundamental human rights that every living soul on this planet should inherit by birthright. It’s an unyielding resistance against the oppressive, suffocating grip of occupation and the callous denial of the most basic human dignity ... The battle for justice in Palestine is not merely a political struggle. It's an elemental moral battle ... If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. I implore every person of conscience, regardless of their origins or beliefs, to stand steadfast with the Palestinian people in their unwavering quest for justice."
- attributed to Malcolm X
There are reports there, they live there, listen to them.
So much respect for James, he is by far the most direct and fearless reporter.. so so brave.. I can not imagin how many threat he must get for making these reports
On and on it goes, where it stops nobody knows
As long as the west, my country and your country probably, keep funding and condoning the war crimes, they will continue.
Certainly not by any LBC reporting...that is clear
@@pkia898do you think there should be no reporting of the Israeli atrocities?
@garriejackson9551 no by all means, talk all you want. But the idea that.more reporting will do much seems fanciful at this point. Actually I don't care if any reporters do anything.
@pkia898 the word 'complicity' comes to mind doesn't it? Of Western governments. And certainly some media. Keep on reporting I say.
But history will be quite damning on this period.
Why is this written like its new?? That has been the case for years. I know people in Khan younis. Ive skyped them years ago and they regularly showed me what they live in and what they deal with. Ive followed journalists and aid workers within Gaza for years. Ive read un human rights and save the children reports for years. This is a done deal, it IS inhabitable (made so, regularly and then they try to rebuild knowing it will be destroyed again in two years max)
Thank you for this interview 😞😖😔
Thanks James for standing up for humanity, shame on western media not covering this
Listening to Nick Ferrari this morning talking about Palestinians, I really thought I had tuned into GB news by mistake.
I agree. The Johnson woman is even worse as she did a program about the fake beheadings, baby broiling, etc, and has allegedly never knowingly apologised for 'fake news'. I could find no trace on the internet of 'the professor of social science' you had on your program that day, either, Rachel. There is a male professor of that name, but not a female professor, who you introduced. LBC is a disgrace, apart from James.
Didn't Trump move US embassy to Jerusalem? Highly provocative.
He also recognized the occupied Golan Heights as part of Israel even though it's against international law. He did these things because he got donations from billionaire Sheldon Adelson. During his campaign in 2024 he got donations from Adelson's widow to support Israel to annex the WB. This, in addition to the new Christian Zionists picks for his administration, there's a big chance he's going to do this.
Israel will be paying reparations.
Hahahahahahahaha Gaza won't get rebuilt unless Israel allows it. 😂
@@annamcmahon2394 Gaza will be rebuilt with American money, along the lines of Jared Kushner and other wealthy American Jews, like the widow of Sheldon Adelson.
@@pkia898 😧
GAZA is nothing now . Next time, the think about before attacking Israelis
I am lost for words don’t lose your humanity or you become the very thing you say you hate.
Well Done James , at least you speak out about what’s going on , unlike your other presenters , they are Cowards
Get over there and do something then, stop being a coward by posting on here.
@@jamjam2833plenty of doctors and surgeons have done that, what do you think of their repeated testimonies of dozens of children murdered with bullets to the head?
@@jamjam2833are you there?
@@Laytown knock knock
@@jamjam2833 are you there? You questioned someone else on being present, I've spent 10 weeks there...how many weeks have you spent there?
No such things as Gods chosen people and a promised land. There was no Exodus no Yahweh No Moses. When will we evolve and stop believing this nonsense.
The allies starved the Germans in ww2
Its why subsequently the UN was created with international laws.
I wonder why James still able to be there without suspension!! What we know he is on the right side of history.
Don't worry the USA hasn't made an assessment yet, so all the people in gaza have no worries
Lame ducks
The Palestinian “Trail of Tears…”. History repeats itself. (Where will they locate the Palestinian “reservations” in the Middle East???)
The world will have to listen the voices of Palestinian
We are listening and assessing that they are still worshipping Hamas 😅
No they don’t
Hamas has not surrendered,returned hostages ,obrien has never mentioned this .should be sacked.
any accusations aimed at Israel is shaken like water off a ducks back. ( confusion is stepping in )
It’s a fact not an accusation. Please move on.
No, you don’t say.
Thank you, James! Free Palestine!
What have the Palestinians done since it’s existence to be hated this much?
Am I missing something?
They haven't done anything, they just live on land that Western interests want to colonize and exploit and they won't leave or roll over and die.
No different than what Chevron is doing to indigenous people in south America or what European countries and companies are doing in Africa.
The people are in the way of capitalist wealth extraction, the land has value, human lives do not.
No different than what Chevron is doing to indigenous people in south America or what European countries and companies are doing in Africa.
The people are in the way of capitalist wealth extraction, the land has value, human lives do not.
The z1onists want to create a greater Izrael stealing land from the indigenous populations of Palestine, Libya, Lebanon and Syria
@@itcouldbelupus2842 and what is this? Existing??
What are the surrounding countries doing to help these poor people?? Help them!! stop the talk Britain!
absolutely terrrorble not a small measure of it at all
It’s always funny how Israhell is always “accused” of committing while Khamas somehow directly commits
Don't start a war if you're not prepared to accept the consequences.
Don't forget to mention oct 7 james
1,200 vs 44.000, go figure.
@@MrFunkyClaudeyou can’t start a fight then cry victim when you are losing 🤷♂️
I think we are all sick of the October 7 justification.
Wir wollen es nicht wissen.
🥱
Know zionism no peace, no zionism know peace!
Same can be said about Islamization
Where is your evidence about islamization as not a religion of peace. If you dont have the evidence dont make incorrect remarks@abhishekpandey3244
James is the only humane reporter on LBC.
1 question exposing everything , did they send leaflets and messages to people of gaza and hammas ? just use your f brain if you have one
What difference does it make if they send leaflets?
itcouldbe.What other army in existence has ever given civilians warning of attacks? What other army in existence has ever aborted an operation due to civilians being in the way? What country in existence has ever taken in the children of it's enemies, to start them on an arranged programme of cancer treatment, the very day those enemies started attacking them? Israel did all those things, but they are still the bad guys.
@@vincekerrigan8300 are people mad at them because they did those things?
@@vincekerrigan8300 Let's say that they did all those things and you aren't leaving out any important context.
What does that change?
@@vincekerrigan8300 Those with power do things that appear decent with ulterior motives all the time, surely you don't just uncritically accept the narrative you're given by a government do you?
Isreal doesn’t care about civilian casualties at all. In fact they like them. They just have to consider global public opinion slightly.
I was so upset when I went to Jordan. With the water war . Jordanian only allowed to take water from the Jordan river 2 days while Israel waters the Naig desert.
im sure Shealaugh Foggarty will have the Israeli ambassador on her show to refute these allegations next week.
About time hands held up the white flag
What other nation on earth would be allowed to do this?
In February 2020, it was revealed that Executive Director Ken Roth accepted a donation in 2012 from a Saudi real estate tycoon for $470,000 “promising not to support advocacy of the LGBT community in the Middle East and North Africa.”
Thanks James for this interview 👍
meanwhile, weather modification has ruined UK's crop yield this year, and the 30% of our food imports the come from Spain have been wiped out by flooding
Promotes a Palestinian “right of return,” which, if implemented, would effectually mean the elimination of Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people.
Truth 👌
If doctors can get in then journalists can.
In November 2023, MEMRI leaked a document detailing a €3 million donation in 2018 to HRW from Qatar. The text contains the word “additional” in reference to the donation, suggesting previous funding that continues to be hidden.
This is not new news. Sadly.
According to sky news its an evacuation 😂😂
It’s been genocidal since the appalling events of October 7th!
Buh...t GHaaa...mmaaas
name one matter which US regime solved responsibly?
I encourage everyone to watch H2 and The First 54 Years.
We all knew this would happen after October 7th !
I think the people that knew about Plan Dalet knew about it since 1947.
Thank goodness for James and Tom at LBC!😊
In light of what has happened since October 7 I'm still waiting for someone to explain, how is Jeremy Corbin Antisemitic?
Free the hostages...
I think it's the policy of West. To let public keep on talking, protest about the atrocities , since 2001 and Thier government repeat the same again and again ? Do West public have the rights / guts like Sri Lanka , Bangladesh to kick out Thier corrupt leader who's loyalty is towards 3rd country ? .
Unfortunately people in the west are too comfortable to rock that boat, mostly
I will charge my phone whilst my house burns down how deluded
Where was James when the Israeli Football hooligan story was doing the rounds? It's as if it didn't happen in LBC land. Sorry but he is losing credibility and that's extremely sad considering he is the voice for the vulnerable and peaceful folks.
Keep going idf.youve the lord watching over you.😊
they could always move in with you james
Old news. Ambassador Danon actually told everyone today that "once the hostages are back" the education of Gazan children will be looked at
That is so reassuring because all of the spokespeople for that state have always told the truth and have shown themselves to be beacons of integrity.
@@Badgerbeard Wonderful example of irony!😃
@@JIm-ib3tw Cheers Jim
That's if there's any children or any human left