9 in our eyes, 12 in our heart. I don't wanna remember him as 'the guy who left exo'. I wanna remember luhan as 'the deer-like member who loves coffee' forever :')
Nekochii Chan i know that chanyeol and baekhyun follows them, they also follow tao and kris but sadly taoris doesn't follow them. it's been rumored that luhan and kris are joining SM back, but not exo. also, sehun has been meeting luhan about twice this year, i think? he once posted a picture of luhan but he deleted it right after.
True we can see when they debut their first album become an 10millions sellers and that time Luhan was the most popular in Exo imagine if they still together Exo will be on top no one can beat them
Nah there’s no proof they’d treat their local artist with respect as well. The only chinese artist SM gives respect is Chenle cuz his family is mad rich af he could sue SM if they dare mistreating him
I'm an exo-L since 2012 and will also be in 1000 years. People introduce EXO to their friends by showing EXO' MVs. But me, I always say: "Just go watch EXO's showtime." Because them new fans really need to see ot12. Ot12 is the best thing that ever happened to an exo-L's life. And Exo-L, we're not like other fandom, we are mature and loyal, because we have been suffered from the pain of losing members, we share both happiness and sadness with our kings. 12, 11, 10,... who cares? I will always be an exo-L even when there's only 1 left.
No, there isn't any EXO's solo concert with OT12, Kris left literally a week or so before their first concert. Before that OT12 participate in SMTOWN concert tho. But not in their solo concert.
@@ahmadrifaldi4591 it's fanmeeting. I'm talking about solo concert. But if the oc talk about ot12 in general shows, then fanmeeting counted, SMTown concert also counted.
If I choose 15 things that I did good in my life: *For supporting 1.-Chanyeol 2.-Baekhyun 3.-Sehun 4.-Suho 5.-Lay 6.-Luhan 7.-Xiumin 8.-Chen 9.-Do 10.-Tao 11.-Kris 12.-Kai *And for loving 13.-My Family 14.-My Life and 15.-EXO
Im realy happy in your list EXO ot 12, your family and your life, this is i like to see for all fans and luhan if he know this he will happy becouse luhan want all fan happy whit they life and family that why he make song medal, don't bother, dream land, true colore for he self and for all fans EXO L and Lufans😄💞👍
I don't want them to come back. Only because it will make their lives back to the hell it was before while in EXO. I think it would be better to have a reunion when all their contracts are terminated and if they all choose to leave and carry on their dreams that they had.
@@nimbusykz2288 It was said later on that Sehun wasn't told because he would've been too hurt by the news to possibly perform. He and Luhan were arguably the closest members at that time and Luhan leaving really took a toll on him afterwards. He was the only member that didn't know when they performed this stage.
He was the most popular kpop idol back in the days , nobody could ever take his place in EXO . All the members knew that luhan was going to leave , but sehun did’nt know that he was going to leave .
Yeah i want to see him with exo preforming on state not only him but kriss and tao to i want exo to be complete again i want to hear them shouting "We are one We are Exo"
i recently became an EXO-L and i still cried bc after watching all the exo showtimes and other series i fell in love with ot12. im sad i didn't get to see luhan, kris and tao when they were still in exo:(
+XxEmmiexX 22 Same here :'( One of my friends who also joined after they left doesn't care about the members who left, and gets annoyed that I love ot12. It's really sad...
Its 2016 already bu still watching this , my tears still weak when it comes to them .. I miss Luhan , I miss tem together. But you know what is hurt more the fact that they can't show how sad , how they are in pain and how they can't cry because they worrying about us , their fans not to worry about them. I would like them to be themselves because we will understand them. Its hurt more that they knew all along that Luhan will leave after the concert but they can't show what they are feeling .... So many happenings in 2014 .. I MISS THEM , I MISS LUHAN , TAO AND KRIS. I wish their success and happiness and their health. I love you EXO. forever 12 in our hearts 😻
+Hanis Wahab luhan left exo 2 years ago. the concert that they had in the video is luhan's last concert with exo. and the members didn't announce that luhan was leaving to the fans cos they're scared that they will break their hearts. They just kept it a secret until the word's out by itself
You can tell that Lay and Xiumin cared so much for Lu Han by they way they clung to him. They knew this was the last time they would perform with him as Exo. I'm glad that Lu Han got to do that last two concerts in Beijing. It was a fitting end to his time with Exo. I miss seeing him in pictures of Exo now, but I'm sure he will do well in China...once he gets his health back on track. Always and forever he is my Xiao Lu and I will always support him....as much as I can do for a distance.
i admire all members of exo, however amongst those who left (kris, luhan and tao) you can clearly see that luhan made a clean departure. unlike kris who left before all their concerts in may 2014, luhan made sure all their TLP concerts were finished and only departed approaching end of the year. even though he knew he is leaving, he did not performed half-heartedly yet practiced tediously and put together perfect performaces which could be easily found here on youtube. he informed the members beforehand and with responsibility he completed his assigned task (just like us folks working in a company, serving our 1 month notice and finishing our required duties) before leaving. tao, the latest to leave also did not made a clean departure considering he procrastinated his official announcement. after CMB's performance, he went into a so-called "rest" without updating neither his members nor fans about his status in exo. and then months later, promoting his solo album followed by issuing nullification. i am in no place to judge, but considering the series of happening, you can see luhan is a "valuable employee". one who would be responsible, complete duties, serve notice and formally inform people in the organization (for luhan's case, his members) before departing. it is also a bonus that he's incredibly talented enough to be in both the dance-line and vocal-line. yes, kris and tao are undeniably talented as well otherwise they wouldn't have debuted, however it's clear luhan's talents surpasses them. just your loss SM, losing an extremely talented boy with good character along with humility. learn to treat your artistes better next time.
I hope one day OT12 will comeback coz’ it breaks my heart seeing them now performing with only 6 members since DO, Minseok and Suho went to the Military and soon the others will. I really hope someday they will make a comeback as a whole group or if not, they will reunite again and hang out as one group. I will wait.
Kris has heart problems and wasn’t given time to rest and take care and he wanted to leave to have more freedom in making music Luhan left also cause of health problems as said that exo m was treated unfairly Tao’s dad forced him to leave cause he had a LOT of injuries and health issues and claimed that they were being overworked They all left for their health and freedom
I'm so sad that maybe in the future, the new exo-Ls will not know about luhan and kris ! :( I know that they will be like: " oh, so these 2 guys left...well that's sad but anyway, i never knew them so it doesn't affect me.." or something like that. I know it because this is what happens to me! :( I hope that the other member will remain in EXO and they won't leave the group :"((( #FOREVEREXO OT12 IN MY HEART♥♥♥♥
Well I'm a new fan (have been a fan for not even a week now but I'm already in so deep) but I really really like Luhan and Kris bc once you become a fan you start watching every video you can find that has EXO in it and the most videos (like EXO's showtime and happy camp) has still got Luhan and Kris in it, and I have to say that I really like them both and see them as EXO members even though they left before I became a fan, Luhan and Kris are still there in EXO's memories you know, you can see them in 80% of the videos still, they won't be so easily forgotten! Not even by new fans. And I might not have felt the sadness and surprise of Luhan and Kris leaving, but I do miss them when I watch more recent videos and don't see them in those videos.
I had a dream - Sehun came to Beijing. He entered Luhan's house and shouted "Hyung!!!" and ran up to him and gave him a hug while Luhan was texting someone. Luhan hugged back. Sehun said while crying, "I miss you so much hyung please why did you leave without telling me? What happened to us being brothers? What happened to the precious friendship we shared??!!" Luhan stayed quiet for a while. He finally said, "I had no choice but to leave. Kris was right, SM was terrible - but I still love all of EXO. Hyung will always be there for you when you need me. I will never forget my experience with EXO. I still love all of you, and I always will. I could never forget you even if I tried." Sehun said whilst crying "Really? Promise me that youll always be there for me - you'll always talk to me and make me happy!" Luhan said "I promise." Sehun held on to Luhan tightly - Sehun would not let go. He couldn't stop crying. They continued to cry together. I woke up sweating and in tears - I couldn't go back to sleep. This really hit me - this must be how EXO feels - I just want all of you to know that you need to give EXO support and love. There have been too many problems EXO has been feeling lately - they need love, not hate. You may not like all the members for whatever reason, but like it or not, they're all a part of EXO. Please don't hate them. What haven't they done to impress the fans? They work hard for us. It's important we show them we appreciate them. Copyright...XD. No but seriously - don't copyright.
i had the same dream for them too...luhan and sehun and the rest of exo member > when they no longer idols they will be brother friends again and bond and enjoy the brotherhood friendship again
as much as luhan loved exo and they loved him just the same, i think he made the right choice. he couldn't sleep therefore not keep up with their busy activities and promos. the sleep deprivation probably caused migraines and imagine that with singing and dancing under bright ass lights. feeling exhausted and drained he also had to fly constantly to korea, china, and other countries even tho he has a massive phobia of heights. not only that but sm is a piece of shit company that indeed treated their chinese idols poorly, its disgusting. at least he's in his home country, writing and producing his own music, supported by a team/manager that care for him, and is delving into acting.... luhan is making a name for himself and thriving through many hardships. support him!
SM was wrong to treat the Chinese the way it did, but do not say that SM sucks, SM is a good company, you just said that because of the Chinese, that's not fair to SM, SM wrong? Was wrong! But we've all been wrong many times (even this mistake being huge), do not forget that to err is human (if someone comes from mimimi or come, because I will not even see the comment)
I'm not sure if it's completely true but they have said that LuHan has a minor heart condition and that in itself would cause tiredness and put a lot of stress on, also with the eczema as well.
I really teared up when I saw Lay and Xiumin holding Luhan's hands. They knew Luhan was sick and they held him at the concert and kept supporting him. Luhan was smiling but his smile was not the same. How do I say this.. It was a sad smile? I'm sad cause Luhan was the reason I came to know EXO. But, right now I just hope his health will get better.
Think of it this way at least he is still in the spotlight at least he still is out there and doing his thing =) it is not like he died we should be happy that we still get to see him everyday and look at his success now
Ever since their new comeback of the war. I wonder if the former members have listened to their new album at home, in a car etc. and not envy but just happy that they're doing better and are well.
Everyone here says that old EXO-L's miss ot12 the most etc... I'm new, I joined the EXO-L like two weeks ago. I discovered EXO maybe a month ago and I regret that I hadn't done it before. That regret feeling all the new fans get, the old fans don't. We also miss them a lot and I'm craving for an ot12 reunion just to see all of them together at least once because I never did before. Old fans are so lucky, I'm jealous that it makes me cry even more.
this is y that luhan wear red on his last stage(? spotlight⭐ im surprised that y chen can still keep smiling when he embraced with luhan😱 if i were him i cant even stop crying i will never ever forget about exo12
I cried so much watching this..This is so sad,makes me so heartbroken.And I really miss Luhan as EXO,but I know Luhan is very happy now..So I wish all the best for his solo career.That is all I can do. Love you, Luhan!
Being a Luhan stan since the beginning, watching this video never fails to make me cry. I still love and support his individual activity and I think him leaving EXO was for the best but I just want to see OT12 in one frame again. Damnit T_T
it's already 2016 but I still can't move on..T_T This moments always broke my heart.. there are lots of "what if" in my mind..T_T I really missed XiuHan and HunHan...T_T
This is a heck of a far cry, but who here wants them to have a reunion concert someday? ;-; Well ofc we'd have to wait for all three lawsuits to pass by, but wouldn't it be nice to see the boys together and smiling again? ;;;;;;-;;;;;;; Okay then again EXO's under SM, and there's no way SM would allow this shit to happen ;;;;;;;;;;;-;;;;;;;;;
Yes :-( I'm so glad I was around when they were all together. Being able to cherish the beautiful moments. The happiness and joy. Their smiles and laughs and it makes me sad that they're not all together ;-;
It's January 4, 2020 (2AM) and I'm missing Luhan so bad. I'm an EXO-L since 2013. OT12 until the end!!! I'm still hoping that one day EXO will be complete again.
You can tell Exo M are more genuine and closer than Exo K. It's so sad seeing Xiumin and Lay hugged up on Luhan knowing it would be the last time they perform together as 12. I hope all of Exo will Reunite one day :')
Yes it's only 2 months since when I become a exol but now I am crying like a fool. I still don't know them by face . But when I saw Kris, Luhan and specially tao last moment with exo , I felt my heart is aching And I ended up with crying. Ahhaaa sorry for my poor English because its not my 1st language and I seriously fellow my bias( beak) 😝😝
It's 2017 yet I still can't move on. He was my very first bias in EXO. The time when I still don't know all their names but only him stands out for me. I know it's impossible but can EXO atleast have a concert again where they're complete. COMPLETE as 12 MEMBERS. Please 😢 atleast 1 concert. And if that ever happens, my tears will probably cause flood 😭 I miss him so much. But I still support him as a solo 😘 lysm luhan 😘 you'll always be mu deer 😘😘😍
It's right, all people said they may not infront of your eyes, but they will forever in your heart. Now I know how it really mean to me. Losing them were like losing some really important family for me. It's broke my heart if I always remember them as 12 and I be like "I wonder how KrisTaoHan will be here" "Ah, I miss Ot12". I may see them as 9 but my heart keep it 12. I can't forget them easily. I keep crying everytime I listen to Promise. Let just keep support them, eventho some of us doesn't want to let go of the past 12. 9 in our eyes 12 in our heart.
No one told Sehun that Luhan was leaving EXO,on their last concert together,he even asked Suho why all the members embraced Luhan but he hadn't answered that time..
It is sad that I won't be able to see my sang namja LuHan to perform with EXO but life goes on and I hope that he will come back to EXO as of now he is in China with his family and friends and he seems to be happy where he is now it wouldn't be the same without LuHan in EXO since he is the face of the group, I wish him well in his career I will always support him as an EXO member and as a solo artist good luck in all your future endeavours my sang namja LuHan I will always be by your side and support you.
It still shocks me when I remember Luhan and Kris left. I was thinking that it won't effect me that much if I watch this but well I couldn't hold my tears. Exo Luhan and Kris fighting!
They all knew he was going to leave. They all supported him too, probably because he actually talked to the members in advance, explaining whatever reason he had to leave. This actually made me cry :(
every snice when Luhan and Tao left exo I can see that Sehun and Baekhyun crying a lot cause Baekhyun and Tao were close with each other and same with Luhan and Sehun.
I still don't want to believe this..... Where are the 12 Hyungs that promised to be together till the end? Why did SM do this to us all.... I can't help but let my tears fall when I hear his voice... Also Kris Oppa...
We need to move on , but never forget this... Lu left because of his family and sickness. It's okay , better for him to be well , and enjoy with his family. BUT STILL WE ARE ONE!
i wonder why only lay and xiumin showed that they care for luhan>why the other members didn't show it even in a simple sattle way>are they really truly "we are one" "one family" "brotherfriend"
+ong wk > sme still controls their feeling and emotions? i don't see wrong for exo members to show their feelings since they are brothers like one family for more than 2 years...how come lay and xiumin expressed and showed owed?
+ong wk > that is really a very sad part of being an sme artists > being treated as a commodity not a person TTT so, on my part this may not be good but because i don't want to support sme anymore i stopped supporting exo TTT
Luhan's departure for me is how can I say it, most obvious? He left hints, from thenway he acted upto thenway his eyes glowed, he is my bias and up until now, I am thinking, maybe if SM did treat him right, yes SM gave him fair amount of lines that is too much that affect his health, I hope now that he is free, he can be happy and one day, when he and exo meet again, there won't be any awkward scenes, I want them to smile again and say "It's been a long day without you my friend." Luhan FIGHTING! 😊
I couldn't believe I witnessed his last stage live. I really have no idea it would be his last but one thing for sure he cried during Moonlight and I was like, why? Until, I knew it's his last concert w/ exo :'(
![[FULL] EXO PLANET #2 - The EXO'luXion in SEOUL (DVD) Concert Disc01 (1/3)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/y5wb19-2UrA/mqdefault.jpg)
9 in our eyes, 12 in our heart. I don't wanna remember him as 'the guy who left exo'. I wanna remember luhan as 'the deer-like member who loves coffee' forever :')
Same 😭😭😭
Well he is remembered as "the guy who left Exo"
actually, he's not even 'the guy who left exo' he's 'the second guy who left exo'
***** what spoiler???
Same :(
That moment when you remember Luhan still follows EXO members on Instagram.😭
Don't trigger me like that T_T
Nekochii Chan unlike tao and kris who unfollowed them all :(
Nekochii Chan but exo's member didnt follow back luhan.. im sad when i know it... i know because i see following the member who follow by luhan....
they cant do much online. they "probably" get in touch once in a blue moon. too many things happened between the three and the management..
Nekochii Chan i know that chanyeol and baekhyun follows them, they also follow tao and kris but sadly taoris doesn't follow them. it's been rumored that luhan and kris are joining SM back, but not exo. also, sehun has been meeting luhan about twice this year, i think? he once posted a picture of luhan but he deleted it right after.
I regret not knowing exo before this.....
Krystal sameeee😢😢
Me too....
Same😭
Same😭😭😭
Me too...
Just imagine if there is still Kris,Luhan and Tao what would happen. No one can beat EXO.
True we can see when they debut their first album become an 10millions sellers and that time Luhan was the most popular in Exo imagine if they still together Exo will be on top no one can beat them
Suho,xiumin and DO went for military this critical situation I hope there were Kris , Luhan and Tao.
@@samjhanamaharjan7468 If so we'll always have a leader with us
@@doxing1270 right 100 ℅
There must be a reason for them to be apart. Just keep supporting them!Peace.
9 in our eyes but 12 in our hearts
+Alya Marsya awww :( you put it perfectly x
The new CEO is not doing a good job.He lost Jessica from Girl's Generation,he lost Sulli from f(x) and he lost Luhan,Kris and Tao from Exo.
Very well said
+Brielle Ong Tambien HanGeng de Super junior (Hace Tiempo)
agree
memories can never be removed, it still hurts me so much.
I'm crying rn😭 I miss Lu
me 2 every night i'm still crying what that happened 😢😢
Wei Xuan damn 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Kyara Lee i know it hurts but pain has to forget so you or exo wont be sad but deep inside them kris,luhan and tao is still in there minds
你说得对
If only SM treated their foreign artist with the same respect as they treat their local artist things wouldn't hae gone like this.
Yeah I think your right...they're humans too...they have feelings...but its okay...luhan is having fun and has so much success in his homeland now😊❤
Angelina Fang yes he is really succesful in china ❤
Luhan my biasss 😭😭
Nah there’s no proof they’d treat their local artist with respect as well. The only chinese artist SM gives respect is Chenle cuz his family is mad rich af he could sue SM if they dare mistreating him
And people wouldn't have hated junmyeon for smthn that he haven't done
When you remember that luhan liked XIUMIN's post on Instagram when XIUMIN got bald😫😫😫😫
What?? That is so cute xD
They were the closest :(
Xiuhan
Rlly? Was it recent??
when was this?
I'm an exo-L since 2012 and will also be in 1000 years.
People introduce EXO to their friends by showing EXO' MVs. But me, I always say: "Just go watch EXO's showtime." Because them new fans really need to see ot12. Ot12 is the best thing that ever happened to an exo-L's life.
And Exo-L, we're not like other fandom, we are mature and loyal, because we have been suffered from the pain of losing members, we share both happiness and sadness with our kings.
12, 11, 10,... who cares? I will always be an exo-L even when there's only 1 left.
i agree with u. i will always be exo-l and jam to their songs.
So true we will always support exo❤️
Are you still being exo L ? :)
this was the best comment Ive read. ❤😭
2019 and I'm still waiting for them to be complete again.. It look liked it's impossible but I'm still hoping
I DIDNT EVEN KNOW ABOUT EXO WHEN LUHAN WAS WITH THEM SO WHY AM I CRYING
same
same
im crying like the world is ending
same
Ikr 💔
*to all the people who watched & witnessed ot12/ot11/ot10 concert, y'all so blessed*
No, there isn't any EXO's solo concert with OT12, Kris left literally a week or so before their first concert. Before that OT12 participate in SMTOWN concert tho. But not in their solo concert.
@@plucicrescens there is a fanmeeting in japan and ot12
@@ahmadrifaldi4591 it's fanmeeting. I'm talking about solo concert. But if the oc talk about ot12 in general shows, then fanmeeting counted, SMTown concert also counted.
KrisHanTao is together again! you must watch this!
ua-cam.com/video/OTaqb06gVmc/v-deo.html
I think rn, anybody is lucky to have watched ot9 LOL 😭😭😔 Waiting for lay to come back AND the pandemic to end...
Ppl that worked w Luhan after he left EXO said that he cried a lot during practice silently
Oh my 😭😭😭😭😭😭
I feel very bad when our cute and generous Luhan cries 😭😭😭😭
:'(
For real?
Pr...
who’s still here on may 2020?😭
Me
torturing myself hi im here
I'm not exo fan but I really feel bad
me
m-me 😢😧
2017 here？😭❤
9 in your eyes 12 in your heart❤
Still here with that opinion in 2019
Exo-L for Exo This is promise no
8 in our eyes
9 in our minds
12 in our hearts
uWu
5 years but still crying and made my heart broken over and over again.
:((
😢😢
same😭
Its really so hard for L and for EXO ... Im crying right now ...
Some im realy sad and cry becouse realy s kind, now EXO M will lose all fans onli aploade and serche song and film EXO K in 2012-2020 😢😭
If I choose 15 things that I did good in my life:
*For supporting
1.-Chanyeol
2.-Baekhyun
3.-Sehun
4.-Suho
5.-Lay
6.-Luhan
7.-Xiumin
8.-Chen
9.-Do
10.-Tao
11.-Kris
12.-Kai
*And for loving
13.-My Family
14.-My Life
and
15.-EXO
SecretDetective12345 Uwwu wdym 12 kai just do 1. EXO
@@renjvcn They want to emphasize how they support every member individually. There's no ranking in it, it's just them keeping track of counting.
I choose all
Im realy happy in your list EXO ot 12, your family and your life, this is i like to see for all fans and luhan if he know this he will happy becouse luhan want all fan happy whit they life and family that why he make song medal, don't bother, dream land, true colore for he self and for all fans EXO L and Lufans😄💞👍
who is watching it after monster.exo l will always miss them..
me.. I'm crying so much, oh god..
I'm crying
yass I really miss them all😭😭💕
+SEVENTEEN's KIMCHI me
I m watching after monster..forever missing Luhan with Exo :-(
I started loving exo when they already left.....it soo good to see Exo as 12 I hope Luhan,Kris, and Tao will come back
me too :(
Herrah Reyes tbh i dont think that'll ever happened cause of SM. Im pretty sure some of them never chose to leave i think SM kicked them
Same, then I saw on Wikipedia that there were 3 former members, I searched their last performances and I was legit crying for 1 hour ;-;
I don't want them to come back. Only because it will make their lives back to the hell it was before while in EXO. I think it would be better to have a reunion when all their contracts are terminated and if they all choose to leave and carry on their dreams that they had.
Imagine being a trainee for years and working so hard just to be treated like trash. Then all your hard work goes down, so u have to quit. Really SM?
Agrees😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
😖😖😖😭😭😭😭😭😭
He trained with exo for 8 years. 2006-2014
😭
Sm entertainment is the worst
The fact that Sehun is the only one who didn't know that it's Luhan's last stage with them
wait how do you know that lol
What? How did you know??
Luhan didn't tell him bcz sehun got hurt
@@nimbusykz2288 It was said later on that Sehun wasn't told because he would've been too hurt by the news to possibly perform. He and Luhan were arguably the closest members at that time and Luhan leaving really took a toll on him afterwards. He was the only member that didn't know when they performed this stage.
Yes, actually luhan tried to be notice by sehun but sehun doesn't notice it
June 2019, anyone whos still crying? Missing ot12:(
I am one like you
octubre, me
Yes we exols want 0t12 back😭😭
Me
February 2020 n im still crying
This pandemic, made me go back to watch the last stage performance of Luhan, Kris and Tao😢
I miss EXO OT12😭
Me too I miss OT12 so much 🤧
Me too😭😭
Same here 😭
@@baconbyun9100 😭
Luhan is the only member who is still following all Exo members on Instagram 😭💕 even he commented on Xiumin’s post
Seriously
صحح 😭😭😭💖
Which posttt??? 😱😱😭😭
Wich post?
xiumin post befor going to military
He was the most popular kpop idol back in the days , nobody could ever take his place in EXO . All the members knew that luhan was going to leave , but sehun did’nt know that he was going to leave .
i want to see Luhan sing with exo again.. I miss him,im crying
Nikita Aurellia17 I want to......im crying to.....I love Luhan very😍😍😍😍♥♥💕💕💗💗💕♥😍💝💝💖💖😘😘😘😢😢😢😢😢😢
Me too
I want to see OT12 together again
Me too😭😭😭
Yeah i want to see him with exo preforming on state not only him but kriss and tao to i want exo to be complete again i want to hear them shouting "We are one We are Exo"
i recently became an EXO-L and i still cried bc after watching all the exo showtimes and other series i fell in love with ot12. im sad i didn't get to see luhan, kris and tao when they were still in exo:(
+XxEmmiexX 22 SAME X(
I didnt get to see Kris and Luhan too :( but Tao yes.
me too 😢
Same T_T
+XxEmmiexX 22 Same here :'( One of my friends who also joined after they left doesn't care about the members who left, and gets annoyed that I love ot12. It's really sad...
It's 2019 but why I'm still crying... And be sad knowing EXO are only 9
But they are 12 here in my heart
Mee toooo
I cry too
It's January 2021, I don't know why it's so hurt to watching this and yeah I'm still crying :'), miss exo ot12 so much💔
Who else is watching after lotto by exo...I MISS ALL 12 MEMBERS!!!!😭😭
ARMY ??
+kathleen gamilong yeah...
+ARMY _4life do you know what is the song??
me
+kathleen gamilong what?
Its 2016 already bu still watching this , my tears still weak when it comes to them .. I miss Luhan , I miss tem together. But you know what is hurt more the fact that they can't show how sad , how they are in pain and how they can't cry because they worrying about us , their fans not to worry about them. I would like them to be themselves because we will understand them. Its hurt more that they knew all along that Luhan will leave after the concert but they can't show what they are feeling .... So many happenings in 2014 .. I MISS THEM , I MISS LUHAN , TAO AND KRIS. I wish their success and happiness and their health. I love you EXO. forever 12 in our hearts 😻
Really sad 鹿晗（luhan) left exo.......
it's been like 2 years and still crying when watching this..
+Hanis Wahab luhan left exo 2 years ago. the concert that they had in the video is luhan's last concert with exo. and the members didn't announce that luhan was leaving to the fans cos they're scared that they will break their hearts. They just kept it a secret until the word's out by itself
Who is here in 2019, because miss ot12 ????
#EXO7thanniversary
#weareone
#7yearswithEXO
Febry Nurftriani i'am ☹️☹️
*silently crying*😥😥
2020😭
Sehun didn't know anything and was smiling happily
You can tell that Lay and Xiumin cared so much for Lu Han by they way they clung to him. They knew this was the last time they would perform with him as Exo. I'm glad that Lu Han got to do that last two concerts in Beijing. It was a fitting end to his time with Exo. I miss seeing him in pictures of Exo now, but I'm sure he will do well in China...once he gets his health back on track. Always and forever he is my Xiao Lu and I will always support him....as much as I can do for a distance.
miss luhan
i admire all members of exo, however amongst those who left (kris, luhan and tao) you can clearly see that luhan made a clean departure.
unlike kris who left before all their concerts in may 2014, luhan made sure all their TLP concerts were finished and only departed approaching end of the year. even though he knew he is leaving, he did not performed half-heartedly yet practiced tediously and put together perfect performaces which could be easily found here on youtube. he informed the members beforehand and with responsibility he completed his assigned task (just like us folks working in a company, serving our 1 month notice and finishing our required duties) before leaving.
tao, the latest to leave also did not made a clean departure considering he procrastinated his official announcement. after CMB's performance, he went into a so-called "rest" without updating neither his members nor fans about his status in exo. and then months later, promoting his solo album followed by issuing nullification.
i am in no place to judge, but considering the series of happening, you can see luhan is a "valuable employee". one who would be responsible, complete duties, serve notice and formally inform people in the organization (for luhan's case, his members) before departing.
it is also a bonus that he's incredibly talented enough to be in both the dance-line and vocal-line. yes, kris and tao are undeniably talented as well otherwise they wouldn't have debuted, however it's clear luhan's talents surpasses them.
just your loss SM, losing an extremely talented boy with good character along with humility. learn to treat your artistes better next time.
The new CEO lost 5 idols already.Jessica from Girl's Generation,Sulli from f(x) and our three boys.We need to bring Lee Soo Man back.
+Brielle Ong Can you please explain this CEO situation? Sorry I'm still rather new
+Brielle Ong JESSICA AND SULLI LEFT?
Preach.
***** I do agree, and I still support all of them. I think Esther xD was just stating how Luhan made the cleanest departure
I hope one day OT12 will comeback coz’ it breaks my heart seeing them now performing with only 6 members since DO, Minseok and Suho went to the Military and soon the others will. I really hope someday they will make a comeback as a whole group or if not, they will reunite again and hang out as one group. I will wait.
Realistically, those days are over. It's best to hope for OT9 again in a few years, after EXO is done with the military.
why Tao Luhan and Kris left the EXO? pls i need answer :(
Kris has heart problems and wasn’t given time to rest and take care and he wanted to leave to have more freedom in making music
Luhan left also cause of health problems as said that exo m was treated unfairly
Tao’s dad forced him to leave cause he had a LOT of injuries and health issues and claimed that they were being overworked
They all left for their health and freedom
yes, it breaks my heart seeing what used to be 12 turn into a group of 6. i hope the members can finish their services soon and reunite.
@@ariel-lz7im and it's actually 5 cuz Lay can't even perform with the members ;-;
2020 but still crying and remembering tha past Exo😭
Same. ;-;
me too
I'm so sad that maybe in the future, the new exo-Ls will not know about luhan and kris ! :( I know that they will be like: " oh, so these 2 guys left...well that's sad but anyway, i never knew them so it doesn't affect me.." or something like that. I know it because this is what happens to me! :( I hope that the other member will remain in EXO and they won't leave the group :"((( #FOREVEREXO OT12 IN MY HEART♥♥♥♥
Other members*
I'm actually a new EXO-L and I will never forget them because EXO will never be the same without them.
I understand what you feel, I discovered their after Kris leaving and I don't feel the same sadness with Luhan :(
*them
Well I'm a new fan (have been a fan for not even a week now but I'm already in so deep) but I really really like Luhan and Kris bc once you become a fan you start watching every video you can find that has EXO in it and the most videos (like EXO's showtime and happy camp) has still got Luhan and Kris in it, and I have to say that I really like them both and see them as EXO members even though they left before I became a fan, Luhan and Kris are still there in EXO's memories you know, you can see them in 80% of the videos still, they won't be so easily forgotten! Not even by new fans. And I might not have felt the sadness and surprise of Luhan and Kris leaving, but I do miss them when I watch more recent videos and don't see them in those videos.
I had a dream - Sehun came to Beijing. He entered Luhan's house and shouted "Hyung!!!" and ran up to him and gave him a hug while Luhan was texting someone. Luhan hugged back. Sehun said while crying,
"I miss you so much hyung please why did you leave without telling me? What happened to us being brothers? What happened to the precious friendship we shared??!!"
Luhan stayed quiet for a while. He finally said, "I had no choice but to leave. Kris was right, SM was terrible - but I still love all of EXO. Hyung will always be there for you when you need me. I will never forget my experience with EXO. I still love all of you, and I always will. I could never forget you even if I tried."
Sehun said whilst crying "Really? Promise me that youll always be there for me - you'll always talk to me and make me happy!"
Luhan said "I promise."
Sehun held on to Luhan tightly - Sehun would not let go. He couldn't stop crying. They continued to cry together.
I woke up sweating and in tears - I couldn't go back to sleep. This really hit me - this must be how EXO feels - I just want all of you to know that you need to give EXO support and love. There have been too many problems EXO has been feeling lately - they need love, not hate. You may not like all the members for whatever reason, but like it or not, they're all a part of EXO. Please don't hate them. What haven't they done to impress the fans? They work hard for us. It's important we show them we appreciate them.
Copyright...XD. No but seriously - don't copyright.
jw what language did you hear them speaking lol
haruhizuzu123
They spoke in Korean - I don't even know Korean - but I understood them. Idk, Luhan is my bias - It was hard for me to write this.
i had the same dream for them too...luhan and sehun and the rest of exo member > when they no longer idols they will be brother friends again and bond and enjoy the brotherhood friendship again
LuzM Agui I hope so...
I wish I get to see them perform as ot12 even if it is only im my dream... TT
Luhan was the deer that bought me to EXO I would've never knew about EXO if luhan wasn't there😭😭😭😭
Luhan Fighting!💗💗💗💗💗😭😭😭😖
Who here in 2019?😢
Me....but i love them in such a short time...i miss all of them so much
Apa salah nya kalau tengok 2019
Nur Aina 2020 ;(
Me in 2020 :')
as much as luhan loved exo and they loved him just the same, i think he made the right choice. he couldn't sleep therefore not keep up with their busy activities and promos. the sleep deprivation probably caused migraines and imagine that with singing and dancing under bright ass lights. feeling exhausted and drained he also had to fly constantly to korea, china, and other countries even tho he has a massive phobia of heights. not only that but sm is a piece of shit company that indeed treated their chinese idols poorly, its disgusting. at least he's in his home country, writing and producing his own music, supported by a team/manager that care for him, and is delving into acting.... luhan is making a name for himself and thriving through many hardships. support him!
Bianca Portillo Well true SM Is Shit They are bad-threating exo and Girls
Genaration
SM is amazing*
SM was wrong to treat the Chinese the way it did, but do not say that SM sucks, SM is a good company, you just said that because of the Chinese, that's not fair to SM, SM wrong? Was wrong! But we've all been wrong many times (even this mistake being huge), do not forget that to err is human (if someone comes from mimimi or come, because I will not even see the comment)
I'm not sure if it's completely true but they have said that LuHan has a minor heart condition and that in itself would cause tiredness and put a lot of stress on, also with the eczema as well.
@@inishireland what?? Really I didn't know that!
God I miss him..I miss the three of them......watching EXO showtime really makes you love em.
Today 10 October,2019 it's been 5 years since Luhan left😭😭😭 I'm missing him 😭
Who is here in 2018 after luhan follow xiumin's instagram??? 😭😭😭😭 i miss him so much :(
Sameee:"(
Wats luhan's ig?
@@franceskamortela9276 @7_luhan_m
Ojala que esten juntos en un futuro cercano
Memories...
I really teared up when I saw Lay and Xiumin holding Luhan's hands. They knew Luhan was sick and they held him at the concert and kept supporting him. Luhan was smiling but his smile was not the same. How do I say this.. It was a sad smile? I'm sad cause Luhan was the reason I came to know EXO. But, right now I just hope his health will get better.
They all know... Except Sehun😢😭
2019 everyone?😭
Did sehun not know he was leaving?
@@itzel1489 no cuz he was the closest to luhan and was already heart broken when kris lwft
@@Aminah31 this broke me and it's 12am-
😭😭😭😭
@@Aminah31 why,can you tell about it to me
*LUHAN, you are my forever only bias in KPOP*
*EXO, the only KPOP group i'll stan forever* 💙
I think Lay knew that something was going on...
+Raining Starlight seriously ?
+Raining Starlight seriously ?
+Raining Starlight I'm sorry I'm new to this but can you tell me how did you know that Lu told them?
Roorarita lay has a warm smile that make everybody feel at peace i think omfg
im crying so much :( I miss luhan so so so much
me too.
me too
Think of it this way at least he is still in the spotlight at least he still is out there and doing his thing =) it is not like he died we should be happy that we still get to see him everyday and look at his success now
aw ur username is so cute
Saloni S. Do you mean mine? if so thank you
You will always be my first bias. I'm literally crying right now while watching this. I missed OT12 so much.💔
he was my first bias, ....
i started crying as the video starts.
12 members always in my heart
Ever since their new comeback of the war. I wonder if the former members have listened to their new album at home, in a car etc. and not envy but just happy that they're doing better and are well.
I dont really need luhan to come back to exo cause hes better where he is but i want exo to be together and talk again
SM please treat your chinese artists well, please we beg you
2018 here? :')
2019
I’m from 2019
aww at 1:10 lay looks like he trying not to cry
i think it was at that moment when luhan asked lay if it's okay for him to go back to china ( mean he's leaving ) and lay just nodded sadly
waaaa why u tell me that why i read it im crying.....waaaa...
He was😭😭😭😭
Everyone here says that old EXO-L's miss ot12 the most etc... I'm new, I joined the EXO-L like two weeks ago. I discovered EXO maybe a month ago and I regret that I hadn't done it before. That regret feeling all the new fans get, the old fans don't. We also miss them a lot and I'm craving for an ot12 reunion just to see all of them together at least once because I never did before. Old fans are so lucky, I'm jealous that it makes me cry even more.
왜 이제야 좋아했을까 ㅠㅠ 언제든지 돌아와 반갑게 맞이해줄게
still remember how luhan made me cry like there's no tomorrow
this is y that luhan wear red on his last stage(?
spotlight⭐
im surprised that y chen can still keep smiling when he embraced with luhan😱 if i were him i cant even stop crying
i will never ever forget about exo12
I cried so much watching this..This is so sad,makes me so heartbroken.And I really miss Luhan as EXO,but I know Luhan is very happy now..So I wish all the best for his solo career.That is all I can do. Love you, Luhan!
Being a Luhan stan since the beginning, watching this video never fails to make me cry.
I still love and support his individual activity and I think him leaving EXO was for the best but I just want to see OT12 in one frame again. Damnit T_T
Its 2020 and i still miss Kris,Luhan and Tao😢💔😢💔
it's already 2016 but I still can't move on..T_T
This moments always broke my heart..
there are lots of "what if" in my mind..T_T
I really missed XiuHan and HunHan...T_T
This is a heck of a far cry, but who here wants them to have a reunion concert someday? ;-;
Well ofc we'd have to wait for all three lawsuits to pass by, but wouldn't it be nice to see the boys together and smiling again? ;;;;;;-;;;;;;;
Okay then again EXO's under SM, and there's no way SM would allow this shit to happen ;;;;;;;;;;;-;;;;;;;;;
Yes :-( I'm so glad I was around when they were all together. Being able to cherish the beautiful moments. The happiness and joy. Their smiles and laughs and it makes me sad that they're not all together ;-;
It's January 4, 2020 (2AM) and I'm missing Luhan so bad. I'm an EXO-L since 2013. OT12 until the end!!! I'm still hoping that one day EXO will be complete again.
Its 21 December 2020 but i miss them
when evry old video about exo suddenly gets recommended on my feed...
oh, the memories of the legendary #ot12... 😔😔😔
You can tell Exo M are more genuine and closer than Exo K. It's so sad seeing Xiumin and Lay hugged up on Luhan knowing it would be the last time they perform together as 12. I hope all of Exo will Reunite one day :')
its just a month since I become a fan but why I am crying? 😭😖
Same😭😭😭😭
me too😢i just became exol but seeing this...crying😭😭
sameee😭😭😭
Yes it's only 2 months since when I become a exol but now
I am crying like a fool.
I still don't know them by face . But when I saw Kris, Luhan and specially tao last moment with exo , I felt my heart is aching
And I ended up with crying.
Ahhaaa sorry for my poor English because its not my 1st language and I seriously fellow my bias( beak) 😝😝
I feel you😭😭😭😭
*You will always be my first love in kpop no matter what happened, my love for you will always be greater than the other groups that I stan now.*
I love you luhan exo❤❤❤❤❤
It's 2017 yet I still can't move on. He was my very first bias in EXO. The time when I still don't know all their names but only him stands out for me.
I know it's impossible but can EXO atleast have a concert again where they're complete. COMPLETE as 12 MEMBERS. Please 😢 atleast 1 concert. And if that ever happens, my tears will probably cause flood 😭 I miss him so much. But I still support him as a solo 😘 lysm luhan 😘 you'll always be mu deer 😘😘😍
They maybe met secretly few times...I'm still happy that KrisTaoHan living their best life
i realy cried this is nice vedio
+Sara Imad Fakih Thank you so much! _/\_
+1
+LUHAN SOLO what song
I'm About To Cry:(
+kathleen gamilong It's closer by Taeyeon
2019 everyone? I miss them. Gosh,im not crying! You are!! T_T
It's been years, I'm still stuck on you Luhan.
This Actually Made me cry....Lulu was my Favorite... Now I'm crying Everyday... T~T
Luhan Lover me too but still my favorite even if he's not in exo anymore. I still support him as a solo artist and I still support exo.
It's right, all people said they may not infront of your eyes, but they will forever in your heart. Now I know how it really mean to me. Losing them were like losing some really important family for me. It's broke my heart if I always remember them as 12 and I be like "I wonder how KrisTaoHan will be here" "Ah, I miss Ot12". I may see them as 9 but my heart keep it 12. I can't forget them easily. I keep crying everytime I listen to Promise. Let just keep support them, eventho some of us doesn't want to let go of the past 12. 9 in our eyes 12 in our heart.
Leaving exo must not be an easy decision for him. Let's wish the best for him.
3:12 Look at Kai , he knew that it’s luhan’s last stage with them
the sad thing is sehun never hold luhan hand :(
No one told Sehun that Luhan was leaving EXO,on their last concert together,he even asked Suho why all the members embraced Luhan but he hadn't answered that time..
Naomi S OMG REALLY?!? I THOUGHT I COULD HOLD MY CRYING!! BECAUSE OF UR COMMENT T-T its so depressing ;-;
No one told Sehun that luhan is leaving exo that time
@Cess Siguan really? Is this true? I thought this was just fanfic but seeing more are confirming... Why did they not tell Sehun???
Why didn't they tell him?
Luhan,Kris, and Tao will be missed😓😪
Tbh. Luhan was one of the underrated artists in exo. Watched their previous videos and he was such a team player and loved his former members so much.
Kaasar.. 2021 na eh.. naiiyak parin ako! Bat kc nakita ko pa toh 🥺😭😭💔 luhan!!!!
It is sad that I won't be able to see my sang namja LuHan to perform with EXO but life goes on and I hope that he will come back to EXO as of now he is in China with his family and friends and he seems to be happy where he is now it wouldn't be the same without LuHan in EXO since he is the face of the group, I wish him well in his career I will always support him as an EXO member and as a solo artist good luck in all your future endeavours my sang namja LuHan I will always be by your side and support you.
It still shocks me when I remember Luhan and Kris left. I was thinking that it won't effect me that much if I watch this but well I couldn't hold my tears. Exo Luhan and Kris fighting!
I miss you.. I miss ot12 so bad...
its already 7 years , but i still hoping for his back, while i know that is impossble. :"(
They all knew he was going to leave. They all supported him too, probably because he actually talked to the members in advance, explaining whatever reason he had to leave. This actually made me cry :(
WHY AM I CRYING SO MUCH? I DIDN'T EVEN WAS AN EXOL WHEN OT12 WAS TOGETHER UGH I CAN'T
He is my fav member in exo....the reason why i came to know of exo..
every snice when Luhan and Tao left exo I can see that Sehun and Baekhyun crying a lot cause Baekhyun and Tao were close with each other and same with Luhan and Sehun.
I still don't want to believe this.....
Where are the 12 Hyungs that promised to be together till the end?
Why did SM do this to us all.... I can't help but let my tears fall when I hear his voice... Also Kris Oppa...
We need to move on , but never forget this... Lu left because of his family and sickness. It's okay , better for him to be well , and enjoy with his family.
BUT STILL WE ARE ONE!
SkyWonder Tutorials
sickness? i really don't know anything about lu having sickness
He does. Insomnia... He cant even sleep. He's too tired. Kris and lu left exo because of their healt condition is not good.
i wonder why only lay and xiumin showed that they care for luhan>why the other members didn't show it even in a simple sattle way>are they really truly "we are one" "one family" "brotherfriend"
That's why I think exo m members most close with each other rather than k.
Most of the time, sm ent does not allow them to.
+ong wk > sme still controls their feeling and emotions? i don't see wrong for exo members to show their feelings since they are brothers like one family for more than 2 years...how come lay and xiumin expressed and showed owed?
That's what I've been told. Tao was also forced by sme to delete a Weibo post that was to support luhan when luhan left
+ong wk > that is really a very sad part of being an sme artists > being treated as a commodity not a person TTT
so, on my part this may not be good but because i don't want to support sme anymore i stopped supporting exo TTT
Always be a fan of EXO no matter what! Miss my ot12 and still hoping to see them again.
Shane Ferrer
Me too :(
Whose still watching these in 2018? Waiting for EXO comeback on OCTOBER 11,2018 as an OT12? 😞💔
Luhan's departure for me is how can I say it, most obvious? He left hints, from thenway he acted upto thenway his eyes glowed, he is my bias and up until now, I am thinking, maybe if SM did treat him right, yes SM gave him fair amount of lines that is too much that affect his health, I hope now that he is free, he can be happy and one day, when he and exo meet again, there won't be any awkward scenes, I want them to smile again and say "It's been a long day without you my friend." Luhan FIGHTING! 😊
I couldn't believe I witnessed his last stage live. I really have no idea it would be his last but one thing for sure he cried during Moonlight and I was like, why? Until, I knew it's his last concert w/ exo :'(
I miss exo ot12 :(
I miss Luhan too. He may not be one of my bias, but all the OT12 members as one was the main reason why I became an EXO-L during their debut.