Israel reacts to Hamas accepting Egyptian cease-fire proposal
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 тра 2024
- Hamas said they accepted a cease-fire proposal from Qatar and Egypt. According to unnamed Israeli officials the deal is a pressure tactic. NBC News’ Richard Engel reports on Israel’s response.
» Subscribe to NBC News: / nbcnews
NBC News Digital is a collection of innovative and powerful news brands that deliver compelling, diverse and engaging news stories. NBC News Digital features NBCNews.com, MSNBC.com, TODAY.com, Nightly News, Meet the Press, Dateline, and the existing apps and digital extensions of these respective properties. We deliver the best in breaking news, live video coverage, original journalism and segments from your favorite NBC News Shows.
Connect with NBC News Online!
Breaking News Alerts: link.nbcnews.com/join/5cj/bre...
Visit NBCNews.Com: www.nbcnews.com/
Find NBC News on Facebook: / nbcnews
Follow NBC News on Twitter: / nbcnews
Get more of NBC News delivered to your inbox: nbcnews.com/newsletters
#IsraelHamasWar #Israel #Ceasefire
The reporter should correct his rhetoric the hostages did not die in captivity they were killed by Hamas
They were killed by isreli airstrike
U mean Israel killed them which what they been doing and trying to do they don’t care about the hostages if they did they would have made a deal
Three were definitely shot by Israeli snipers and the others were probably bombed or starved by Israel just like the more than 34,000 Palestinians. Israel never cared about the hostages. Its goal was extermination and flattening Gaza. Just read the intent from leaders of Israel in the ICJ report from South Africa.
Israel=new Nazism! history will judge them for thousands and thousands innocent children who died for nothing Idont think they could choose their religion,side or nothing anymore
Hamas rejects the ceasefire on table and comes up with a made up one last minute. They need more time to get more weapons.
seems hamas made a deal with everyone except who they are actually fighting with.
It's called third-party mediation, genius.
I don't know why people get excited. Netanyahu already made his mind. he is going to finish what he started.
Genocide? And more stealing land?
@checo8187 you are speaking 🔊 about hamus.
@checo8187
whatever you call it, I am just saying that I have seen enough to know that the war is not over yet. I have no horse in this race.
knowing this is a sensitive subject, I should not have said anything
Hamus never wanted peace and never will. They have different goals
Not ' having died during captivity ', but ' having been murdered during captivity.
I agree, those rockets had ill intentions from the get go.
Right? NBC is terrible
I was thinking that as well.
Please wake up
These Zionist propaganda media don’t know the truth from their behinds
Hamas agreed to a deal they created in absence of Israel so no deal…
The deal was initially proposed by Israel. They just didn't expect Hamas to agree to it. They wanted to show "see, they won't end it" and Hamas basically called Bibi's bluff.
@@MaeveDaly02 wow you must have been at the negotiating table cause that’s not what Kirby said..please give us all the exact details would love to hear it
@@Madman_MS bro my dude the zionist entity literally sent delegates and the CIA director went to Cairo as well . The Zionist entity did not expect them to accept it. Netanyahu cant accept it or else his coalition allies will drop him and that will be the end of his political career . It was another farce attempt to show that "Oh, Hamas doesn't accept any ceasefire deal," to sway the American public back to its support but it failed this time.
They r just trying to stop Islrael from invading rafah
And regroup
How does any of u see that history won’t look at u kindly at all, those poor kids will grow up to become hamas so no work done
And keep civilians Rafah. Those civilians are so gullible.
@@michellemirembe6057 Exactly and that is why there needs to be a 2 state solution.
@@michellemirembe6057 so let's go home and say it's good ... nonsense...
If Hamas wants this to end, why don't they give back all the hostages?
Cause they won't have leverage anymore
Because Israel has already made it crystal clear that even if they return the hostages the war will continue.
Israel has already said that rescuing the hostages won't end this conflict...
Why does Israel hand out free abortions to their own people, tells us pro lifers everything we need to know about those people
This is an old War ...and what makes Israel so ''special'' as a warring party???
You can't get what you want without giving something thé other warring party wants.
You can't ''impose'' your will on a still standing ennemy......no matter How you think of yourself as ''special'' it is the Battlefield that decides.
And to quote Herr Blinken this is as ''magnanimous' as a deal could be to the Israelis....all other talk is pure sophism.
How do you call dead hostages...hostages. How evil is that.
It is sad that Israel has killed so many of their own hostages by bombing civilian neighborhoods but I guess that is what Israel wants..
That's the least of our semantic worries pertaining to this conflict.
Their families surely would like their remains returned, don't you think?!
How do you steal someone land and call it self defense
@@generaljg4373Ask Arabs, they have been doing this since the 7th century
Egypt open the border if your so concerned!
or the other 30 arab muslim countries
Now that is the best comment I’ve read for weeks. 🙏
We don't care our border will not be opened and Palestinians will stay in Gaza
That there land jews should be mad at Germany for kicking them out after the war
And west is so concerned for the Zion, why don't they take them back
No deal with terrorists..
Exactly no deal with zionists occupiers of Palestine 😘🇵🇸
Just like you?
Hamas agrees with it's own proposal. Hmmm.
Be quiet fool
Free Gaza from Hamas terrorists
Free the world from Zionism NOW..
FREEDOM JUSTICE FOR PALESTINE 😘🇵🇸
💯
Free Gaza from the apartheid state
They voted for Hamas. They are not innocent and there is no moral equivalency to Israel. Evil will ultimately loose, hence Israel will be victorious.
Israel=new Nazism! history will judge them for thousands and thousands innocent children who died for nothing Idont think they could choose their religion,side or nothing anymore
You can’t accept I take it back 😂😂😂😂
Why is there not more pressure on Hamas to release all kidnapped people? Would that not be a world crime against humanity!
Why is there not more pressure on Israel to release its hostages? Goes both ways.
They will just use the time to rest and rearm.
while eating food supplied by israel ...
The celebration appears to be stage managed to drive a political message.
Have you seen the people ? They are desperate and jumped on any ray of hope. If they were not so desperate, they would think about how "peace" means returning to living under a blockade and having to rebuild everything: water treatment, water distribution, electric grids, hospitals, schools, homes, etc. People are afraid for their lives and hungry, so any announced deal was prematurely taken as a possible way out.
Just like celebrations after Sept 11th. And celebrations after Oct 7th.
@Baraz_Red Does Hamas, who controls the people of Gaza, care about the peace for Gaza. Why have Hamas violated the September 2023 ceasefire in the first place?
Humass trying to take the political high ground and make Israel look bad its utter BS.
Exactly 💯 and then we hear now how they had to change the agreement with respect to the number of hostages to be released from 40 to 33 because they can't come up with enough LIVE hostages to fulfill the original agreement.
The deal is with Egypt? I didn’t know they were speaking for Israel.
pretty sure if hamas 'accepts' a deal to release hostages, its because IDF is one step away to find and free them
No cease fire. You don’t get to just cancel a war you started
You are funny if you really think this is a war.
How many deals are there? Listening to the US spokes persons, this is like deal or no deal? Someone call Noel edmunds
REMINDER: Netanyahu LITERALLY helped financed Hamas, and was recorded stating that keeping Hamas in power was key to avoiding a Palestinian state.
The Times of Israel reported repeatedly, so it's embarrassing that NBC has not.
Why are they still holding hostages?
Because Israel does the same thing
Israel doesn't have hostages
@@Nigscoopthose are not hostages but prisoners who committed crimes
to buy time when they are losing ..
Hamas accepted a ceasefire that was never proposed by Israel.
Deal; what deal? 😂
Be quiet
Devil is not in the details, Devil is in Israel.
The Devil is clearly in you imo
Allah and Yahweh are both devils.
hamas must realize that the world doesn't revolve around them, they can't always get what they want and expect the other side to make all the concessions
How much money is being exchanged as a part of this deal?
Never negotiate with terrorists
we deal with Israel, so that rather beggars that line of thought.
@@DaleHartleyhamas are the terrorists get your facts right
You people. Murder is never the answer. 10% of Gaza is Hamas so what are we doing? O, I forgot, beach front property. The contracts are already signed. Come back here in 1 year and thank me.
Rafah must be completely cleared from hamas.
No deal
It’s idiotic to think a deal can be done with Hamas
I can’t imagine the horrors that the captives, especially the women, have been facing every day at the hands of Hamas
Just look at what Israel is doing to the Palestinians, you don't have to imagine it.
how many are now 8 months pregnant ??
@@direwolf6234We won't see any of those women alive again 😢
With so many mediators how do media outlets know accurate information is from either side.
Wow, that scene in Veep was right. Qatar really does like to include themselves in these types of situations 😂
You should look into how much money they're pouring into our universities...
NO DEAL WITH TERRORISTS!
Terrorists accepted the deal but now if israel rejected then that means they only want to target civilians, idf is most moral army wow 🤡
But we are allies with Israel, we have to honour our deals dont we?
The Torah is the biggest terrorist
@@DaleHartley lol what are you on about you ignorant
Israel?
A sly attempt to imply that the USA is collaborative with Palestine 😅 Hamas expected 🤔 a deal designed by and for whom?
*Well I don't know how a deal is ever reached if they keep changing their minds on what that means!*
They're still hostages?
and several americans
lies and more lies
Problem is Israel isn’t on board with any of this
Why does anyone trust Hamas given their track record - "Hamas has accepted a version of the deal" - what does that really mean?
Over 75 years of military occupation Palestinians have learnt not to trust the warmonger land stealers either
Israel invaded, occupied, and illegally expanded settlements into Palestinian land. Hamas and other Palestinian leaders have been calling for a two-state solution on the borders designated to them by the U.N. in 1967. The issue is - and always has been IMO - that Israel wants ALL of the land in Palestine for themselves. I hope for peace between the two parties, but wanting ALL of the land is an impediment to peace.
No one trusts Israelis anymore. Their attempted propaganda during the conflict was so blatant and disgusting
Father God gave that land to Israel 3,500 years ago.@@AdAstraStakePool
To trust in Israeli is like trusting netanyahu the Zionist
Freedom justice for Palestine 😘🇵🇸
There goes the media, raining on their parade...
So this could happen 2 more time with the other 100 hostages?
that's their plan ..
You mean the 93 hostages
temporary ceasefire . F.....king Joke
They have a full blown three-letter director with his entourage on the ground. He can put handcuffs on Netanjahu right there, right now.
Wouldn't it be easier to do Bush...FFS
how about donald and save us all a lot of trouble ...
Why ??????
Where’s the hostages? Then no cease fire 😢
My interpretation is that Hamas has agreed to a cease file and that the deal is being brokered by Qatar and Egypt. However, i have seen no release from the Israeli government of any acknowledgement of cease fire negotiation. It doesn't makes sense to have a cease fire negotiation between two governments when one of them is not present at the negotiations. Very curious that Israel has not disclosed any official information on this.
Just like russia, HAMAS has never kept an agreement.
We don’t ever keep our word though. consider westward NATO expansion for one.
Just wait till everyone figures out that Russia and Iran trained and aided that initial Hamas attack. Netanyahu KNEW about this attack well before it happened and allowed it to happen for an excuse to commit genocide over territory and money.
Study history more accurately! You get the point?
@@NGLaw56 No nation is forced into NATO, except by RUSSIA. Russia has invaded each and every one of its neighbors. Kept no agreements.
😂😂😂 comment by a frustrated zionist, you lost war you lost morality
40 days to re-group NO DEAL
They aren't going to do nothing,talk ,send more money,talk ,talk ,talk. Money !!!!
Well I guess all of their leaders in Qatar, Turkey and Iran spent all the Billions they siphoned off the last round of Humanitarian Aid dollars so they need to refill their bank accounts again!
Your click bait said Israel rejected the deal already.
It said "reacts" not "rejects" 🤓
Hamus can end every time.
Israel didn't ask for the war and didn't start.
@GadzonkaZonkaThat's probably a grammar error :/
Was Israel involved in this deal?
No. But Egypt, Qatar, BBC and all haters of Israel are.
No.
No deal according to Israeli sources so this Rafah IDF Tour 2024 is still on 😊 🇮🇳🇬🇧🇮🇱
@@Sardarji-bq6ojdaal khor
Why do Musselman always beg kufr to help them 🤷🏽
Hope not
Could not sneak one by A!
but khkhamas?
1.Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Haifa Massacre 1938
4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1939
6. Haifa Massacre 1947
7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
12. Jaffa Massacre 1948
13. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
14. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
15. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
16. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990
17. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
18. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
19. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
20. Gaza Massacre 2012
21. Gaza Massacre 2014
22. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
23. Gaza Massacre 2021
24. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing.
SO DONT LET ANYONE CONVINCE YOU THAT IT ALL STARTED ON OCTOBER THE 7Th
"cutter" HAHAHAHHA ... its QATAR
We can only hope that though they have never done it before Hamas might actually abide by all the terms of the agreement. I for won't be holding my breath
What's the opinions of Benjamin's about this Announcement???
Based on details announced so far by Hamas officials and an official briefed on the talks, the deal that the Palestinian group said it had agreed to included the following:
PHASE ONE
- 42-day ceasefire period
- Hamas releases 33 Israeli hostages in return for Israel releasing Palestinians from Israeli jails.
- Israel partially withdraws troops from Gaza and allows free movement of Palestinians from south to north Gaza.
PHASE TWO
- Another 42-day period that features an agreement to restore a "sustainable calm" to Gaza, language that an official briefed on the talks said Hamas and Israel had agreed in order to take discussion of a "permanent ceasefire" off the table.
- The complete withdrawal of most Israeli troops from Gaza.
- Hamas releases Israeli reservists and some soldiers in return for Israel releasing Palestinians from jail.
PHASE THREE
- The completion of exchanging bodies and starting the implementation of reconstruction according to the plan overseen by Qatar, Egypt and the United Nations.
- Ending the complete blockade on the Gaza Strip.
That was a terrible deal
The poor children, had not their parents danced in the streets on October 7th.
ما تفعلة إسرائيل بالفلسطينيين الأبرياء أصحاب الأرض الأصليين وأصحاب الحق أبشع بكثير مما فعلة هتلر باليهود وينددون بة فى كل مكان.. إسرائيل لا تقاتل حماس بل يقتلون الاطفال المساكين والنساء الأبرياء ويشردون العائلات المسالمين ويدمرون البنايات والمنازل على رؤوس أصحابها ويعتقلون الرجال المسالمين العزل من بيوتهم ويقولون عنهم حماس ويحاربون أيضاً المرضى والجرحى فالمشافى ويقتلونهم ويحتلون الأراضى وهى ليست لهم ويقتلون الأطباء والعاملين في المجال الإنساني والمسعفين وموظفى الأمم المتحدة والصحفيين 😮😮 إسرائيل تحارب البشرية والإنسانية والأخلاقية وهذا سيخلق أجيالاً من الكراهية ضدها فى جميع أنحاء العالم.
Wow, like kids gaming on the playground. Hamas announcing a done deal before the it is agreed upon. So manipulative. How does one negotiate with liars?
LOL both sides of this one bud have truth problems.
Hamas is a narcissist that gaslights
Devil in the details! 🤔
The hostages will not be returned as long as Netemyahu continues to endorse strikes.
They shouldn't have been taken in the first place.
Hamas were never going to release the hostages ,if they wanted peace they would never of taken them in the first place
stop blaming one man for what israel knows it must do ...
130 hostages but 93 alive interesting must of been them Israeli air strikes that did the job. That Hannibal directive kicked in.
But he still attacking Rafah
Please show the tens of thousands Israelis rally for ceasefire in Israel!
There are not tens of thousands rallying for a ceasefire. They are rallying to make any deal to get as many hostages as possible. They could care less if Israel wipes Hamas off the map 3 months later.
they need to vote every right wing fascist out next chance they get.
Just so you know, they want hostages back even if it's meant for a temporary ceasefire deal but the majority of Israelis wanted Hamas control in Gaza removed.
You mean the rally to bring the hostages home....also not tens of thousands. You Hamas supporters REALLY love exaggerating numbers....
It's for the hostages.....and you Hamas supporters really love exaggerating numbers don't you...
Hamas is finished. These cease-fire proposals are a last ditch attempt to survive which will and must fail. Hamas is done.
Are they attempting to stop evacuation?!
You are doing nothing more than to make excuses for Israel not accepting the peace deal
Give all the hostages back
You’re doing nothing but supporting terrorists how absolutely despicable are y..u ?
Israel won't agree. Bibi has a reputation to uphold. 😡
Israel said hard pass. They are already in rafah.
wonder who's the bad person here, hamas and israel are the same both want war
Egypt is America
Of course they did 😂
It's one israeli hostage in exchange for 50 palestinian hostages
The war is over 🎉🎉🎉
Pro War candidates Biden, Trump and Kennedy or Anti War candidates Stein/Sachs. The crowded field makes the chances greater that the anti war candidate can win.
Funny that there were no wars when Trump was in office. Bad actors in the world can sniff out weakness, like in the Chiden Admin.
What if I don't wanna stop something you started that I never wanted to happen . I'm the bad one for not stopping cuz I don't want it to ever happen again maybe your the bad one for starting it huh
Bunch of robots comenting negetivly
Say:
Jesus is Lord & I believe in my heart that God raised Jesus from the death in third day. I repent of my sins Jesus save me now in Jesus Christ amen ❤️💝✝️🩸
Terrorists don’t negotiate
israel can't negotiate ofc
You are correct. Israel does not negotiate. Have you ever heard of the "Hannibal Directive?"
devil is in nettie pot
Abbas leader of the west Bank’s Palestinians backs Israel
What cruel world!! Praying for everyone in Gaza!!❤❤❤❤
In the end.. there wont be any hamas in Gaza.. the Gazans themselves dont need them
All appreciations to the great diplomacy of Egypt and Qatar
Why don’t they take Palestinian refugees, then?
🇶🇦 Qatar is the responsible for the current situation. Hosting the billionaires.
@@danielmartin7838 they don't care for the people. Had never cared .Will never.
Its about spreading hatred.
@@XJ_4evrBingo 🎉 and I suspect the leaders are going to get a big payday under the guise of Humanitarian Aid money too. It's interesting that no one seems to question why Qatar is so involved in the negotiations?
No just keep pounding Allah things are looking better
Netanyahu doesn’t want a deal! It so crystal clear now
Why would he hamas have proven they can't be trusted
it up to their cabinet not one guy ...
Egypt will not let ground invssion in Rafah happen, except Al-Sisi, who closed the border crossing
What does Egypt have to do with allowing a ground invasion? They have no influence over Israel's military plans.
NotherByteCollusion = NBC
We all know who owns the media 😂
Trump
Oh now they want a ceasefire 💀.
I believe that the terrorist called for a cease fire the very next day after they massacred innocent people.
Celebrating what..?
Your Famas literally had no option at all. 🤡🇵🇸
This is staged
I guess releasing the hostages wasnt one of Israel's priorities in this war.
and your evidence is ???
@@direwolf6234 Didnt you watch the video? There was a deal to release them.
@@atomixfang so what did you see ? is see a deal worked out by egypt that didn't include israeli input ...
@@direwolf6234 A deal that included Releasing hostages. I thought that was the point of the invasion. Werent all those whinners with their portraits on the streets for the release of hostages? They had the opportunity to release them. It is all dirty hasbara.
Biden not my president. Yisrael i stand with you. As American i will not abandon Yirsael. Adonai forever. Adonai ye Yirsael. 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
😅😆🤣😂