Measuring Capacitance and ESR - Workbench Wednesdays

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 51

  • @element14presents
    @element14presents  5 років тому +2

    James covers more details on capacitance measurements in this blog post - bit.ly/2IMkolY

  • @ian.lwilson7156
    @ian.lwilson7156 Рік тому

    Brilliant. My neighbor just gave me his one. He was a marine engineer looking after reefers on the sea. As an electrician/inspector for 40 years I’ve only just learnt what ESR means.

  • @BrainSlugs83
    @BrainSlugs83 5 років тому +7

    Liked for recommending to users that they RTFM. Super tired of the idiots telling you to throw the manuals away and not read them. 👍

  • @OsoPolarClone
    @OsoPolarClone 5 років тому +3

    Great video. I really like your explanations and the delivery of the educational elements. GREAT JOB! This compliment applies to ALL of the videos I have seen you do.

  • @phildodd9942
    @phildodd9942 5 років тому +3

    Excellent tutorial as always ! I bet that James is a great person to buy secondhand kit from, as EVERYTHING on the board is likely to have been tested - at least once ! Yes, Peak are based in the UK, in Derbyshire which is in the middle of England, south-east of Manchester. The name "Peak" comes from the "Derbyshire Peak District", a favourite holiday destination in the UK. There's more to capacitance than you suspected !

    • @tonyd1149
      @tonyd1149 3 роки тому

      Thanks for the information on the manufacturer of this instrument. :-)

  • @SwapPartLLC
    @SwapPartLLC 5 років тому +2

    I've had an ESR70 for about 4 years. It works great, but the leads are not very durable. The female banana jacks broke off of the alligator clip leads within first year. They're rather pricey to replace, like $40, but I'm cheap so I just hacked away some of the plastic and resoldered them. Some shrink wrap and they are better than new. Other than that, it is a good product and I do recommend it.

  • @MAYERMAKES
    @MAYERMAKES 5 років тому +2

    I use 30year old LCR meter t otest my Caps, so I just check the cpacitance and hope the esr will be OK. Such an ESR meter would be a usefull upgrade! the one shwon in the video might be my next purchase for my workbench

  • @briantamburelli7573
    @briantamburelli7573 9 місяців тому

    Thank you for the video. Very informative.😊 Oh by the way, I had a Commador Vic 20 when I was 13 back in 1983. I bought it from my Middle School math teacher.

  • @PapasDino
    @PapasDino 5 років тому +1

    Having the suite of Peak devices makes life much easier at the workbench...although there are many low-cost tools available you get what you pay for...buy nice, not twice!

  • @tonyd1149
    @tonyd1149 2 роки тому

    Dear Element14, question(s), kindly, regarding the Peak ESR_+ meter, please. ¿Is it safe to 'power on' this meter on with the leads connected to a passive discharged capacitor, or a resistor, please? You do this with a discharged cap (~7:28), and seemingly without any issues. (The reason I ask is that the manual says: "To allow the self protection mechanism to function, always ensure that the Atlas ESR has completed any analysis before connecting the test probes to a component"). ¿Do they mean powering it up (turning it on) with leads attached to component under test? Just wondering. (I own one of these fine instruments and am very worried about damaging it [big deal for me just purchasing one]). Any comments most welcomed. Thank you for making and posting this teaching video.

  • @TheBizzyBScience
    @TheBizzyBScience 2 роки тому

    great video, can an ESR meter pickup pf resistance?p, Mine mesr 100 reads OL on a 47pf cap, is this normal?

  • @drulli1
    @drulli1 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for your evaluation video. What is missing in your review is a comparison of the measurement with a trusted high end test device. I have a peak ESR and an hp4261A LCR meter on my bench. They use different frequencies 100kHz vs 120H/1kHz and the calculated capacity of DUTs vary quite a bit, 15%.

  • @FullMoons-pb8pz
    @FullMoons-pb8pz 5 місяців тому

    Hi
    I need your help.
    I have checked the capacitors on my digital piano and got the following results in ESR levels. I used the peak ATLAS ESR70 gold.
    10000 uF 25V - ESR 0.01 ohm
    2200 uF 25V - ESR 0.02 ohm
    470 uF 10V - ESR 0.20 ohm
    100 uF 25V - ESR 0.43 ohm
    47 uF 16V - ESR 0.64 ohm
    10 uF 16V - ESR 1.01 ohm
    1 uF 50V - ESR 1.10 ohm
    I am especially suspicious about ther results for 10 micro and 1 micro F. They should be around 8 and 5 respectively. Do these results mean that I need to change the 10 micro and 1 micro D capacitors?
    Thanks for your replies.
    Tan

  • @user-ty2uz4gb7v
    @user-ty2uz4gb7v 5 років тому +1

    Are there any ESR meters that will measure smaller than 1uf with high resolution in ohms?

  • @Jnglfvr
    @Jnglfvr Рік тому

    The reason it doesn't matter about polarity is because it is using a low voltage (500 mV) AC signal. The capacitor will be reversed polarized each half cycle no matter how you hook it up. The saving grace is that the voltage used is very small. Small even for sensitive tantalum capacitors. No different than how an LCR meter makes these measurements.

  • @ThomasFranksomt
    @ThomasFranksomt 5 років тому +2

    ESR is not leakage, right? So the fact that the ESR is low doesn't necessarily mean that it's not potentially leaky?

    • @power-max
      @power-max 5 років тому +2

      Yes, the 2 are totally different. Leakage can be thought of as a resistor that shorts the ideal capacitor in that model.

    • @element14presents
      @element14presents  5 років тому +1

      Leakage is related but different from ESR. James covers how to measure it and the relationship between the two in this blog post: bit.ly/2IMkolY

  • @cognetic
    @cognetic 5 років тому +1

    I have the PEAk ESR70 and love it!

    • @CM-dw3gh
      @CM-dw3gh 3 роки тому

      Does it measure all types of caps in circuit?

    • @cognetic
      @cognetic 3 роки тому

      No. To my knowledge the only way to test a cap is out of circuit.

  • @jameskrivitsky9715
    @jameskrivitsky9715 5 років тому +1

    James, do you have access to a BLUE ESR tester designed by Bob Parker ? I would like to see a comparison and your thoughts on which is more accurate and useful. Thanks J K

  • @tandoganpolat7151
    @tandoganpolat7151 5 місяців тому

    I have Kawai CN31 piano. It gives no sound. I have checked the capacitors on sound amplifier of my digital piano and got the following results in ESR levels. I used the peak ATLAS ESR70 gold.
    10000 uF 25V - ESR 0.01 ohm - uF reading 8811uF
    2200 uF 25V - ESR 0.02 ohm- uF reading 2015uF
    470 uF 10V - ESR 0.20 ohm- uF reading 479uF
    100 uF 25V - ESR 0.43 ohm- uF reading 98uF
    47 uF 16V - ESR 0.64 ohm- uF reading 50uF
    10 uF 16V - ESR 1.01 ohm- uF reading 11uF
    1 uF 50V - ESR 1.10 ohm- uF reading 0.98uF
    I am especially suspicious about theIr results for 10 micro and 1 micro F. They should be around 8 and 5 respectively. Do these results mean that I need to change the 10 micro and 1 micro D capacitors?
    Thanks for your replies.
    Tan

  • @BrainSlugs83
    @BrainSlugs83 5 років тому +2

    I knew it was the soldering iron! 🤣🤣🤣

  • @diyelectronics5375
    @diyelectronics5375 3 роки тому

    It could be measured battery esr like 18650?

  • @radioman140
    @radioman140 2 роки тому

    any good in circuit esr meters for testing capacitors in the pF range i.e 20 to 100 pF?

    • @johnnytacokleinschmidt515
      @johnnytacokleinschmidt515 2 роки тому

      ESR is not generally an issue in smaller capacitors. The construction and the value work against ESR concern.

  • @markmarkofkane8167
    @markmarkofkane8167 2 роки тому

    What about if the battery needs replacement? Are those batteries readily available?

  • @motobacktoconstitution4138
    @motobacktoconstitution4138 4 роки тому

    Wich brand ESR are in circuit testing?
    So you dont have desolder all day to check wich one is bad?

  • @ja.935g67
    @ja.935g67 3 роки тому

    2 years later I stumbled upon this video on a Wednesday 🤔😆

  • @ramstopgun
    @ramstopgun 4 роки тому

    How to measure 36000uf capacitor esr ?

  • @angeliquerobaye8351
    @angeliquerobaye8351 5 років тому

    Perfect, I loved, 😘

  • @catharperfect7036
    @catharperfect7036 5 місяців тому

    Great vid my fellow home-boi goose-pimp.

  • @CABohol
    @CABohol 5 років тому

    Nice

  • @zoozolplexOne
    @zoozolplexOne 2 роки тому

    cool!!!

  • @Stefan_Payne
    @Stefan_Payne 5 років тому

    I find the ESR70 a bit lacking as it doesn't do Leakage Measurements.
    Had some 2200µF Caps with more than 3000µF measured...

  • @warunakumara7671
    @warunakumara7671 10 місяців тому

    sir plz guide us how to measure esr value of smd ceramic caps , smd electrolytic caps , smd tantalum caps , and ceramic caps ... plz do a detailed video , thank u for the video , waruna kumara from srilanka

    • @bald_engineer
      @bald_engineer 10 місяців тому +2

      Use a LCR meter.

    • @warunakumara7671
      @warunakumara7671 10 місяців тому

      @@bald_engineer thank u sir if can plz do a detailed video about it using lcr meter

  • @dreggory82
    @dreggory82 5 років тому

    It can't possibly accurately measure parallel caps individually in circuit.

    • @bald_engineer
      @bald_engineer 5 років тому

      dreggory82 Nope.

    • @tonyd1149
      @tonyd1149 3 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/oHV4fGaALq8/v-deo.html

  • @rflberg
    @rflberg 5 років тому

    I got a different one made by someone else. It only measure ESR at 100khz and puts out less voltage than a diode junction.

  • @powdermnky007
    @powdermnky007 4 роки тому

    Money units

  • @lukehogan9832
    @lukehogan9832 5 років тому +1

    Can you make me a xbox voice changer I've been watching you for a while and I definitely think your smart enough and there are none out there fore xbox one

  • @rompstar
    @rompstar Рік тому

    I think the device is too expensive, Thinking like tops $60

  • @spicky2966
    @spicky2966 2 роки тому +1

    12v battery hummmm...

  • @svanput
    @svanput 4 роки тому

    cant make your mind up how to say soldering iron, huh?

  • @SevenDeMagnus
    @SevenDeMagnus 3 роки тому

    Cool, thanks. There's no more excuse not to be at expert at something, thanks internet (and thanks to Atari, Nolan Bushness, Apple, Steve Wozniak and Steve Jobs for paving the way for the internet). No internet, no Elon Musk nor Amazong nor Jeff Bezos nor Fintech nor, SpaceX and Tesla).
    Happy Easter, bestfriend Jesus is risen!!!
    God bless, Revelation 21:4