The “morning, Mama” and “Hey, Baby” seemed so natural. Like it just rolled off their tongues. Like they didn’t even have to rehearse it. It made my heart full. Then Beth telling him to not call her that, hurting his feelings, made me wanna cry too. Like they are mother and son. Let him call you that.
Mother is the person who raises you not the person who bore you. Most of the times they are one in the same occasionally they are not. My father was raised by his grandmother when he talks about her he refers to her as his mother.
I really hated how mean they were to that Kid ,like he hadn't been through enough already but I suppose they made him strong ,strong enough to deal with the crap the world throws at you .
@technopirate304 the only time I got real upset with the character. She has no business saying that. Many people adopt. Many times people leave their blood parents and end up having wonderful in laws that treat them like family. Her father always treated rip as a son. She knew how important that was to rip but here she goes breaking Carter’s heart for absolutely no reason. Better to have a good adoptive son than no son at all.
@mckaelyn tennison she is fighting it her self. Remember she cant have kids so in her mind she isnt meant to be anyones mother. But that instant reply of hey baby gives it all away. She so wants to be his mother
I loved how easy and natural her reply "hey, baby" seemed. Then when she stopped and we see the look in here eyes. I was sitting there going "No, no, no Beth. Please dont ruin it". However, Beth's past trauma came to the forfront of her mind and she lets it rule her life sometimes. Carter may have had a mom (even though he never to really knew her) but he's never had a mama. 😢😢😢
🤨 💭 Hmmm, that wasn’t a serious growth spurt during 9 months period. Remember the Indian girl announced she was pregnant at the end of season 4; then got into a car accident in season 5E1. Therefore, it is within 9months…
I think Beth will come around and start seeing Carter as her adopted son. She's still too emotionally scarred but you can already see and feel her heart shifting. I love the whole Rip, Beth and Carter dynamic.
I don’t think they will ever have a mother son relationship. They’re two lost souls from two different times who fortunately crossed paths. Cause only we know how much they need each other.
@Mr Zimm I agree they may not be great people but let's face facts we deal with horrible people in real life everyday. That has nothing to do with having kids unfortunately.
@@Mr_Zimm The good people rarely do good things. When you have seen the world a lot one thing you realize it is those who have seen the worst are many times who has the insight to do the right thing. The average "Good" people does not have the frame of reference for the need of doing Good or what is the good thing to do if it hits them on their face.
Can’t tell you how much I love the symbolisms between him and Rip throughout the show. Rip even has a conversation about his long term plan in the side of the road, just like John had with rip when he was a kid.
I am so glad Beth took Carter under her wing, and that Rip finally came around to the idea. They really did save Carter's life! I love this kid!!! 😊🤗🤘❤
Beth has no idea how to be a mother, but she knows how to fight on someone’s behalf. That’s what she does in that first hospital scene. She fights on Carter’s behalf to get him what he needs; a clear explanation and a chance to say goodbye. She doesn’t realise that’s much of being a parent. It’s you fighting the world to protect your kid.
well... she took it too far with him in the store... He legit just tried the shirt on. You can tell hes never had a nice thing in his life , and it shows with his huge smile when he spots the shirt. He just wanted to see himself in it, didnt ask for it. He did ask about jeans.... which she said yes. But he saw a shirt he liked and showed it to her she said no, but he just went to try it on. He turned around with a huge smile because he liked how it looked on him. She then said take it off we are leaving ( not exact words ) and then crushed his little bit of comfort after his father legit died...
Well ones things for sure he'll definitely mean it when he says he'll fight someone all day 😂 imagine he beats the crap out of you, then just spends the rest of the day verbally putting you down.
I love the relationship the John and Carter are building. The last ride in season 4 had me in happy tears and I can't wait to see what happens in season 5
Finn Little does a beautiful job of portraying Carter. Love the character and hope to see more of him in Season 5 as he matures. Carter seems to have the best combination of qualities to lead the Dutton Ranch in the future, if it survives.
Truly, cause is addiction n amounts to putting ur habit before those ur "supposed "to care for n kids become alienated n resentful, hateful It's tough when ur a kid n u don't always have words for understanding what ur feeling, emotions," you react . Carter's pretty cool all things considered 👍♥️
@@crisostomoalmeida670 As do I. Nope kids should ever, EVER have to say the things he said to his deadbeat excuse of a father. I can't begin to imagine how i would have coped, or not coped, were I in that kid's position.
@@davecrupel2817”I can’t begin to imagine how I’d have coped, or not coped in that kids position” but in the same comment agreed on HATING people just for having addiction. Imagine that kid doesn’t cope, and turns to drugs instead. A lot of addicts are there because of severe trauma like this kid went through, where addiction runs in the family
Im so glad Cater & Beth crossed paths. They both needed this encounter. When Carter said "Morning Mama" & she replied "Hey Baby" that interaction had all the feels. She thought about it for a second and realized what he called her. The look on Cater's face when she said "You cant call me that" broke my heart into a million pieces 😭😭💔💔 I understand why she said it because, she thought she would never hear anyone say that too her ever, and hit her in a way she never thought she would ever hear it in her life. I feel deep down inside she's loves Carter. ❤❤
She’s been acting like she’s mama and she just needs to accept the love. She can make space. Especially since she took him in and started raising him right.
The second Beth stopped after he called her mama, I honestly cried. She will never get to know that feeling of being a parent from a child of her own. Jaime took that away from her; plain and simple. Carter saw her as that and sadly, what Beth said is true that she is not his mother. I just wish she approached the situation differently with him. I wish she took him to the side saying, “Carter, as much as it pains me to say this to you, I am not your mother. Please don’t call me that ever again. However I am your friend, Carter. You can count on that.” Thanks for uploading.
@@gandres_07 Yes I have. Although that is not how the character Beth operates. Absolutely she can adopt Carter and he can call her mom. However at the end of the day, Beth knows she is not his real mother. Beth is a realist. And being one of the bloodlines to Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, Beth cannot give another line to the ranch like Kasey and Jaime can. Adopting Carter would be amazing and Beth can ensure Carter has a place at the ranch but when it comes to what Beth, Jaime and Kasey does for the ranch, Carter cannot do that. Although Carter can be the next Rip Wheeler of the business. A good hard working hand that is loyal beyond a shadow of a doubt.
She can be very black and white. A biological mom does not make you a mom roght away... just like family it is not always by blood... She too hung up on not able to have a baby and her own mother died. It stands in the way of something beautifull and fullfilling.. so sad....
@@TheRealDeal92 "And being one of the bloodlines to Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, Beth cannot give another line to the ranch like Kasey and Jaime can" Jaime is adopted. If you're arguing that Beth cannot provide a pure heir then the only one who can is Kayce.
I love the grandfather energy of John's. Grumpy grumpy man towards everyone, even his own kids. But the way he interacts with his biological grandchildren, and Beth's "foster child" is a totally different man. I don't know why but even the grumpiest fathers tend to turn so very soft when they interact with the kids of their kids. Like completely different people.
So true! Growing up, my father was a VERY strict man with us, when the grandkids came, I was shocked to see a completely different soft side of him in how he interacted with them.
Seeing how Carter has grown on the ranch is nice. I wanna see him and Tate interacting. I think they would be good for each other. And when Rip told Carter that they don't get rid of orphans on this ranch and the way Rip looked at him made me happy.
@@Link.dg1 it's interesting to see what's gonna happen next when it resumes in the Summer. The season was just starting to get good. I thought it was gonna shoe the reunion with Jimmy before it ended. But oh well.
Jerry Lee "Funny that Beth doesn't want the title of mother, but she has been a mother to the whole family from Episode 1. Respect" Edit: "Chase" corrected to read "Kayce" Jerry Lee, "respect" for sure👍🏼, but maybe for a different reason. She's more of a leader, 2nd to her dad, of the family. She would have been the tough no non sense son, if she had been a boy. She just seemed to have stepped up to assuming a leadership roll. Kayce, for a long time after getting out the military, wanted little and nothing to do with involving himself and his family with the ranch, much less to being eventual heir and leader. Jamie was essentially brought on board as a youngster and "adopted" into the family by John as a "son". Taylor Sheridan, writes ALL the dialogue for all his shows including Yellowstone and the actors deliver the lines as written...with no deviations or improvisations. I mention that, because like many viewers, there may be a character the just gets on your nerves or we think that they need to be "gone". All that is in Taylor's hands. I have a theory about Beth. I see Beth as the Dutton family "Fixer". She is almost a superwoman, but like Superwoman or Superman, she can't be everywhere and "fix" everything, every time. Her "Kryptonite" may be that she doesn't believe she cannot "fix" everything. She seems to thrive on attacking problems and people. If she had been a guy,. she would have probably made a good special forces operator. People say that Beth is being seen too much lately in recent episodes. I'm wondering if it is a set us up to find her finally overwhelmed from trying to "fix" too many things. Beth is devoted her dad and all things Yellowstone. Between John and Rip, Rip is the one who has a way of reaching and talking sense to Beth. It may be Rip who may have to be there to "catch" Beth, if and when she hits her saturation point. She isn't going to be an example of a mother, in Carter's life, but he is observing that there is more to her than most see, based on her interaction and relationship with Rip. My apologies for blathering on so much.
That one scene where Beth tells Carter she is not his Momma, to me is her most powerful scene. you can tell it broke her telling him that, yet knows it's for the best.
I worked with a lot of kids like Carter, which is a sad statement on our society. The writing on this show is spectacular, and the actors bring it to life in an amazing way. That scene where Beth and Carter meet, and she takes on the role of "friend of family" is something.. All she has lived through goes through her mind, and all she watched Rip go through, and she realizes at that moment Carter is at a fork in the road, and she steps up, stretches way beyond her comfort zone and enters his world. She fires out at that doctor with both barrels, and claims her position with all the force she has. I didn't see that happen but once or twice This is what makes her character so interesting. Something tells me we will see Carter get a haircut this season, we will see him grow a bit, and he might show signs of understanding the chance he has been given, both good and bad. I think he will embrace it all full tilt, like kids do, especially desperate ones...and then as clarity comes, he will come to understand exactly what it means.
She is his mama, but, since she can never have children, it is too painful for her to adopt the title. But, regardless of what she says, she is his mama - mama by choice - now and until the end of time. And Lord help anyone who tries to do him wrong while she still walks the earth.
Omg this is exactly what happened to me, except no one saved me. Parents died when I was a child, and it took me decades, decades, to dig myself out from that hole.
Sending you so many hugs ❤️ my older brother died 12 years ago (yesterday) back when I was 19 in a motorcycle crash, and my mom died this past November from non smoker’s lung cancer. I thought nothing in the world could compare to the pain of losing my brother so suddenly, but losing my mom, who was such a beautiful soul to such a dreadful disease so gradually cut me deep in ways I never imagined. My dad and I are still coming to terms with the sudden loss of her, four months after she was diagnosed. I hope things ever only go up from here for you filled with joy and light❤️.
At first I thought they were being incredibly abusive to him. But then I realized he never had a figure in his life to teach him tough love and be truly parented. The way they do it is probably the best way unfortunately.
Idk if Kenzie meant making him work. which was definitely good for him. Beth was too hard on him in the store, but she has her own anger issues and he upset her by responding to the woman accusing her of abuse. I'm glad they worked it out, and he now has numerous different adults to look after him and teach him different things.
Yeah it's like he just doesn't respect boundaries or know his place , like with the shirt And Beth don't play n going to pull that shirt off of him n let him know, it's my way or the high way! Tough love, well striped! I truly love this show 👏♥️
@@whitespirit26 I humbly disagree hon, I was one like Carter n couldn't, wouldn't take no for n answer n u needa be straightened out or it leads to stealing n disobedience in many forms ☮️And scripted in, it shows itself. Really great writing
Underneath all of the strength from her father, I feel like she really just secretly wants to be the woman her mother wasn’t and to have the family she never got to have
John at some point explained, that he calls Jamie his 'son' because John did everything that was in his power to earn this role. Beth and Rip not wanting to be called Mom/Dad by Carter, is because they wouldn't call him their 'son' (yet).
@@whitespirit26 That's cuz you're a feminine gal.. Beth would only dare to be feminine and vulnerable around Rip and that's cuz he's monster.. the only one that can match (and surpass) her ruthlessness
@@Brandon-w3o Rip is a stand-up man, a Western Knight, not a monster. And no one will hurt his lady while he is around. I particularly enjoy the scene where paid thugs try and he comes charging in and takes them out, running right into pistol fire. Favorite quote later that night when he looks at what they did to her face: "I wish that I could bring 'em back to life so that I could kill 'em all over again." My kind of hero.
@@Brandon-w3o beth comforted the kid when the first met. cried when he hurt her. she is vulnerable around him. shit even the 2nd dinner they have shes smiling ear to ear because she has a chance to be a mom. something she thought shed never beable to. thats why she snaped back the way she did. she resigned herself to never being called mom. do you even watch the show lmfao
“3. You work really, really, fucking hard. You learn. You fail. Learn more. Fail more. And don’t let anyone outwork you. Ever.” I’d rather be someone who fails often, than someone who wins often. I gain more from failure than I do from winning.
That's a stupid argument. U fail, then u learn, and with learnings u eventually wins something. So every winner had more failures than you, because they out work, out fail, out learn you. You have failed to fail often therefore please don't bullshit about your failure. You are just lazy.
The way things are set, Yellowstone could have a storyline set for about 10-15 years. The Tate-Carter dynamic is exciting to me, if done right. Could be Tate vs Carter too. I hope this is explored
@@Mark-ki7ic a scenario that intrigues me is if Tate’s mom’s side influences him into taking control of the ranch and letting them settle on it and Carter (the outsider) steps up for the Duttons to lead the fight to regain it
I just hope they dont put Tate against Carter as i think it would be a bad thing in my opinion. If it happens i think it may partially ruin the story line between those 2 characters. I dont see how it would actually add anything positive and really just kind of be a bad bump in the road. I think it would almost be a obligatory story line that really wouldnt do any good or add more to the show.. just my open ended opinion.
Now I'm imagining Carter meeting Tate. The two enjoying each other's company as time passes. Carter being an older brother figure for Tate; and maybe showing him how to play a little poker.
Have seen all of these so many times and know what to expect but they still tear me up. Carter still has that adorable chubby face, such a sad face that has been through so much. Just heartbreaking to see him cry.
Carter was such a good addition to Yellowstone! Love the show and development of characters by Sheridan. He has a great way of painting stories and showing emotions and people's inner truths, for fiction, that is! Great stories!
I didn't knew this series existed until now. But man these writers and actors know how to do it right. It frightening. These characters are genuine as f**k.
I've been waiting since Lonesome Dove, The mid 1990's for another western, cowboy fantastic series to hit television,❤ Yellowstone is a pure pleasure to watch,❤
Love this show, sure going to miss it when its over. All of cast and crew did such a great job. And the landscape is just amazing, I feel it calling to my soul, and I live in the Mountains in Colorado. Just never get tired of it! There is something very magical about the High Country. Ya' ll be safe be blessed and if get the opportunity, be a blessing ❤
I love Beth, such a deliciously complex character. It came so naturally to her to love Carter as her own but part of her can't fully accept in. Easiness with which that "Hey,. baby" came out of her scared the life out of someone who doesn't get scared. I only wish Carter had come back with something like "You are still my family" or calling her Aunt Beth.
Oh shut up this is why kids are so out of control and nowadays because everyone thinks that children need to be coddled know they f****** don't they need hard work they don't need you to baby them especially if you have boys stopped doing it cuz you're ruining our society these are the type of man and woman we need in our society strong
Damn. This hits close to my heart. Instead, mom abandoned me at 13, I never committed crimes, but I worked hard until I was old enough to get a paying job. Then, my Wife found me. She made me the man any mother would be proud of, except my own. 40 yrs married nov 5 2024.
This missed a couple good moments. 1. Rip telling him when he saddles the horse wrong that if he doesn’t know something, to ask……and MIND YOUR FUCKING MANNERS. 2. Walker asking him if he wants to be a cowboy. When he responds “life’s pretty much robbed me of my options” and him saying “yea, that’s how it usually starts”
My favorite Carter quote is ‘I know what I wanna be when I grow up.’ Jake: ‘What’s that kid?’ Carter: Him, I wanna be him’ Jake looks toward Rip and Carter says ‘No, him’ and points to John.❤️
The “morning, Mama” and “Hey, Baby” seemed so natural. Like it just rolled off their tongues. Like they didn’t even have to rehearse it. It made my heart full. Then Beth telling him to not call her that, hurting his feelings, made me wanna cry too. Like they are mother and son. Let him call you that.
Shit making me wanna cry and hug that kid damn
Not yet they arent but he is healing her and rip is healing her
Even worse when you know why she refuse to be seen as a mother.
Mother is the person who raises you not the person who bore you. Most of the times they are one in the same occasionally they are not. My father was raised by his grandmother when he talks about her he refers to her as his mother.
I really hated how mean they were to that Kid ,like he hadn't been through enough already but I suppose they made him strong ,strong enough to deal with the crap the world throws at you .
When, Carter said, "Good Morning, Momma" when, Beth walked past him through the horse stalls, my heart just fell and cried for, Carter.....
And she instinctively says "Hey Baby...😬
One of the most heartbreaking scenes in the entire series imo
I don’t understand why the hell she did that. He’s a mini Rip.
@technopirate304 the only time I got real upset with the character. She has no business saying that. Many people adopt. Many times people leave their blood parents and end up having wonderful in laws that treat them like family. Her father always treated rip as a son. She knew how important that was to rip but here she goes breaking Carter’s heart for absolutely no reason. Better to have a good adoptive son than no son at all.
@mckaelyn tennison she is fighting it her self. Remember she cant have kids so in her mind she isnt meant to be anyones mother. But that instant reply of hey baby gives it all away. She so wants to be his mother
beth's hey baby was so genuine it caught me off guard 😭
😭😭😭
true - his mama was real and her baby was equal to it....she may come around yet
We still knew exactly how she felt about that boy after that scene was over, too. She fooled him but no one else.
Poor baby. I think she meant it about not feeling like she could be a mom, but she definitely loved him.
She loves that boy like her own, you can see it. I hope in season 5 her and rip adopt him as their own
That last scene hurts so much.
Why is no one talking about the "You put tuna in the hamburger helper? Why not just use the tuna helper darling" That had me rolling
I just love her “there’s tuna helper”
@@Mia_M that's so me i didn't know that was a thing
Having the largest ranch in the country have tuna but no ground beef is a giant plot hole.
@@brendamoon2660might not have been any beef bc they ate it all
“Morning, mama.”
“Hey, baby.”
Even though she vehemently denied it, we all knew that she felt maternal feelings for Carter.
that scared the hell out of her
I hate how they did this scene…we all know she not his momma…but she acts like it
They both knew that they had a special bond she was just putting up her shield against it. Very sad scene for both😢😢
That was a punch to the heart, made me cry
I loved how easy and natural her reply "hey, baby" seemed. Then when she stopped and we see the look in here eyes. I was sitting there going "No, no, no Beth. Please dont ruin it". However, Beth's past trauma came to the forfront of her mind and she lets it rule her life sometimes. Carter may have had a mom (even though he never to really knew her) but he's never had a mama. 😢😢😢
I love how Beth is sitting on a “thank you for not smoking” sign on a bench while she’s smoking 😂😂😂😂
Hahah so good!! Love her character, well written show ❤
Gangsta!!!
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Her reaction after realizing Carter's words hit me every time
The emotions, a split second of joy followed by surprise, sadness and even fear show what a great actor Kelly is.
Which scene are you talking about
@@ashleytrout7452 the last one, with Beth and Carter, when he said "Morning, mama"
@@ds-convay03 that was soo sweet, it’s even worse when she said “hey baby” so smoothly back to him
I love how Llyod has a thing for helping out the new guys like Jimmy and Carter. Out of everyone, his heart is the biggest.
He's like the bunk house grandpa. So sweet
@@Heck111yur One question remains. Is he truly in his late 50? Or does he refuse to acknowledge his true age? 🤣
@@tjjordan4207 it's obvious he just denies his true age you can tell when Rip was a teenager he was in his 40s then
@@johneverette699 Still, he looks good for someone that old, especially if he's in his 70s.
🤨 💭
Hmmm, that wasn’t a serious growth spurt during 9 months period. Remember the Indian girl announced she was pregnant at the end of season 4; then got into a car accident in season 5E1. Therefore, it is within 9months…
I think Beth will come around and start seeing Carter as her adopted son. She's still too emotionally scarred but you can already see and feel her heart shifting. I love the whole Rip, Beth and Carter dynamic.
I don’t think they will ever have a mother son relationship. They’re two lost souls from two different times who fortunately crossed paths. Cause only we know how much they need each other.
Beth and Rip are not good people
@@codranine6054 I think they are exactly what they need to help them both heal old wounds.
@Mr Zimm I agree they may not be great people but let's face facts we deal with horrible people in real life everyday. That has nothing to do with having kids unfortunately.
@@Mr_Zimm The good people rarely do good things. When you have seen the world a lot one thing you realize it is those who have seen the worst are many times who has the insight to do the right thing. The average "Good" people does not have the frame of reference for the need of doing Good or what is the good thing to do if it hits them on their face.
“He’s kicking your ass and talking shit at the same time” 😂😂😂
🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Literally one of the best lines in the entire series.
He looked like one very proud father.
Can’t tell you how much I love the symbolisms between him and Rip throughout the show. Rip even has a conversation about his long term plan in the side of the road, just like John had with rip when he was a kid.
The dinner scene is my favorite. They are having dinner like a family. Beth sees the future and she loves it.
The kid’s acting is no joke! 👏
Yes better than Tate.
For real
Agreed!!!!!
21:25 I like Carter turn to Rip for confirmation, like son and dad. Rip's laughing back is just the proof Carter's now his own boy
Him and Beth deserve to be parents! They’d be amazing parents despite their faults.
I am so glad Beth took Carter under her wing, and that Rip finally came around to the idea. They really did save Carter's life! I love this kid!!! 😊🤗🤘❤
Wait till you see him in season 5!
When, Carter said, "Good Morning, Momma" when, Beth walked past him through the horse stalls, my heart just fell and cried for, Carter.....
@@nexpro6118 held his heart out to her.
Love the honesty of the characters in this show.
Whats the 4th way to get rich?
"I have pirates working for me."
love that line.
Her reaction was pure Beth, but Carter's reaction to it still breaks me
Her "hey, baby" tears my heart apart
Beth has no idea how to be a mother, but she knows how to fight on someone’s behalf. That’s what she does in that first hospital scene. She fights on Carter’s behalf to get him what he needs; a clear explanation and a chance to say goodbye.
She doesn’t realise that’s much of being a parent. It’s you fighting the world to protect your kid.
Shd is disgusting period
… sounds like a mom
Sapo❤😂🎉😢😮
Very true.
well... she took it too far with him in the store... He legit just tried the shirt on. You can tell hes never had a nice thing in his life , and it shows with his huge smile when he spots the shirt. He just wanted to see himself in it, didnt ask for it. He did ask about jeans.... which she said yes. But he saw a shirt he liked and showed it to her she said no, but he just went to try it on. He turned around with a huge smile because he liked how it looked on him. She then said take it off we are leaving ( not exact words ) and then crushed his little bit of comfort after his father legit died...
Imagine how badass of cowboy carter will be if he manages to survive being raised by Beth and Rip
Having both their traits, good and bad would be a lethal combo.
😂😂
Well ones things for sure he'll definitely mean it when he says he'll fight someone all day 😂 imagine he beats the crap out of you, then just spends the rest of the day verbally putting you down.
The kid that eats lightning and shits thunderbolts
When tate has the ranch Carter will be his rip
I love the relationship the John and Carter are building. The last ride in season 4 had me in happy tears and I can't wait to see what happens in season 5
there's a novel and movie with both names (mentioned above) combined...
even with this being a Carter highlight, I can't help but think... god damn Kelly Reilly is an amazing actress
Totally draws u in to the story,scene! So does everyone else too, great cast! 👏
Yessss, she is amazing!!!
I see her in sherlock, great actress.
The way she said “hey baby” it just rolled off her tongue. 😭🥺 hopefully she’ll come around to it but idk. Poor things.
It broke my heart when she took back the hey baby. Like just be his mom
Love it. Beth: "Lady, you crave trouble. You just don't want resistance. If you don't want resistance around here, you just mind your own business.""
Yes! 👏🏻
Man I want to move there. People not taking crap from others.
@@batman66ism But with respect due.
@@sonofizzy Oh of course. That's the key word.
This needs to be said to every Karen who tries to poke her nose in shit
Finn Little does a beautiful job of portraying Carter. Love the character and hope to see more of him in Season 5 as he matures. Carter seems to have the best combination of qualities to lead the Dutton Ranch in the future, if it survives.
I really like Carter can't wait for season 5
When, Carter said, "Good Morning, Momma" when, Beth walked past him through the horse stalls, my heart just fell and cried for, Carter.....
C - "Mornin, momma."
B - "Hi Baby."
🥰🥰❤
B -"You can't call me that"
🥺🥺🥺😭😭
I'm criying 😔😔😔
The hospital room scene was 2:30 minutes long. There was so much packed into that scene. From strangers to friends to family.
"If there's a hell then you're in it.... I'll see you when I get there" That straight pit of hate and despair that a kid becomes
Truly, cause is addiction n amounts to putting ur habit before those ur "supposed "to care for n kids become alienated n resentful, hateful
It's tough when ur a kid n u don't always have words for understanding what ur feeling, emotions," you react . Carter's pretty cool all things considered 👍♥️
That's why I hate addict, alcoholic and smokers
@@crisostomoalmeida670 As do I.
Nope kids should ever, EVER have to say the things he said to his deadbeat excuse of a father.
I can't begin to imagine how i would have coped, or not coped, were I in that kid's position.
@@davecrupel2817”I can’t begin to imagine how I’d have coped, or not coped in that kids position” but in the same comment agreed on HATING people just for having addiction.
Imagine that kid doesn’t cope, and turns to drugs instead. A lot of addicts are there because of severe trauma like this kid went through, where addiction runs in the family
Im so glad Cater & Beth crossed paths. They both needed this encounter. When Carter said "Morning Mama" & she replied "Hey Baby" that interaction had all the feels. She thought about it for a second and realized what he called her. The look on Cater's face when she said "You cant call me that" broke my heart into a million pieces 😭😭💔💔 I understand why she said it because, she thought she would never hear anyone say that too her ever, and hit her in a way she never thought she would ever hear it in her life. I feel deep down inside she's loves Carter. ❤❤
She’s been acting like she’s mama and she just needs to accept the love. She can make space. Especially since she took him in and started raising him right.
She's so gangster it hurts lol
Rip and Beth " would make great parents !
The second Beth stopped after he called her mama, I honestly cried. She will never get to know that feeling of being a parent from a child of her own. Jaime took that away from her; plain and simple. Carter saw her as that and sadly, what Beth said is true that she is not his mother. I just wish she approached the situation differently with him.
I wish she took him to the side saying, “Carter, as much as it pains me to say this to you, I am not your mother. Please don’t call me that ever again. However I am your friend, Carter. You can count on that.” Thanks for uploading.
Never heard of an adoption?
@@gandres_07 Yes I have. Although that is not how the character Beth operates. Absolutely she can adopt Carter and he can call her mom. However at the end of the day, Beth knows she is not his real mother. Beth is a realist. And being one of the bloodlines to Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, Beth cannot give another line to the ranch like Kasey and Jaime can. Adopting Carter would be amazing and Beth can ensure Carter has a place at the ranch but when it comes to what Beth, Jaime and Kasey does for the ranch, Carter cannot do that. Although Carter can be the next Rip Wheeler of the business. A good hard working hand that is loyal beyond a shadow of a doubt.
She can be very black and white. A biological mom does not make you a mom roght away... just like family it is not always by blood... She too hung up on not able to have a baby and her own mother died. It stands in the way of something beautifull and fullfilling.. so sad....
@@TheRealDeal92 "And being one of the bloodlines to Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, Beth cannot give another line to the ranch like Kasey and Jaime can"
Jaime is adopted. If you're arguing that Beth cannot provide a pure heir then the only one who can is Kayce.
@@TheRealDeal92 except that John thinks of Rip as a son - more so than Jamie (who himself is adopted) . You are completely wrong and confused.
You have Beth as a Mom, Rip as your dad Carter as your son. Perfect family.
Introducing this kid into this group was genious! He adds emotion the others do not add the same!
Just when you think it can't get better they add Carter.
Carter's actor is amazing. You can really feel the pain in his eyes...
It genuinely warmed my heart seeing Rip,Beth and Carter sitting around the table eating supper.
She let her guard down for one SECOND, and said "Hey Baby" from her heart. Then she closed back up. 😔
I love the grandfather energy of John's. Grumpy grumpy man towards everyone, even his own kids. But the way he interacts with his biological grandchildren, and Beth's "foster child" is a totally different man. I don't know why but even the grumpiest fathers tend to turn so very soft when they interact with the kids of their kids. Like completely different people.
Beause they don't have to be the Disciplinarian as much as the parents do. So maybe they can become their grandchildren's friends.
So true! Growing up, my father was a VERY strict man with us, when the grandkids came, I was shocked to see a completely different soft side of him in how he interacted with them.
“We’re gonna run that foul right out that mouth” best line ever Lmaooo
Apparently, John wants this kid to shut up and ride. Besides, talking is not concentrating.
If hypocritical.
@@monteagudoabeezekieljardie7884. John didn’t mind talking, he did kind how much Carter was cursing
Seeing how Carter has grown on the ranch is nice. I wanna see him and Tate interacting. I think they would be good for each other. And when Rip told Carter that they don't get rid of orphans on this ranch and the way Rip looked at him made me happy.
I wanna see them fight to the death😂
@@Link.dg1 I wanna see Rip destroy Jamie painfully and slow!
@@richardcasados 😂 honestly same
@@Link.dg1 it's interesting to see what's gonna happen next when it resumes in the Summer. The season was just starting to get good. I thought it was gonna shoe the reunion with Jimmy before it ended. But oh well.
@@Link.dg1 wrestle maybe but when push comes to shove cousins always have each others backs
Funny that Beth doesn't want the title of mother, but she has been a mother to the whole family from Episode 1. Respect 🤠
Jerry Lee "Funny that Beth doesn't want the title of mother, but she has been a mother to the whole family from Episode 1. Respect"
Edit: "Chase" corrected to read "Kayce"
Jerry Lee, "respect" for sure👍🏼, but maybe for a different reason. She's more of a leader, 2nd to her dad, of the family. She would have been the tough no non sense son, if she had been a boy. She just seemed to have stepped up to assuming a leadership roll. Kayce, for a long time after getting out the military, wanted little and nothing to do with involving himself and his family with the ranch, much less to being eventual heir and leader. Jamie was essentially brought on board as a youngster and "adopted" into the family by John as a "son".
Taylor Sheridan, writes ALL the dialogue for all his shows including Yellowstone and the actors deliver the lines as written...with no deviations or improvisations. I mention that, because like many viewers, there may be a character the just gets on your nerves or we think that they need to be "gone". All that is in Taylor's hands. I have a theory about Beth. I see Beth as the Dutton family "Fixer". She is almost a superwoman, but like Superwoman or Superman, she can't be everywhere and "fix" everything, every time. Her "Kryptonite" may be that she doesn't believe she cannot "fix" everything. She seems to thrive on attacking problems and people. If she had been a guy,. she would have probably made a good special forces operator. People say that Beth is being seen too much lately in recent episodes. I'm wondering if it is a set us up to find her finally overwhelmed from trying to "fix" too many things. Beth is devoted her dad and all things Yellowstone. Between John and Rip, Rip is the one who has a way of reaching and talking sense to Beth. It may be Rip who may have to be there to "catch" Beth, if and when she hits her saturation point. She isn't going to be an example of a mother, in Carter's life, but he is observing that there is more to her than most see, based on her interaction and relationship with Rip. My apologies for blathering on so much.
She *does* want the life of a mother. She just doesn't want others to think/know that she does, lest she be be seen as weak.
Not the responsibility just to do an stop when wants to
True
Boy the look on Carter's face when she says she's not his momma kills me...
That one scene where Beth tells Carter she is not his Momma, to me is her most powerful scene. you can tell it broke her telling him that, yet knows it's for the best.
I love it. Not only does it show how she feels about herself but how carter gotten so comfy with her 😢❤
Whats that episode?
I worked with a lot of kids like Carter, which is a sad statement on our society. The writing on this show is spectacular, and the actors bring it to life in an amazing way. That scene where Beth and Carter meet, and she takes on the role of "friend of family" is something.. All she has lived through goes through her mind, and all she watched Rip go through, and she realizes at that moment Carter is at a fork in the road, and she steps up, stretches way beyond her comfort zone and enters his world. She fires out at that doctor with both barrels, and claims her position with all the force she has.
I didn't see that happen but once or twice
This is what makes her character so interesting.
Something tells me we will see Carter get a haircut this season, we will see him grow a bit, and he might show signs of understanding the chance he has been given, both good and bad. I think he will embrace it all full tilt, like kids do, especially desperate ones...and then as clarity comes, he will come to understand exactly what it means.
Dam ! Well said! U have the gift of gab, heartfelt 👏♥️
Beautifully put 👍
She is his mama, but, since she can never have children, it is too painful for her to adopt the title. But, regardless of what she says, she is his mama - mama by choice - now and until the end of time. And Lord help anyone who tries to do him wrong while she still walks the earth.
Wait... Why does he have to get a haircut?!
I bet he becomes a Michael Corleone type of character.
Love the part at the beginning, where Beth is sitting on the bench, and it says thank you for not smoking, and yet she lights one up!
His last words to his father were so epic!
Omg this is exactly what happened to me, except no one saved me. Parents died when I was a child, and it took me decades, decades, to dig myself out from that hole.
But ur still here to speak bro, Survivor! ♥️👏
Sorry but you made it
Sending you so many hugs ❤️ my older brother died 12 years ago (yesterday) back when I was 19 in a motorcycle crash, and my mom died this past November from non smoker’s lung cancer. I thought nothing in the world could compare to the pain of losing my brother so suddenly, but losing my mom, who was such a beautiful soul to such a dreadful disease so gradually cut me deep in ways I never imagined. My dad and I are still coming to terms with the sudden loss of her, four months after she was diagnosed.
I hope things ever only go up from here for you filled with joy and light❤️.
❤❤❤
Ive been searching for these scenes on youtube for months. Brings back so many memories. Top class acting Well Done.
At first I thought they were being incredibly abusive to him. But then I realized he never had a figure in his life to teach him tough love and be truly parented. The way they do it is probably the best way unfortunately.
Not unfortunately. He was tough already but had zero self worth, having to earn something set him up for life.
Idk if Kenzie meant making him work. which was definitely good for him. Beth was too hard on him in the store, but she has her own anger issues and he upset her by responding to the woman accusing her of abuse. I'm glad they worked it out, and he now has numerous different adults to look after him and teach him different things.
Yeah it's like he just doesn't respect boundaries or know his place , like with the shirt
And Beth don't play n going to pull that shirt off of him n let him know, it's my way or the high way! Tough love, well striped! I truly love this show 👏♥️
@@whitespirit26 I humbly disagree hon, I was one like Carter n couldn't, wouldn't take no for n answer n u needa be straightened out or it leads to stealing n disobedience in many forms ☮️And scripted in, it shows itself. Really great writing
You don't sound like Carter, he started listening to them before the shirt incident.
I love how everyone relates and parents this kid correctly.
Underneath all of the strength from her father, I feel like she really just secretly wants to be the woman her mother wasn’t and to have the family she never got to have
John at some point explained, that he calls Jamie his 'son' because John did everything that was in his power to earn this role. Beth and Rip not wanting to be called Mom/Dad by Carter, is because they wouldn't call him their 'son' (yet).
Not Rip being so proud of Carter kicking everyone's ass at poker 🤣😭😭
Absolutely right! “You give flowers for no reason” ❤
That last scene was stone cold... This is why I love Beth!
I wasn't angry at her bc I understood her reasons, but I wanted to hug the poor kid so badly.
@@whitespirit26 That's cuz you're a feminine gal.. Beth would only dare to be feminine and vulnerable around Rip and that's cuz he's monster.. the only one that can match (and surpass) her ruthlessness
@@Brandon-w3o Rip is a stand-up man, a Western Knight, not a monster. And no one will hurt his lady while he is around. I particularly enjoy the scene where paid thugs try and he comes charging in and takes them out, running right into pistol fire. Favorite quote later that night when he looks at what they did to her face: "I wish that I could bring 'em back to life so that I could kill 'em all over again." My kind of hero.
@@Brandon-w3o I don’t understand. Can you please explain it?
@@Brandon-w3o beth comforted the kid when the first met. cried when he hurt her. she is vulnerable around him. shit even the 2nd dinner they have shes smiling ear to ear because she has a chance to be a mom. something she thought shed never beable to. thats why she snaped back the way she did. she resigned herself to never being called mom. do you even watch the show lmfao
Lloyd in the background "get a room you guys" 😂 there's never a dull moment in the bunkhouse
"The kid sure likes it"
"The kid?"
Lmao
“3. You work really, really, fucking hard. You learn. You fail. Learn more. Fail more. And don’t let anyone outwork you. Ever.”
I’d rather be someone who fails often, than someone who wins often. I gain more from failure than I do from winning.
That's a stupid argument. U fail, then u learn, and with learnings u eventually wins something. So every winner had more failures than you, because they out work, out fail, out learn you. You have failed to fail often therefore please don't bullshit about your failure. You are just lazy.
I love how Carter is not good, he’s difficult and have a purpose, to taught BETH something in life 😊
The way things are set, Yellowstone could have a storyline set for about 10-15 years. The Tate-Carter dynamic is exciting to me, if done right. Could be Tate vs Carter too. I hope this is explored
Hope Carter turns into Rip for Tates Kaycee
@@Mark-ki7ic a scenario that intrigues me is if Tate’s mom’s side influences him into taking control of the ranch and letting them settle on it and Carter (the outsider) steps up for the Duttons to lead the fight to regain it
I just hope they dont put Tate against Carter as i think it would be a bad thing in my opinion. If it happens i think it may partially ruin the story line between those 2 characters. I dont see how it would actually add anything positive and really just kind of be a bad bump in the road. I think it would almost be a obligatory story line that really wouldnt do any good or add more to the show.. just my open ended opinion.
Yes! I'm real excited and interested to see how theor dynamic goes
Now I'm imagining Carter meeting Tate. The two enjoying each other's company as time passes. Carter being an older brother figure for Tate; and maybe showing him how to play a little poker.
Have seen all of these so many times and know what to expect but they still tear me up.
Carter still has that adorable chubby face, such a sad face that has been through so much. Just heartbreaking to see him cry.
Carter was such a good addition to Yellowstone! Love the show and development of characters by Sheridan. He has a great way of painting stories and showing emotions and people's inner truths, for fiction, that is! Great stories!
I love how the kid needs to learn how to self regulate, solely to avoid being punished, but the adult doesn’t have that rule for herself
When Beth told him not to call her mom, it sort of broke my heart. And then they never addressed it. Wtf.
We all know one day Beth let him call her momma🥰😍❤️
I didn't knew this series existed until now. But man these writers and actors know how to do it right. It frightening. These characters are genuine as f**k.
Omw Rip's eyes got the biggest when Beth said "The kid liked it." Most shocked I've ever seen him.
I've been waiting since Lonesome Dove, The mid 1990's for another western, cowboy fantastic series to hit television,❤
Yellowstone is a pure pleasure to watch,❤
Just watched Lonesome Dove the other day. Its on Tubi.
When carter is playin cards and rip behind him smiling reminds me of me and my dad when we played cards with hands on our ranch or with family
I can’t wait for the next episode to come out…. Please keep this show going….
I really hope when the end comes for this series Carter gets his break. And lives happily ever after.
I think he might be our kid, baby. - love that line.
Love this show, sure going to miss it when its over. All of cast and crew did such a great job. And the landscape is just amazing, I feel it calling to my soul, and I live in the Mountains in Colorado. Just never get tired of it! There is something very magical about the High Country. Ya' ll be safe be blessed and if get the opportunity, be a blessing ❤
I've never even seen this show and I'm in love with all 3.
Ive never watch Yellowstone before, and I am loving it for real!!
i STILL cant get over the fact that Rip is Johns from riddick.................just BLOWS my mind.
What did I miss
That was bill the butcher from the boys
He made me love Beth that much more. He definitely helped heal something.🥺
Such a awesome actor! Sweet kid! My heart went out for him 😭
"Best thing he goes to sleep tonight and don't wake up." Holy shit.
For robbing a store?? So awful.
@@whitespirit26 absolutely terrible thing to say.. but this is why this show is so good! Goes over the line sometimes.
@@Yomomma45738 Plus I think the point was that Beth saw what attitude he was up against and wasn't going to let him be given up on.
@@whitespirit26 right she completely seen rip in him. But that line.. Jesus lol
Yeah, poor sweet kid. Thank goodness he got a good place.
The actors in this show are hilarious and great, especially this trio! Incredible work from these three
I just want to give him.a hug. Such great writing and acting!
He’s the missing piece Beth and Rip needed…
Really, that kid they can't make 👏 Can't wait for more 👍
This is how a powerful man is being raised. ❤🎉
I wonder what will be in store for Carter in season 5
Beth, Rip, and Carter all dealing with their trauma’s in their own way…. Theirs between them and Carter in their own ways….
That song they play when they're eating is so beautiful
I love Beth, such a deliciously complex character. It came so naturally to her to love Carter as her own but part of her can't fully accept in. Easiness with which that "Hey,. baby" came out of her scared the life out of someone who doesn't get scared. I only wish Carter had come back with something like "You are still my family" or calling her Aunt Beth.
Love how they connected here,shows beth has heart.
This TV show gives us exactly the clips we want!
Kid is an absolutely amazing actor. He sells that part lock stock and barrel.
No kid should ever be this hungry, both for food and affection.
Oh shut up this is why kids are so out of control and nowadays because everyone thinks that children need to be coddled know they f****** don't they need hard work they don't need you to baby them especially if you have boys stopped doing it cuz you're ruining our society these are the type of man and woman we need in our society strong
I really like that young man.
In season 5 forgot the episode he casually now calls Carter her" Baby"
Damn. This hits close to my heart. Instead, mom abandoned me at 13, I never committed crimes, but I worked hard until I was old enough to get a paying job. Then, my Wife found me. She made me the man any mother would be proud of, except my own. 40 yrs married nov 5 2024.
This missed a couple good moments.
1. Rip telling him when he saddles the horse wrong that if he doesn’t know something, to ask……and MIND YOUR FUCKING MANNERS.
2. Walker asking him if he wants to be a cowboy. When he responds “life’s pretty much robbed me of my options” and him saying “yea, that’s how it usually starts”
Big hypocrisy about the swearing.
My favorite Carter quote is
‘I know what I wanna be when I grow up.’
Jake: ‘What’s that kid?’
Carter: Him, I wanna be him’
Jake looks toward Rip and Carter says ‘No, him’ and points to John.❤️
Beth's lil smile when the baby is sharing how hurt he is - is everything
carter was cool loved his part
I Adore that kid!!! Little Rip!
He is not same as Rip.
Rip has honest heart.