JUST IN: House Holds Contentious Debate Over Bill To Codify Definition Of Antisemitism
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 кві 2024
- Members of the House of Representatives debated HR 6090, the Antisemitism Awareness Act of 2023, which would codify the definition of antisemitism set forth by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance for the enforcement of Federal anti-discrimination laws.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
AIPAC needs to register as foreign agent!
Absolutely!
@@kentexican5844The most mighty lobby, Muslims lobby need to be registered as foreign agent. As well as congresswoman Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib, and alike. If we don't want to loose this recently wonderful country.
@@lilac6878 Tell me more about the "muslims lobby". And how do you figure Omar and Tlaib are a lobby?
@@kentexican5844 They certainly do not represent America or Americans.
@@idavidb I'm afraid I don't know who you are talking about.
That whole meeting was funded by AIPAC money/Intrests👎
P😊
Only one thing We The People have to do now 🫡
Are you being serious? Do you support racism
@@breezybreeze12 of course not. I also dont support 14,000 dead children. Silence is not patriotism.
@@breezybreeze12Yes
I wonder if Israel ever passed a law that protects America
F**k no!! They hate America 😂😂
Or Christians...
Christian evangelism is illegal in Israel which is a fact that needs to become common knowledge around the world. All these pastors sending cash to Israel cannot preach there without being arrested! The Zionists consider it antisemitic!
Christian evangelism is illegal in Israel which is a fact that needs to become common knowledge around the world. All these pastors sending cash to Israel cannot preach there without being arrested! They consider it antisemitic!
My comments continue to be deleted.
Viloence is already illegal.
Unless your country is occupied by invaders then armed struggle is allowed under international law.
RIP American Constitution.
Long Live our masters in Israel
Your country is gone you are a state from Israel now
This bill is a joke.
I wish it was a joke. it's 1984 newspeak.
Where did the 1st Amendment go.
It's was supposed to protect speaking against the government .
Not anymore. Don't you know who owns you?
Nobody owns me!! They can say so all they want but I refuse to do as they say!!
I mean the people lazily lay by why gov pass these laws.. it's kinda our fault for not doing anything.
House.gov, you can see them all and contact your state representative, but by the time you do, they've already passed it.
Not accepting slaughtering humans has nothing to with being against any ethic group
This is a motte and bailey fallacy. Obviously being against slaughtering of humans is a good thing, but you are not against the slaughtering of Jews, which makes your statement void, in addition to the fact that many people are using this conflict in order to promote hatred against certain ethnic groups, which is why this bill had to be passed.
@@rinkohorowitz 75 yrs of abuse then OCT7
@@user-iv7lx3jj4wHamas is a terror group. There is zero comparability.
@@user-iv7lx3jj4w What does this have to do with anything?
Americans don't have to pledge allegiance to Israel. Period.
Is Hamas funding these colleges. Why else would they support terrorist
" Does it matter what is codified?? *Shall not be infringed* was codified in 1791."
Wasting more time and NOT FUNDING OUR GOVT. OR PROTECTING OUR BORDERS.
SMH GOP SMH
💯🎯‼️
I'm old enough to remember when Americans had freedom of privacy. Looks like freedom of speech is gone too.
@@heregoes8839 No it's not!
@@jackielobin7100 Yes it is. It was gone long before today. Ask the Christians, the trump supporters, the pro-life crowd, covid protesters, the unvaccinated, the 45th president, January 6th protesters, the parents at the school board meetings, Alex Jones, 2nd amendment advocates, Fox news.
I bet you had no problem with the government destroying the first amendment rights of those people and groups.
And being critical of Israeli policy isn’t antisemitic.
Until this bill passes.
Let's pass the bill
@@MARIE-ww6wr Not a chance. I like having free speech.
@JacobSteinberg75 I think you mean free speech means means speech I agree with when it's convenient. Spare us with your empty platitudes about free speech.
@@JacobSteinberg75You couldn't care less about free speech. You don't have to worry about your words censored here on YT. Any conservative perspective speech is most definitely being censored or deleted.
To find out who rules over you, look at who you're not allowed to criticize.
just call it the "Don't criticize Israel bill." Pathetic piece of legislation that won't survive Constitutional attack.
Whos in charge of my country
Not us. . . fed is an outside entity.
You know who
@@JohnnyNada I'd like your comment more if i could.
Definitely not the people.
Begins with an “I” ends with an “L”
Hate laws are unconstitutional and must be challenged in the courts. All groups and individuals must be treated equally under the law, no special privileges.
They are talking about definition of the word. It's not that they are creating any laws.
They’re gonna drag me away from my kids and lock me up over jokes my Jewish friends encouraged on Twitter years ago 🙄
@@Tati8796 Yes it is, read the bill. They want to put state appointed anti-smetism guards schools, to monitor the speech of students. EVERY American should be against this.
@@SixOneNiner23 Oh, please, stop the drama
@@Tati8796 no drama, it’s true, they’re monsters.
They aren't just protesting on college campuses, families of hostages + 100k of their friends in Israel protesting netanyahu.
What you just said will soon be against the law.
They are also protesting the carnage in Gaza. The Israelis have been lied to by their govt just as we Americans have been with our president saying one thing out of one side of his mouth yet, saying the opposite thing out the other side of his mouth. Lipservice to be sure.
Stop lying!!!!!!!
This violates my right to freedom of speech!!
Freedom of speech died with the internet
As a Republican I was deeply looking forward to voting straight republican no the republican Congress just voted to remove my first amendment right to criticize Israel you won but you lost my vote and trust !
Does that mean you're voting Independent now? Because Democrats voted for this too 😂.
Jill Stein for pres? Who are you voting for? I'm not voting for Biden!
In America you can crticize God, but you cant criticize Israhell.
Your "Bill" won't stop my Holy Bible from being right.
I'm not a Christian, so I don't quite understand. Does this law mean that the Bible is illegal?
@@SW-bw5uu I’m not %100 on this, but I think the bill just defines antisemitism, and doesn’t have any legal ramifications. Still it’s a bit ridiculous if you read through the examples in the definition recommended
Dems and Reps sure figure out how to cooperate quickly when a certain group and restricting rights are involved. 🤔 🇺🇸
In America, you can have personal prejudices against any group, as long as it stops short of any attempt at persecution or unfair treatment.
Not anymore.
从此犹太人将是美国的神，神圣不可侵犯。
It’s going beyond that. If this bill passes you can’t even criticize Israel government policies
Anti-zionism does not mean anti semitism. Zionism is a political ideology, not a religion or a race. Limiting free speech criticizing one political group BASED on religion has to be unconstitutional. Are they going to make a law saying that criticism of Saudi Arabias government is considered islamaphobia? I dont think so.
They aren’t even Semites
I hate Congress
Israel says “jump,” US politicians ask “how high?”
But this goes completely against the First Amendment. Which says "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion".
ABSOLUTELY 💯 PERCENT CORRECT!
💯 Yes indeed!!
I'm not a Christian, so I don't quite understand. Does this law mean that the Bible is illegal?
Protest against war is not anti semitism sir🤨
for the longest it has always been anti-government. And if the government populace does not agree with war goals, the gov does any and everything in its power to quite the people.
I really really despise Nadler.
We all do.
Who doesn't?
I despise about everything he said but can agree with some of what he said doesn't mean I agree with about of anything else he says
He opposed this bill. He is for free speech.
I've never agreed with anything he said until right now.
get all duel citizens out of our government -
I’m Christian can we make a bill making it a hate crime when people use the lords name in vane? Oh and I don’t want anyone to say anything negative about my religion or anything that hurts my feelings? Oh and I want to do bad stuff too and don’t want anyone to say I’m doing bad stuff, that’s all.
I’m Mainland Chinese christian and I’m just super upset about the bill. God bless you. Stay strong.😭
I'm not a Christian, so I don't quite understand. Does this law mean that the Bible is illegal?
I'm old enough to remember when Americans had freedom of privacy. Looks like freedom of speech is being taken away too now. America was a nice idea while it lasted.
"A republic. . . as long as you can KEEP IT"
Will Anti Semetic laws protect the Palestinians. They are the original Semitic people
It is a shame that these politicians diverting attention from genocide and taking about something that they can not eliminate with law and order but education and humanity
Not seeing the genocide by Israel is a sin, against the humanity and itself antisemitic
the students at Colombia were 100% wrong in vandalizing and maybe other acts violence, but they were not anti-Semitic.
Many Jewish students and Jewish faculty members were part of the protest, are you calling those Jewish participants anti-sematic?
Dear Congress, you have an obligation toward the American people not toward the Israel.
Can someone please explain to me how "please stop doing genocide of Palestinians" is equal to "Jewish people bad"
It is a false equivalence. Jewish people who support what is happening in Gaza is bad, but it is bad because of those actions, not because of being Jewish.
Correlation is not causation.
Listen very closely to the second speaker because he is one of the only people actually making sense.
Biden doesn't know where he is 😅😂😅😅
That's getting old! I watch his speeches, all the way thru. Not snipits from propaganda news outlets. RECORD BREAKING ECONOMIC NUMBERS after Trump trashed them!! Biden did that and MUCH MORE! Infrastructure Bill! Trump didn't. Out of Afghanistan Trump didn't. Record oil drilling Trump didn't. Record stock Market!! Trump said it would crash. Hmm..,..
Maybe u should Google some FACTS. U R WRONG. SMH
Can we use the Anti semetic law to protect the Palestinians.
Im Jewish. This is a family matter. Butt out congress
Civil rights are a legal issue
@@05luscious Yeah and mine are being violated by this bill.
Criticizing a foreign government is antisemitism now?
This new law will help ban the Christian Bible. Is laying the ground work for our Lord and Master Satan.
There are several Semitic tribes - are you intending to protect ALL Semitic speaking people? Or are you drafting unconstitutional legislation to protect Jews?
To protect the JEWS
Absolutely 💯 percent correct & yes, they are attempting to do exactly that or in reality, protect Zionist Israel.
ABSOLUTELY 💯% CORRECT!
False-Jews... real Jews believe in Christ per himself in John 8.
Palestinians are semitic people too. Original Jews are genetically the same with Palestinians.
why is it a crime to be Anti Israel? you can be anti any other country in the world, but you cannot be anti Israel, why? why? why? why?
it doesn't feed into gov war goals.. it has always been that way whenever the people do not agree
Because, it will become against the law to have a Christian Holy Bible. The Christian Bible is Antisemitic.
Yup exactly!! Replace Israel with China and CNN, msnbc, Fox and the other mainstream news outlets will go crazy
Exactly.
On going criticism of US suppoert for Israel is changing the mainstream narrative and it’s putting pressure on officials trying to send more money to Israel so this bill is basically a way to *hush* any criticism going forward.
They cry out in pain as they strike down your 1st amendment rights...
Remember when these same politicians, mostly Republicans ranted how wrong an Anti Hate speech law is..LOL
Nobody:
Dems: We chang the definitions of words to fit our narrative.
Republicans introduced HR-6019
It's a bipartisan bill so this is on both parties.
its not about Dems vs. Republicans that's the psy op. Its about the Uni-party Establishmentarians vs. WE the People
Majority who voted against were democrat. They are all bought no need to single them out just reset the house
Nads once again lying through his neck high waistline. Shame on your partisan self and your politically motivated rhetoric.
Register AIPAC as a foreign agent .
Oh plz always with the Trump stuff . he has been gone how long now ? Get over it already .
I’d be with you on that if he wasn’t running again. But as it stands, Trump’s 2017-2021 term is fair game, as every voter will naturally want to (re)examine that record when they decide whether or not they want to sign off on him getting another four years. (Obviously, some will, some won’t, and some are still deliberating).
Beware of those you can’t criticize
How can we pass an anti-Asian bill and an Anti- Jewish bill but not pass an Anti-black American bill? I just want people to think about that for 1 min. Then ask yourselves if hate for black people in this country is worse than the hate for any group of people? Ask yourself do you really blame black people for how we feel? Ask yourself why the government won’t vote to protect black lives but can protect other groups.
Stop voting democrat
Our constitution says black people only count as 3/5 of a vote. What do you expect? Japanese Americans got an oficial apology in 1988 for something that happened decades before Jim Crow laws were outlawed. Black people got a nod in 2008, probably only because he was the first black president.
Listening to all these old white men lecture everyone on discrimination and violence is a whole cackle.
Someone please give Jerry Nadler a tissue. Or better yet, an Oscar for his acting ability.
Im sooo disappointed Mr. Jordan. Free speech is free speech. Even if its hateful. Let people get the reprocussions from their peers. Not from the government. Pretty soon this will spread to ANY person saying bad things about ANY population. The state shouldn't be policing speech. It should police ACTIONS.
Now you know he has always been theatre. Jordan has proven he has no values just like Mike Johnson
Nudler..
We aganst antisemitism but we not suport antisemitism bill
Exactly
Well that’s pretty reasonable. I’m against racism, but i won’t support a law that sends people to jail for saying racist things on school campus or online. It’s called freedom of speech. This bill literally makes key phrases and ideas of the Bible ‘antisemitic’ and subject to legal interference on campus. That’s ridiculous. You can be against antisemitism and realize that a bill like that is stupid as fuck
Schumer is so full of crap. What? Not what ........Still !!!!!
Nothing changes here.
It's not antisemitism, it's anti genocide
Jail time for speech 💬
Take this one off!
They need to make sure that nothing in that bill infringes on our right to free speech. And it must not interfere with the Christian teaching of the Bible. Any wording in that bill that prohibits the belief in Jesus, father, son and holy Ghost.
I'm not a Christian, so I don't quite understand. Does this law mean that the Bible is illegal?
Jerry Nadler speaking out both sides of his mouth per usual
Codification is how they control human rights. To codify something is to bring it under jurisdiction of that abomination known as the uniform commercial code.
It is a form of British admiralty law and mostly applies to anything to do with money.
The Human Race, any and ALL portions of it are NOT subject to the ucc UNLESS they relinquish their HUMAN RIGHTS.
THIS ATTEMPT IS WRONG to try and WRONG to even consider. First the Jews then who?!
Nadler Hubris. This stance will hurt him
If only.
Yeah. He needs to be kicked out of congress.
So Americans can criticize their own government but not foreign governments? Oh! Just not one foreign gov't. How free are we??
Criticism and call for extermination is two different things
@@leonredsquare Well, given that many top Israeli officials & zionist Americans have literally called for the extermination of Palestinians... I'm not sure we're talking about the same group of people
you can criticize, just don't harass and intimidate.
@@larisatriener7697 It looks more & more like the anti-genocide protestors are the ones being harassed & intimidated
@@larisatriener7697 The only people doing that are pro lsreali. Look at what happened at UCLA last night.
As u can tell hes reading a paper he didn’t write…..
Really this is what the fk congress is getting paid for ..We have real problems
How do you pass a new bill that there is no need for? Create the need.
Just declare Columbia University a Yeshiva and no more worries about antisemitism there. The white students can find better options for education.
It's 1984 and if you obey all the rules you may have a chocolate.
Henceforth, I hereby declare myself to be antisemitic, simply because this government thinks it can force me not to be.
So now they are infringing on my free speech, I could have given a shit about what Israel was doing in Gaza now your messing with my rights
I think we need to vote out all congress out and put in young educated people that don’t want wars and are not bought by special interest and protect our constitution
You can find any young educated people .
Yes! I vote for that
Yes
What we see on college campuses is voices for ceasefire and protection of innocent lives of Palestinian people.Whoever calls for death or violence is in direct collision with very idea of protesting.
One too many Congressmen have called to "turn Gaza into a parking lot"
Even Nadler states how ridiculous and anti first amendment this bill is.
No Washington DC anymore...only Jerusalem DC
These time wasters should have been gone ten years ago. They should have been balancing the budget.
Instead they argue for hours on end about things which don't matter in the end. They get the free ride, we always pay the bill 💵.
It doesn't matter what the issue is, Jerry gets on the wrong side of it, and argues until he wins.
I bet his constituents are proud of him for wasting their kid's retirement money for helping out some other country while our own national debt piles higher and higher.
When Congress can't take care of business, they have to be replaced by different people who will get the job done.
This hasn't occurred to the common voter yet, but it will when the debt gets high enough that they can't afford cigarettes anymore 😆.
Instead of voting for the same people that got us into debt in the first place, put someone else in office.
This endless bickering isn't solving anything anyway. Just wasting taxpayers money while old useless men argue back and forth, and collect a big paycheck for it.
You are full of it..all of you..what is wrong with you..
VOTE NEW CITY COUNCILS
VOTE IN NEW MAYORS
VOTE IN NEW GOVERNORS
VOTE IN INDEPENDENT PRESIDENT.. THIS IS THE ONLY WAY WE CAN GET RID OF THIS ONE SIDED CORRUPTION IN OUR WHITEHOUSE...
WE NEED POLITICS THAT ARE FOR THE PEOPLE NOT THE LOBBYISTS
Collecting names on who to campaign against!
Never thought i would see the day i agree with nadler. Maybe hes worried about being voted out
By attacking the 1st Amendment.
I am SOOOOOOO tired of hearing about Jews. SOOOOOOOO tired.
A people so great, it’s actually against the law to criticize them!
The river is a border that our rulers care much more about than our own border.
I had two Latinos call me a Hymie in Santa Rosa. It didn't bother me a bit because they profiled me correctly :) If they had called me a square head or Shqip I would have given them a high five!
Do you mean homey as in brother?
@@AlejandraRodriguez-gx7gb hymie like hymie town
Well soon Bibi picture will be in every America classroom.
Ben Shapiro is jumping with glee
If this bill becomes law, we should work to increase that number from 109 to 110.
Start charging people with hate speach ,and hate crimes untill you
start charging people and let people
see that you will not tolerate it.
We need to do away with all special protection laws besides for the youth, the elderly and women. Our laws protect all. The said groups above need extra attention due to vulnerability. No group or individual is above questioning/criticizing without being called a bigot.
Imagine, if you will, a religious ethnostate whose actions are so obviously good and noble, laws have to be passed to stop criticism of them.
There has to be accountable response for the crimes that are being done to America because of all this
This bill is the " Born again Christian wsiting for Jesus Bill"
I'm not a Christian, so I don't quite understand. Does this law mean that the Bible is illegal?
Wrong way Chucky
Always voting against the people
Let's talk about giving Biden more money to do nothing for America. Where does it go??
Fuck anyone in congress that votes for this. Freedom of speech is one of the few things left about this country that makes it exceptional.
Thank you , its about time, you take action against this kind of aggresive pritestors .
What pork or other crap is in that legislation? How does it infringe or counter the protections of free speech as stated in the Constitution? What are we not being told? What specifically is being objected to? FYI, I'm pro-Israel/Jew & we do need clarification on the free speech issue..
You stuck on stupid with rhetorical questions
In all law we trust print that in the $20 bill and see church and State divided
You should call it what it is lawlessness. Evil, hate with no understanding of right from wrong.