#AskBR

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 113

  • @Indians30
    @Indians30 6 років тому +86

    Nayagan is the best movie in Tamil ever made and the best acting by Kamal, Ilaya Raja sir, PC Sri Ram sir, Maniratnam sir, etc... Everyone has delivered their best....

    • @akhilansari6908
      @akhilansari6908 3 роки тому +5

      I consider thevar magan, kuruthipunal and virumaandi equal to nayagan one of classical masterpieces

    • @500an6
      @500an6 3 роки тому +3

      I consider anbe sivam equal to Nayagan

    • @Nooralam039
      @Nooralam039 2 роки тому +2

      Don’t call it only Tamil movie it’s a greatest Indian movie ever.

    • @Indians30
      @Indians30 2 роки тому

      @@Nooralam039 We cannot say that. It is one of the greatest movies we can say. Have you watched Gangs of Wasseypur?? Go and watch. It's another milestone gangster movie

    • @Nooralam039
      @Nooralam039 2 роки тому +1

      @@Indians30 of course I have already watched gangs of wasseypur and it is a gangster movie with gangs but nayakan is one man show. I am not from tamil nadu i am from Bihar.

  • @spandanbanerjee34
    @spandanbanerjee34 11 місяців тому +4

    One of the finest works by Mani Ratnam and Kamal Haasan ... technical and artistic finesse at its peak 💙

  • @chandramohanganapathysubra1327
    @chandramohanganapathysubra1327 5 років тому +12

    This is the greatest film ever made and defeating this feat is next to impossible. boy o boy , literally i have lost count of the number of times, i watched this masterpiece.

  • @Indians30
    @Indians30 4 роки тому +11

    The best Indian movie ever made in terms of acting and cinimatography.

  • @jayanmeppalli7585
    @jayanmeppalli7585 6 років тому +66

    Why so short BR... I expected atleast a 20 mins video.. a classic like this deserves more time to analyse..

  • @premgokuls
    @premgokuls 6 років тому +27

    Thanks for this. For once I’ve understood why Nayagan was so great at that time. I’ve always felt Thalapathy more wholesome. But I get it now how Nayagan totally changed how a could be presented at that era and continue stay so fresh even now.

    • @LordLaavineshNithianandan
      @LordLaavineshNithianandan 2 роки тому

      Thalapathi is Original as it gets and it is plot is derived from vedic literature not Hollywood rip off!
      Don't compare Thalapathi☀️ with nayagan which is mere copy rather than inspiration.

  • @saahilthakkar4593
    @saahilthakkar4593 3 роки тому +3

    The frame within the frame was also used in In The Mood For Love, Mani Ratnam is a legend!

  • @VarunIND789
    @VarunIND789 3 роки тому +6

    Nayakan is the Best ever Gangster Movie Ever made In Indian Cinema 💯

  • @bestwhatssappstatuses1865
    @bestwhatssappstatuses1865 5 років тому +3

    Dream combo kamal mani sir pc sir

  • @dannygzz9286
    @dannygzz9286 Рік тому

    I saw this move recently it really showed me why kamal Hassan is a true talent. especially for this film it’s not only a gangster film. but it’s about a man who goes by living with a certain code of morality and ethics. and how he punish the people who abuse the poor and is seen as a form of law and Justice it’s such a great film.

  • @thesingam0759
    @thesingam0759 6 років тому +6

    Thanks for answering my question BR!

  • @mohansundaram4247
    @mohansundaram4247 6 років тому +6

    Nice sir, without knowing the elements in the film we use to watch many times, after your brief explanation I was eager to watch the movie again, film like thalapathi, Nayagan , Bombay producers y not take steps to again release on theatres

  • @raghavendrar4780
    @raghavendrar4780 6 років тому +5

    Thank You So Much 😍😍😍😍

  • @Ram-oy3vh
    @Ram-oy3vh 4 роки тому +2

    I have grown to appreciate BR’s reviews. Goes in depth and has all the nuances to do proper homework on the movies he reviews. Just hope he stops collaborating with these new amateur reviewers like Fully filmy and etc. We regard you at higher bracket man. Hope to see more from you at this level.

  • @3ctechnologysolutionsllc280
    @3ctechnologysolutionsllc280 5 років тому +2

    one more information )- NAYAGAN movie was nominated on Oscar award in a best foreign movie category also

  • @vineetchugh5404
    @vineetchugh5404 6 років тому +4

    Although I have seen both Tamil and hindi dubbed of Nayakan and loved it...Would have appreciated english subtitles for Nayakan scenes being discussed. Some very interesting analogy you have done.

    • @liberatt5756
      @liberatt5756 Рік тому

      Bro where is hindi dubbed version of nayakan

  • @varungk3388
    @varungk3388 Рік тому +1

    Also the Real Vardarajan's daughter married a Policeman,so maybe that influenced the decision.

  • @ArunK-zu1go
    @ArunK-zu1go 2 роки тому +1

    Sir, U are a genius reviewer...👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌

  • @TheElixir007
    @TheElixir007 6 років тому +12

    OMG so excited for next week's 7G Rainbow Colony!!!!

  • @jaganathan6116
    @jaganathan6116 4 роки тому +2

    Another level explanation

  • @Skandawin78
    @Skandawin78 4 роки тому +3

    Hastily done episode. BR you are such a wonderful reviewer and such a big fan of Kamal and ilayaraja , should have taken ur own sweet time to peel the different known and unknown layers in this cult movie.
    BTW, 14 mins for Sarkar and just 11 mins for Nayagan is unpardonable.

  • @arulalagan8702
    @arulalagan8702 6 років тому +2

    Thank U BR sir. I Never Before Heared This Much Information About Nayakan Movie. As Am Only Fan Of Mani Ratnam Sir. I Request U To Share All The Mani Ratnam Sir Movie.

  • @thirumurugan6579
    @thirumurugan6579 6 років тому +2

    Super questions. Good Pick

  • @rammkumaru261
    @rammkumaru261 3 роки тому +2

    For me iruvar is the best maniratnam movie

  • @கார்-ட3ங
    @கார்-ட3ங 6 років тому +40

    Why maniratham's movies like Nayagan,Mouna raagam being talked for decades? The reason is obviously Maestro Ilaiyaraaja!

    • @damodaranvanisri
      @damodaranvanisri 4 роки тому +6

      I agree Ilayaraja is a genius. But come on bro, give some credit to the director too.......

    • @tommichael5819
      @tommichael5819 4 роки тому +2

      Dumb af.

  • @ridgewoodindie3563
    @ridgewoodindie3563 4 роки тому +1

    Character themes were done by RD BURMAN in films like aradhana and sholay before ilaiyaraaja. Ilaiyaraaja introduced it to tamil films maybe though.
    That being said, nayakan has some of the best music ever produced

  • @goppalbalan2586
    @goppalbalan2586 2 роки тому

    Per square India has the most talent in the whole world. Undoubtedly and undeniably.

  • @raguls1628
    @raguls1628 6 років тому +28

    Pleass do BR on Hey ram movie

  • @alokacs3986
    @alokacs3986 6 років тому +4

    Sir old Kannada movies are good. Please do one Kannada movie.

  • @kevinprabhu6358
    @kevinprabhu6358 6 років тому +5

    Can you do it for mullum malarum..where mahendran sir showcased the brilliant acting side of rajinikanth which we can't see them these days

  • @rahulrahul.rc2101
    @rahulrahul.rc2101 3 роки тому +3

    Cult classic Film! 👊

  • @chandramohanganapathysubra1327
    @chandramohanganapathysubra1327 5 років тому

    this film needed atleast a 1hr discussion BR. please try to do it once again.thanks.

  • @my____turn
    @my____turn 2 роки тому

    Does any one have nayakan movie file hd. Amazon prime have the file. Remastered ultra HD . If anyone have the same file please reply me

  • @venkateshravichandran5847
    @venkateshravichandran5847 6 років тому +1

    Brilliant as usual BR... I always your episodes/interviews and re-watch many movies/scenes due to your brilliant analysis and how you catch links and relations in movies and so I get very excited for your videos because I know I will get something fresh about movies I have watched to make me want to go back and also feel proud if my opinion on something matches yours as your analysis and reasoning is nothing short of brilliant and Justified. # BR # Brilliant Reasoning

  • @goppalbalan2586
    @goppalbalan2586 2 роки тому

    This is a land of Kamal Haasan Sivaji Ganeson Mohanlal Mamooty Mani Ratnam Ram Gopal Varma Amir Khan Nana Patekar Naseerudin Shah and list is endless.....

  • @narendrakumandan
    @narendrakumandan 6 років тому +4

    Can you take interview of Ram Gopal Varma?

  • @deepap6147
    @deepap6147 6 років тому +34

    Why so short Mr. BR...

    • @b0rangan
      @b0rangan 6 років тому +10

      Deepa P Genetics, I guess. Runs in the family. 😀

    • @deepap6147
      @deepap6147 6 років тому +3

      :) :) Ha ha ha Thanks for your sweet reply. When are you doing "Mouna Ragam". I watched it today for the nth time and was so impressed from the get go.. When Mani sir has Revathy's childhood pics arranged on a mat as her room decor to Ilayaraja sir s haunting background score which drags me down the nostalgia lane to my school days... and Karthik who I was impressed only in this movie never before and never after and then Mohan, whom I couldn't fathom why he soooo famous (bad grammar) but I still loved him in every movie of his and then there is Revathy who spells fun, madness, free spiritedness and more. She gave many a girl an identity to grow up as a self-respecting woman very much capable of thinking for herself yet being so traditional... A 43YO from Austin, TX :)

  • @anupmahani1316
    @anupmahani1316 6 років тому +4

    @Baradwaj Rangan, Can we have #AskBR for Vanaprastham (1999) ?

  • @SanthoshKumar-cg8md
    @SanthoshKumar-cg8md 6 років тому +4

    Do you think this film would be a success if it's been released today?

    • @b0rangan
      @b0rangan 6 років тому +1

      Santhosh Kumar Why not? 😀

    • @SanthoshKumar-cg8md
      @SanthoshKumar-cg8md 6 років тому +1

      Baradwaj Rangan No doubt on the movie, just curious on how would the current fast paced movie lovers would respond 😉

  • @premgokuls
    @premgokuls 6 років тому +3

    #AskBR 7G Rainbow Colony - 7G and Pudhupettai are the 2 of my favorite Selvaraghavan movie and I feel only in these two movies the director was able completely execute his vision on screen. While even 7G was about a hero stalking a girl, why was this still enjoyable versus similar movies now are detested pr condemned (rightly so). Was it because the hero gets reformed and responsible in the end? How does a movie tread this thin line between stalking and love and succeed?

  • @madhurz557
    @madhurz557 6 років тому +6

    Pls do Mahanadhi and Kurudhi punal movie....

  • @ilayarajapriya2029
    @ilayarajapriya2029 5 років тому +1

    U r speech and explain is very nice sr Thes move one of ever green move in tamil filam always my one and only best move

  • @rahulmarar1694
    @rahulmarar1694 6 років тому +1

    This was terrific.... Will you be doing #AskBR on Malayalam films?

  • @RajeshRavi777
    @RajeshRavi777 6 років тому +4

    This video is amazing, but it's 30 minutes short :D

    • @b0rangan
      @b0rangan 6 років тому +1

      Rajesh Ravi haha. But you guys don't watch long videos sir 😀

    • @RajeshRavi777
      @RajeshRavi777 6 років тому +2

      Of course we watch :) And especially with a cult classic like Nayakan, where there's so much more that can be spoken about (I'm guessing), 11 minutes just flew by. I wanted to listen to much more on this particular movie. And if BR won't go in-depth with movie analysis, who will?

  • @fireisawesome1466
    @fireisawesome1466 6 років тому +5

    sir can you give an analysis on songs that progress the movie like neela vaanam from Manmadhan ambu

  • @HijasFarook
    @HijasFarook 6 років тому +32

    5:14 when you use non-tamil films as a reference please add subtitles! Mujhe Hindi maalum Nahi :p

    • @HijasFarook
      @HijasFarook 6 років тому +3

      Sanjeev Jayakumar Thank you bro, now got the reference clearly.

    • @vaanucp6724
      @vaanucp6724 6 років тому +6

      Hahaha Mujhe Hindi Maalum Nahin? I believe these are Hindi words 😂😂😂

    • @b0rangan
      @b0rangan 6 років тому +7

      Sanjeev Jayakumar thanks for helping out. I thought the "sense" of the stretch came out even without subtitles. Still...

    • @341984jp
      @341984jp 6 років тому

      Hijas Farook 😂😂😂 very sarcastic statement 😃

  • @tmadhusudhanan
    @tmadhusudhanan 6 років тому +4

    First Like.!!!

  • @sendhuprakash602
    @sendhuprakash602 5 років тому +3

    Dear BR, Nayagan is a cult classic which is of no doubt..But I felt the film doesn't need 'Nila adhu vaanathu melay' song at that situation..A female objectifying song at that situation should have been avoided..Can you clarify me whether any reason there behind placing that song??.. Just a doubt

  • @mamabari07
    @mamabari07 4 роки тому

    Good stuff.. thx

  • @4100027
    @4100027 6 років тому +1

    Super

  • @pinkpanther1947
    @pinkpanther1947 3 роки тому +1

    ❤️

  • @akshithamehta879
    @akshithamehta879 4 роки тому

    please do an #AskBR on mahanati

  • @venkykumbakonam1021
    @venkykumbakonam1021 6 років тому

    BR - great analysis as usual. Though I love each and every performance of Kamal, but I think the way he expresses anger with his daughter is one of his best. What do you think? I think every department of the film came together like in all great movies. Again he did this when he was 34 or 35. Unbelievable.

  • @mkuberchandan4870
    @mkuberchandan4870 6 років тому +1

    Muaah 😘😘😘😘😘

  • @ashwinsrinivasan9092
    @ashwinsrinivasan9092 3 роки тому

    Please do a similar analysis for Kireedam !!!

  • @rishidhev739
    @rishidhev739 6 років тому +4

    Is this movie is slightly based on the real life of late Bombay don Varadharaja Mudhaliyar ?

  • @rudhresh-rudie4750
    @rudhresh-rudie4750 6 років тому +1

    Why am i not able to see the subtext as well as my other reader and viewer collegues

  • @4100027
    @4100027 6 років тому +6

    Where to send our questions ?

    • @b0rangan
      @b0rangan 6 років тому +5

      ninja you can post the questions here. Or else follow filmcompanionsouth on twitter and reply when the notification to send questions comes out.

  • @SuperJoseph234
    @SuperJoseph234 5 років тому +6

    Velu Nayakar = Thanos

  • @yaaro4471
    @yaaro4471 6 років тому +7

    We can see how great Kamal is as an actor ..than Amitab Bachan ; just see the body language

  • @sudharsanjana7703
    @sudharsanjana7703 4 роки тому

    Pease ask about thalpathi

  • @elanchezhiyan.a712
    @elanchezhiyan.a712 5 років тому

    #Ask br, , , can you breakdown theakadi , , and find valabai

  • @AK-yq3cx
    @AK-yq3cx 5 років тому

    Please make a #AskBR on 7aum arivu

  • @raghuram120
    @raghuram120 6 років тому

    Where I should comment for 7g rainbow colony movie

    • @b0rangan
      @b0rangan 6 років тому +1

      Right here. Questions come through the filmcompanionsouth pages or handles (fb, twitter, insta and youtube here)

    • @raghuram120
      @raghuram120 6 років тому

      Baradwaj Rangan thank you sir !!! I am waiting.

  • @theoptimist4771
    @theoptimist4771 6 років тому

    21,694th view!!!!!

  • @goppalbalan2586
    @goppalbalan2586 2 роки тому

    Why you Indian never come out of the Tamil, Indian boundaries? Why you people always lock Kamal Haasan within the boundaries of Tamil cinema.... He is Jambavan,,, he is universal level.....!!!!! Stop locking him.... Kamal ji himself know that he is the best actor/artist in the whole world..... When the hell you all will accept this fact.. please stop your mental block....

  • @gopalakrishnangopalakrihna6965
    @gopalakrishnangopalakrihna6965 5 років тому

    தமிழ்ல பேச மாட்டீங்களா

  • @goppalbalan2586
    @goppalbalan2586 2 роки тому

    STOPPPP COMPARING WITH HOLLYWOOD....!!!!!! STOPP STOPPPP
    I CHALLENGE YOU MR BARADHWAJ RANGAN..... CAN YOU NAME 1 ACTOR FROM THE WHOLE WORLD BETTER THAN PARTHA SARADHI SRINIVASAN /KAMAL HAASAN
    PLEASE DO REVIEWS RESPONSIBLY.....

    • @chaitanyach6868
      @chaitanyach6868 Рік тому

      Kamal Haasan might be the greatest actor in Indian cinema but there are many actors in the world. Daniel Day Lewis Al Pacino Marlon Brando are the best method actors of all time. They just do limited films but Pacino in 70's and 90's he's the greatest Brando in 50's and 60's. Day Lewis is a greatest method actor ever lived

  • @rickdalton2412
    @rickdalton2412 6 років тому +9

    Idha dislike panaravanga enga irupanga? 🤔
    Satyama andha mentalkanth fan ah dhaan irupanga

    • @vishalfazil6107
      @vishalfazil6107 6 років тому

      Wingardium leviosa vijay fans(kids )

    • @95Satya
      @95Satya 6 років тому +1

      Vishal Fazil Yaar bro sonna vijay fans does not like kamal?
      Kamal sir mathiri unnoru actor namaluku kidaikamatanga he is vera level

  • @ahhsbbsbbw
    @ahhsbbsbbw 3 роки тому +2

    I'm a 2k kid. I saw this film. I don't why people celebrate this? Hey ram was a cult, this movie is not that great.
    Lots of logic mistakes, useless songs, no depth in story. It should have been taken in 2 parts.

    • @ahhsbbsbbw
      @ahhsbbsbbw 3 роки тому +1

      It is very fast, I can't sink with emotions. Last 30 minute was great.

    • @ahhsbbsbbw
      @ahhsbbsbbw 3 роки тому +1

      Vada chennai is the best

    • @dailybroccoli7538
      @dailybroccoli7538 3 роки тому

      Lol yeah

  • @nitz7061
    @nitz7061 6 років тому +3

    I dont really like this movie due to all the hype. I think only Thalapathi will be my preferred Mani Ratnam movie at this point.

    • @dixondavid9526
      @dixondavid9526 6 років тому +6

      Just one black ship can't understand

    • @nitz7061
      @nitz7061 6 років тому

      I never said I couldnt "understand" the movie so i hate it. Its just overhyped and most of the mani ratnam fans are toxic and pretentious which made me hate it unironically.

    • @rickdalton2412
      @rickdalton2412 6 років тому +4

      Matt Devil Murdock yeah.. True.. Another idiotic rajini fan😂😂😂

    • @nitz7061
      @nitz7061 6 років тому

      Another pretentious dumbfuck

    • @rickdalton2412
      @rickdalton2412 6 років тому +1

      Matt Devil Murdock oh.. Rajini fans know English? 😂😂.. Fucking bastards know English?