Why even have him there? He does not get to answer or explain anything many many times. I am neither for or against Mr. Z or Facebook. These kind of hearings are usually just held to humiliate and less used to get or understand actual information or get actual data to help lawmakers decide how to proceed.. Murica!
The guy at the start Mr Pallone, he was asking questions that required a 2-3 minute explanation and just asked for a yes or no completely taking away what this whole thing is about by not letting him explain his answers. Zuckerberg was in the middle of explaining it and he interrupts him, he says it should be easy enough to say yes, which it isn't since there's no context for his answer
Melted Cheese free speech does not extend to hate speech. Also facebook is not the government. The government cant arrest you for speech unless you are intentionally harassing someone.
This is disappointing the amount of time they wasted asking questions that anyone with a fundamental knowledge of the internet and social media would understand completely.. he was asked SEVERAL times if he would promise to give users the option to decide what content they can make private or public... he had to answer that like half a dozen times! It was completely ridiculous.
Why was the question, 'Will facebook users be given the option to opt out of third parties obtaining information they do not wish to share with them?' not asked? To me its like the most important and obvious question to ask.
Yes, I have used third party apps before. Never have I seen a box to tick for me to give them permission to access my data. They should state before anyone using any app that 'Do you give us consent to access your data? If not, then do not use this app'. Very sneaky tactics if you ask me. They should be transparent and clear when they access and use your data before you use any of their apps. How can I give them permission to access my data, if I am unaware of it?
I'm not American, and don't know much about congress and whatnot. But how is this a good system? 4 minutes each - 3 of which are taken up by some old person spreading misinformation or misinterpreted information and then demanding him to give a 1 word answer? It annoys me just watching them shut down any answers he gives that are over a sentence long.
I watched the first hearing and the second hearing. Why they heck do they have to keep asking the same questions. It's so irritating. It kinda of sucks many of this politician are the ones that will be representing us for a long time. We should as voters put limits on how long congress can stay in office. Not only would that negate corporations donations but force out entrenched incompetent politician that dont fully support their constituents beliefs. We need to bring integrity back but that just wishful thinking.
Fabian Caezar as far as I know, there is so many conspiracy theories about Zuckerberg being a lizardmen. Have you read any sci Fi or watched ? In the books and movies reptilian are described as a highly intelligent creature capable of domination
Watched the first grilling; seems some of these people just do not understand or do not want to understand what MZ has programmed to do - they just wanted to push their agenda. the responsibility lies on the USERS regardless if terms and conditions are short-simple...common sense tells you joining is at USERS OWN RISK. It is so unfair that MZ's contribution to the global community as a whole is not being looked at but something trivial. These lot should say thank you to MZ and support him where they can rather than treating him as though he has committed 'the crime' !!!
the senate doesn't understand the internet, fb has to log logged-off activity just as much as logged-on data. if the feds say "give us your servers and your logs" and fb doesn't, they're screwed.
Its frustrating that some of the questioners didn't understand the opt in nature of Facebook but im glad the question was raised about the left wing bias of Facebook.
Yeah when the guy was trying to get Zuckerberg to talk about searching something and then an ad appearing for it like he had no clue what cookies are. So many questions were just stupid and clearly shows that these guys don't know how the modern world and internet works.
faint... i keep feel that I listen to them telling fb to keep everyone's priviacy.... which could just mean close down facebook itself... or did i misinterpret what they mean.... keep all privacy and no 3rd party = no social = online personal diary...?
This matter is not for Zuckerberg, but for people's human right and protection of Personal Privacy of people in the all over the world. Zuckerberg must owe the responsibility legally under the US law for the security of Personal Information. His staffs are pleased that ' we might not need to have any responsibility legally under any kind of the US law enforcement ' after attending to Capitol Hill hearing. We must not allow Zuckerberg and his staffs' illegal optimism.
Why do they not let him explain his answers? One guy just made him answer yes or no to questions that need an explanation and context for his reason. Most of these morons asking the questions have no idea what they're talking about one guy had no idea how cookies and ads worked.
But still just letting him talk for 30 secs couldn't hurt, he had no chance to explain, none of the questions that guy asked could be answered yes or no and be a good answer though. Bad example but look at school exams for maths, they ask you a question that's worth 4 marks and the actual answer is only worth 1 and those other 3 is for showing how you got to your answer this can apply to this since what good is yes or no when testifying at before congress?
Yeah true, I think they should've given the congressmen more time. In 4 minutes you can't really ask a question and get a good answer in that small amount of time.
Who made the call to have a bunch of old people who barley know the difference between Facebook and Napster ask the same questions over and over for two days lol?
Yeah it was painful to listen when the guy asked about ads, he didnt know that ad revenue was a thing and didnt know what cookies are and thought it was a facebook only thing.
He lied by saying you can delete face book, you can not delete a face book account, you can only deactivate a face book account, so by rights its always there and can be accessed easy if hacked, even after people die, accounts should be able to be deleted and deleted for good no more signing back in ever again if that's what the owner of the account wants
On 40 min and many other time stops... When he answers senator of illinois.. Zuckerbergs voice change wierd as he was an ad himself but for his company.. Hes acting strange in a wierd way sometime!
Yeah the cushion was not only to make him more visible to them but it was to help combat the case of grapefruit sized hemorrhoids that Congress just gave him 😂😂.
It's a little too late man I'm sorry for your own decisions & awareness at the time. A little off subject to touch on quickly is a generation of introverted ego social bubbles. Unfortunately, You've unknowingly placed around open young & older minds. They crave more dopamine. But the damage is done before you were aware of it. Now you see it when you're lucky enough to be in a room for not suffering from social discomfort. As it makes more sense when you come to the realization.
Ads are like spell for vulnerable beings...☯️✝️✝️❤️🕉what happens if the employees at social media company aren't allow to vote and their family? Would that be unfair?
Mr House couldn’t agree more, Congress are worryingly dumb on this subject, I feel sorry someone as intelligent as Mark being stuck in a room with these idiots
I think face book is the best thing that happen .support him not put him down everybody loves fb we all have security settings use them .If you dont like facebook dont use it simple dont blame him .
Buddy, do you have any idea how much Zuckerberg loves your information? Even if your privacy settings are toned down it's not gonna change a thing. They're still gonna collect that data from you. Facebook is not the best thing to happen to his world, it's made a lot of us disconnected in a way.
An free entertainment and thrilling adventure for an mega billionaires of world . An free drama ( by an young man second Noah mark zuckerberg) with an old age sapiens . Let all his enemies be wiped off and graveyarded allowing his descendants to conquer the earth. Wonderful drama and entertainment made by this mega billionaires of world
Nate The problem is that they don't state the terms of their 'censorship' on the TOS to the extent that they conform. They censor many conservative views for what they consider 'hate' speech, but are unable to fully describe what hate speech is. Everyone can admit that calling for the death of a set of people is hate speech, but is criticizing their beliefs/culture hate speech? That's what facebook believes and it's what they punish many people for. Another problem is the complexity of many terms of service. They are long and full of drivel which most people could care less for or don't understand. I'm guessing that's what that old man meant about it being in 'swahili', though he most definitely construed it the wrong way if so. And lastly, there is the problem in which facebook collects information on people that aren't even using facebook. Not sure the timetable in which this was brought up, but apparently facebook is somehow collecting information on people that aren't on facebook in order to stop them from signing up for facebook.
Why even have him there? He does not get to answer or explain anything many many times. I am neither for or against Mr. Z or Facebook. These kind of hearings are usually just held to humiliate and less used to get or understand actual information or get actual data to help lawmakers decide how to proceed.. Murica!
Have you read the whole transcripts?
The guy at the start Mr Pallone, he was asking questions that required a 2-3 minute explanation and just asked for a yes or no completely taking away what this whole thing is about by not letting him explain his answers. Zuckerberg was in the middle of explaining it and he interrupts him, he says it should be easy enough to say yes, which it isn't since there's no context for his answer
It is pointless talking to a bunch of old folks about Tech they don't understand
yeah, the guy asking about ads killed me in side. He's asking asking about the internet yet has no idea what cookies are or how ad revenue works.
This hearing is a 5 hour meme.
5hr+ of pointless testimony tbh, nothing achieve yet. The one whom should grilled and roast is Cambridge Analytica
they are a drop in the bucket to whats really going on. just got media attention so you heard their name. thats all.
No he plays a part in this too. He's censoring so many people on the platform, he's not innocent by far.
Melted Cheese he censors hate speech, which is what conservatives use to communicate with each other.
James Jamesbond Censorship is censorship either way. Whatever happened to free speech?
Melted Cheese free speech does not extend to hate speech. Also facebook is not the government. The government cant arrest you for speech unless you are intentionally harassing someone.
This is disappointing the amount of time they wasted asking questions that anyone with a fundamental knowledge of the internet and social media would understand completely.. he was asked SEVERAL times if he would promise to give users the option to decide what content they can make private or public... he had to answer that like half a dozen times! It was completely ridiculous.
that awkward smile 👌
The us government should know a thing or two about invading privacy, shouldn't they?
I find it unprofessional that they`re on there phones.
Muchas gracia (sorry for bad german)
Kingo Bingo thas not german😂😂👍
Anyone can tell that's chinese gosh
You made my day 👍
gutes deutsch bruder alles gut
Rama lama ding ding 😂😂
Why was the question, 'Will facebook users be given the option to opt out of third parties obtaining information they do not wish to share with them?' not asked? To me its like the most important and obvious question to ask.
andrew pankiw
Because these old people who were questioning him actually have no idea how any of this works.
It was asked by someone on the first day of testimony. He basically said that the option is already there, if you don't use the apps.
I use Facebook apps and I have never seen the option of not allowing a third party to access my data
andrew pankiw that is the option. By using the third party apps, you are giving permission for your data to be used by the third party.
Yes, I have used third party apps before. Never have I seen a box to tick for me to give them permission to access my data. They should state before anyone using any app that 'Do you give us consent to access your data? If not, then do not use this app'. Very sneaky tactics if you ask me. They should be transparent and clear when they access and use your data before you use any of their apps. How can I give them permission to access my data, if I am unaware of it?
1 hour 16 minutes, Mr Zuckerberg is pissed off...
Dear Guardian. It's very helpful, if chapters are added to the video. Especially if the video is 5h.
Anyway thanks for the upload.
Maybe he can leak who HowToBasic is.
What’s going on. I have no clue what so ever.
slumpie
Something about Facebook taking peoples information without them knowing
After he survives this. He has no intention of standing for POTUS.
Mr.Rush Illonois pleas speak clearly or get yourself an interpreter
He has a trachea problem I think, everyone else could understand him so maybe its you
Sasindu
I understood what he asked, it was hilariously dumb, the guy is totally out of his depth
Good for you Alade!
Sasindu Avishka sasindu
They should be allowed to ask as many questions as they like. Either that, or just go on and have it on askfm... Geez.
I'm just wondering where he goes to get his hair cut like that, and if he bring his own bowl.
Tim Campbell someone just grabbed some scissors, handed them to his kid and let his kid go to work.
S955US84 ikr, all he has to do is wrap the tie around twice instead of once.
I'm not American, and don't know much about congress and whatnot. But how is this a good system? 4 minutes each - 3 of which are taken up by some old person spreading misinformation or misinterpreted information and then demanding him to give a 1 word answer? It annoys me just watching them shut down any answers he gives that are over a sentence long.
I watched the first hearing and the second hearing. Why they heck do they have to keep asking the same questions. It's so irritating. It kinda of sucks many of this politician are the ones that will be representing us for a long time. We should as voters put limits on how long congress can stay in office. Not only would that negate corporations donations but force out entrenched incompetent politician that dont fully support their constituents beliefs. We need to bring integrity back but that just wishful thinking.
Its brilliant communication .All the best Mark .
What happened to his light hair and eyes? Are we sure that's him and not some robot/android?
lizard man
Bailey Fontenot reptilian
I want to ask something... why everybody called zucky "lizard/reptil/reptilian"?? I'm curious...
Fabian Caezar as far as I know, there is so many conspiracy theories about Zuckerberg being a lizardmen. Have you read any sci Fi or watched ? In the books and movies reptilian are described as a highly intelligent creature capable of domination
I'm sure that he's a robot
Is that correct? That's correct. correct? correct.
A mind field to opt in or out??? Ms Eshoo and the rest of Congress should have researched or used FB so can ask appropriate questions!!!
Watched the first grilling; seems some of these people just do not understand or do not want to understand what MZ has programmed to do - they just wanted to push their agenda. the responsibility lies on the USERS regardless if terms and conditions are short-simple...common sense tells you joining is at USERS OWN RISK. It is so unfair that MZ's contribution to the global community as a whole is not being looked at but something trivial. These lot should say thank you to MZ and support him where they can rather than treating him as though he has committed 'the crime' !!!
i felt sorry for him here.
Politicians can't do yes or no questions but requires others to do so? Oo
As long as he gets to decide what to censor with no restrictions on him, we have a problem.
Ms castor 😑😐 we the users has control if we like to post it or share something. Facebook didnt demand us to post and share things!
When was the first grilling?
Yesterday...
Facebook bothered somebody and it came to this charade...when you go up to a point ,always is somebody who want's to
take you down and destroy you.
the senate doesn't understand the internet, fb has to log logged-off activity just as much as logged-on data. if the feds say "give us your servers and your logs" and fb doesn't, they're screwed.
Mark Suckerberf belongs in the jail forever
Mr Barton vice chairman of Texas seems like such a nice guy
Mark Zuckerbergs backround: I counting 4 people who are like :-(
faaaaak fredom of speach is gone
Im pretty sure, even in America, you're allowed your defence
this questioning with time limits is ridiculous, he barely gets a chance to answer their stupid questions
why not add a Hispanics, Asian or Native Americans.
Its frustrating that some of the questioners didn't understand the opt in nature of Facebook but im glad the question was raised about the left wing bias of Facebook.
Yeah when the guy was trying to get Zuckerberg to talk about searching something and then an ad appearing for it like he had no clue what cookies are. So many questions were just stupid and clearly shows that these guys don't know how the modern world and internet works.
He is one of the most powerfull men on the planet , it's all a sham to "ease" the minds of the plebs !
The opening remark so far is fair....
1:03
when will he come?
I don't know I am really sorry I was faking Shubham Singh from india
Bloody hell, the comments section hasn't been shut down!😨
Edit: Meanwhile in Syria...
faint... i keep feel that I listen to them telling fb to keep everyone's priviacy.... which could just mean close down facebook itself... or did i misinterpret what they mean.... keep all privacy and no 3rd party = no social = online personal diary...?
It's very simple. Stay away from Facebook.... End of story.
Yeah i've never had facebook and my life has been perfectly fine.
Squirm squirm haha
Why doesn't facebook develop a browser?
That would be awful if they were to do that.
This matter is not for Zuckerberg, but for people's human right and protection of Personal Privacy of people in the all over the world. Zuckerberg must owe the responsibility legally under the US law for the security of Personal Information.
His staffs are pleased that ' we might not need to have any responsibility legally under any kind of the US law enforcement ' after attending to Capitol Hill hearing. We must not allow Zuckerberg and his staffs' illegal optimism.
Hey mr senator, take a look at your glass cup, is it Granny Peach Tea?
Why do they not let him explain his answers? One guy just made him answer yes or no to questions that need an explanation and context for his reason. Most of these morons asking the questions have no idea what they're talking about one guy had no idea how cookies and ads worked.
Cause they only had 4 minutes each I am guessing.
But still just letting him talk for 30 secs couldn't hurt, he had no chance to explain, none of the questions that guy asked could be answered yes or no and be a good answer though. Bad example but look at school exams for maths, they ask you a question that's worth 4 marks and the actual answer is only worth 1 and those other 3 is for showing how you got to your answer this can apply to this since what good is yes or no when testifying at before congress?
Yeah true, I think they should've given the congressmen more time. In 4 minutes you can't really ask a question and get a good answer in that small amount of time.
Who made the call to have a bunch of old people who barley know the difference between Facebook and Napster ask the same questions over and over for two days lol?
Psykward so true it’s embarrassing
Yeah it was painful to listen when the guy asked about ads, he didnt know that ad revenue was a thing and didnt know what cookies are and thought it was a facebook only thing.
who else watched the whole thing
Martin Tang nobody
Just came to this video to drop a comment "why so many people called zucky lizard/reptil/reptilian?"
He lied by saying you can delete face book, you can not delete a face book account, you can only deactivate a face book account, so by rights its always there and can be accessed easy if hacked, even after people die, accounts should be able to be deleted and deleted for good no more signing back in ever again if that's what the owner of the account wants
Pearcey111 u can delete it
You dont really delete it you just deactivate it and it spells you deleted
But if you want it back you can reactivate it
There is a delete button sir
its the internet, and good luck!
This was stupid. If you don't have time to hear the answer way asking???
He say "we dont Sale data" thats a big lie you dont know me but trust they Sale that a fact!
On 40 min and many other time stops... When he answers senator of illinois.. Zuckerbergs voice change wierd as he was an ad himself but for his company.. Hes acting strange in a wierd way sometime!
The Facebook government sucks
He makes all them billions, but yet can't fix his hairline lol
Zuckerberg 4 President
Mark just needs prison time
Lizardboi
Yeah the cushion was not only to make him more visible to them but it was to help combat the case of grapefruit sized hemorrhoids that Congress just gave him 😂😂.
42 minutes in to this and I'm already bored......what a waste of time for Mark Zuckerberg...I mean damn
This moment when CaseyNeistad has more views because he cut his hair :D
why does everyone behind mark look like paid hitman waiting for the kill?
the camera girl tho
these old people don't even know what to ask him to get the answers the're looking for XD
It's a little too late man I'm sorry for your own decisions & awareness at the time. A little off subject to touch on quickly is a generation of introverted ego social bubbles. Unfortunately, You've unknowingly placed around open young & older minds. They crave more dopamine. But the damage is done before you were aware of it. Now you see it when you're lucky enough to be in a room for not suffering from social discomfort. As it makes more sense when you come to the realization.
Ads are like spell for vulnerable beings...☯️✝️✝️❤️🕉what happens if the employees at social media company aren't allow to vote and their family? Would that be unfair?
I do like funny hearings
There are some sharp minds here and Mark is being very slipping and sliding with his answers !!
and he has been caught at last ...
michaelauknz caught about what? Caught about being slow to realise someone misused information that was given to them by the user themselves?
The only sharp mind in that room is zuck. How does the usa function if congress is filled with people as stupid as this?
Mr House couldn’t agree more, Congress are worryingly dumb on this subject, I feel sorry someone as intelligent as Mark being stuck in a room with these idiots
Robbin.
Porque ofccbbk não está funcionando o que ouve
Wy tu jakieś tam przesłuchania Cukenberga oglądacie, a w Polsce nam posła Gawłowskiego aresztowali.
Facebook will go down before 2019
The Zucc
The future president of USA and mega billionaires of world mark zuckerberg the excellent drama and entertainment made for viewers wonderful
Liar.
paul wright your people r so lucky to use facebook ,in china ,if you know the baidu search engine , i open it. It told me the sexiest girl in doraemon
I think face book is the best thing that happen .support him not put him down everybody loves fb we all have security settings use them .If you dont like facebook dont use it simple dont blame him .
jason rainsbury you're either 5 or 50 u don't even know what is happening, don't comment
Buddy, do you have any idea how much Zuckerberg loves your information? Even if your privacy settings are toned down it's not gonna change a thing. They're still gonna collect that data from you. Facebook is not the best thing to happen to his world, it's made a lot of us disconnected in a way.
An free entertainment and thrilling adventure for an mega billionaires of world . An free drama ( by an young man second Noah mark zuckerberg) with an old age sapiens . Let all his enemies be wiped off and graveyarded allowing his descendants to conquer the earth. Wonderful drama and entertainment made by this mega billionaires of world
The diversity guy ahaha
*_ZUCC_*
No es vida vivir así . ..de amonestación a amonestación...y lo que se AVECINA ni te cuento MARK...mmmmmmmmm
He should be slapped every time he deliberately calls hard working conservatives,terrorists.
Violence in the face of displeasure, sounds about right
Nate The problem is that they don't state the terms of their 'censorship' on the TOS to the extent that they conform. They censor many conservative views for what they consider 'hate' speech, but are unable to fully describe what hate speech is. Everyone can admit that calling for the death of a set of people is hate speech, but is criticizing their beliefs/culture hate speech? That's what facebook believes and it's what they punish many people for.
Another problem is the complexity of many terms of service. They are long and full of drivel which most people could care less for or don't understand. I'm guessing that's what that old man meant about it being in 'swahili', though he most definitely construed it the wrong way if so.
And lastly, there is the problem in which facebook collects information on people that aren't even using facebook. Not sure the timetable in which this was brought up, but apparently facebook is somehow collecting information on people that aren't on facebook in order to stop them from signing up for facebook.
Grow up
N8