How to use Chat GPT to summarize academic journal articles
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- This video shows you how to use Chat GPT to summarize an academic journal article by copy/pasting the article into Chat GPT. It offers some suggested wording for the prompt.
Here are three other videos reviewing tools for interacting with texts like PDFs or research articles:
ChatDOC vs. ChatGPT: • ChatDoc vs ChatGPT: Wh...
ChatPDF vs. Humata: • ChatPDF vs. Humata: Wh...
Textero.ai vs. ChatGPT: • Textero.ai vs ChatGPT:...
![How to use Zotero's full potential [The AI Revolution in Zotero]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gA3o2MlnPBQ/mqdefault.jpg)
It is so useful sir I have somehow told it to convert the topics of any subject into a story line of my favorite show and it quite effectively can create new and new short reading episodes using the Format of Multiple characters talking to each other, and asking questions and the other one's then answers the question then any other one asks a new question, if it makes sense as English is not my first language, I am Indian
Hi AI World, Yes, I think I understand what you are saying. You have converted the text into a conversation between two speakers. What is the prompt that you used. It sounds like a great strategy of use.
It is an "act as" Type prompt
Here it goes: Act as the characters of 'xyz' tv show and explain the topic of 'abc' in simple language, while creating a response which is not in the storyline of the show, come up with new conversational arguments between the characters while remembering and mimicking their personalities and voices.
The wording of the prompt can be improved, again because English is not my Primary language.
You really put your best forward in Teaching , I appreciate it very much Sir, Personally I think and believe that as an Academic Student AI should only be used for studying purpose otherwise it is just Exploitation of most writing skills.
@@a.iworld very cool!!!
@@vitorpmh Yes, I agree. That is a very cool prompt!
Brilliant😍
Can you please share the prompt that you have used in the pinned comment? This would really be helpful to us. Thank you
Sure. Here were the prompts used:
I am wondering if you could help me write a 500-word summary of an article? Can you summarize the following text, cite the authors, and offer three arguments and three counter-arguments that help compare and contrast their position on harm reduction? Also evaluate their conclusion and give me your opinion:
Here are two summaries of academic articles about Harm Reduction. Can you compare and contrast them? I would like you to provide a synthetic analysis and summary of the 5 key issues. Can you please present this analysis in the form of 5 paragraphs?
I am interested in writing an academic paper referring to these two articles on harm reduction that you just summarized above. I would like to use these arguments to discuss the current state of harm reduction in Vancouver, BC. Can you prepare an outline for me?
I am in a 4th year university course at Kwantlen Polytechnic University where we are studying harm reduction. In reference to the above articles that you summarized, what are some possible points for discussion that I could offer to my class? Can you present 5 bullet points and suggest two discussion questions? In addition, can you suggest 2 uncommon or radical perspectives on harm reduction and elaborate?
@Exp Thank you for the kind words. I am so happy that this was useful for you. It makes me smile. Thanks!
Great content on academic research tools! Immersive Translate, a web plugin, could be a great addition to your toolkit for translating research documents effortlessly.
Valuable channel, deserves more subscribers. Best of luck 🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🤗
Thanks Soumeya!
You asked for a 500 word summary. Did you count the words? My experience is that ChatGPT is not good at counting... Maybe I am doing something wrong
Thanks for your video it is s nice tool. And thanks for sharing your prompts
Dear Delfino,
Thank you for the kind words. I appreciate the kudos. I hope the prompts are useful for you.
Best,
Mike
Could you have used the url of the Google Scholar article instead?
Dear Linda,
I do not think it can access the internet. I just tried asking it to assess a Google Scholar article and I provided the URL.
This is what it said: "I apologize, but as an AI text-based model, I am unable to browse the internet or access specific articles like the one you mentioned."
But I think soon there will be official plug-ins for Chat GPT that will allow it to access the live internet. It will be offered by OpenAI.
Best,
Mike
You could try using the citation of the article. @@UniversityAIed
Thanks for the demonstration.
I am so happy that this is useful. You are welcome!
Thanks a lot. Could you share the prompts you used please?
Hi Elt M,
Sure. Here are the prompts used:
I am wondering if you could help me write a 500-word summary of an article? Can you summarize the following text, cite the authors, and offer three arguments and three counter-arguments that help compare and contrast their position on harm reduction? Also evaluate their conclusion and give me your opinion:
Here are two summaries of academic articles about Harm Reduction. Can you compare and contrast them? I would like you to provide a synthetic analysis and summary of the 5 key issues. Can you please present this analysis in the form of 5 paragraphs?
I am interested in writing an academic paper referring to these two articles on harm reduction that your just summarized above. I would like to use these arguments to discuss the current state of harm reduction in Vancouver, BC. Can you prepare an outline for me?
I am in a 4th year university course at Kwantlen Polytechnic University where we are studying harm reduction. In reference to the above articles that you summarized, what are some possible points for discussion that I could offer to my class? Can you present 5 bullet points and suggest two discussion questions? In addition, can you suggest 2 uncommon or radical perspectives on harm reduction and elaborate?
@@UniversityAIed thank you for sharing these.
I saw KPU in one of your scripts - good place!!
Dear SJ,
Yes, I'm at KPU. Thanks for the kudos. It is a good place!
Best,
Mike
how to check plagiarism of academic paper using chatgpt?
Dear Investing Insights,
It is easy to check. Just find a unique sentence or part of a sentence and copy/paste it into Google in quotations. And search. Try this a few times. You will eventually find phrases or complete sentences that are copied from something it was exposed to during its training. Often the first sentence of a paragraph will have some deep similarity to something found on the web.
Best,
Mike
thank you very much for the sharing. But i have a question for you? how can we use this for journals that is very long? Can you help me in this? tq
Dear @user-hv8iy7lp5q,
You can try Chat GPT interfaces like ChatDOC, HUMATA, ChatPDF, AskYourPDF, or Shary.AI.
These interfaces allow a user to upload a longer PDF or text into Chat GPT, and then allow you to query that specific article. It restricts the questions to that specific document.
You can watch my reviews found in these six videos:
ua-cam.com/video/vFXS0z6ap2Q/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/nQSZdzYJ3ZQ/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/LMlYJXWusks/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/u3OPhrMTMrE/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/NmNGF34n0Hk/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/4rdGVCK_7fc/v-deo.html
Best,
Mike
@aiineducation5746 thanks for the recommendation on ChatDOC. I just signed up and I love it already 🔥.
Can you write your first prompt in a comment
Sure. Here were the prompts used:
I am wondering if you could help me write a 500-word summary of an article? Can you summarize the following text, cite the authors, and offer three arguments and three counter-arguments that help compare and contrast their position on harm reduction? Also evaluate their conclusion and give me your opinion:
Here are two summaries of academic articles about Harm Reduction. Can you compare and contrast them? I would like you to provide a synthetic analysis and summary of the 5 key issues. Can you please present this analysis in the form of 5 paragraphs?
I am interested in writing an academic paper referring to these two articles on harm reduction that you just summarized above. I would like to use these arguments to discuss the current state of harm reduction in Vancouver, BC. Can you prepare an outline for me?
I am in a 4th year university course at Kwantlen Polytechnic University where we are studying harm reduction. In reference to the above articles that you summarized, what are some possible points for discussion that I could offer to my class? Can you present 5 bullet points and suggest two discussion questions? In addition, can you suggest 2 uncommon or radical perspectives on harm reduction and elaborate?
10
Thanks a lot for this video! Just a question- what do we do when it says ‘ too many requests in one hour, try again later.’ This happened the first time i tried using it. Is there a limit for how many times we can use it or something like that?
Dear Soma Mb,
The free version of ChatGPT is often overloaded with users and requests. So, one solution is just to try using it at different timeslots. I tend to get fairly good results during the evening. Just try logging into the program at different hours and/or days of the week.
Best,
Mike
Hey sometimes chatgpt doesn't summarize it and gives reasons such as the article is very old or new (i don't exactly remember the reason) but it's definitely not because of the long word count. How do i solve the problem?
Dear aditidwivedi719,
There are many interfaces with GPT that I think now work better for summarization. You can watch my other videos that review ChatDOC, FileGPT, Humata, AskYourPDF, etc... and I think you will find that these other interfaces work much better. Here is the review of ChatDOC if you are interested:
ua-cam.com/video/LMlYJXWusks/v-deo.html
I have also read that Claude AI is very good at reading uploaded documents, but I have not tried it out yet. Give these a try.
Best,
Mike
@@UniversityAIed I feel they don't work in Indian articles even if they are in English
Dear @@aditidwivedi6719,
I don't think I understand. You are saying that Generative AI does not work well with Indian articles because the authors are non-native speakers? Can you elaborate or give an example?
Best,
Mike
@@UniversityAIed No like whenever i ask it to summarize an article, i type the article name and author, chatgpt says that he doesn't know about it or the article is from the time when chatgpt didn't exist. This happens for almost all the articles and books that i use for my research. I feel chatgpt doesn't know much about indian books and journals
time waste
Dear @umairnazir5579,
Do you mean the video wasted your time, or, that Chat GPT is a waste of time?
Best,
Mike
Chatgpt saying too long plz submit shorter
Dear hunkmonk, Chat GPT does not like to process long passages of text. But I get good results if I keep the passage of text under 3000 words. So, for example, if you have an article that is 9,000 words, then you would have to cut it up into three portions and paste them into Chat GPT separately and then ask for a summary. Do that three times, and then you can copy/paste all three summaries back into Chat GPT and ask it to stitch and harmonize the three summaries into a cohesive whole. I hope that helps.
@@UniversityAIed it will loose context if we let say splitting into parts... jurnal articles usually took like 5 pages or more ..good solution is using openai API along with python , there's python module to keep memory/ context ...let say we want to summarize 10k character of jurnal articles but I have no success
@@AntonNb I think one solution, without having to code with python, is ChatPDF: www.chatpdf.com
Try it. But you can only upload three PDFs each day on the free trial.
@@UniversityAIed i don't know why, but in my case, I had to keep the passage of text under 1500 words in order for chatgpt to work without error. i wonder why..
You can also try HUMATA. See my review of both here: ua-cam.com/video/NmNGF34n0Hk/v-deo.html
Could do a video of the best Free GPT AI website or apps out there that could us out with essays 😅
Ok. Yes, that would be a useful video. I'll see what I can do.
Storm,
You can watch me review of Chat PDF and HUMATA: ua-cam.com/video/NmNGF34n0Hk/v-deo.html
It might be of interest to you.
Best,
Mike
Thank you for sharing this and I appreciate your exploration of ChatGPT as a tool -- and agree that we should keep exploring this as educators. However, even in what is generated it seems that there are some of the problems with ChatGPT in that it does not always provide factual information. In the past, I've uploaded documents that I have read and there are factual errors in the ChatGPT summaries (it was an overview of work on socio-spatial analysis -- qualitative work). Checking some of what you've uploaded there are some things that are not exactly correct in the output as well. For example, the first article is by Strathdee, Crago, and Shannon, yet by the time you get to 16.53 min in the video, the "first article" is by Milloy et al. and so is the "second article." Also even while Milloy is the actual fourth author in the second article you originally summarized, one wouldn't use "Milloy et al." when citing it, i.e., I would point out to a student that this is technically incorrect. These are minor-ish errors in terms of the names of authors, but it brings up how ChatGPT is difficult to trust. I'm sure if one was to read the articles you had ChatGPT summarize and compare that to the the AI output that they would find, perhaps, even more important discrepancies. In addition, at the 17 min mark, we can also see that neither of the two original titles are correct at this point, but some other titles have been used. When I then look up the titles for two articles ChatGPT mentions, I don't find either cited in your original two articles nor can I find them in a broader search in Google Scholar. I agree with much of your use for brainstorming here, but there are so many red flags in terms of actual and potential factual errors in the output.
Dear Jaime Wright,
I can't agree with you more. Generative AI cannot be trusted to cite or find articles. It often confabulates or makes up stuff. I made this review video early on in January 2023 and I think I was too eager to sing its praises. I should really update this video. I have made other videos that review interfaces with GPT that I think work better for summarizing (e.g. ChatDoc et al). I have also read that Claude is better at summarizing than Chat GPTbecause you can upload specific articles for it to parse. But I have yet to sit down and seriously review it.
Many thanks for your long and thoughtful reply.
Best,
Mike
@@UniversityAIed Thanks for all your work on this. Best to get ahead of it, so to speak.
Can we ask chat gpt to write literature review for our dissertation with no issues of plagiarism?
I think there are two questions here. 1) Can summaries or lit reviews be detected? 2) Are such summaries a problem regarding academic integrity.
Firstly, I think if you watch my video reviewing 13 AI content detectors, then you will see that machine written text can be detected, especially if Hive Moderation is used. It will be revealed as not your own writing written solely by your own hand.
Secondly, I think your question brings up the much more thorny question of whether it will be accepted by an academic institution as "your work." I do not know whether using AI-assisted writing will constitute an academic integrity violation. If the summary feature is part of the MS Word program, then I think your institution will have to create a clear set of guidelines regarding the use of MS Word. Since it is the most popular word processing program being used in the academy I think that this will be critical guideline for institutions to craft. So, I think my answer would have to be: I dunno.
Machine-assisted writing is pretty much here to stay, but the academy has not caught up to this development. Each school will have to develop its own guidelines. Sorry if this sounds like I'm dodging your question, but it is my honest answer.
Follow-up answer: You can also try using ChatPDF or HUMATA interface to query a specific document or PDF. They might help you with your literature review. Here is my review of them: ua-cam.com/video/NmNGF34n0Hk/v-deo.html
Iam a student from India. NCERT is the standard textbooks for class 11th and 12th. so to understand concepts in physics subject, I am copying entire chapter from NCERT and pasting into chatgpt search box for analytical explanation of that chapter. but my problem is mathematical formulae, equations, derivations are not exactly pasted into chatgpt. only text format is pasted clearly. how to overcome this problem?
I don't think it can completely overcome this problem because I suspect it was not shown those equations or math problems you mentioned during its training. Most of the training is text based. But there is also some training in computer code. Maybe your specific questions are beyond its current training.