Great legend Tagore.......he will not only be remembered for his work ...but he will also be remembered for his ideologies and philosophy...his role in igniting the spirit within the freedom fighters....he is a immortal soul and has truely enlightened Bengal culturally in it's real sense...my salute to be born in the land of such a great legend...
i suggest having the english translations of the lyrics scroll while the song is being played. That way non-bengali listeners will also enjoy this wonderful program.
Came here for Monali. But got a nice history lesson! Thank you so much Monali and Shantanu! In such a short video you have provided very important thoughts on Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore and Mahatma Gandhi!
Motivational ..... It was totally good .... Monali was out of track somewhere but totally it was good she was the part of this programme out of her busy schedule n had make the programme a grand success....
সংগীতের সর্ব শ্রেষ্ঠ মঞ্চ সা রব গা মা পা।আর সংগীতের দুই নক্ষত্র মঞ্চে উপস্থিত ছিলো কিন্তু জাতীয় সংগীত গাওয়ার সময় যে সবাই দাঁড়িয়ে গাইতে বা শুনতে হয় সেটা যে তারা ভুলে যাবে তা এই মঞ্চটার থেকে আশা করা যায় না।
I had known shantanu very little. He is a great preacher as well as a great narrator. At the top of that he blend them in music. If you cant like this man you are not a normal human being.
যেহেতু এই গানটি বাংলাদেশের জাতীয় সঙ্গীত .....গানটি গাওয়ার সময় দাড়ানো উচিত ছিলো সবার.... বাংলাদেশ ও এর জাতীয় সঙ্গীত ও রবীন্দ্রনাথ ঠাকুরের প্রতি সম্মান জানিয়ে.... এতে দৈন্যতা প্রকাশ পেলো যা খুবই দুঃখজনক😊
@@saugatadas9516 আমি বলতে চেয়েছি ভারতীয় দের কাছে ওইটা শুধু রবীন্দ্রসংগীত। নিজের দেশের জাতীয় সংগীত এর উপর মানুষ এর যে ভক্তি ও শ্রদ্ধা থাকে তা অন্য দেশের জাতীয় সংগীত এর উপর থাকেনা। যদিও থাকে সেটা রবীন্দ্র সংগীত হিসেবে। আপনি কি ভারতীয়?
now the world has got so complex that many of our new generation don't understand the songs' simplicity and the complexity creates webs of boundary to reach the depth of the song. I read in class 10 but most of my classmates doesn't understand and reach the ending and break the pillars of limitations
Emotionally yes, but merging Bangladesh with India at the moment is a far fetched dream. Yeah do not even think of seperating BEngal from India. We are Indians first Bengalis later.
I just stop thinking about GURU DEV because he is out of the world how a man can be so immensely talented.he was able to mark his presence in the participation in the freedom movement of India..just feel previliged as an Indian because we both sharing the same air same sky
I have lot of respect on Shantanu Moitra. But it seems better that he keeps himself away from delivering historical facts. 1923 Bengal partition???? It was 1905...
Not expected from Monali.. She was totally not prepared in fact she made mistake in the song ekla cholo re... But though she made those mistakes still her voice it's just outstanding which made me feel very happy... Rabindranath Tagore is there in every Bengali, in every Bengali's heart....
+JNUI CHATTOPADHYAY With due respect , lets not get into all the intricacies -- So many Bengali -Indian's reside abroad and need to learn the Bengali culture for the next generation and more generations to come .
That's what all Bengalis say.. people from other parts would name other people.. actually.. there were many reasons for British leaving India..one of them was certainly Netaji but not the only reason..
আমি আপনার সাথে একমত। আমার দেশ যেমন আমার কাছে গর্বের তেমনই অন্য দেশের মানুষ ও তার দেশ কে নিয়ে গর্ব করে। তাঁদের এই অনুভূতি কে সম্মান জানানো আমাদের কর্তব্য। আমি উঠে দাঁড়িয়েছি। সবার কাছে অনুরোধ, আপনারাও বাংলাদেশ কে সম্মান জানান। জাতীয় সংগীত শুনলে অন্তত উঠে দাঁড়ান।
Tagore wrote several pieces to Netaji aswell. There was a significant bit of rabindrasangeet that hold true to this day, and is used in Netaji's context. Subhas-Rabindranath relationship was strong as well, both asking out for each other often. And no, Gandhi was never the direct reason for the British flying out of India, it was the mutiny of the then Indian Navy and Army, by the conflict instilled in them by the Azad Hind fauj and Subhas Bose himself. We have been cultural enough to know the truth. Thus, we expect the composition maestro, Mr. Santanu Moitra ji to fact- check at times as well. This rendition was quite good 👍
Lots of inaccurate facts. Jodi tor was written for Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. Inaccuracy with partition of Bengal.It was declared in 1905 not 1923. The idea of relationship between Bangladesh and India couldn't have been imagined in 1923.
Tagore couldn't possibly know that there would be a country called Bangladesh in future.So when he wrote that song 'aamar sonar Bangla' he didn't mean it as the national anthem for Bangladesh. ........or a collaboration between west Bengal and Bangladesh as said by Shantanu Moitra..
yea r8 bt now it is the national anthem of BD.And the whole world recognise this song with papers as the national anthem of Bangladesh. So its our duty to show respect for any national anthem of any nation.
Umm.. According to wikipedia and some other sources this song was dedicated to Netaji after Gandhi went against him but Gandhi had said that he was a fan of this song. Where are we going wrong ?
A great attempt to get the air of freedom that prevailed all around those days. Monali Thakur should have been careful with the lyrics when she sang "Bidhir badhan ..." and "ekla chalo re ..."
ক্ষমা করবেন ভারতবর্ষ ছাড়া বাংলার কোন দাম নেই। আমাদের মহান পূর্বপুরুষরা কেউই বাংলাকে ভারতবর্ষের বাইরে কল্পনাও করেননি৷ বাংলা আমার পরিচয় আর ভারত আমার মা, ওই গর্ভ থেকেই আমার বা আমাদের জন্ম।
Great legend Tagore.......he will not only be remembered for his work ...but he will also be remembered for his ideologies and philosophy...his role in igniting the spirit within the freedom fighters....he is a immortal soul and has truely enlightened Bengal culturally in it's real sense...my salute to be born in the land of such a great legend...
Voice of monali madam is awesome 😍
যে কোনো দেশের জাতীয় সংগীত গাওয়ার সময় দাঁড়িয়ে সম্মান জানানো উচিত।।।।
লেখার শেষে ১টা '।' দেওয়া উচিৎ ৪টে নয়।
এতো জ্ঞান কোথায় রাখেন আপনারা হ্যাঁ,, এখানে গান এর কথা বলছে শান্তনু স্যার
One of the finest anchoring and recitations I have ever listened. Thank you Santanu Moitra. B. Paul from Calcutta.
God gifted voice is Always powerful whatever language it might be
Just awsome voice of Monali Thakur...
it's was so soothing to hear the conversation about relationships between Gandhi and Tagore ji..
এই গানটি শুধু গান নয়,প্রত্যেকটি বাঙালির হৃদয়ের স্পন্দন, আবেগ, মমতা,ভালবাসা জড়িত আমাদের জাতীয় সংগীত। এই গানটির সাথে আমাদের সর্ম্মানের জায়গাটাও সেইরকম।
Shantunu moitra is a unique and great personality. Long live shantunu moitra
i suggest having the english translations of the lyrics scroll while the song is being played. That way non-bengali listeners will also enjoy this wonderful program.
+Dr. Jaideep Banerjee Absolutely agree Dr Jaideep Banerjee .
Tapesh Majumdar
yes
plz try to do it if it's possible
sir Santana do translate plz
its just awesome. nice presentation from Shantanu and guy on Guitar is also doing great....and A Magnificient Monali
Please make more such programs so that the new generation understands and relate to the songs.
Voice of monali ,Narrations r good.
keep on doing such programmes and inspire new Indians towards rabindrasangeet
Lots of love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩 love u guys sob gaan gula prane gatha
Came here for Monali.
But got a nice history lesson!
Thank you so much Monali and Shantanu!
In such a short video you have provided very important thoughts on Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore and Mahatma Gandhi!
A very nice attempt to revive & help us remember some parts of history & the relationship between Mahatma Gandhi & Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore!
Motivational ..... It was totally good .... Monali was out of track somewhere but totally it was good she was the part of this programme out of her busy schedule n had make the programme a grand success....
সংগীতের সর্ব শ্রেষ্ঠ মঞ্চ সা রব গা মা পা।আর সংগীতের দুই নক্ষত্র মঞ্চে উপস্থিত ছিলো কিন্তু জাতীয় সংগীত গাওয়ার সময় যে সবাই দাঁড়িয়ে গাইতে বা শুনতে হয় সেটা যে তারা ভুলে যাবে তা এই মঞ্চটার থেকে আশা করা যায় না।
I had known shantanu very little. He is a great preacher as well as a great narrator. At the top of that he blend them in music. If you cant like this man you are not a normal human being.
I am just like this video for only how she handle this song when she forgot the line.. Just mind blowing ❤
Voice of Monali Thakur is just mesmerizing
এটইি রবীন্দসঙ্গীত সব বাধা বাধঁন চিরে দেখে। Its rabindrasangeet that tear every boundary with the wind of rhythm, song,poem,love.
All the people should has stand up bcoz this song is a national anthem of Bangladesh
This program was in india not in bangladesh
If Jana Gana mana is sung.in bangladesh would.any one stand in silence there?
It may be your national anthem but for us it is a rabindrasangeet.
Its a folk song here as rabindra sangeet ☺
যেহেতু এই গানটি বাংলাদেশের জাতীয় সঙ্গীত .....গানটি গাওয়ার সময় দাড়ানো উচিত ছিলো সবার....
বাংলাদেশ ও এর জাতীয় সঙ্গীত ও রবীন্দ্রনাথ ঠাকুরের প্রতি সম্মান জানিয়ে.... এতে দৈন্যতা প্রকাশ পেলো যা খুবই দুঃখজনক😊
Nasrin Sultana right
Yes
ওদের কাছে এইটা শুধু রবিন্দ্রসংগিত।
@@md.nahidhasantamim2248 what do you mean by oder kachhe
@@saugatadas9516 আমি বলতে চেয়েছি ভারতীয় দের কাছে ওইটা শুধু রবীন্দ্রসংগীত। নিজের দেশের জাতীয় সংগীত এর উপর মানুষ এর যে ভক্তি ও শ্রদ্ধা থাকে তা অন্য দেশের জাতীয় সংগীত এর উপর থাকেনা। যদিও থাকে সেটা রবীন্দ্র সংগীত হিসেবে।
আপনি কি ভারতীয়?
I love this section.... and I love Bengal....
Its our national anthem when we sing this song we stand up ......Amar sonar Bangla ami tomai Valobasi
simply awesome !!!.....full of depth and emotions
ekla chalo, ekla chalo, ekla chalo re........
জাতীয় সংগীত শোনা মাত্রই আমার শরীরে লোমা দাড়িয়ে যায়......
এটাই মোনালি ঠাকুর।
How a beautiful voice of monali thakur really
monali is owesome
Monali You beauty.,.. Respect from Bangladesh.
Mr Moitro is full of creative ideas
Monali has the sweetest voice.....
now the world has got so complex that many of our new generation don't understand the songs' simplicity and the complexity creates webs of boundary to reach the depth of the song. I read in class 10 but most of my classmates doesn't understand and reach the ending and break the pillars of limitations
great program!
the brilliant shantunu mitara.
Monali di is soooo cute...and soooo pretty
I am the biggest fan of monali thakur.....😍😍😘😘
Bengal should be together again. Love from Bangladesh.
Faisal Nayeem Is already together by hearts! We should never let this bond go down :) Amar sonar bangla...
Souradeep Dutta Proud to be #Bengali. Jai Bangla 😍😍😍
Bengal is Bengal. No east no west. We are together by heart, by brotherhood.
Emotionally yes, but merging Bangladesh with India at the moment is a far fetched dream. Yeah do not even think of seperating BEngal from India. We are Indians first Bengalis later.
Inshallah....
love you monali mam and shantanu sir
Monali Di tumi jemon sundor, tomar gantao khub sundor, very sweet your voice ☺☺😙😙
My favorite singer
respect from bangladesh
very sweet her song
shantanu sir ...Hello Love you sir....song very nice musical.....
I just stop thinking about GURU DEV because he is out of the world how a man can be so immensely talented.he was able to mark his presence in the participation in the freedom movement of India..just feel previliged as an Indian because we both sharing the same air same sky
I have lot of respect on Shantanu Moitra. But it seems better that he keeps himself away from delivering historical facts. 1923 Bengal partition???? It was 1905...
Monali & Santonini both are amazing.
We are independent only because of Azad Hind Fauz formed by our Netaji
monali you are amazing 😚😚🙂🙄😙😚😶☺😍
Monali singing are amazing
Lots of ❤️from. 🇧🇩
Precious🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹
Appreciable approach
Not expected from Monali.. She was totally not prepared in fact she made mistake in the song ekla cholo re... But though she made those mistakes still her voice it's just outstanding which made me feel very happy...
Rabindranath Tagore is there in every Bengali, in every Bengali's heart....
Ekdom
Haha.. She forgot the line 'bojha tor bhari holei' and then again continued 'dubbe tori khan'. Handled the situation so beautifully ;-)
+JNUI CHATTOPADHYAY So true!!
+JNUI CHATTOPADHYAY With due respect , lets not get into all the intricacies -- So many Bengali -Indian's reside abroad and need to learn the Bengali culture for the next generation and more generations to come .
British left from India because of netaji
That's what all Bengalis say.. people from other parts would name other people.. actually.. there were many reasons for British leaving India..one of them was certainly Netaji but not the only reason..
@@mj1_5676 i am a bengali and i agree
Pŕime Minister Atlee when asked whom Britain felt threatened most during the fight for independancè, replied the it was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
আমি আপনার সাথে একমত। আমার দেশ যেমন আমার কাছে গর্বের তেমনই অন্য দেশের মানুষ ও তার দেশ কে নিয়ে গর্ব করে। তাঁদের এই অনুভূতি কে সম্মান জানানো আমাদের কর্তব্য। আমি উঠে দাঁড়িয়েছি। সবার কাছে অনুরোধ, আপনারাও বাংলাদেশ কে সম্মান জানান। জাতীয় সংগীত শুনলে অন্তত উঠে দাঁড়ান।
Absolutely, but pseudo bongs may think differently
Tagore wrote several pieces to Netaji aswell. There was a significant bit of rabindrasangeet that hold true to this day, and is used in Netaji's context. Subhas-Rabindranath relationship was strong as well, both asking out for each other often. And no, Gandhi was never the direct reason for the British flying out of India, it was the mutiny of the then Indian Navy and Army, by the conflict instilled in them by the Azad Hind fauj and Subhas Bose himself.
We have been cultural enough to know the truth. Thus, we expect the composition maestro, Mr. Santanu Moitra ji to fact- check at times as well. This rendition was quite good 👍
No words to describe ...what it is......ufff,❤️🥰❤️❤️🥰must watch to understand what is the purpose of literature and music...
something good ..awesome santanu da
Lots of inaccurate facts. Jodi tor was written for Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. Inaccuracy with partition of Bengal.It was declared in 1905 not 1923. The idea of relationship between Bangladesh and India couldn't have been imagined in 1923.
khub sundor. ...apnara khub valo thakben
Just awesome 👌
Excellent piece Santanu Babu 👍
It was a collection of some magical moments
Excellent programme
So sweet monali.
Best Best👌🏻👌🏻
in single word. just awesome
Culture and history of Bengal is very rich..
Tagore couldn't possibly know that there would be a country called Bangladesh in future.So when he wrote that song 'aamar sonar Bangla' he didn't mean it as the national anthem for Bangladesh. ........or a collaboration between west Bengal and Bangladesh as said by Shantanu Moitra..
yea r8 bt now it is the national anthem of BD.And the whole world recognise this song with papers as the national anthem of Bangladesh. So its our duty to show respect for any national anthem of any nation.
What he meant was epaar and opaar bangla..
I agree with you .
আমার সোনার বাংলা,
আমি তোমায় ভালোবাসি।।
Really entertaining as well as calming and soothing....👍👌.
Bengal partition: 1905; Gandhi came to India 1915. What are we missing?
Only Shreya Ghoshal can do justice to the Shantanu Moitra composition. no second thought!
Shantanu composition?
Ayaz, please educate yourself. PLease. These are TAGORE COMPOSITIONS. Lyrics + Tune. Okay !
Exactly 😂
অদ্ভুত...বলে কয়ে জাতীয় সঙ্গীত গাইলো কিন্তু কেউ সম্মান জানালো না। সম্মান না জানিয়ে নিজের দৈন্যতা প্রকাশ করলো ওরা।
Tapash Barua
Exactly
Tao to bole6e and kore6e.... Okhane to tao hoy na.... R apnader ki sob baper a khud dhorte hoy.... Cha er dokane adda mara public....
আপনাদের জাতীয় সঙ্গীত। আমাদের নয়।
tumara thu bangla te thakona hindustane thako a jonno r ki
Umm.. According to wikipedia and some other sources this song was dedicated to Netaji after Gandhi went against him but Gandhi had said that he was a fan of this song. Where are we going wrong ?
This is Our national anthem,, amar sonar bangla ami tomay valobashi 😍
My favourite singer Monali❤️❤️❤️❤️
Awesome!
Annek dhanyabad duojanke.Assam.
great work sir
Thanks santanu sir
Love from🇧🇩
Incredible
monali didi I love you so muss
Santanu Uncle please go through INDIAN history 1ST
I have a request to monali thakur.
We are want to heard fulfill our national anthem of your voice any programme.
অপূর্ব সুন্দর ভাষায় প্রকাশ করতে পারব না শুদ্ধ সংগীত পরিবেশন
Lots v love & respect! 😍😍😍
একজন বাংলাদেশী হয়ে আমার খুব ভালো লাগল এই গানটা
really amazing santanu da
Khub valo hoise monali.
Unique presentation.
A great attempt to get the air of freedom that prevailed all around those days. Monali Thakur should have been careful with the lyrics when she sang "Bidhir badhan ..." and "ekla chalo re ..."
Love you
Monali thakur
দুই বাংলা এক থেকে যদি বঙ্গরাষ্ট্র গড়ে উঠতো! তাহলে সেটি হত এই অঞ্চল, এমনকি সমগ্র এশিয়ার মধ্যে অন্যতম সমৃদ্ধ একটি রাষ্ট্র।
Mante parlam na
ভাই এটা আমাদের দুর্ভাগ্য। ধর্মীয় গোড়ামিই আমাদের আলাদা করে দিয়েছে। পূর্বে এক ছিল। যা আমরা ইতিহাস থেকে জানতে পাই।
ব্রিটিশ শাসকরা বাংলাকে বিভক্ত করে বেশিদিন ভারতবর্ষ শাসন করেছিল৷ ধর্মান্ধ বাঙালীরা এটা বুঝতে পারেনি৷
ক্ষমা করবেন ভারতবর্ষ ছাড়া বাংলার কোন দাম নেই। আমাদের মহান পূর্বপুরুষরা কেউই বাংলাকে ভারতবর্ষের বাইরে কল্পনাও করেননি৷ বাংলা আমার পরিচয় আর ভারত আমার মা, ওই গর্ভ থেকেই আমার বা আমাদের জন্ম।
I was telling about "akla chalore..." song
I love u Monali
Wonderful mammm
Wonderful prog.
It's quite heart-wrenching,that they didn't show respect and honour to the National anthem of another country. They might be literate but uneducated
Just awsome..all song...