The Mutya's version was always the best, Siobhan is doing an amazing job with just every song, this is however a Keisha song, always been. She owns it.
Siobhan voice is quite similar to Heidi's. Siobhan a stronger singer but Heidi has a nice tone to hers. They definitely both were the key voices with the Harmonies. I really would love to see them do a re record of their best Hits with Siobhan vocals on a studio album. Heidi will always be the main singer and Amelle on some of their huge hits.. and the official videos will always reflect that It would be interesting to see some new re recordings with Siobhan on some of these big Heidi and Amelle era songs.. with Mutya and Siobhan doing their versions.
This song has been redeemed for me. I loved the original instantly and I hoped Mutya would do the video before she left.. guttered she didn't but this fixes it with Siobhan added its perfection.
yes yes yes !! finally they're doing red dress!! I thought they'd banished it. thankfully not!! love seeing Siobhan and mutya in this. keep it up. they sound great 🎉
@@jaywest3734 She was on the original but she didn’t like the song at the time and even mentioned how she appreciated that they waited until she was gone to release it as a single. But now she said she can appreciate the song better.
There are two recorded versions of Red Dress. I know I had to buy the Mutya CD version online somewhere years ago...that recorded version sounded better with her.
I think I'm more shocked they did this than 2 Hearts... Thought Mutya hated it dunt she?! I don't tho 🫶 And as much as i stanned Heidi ... This is the ultimate version! Swapping Mutya/Amelle lead for Siobhan on 2nd chorus feels like one of those "shudda always been" moments
No need to compare these two sugababes ladies. Heidi was fantastic in her own way in the group! Not to sound shady but the band took off when Heidi joined. There was something extremely magical with line up 2 .
Emotionally ... 2.0 always Realistically, musically and commercially ...1.0 obvs ...I'm praying they'll settle some beef one day and we'll see 5.0: MKSH
You would be surprised the amount of artists that record songs they don't like and even albums they can't stand. They had several songs over the years they didn't like, even ones they wrote lyrics for.
Fantastic sound. I like the switch up. Nice to see siobhans take on it but my heart will always be with lineup 2.0. But looking forward to seeing them live this year!
How wrong is this?! Sing new songs!!! What is the ginger one doing there, singing red dress ?! Songs like Push the button, round round, red dress, etc are immediately associated with Heidi. It’s just stupid to be honest!! If you want to sing legacy, sing overload for example … ridiculous!!! Bring back Heidi
They are the originals. Heidi isn’t part of this. They can sing what they like. You’re in the minority. Heidi was only ever a place-holder/replacement. They sing a mixture of new and old songs which is what people want.
@@anglodoomer5995 hahaha ok that was my opinion lol but they did need a pretty white girl with a high voice with the added bonus of being more approachable and smiley
So I guess Mutya and Keisha being on ALL of those songs don't matter? They aren't allowed to sing their own songs without Heidi? Yet Heidi was happy to the same songs with Jade and Amelle, songs only she was on, and that was ok? It was ok for Keisha and Heidi to sing songs they originally did with Mutya with Amelle? but Mutya and Keisha can't sing them without Heidi? None of those songs are associated with just Heidi, they are associated with Mutya and Keisha also, their songs, they can perform them with whoever they want and let's be honest here, Siobhan is putting her own spin on them, they sound fresh with her and better live than Heidi ever was.
The Mutya's version was always the best, Siobhan is doing an amazing job with just every song, this is however a Keisha song, always been. She owns it.
I’ve seen them and they are amazing live. No fancy sets, no dancers or huge displays. Just the three of them belting out great live vocals
Siobhan voice is quite similar to Heidi's. Siobhan a stronger singer but Heidi has a nice tone to hers.
They definitely both were the key voices with the Harmonies. I really would love to see them do a re record of their best Hits with Siobhan vocals on a studio album. Heidi will always be the main singer and Amelle on some of their huge hits.. and the official videos will always reflect that
It would be interesting to see some new re recordings with Siobhan on some of these big Heidi and Amelle era songs.. with Mutya and Siobhan doing their versions.
This song has been redeemed for me. I loved the original instantly and I hoped Mutya would do the video before she left.. guttered she didn't but this fixes it with Siobhan added its perfection.
I agree that Mutya's version sounded better.
The originals are the best ever !!!!! Siobhán sounds great on this song too ❤
UK, you have no idea how I envy you folks right now! They need to be known worldwide so I can see them here in Canada!
@White Patterns answer me this.... where are they touring right now?
The OGs need to re-record all of their hits with this line up
I’d definitely buy all the releases.
Hella yes
Absolutely
They all look and sound unbelievable. Especially Mutya - I'm loving this look!
yes yes yes !! finally they're doing red dress!! I thought they'd banished it. thankfully not!! love seeing Siobhan and mutya in this. keep it up. they sound great 🎉
I thought Mutya was on the song originally.
@@jaywest3734 Mutya was on the track but had never sung it live before this tour
@@jaywest3734 She was on the original but she didn’t like the song at the time and even mentioned how she appreciated that they waited until she was gone to release it as a single. But now she said she can appreciate the song better.
There are two recorded versions of Red Dress. I know I had to buy the Mutya CD version online somewhere years ago...that recorded version sounded better with her.
Song is much better with Amele and Heidi,but i like it with Mutya and Siobhan too
The best version of this song by far. I love how they switched it up and the dance routine is ace.
i bet Siobhan herself is amazed by the reactions of the crowd ,when she sings Heidi s parts...
Mutya is a living legend. Period
THE HARMONIEEEESSSS 1:55 😍😍😍
Red Dress really used to be one of my favorites, didn't think I'd ever hear another version of it 🫶
Gutted - I had standing tickets for this but then needed knee surgery and couldn't go. Next time!
Waauw Siobhan sings way better than Heidi. I always felt she tends to hold back.
Thanks for filming and uploading. Saw them the other night in Cardiff but couldn't get this close!
i wished they did the outro to.
'so dont call me baby, cooler than the red dress, i'm giving it up, dont call me baby'
Love this song
ok i need a live album now just for this 🙏
I think I'm more shocked they did this than 2 Hearts... Thought Mutya hated it dunt she?!
I don't tho 🫶
And as much as i stanned Heidi ... This is the ultimate version!
Swapping Mutya/Amelle lead for Siobhan on 2nd chorus feels like one of those "shudda always been" moments
Right? I would never expect to see not only Mutya but Siobhan singing this song. I thought it was as banished as late stuff from Catfights and Sweet 7
Love uuuuuu
Heck, I’d thought they only do One Touch tracks. Not tracks from later… but I’m FAR from mad!
Is this the original formation? ❤
Yes :)
❤
mutya
They sound great. Siobhan sounded like Heidi a lot.
… but better ;)
@@unidan82 The scream I screamed.
Sometimes sound Siobhan like Heidi but not better
@@unidan82 Oh Dan 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Best song in female group is Round round
Siobhan just brings a cool factor that Heidi could never ….
She's a better singer.
No need to compare these two sugababes ladies. Heidi was fantastic in her own way in the group! Not to sound shady but the band took off when Heidi joined. There was something extremely magical with line up 2 .
@@loveandpeace_totheworld The group "took off" when Heidi joined because of the change in sound, nothing more nothing less.
@@loveandpeace_totheworld This is rich coming from you when you trolled every sugababes video with heidi and Siobhan comments lol
Emotionally ... 2.0 always
Realistically, musically and commercially ...1.0 obvs
...I'm praying they'll settle some beef one day and we'll see 5.0: MKSH
I never thought they'd sing this this since Mutya and Keisha dont like the song at all they said 2 years ago
They’ve decided they love it now :)
Haha
You would be surprised the amount of artists that record songs they don't like and even albums they can't stand.
They had several songs over the years they didn't like, even ones they wrote lyrics for.
Fantastic sound. I like the switch up. Nice to see siobhans take on it but my heart will always be with lineup 2.0. But looking forward to seeing them live this year!
I am a fan of the sugababes however, this line up singing the songs that only heidi and keshia were part of just annoys me
Did it annoy you when Amelle, Heidi and Jade sang songs that only 1 of them was on? Just using your philosophy..
How wrong is this?! Sing new songs!!! What is the ginger one doing there, singing red dress ?! Songs like Push the button, round round, red dress, etc are immediately associated with Heidi. It’s just stupid to be honest!! If you want to sing legacy, sing overload for example … ridiculous!!! Bring back Heidi
They are the originals. Heidi isn’t part of this. They can sing what they like. You’re in the minority. Heidi was only ever a place-holder/replacement. They sing a mixture of new and old songs which is what people want.
@@unidan82 "place-holder/replacement" citation needed
@@anglodoomer5995 hahaha ok that was my opinion lol but they did need a pretty white girl with a high voice with the added bonus of being more approachable and smiley
So I guess Mutya and Keisha being on ALL of those songs don't matter? They aren't allowed to sing their own songs without Heidi? Yet Heidi was happy to the same songs with Jade and Amelle, songs only she was on, and that was ok? It was ok for Keisha and Heidi to sing songs they originally did with Mutya with Amelle? but Mutya and Keisha can't sing them without Heidi?
None of those songs are associated with just Heidi, they are associated with Mutya and Keisha also, their songs, they can perform them with whoever they want and let's be honest here, Siobhan is putting her own spin on them, they sound fresh with her and better live than Heidi ever was.
Siobhan never replace Heidi,she was the best,but i like Siobhan singing Heidi s part too