Could A Single Modern LHA & Cruiser Have Won The Battle Of The Coral Sea? (Naval Battle 99) | DCS

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 187

  • @lohrtom
    @lohrtom Рік тому +73

    Cap, carrier would not turn around to get you. During flight ops , a destroyer or frigate trails the ship by a mile. It’s called plane guard, it’s their ship to pick up pilots from botched landings or takeoffs. The pilots also like it because it also serves as a distance from carrier marker.

    • @grimreapers
      @grimreapers  Рік тому +15

      thx

    • @Max_Griswald
      @Max_Griswald Рік тому +4

      It's too bad we saved taxpayer money by not having a destroyer or frigate in the carrier group. Sorry Cap!

    • @cojones8518
      @cojones8518 Рік тому +9

      And the ship that picks you up demands a ransom before the pilot is returned. Usually paid in ice cream.

    • @TheAmbex
      @TheAmbex 11 місяців тому +1

      ​@@cojones8518I can get behind this tradition 😅

  • @thalo215
    @thalo215 Рік тому +35

    Nicely done Brandon. Had it over a year and not flown it once yet. Great video.

  • @FlameHawke
    @FlameHawke Рік тому +17

    That was amazingly disciplined, and highlights the process where there's one pass b/c a second would be suicide. Well done, and excellent landing on Brandon's part

  • @jrizos06
    @jrizos06 Рік тому +13

    Great flying Brandon! We'll have to welcome him into the show favorites of the people's champ and Grump

  • @CzechTex
    @CzechTex Рік тому +2

    Commenting because the ONE TIME I skip a briefing, you rebrief the crew in game.
    Bless you, Cap.

  • @Maverick0451
    @Maverick0451 Рік тому +7

    Hell yeah!! This one was really fun!! Hits right in the feels too, I was in the Corps and served on an LHA, the USS Nassau. She had Harriers at the time as well because this was 2005-2006. Great flying as always Grim Reapers!!! Hats off to the Flying Dutchman on this one!!! Got into a new aircraft and stuck the landing on the first go!!!

  • @manjisaipoe517
    @manjisaipoe517 Рік тому +23

    Brandon, very impressive display in a new to you aircraft! Thanks for the fun Cap, and all the Reapers on this mission. I really enjoy seeing the older aircraft being used in these ways. Peace.

    • @_Brand0n
      @_Brand0n Рік тому +5

      Thanks for the comment! Its indeed always fun when Cap is recording! I was late so i didn't know what the plan was so bought the plane while Cap was briefing us and learned it mid flight :)

  • @jordannewsom4578
    @jordannewsom4578 Рік тому +25

    Awesome video as always guys, I just absolutely freaking LOVE these naval battles, please keep doing them!! Idk if y’all have already done this but here’s an idea if you haven’t, how about a single modern carrier takes on the Japanese fleet at the battle of Layte Gulf?? Or a modern Iowa class battleship maybe going up against the Yamamoto? Might have already done that one I think, can’t remember tbh. Please keep up the great videos!!

    • @grimreapers
      @grimreapers  Рік тому +7

      It was such a large battle, it's gunna be hard to get to grips with.

    • @ChadEh
      @ChadEh Рік тому +2

      😊

  • @lightningwingdragon973
    @lightningwingdragon973 Рік тому +45

    A single modern US destroyer (or frigate) at the Battle off Samar

    • @javierarceo1973
      @javierarceo1973 Рік тому +3

      THIS PLEASE!

    • @Benevolent_Fafnir
      @Benevolent_Fafnir Рік тому +1

      I don’t think the US currently has any frigates in service do they? Only LCSs… The Constellation frigates won’t be in service until 2026.

    • @kentgoldings
      @kentgoldings Рік тому +4

      The DCS ship AI is just good enough to make interesting targets. The kind of audacity that psyched-out the Japanese into withdrawal off Samar really isn’t programmed into the simulation. If you replayed the Battle off Samar in DCS, the Japanese would roll over the Taffys.

    • @spartenkiller456
      @spartenkiller456 Рік тому +1

      ​@@kentgoldingsIn hindsight, we already knew that. The Japanese saw how hard the US was fighting against insurmountable odds and wondered what sort of reinforcements they had just out of sight. But you're right, that sort of speculation is beyond the scope of the simulation.

    • @kentgoldings
      @kentgoldings Рік тому +2

      @@spartenkiller456 I think the Japanese saw a bunch of destroyers, escorts, and Jeep carriers and imagined they were looking at Battleships, cruisers, and fleet carriers.

  • @1984Phalanx
    @1984Phalanx Рік тому +12

    Could a modern us carrier win the battle of hastings?

  • @ryanerickson8138
    @ryanerickson8138 Рік тому +7

    Well done adding an interesting wrinkle to the war game by using Harrier over F-35.

  • @travisleemusictx
    @travisleemusictx Рік тому +2

    Fun fact: Lexington was never sunk, Japan just kept *thinking* they sunk it, and then it would be back attacking them later. It's a museum ship now, i drive right by it every day.

    • @haroldbenton979
      @haroldbenton979 Рік тому

      The CV2, the first Lexington, was sunk it was her sister, the Saratoga CV3 that kept coming back for more after getting torpedo hits. However the one that they declared sunk and would keep turning up time and again was Enterprise. She literally was the only carrier in combat for a bit after we lost the Wasp and Hornet after the Saratoga took yet another torpedo.

    • @travisleemusictx
      @travisleemusictx Рік тому +1

      @haroldbenton979 you know what, you're right. The Lexington I know was almost finished with construction when that Lex sunk, and they changed her name to Lexington last minute before launch to commemorate it, thus the dates are so close together it's easy to get the Coral Sea Lex and THIS Lex mixed up.

    • @travisleemusictx
      @travisleemusictx Рік тому

      @haroldbenton979 still true about the CV-16 Lex being declared defeated by Japan multiple times though, they started calling it the Blue Ghost. Badass ship.

  • @theserpent4495
    @theserpent4495 Рік тому +5

    Love the fact you’re using harriers, please use more official modules!

  • @davidguest3506
    @davidguest3506 Рік тому +6

    Very cool. I had the pleasure of working on the America just recently. Interesting ship all things considered however already outdated being made of reused parts. Hope to see new Wasp class ships entering service with the ability to provide air and amphibious support.

    • @Wolfe351
      @Wolfe351 Рік тому

      what's reused on it?? Building a 1/72 RC LHA2 Saipan.....amongest other models.....

  • @jyralnadreth4442
    @jyralnadreth4442 Рік тому +3

    1990s Royal Navy carriers with Harriers vs IJN Pearl Harbour. I think that would be a very interesting fight with Sea Harriers tangling with Zeros with RAF Harriers pounding ships.

  • @nigeldepledge3790
    @nigeldepledge3790 Рік тому +2

    I think I know what Cap's problem was with landing the Harrier when low on fuel.
    Cap, you needed a Spanish freighter to set down on. That's always the way when you're low on fuel in a Harrier.

  • @snap4921
    @snap4921 Рік тому +2

    Matrix. Great info as always. Great to have someone who been there done that around.

  • @IetsgoBrandon
    @IetsgoBrandon Рік тому +8

    I really appreciate your naval battle. Looking forward to see more🥰

  • @deepat
    @deepat Рік тому +2

    Love hearing you talk about realism in a completely fictional fight, in a game.

  • @anathardayaldar
    @anathardayaldar Рік тому +3

    I thought IJN didn't have radar. So stealth planes are unnecessary.

  • @steveturner3999
    @steveturner3999 Рік тому +1

    ‘’Matrix, how are you still alive?’’ Clean living Cap. Clean living.

  • @adamedwards1937
    @adamedwards1937 Рік тому +3

    These battles remind me of John Birmingham's World War 2.0 book series

  • @lohrtom
    @lohrtom Рік тому +10

    Let’s go Brandon!

  • @Politicaloverwatch
    @Politicaloverwatch Рік тому +2

    @ 36:00 😂😂😂😂 llets geaux brandon

  • @Sam-li9fx
    @Sam-li9fx Рік тому +3

    French carrier strike group vs Russian carrier strike group?

  • @fedster187
    @fedster187 Рік тому +4

    id love to see you do the Dance of the vampires chapter from tom Clancy's book red storm rising

  • @RogueWraith909
    @RogueWraith909 Рік тому +2

    Beautifully done Brandon! Beautifully done!

  • @rosiehawtrey
    @rosiehawtrey Рік тому +3

    Doing great. I can thoroughly not recommend having cancer necrosis... These very interesting, Moskva getting a kicking especially..

  • @TimperialBroadcastingAgency
    @TimperialBroadcastingAgency Рік тому +1

    Could you imagine being on that simulated IJN fleet? You're prepped for action, the strike force is away, then you get the action warning once the radars have picked up all six (!) incoming fighters. Obviously a recon element; that's an impossibly weak strike force. You can only barely see the alien-looking planes and can barely hear them. They start orbiting at the extreme range of your big guns, but no one is going to waste time on throwing flak through the 120mm dual-purpose cannon for single aircraft, especially when there's already a CAP going.
    Then, suddenly, one after the other in the span of a few minutes, all those carriers you're escorting explode as single quadruple-weight bombs blow giant holes in them amidships. The entire Fifth Carrier Division, bloop, gone.
    And the fighters leave after chucking a couple more bombs for good measure, and because that cruiser over there clearly offended their sensibilities or something. No frenetic close-in shooting, no forest of salt-spray pillars from dozens of misses, just... some tense moments waiting, a quick metaphorical punch to the face, and over.

  • @maximusdecimusgames
    @maximusdecimusgames Рік тому

    I dont always watch the battle scenario/details, but when I do it's bc I fell asleep watching the Playlist.

  • @onnokis5596
    @onnokis5596 Рік тому +2

    Modern Submarine vs ww2 submarine u-boat

  • @Plastikdoom
    @Plastikdoom Рік тому +2

    Ahh yes, the silly, but lovable lawn dart.

  • @svenskdod
    @svenskdod Рік тому +3

    "Only when we all follow orders perfectly can we complete the mission".... he says when the SAM alley mission was a complete cluster... 😂

  • @Pablo668
    @Pablo668 Рік тому +2

    Nice work Cap! The Harrier is the only aircraft I have in this game.

  • @paulheitkemper1559
    @paulheitkemper1559 Рік тому +3

    The other point about not splitting the Japanese fleet is that they can provide mutual support. If you split them then you just defeat them in detail.

  • @joeltmo
    @joeltmo Рік тому +1

    Awesome. Really enjoy your missions. cant wait for the next pvp campaign episode to drop

  • @Jordanpgates1
    @Jordanpgates1 Рік тому +1

    Looks like Cap was in God mode again which made this a top-notch video! Fantastic job shifting from plane to plane!

  • @jamison884
    @jamison884 Рік тому +3

    Hey Cap, can we put a peantly on your Dutchman? A Max Verstappen dominance penalty. That would make some of us feel a little better.

  • @iamscoutstfu
    @iamscoutstfu Рік тому +1

    Ok, time to request a scenario.
    I request an alternate us carrier group vs CCP carrier group.
    Instead of 1 supercarrier, id like to see 2-3 LHAs with 4-5 A.Burks and, if possible, Frem frigates.
    I have a theory that multiple light carriers might be a superior model to one single super carrier. It should be more resilient to losses, be able to match the super carrier launch rate, and have a higher rearm-refuel-relaunch rate overall compared to a single super carrier.

  • @isaiahwelch8066
    @isaiahwelch8066 Рік тому +1

    Cap, have an idea for you! In the 1980s, an F-15E piloted by an Israeli pilot collided with an A-6 Avenger, and lost a wing. But rather than go dowm, the pilot basically ignited afterburners, and landed the plane at twice landing speed, and managed to stop with 15 feet of runway left. Think you or your boys could do the same thing, and succeed like the Israeli pilot did?
    The second scenario is that of an A-10 that got hit by an RPG-7 in Eastern Baghdad in 2005. The pilot, "KC" Campbell, managed to fly 90 minutes back to base, on purely mechanical control, and with only one engine. Again, think you or your boys could succeed flying an injured A-10 on only one engine, and no hydraulics?

  • @soccernflying5709
    @soccernflying5709 Рік тому

    Matrix: 25:56 “Thank you, may I have another!” LOL 😂😂

  • @mavrikmavrik3032
    @mavrikmavrik3032 Рік тому +1

    Fun video, I would have loved to see the full end of the battle to see what happens. I don’t mind the longer vids as I watch/listen while I work so I have the time to listen.

  • @MrEricErwin
    @MrEricErwin Рік тому +1

    I don't see that boat turning around for you capt.

  • @JohnDoe_75
    @JohnDoe_75 Рік тому

    The "WOW" clip is from a Belgian folk figure called "Eddy Wally" who was quite a figure, old people liked his stuff but he was a bit of a joke to the rest of the country. He passed away in 2016.

  • @davewarrender2056
    @davewarrender2056 Рік тому

    Ffs , your flying harriers , let the plane get closer , jam on the air brake , vector thrust nozzle forward to also change height , planes go over the top you , light it up with cannon fire. This is wat made these planes so good

  • @gustavakerfelt6691
    @gustavakerfelt6691 Рік тому +1

    Fantastic job guys, well done.

  • @dannycostello
    @dannycostello Рік тому +1

    Imagine if they fully integrated VR into this game

  • @randalljones4370
    @randalljones4370 Рік тому +1

    Yelling out 'Sparkle' while strapped to a Hairier ... hm ... sounds like Cap's angling for the lead singer role in Judas Priest**.
    But of course, that's GR.
    .... now, transiting with the flaps down ... that's GR perfection !!

  • @corvanphoenix
    @corvanphoenix 3 місяці тому

    Great show guys, ty.

  • @Hot1765
    @Hot1765 Рік тому +1

    Really good laser and landings👌..cap start swimming

  • @kenhelmers2603
    @kenhelmers2603 Рік тому +1

    Fun excersize :)

  • @THeBoZZHoGG
    @THeBoZZHoGG Рік тому +1

    would be nice to see an actual recreation of this actual battle

  • @jonathantoymaker
    @jonathantoymaker Рік тому +3

    How about a NATO fleet vs Poseidon......

  • @jmtpolitico80
    @jmtpolitico80 Рік тому +2

    Good job guy's! Specially Brandon!😉

  • @mirvjournal1693
    @mirvjournal1693 Рік тому

    " I don't want my poorly maintained aircraft to blow up."

  • @drrocketman7794
    @drrocketman7794 Рік тому

    I'm surprised that the old propeller driven planes with the Mk. I eyeball radar and 7.7mm machine guns are actually a serious threat to a modern military aircraft.

  • @mrdee734
    @mrdee734 Рік тому +1

    Simba GALORES!

  • @hmmjedi
    @hmmjedi Рік тому

    Just a quick note CAP out in the mid-ocean the shark I would be afraid of most is the Oceanic White Tip even Jacques Cousteau called it the most dangerous of all sharks... The Whitetip is also thought to be the shark most responsible for the death of sailors from the USS Indianapolis and near South Africa, it's a global warm water shark, RMS Nova Scotia was sunk by a uboat and many of the deaths where attributed to the Whitetip... but great video by you all...

  • @scottclark7592
    @scottclark7592 6 місяців тому

    when they were landing it reminded me of the old lunar landing video game from the 80s

  • @timblack6422
    @timblack6422 Рік тому +1

    Well done!

  • @TexasCat99
    @TexasCat99 Рік тому

    Should of kept the 5 mine sweepers, 2 mine layers, 3 gunboats, oiler, 12 transports ships of the Japanese to make the work harder in terms of targeting.

  • @Kaelland
    @Kaelland Рік тому +1

    Technically, the US Navy did operate the AV-8B Harrier II, but not operationally. VX-9 and VX-31 both operated the Harrier II, but both of those are test and evaluation squadrons.
    As far as the Marines go, VMA-214 retired the Harrier II in 2022. VMA-231 is still using the Harrier II, and they're not set to retire those aircraft until 2026. VMA-223 is set to keep their Harrier IIs in service until 2027.

  • @clangerbasher
    @clangerbasher Рік тому +2

    A LHA in 'sea control' role could have up to 20 Harriers.

  • @dexlab7539
    @dexlab7539 Рік тому +1

    WOW Brandon -Well Done! 😊

  • @timbaskett6299
    @timbaskett6299 11 місяців тому

    I have an idea for a bit of a fun video. Could the Grim Reapers crew land warbirds on a LHA/LHD? Pegasus.....the next best thing to a Merlin!!! I wish I could show you my design for the "AV-24". It is about the size of a Harrier, with twin vertical stabilizers on two fuselage extentions, and the rotating main nozzle like the F-35B, but the forward nozzles like the Harrier, and a reduced observability/planform design like a Gen 5 aircraft. I "designed" it when the F-35B was first announced, and I personally hated the thought of losing the Harrier's profile in the air.

  • @michaelperrin2531
    @michaelperrin2531 Рік тому +2

    Good landing Brandon

  • @bigmull
    @bigmull Рік тому +2

    I wonder how the Harriers would fare againdt the Bismark?

    • @LatitudeSky
      @LatitudeSky Рік тому

      The LongTom gun would take them ou -oh wait, wrong Bismark. Don't mind me.

  • @CrystalKingdomGeneral4942
    @CrystalKingdomGeneral4942 Рік тому

    Fun fact: in spite of the USN getting hurt more than the IJN, the USN still won in a strategic sense; as the Japanese expansion into the South Pacific near Australia was stemmed, if only temporarily. Also, it put 3 IJN carriers out of action (1 permanently, 2 until Guadalcanal).

  • @5Andysalive
    @5Andysalive Рік тому +1

    The bombs even have an iron sight on top.

  • @daniellee5192
    @daniellee5192 Рік тому

    I enjoyed that immensely. Note every mistake cost you an aircraft.

  • @luxordeathbed
    @luxordeathbed Рік тому +4

    Can't wait to see a modernized battleship scenarios in the future. Whenever it happens.

  • @quantumcomata105
    @quantumcomata105 Рік тому +1

    Valued viewer reporting! Let's have it Valued Narrator & Narringtons!

  • @DavidWilliams-ig5ec
    @DavidWilliams-ig5ec Рік тому

    If fought today, subs would sink the carriers before they even had a chance to launch their first aircraft.
    The air wing would then mop up.

    • @Briselance
      @Briselance Рік тому

      Subs aren't invincible. They can be detected in advance, and sunk.

  • @mustang1912
    @mustang1912 Рік тому +1

    Game vastly overrates the number of working missiles, the accuracy of cannon and the turn rate of jets with airframe stress.

  • @tom23rd
    @tom23rd Рік тому

    I have to push back: maybe people skip the briefing, but I love the briefing. Context is important, and so is knowing the intent. Especially before railing on people in the comments. You best not stop doing them damn it. 😅❤

  • @Stricker-ng7fv
    @Stricker-ng7fv Рік тому +1

    Lha will have helicopters and f35s as well?

  • @gotafarmyet4691
    @gotafarmyet4691 Рік тому +1

    Wait, What, Everything went right how is this a Grim Reapers Video?
    The one advantage that is not programmable is that the guys going back would have information on the areas the enemy would be going after and simply position themselves to avoid those areas. Also with the normal assets that would have been there, still sending in their forces as decoys would make it even easier.

  • @TheWeirdLateNightPodcast
    @TheWeirdLateNightPodcast Рік тому

    Hey Cap, I was just wondering if that losses gui may be available to download (the red losses, blue losses) thing

  • @AEFisch
    @AEFisch Рік тому +1

    And why exactly are you using GBU to bomb a ship instead of Harpoons? The zero's wouldn't even see you

  • @Algux
    @Algux Рік тому +1

    The Answer is no, despite your previous game play. The enemy is never stupid. They would not make it easy for you and they did in that last video. Also one enemy sub would have scuppered your previous battle. Now a single modern carrier with accompanying ships is different. That would be an easy win. Great Video btw.

    • @Briselance
      @Briselance Рік тому +1

      The enemy would not be stupid. But they would still be outgunned. It could have done the trick, I think.

  • @wilbie247
    @wilbie247 Рік тому

    Can you create modern carrier fleet against the royal navy from the Middle Ages.

  • @krazykreaper504
    @krazykreaper504 Рік тому

    It'd be interesting to see if a modern Japanese LHA could take on the US/Australian force, given the focus the modern Japanese self-defence forces are placing on them.

  • @thebatt6183
    @thebatt6183 Рік тому

    No mercy in this game

  • @werecatpodguski
    @werecatpodguski Рік тому +2

    Cap has scratch one flat top!

  • @Dirtyharry70585
    @Dirtyharry70585 Рік тому

    Maybe load 4 Harrys with external gun pods and the new smart rockets. For other’s defense

  • @deadmeat8754
    @deadmeat8754 Рік тому

    "Cap you idiot!", AV-8B Harrier II will be retired by 2025 as an active fleet aircraft. They were previously intended to serve as long as 2030 and were refreshed accordingly, but plans change with budget considerations. The F-35B in Beast Mode with the multi-function gun pod should have been used. There also should have been more Blue force aircraft as the LHA America would be expected to serve as a "Lightning Carrier" in an actual conflict. I'm assuming the Bots couldn't be equipped with the Harrier II?

  • @ArchAngel-FJB
    @ArchAngel-FJB Рік тому +9

    Let's Go Brandon💪

  • @Wolfe351
    @Wolfe351 Рік тому

    is there a link for the LHA mod?? It looks a little to blue for the hull colouration should be same grey as the Tico

  • @matthewgordon-clark2392
    @matthewgordon-clark2392 Рік тому

    Do you think a 2023 RAAf and USMC deployment to Darwin could stop a 1942 IJN attack on Darwin?

  • @kurtreichenbach8927
    @kurtreichenbach8927 Рік тому +5

    Lets Go Brandon!!!!! RB

  • @erikerice9068
    @erikerice9068 Рік тому +2

    Grupnik has not been around for while, why is this?🤔

    • @grimreapers
      @grimreapers  Рік тому +1

      He's having some health problems, fingers crossed things calm down for him.

    • @erikerice9068
      @erikerice9068 Рік тому

      @@grimreapers my apologies, I hope he gets better

  • @robertnijkamp2051
    @robertnijkamp2051 Рік тому

    I've a question could a modern day abdcon fleet win against the japanese in the battle of the Java sea. with the correct helicopters on board

  • @chriscroumbie-brown6914
    @chriscroumbie-brown6914 Рік тому +1

    The GR's can take off without a Crash??? What's going on with the World !

  • @matthewjackson5325
    @matthewjackson5325 Рік тому

    how do we get the script for the $ tracking. we are trying to write our own and struggling. any info is helpful thanks.

  • @WreckedRover
    @WreckedRover Рік тому

    You guys should lisp when you say sparkle.

  • @yuriyantropov2004
    @yuriyantropov2004 Рік тому +1

    Can you tell me how to make the same loss statistics in the right-hand corner as in the video? Is this a custom mod, or can it be downloaded somewhere?

  • @chuckhighlights5544
    @chuckhighlights5544 Рік тому

    Can we creat aircraft. Two seater new. Rear fireing teret. Missils and gunner. Fighter bomber

  • @mrhedgebull1658
    @mrhedgebull1658 Рік тому

    Just a thought Cap, given how well the bombs worked and how much redundancy there was with them, would it have been worth using a couple of the Harriers for providing air cover and hopefully prolonging the time over the enemy fleet to take out some more of the cruisers as well?

    • @grimreapers
      @grimreapers  Рік тому +1

      Agreed. We figured we would miss most of the bombs, hence the redundancy.

    • @mrhedgebull1658
      @mrhedgebull1658 Рік тому

      @@grimreapers Possibly retry with a couple of planes on air cover to see how much damage could be inflicted?

  • @amargen
    @amargen 6 місяців тому

    no gun pods?

  • @trev8591
    @trev8591 Рік тому +1

    Brilliant, chaps! Brandon the new People's Hero?