I really like his frock coat. I'm puzzled by the discolored material near the front buttons on both sides. Perhaps it's just the wear and tear from opening and closing the coat.
I'm curious of your opinion of Shelby Foote? He seems incredibly knowledgeable but I strongly disapprove of his lack of footnotes and bibliography in The Civil War: A Narrative. Not sure how I feel about him as a historian, but in interviews he seems to be a genuine and kind man with a deep respect for history.
During the Civil War, those medical practitioners up on such things would call it "Da Costa's Syndrome" or "Soldier's Heart," during WW1 those who avoided the ignorance of calling it cowardliness would call it "Shell Shock" and during WW2, people (other than Patton) would call it "Battle Fatigue," whereas today we call it "PTSD." A shell bursting nearby should be expected to give Colonel Tinkham "Shell Shock," both physically and mentally.
Please show me where in the Constitution of the United States that it is forbidden to withdraw from that agreement and also show me where another country that is not a part of the United States can commit treason against the United States and the Constitution of the United States. I know you will not answer that because it points out some uncomfortable truths, like invading a foreign country and when the citizens of that country fight to kick you out. The first thing you do is call them insurgents in their own country. Priceless. Yep surging inside their own country from over the borders of their own country while never leaving their own country. The same thing as calling Southerners Rebels. You can't rebel against an invading army in your own country, not part of the Constitution of the United States; but the North has been known for rationalizations and hysterical rhetoric such as with Salem witch trials. The Vampire scare of the 1800s, several werewolf sightings and the recent drone hoopla and UFO/UAP sightings which were mostly commercial aircraft. The people of the North make up crap and run with it and then tell yourselves for generations your own lies as truths.
Missouri never had chance to vote to leave or stay in Union , The Gov of Missouri only called out the state miltiia to keep order until a vote could take place , No Different then other States some voting yes and some voting no ! General Lyons decided to invade without orders ( Gen. Lyons is worst moral person to wear US Uniform) . The Gov. tried to get Gen Lyons to stop but he wouldn't and hence why the Gov. and state Militia had no choice to side with the south and hence why south decided to make move on Kentucky . a Illinois regiment invades a another state state !? So in today world since Chicago is out of control and having no laws , I wonder how people Illinois would like it if State of Missouri sent the Militia to Chicago and rest of Illinois , as quote says rebellion and Traitors Illinois today fits the bill ! When something is done it can;t be undone or expect it not to comeback on you !
We had difficulty understanding your post but I think I get the meaning of it and I agree. I think if you proof read your commentary and correct it , you might find that more people would as well.
During Bleeding Kansas time the Missoury proslavery groups went to Kansas to commit election fraud. Proslavery people were free to commit election fraud. Kansas became free state in 1861 and a local Civil War became untill 1865 at the Kansas-Missouri border bedide this there was a the Little Dixie local proconfederate guerilla war, BTW Little Dixie was the highest slavery populate area in the Missouri. Instead of election fraud it would have been peacful cohabitation between the free system Kansas and the slave system Missouri.................. Pro US soldier is forbidden to transfer weapons from US Army armory to remain in federal hands in Illinois. Incidentally, Lyon's superior was removed, he hesitated, but he was not a traitor, he remained in federal service. Perhaps you are confused by Fremont's failure to carry out his orders. Fremont, his next leader, requested that Lyon retreat to the railroad terminus at Rola, so that he could retake Springfield with an army of up to 30,000 reinforcements. This was eventually done. BTW It would be the 26th Illinois infantry rehgiment got muskets from weapons saved by Lyon?
@@charlesbelser7249 I understood the post completely. The sum of it is that another state without jurisdiction has jurisdiction in another state or territory to call them traitors and move to suppress that other state or territory. The parallel of today's political climate of states and cities ignoring US Supreme Court ruling and Federal law. Now wouldn't they be considered Sedition, Insurrectionists or Treasonous. There was no treason on the Souths part since they succeeded from the agreement that is known as the Constitution of the United States. So the Treason clause does not apply and there is no clause in the Constitution of the United States that states cannot withdraw from that agreement and is forbidden to do so, nor is there a clause that states that those who are part of the country should be burnt to the ground. The Whiskey Rebellion was an actual rebellion of citizens in the Northern states who were part of the United States. The Confederacy was a foreign country. See the point.
Being a detail oriented history buff, I like these kinds of stories.
I don’t think I know anything about Farmington. I’m going to look it up. Nice video.
Nor did I. Missouri was freaking WILD!
Thanks for another great story Ron it makes me wonder though if any one man or handful of men made it through all them battles alive? 🍀🍀🍀
Thank you a lot, Ron! Informative as usual!
I really like his frock coat.
I'm puzzled by the discolored material near the front buttons on both sides. Perhaps it's just the wear and tear from opening and closing the coat.
I'm curious of your opinion of Shelby Foote? He seems incredibly knowledgeable but I strongly disapprove of his lack of footnotes and bibliography in The Civil War: A Narrative. Not sure how I feel about him as a historian, but in interviews he seems to be a genuine and kind man with a deep respect for history.
Sounds like Tincum was pretty good at leading an orderly retreat. 😊
Homer Illinois, Birthplace of James Butler Hickok. Later he was known as Wild Bill ,also s Civil War Veteran .
So why did he resign? Was it related to his injury?
I have not yet been able to learn why he resigned. the search continues!
During the Civil War, those medical practitioners up on such things would call it "Da Costa's Syndrome" or "Soldier's Heart," during WW1 those who avoided the ignorance of calling it cowardliness would call it "Shell Shock" and during WW2, people (other than Patton) would call it "Battle Fatigue," whereas today we call it "PTSD." A shell bursting nearby should be expected to give Colonel Tinkham "Shell Shock," both physically and mentally.
Nice to hear about a real patriot who had no patience for traitors!
Please show me where in the Constitution of the United States that it is forbidden to withdraw from that agreement and also show me where another country that is not a part of the United States can commit treason against the United States and the Constitution of the United States. I know you will not answer that because it points out some uncomfortable truths, like invading a foreign country and when the citizens of that country fight to kick you out. The first thing you do is call them insurgents in their own country. Priceless. Yep surging inside their own country from over the borders of their own country while never leaving their own country. The same thing as calling Southerners Rebels. You can't rebel against an invading army in your own country, not part of the Constitution of the United States; but the North has been known for rationalizations and hysterical rhetoric such as with Salem witch trials. The Vampire scare of the 1800s, several werewolf sightings and the recent drone hoopla and UFO/UAP sightings which were mostly commercial aircraft. The people of the North make up crap and run with it and then tell yourselves for generations your own lies as truths.
Missouri never had chance to vote to leave or stay in Union , The Gov of Missouri only called out the state miltiia to keep order until a vote could take place , No Different then other States some voting yes and some voting no ! General Lyons decided to invade without orders ( Gen. Lyons is worst moral person to wear US Uniform) . The Gov. tried to get Gen Lyons to stop but he wouldn't and hence why the Gov. and state Militia had no choice to side with the south and hence why south decided to make move on Kentucky . a Illinois regiment invades a another state state !? So in today world since Chicago is out of control and having no laws , I wonder how people Illinois would like it if State of Missouri sent the Militia to Chicago and rest of Illinois , as quote says rebellion and Traitors Illinois today fits the bill ! When something is done it can;t be undone or expect it not to comeback on you !
We had difficulty understanding your post but I think I get the meaning of it and I agree. I think if you proof read your commentary and correct it , you might find that more people would as well.
During Bleeding Kansas time the Missoury proslavery groups went to Kansas to commit election fraud. Proslavery people were free to commit election fraud. Kansas became free state in 1861 and a local Civil War became untill 1865 at the Kansas-Missouri border bedide this there was a the Little Dixie local proconfederate guerilla war, BTW Little Dixie was the highest slavery populate area in the Missouri. Instead of election fraud it would have been peacful cohabitation between the free system Kansas and the slave system Missouri..................
Pro US soldier is forbidden to transfer weapons from US Army armory to remain in federal hands in Illinois. Incidentally, Lyon's superior was removed, he hesitated, but he was not a traitor, he remained in federal service.
Perhaps you are confused by Fremont's failure to carry out his orders. Fremont, his next leader, requested that Lyon retreat to the railroad terminus at Rola, so that he could retake Springfield with an army of up to 30,000 reinforcements. This was eventually done.
BTW It would be the 26th Illinois infantry rehgiment got muskets from weapons saved by Lyon?
@@charlesbelser7249 I understood the post completely. The sum of it is that another state without jurisdiction has jurisdiction in another state or territory to call them traitors and move to suppress that other state or territory. The parallel of today's political climate of states and cities ignoring US Supreme Court ruling and Federal law. Now wouldn't they be considered Sedition, Insurrectionists or Treasonous. There was no treason on the Souths part since they succeeded from the agreement that is known as the Constitution of the United States. So the Treason clause does not apply and there is no clause in the Constitution of the United States that states cannot withdraw from that agreement and is forbidden to do so, nor is there a clause that states that those who are part of the country should be burnt to the ground. The Whiskey Rebellion was an actual rebellion of citizens in the Northern states who were part of the United States. The Confederacy was a foreign country. See the point.
Tha heck is this all about ..?!? Sheesh …