Can I make my own Hornby 'Saint?' - What's On The Workbench? Ep.2

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
  • Since there is no decent 'Saint' on the RTR market, I decided to see what I could cobble together from a bunch of scraps and spares I had lying around (plus a few new bits). It's not perfect and I would definitely do some things differently but overall I am pleased with the result!
    Maybe this will encourage some of you to have a go?
    Images from Wikimedia Commons are used here under a Creative Commons (attribution) licence.
    Clip from 'Iron Man' is copyright of Disney.
    Home to the Railway Mania Podcast and the Sudrian Histories project, Railway Mania is a hub for railway enthusiast entertainment, including videos on real-life railways as well as modelling builds and tutorials.
    The Railway Mania Podcast is available to listen on all podcasting apps, as well as being hosted on the Railway Mania UA-cam channel. Often the video versions will include additional information and footage where possible.
    For anyone wishing to give it a go and browse the back catalogue, all episodes are available on the website, please check out the shop and see what merchandise might take your fancy:
    www.railwayman...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 105

  • @JM-oh4yi
    @JM-oh4yi Рік тому +12

    Very nice! The GWR using standardized components really helps out when kitbashing models.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      Oh yeah but it’s addictive! Every project seems to give me more spares to combine into another, and so on and so forth….

  • @theflyingkipper42
    @theflyingkipper42 Рік тому +8

    Great custom!

  • @davidsheriff8989
    @davidsheriff8989 Рік тому +6

    What a lot of work for perfection...hats off to you for this painstaking job....well done.

  • @Arkay315
    @Arkay315 Рік тому +5

    It looks quite magnificent, especially since it was made from spare parts.

  • @Slushiebop
    @Slushiebop Рік тому +1

    Honestly, this looks like a engine you could say was taken from an abandoned scrapyard, rebuilt and serves on a preserved line. I love it!

  • @musoseven8218
    @musoseven8218 Рік тому +1

    Nice work my friend a man after my own heart. I've had some successes and failures, it's how we learn👍✌️🙄😊

  • @johnjephcote7636
    @johnjephcote7636 11 місяців тому +1

    I made Saint Benedict (curved footplate) with the Bear's bogie tender (1935 photo evidence), in EM. I used the boiler, cab and part of the footplate from an ancient West Coast cast white metal kit but all the rest I built from scratch, the old way - cutting metal and soldering and referring to Jim Russel's 4mm GWR loco drawings.

  • @andrewclimo5709
    @andrewclimo5709 4 місяці тому

    Brilliant!! I have a half started Saint project myself. This has fired me up to get going with it again.

  • @ciaranburke3243
    @ciaranburke3243 Рік тому +1

    That's lovely, nice job 👌

  • @Steamer96
    @Steamer96 Рік тому +1

    Impressive!

  • @gregoirewolff
    @gregoirewolff Рік тому +1

    A-Maz-Ing.
    Cheers from Canada!

  • @Mookie1340
    @Mookie1340 Рік тому +1

    Well done. Great video.

  • @vectorbrony3473
    @vectorbrony3473 Рік тому +4

    I think you did a great job with this project. I did something similar turning a LBSCR E4 model from bachmann into a E3 which involved changing the wheels for smaller ones, modifying the front splashers and adjusting the coupling rods to fit romford wheels.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +3

      ooh that sounds like a great bit o'bashin'! Love it

  • @aryanmangar2001
    @aryanmangar2001 Рік тому +1

    Great job on this! Your videos are therapeutic to watch lol

  • @heaptoncollierymodelrailwa6011

    Quality stuff!
    Great video- I am amazed there isn’t a RTR model of one of these!

  • @clintockmaconaghie3763
    @clintockmaconaghie3763 Рік тому +1

    You have done so well. Great Project and an inspiration to many others

  • @lukeslocomotives
    @lukeslocomotives Рік тому +1

    Cool! It looks so much better than Hornby's take on the Saint!

  • @dibsyardshuntinglayout
    @dibsyardshuntinglayout Рік тому +1

    I think you have done an incredible job!

  • @dinmorejunctionmodelrailway
    @dinmorejunctionmodelrailway Рік тому +1

    A well presented video and congratulations with your end result.

  • @ajaxengineco
    @ajaxengineco Рік тому +3

    Those GBL models are great for slicing up to make better things out of. I don't think that, for the money, especially with all etched plates, that this is too bad a job at all - a thrifty utilisation of damaged models and plastic statics done right. I didn't notice the smokebox height until it was pointed out, I think you'll get away with it. Time to do the WCPR's 2-4-0T 'Clevedon', next? ;)

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      Mate I would love to do the old Dubs 'No.1 Clevedon'. Will have to think about what donor parts I could scavenge.....

  • @that-D.T.S.-bloke
    @that-D.T.S.-bloke Рік тому +1

    Nice model it actually looks like a official product

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      Thanks! Guarantee a manufacturer announces one now haha

  • @nigelgresley87546
    @nigelgresley87546 Рік тому +1

    I would’ve loved for the loco to be Lady Of Legend, but amazing work nonetheless!

  • @ewanfawkes2708
    @ewanfawkes2708 Рік тому

    Another Hall bites the dust!

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому

      hahaha I like to think this one was put to good use ;)

  • @DjAlLindsay
    @DjAlLindsay Рік тому +1

    Really nice looking model. As a fellow Clevedon resident, did you know the original name plates now reside in the entrance hall at Clevedon Court itself

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      I remember seeing them there whilst on a school trip many years ago!

  • @saltleywsc
    @saltleywsc Рік тому +1

    Superb job!..watch someone do a RTR one now !!!!

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      I cannot believe it hasn’t been announced yet!

  • @riklund691
    @riklund691 Рік тому

    Brilliant! Don't worry about the tender(ie 4000 as opposed to 3500gallon) you know that tenders were frequently changed between engines as a matter of course.)

  • @VestedUTuber
    @VestedUTuber Рік тому +1

    Just a bit of advice on the buffer beams next time, consider thinning your paints and using multiple coats instead of one thick coat. The paint looks a bit thick on those.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      Cheers, I did 2 coats but it needs another as there is still a bit of black showing through - it was done after the matt lacquer so it's overly shiny at the moment, both of those things are making it look a little untidy.

  • @thomasgray4188
    @thomasgray4188 Рік тому +1

    This is giving me ideas about building a Star class since the saint and star share a boiler. And while there are RTR stars available they are quite expensive for me still.
    Id also like to add that I've been mulling over purchasing a cheap toy train to convert into a model of the Hitachi alstom hs2 bid.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      Yeah I think that's a great idea. You could use the Castle chassis without having to chop much off as you'd be able to keep the 4-cylinder front end.

    • @thomasgray4188
      @thomasgray4188 Рік тому +1

      @@RailwayManiaNet but the a new cylinder block would be needed because the stars had slightly smaller cylinders and I would need to get the right frames on the castle donor.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      You might be able to file down the cylinder block slightly (it's only half an inch wider in radius as it's 1 inch bigger in diameter, unless you are doing original condition with the smaller cylinders)? I guess it depends which loco you want to represent due to the small detail differences.

  • @thesudricmerman3318
    @thesudricmerman3318 Рік тому +1

    amazing model i wouldn't have a clue how to make something like this

  • @profcraneporter
    @profcraneporter Рік тому

    GWR: The Saint is the ancestor of all our 4-6-0s
    Corwin: All the 4-6-0s are the ancestor of my Saint

  • @McAttack21574
    @McAttack21574 Рік тому +2

    Me here waiting for more sudrian histories updates, mainly focusing on recent model progress

  • @jerribee1
    @jerribee1 Рік тому +1

    Blimey. If you can do all this, I reckon you can probably do a scratch build.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      I find it difficult to make things up from raw materials, for me it's always easier to start with one object to try to turn into another.

  • @ExpressRhubarb
    @ExpressRhubarb Рік тому +1

    love the saints and stars so much. so glad we now have the Lady at Didcot
    reckon you'd ever attempt a saint in NWR blue for your sudrian histories project? Maybe Saint Pedroc? :P

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +3

      Me too! Saint Pedroc is a good one but I think I want to try some more of my own designs for the NWR..... although it'd look great in blue......

    • @SodorTrain1225
      @SodorTrain1225 Рік тому +2

      @@RailwayManiaNet St. Tibba, the founder of what would become Wellsworth Hospital, would work, too. Not to mention Sodor's patron saint, St. Luoc.

  • @newobanproductions999
    @newobanproductions999 Рік тому +1

    I have had plans on doing one of the Scotts (the Atlantic version of the Saints named after characters by Sir Walter Scott) out of the aforementioned Hornby Saint and converting it to loco drive which has been on the back burner since before the thing that begins with "P" began but had unable to due to how hard it is to get the Hornby Saint.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      Yeah to be honest mate I wouldn't even bother with it, you'd have to modify the running board anyway to have the drop-downs and it's dimensionally a bit squiffy. Honestly I think the Castle is a better starting point and they made loads of them. The next one I do will just (hopefully) use Castle and 2800 components without needing the Hall.

  • @austint918
    @austint918 Рік тому +1

    I’m American and would love to have a model of 2999 “lady of legend”. But I don’t think I have the skill set to do this plus getting the parts would be hard. I love George Jackson Churchwoods designs It’s just hard to get British models in America.

  • @Lnerfan1
    @Lnerfan1 Рік тому

    Gimme that model!!!! I'll turn it into Alled Greedy or 87546 and improve it!!! Gimmeeee!!!!

  • @georgethomas7814
    @georgethomas7814 Рік тому

    Wow you should be proud of that....

  • @upwellonwards7373
    @upwellonwards7373 Рік тому +1

    fantastic build mate love it but i wonder whats next a cathedral??

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +3

      Already got one haha! I might have a root around in the photo archives and see if I can put together a video on how I did it?

    • @upwellonwards7373
      @upwellonwards7373 Рік тому +1

      @@RailwayManiaNet crikey a step ahead

  • @SodorTrain1225
    @SodorTrain1225 Рік тому +1

    Awesome Saint! Did you get the nameplates from Light Railway Stores? I can't seem to find custom curved ones for some reason.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      Hello mate, I designed them myself on Adobe Illustrator by putting a Hornby plate in the flatbed scanner and tracing it, then sent the etch sheets off to a company called PPD in Scotland who etched a bit sheet for me.

    • @SodorTrain1225
      @SodorTrain1225 Рік тому +1

      @@RailwayManiaNet Cool!

  • @westinbridges7321
    @westinbridges7321 Рік тому +1

    Well, looks like he can build his own Saint loco.

  • @randombread7535
    @randombread7535 Рік тому +1

    like loco also Is your Sodor thing model done?

  • @warbabyproductions
    @warbabyproductions 11 місяців тому

    hey i got a question. where'd you get your custom ethced plates? i've been on the hunt for some gwr style nameplate and numbers to get etched but haven't found a website or anything which could get them done.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  11 місяців тому

      I designed them on Adobe Illustrator and had them etched as part of a big sheet by a company called PPD Ltd. Hope that helps!

  • @NexusWorks924
    @NexusWorks924 Рік тому

    Alright 👍

  • @TheTopazToad
    @TheTopazToad Рік тому

    Hey, I saw those "Westlin" nameboards... Is there another model you're working on at the moment? Perhaps one we might see in a Sudrian Spotlight?

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому

      Hi mate yeah Westlin was (I think) the 4th or 5th loco I made about 8 years ago now, but the custom nameplates are part of a revamp of the model so hopefully it will be on here soon.

    • @TheTopazToad
      @TheTopazToad Рік тому

      @@RailwayManiaNet Nice! I remember seeing pictures of it on one of your sites. Can't wait to see the rebuild!

  • @JDT153
    @JDT153 Рік тому +1

    Hey thats cool! where did you get those name/number plates done?

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      I’ll try and do a video at some point on how they were done ✅

    • @JDT153
      @JDT153 Рік тому +1

      @@RailwayManiaNet ty!

  • @CJs_Models
    @CJs_Models 27 днів тому

    what do you use as an undercoat on your engines?

  • @NexusWorks924
    @NexusWorks924 Рік тому

    Is the next video going to be a sudrian Spotlight

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому

      Next one is a podcast, then I think another modelling one (maybe a Sudrian one), then another podcast :)

    • @NexusWorks924
      @NexusWorks924 Рік тому

      alright can't wait to see the Podcast Perhaps it will be on a preserved loco

  • @terrier_productions
    @terrier_productions Рік тому

    who did the etched nameplates? or was it a custom job?

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      I designed them in Illustrator and sent it off to PPD who did the etchings. I got the size by putting a Hornby nameplate in the flatbed scanner and tracing over the image. I might do a guide on designing basic etches at some point if it's of interest?

    • @tonypetts6663
      @tonypetts6663 Рік тому

      @@RailwayManiaNet Would like a how to on that, I need to get started on a Christmas layout, saint Nick, 2512 etc and some others. It'll be for next year now though.

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому

      That's such a good idea. Why didn't I think of that?!

    • @tonypetts6663
      @tonypetts6663 Рік тому

      @@RailwayManiaNet Been thinking of it for a few years, Hornby's Santa express just isn't up to the job😋

    • @terrier_productions
      @terrier_productions Рік тому

      @@RailwayManiaNet would love that.. I’m currently doing some Thomas customs and I need some custom etched nameplates for them

  • @Shed87AProductions
    @Shed87AProductions Рік тому +1

    NOOOOOO EARL BATHURST
    poor thing :(

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      Lol

    • @Shed87AProductions
      @Shed87AProductions Рік тому +1

      @@RailwayManiaNet not nice smh

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +1

      @@Shed87AProductions I'm sure the world will cope with one fewer £10 static model that came with a magazine.

    • @Shed87AProductions
      @Shed87AProductions Рік тому +1

      @@RailwayManiaNet ye atleast I've seen the real one

    • @lukeslocomotives
      @lukeslocomotives Рік тому +1

      The real 5051 is my favourite locomotive, would quite like to convert a Hornby Castle to 'The Earl' in her 2003 Torbay Express condition

  • @MaxwellTheTrainFan
    @MaxwellTheTrainFan Рік тому

    Pls show us ben again and the nephews on him and bill

  • @jaredhebert942
    @jaredhebert942 Рік тому +1

    Welcome Back! So nice to see you upload again, hope you've been doing well in the last few months. Honestly nice to see a Western loco in BR Lined Black, the Saint here looks real sharp! Have A Happy Thanksgiving!

    • @RailwayManiaNet
      @RailwayManiaNet  Рік тому +2

      Thanks Jared, really nice of you to say :) hope you have a nice time too!

  • @antiussentiment
    @antiussentiment Рік тому

    We're not worthy...