Shiv Ling vs. Radioactivity
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 лип 2024
- Is the shivling actually a radioactive nuclear reactor? Let’s explore where this idea comes from…
One-time donation:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Community:
UA-cam Membership: / @scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
Discord: / discord
#shivling
#radioactive
#jyotirling
Sources:
[1]: The facebook post m. sahihaiyahi/ph...
[2]: Background radiation Map
aerb.gov.in/english/backgroun...
GM Skeptic: / geneticallymodifiedske...
Rationality Rules - / @rationalityrules
Pakistani Mulhid - / pakistanimulhidurdu
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
01:00 - Mythology and Fiction
03:22 - Whatsapp University and Facebook Facts
06:51 - The origin of the ShivLing-radioactivity claim
10:06 - Are Shiv Lings Radioactive?
12:14 - The problem with such claims
14:13 - Why do I “target only Hinduism”?
Patrons that support me at the highest tiers:
rahul raman
Abhilash
Nate Hand
Prabhakar Bhat
Dev Agrawal
Jeevan
Prince Rachit
Lex Luthor
Sushanth
Kashmira wagh
Kiran CJ
Prachet Verma
sashipraveen kalli
Suds Mekathotti
tariq sharif
Akshay Gupta
Thinking Humanist
Dheeraj
Viswanathan Gopalan
Wrichik Basu
Sumana Gopinath
Vishwaneet Singh
Music Credits:
A hand in the dark - Underbelly & Ty Mayer
Cheel - Smokey Eye
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
UA-cam: / scienceisdope
Reddit: / scienceisdope
so this guy can insult hinduism , but nupur sharma can't speak about the facts in islam . wow
How am I insulting?
I smell logical fallacy of False Dichotomy 🤥
Kuch bhi
🤣😂 are you a joke
@@scienceisdope If he has the answer to your question he wouldn't be known as an AndhBhakt.You seriously think he can reply?
Sadhguru: Dimension Dimension Dimension🎵🎵
Pranav: Evidence Evidence Evidence🎵🎵
is it Pranav who's only asking for evidence aren't you! this is all a cooked up shit by these kinds of people in the name of science who need more views, likes, and subscribers what's the solution...Chalo let's go against the most spoken topics ...yaar ham tho science waale hein yaar let's just go against what most popular videos on youtube are & more controversial I suggest you guys watch cosmos instead of this shit there's a co-relation at least about generations , understanding, and science what's here is all is one-sided pranavology hope you grow big using these ppl kid all the best pranav
Indeed😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
We don't have evidence of evolution .
And now a days childern wants evidence😅
@@AmitSingh-yw1gr whatttt???
We have tons and tons and tons of evidence which clearly points to evolution. What world r u living in?
@@amishbhat3560 Sir Please , be clear .
We have a lot of missing links.
And you are saying we have evrything.
Be clear with facts .
it's funny how these people think that having higher amounts radioactivity in places of worship is a good thing without realising having radioactive metals in places of worship only causes cancer among the worshippers themselves😅.
IKR
The main point is Hindus started believing wrong book .
Written by fake people.
@M P yup rest are living peacefully.
Developing nation .
Lolzz... very true... sad but true 😅
@@prabalsingh4402 you wish
Imagine if these shivlings were actually radioactive.. we'd have infinite source of clean energy and essentially solve global warming. Also, people in the vicinity of these idols would've been long dead.
So, also population control? Win win
That would have been called “Evolution through religious rejection ” 😜
@@BIJSNEO damn
The extent of time I have spent close to Shivling, bruhhh I would be long gone, age six probably. And see I'm still alive has lived 20+ years and I still spent time close to Shivling-it calms me tbh.
I don't claim here that shivlings are source of energy lol
But but but
I can assure ,or sure ,that truth will rise up by next 12 years or before it
That we are in stage of trickery .
So a very very very critical thinking is needed more than anyone can have.
You'll never run out of content in this county. 😂😂
Keep up the good work.
Ye until Hindus stop believing wrong book .
Written by fake people.
He will feel happy if he ran out of content
@@shakthi807 yes
Only one person on UA-cam who's gonna be happy if one day he's out of content
I wish the time comes soon
@@theunbeatable728 These types of messages are common amongst INDIAN UNCLES (the worst group to listen to).
He is good in science but atleast he should read history of India.
Thanks for calling out this bullcrap. The rise of social media has done more harm than good in Indian society. I am happy that sanity is still alive in this country which is going more and more crazy and dogmatic with each passing day.
The main point is Hindus started believing wrong book .
Written by fake people.
what about bageshwar dham sarkar
The original Hindu p h o bia started when your left wing b o ts tried to associate everything with shivling when their l I e was e X o posed in gyanwapi temple case ! Shivlinga which means symbol or prateek is worshippable sign just like h!j)a aswad on Makkah etc
I love how I don't even need to see a video for this.
If someone, still believe in this after reading the title twice. They probably don't even deserve a video for this😂
But there are several people who very strongly believe in pseudoscience reasoning. This video is to approach them and try to reduce misinformation.
@@krishcshah true.
@@krishcshahthis is not there fault
The main point is Hindus started believing wrong book .
Written by fake people.
7.8 Lakh AYUSH doctors would disagree with you. 😤😤
@@beactivebehappy9894 all ayush doctors saying that shivling is radioactive?
How do people not realise that a hindu person will mostly point out flaws in Hinduism or a Christian will point out flaws in Christianity. You can only criticize things you have seen closely and experienced firsthand. How am I supposed to call out Islam for their bs if I don't even know what all bs exists in islam ?
Because you will be beheaded or tried for blasphemy.
All you have to do is read a book quran and the first testament there are not complex or big like Mahabharata , very simple and short
You just spoke my mind. There are countless people to critisize other religions. You can only critisize something you know about very well and in this case it will be the religion one grows up in.
For that watch videos on 'Babaki' UA-cam channel.
@@Hello-uy6dx According to Quran Earth is flat but according to Science Earth is not flat but sphere.
Now what should I believe??
A lot of my classmates which are graduates and post graduates find Aajtak's News anchor Mr Mishra video very enlightening and got impressed and shared on their stories. These are people graduated in India's most prestigious universities.
Problem is not education, its biases which they acquire from their parents, and surrounding. Its really tough to convince sometimes that they are thinking is actually is not true.
True affffffffff 👁️👁️
They are called intellectually dishonest beings …
If you are mentally trapped in young age, you will likely refuse truth later. First impressions are very powerful.
@@123xyzabccba I don't think most people are dishonest... It's more childhood conditioning. i have been an agnostic for a while now and yet i have some biases that were ingrained in me in my childhood. Breaking that conditioning is not easy at all. It takes a conscious effort.
And how can they convince u that u are not true .
I love how Pranav only discussed facts here and not tried to make fun of Shivling and Hinduism. This is how a rational debate should look like. He only debunks the claim about Shivling and radioactivity and not comment on Shivling as it is not his expertise. As a Vedantist I truly appreciate Pranav. It is a shame and funny why some people draw such parallels between lingam and radioactivity. It actually defames the Shiva himself as you are calling God a radioactivity power plant! No scripture says so.
Cuz they are low key looking for materialistic explanation for their beliefs. They want materialistic reasons to worship or to be devoted.
Agree
Agree 🙏🙏
still some idiots will feel that he mocked shiv-ling and get offended.
@@sky_shades You are trying to spread Islam in smart manner.
See anyone can be accused of anything when you use "TINFOIL LANGUAGE"
If the Shiv Lings are radioactive, wouldn't the pujaris who daily are in it's vicinity become mutants or Dr. Manhattan? 🤣 /s
Or Hulk🤣🤣
@@arbaazm1409 right, i forgot gamma radiation 😂
Yogi Adityanath would become professor X
Science is dope
Religion is Soap
Pn Oak can be named the father of Indian conspiracy theory or even whatsapp University
+@Anikesh Nair
P N Oak was the inspiration for the foundation of WhatsApp University's Zealous Hindu campus.
Other persons might be inspirations for WhatsApp University's other campuses like Zealous Muslim campus, Zealous Christian campus, and so on.
I don't know why people try to prove their religion by science. Religion is based on belief and science is based on evidence.
India need atleast 1 crore pranavs.
😂👍👍👍❣️❣️❣️❣️
"Why don't you criticise mulla and pastors?"
I sincerely want to ask these Sanatani Hindus. My brothers in humanity, please tell me.
How will his criticism about Mulla and Pastors help you in one way or another?
This is like whenever someone tells you to not waste water on Holi, you say "Go first criticise Muslims for bakra eid"
If he criticise Bakra eid, will you stop wasting water on Holi? Come on man.
Had there been no Muslims and Christians in the world, what excuse would you have?
He is just calling out the pseudo science in YOUR religion, why don't you bring your claim to debunk his claims?
What you are doing is "Okay I will accept criticism but in order to change my perception, you have to criticise other religions too"
So if he criticises mulla and pastors, will you accept that your religion is wrong?
Is that how weak your faith is that it needs the criticism of other faiths?
Huh?
That makes absolutely no sense.
Look at me, I being a believer in God have absolutely no problem when he is criticising my God.
I might get offended to the level 1 or the level 100 but would I say "Oh you are criticising my religion although what you said is true. I can't help it. What about his religion? Criticise it too"
That would be foolishness.
+1 for u buddy, straight up truth
@@unexceptionalnoob -1 for foolishness
@@sampreeth6575 what foolishness can you elaborate?
@@Prat-zi1ou foolishness for actually thinking what this guy said was legit.. read my previous reply bruh...
@@Prat-zi1ou shit shit shit.. my bad bruhh.. meine wrong comment pe reply krdiya... I'm sorry.. i actually agree with this comment 100%
This channel is a breath of fresh air. We need more rationality! 🙌
Half knowledge is always dangerous. Whenever religion meets science disaster happens.
There're thousand more pseudo-scientific claims particularly in hinduism , there's no rational freethinking among ppl who study in WhatsApp Uni.
@@JonSnow-pi6jb yeah but "RELIGION"
When will he debunk those who think evolution is fake? Waiting for it eagerly.
When is Jesus landing on earth ?
"religion Failed, Politics Failed: Now We Have to Try Science" - OSHO ,
what a guy
Bro even he was a cultist.
😂
@@mayankbisht7691 then how come he can say such dialogues?
@@chandradeorana9301 that's his cult dialogue 😆
I see the rationalist community growing in here! More power to Pranav!
Hats off to those Andhbhakts who believe that Radioactivity is a good thing🙏
🤣🤣
I mean it is. Atleast some are.
@369 Pluto How do you know that I don't know if our body emits radiation.
Great conclusion, maybe you should conclude your YT here and uninstall it♥️
@369 Pluto radioactivity nd radiation...same thing,,,wow,,,,keep believing on those baseless things...
@@akscs373 radioactive particle emmits radiation
People are like ok i understand my religion is bullshit but please show something criticising other beliefs to satisfy my ego..😂😂
"Christianity is Chrisn-Nity", I guess thats enough conspiracy theory for today.
😂😂😂
I never heard such cringe in my whole life😭
I and Pranav worked together long back and we used to debate about religion and science. Of course, at the time I was a staunch believer in Christianity. Many years later I found my way out of illogical stories and became an atheist.
For the people who think Pranav is anti-Hindu, I have to say that he's anti-religion or anti-faith and what he used to criticize was specifically Christianity with me. But, he is not educated in the Christian context enough to make larger criticisms as he was brought up in a Hindu household. India is still largely Hindu populated and ergo his criticisms are more about Hinduism, naturally. Every religious faith is stupid as it put forward claims without evidence, but in the Indian context, Hinduism has more relevance. Criticism of Christianity has more relevance in Kerala or Goa, but not pan India.
+@Bony John
I very much like the work done by this channel Science is Dope.
However, I see at least a little bit of merit in the proposition that even within the context of India, Islam and Christianity also need to be taken to task for spewing absurdities-which this channel HAS DONE in a couple of videos.
The reason I say this is that Islam and Christianity, even though numerically significantly smaller in India than Hinduism, have wielded an influence on the subcontinent of India that is far greater in proportion to their respective numerical strengths; Islam was the religion of the rulers of India for many centuries, while Christianity was followed by the British rulers of India, and was "inculcated" through missionary activities.
*P.S.:* I used to be a pretty devout Hindu, but became an atheist a few years ago.
And BEFORE any Hindu apologist here tries to claim that Hinduism (i.e. so-called Sanatana Dharma) accepts, accommodates, includes atheism, I would urge such a person to read Chapter 7 and Chapter 9 of the Bhagavad Gita, which show the disdain and contempt that Krishna has for persons who do not surrender to him-and naturally, atheists fall under the category of persons who do not surrender to Krishna.
So... NO, Hinduism DOES NOT accept, accommodate, or include atheism in its fold.
@@yevodee4024 I agree. Criticism on other religions would only do good. I just wanted to point out to people why he is not doing as much on other religions.
+@Nihilistic Atheist
Where in Chapter 7 and Chapter 9 does the Bhagavad Gita compare atheists to "gamblers drunkards"?
I could not find that.
HOWEVER, in the same chapters, Krishna says that persons who do not surrender to him (i.e., persons who do not surrender to God)-which would include atheists because atheists do not believe in the existence of any god of any religion, any belief-system or any "dharma"-are lazy, demonic (i.e. wicked), unintelligent, the lowest among human beings, etc.
He further states that such persons would never obtain the fruits of their work.
@@yevodee4024 well I didn't believe in verse that you quote from Bhagwat Gita as you claim, but I have a question that what are the widening of Hinduism coz if Vaishnav follow Gita then what about Shivaits and Shakts and for your kind information there many schools of philosophy in ancient India like charvaka and many more who were disbelievers of God.
+@@vibhutisrivastava2789
Can you please type your comment: {"well I didn't believe [...] disbelievers if God"} in a more *clear manner with appropriate punctuations* like full-stop (AKA period), commas, question mark, etc.?
Your entire comment is one long string of words with no punctuations, and with several disjointed points.
Therefore I am unable to clearly understand what exactly you are trying to say, and therefore I am unable to give an appropriate response.
You're a beacon of rationality and logic among us youths. Please keep our hopes in the scientific perspective alive.💙🙏
Russian troops attacked a temple in Ukraine.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Oh sorry, It was Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant🙃
😂
🤣🤣🤣
broooooo
Lmao
Inventing psuedo scientific theories to justify your belief system is the greatest disservice you can do to your beliefs. We don't need to justify Hinduism on the anvils of science. There is lot of value in it without it having to be 'scientific'. As a Hindu nationalist, I fully support your efforts Pranav. Koodos to you!
I had no idea you followed GM Skeptic and Rationality Rules. I have been using that example for some time to your haters. Hinduism or any other religion isn't that popular in the west as Christianity and people fall into Christianity-related pseudoscience plus GM Skeptic is ex-christian so ofc that's what he would make videos about. Great video as always.
Christianity can be end but it is impossible to end hinduism since it is part of Indian culture !!
@@Nothing-yo5uo Christianity is also deeply part of western culture and culture does not end (unless the civilization perishes somehow) it changes. I hope for a better future both India(and the rest of the east) and the West.
@@someoneyouveneverheardof Rationality rules rules.
+@@Nothing-yo5uo
Just because something "impossible to end", does not mean that it is automatically great.
Islam is actually growing. Does that mean that Islam is a great thing???
I guess what lies inside your skull is the same as what your UA-cam ID is.
@@yevodee4024 Why are you attacking me? I am not hinduism is great but even one of the four horsemen of Atheism Sam Harris have praised Advaita Vedanta and Buddhists practices.
How else could they power the mercury vortex engines of the pushpak vimaan and the nuclear weapons used in kurukshetra.
Don't give them ideas for more such WhatsApp University forwards🤣
By imagination
That has no historic evidence
Simple. By sitting on top of a mountain and meditating to gain immense knowledge about the universe while traversing all dimensions at the same time. After that you channel your acquired power to the pushpak vimaan and voila !! Sadhguru logic lol
@Nihilistic Atheist bruh that was actually funny, why m imagining some molecule vibrating and breaking down into its constituents with the sound of omm
You'd never stop getting the "oh what about this religion" comments btw. Some people are way too invested in their belief systems that they'd rather ignore the evidence provided to them and turn back around to criticise you for problems you haven't solved and answers you haven't found yet.
It's all fiction.. Don't waste your time on it
Pls keeping more of such vids, they are needed these days... else someday someone might end up saying that sun and other cosmological bodies are balloons of different coulurs and materials meant for different purposes and reason
Yes this will help many .
The main point is Hindus started believing wrong book .
Written by fake people.
Why doesn't he talk about Christian superstitions?
@@devsucksatlife I agree with you, any sort of unjustified claims of any belief should be brought out...
@@sky_shades and no, I do respect it... just that the false claims which could have been associated with it have to be removed,rest all things of Hinduism are wonderful, like Aryabhattas invention of zero, Madhavacharya, Sushrutha and many others are wonderful examples of that age, which s called the Vedic Age, and they do deserve respect...in fact if I am not wrong one of the Vedas(I don't remember exactly whether ist Rig or Atharva), it also talks about the different ways by which a person can lead his life to be in his best form and shape, so such things which are associated with Hinduism, are the best advices that have been given... and yes, don't forget Swami Vivekananda and some of his best teachings that he had given... especially the ones which he had made in his Chicago speech... these are examples for the pride of Hinduism
@@sky_shades lol first listen his last answer in this video
Man, I really love your videos. I might not be an atheist, but really love your methods of rational and respectful debunking. I have seen a lot of people trying to debunk these myths in an assaultive way, and I just think it does more harm than good. Your channel has this welcoming and respectful vibe, I believe that your videos would actually convince someone to trust science and withdraw themselves from beliefs that cause more harm than good.
@Nihilistic Atheist yeah. I wrote that thing in sort of a flippant way and did not have all the words in my mouth
What I really appreciate that you calmy and with due respect put your views. No aggressive athiesm that says everyone is crazy.
Exactly
so basically P.N Oak is biggest Andhbhakt ever😂😂
Almost on the same level as Joker Naik
Thanks for making the video. Efforts behind the content deserves an applause.
.
If you may make YT Shorts about how to developing Scientific temper to kids, it'd definitely be of greater help to the generation to come!
Nice video idea
I would recommend to watch Dr Stone anime. It will help kids to understand and love science
The main point is Hindus started believing wrong book .
Written by fake people.
you are doing such a great work, deserve a lot of appreciations 👏🏻👏🏻
HOW cleverly he is Using Freedom of Speech to Defame HINDU 🕉️ God..
Imagine He Doing Same With Allah..
And Next Day (Sar Tan se Zuda) Beheaded 🙂....
#Stop_supporting_these_people
They Can't Criticize ALLAH
What Do you Think there are Just Hindu making these Claim not Muslim☪️️
But He make almost all Video Against Hindu God and Thier Supporter 🙃
#BE_WISE enough
Respect your GOD
Atleast Learn Something From Muslims
One Word Against their God And next Day your head Chopped off.. 🙂🙂🙃🙂🙃
@@shubhamanand19He is not criticizing God, he is debunking the pseudoscience and blind faith on any claim. If u could have seen the video properly, u would have found the answers for all your remarks in the video itself. And, learn good things from other religions, not the bad one.
Hinduism has a lot of good things to be appreciated we should stop appreciating our religion on the basis of false claims...it only makes us sound illogical
With over a billion people in India drunk on religion with strong genetic predisposition towards religiosity, you will never run out of contents in this country.
@Nihilistic Atheist i never deleted any comments. Not unless i got death threats for it from hindutvas or jihardees.
Genetic predisposition towards religiosity? I hope you understand you have to atleast make sense while writing a sentence.
@@Viper60589 have you studied indian genetic traits. Read up and then comment. Genes play a huge role in how you behave, your temperament, what you believe and your propensity to believe it.
@@NordicPolestar How can genes affect if I'll be religious or not? Don't talk like a dumbfk.
Half knowledge is more destructive than no knowledge if you're thinking like this than I want to make you sure you're just seeing it with one's perception absolutely he done great things disclosing fake claims but as we indian proud na aryabhatta sushrut ramanujan many more were sanatanis hindu tradition might feel somewhat stupid and lack of knowledge leads to ignorance about us and not able to prove this and uk 1000s of time hindu knowledge and legacy was destroyed and ruined let time say might their be proof in upcoming future and if u don't know anything about something u don't have rights to say anything and why we want other religion to be inferior to us Supreme God is one just we refer to them with different names it's india do respect every religion it's not always necessary to defame others and if you're Muslim then I want to tell you I have more Muslim friends then hindu friends they really respect and also love my religion my one friend is doing PhD in sanskrit(base of all hindu literature and customs) and one loves the serial mahakali so don't grow hatred or anything If you love your religion very good but don't make assumptions to others
And uk hindu panchang we predicted constellation even their positions so correctly 1000s or year before Discovery it's not just a claim it's evidence
Sanatan dharm is 1.95 billion year old
Our dharm teaches us peace and love but also taught violence against adharm.
Jay hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
wait ,if we go and pray to a strong radioactive shivaling wont we be bleeding from all orifaces including rectum due to radioactive posioning
Keep up the good work man . Now I am gonna share this story to my family what's app group . (Honestly I was fed up explaining the Shiv and radioactivity fact is wrong and pure bullshit but no one believed .)
The biggest tragedy today we are facing is that Religion is considered as history
+@Shuveshek Rai
People just WANT their religious beliefs to be true... its almost like they are fear an identity crisis.
Zealous Muslims: Scientific findings are wrong, our Quran and Hadiths are correct because they say they are correct;
Zealous Christians: Scientific findings are wrong, our Bible is correct because it says it is correct;
Zealous Hindus: Scientific findings might be correct, BUT we knew all this already because we say we knew all this already.
😁😁😁
What lack of proper education does to common people
History can be debunked easily by tracing the origins of the language used in the era.
@@kotimara8711 education doesn't do shit. Well educated and qualified people still believe in pseudoscience and pseudohistory
sending this video in the family group to get banned💪😎
Pranav, please make a video on the claim that ancient people lived longer than us. Our parents and grandparents frequently talk about how our ancestors lived for a hundred of years and that we should follow ancient lifestyle. I do not believe that and want to know if there is scientific evidence that disproves the theory.
Actually there are endless such claims which maybe false... But there is no use trying to prove them wrong or right. Don't waste time on such claims. If you want to learn about Hinduism try @Acharya Prashant once.
It can be simply proven wrong by the fact that it has no evidence plus we know about various personalities from ancient india who did not even lived for so long like many kings,scholars and more
That is an important topic, this myth needs to break.
Just show the India's life expectancy graph next time you're involved in this discussion. Also show the life expectancy graph of the west in the era of the industrial revolution, I think it will clear things up pretty much on the spot.
@@mirchi6873 Posterboy of Vedantas😁 he himself is not clear about his philosophies, he mix a lot of western philosophies and try to equate them with Upanishads.. there is no such thing as true Hinduism. All think they are following true one. Have ever read any Upanishad?
Forsake of argument lets say there's a correlation between location of Shivlings and Radioactivity, Wouldn't you not want that as alpha, beta , gamma radiation is harmful not just to humans but any life? Wouldn't it be stupid to built large places of gathering near those supposed radioactive zones, atleast they gotta get pseudoscience properly 🤠
Dude Pranav, is the IT cell making you popular? I hope they dont flag your video as hateful content
Hey man, I've been watching you since the very beginning and your content is really genuine. I really appreciate your work........❤️
bakwas ...explaining Neuclear theory with the help of 9th class science ...First go and study more ...
Much needed video! Hope it reaches many many people
Damn, this is a really in depth explanation. I'm loving it. Thanks for your work🙂
HOW cleverly he is Using Freedom of Speech to Defame HINDU 🕉️ God..
Imagine He Doing Same With Allah..
And Next Day (Sar Tan se Zuda) Beheaded 🙂....
#Stop_supporting_these_people
They Can't Criticize ALLAH
What Do you Think there are Just Hindu making these Claim not Muslim☪️️
But He make almost all Video Against Hindu God and Thier Supporter 🙃
#BE_WISE enough
Respect your GOD
Atleast Learn Something From Muslims.. Bro 🤜
@@shubhamanand19 Can you show exactly the part where he defamed Hinduism ?
Rhetorical question, I know you can't, cus he did not. You are talking outta your arse.
+@@shubhamanand19
I guess you are blissfully unaware of UA-camrs like The Apostate Prophet, Abdullah Sameer, and so on.
Please ask them why they point out and criticise mainly Islam's absurdities, and why they hardly touch upon Hinduism's (i.e. so-called Sanatana Dharma's) absurdities. 🙂
@@sky_shades You smell of tinfoil..... This bs isn't Hinduism he isn't even criticising Hinduism.
This is like you making your own bullsh1t naming it Hinduism for your own benefit and then crying anti-Hindu when criticise.
But how can it be anti-hindu when it isn't even Hinduism 😂😂
@@shubhamanand19 there r tons of them also...check out arona, abdullah sameer etc...atheism is way to go
The Indian Constitution tells all Indians to strive for Scientific and rational bent of mind. Well done Pranav
Surely with a name like PN Oak, is the biggest clue ?
I hope the awful orange brigade will not demolish the Taj Mahal, magnificent cultural structures such as this are owned by all humanity regardless of their location.
I work at a nuclear power station. There is a reason for the shape of the Reactor Containment Building (assuming the Shiv is representing a PWR/BWR and not gas-cooled reactor, like a Magnox).
Pranav, it's worth appreciating how you are debunking pseudo sciense claim without hurting anyone's religious sentiment. Your Channel is really underrated. It deserves more viewers. Keep doing what you are doing 👏
It’s funny to say it’s a reactor; cuz in vedas it’s clearly mentioned it’s a male organ that’s why it’s called ling edit: it’s mentioned in Shiva Puranam also
Edit 2 : just google it and read shiva puran and visit temple and read the scripture ( I did because of parental pressure) before comment like a PhD in WhatsApp university
Hey that's written in Shiv puran. I have checked it.
If it's written in veda, then please give me source.
@@theaveragescienceguy8652 how does the name rudra make it that organ? Can you quote the text because I have heard it's supposed to represent the shape of the universe or something according to Hinduism.
@@khosrowanushirwan7591 nope.., read shiva puranam… the word yoni means women’s parts and the word ling means male parts .., it’s just a representation of congregation.., that’s why the human form of shiva has half Parvathi and half shiva … read Hinduism and Sanskrit properly before lamenting
@@khosrowanushirwan7591 shape of universe lol.., there is no shape of universe, there is only existing model.., cuz it’s a explosion after big bang and you can’t map a explosion in a place where no space time continuum present.., just a google search can debunk your claim
@@theaveragescienceguy8652 I said mentioned in Hinduism aka scriptures.
"Namaskaram Anna" will be so pissed after watching this video. UA-cam channels like String should be banned from the Internet as they play a huge role in spreading all these misinformations. It's so heart breaking just by scrolling via their comment section. I pity my fellow Indians who are still living in the past glory, mythology and outdated culture of our country.
Living with mythology or culture is not a bad thing, being ignorant is. We can see how Norse mythological character Thor was made a hero in Avengers. We can have these aspects and still be scientific.
@@anibeto7 Myths are stories to be shared with the younger generations for portraying morales, I agree on that. Problem starts when people starts idealizing and forming a cult on behalf of that 😗. All I want to say is that Myths should be taken as it is, shouldn't be mistaken for history.
And by the culture I meant..for example It's an age old tradition that had been spoon fed by our "culture" to respect the elders irrespective of what they tell. It's considered unmannerly to question their illogical statements or to oppose them. This has to change and the younger generation should be encouraged to ask more questions and promote scientific temper in them. But sadly I still see most of the parents rolling their eyes when kids do so,for the sake of our "culture".
A culture is never outdated whatever it might be. You are mistaking culture and pseudoscience as one and the same.
@@Viper60589 Well by our culture child marriage was permissible back then. Wasn't it? So deeds like that needs updation, that's all I said.
And pseudoscience comes when such deeds are connected to myths and then myths to science 🤷 It's all connected you see.
@@sapiens8141 Again you're mistaking culture for a tradition/custom. Culture is a cumulative. Traditions and customs change as per time and circumstances.
Bro, plz don't do this video. Current India is not safe and you will be charged with blasphemy for this video.
Mark my words - the title of the video will attract blasphemy accusations! They have already filed blasphemy cases against people who were humoring the fact that not every cylindrical looking structure (atomic center, poles etc) are a shiv-ling. Case filed against Saba Naqvi for a similar tweet. So I am sincerely warning you about current situation in India.
Debunking pseudoscience wouldn't come under blasphemy. He never insults religion, he's jist against pseudoscience. Some people don't understand this simple fact but it's ok .
@@tanishkasingh3365 But you can't argue with andh-bhakt logic
We can't just keep quite and do nothing out of fear. Pseudoscience needs to be called out. We will all be together with him.
@@debjyotisarkar1429 yes ,but we don't need to argue with them ,let them believe anything they want ,truth will remain the same
@@debjyotisarkar1429 yeah.. But if someone will not address these things ... Many kids who are rational will be future andhbhakt...
Working on an nuclear research project at atomic energy regulatory board-Mumbai and discussed with my faculty Dr diptendu sir on this and he literally laughed on these claim straightly for 5mins
i guess you're lucky then, because in india many learned engineering and medicine professors still believe in religion based pseudoscience.
LOOOL
Love gm skeptic. He's the reason why I'm an atheist. As a Christian I'm aware of the bs there. But I'm not v aware about the bs in Hinduism. Thank you for educating us on that. Keep up the good work. Now i can be prepared for the bs happening in India
Wow ! Your video quality has improved alot . And the content is as usual , dope 🙌 .
I am afraid you will be charged with blasphemy😶🙃
Actually claiming Shivling as Nuclear reactor is blasphemy and funny in a way
@@mirchi6873 true
Blasphemy only applies for religion of peace
@@ashwanichandola6172 did you see what happened to a tailor in Udaipur? Bruh it's horrific
@@mirchi6873 it's not horrific. It's just Normal Islam
I am a Hindu and i really appreciate your videos on debunking this kind of videos, especially “scientific”. I really think people should draw a line between religion and science. People unnecessarily try to prove my beautiful religion as scientific in order to prove legitimacy of the religion. I think people should understand religion is mostly belief and science is mostly evidence. No need to prove our religion is great because it’s already great with rich history and texts. But only one request please don’t call our stories from Vedas as mythologies, we believe in them very and I know you don’t want hurt any religious sentiments of the people. Thank you and you got yourself a subscriber and looking forward to your journey in the future.
A great religion is the one with evolves with time and not the one with history and text, as anyone can have those.
Shivling are not source of radiation energy their shape is best fit for confinement of energy's which is dome shape.
how is that the case?
and what form of energy are u referring to?
Never seen someone this genuine! Appreciated
Oh flat surface jao bakri Kato Janna milagi chutiya hinduism lot of scientific thing but your chipti surface
@@yush340 ABE GANDU HAZARO MUSLIMS BHI ATHEIST H...ISNE ISLAM ZAKIR NAIK KO BHI EXPOSE KIYA H.....RHI BAAT TOH ARABIC SCIENTISTS BHI RHE H NEWTON KA DOST BHI THA EK....DOOSRI BAAT HINDUISM ME SUPERSTITIONS KO HISTORY MANNE WLE LOG BHI BOHT H SO U CANT DENY...BUT OVERALL ISLAM IS WO&ST
@@yush340 hinduism is scientific 😂😂😂
@@rashidkaleem8650 oh converted chutiya Islam se bhut shi hai hinduism bhut shi hai most terrorists religion fake things is from Islam
🤣🤣🤣 man flying with donkey belivers
Those people who say this types of shit are those who themselves never ever read their own scriptures- the shiva purana here.
In Shiv Puran, 12th chapter named "Daaruvan story " where the origin of shiva lingam is given there's it's description is eroticised and clearly it's stated as a phallus.
and the base of the Shiv Ling is known as YONI which means VAGINA
Heyy !! Loved your content and it has actually changed my prospective of looking at stuff like this . I would really like to see a video on debunking the claims of Ramanujam that his goddess Lakshmi is bleeding math and her being his only source of mathematics knowledge.
Although I agree Amish Tripathi's books are fun, he is a pseudo scientific claim expert. I was a fan and went to meet him in a bookstore for signing. After the signing he started claiming that our ancient history was full of miracles and atomic energy weapons, vinayaka was plastic surgery and the usual bullsh*t. I was pretty disappointed. I don't know about others.
true, even I was a fan of his books because I am a fan of mythology but he started correlating them with reality for real.
Perhaps you need to re-read the history.
First successful surgery was performed in India.The Sushrutaa Samhita is among the most important ancient medical treatises and is one of the fundamental texts of the medical tradition in India along with the Charak Samhita. Sushruta is the father of surgery.
Sushruta has described surgery under eight heads: Chedya (excision), Lekhya (scarification), Vedhya (puncturing), Esya (exploration), Ahrya (extraction), Vsraya (evacuation), and Sivya (suturing).
The Sushruta Samhita documented the etiology of more than 1,100 diseases, the use of hundreds of medicinal plants, and instructions for performing scores of surgical procedures - including three types of skin grafts and reconstruction of the nose.
2- His techniques of surgeries are still used by INDIAN DOCTORS to perform complicated operations that are not yet achieved by modern science.
Ex-
Doctors use 2500-year-old Sushruta technique to reconstruct Afghan woman's nose
link :
www.newindianexpress.com/cities/delhi/2018/oct/08/doctors-use-2500-year-old-sushruta-technique-to-reconstruct-afghan-womans-nose-1882846.html
Why u no makin video on Zoroastrianism vro. R u afraid of Boman Irani ?
😂
This cmt made my day
😂😂😂😂
Woh i have actually never seen pseudoscience from zoronastrianism and if is true then plz send me some sources
@@loading3138 Because their founder was a great man he compared withi Pluto and Socrates.
But Bhai, according to my abject delusions it is true and I will believe it's true.
Sarcasm ,righ5?
@@tanishkasingh3365 no sarcasm 😡🤬. You are hinduphobic. If you want proof of the shiv ling, watch my fevrite researcher Praveen Mohan
Delusions 🤣
@@zany4132 may Praveen Mohan's curse haunt you your entire life 😡
Meanwhile bhakts - only whatsapp and facebook is the true source.😵
ancient aliens also mentioned Shivlingas as The sign of Nuclear reactor in one of their episodes, but they said these lingams are just symbols of nuclear reactor and didn't claim lingams as actual Reactors. May be lots of people are influenced by this series also and got misleading thoughts.
Lol lingas are shiva's pp
@@erennn1620 I guess you are getting me wrong. I'm just stating that this series also influenced people thoughts wrongly on a mass level. When you do Abhishek on Shivling, the Pujari tells very firstly that the ling is Shiva and the bottom part is Shakti means Parvati. That clearly indicates that these two parts are the source of Reproduction. Hence your point is also right. The interesting part is everyone depicts the meaning differently. May be Someone will also say otherwise... You can find numerous meaning of shivlings when you search... Same goes with every single belief.
@@suraj_gatade Well the story of Shiv ling comes from chapter 7 or 12 of Shiva Purana is very funny tbh
@@erennn1620 Yes, it is in Chapter 12 of Shiv-Puran.
Ancient Aliens is a fake show made by conspiracy theorists
Oak could have become the meme lord of 2022 with his creativity.
Dude, I want your autograph🔥💯
There is another self proclaimed historian in talks... he says he is a physicist but make lot of content on history... mostly appears in beerbiceps podcast... please make a video on his claims... he seems to be the successor of P N oak
you are talking about Abhijit chavda right?
Man that person is rw propagandsit ultra pro Max in his sati video he claimed history with logical thinking. I am from Kolkata joransanko and history Student from calcutta University and I have seen scriptures of how many women were burn near Hooghly ghat after sati it was about 700 avrg year
@@loading3138 Bro is there any online source of that scripture
@@loading3138 read meenakshi jain's work and stop spouting nonsense also what is the source of 700 satis per year who was keeping the record? Provide a primary source or please get lost. Btw I'm a bengali too.
Abhijit Chavda is that Conspiracy theorist!
Thanks man, your work is really appreciable
You are doing a great job Pranav...
Wow! a lot of research you have done to make this one.
Is there any channel on you tube which provides this types of content in hindi??
Please suggest if any!
Aastha Mukti
Thank you 👍🏻 you're doing great work
Finally! Someone made a video on this... Thanks man!!!
Bro one recommendation: Just start a podcast. Invite people who can talk.
indian podcast sphere right now is so full of mysticism, babas preaching and pseudoscience. All of it truly repels me from getting into any of it.
@@sai_69 So damn true. Everybody has the "answers" these days.
Hey man
Could you make a video on evidence on Mahabharta and Ramyana and all those things associated with it?
Is it really real?
are there any evidences for those?!
Knowledgeable video.. Appreciated!!
Need this type of youtubers who gives you knowledge without hurting anyone's religious sentimentals.. Just pure knowledge!!
So much informative. I can't have words to thank you enough. Thank you so much.
I liked Carl Sagan pointing the gun the last time the best😂😂
And Pranav is always Killing.
I was once told that the some women getting pregnant in Mahabharat with just eyes or staring or whatever was actually an evidence of test tube babies. Imagine my face when I heard that.😂 😮
@Nihilistic Atheist : yes, Modi can say , his IQ level is very very low
@Nihilistic Atheist : yes, Modi can say , his IQ level is very very low
@@123xyzabccba ur is very high 😂😂, why won't u become prime minister
@@kattar2345 : Modi is a puppet and it’s always the one who is dumb is made the puppet..
@@kattar2345 because u said his iq is high, u have to be a gunda and uneducated to do shit in politics in this country XD
My mom is the best in the world, and it's scientifically proven.
Awesome 👌. Keep up the good work sir. Stay safe and keep your loved ones safe. ❤️
Yet another brilliant video!
It seemed superstition will decline with every turning decade, but it's getting more rigid with scientific claims.
I love your channel ❤ teach me more than college
Good job. Keep exploring.
The People who are saying a shivling is radiactive is actualy distroying a faith of beliver,please leave shiva out of your pesudo science ,wheather shiva existed or not people have belif of him,Thanks to you we are showing truth, i am not able to understand why shiva ling is not shiv linga? why our faith is do with science ? its two diffrent things,
Faith is personal and Science is universal ,
Hi Pranav
Great info 👍🏼
Could you please make a video/series on - What is actually scientific in Hinduism?
Religions are not scientific, its more like philosophy
Havn't watched video yet but i can surely say you gonna get lot of flack for this one.
Keep busting more myths.
I loved your video man 😍, you gotta new subscriber 👍.
Sir, science is truth. There has been people twisting science but it has always brought truth in front sooner or later. 👍
Video suggestions:
a brief video on *HOW INDIA HAPPENED* from origin.
you seem a good rationalist. many indians doesn't even know the timelines of ancient indian civilization, when different religions came in existence and how they evolved to make the present India.
Thanks for all your homework and presenting very informative and well researched video. Please keep it going. Just subscribed you.
Theist are like why dont you clean other house when your own house is dirty
Thank u for enlightening us👍
*scoffs*
They might have small nuclear fission reactors, but we have a giant fusion reactor inside the Kaaba.
Bro what you think about Balck stone of kabba?Is it a meteorite or normal black stone?
@@Nothing-yo5uo Idk, it's possible that is was a metorite. Those things did fell on earth even back then.
Fun fact, Jahangir had a sword made out of meteorite that fell in Punjab claiming it was a gift from the heavens.
Best thing on UA-cam India!
First of all, this is not an insult of hinduism, I look at it the opposite way, he is helping us discard the wrong beliefs and unscientific claims.
They also claim their first religion and true religion!!
Love listening to you. When I hear such stuff I am so flummoxed. One doesn't know where to start with a response