Lets call this performance know yourself... and absolutely love idina and what her voice can do.... but thank god she is beeing carefull with her voice here
Yeah lol. If they gave me that song I would die. I'm a girl who can't sing very high. Idina has a beautiful voice though that brings life into the movie
Elsa: the cold never bothered me anyways Idina: shoot the high note I’m nit making fun of her just so you know it’s almost impossible to hit that high of a note in the cold
they clearly were working with a scratchy and frankly unsalvagable sound system but the power behind Idina’s belts is still palpable, she did amazing considering the weather.
GamingWithZoe they edited their original comment and deleted a reply where they were telling me that Idina sang early in the morning when it was actually at night. I should know - I was there😂
The sound system wasn't scratchy. She moved it away from her and made that sound on purpose because she knew her voice couldn't handle those notes. While the sound system may have problems, most performances will have some sort of problem. Shes done the moving mic away trick lots of other times to save the show because its a professional trick to do when your voice isn't up to it at the moment.
I know you disney fans hate to hear this, but at the end of Frozen 2, Elsa died and turned into a spirit (no true loves kiss to save her). Prove me wrong!
Ngl it showed Elsa being herself, which truly made Show Yourself better. Well I feel like Into the unkown and Show yourself, has the same resepect towards eachother.
Disney should really stop writing songs she struggles to sing cause she’s never gonna hit those notes live and people will get pissed at idina, and also idina can maybe damage her voice since she’s constantly busy and rarely gets time to rest. Its kinda a shame how she’s not able to properly take care of her voice, if she keeps this up she’s going to lose it
I don’t understand why everyone’s like “she missed the note she missed the note” what she did was very smart because she adapted the song to a way she could sing it given the conditions and still sounded absolutely amazing Edit : thanks for 1k likes omg glad ppl agree she’s amazing
people need to know recordings and studios arent the same as being live. They probably did lots of retakes and put that all together for the actual movie. She can't just sound as nice as she did
They need to stop having her sing in such cold weather when it's hard to breathe. She's a wonderful singer but it's hard on her when it's so cold. I can barely talk when I'm cold like that. I can't imagine singing like that.
@@MariahCarey2 an EGOT please, but she got a tight competition with Thr Lion King's Can You Feel the Love Tonight but even though I love Beyonce. This song still is very remarkable
Disney was just playing around with her voice. In the movie, her voice sound a little high, meanwhile in reality, Idina has a deep elegant voice. It's just the autotune, relax yall don't be so disappointed. It's her real voice.
They use a different key in the film. It’s not autotune. They lower it when she performs it live so it’s easier to sing over and over and over. They did the same thing with Let It Go and Into the Unknown.
I believe this is her real voice. My theory is that Disney actually autotunes her voice to be higher to have that youthful sound to it since she has a lower voice register. Same as the other Disney Princesses that has songs. They might also intended to make the live versions in a lower key to avoid straining.
@@이마크-r8e Nah, she's a vocalist and an accomplished actress, she can raise her voice into a higher register. There are plenty of recordings where she's higher without needing autotune. The other Disney princesses haven't been "autotuned" to raise their pitches. Mandy Moore, Kristen Bell, Amy Adams, Lea Salonga, Jodi Benson, etc. all sound the same in real life. Idina raises her voice to play Elsa, because Elsa is significantly younger, but that's the talent of a voice actor, not technology. Idina sings lower live because she has a lower natural register (which comes with age) and because these songs are written for the studio -- they need to sound the best in the film and on recordings. Live performances are the frosting on the cake, but the studio is the foundation.
@@missalwayswrite Yeah you have a point. After Disney just released the behind the scenes I did realize that she does sing it naturally higher 😅. Still kinda bothers me that she has to maintain that higher pitched voice for some time for her lines in the movie. I do some voice work at school, and it kinda hurts when I do the same voice that is slightly higher. So when I'm a little wonky, our editor slightly corrects it. But then again, I applaud Idina for her work.
음향 문제도 있고 겨울왕국 노래들이 이디나 멘젤이 완창하기엔 워낙에 자기 키보다 높은 곡이기도 한 듯. 녹음할 때에는 최상의 컨디션으로 부분 부분 나눠서 온 힘을 다해서 부르고 보정도 좀 하니까 영화에서는 깔끔하고 지리게 나오는 거고 라이브를 하기에는 이디나 멘젤한테는 어려운 노래들인 듯. 나이도 있고 목이 많이 상해서 컨디션을 많이 타는 것도 있고.. 영화에서 처럼만 라이브 했다면 훨씬 레전드 취급 받았을지도 몰랐겠지만 그래도 좋은 곡 불러줘서 감사할 뿐.
근데 탑 뮤지컬 배우시고 뮤지컬 특성상 고음범벅일텐데 게다가 저분 활동시절에는 마이크 보급이 잘안되서 마이크 없이 벨팅으로 했대요. 마이크없이 극장을 소리로 채우시던분이 저러는거보면 목이상한거 아닌가 해서 좀 슬프네요. 목이상해서 그런지 덕분에 허스키한 매력적인 엘사 목소리를 내주시긴 했지만요.
I'm so proud of this woman! She did this in this so good!! And for the people who disrespect her: you can try to sing this hard songs, live and in the cold!
@@stantwicewithallyourheart8624 cause majority of small kids out there don't know that 30-50 year old adults voice their everyday fav Disney characters lol but I definitely understand so they really shouldn't judge their looks all that matters is heir voices since it's animation not actual real life people playing something else,and plus that's how I imagine all of the frozen characters would sound anyways!!!
I'm a 37 year old man with a wife and 3 year old daughter, and cry like a teenager every time I hear this song. It's so powerful and moving, by far the best song to come out of the Frozen series, and in my opinion the whole Disney franchise.
Anyone who gives Idina crap needs to understand how much she's put into not just her sing but her acting. It's hard enough recording an album, let alone singing in the cold. You can hear how tired she is in her voice and bless this woman for doing what she could so she didn't hurt herself anymore than she already was. She's the original singer, if she wants to change it guess what, she can it's her choice. Brava Idina, keep on being the amazing person we all know you are. I'm still wanting to see this, and might take the day off tomorrow and see it.
I love her voice. No ones voice can be that POWERFUL. A reason she voiced Elsa, comes with so much work and practice and its Idina Menzel she works so hard. I appreciate that and I love her. I'm a big fan.
Omfg. Her voice.... I’m sorry. But it genuinely makes me tear up every time I hear it. It’s genuinely so beautiful. Frozen and Frozen 2 makes me cry. I would listen to her music if she decided to release an album lowkey.
Did anyone else hear a little Defying Gravity at the very end? It has to be muscle memory for her to do that. ALSO. I really don't think she could either hear herself or the music. Its very clear there were audio issues.
Honestly what she did was very smart. You can tell that her voice was not having it in the cold weather, and probably was very tired. As a singer myself, sometimes you gotta find a way around that big high note when you know it could damage your voice even worse than it is. Vocalists know their voices. I had to change some of the high notes in the show I’m in for a couple of nights because I was sick, and now that I’m back in my third weekend I can hit them again. It just be like that sometimes. I love love love her voice, I’m so glad she decided to preserve it
Mur Mur I think she’s just used to doing that. In broadway, the mic is always attached to her so she can move her arms wherever she wants. In concerts she usually keeps the mic on the stand, so i think it’s just a force of habit moving her arms away
its also an uncertanity type thing. being a singer myself ive experience sometimes the fear of screwing it up makes one do that. the bad thing here is she moved it away on some notes that you can tell she actually hit well. she´s probably not used to singing this live.
ChimneySweep07 Thats also a good point. I do believe this is the first time she’s sing show yourself live, so I’m sure eventually she will become more comfortable with it.
I think idinas real singing ,voice is this cool.and its a bit different from elsa..she has to mould herself into elsa to show shes singing for her..this makes her very awesome..
Missed a note? No, she stuck within a range that was safe for her voice. The only problem I see here is her mic control which was weird to say the least, unless they were supposed to add some sustain or something similar (which clearly never happened). Edit: I see a lot of people mentioning her moving the mic away to save face, but she's still singing the notes and hitting them at the same volume (you can literally hear this). I really think she was instructed to move the mic away so they could add effects (which never came off).
NotMyName I think she might not have been able to hear herself properly so she was just doing it as a precaution even though it turned out she didn’t need to as she hit the notes
She does this in EVERY performace. Check out the other live performances of Into The Unknown. No one can honestly believe that someone is trying to add effects in every performance. She's probably saving face. Look, I don't blame her, these songs are hard. What I want to know, is why they keep making her sing them in the original key instead of playing them at a full or half step down. HELP THIS WOMAN! I don't see why they would want her to suffer.
Uh usually that's done to prevent distortion and blowing speakers with some sound setups. She has such a powerful voice that she needs to move it on the crescendo of some notes.
Her voice and range are so powerful! Her technique also seems to have improved. Kudos to her, the other singers, and the songwriters. It’s not fun to sing in cold weather. 😅 It is alsoreally wise to adapt the key to something more reachable. It shows humility and wisdom.
0:53 This is my favourite part of the song ... so much power I LOVE IT AND I LOVE HER. And she’s doing that thing with the mic to add depth to the sound and so that the tone won’t be too loud for the speakers
Y’all I’m just letting you know that she was quite sick during this- she had a cold like Elsa in frozen fever lol That’s why she sounded tired and stuffy and didn’t look like she was enjoying herself as much as usual. She said in an interview she wasn’t going to do it but she would have felt really bad for the fans so she did it anyway, that’s why it’s in the Lower key.
I kind of wonder who sang the line "You are the one you've been waiting for" That was perfectly timed and was so beautiful. You can tell she did not expect that. But regardless she is still one of my favorite singers. I am obsessed with her frozen songs and she had to dig deep down inside to be able to sing that well in the freezing cold. That right there deserves a standing ovation. She is amazing
The reason she can't sing high notes here is because it's too cold for a full breath soprano, I mean look at the condition do, understanding her is making yourself understandable
If you sing you know how hard this song is AND how hard it is to sing in the cold. After all you are using a lot of muscles and when you’re cold it’s very hard to control them. Idina did great!
I'd like to remind everyone that at least unlike Mariah Carey's live "it was cold out so i lipsynced" b.s., Idina is ACTUALLY singing LIVE in freeeeezing cold weather, and while on vocal rest...seriously....given the press tour they were, she was speaking and probably singing for close to 10 hours a day. Even speaking for extended periods of time is going to weaken/tire your voice out. This was BRILLIANT for the strain her voice is being put under and the conditions. Serious talent in this woman, folks.
You can see when she looks to side at the other performers they know her plight, then again before the big finish when she looks upwards. Bless her got battling on when she wasn't well, and still giving an amazing performance
I'm honestly so proud of her for the way she handled that. I admire the way she overcame that stumble. Performing live is so nerve wrecking and I'm not sure I would have handled it as well. She truly is a professional. Honestly this just made me love her more and gave me a tremendous amount of respect for her.
SHe is the best, that song is very hard, try to rich those notes you all "she missed the note" guys, standing in cold enviroment in not so comfortable outfit. She did it great and smart, besides in one of the interview she told herself that both of her songs will be very hard to sing live. Everybody has limits, and its different when You are recording in studio and you can sing it 10 times before You reach the best version. She is amazing!!!!!
@@idkwhattonamemyself452 Well from what I heard when she is singing her voice isnt wracked, she just have bad and good days, like every singer. As You mention she sang and still sing 8 shows a week on Broadway. From what i know she is 46 or something. Ok not Wicked but in other production. And she really can get high note. Besides she is not like "I am the best you can't tell anything wrong about my performance" She said many times that she hear her mistakes, that she know that this day her performance may not be so good, she isn't selfish claiming to be better than others artist like for example madonna, who lets just say it ,cant and never could sing and without all the electronics would be nothing. I think that some pope are just jelous, I wonder how many of them could reach half of this note that she reaches. Sorry for my english it's not my first language.
I absolutely love Idina! Obviously she has some damage from her time as Elphaba, but she still pulled it off. I’m glad she didn’t attempt things she knows she couldn’t do, especially in that weather. But I see the point as say the Elsa on Broadway, Caissie Levy, had also been Elphaba and now Elsa. Regardless Idina is amazing!
@@alfreddelacruz870 oh, honey. Look I'm sure you sing it great. But unless you are a professional singer, have vocal training and have properly warmed up, I don't think you hit every note. This is one of the hardest Disney songs and not just anybody off the street can sing it. But I'm sure you did well in your attempt.
It’s so cold there. I don’t blame her for missing. She’s also a really busy woman. She still has the most beautiful and perfect voice even like this. Just wow. 👏🏻
i hate her mic movement choices, but i completely agree with her not attempting to hit high notes in freezing weather at night. the voice cannot do it well. the high temperature that day was 52 degrees fahrenheit. and we don't know what time it was there. after sunset, so, temp had probably gone even lower.
As somebody who is a performer, they have speakers all around so if she belted (in cold weather btw) into a mic she'd ruin it by making it pop and give feedback.
Guys, listen don't understand she is doing her best on every show, I mean there's many factors to maybe not sing like before, arnel pineda is having the same, you all have to understand that nothing is forever, they were the greatest singers and they still are but come on time is goin on and they are working and working, so they're not young anymore, they maybe never gonna sing like before but they're still great, and still sings like no one else
My gosh! Stop criticising. For all we know Idina will be the only one who can portray Elsa perfectly. Hands down! I love Idina. Show yourself is the hardest song in the movie. Singing it live with the weather sure portray immense power and courage!! Love you Idina from our family in Oz. Merry Christmas! Btw, We adore you singing in Frozen 2. Made my daughters and I bond stronger and well up together as well. 🤗😊😊
Her vocal chords ARE extremely damaged, she was basically raised on broadway and forced to sing to a degree where she just destroyed her vocal chords, so regardless of whether she was sick or not, they are damaged :L
She was damaged. Every song she sang was not good for her voice, and she obviously has to practice a lot too. Thats pretty painful considering shes been singing like this for at least 2 decades.
cmon guys, there are many factors that already hinders her to perform on the top of her game. She is a gem that should be appreciated more and we know that she already proved her talent to the world many times. I guess that her age is just showing off, that her voice in 2019 is not like her voice in 2003. Btw, she did great in this performace, and she coped up with her capacity during this time. ❤️ Let's just not hate her. ❤️
I’m js I love how everyone in the comments is so supportive💕 usually when idina messes up I see a lot of people saying “oH sHes sO bAd” or “sHes soOo incOnsIstEnt” but I’m just like y’all try singing these songs in the conditions she’s in when she messes up. So thanks everyone for not being dirt bags💞💞.
True vocalist! Some of us have to trickle the end of a note because we can’t sustain it all the time. Sometimes your voice is good and some days it’s not😘
thats called professionalism and knowing your own voice
2.1K likes but no comments? Creppy....
Devilleres Elly Ikr..?
Lol wow how can u do that ???? That u have too much Likes even ur comment isnt important ?
Right! Her voice is incredible so why damage it more after doing broadway 8 times a week for 3 years
Lets call this performance know yourself... and absolutely love idina and what her voice can do.... but thank god she is beeing carefull with her voice here
I feel like Disney is playing a game: “How much vocal damage can we give Idina Menzel in one decade?”
YES
Yeah I feel bad 😞
Yeah
I think that’s why she was given 5 years between movies. I don’t mind waiting if she can heal.
Yeah lol. If they gave me that song I would die. I'm a girl who can't sing very high. Idina has a beautiful voice though that brings life into the movie
just because elsa can handle the cold doesn’t mean idina can,,,
Elsa: the cold never bothered me anyways
Idina: shoot the high note
I’m nit making fun of her just so you know it’s almost impossible to hit that high of a note in the cold
😂😂😂😂😂😂
True xD
HAHAHAHAHA
Exactly Elsa might be queen of ice but the real deal is freezing in this weather
they clearly were working with a scratchy and frankly unsalvagable sound system but the power behind Idina’s belts is still palpable, she did amazing considering the weather.
Lauren Wood it was actually 7pm at night
Brielle C what does that have to do with ANYTHING that they said?
GamingWithZoe they edited their original comment and deleted a reply where they were telling me that Idina sang early in the morning when it was actually at night. I should know - I was there😂
The sound system wasn't scratchy. She moved it away from her and made that sound on purpose because she knew her voice couldn't handle those notes. While the sound system may have problems, most performances will have some sort of problem. Shes done the moving mic away trick lots of other times to save the show because its a professional trick to do when your voice isn't up to it at the moment.
I know you disney fans hate to hear this, but at the end of Frozen 2, Elsa died and turned into a spirit (no true loves kiss to save her). Prove me wrong!
Idina Menzel : How much do you want to damage my voice?
Disney : *yes.*
The Grape Gachacle I didn’t copy it. I thought of it myself
The Grape Gachacle wHaTeVer
The Grape Gachacle copies so many other comments like she copied my comment once and I was really sad
Doge MCBORK༯ loooool
Hawa bagayogo bruh cause there is a comment right under it saying “1 week ago” and this said “5 days ago” 🙄
The hype surrounding Into the Unknown isn’t what it seemed. I say the REAL showstopping song goes to Show Yourself!
Yesssss!!! Totally!
I 1,000% agree. It’s the strongest song in the musical by far.
@@derrtyworks My guess is that's what their intention was.
twist58 ikr
Show yourself is a beautiful song! I cry everytime I listen to it! Into the Unknown is beautiful too, but show yourself really gets me 😭
Everyone: how much vocal damage can disney give Idina???
Disney: *yes.*
You forgot to say yes
I know she did not sound like that in the movie
And wicked☠
I respect you for your profile picture
That’s why she sounds different sometimes. But she still sounds good :)
Show Yourself > Into The Unknown
❄️
Ngl it showed Elsa being herself, which truly made Show Yourself better. Well I feel like Into the unkown and Show yourself, has the same resepect towards eachother.
I also have this thought
me too
I like show yourself
I dont like into the unknown
Show yourself is bealtifull
Into the unknown is a poop
@@pedrozxcnuneszxc5747 into the Unknown is good too. Try to listen on Taeyeon's version. But this song is better than into the Unknown
that song is literally made impossible to sing live. never mind in that cold. you can hear her voice is really tired though
She’s been very busy lately. But she’s still a queen
its her first time singing it live i guess thats why she struggles but her voice is amazingly beautiful btw eventhough she didn't reach that note.
@@Ked012 No , I think it's not her first time 😂 It was cold in there
Disney should really stop writing songs she struggles to sing cause she’s never gonna hit those notes live and people will get pissed at idina, and also idina can maybe damage her voice since she’s constantly busy and rarely gets time to rest. Its kinda a shame how she’s not able to properly take care of her voice, if she keeps this up she’s going to lose it
1K thumbs up and even though she may not have technology to make it sound exactly like in the movie, she still has heart for the song!
I don’t understand why everyone’s like “she missed the note she missed the note” what she did was very smart because she adapted the song to a way she could sing it given the conditions and still sounded absolutely amazing
Edit : thanks for 1k likes omg glad ppl agree she’s amazing
ikr, i think it is better to improvise spontaneously rather than forcing a risky note
Iqbal Romdloni So true if she did it any higher she could have damage her larynx(Voice Box).
Exactly
Any one whose taken vocal lessons or done any amount of performing would agree.
people need to know recordings and studios arent the same as being live. They probably did lots of retakes and put that all together for the actual movie. She can't just sound as nice as she did
This is what taking care of her voice sounds like. Choosing to opt down *is* healthy vocal technique. She's fine, and she sounded incredible!
Idina's tired/damaged voice singing on a cold night still sounds much much better than 80% of pop singers nowadays
They need to stop having her sing in such cold weather when it's hard to breathe. She's a wonderful singer but it's hard on her when it's so cold. I can barely talk when I'm cold like that. I can't imagine singing like that.
The cold doesn't bother her anyway
Agreed like she looks like she is struggling with it 😭😭😭😭😭😭
She has asthma too so that will make it harder
It's also way faster than the movie version, which makes it much harder to sing the big notes.
I think she has asthma too which makes it worse
라이브 듣는거자체만으로 넘좋다 욕하지마ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 저렇게 춥고 열악한 조건에서 라이브 완벽하게 해낼거 아니면
Everyone "Why is everyone giving hate on Idina?"
No one: Giving hate
#Theater Gurl the hate comments are normally at the very bottom
@@nicoleobrien1726 where they belong
Efe Asım ŞİMŞEK Yes cause no one gives a shit about all the hate
Disney, do not abuse this talented woman! She has many difficult songs and cannot perform them in these conditions over and over again.
Imagine going to the store and hearing her voice and being like...Elsa?
Crystal Hart Later when you say Elsa you say: “Knock, knock, knock, knock, knock. Do you wanna build a snowman,?” 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I know your in there
*samantha?*
Crystal Hart i would walk up to her and say " Elsa, i know your in there."
Been waiting for her live version. It may be short but very satisfying.!! Geez, can't wait for her singing this on an awards night
I hope this wins the OSCAR!!!
@@MariahCarey2 an EGOT please, but she got a tight competition with Thr Lion King's Can You Feel the Love Tonight but even though I love Beyonce. This song still is very remarkable
@@simplymiggy Can You Feel The Love Tonight isn't eligible. It was for the animated version, but it's not considered an original song anymore.
@@galegai i see, good to know ..
Miguel Parana tbh idk if we are listening to the same live version
Disney was just playing around with her voice. In the movie, her voice sound a little high, meanwhile in reality, Idina has a deep elegant voice. It's just the autotune, relax yall don't be so disappointed. It's her real voice.
They use a different key in the film. It’s not autotune. They lower it when she performs it live so it’s easier to sing over and over and over. They did the same thing with Let It Go and Into the Unknown.
I believe this is her real voice. My theory is that Disney actually autotunes her voice to be higher to have that youthful sound to it since she has a lower voice register. Same as the other Disney Princesses that has songs. They might also intended to make the live versions in a lower key to avoid straining.
@@이마크-r8e Nah, she's a vocalist and an accomplished actress, she can raise her voice into a higher register. There are plenty of recordings where she's higher without needing autotune. The other Disney princesses haven't been "autotuned" to raise their pitches. Mandy Moore, Kristen Bell, Amy Adams, Lea Salonga, Jodi Benson, etc. all sound the same in real life. Idina raises her voice to play Elsa, because Elsa is significantly younger, but that's the talent of a voice actor, not technology.
Idina sings lower live because she has a lower natural register (which comes with age) and because these songs are written for the studio -- they need to sound the best in the film and on recordings. Live performances are the frosting on the cake, but the studio is the foundation.
@@missalwayswrite Yeah you have a point. After Disney just released the behind the scenes I did realize that she does sing it naturally higher 😅. Still kinda bothers me that she has to maintain that higher pitched voice for some time for her lines in the movie. I do some voice work at school, and it kinda hurts when I do the same voice that is slightly higher. So when I'm a little wonky, our editor slightly corrects it. But then again, I applaud Idina for her work.
um autotune for Idina Menzel? are you kidding 💀
The way she sings at 1:08 gives me chills!!! 💙 I would die for a voice like hers! She’s truly talented and deserves an award for this song!!!
음향 문제도 있고 겨울왕국 노래들이 이디나 멘젤이 완창하기엔 워낙에 자기 키보다 높은 곡이기도 한 듯. 녹음할 때에는 최상의 컨디션으로 부분 부분 나눠서 온 힘을 다해서 부르고 보정도 좀 하니까 영화에서는 깔끔하고 지리게 나오는 거고 라이브를 하기에는 이디나 멘젤한테는 어려운 노래들인 듯. 나이도 있고 목이 많이 상해서 컨디션을 많이 타는 것도 있고.. 영화에서 처럼만 라이브 했다면 훨씬 레전드 취급 받았을지도 몰랐겠지만 그래도 좋은 곡 불러줘서 감사할 뿐.
Roman Race 마이크 문제도 있는것 같은데요
@@우소리-g4x 근데 진짜 음향이 쓰레기이긴 하네유 ㅋ
근데 이디나 멘젤 박자가 너무 빠름
인투디언논 부르는것도 박자 빠르게 부르다가
너무 빨라지니까 느릿느릿 부르면서 맞축ᆢ
@@nonameArtist0_0 이디나 멘젤이 엘사니까 박자가 다 맞을 걸요??
@@nunkoyip 인투언논 라이브하는거 들어봐요
앞에서 노래 빠르게 해가지고 마지막에 How do I follow you 할때 느리게 불러요
Let's appreciate Idina Menzel's effort in singing these vocal demanding songs for us❤SHE'S A LEGEND
항상 라이브로 고음을 지르는건 많이 힘드신가봄. 못부르시는게 아니고 고음내는거만 힘들어 하시는거같음 ㅋㅋ. 솔직히 아쉽긴한데 노래 자체가 고음 투성인데 어려울법하다
고음이 심하게 있죠 아무리 잘 부르는 가수도 저런 고음은 힘듬
근데 탑 뮤지컬 배우시고 뮤지컬 특성상 고음범벅일텐데 게다가 저분 활동시절에는 마이크 보급이 잘안되서 마이크 없이 벨팅으로 했대요. 마이크없이 극장을 소리로 채우시던분이 저러는거보면 목이상한거 아닌가 해서 좀 슬프네요. 목이상해서 그런지 덕분에 허스키한 매력적인 엘사 목소리를 내주시긴 했지만요.
나는 왜 좀낮게 부르는게 궁금했다 그건 민폐가 되서다.
@@모투르 이디나 멘젤 나이도 생각해주셔야해요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Idina is the only person who does not cry singing show yourself😂😭
She’s needs to rest her voice so that she can sing with energy.That’s why she can’t hit the very high notes,she made it lower.
Divina Tancio Ocariza I think I was because of the weather. It was freezing cold
-c r x n g- oh yeah I think so.
She's out of breath too. because of the cold + tired. A lot of ppl doesnt see that 🤦🏻♀️
Maybe good verse, but from that video I get scared
Does high pitch hurt her voice?
idina menzel 성우분 너무 좋아요!! 엘사목소리 너무 좋아요😍 이 노래 부를때 엘사 엄마도 나와서 눈물이 살짝 흘렀네요 ㅎ
I'm so proud of this woman! She did this in this so good!! And for the people who disrespect her: you can try to sing this hard songs, live and in the cold!
Man I felt her pain singing THAT song outside in a NYC December is insane. Bravo for how well she did it under the circumstances 👏👏👏
Nobody cares if she missed the note. She's still an amazing singer and vocal artist
My little brother :
"She sounds like elsa!"
Me:
So cute
Lol Same with my 4 yr old daughter 🤣🤣🤣
It's a Christmas miracle!
wow, i wonder why?
@@stantwicewithallyourheart8624 cause majority of small kids out there don't know that 30-50 year old adults voice their everyday fav Disney characters lol but I definitely understand so they really shouldn't judge their looks all that matters is heir voices since it's animation not actual real life people playing something else,and plus that's how I imagine all of the frozen characters would sound anyways!!!
I'm a 37 year old man with a wife and 3 year old daughter, and cry like a teenager every time I hear this song. It's so powerful and moving, by far the best song to come out of the Frozen series, and in my opinion the whole Disney franchise.
Disney: How did the show go Idina
Idina: *coughs painfully* help me
Screaming 😭😭😭😭😭
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
마이크 왜 저따구야 가수가 다 살렸네
한국인이다!!!!
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ 쌉인정
그게아니라 이디나가 므너무 추운곳에서 부르니깐 목이 얼어붙어서 그런거임
마이크 문제보다... 이디나멘젤이 고음부분을 감당못하니깐 입에서 마이크를 땐거
@@카본-t6q 아 네ㅔ
Anyone who gives Idina crap needs to understand how much she's put into not just her sing but her acting. It's hard enough recording an album, let alone singing in the cold. You can hear how tired she is in her voice and bless this woman for doing what she could so she didn't hurt herself anymore than she already was. She's the original singer, if she wants to change it guess what, she can it's her choice. Brava Idina, keep on being the amazing person we all know you are. I'm still wanting to see this, and might take the day off tomorrow and see it.
I love her voice. No ones voice can be that POWERFUL. A reason she voiced Elsa, comes with so much work and practice and its Idina Menzel she works so hard. I appreciate that and I love her. I'm a big fan.
Singing outside in a very cold weather. Big respect! She's amazing ❤
Omfg. Her voice.... I’m sorry. But it genuinely makes me tear up every time I hear it. It’s genuinely so beautiful. Frozen and Frozen 2 makes me cry. I would listen to her music if she decided to release an album lowkey.
마이크가..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 우리나라 코노 마이크가 더 좋을듯
ㅋ인정
ㅇㅈ
쌉인정ㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋ
She lets her voice take the damage and she doesn’t lip sync like other singers wow
Did anyone else hear a little Defying Gravity at the very end?
It has to be muscle memory for her to do that.
ALSO. I really don't think she could either hear herself or the music. Its very clear there were audio issues.
”Its time tryyyyy-- SHOW YOURSELF!!”
Yes, not just at the end in between as well hehe..
I think the song in general has a quite a "Wicked witch" vibe
Omg Yass as soon as I heard show yourself for the first time I immediately thought they were copying the “a-ah-a-ah-a” from defying gravity lmao
She did an amazing job given the weather that was endured there, she looks so exhausted!
Love her voice,no other actress can sing like that from Disney Movies
Anna buturlina russian Elsa
목이 많이 아프신가 보다.. 그리고 추운데 ㅜㅜ 근데 그런데도 잘부르신다 ㅜㅜ 그리고 못부른다고 하시는 분들 뭐임? 자기들이 나와서 사람 많은 곳 에서 노래 불러보세요.. 춥고 힘든데 ㅋㅋ 게다가 목도 아픈데 ㅋㅋ 제발 못 부른다고 하지 마세요...
그리고 이번 노래들이 전작보다 훨씬 어려워요...음도 더 높고 난이도 있어서 쉽지 않죠...ㅠㅠ
Such a fantastic voice!!!!!☺️🙂
yes! She's amazing! :)
Honestly what she did was very smart. You can tell that her voice was not having it in the cold weather, and probably was very tired. As a singer myself, sometimes you gotta find a way around that big high note when you know it could damage your voice even worse than it is. Vocalists know their voices. I had to change some of the high notes in the show I’m in for a couple of nights because I was sick, and now that I’m back in my third weekend I can hit them again. It just be like that sometimes. I love love love her voice, I’m so glad she decided to preserve it
I love how she knows that her voice won't be able to take it, so she moves the Mic away. Shows charector
yes! That's what I thought!
Mur Mur I think she’s just used to doing that. In broadway, the mic is always attached to her so she can move her arms wherever she wants. In concerts she usually keeps the mic on the stand, so i think it’s just a force of habit moving her arms away
its also an uncertanity type thing. being a singer myself ive experience sometimes the fear of screwing it up makes one do that. the bad thing here is she moved it away on some notes that you can tell she actually hit well. she´s probably not used to singing this live.
ChimneySweep07 Thats also a good point. I do believe this is the first time she’s sing show yourself live, so I’m sure eventually she will become more comfortable with it.
ChimneySweep07 Anyway, shes still an incredible singer and I’m excited to see what’s to come from her
this song iS sooooo HARD to sing... i dont blame idina for sounding a little off/weird
She is singing in cold
She had a colddddd
I think idinas real singing ,voice is this cool.and its a bit different from elsa..she has to mould herself into elsa to show shes singing for her..this makes her very awesome..
Missed a note? No, she stuck within a range that was safe for her voice. The only problem I see here is her mic control which was weird to say the least, unless they were supposed to add some sustain or something similar (which clearly never happened).
Edit: I see a lot of people mentioning her moving the mic away to save face, but she's still singing the notes and hitting them at the same volume (you can literally hear this). I really think she was instructed to move the mic away so they could add effects (which never came off).
NotMyName I think she might not have been able to hear herself properly so she was just doing it as a precaution even though it turned out she didn’t need to as she hit the notes
She does this in EVERY performace. Check out the other live performances of Into The Unknown. No one can honestly believe that someone is trying to add effects in every performance. She's probably saving face.
Look, I don't blame her, these songs are hard. What I want to know, is why they keep making her sing them in the original key instead of playing them at a full or half step down. HELP THIS WOMAN! I don't see why they would want her to suffer.
Uh usually that's done to prevent distortion and blowing speakers with some sound setups. She has such a powerful voice that she needs to move it on the crescendo of some notes.
even if her voice is damaged and shes struggling i still am getting chills. she's so incredibly talented and giving it her all.
Her voice and range are so powerful! Her technique also seems to have improved. Kudos to her, the other singers, and the songwriters. It’s not fun to sing in cold weather. 😅 It is alsoreally wise to adapt the key to something more reachable. It shows humility and wisdom.
I say Let It Go, When We’re Together, and Show Yourself are equally phenomenal songs!
into the unknown is better than show yourself in my opinion
sofia jerez Yes, but not quite impactful as Let It Go.
Show yourself is better than let it go
Everyone is just fighting here this is better nope that in my opinion all are best
Show yourself is the new let it go and into the unknown is the new how far I'll go
She still sounds amazing even in the cold weather!!
Im just speechless...
Her voice is sooo beautiful...
0:53 This is my favourite part of the song ... so much power I LOVE IT AND I LOVE HER. And she’s doing that thing with the mic to add depth to the sound and so that the tone won’t be too loud for the speakers
Y’all I’m just letting you know that she was quite sick during this- she had a cold like Elsa in frozen fever lol
That’s why she sounded tired and stuffy and didn’t look like she was enjoying herself as much as usual.
She said in an interview she wasn’t going to do it but she would have felt really bad for the fans so she did it anyway, that’s why it’s in the Lower key.
Yeah you can tell, it was also really cold over there that night and as you may know, it's hard to do that.
Harmonizer which interview?
I kind of wonder who sang the line "You are the one you've been waiting for" That was perfectly timed and was so beautiful. You can tell she did not expect that. But regardless she is still one of my favorite singers. I am obsessed with her frozen songs and she had to dig deep down inside to be able to sing that well in the freezing cold. That right there deserves a standing ovation. She is amazing
Thank you so much for posting this!!!!
you're welcome! :)
The reason she can't sing high notes here is because it's too cold for a full breath soprano, I mean look at the condition do, understanding her is making yourself understandable
I think she sounds absolutely wonderful. She does seem a bit tired though, nothing to do with her voice.
Merida watson she was in the cold. that was so impresive
Merida watson she was also sick during this
@@mercytherat with what?
@@thatgirlcc5553 wdym with what
@@mercytherat what was she sick with?
If you sing you know how hard this song is AND how hard it is to sing in the cold. After all you are using a lot of muscles and when you’re cold it’s very hard to control them. Idina did great!
I'd like to remind everyone that at least unlike Mariah Carey's live "it was cold out so i lipsynced" b.s., Idina is ACTUALLY singing LIVE in freeeeezing cold weather, and while on vocal rest...seriously....given the press tour they were, she was speaking and probably singing for close to 10 hours a day. Even speaking for extended periods of time is going to weaken/tire your voice out. This was BRILLIANT for the strain her voice is being put under and the conditions. Serious talent in this woman, folks.
You can see when she looks to side at the other performers they know her plight, then again before the big finish when she looks upwards. Bless her got battling on when she wasn't well, and still giving an amazing performance
영화에서만 잘하면 되죠뭐 라이브가 뭐가 중요함 나이도 있으신데 날씨도 추운데 목좀 사리셔서 가능하면 겨울왕국3도 찍으셔야 될텐데..안되겠다...
살짝 마이크탓도 있는거 같아요
I'm honestly so proud of her for the way she handled that. I admire the way she overcame that stumble. Performing live is so nerve wrecking and I'm not sure I would have handled it as well. She truly is a professional. Honestly this just made me love her more and gave me a tremendous amount of respect for her.
What a powerful voice! Omg! I am amazed how she put it so perfect in her voice...
Show yourself and Into the Unknown are really the key of the entire movie. But Show Yourself is like a hit deeper
SHe is the best, that song is very hard, try to rich those notes you all "she missed the note" guys, standing in cold enviroment in not so comfortable outfit. She did it great and smart, besides in one of the interview she told herself that both of her songs will be very hard to sing live. Everybody has limits, and its different when You are recording in studio and you can sing it 10 times before You reach the best version. She is amazing!!!!!
kamarza And she’s approaching her 50s. She sang defying gravity eight times week every week for years. You can tell it’s wrecked her voice.
@@idkwhattonamemyself452 Well from what I heard when she is singing her voice isnt wracked, she just have bad and good days, like every singer. As You mention she sang and still sing 8 shows a week on Broadway. From what i know she is 46 or something. Ok not Wicked but in other production. And she really can get high note. Besides she is not like "I am the best you can't tell anything wrong about my performance" She said many times that she hear her mistakes, that she know that this day her performance may not be so good, she isn't selfish claiming to be better than others artist like for example madonna, who lets just say it ,cant and never could sing and without all the electronics would be nothing. I think that some pope are just jelous, I wonder how many of them could reach half of this note that she reaches. Sorry for my english it's not my first language.
I absolutely love Idina! Obviously she has some damage from her time as Elphaba, but she still pulled it off. I’m glad she didn’t attempt things she knows she couldn’t do, especially in that weather. But I see the point as say the Elsa on Broadway, Caissie Levy, had also been Elphaba and now Elsa. Regardless Idina is amazing!
For me, i actually don't think it's hard cause i always sing this everytime when i heard this song.
@@alfreddelacruz870 oh, honey. Look I'm sure you sing it great. But unless you are a professional singer, have vocal training and have properly warmed up, I don't think you hit every note. This is one of the hardest Disney songs and not just anybody off the street can sing it. But I'm sure you did well in your attempt.
It’s so cold there. I don’t blame her for missing. She’s also a really busy woman. She still has the most beautiful and perfect voice even like this.
Just wow. 👏🏻
Such raw power in her voice. No autotune needed, its perfection
Idina I know you'll never see this but I'm sending you all my ♡. You got it. Nobody could've sang this song the way you did.
She always says singing Elsa requires a ton of prep. She has a bit of trouble singing her big numbers live for that reason
캐릭터 엘사가 부르던 그 노랫소리가 사람 입에서 나오는 걸 보니까 진짜 신기하다💙
It is impossible to sing in cold temperatures... hats off to miss Idina, I have literally lost my voice while singing live in cold temps.
i hate her mic movement choices, but i completely agree with her not attempting to hit high notes in freezing weather at night. the voice cannot do it well. the high temperature that day was 52 degrees fahrenheit. and we don't know what time it was there. after sunset, so, temp had probably gone even lower.
As somebody who is a performer, they have speakers all around so if she belted (in cold weather btw) into a mic she'd ruin it by making it pop and give feedback.
She fricking tried
Man I’m scared to see her voice her in 28 degrees Fahrenheit
The three trashcan Shobers aw crap-
Also it sounded like there were audio issues in a few parts of the song that may have been related to the sound tech as well.
This deserved to be nominated for the Oscar. It was way better than Into the Unknown!
Her high note is not a joke, idina u r voice is so beautiful and magical
she did amazing I can’t get enough her amazing voice 🤩
I love Idina Menzel this is the best singer
the wickedly talented. adele dazeem.
Wickedly (get it?)
her voice is EXTREMLY BEAUTIFUL
She's INCREDIBLE!!!
She will never stop shinning.
I feel so bad for her voice was so shaking cuz of the cold but she still did so good!!
Her voice is just out of this world
she is incredible!
Guys, listen don't understand she is doing her best on every show, I mean there's many factors to maybe not sing like before, arnel pineda is having the same, you all have to understand that nothing is forever, they were the greatest singers and they still are but come on time is goin on and they are working and working, so they're not young anymore, they maybe never gonna sing like before but they're still great, and still sings like no one else
"She missed a note" whoever said that, why don't you sing that? You "know" the notes tho.
My gosh! Stop criticising. For all we know Idina will be the only one who can portray Elsa perfectly. Hands down! I love Idina. Show yourself is the hardest song in the movie. Singing it live with the weather sure portray immense power and courage!! Love you Idina from our family in Oz. Merry Christmas! Btw, We adore you singing in Frozen 2. Made my daughters and I bond stronger and well up together as well. 🤗😊😊
OMG that was amazing and especially in the cold I know ur voice is a bit tired but just remember you can do it and to never ever ever give up!😊💕
Idina Menzel you a true legend u bought back my passion for music when I gave in to the difficulties in life 😊😊love you lots
Everyone in these comments: She totally has damaged her vocal cords, you can hear it
Me: um.. she was really sick during this?
Her vocal chords ARE extremely damaged, she was basically raised on broadway and forced to sing to a degree where she just destroyed her vocal chords, so regardless of whether she was sick or not, they are damaged :L
faster jonny you dumb fuck😂😂
She was damaged. Every song she sang was not good for her voice, and she obviously has to practice a lot too. Thats pretty painful considering shes been singing like this for at least 2 decades.
She is?
what te fuch does that mean?
Wow!!!!!! I love her voice and just how she vocalises is AH-MAZING!!
"Cold never bothered her anyway"
Ana Narin I think it really got the best of her this time
I love this song so relaxing beautiful ❤️
She's amazing singing in cold like that
She is a fucking goddess with that voice of hers god damn lol
cmon guys, there are many factors that already hinders her to perform on the top of her game. She is a gem that should be appreciated more and we know that she already proved her talent to the world many times. I guess that her age is just showing off, that her voice in 2019 is not like her voice in 2003.
Btw, she did great in this performace, and she coped up with her capacity during this time. ❤️
Let's just not hate her. ❤️
I’m js I love how everyone in the comments is so supportive💕 usually when idina messes up I see a lot of people saying “oH sHes sO bAd” or “sHes soOo incOnsIstEnt” but I’m just like y’all try singing these songs in the conditions she’s in when she messes up. So thanks everyone for not being dirt bags💞💞.
Still idina is my queen forever
Never found singer tht can hit high note like hundread times
True vocalist! Some of us have to trickle the end of a note because we can’t sustain it all the time. Sometimes your voice is good and some days it’s not😘