Automatic or Manual Car: Which is Best for Indian Consumers

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 січ 2018
  • Automatic Transmission Car Vs Manual Transmission Car with Pros and Cons. क्यूँ Manual कार Better है Automatic Se India में
  • Авто та транспорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 569

  • @ashleysam1971
    @ashleysam1971 4 роки тому +154

    Drive automatic car or manual car, totally your wish.. But try to learn driving in a manual car.

    • @ahteshamkhan665
      @ahteshamkhan665 3 роки тому +2

      Ys u say right,
      If any want first time drive then mannual

  • @Saptarshidey123
    @Saptarshidey123 3 роки тому +12

    The sale of Manual car is particularly high in India. No other country encourages so much manual . We don't want to upgrade ourselves from our tradition. If it is going on for 50 years , so it has to go on in 51 year also.
    No one in today's world wants to make anything complicated hence Automatic gets sold so much outside.
    But yes in India atleast drive manual and adapt by 40%. I have driven both , hands down automatic is convenient more

  • @proartworkscreations1636
    @proartworkscreations1636 6 років тому +18

    I must admit this is the best video that clear the misconceptions about AMT Vs Manual..nice video..I now know what I need

  • @mustanggt5713
    @mustanggt5713 3 роки тому +39

    Automatic cars are purely for convenience only. Being able to drive a manual car is a necessary skill and is cooler too.

    • @Derekjcb
      @Derekjcb 2 роки тому +7

      Horrible experience in traffic

    • @albussd
      @albussd Рік тому +4

      "Cooler"? Hahaha Pardon me but cool gets old real quick once the reality of heavy traffic is faced.

    • @mustanggt5713
      @mustanggt5713 Рік тому

      @@albussd Well, you have a point . Can’t argue .

  • @rambot670
    @rambot670 3 роки тому +10

    Gagan Ji's voice has changed so much on video from 2018 to 2021. Now that's progress :)
    Wonder why I was recommended this video after so many years.

  • @aksrawat
    @aksrawat 5 років тому +3

    बहुत बढ़िया brother 👍👍👍
    बहुत अच्छे ढंग से बताते हो।😊
    Keep growing with your viewership 👍

  • @anilkamble5084
    @anilkamble5084 6 років тому +5

    Awesome man ....
    Kay samjayla
    Great just great,👌👌👌👌👍👍👍

  • @GLBravi
    @GLBravi 5 років тому +1

    Its very good video for my experiance .....
    You are a good speaker ....
    Bhot acha laga aapki baat samjhke.
    Bhoot acheee sir

  • @mohitishaan1731
    @mohitishaan1731 4 роки тому +2

    What to do in AMT when battery goes down. Is it jumpstart like manual

  • @krishnachettri3067
    @krishnachettri3067 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks you have cleared my confusion regarding AMT and manual gear.

  • @Baadshah-Bhai-Sk
    @Baadshah-Bhai-Sk 4 роки тому +1

    Sir aapne bohat achi trah se samjhaya..bohat achi video h..ye ...nice information

  • @mohulghosh8467
    @mohulghosh8467 4 роки тому +12

    I think Manual transmission is best...
    You can play with your car

  • @chandramohanty
    @chandramohanty 4 роки тому +8

    You got a Subscriber. Your voice is very soothing to the ears

  • @sim_1017
    @sim_1017 2 роки тому +4

    Is paddle shifter necessary in AMT as it already comes with M+ and M- option?

  • @anujsalvi6942
    @anujsalvi6942 3 роки тому

    Is Honda amaze CVT a good option?? or jazz manual.. I have city and highway driving needs..

  • @superunconventional
    @superunconventional 6 років тому

    I am planning to buy an Ignis petrol sigma. It doesnt have a tachometer. How will I change gear appropriately ?

  • @siddhanthbhattacharya5160
    @siddhanthbhattacharya5160 5 років тому +1

    Sir which makes much more sense to buy skoda rapid dsg or the Honda city vx manual... ??. Which one of these ticks all the boxes of convenience safety and driving thrill.... sir please do reply as we are confused...

  • @AdityaAshokSharma
    @AdityaAshokSharma 4 роки тому +33

    In dense countries like ours, automatics are a boon, and ur family will find them easier to drive too, unlike a manual. U may end up being the driver of ur family if u get a manual car.

  • @atulbawaskar8545
    @atulbawaskar8545 5 років тому +2

    Sir
    how is Hyundai Xcent petrol automatic?
    Or other option ?

  • @rohitsarangal4285
    @rohitsarangal4285 5 років тому

    I faced such problem in car when I pulled out my car from basement of mall..it's stucked for sometime then pull out..but in ground area automatic is ok...I always looking for either is it good for hilly area or not while carried too much lugeage and members?

  • @thrivenkumaryanamandram9834
    @thrivenkumaryanamandram9834 4 роки тому +2

    Sir, I have trouble while driving uphill So I thought of buying a Hyundai creta 1.4 DCT for easy uphill driving and better performance. Do you think it is good choice?

  • @SandhyaRamachandran
    @SandhyaRamachandran 6 років тому +1

    ARE the points that you mentioned for Automatic cars also applicable for AMT cars ? regarding maintenance, cost of repair etc.

  • @deepakswami2029
    @deepakswami2029 6 років тому

    I was searching for such detailed comparison...thanks a ton sir

  • @vinaybhoopalam1782
    @vinaybhoopalam1782 3 роки тому +1

    Sir, should I go for petrol DCT or Diesel torque converter.

  • @vinodtare7359
    @vinodtare7359 3 роки тому

    Please advise if creta 2020 automatic is better? Is there a difference in mileage you get

  • @10anshul98710
    @10anshul98710 5 років тому

    Very informative video. Really helpful!

  • @nubhaskar3842
    @nubhaskar3842 5 років тому +4

    Good advice. Thank you very much such realistic information

  • @charanpradhan8874
    @charanpradhan8874 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks a lot, गुरुदेव !

  • @SanjayVermadev
    @SanjayVermadev 6 років тому

    Thank you so much for clearing my doubts....

  • @shrinivashalbe6657
    @shrinivashalbe6657 5 років тому +2

    Very very nice information sir, Thanks a Lot sir🙏🌷

  • @rakeshkrishnaraj1755
    @rakeshkrishnaraj1755 3 роки тому +8

    I am lucky to have both. Hyundai i10 auto and a i10 grand manual. Automatic transmission is a breeze to drive. Smooth as silk. Manual is more fun in changing and engaging the gears. Auto is best for city traffic conditions, manual fun on highway with better control . .... To sum up. To each his own..

  • @nagapavankumarkalepu5231
    @nagapavankumarkalepu5231 5 років тому

    I am confused between buying honda city petrol zx version manual and honda city zx version cvt..
    If I buy cvt, do I lose driving experience like over taking etc...?

  • @Nileshsingh3112
    @Nileshsingh3112 6 років тому

    Kindly reply which 1 is d GD 1 tk breeza or s cross

  • @arynbutolavlogs5470
    @arynbutolavlogs5470 4 роки тому

    Hills area k liye sahi rhega automatic gadi ...kahi high m jate time chadte time problem nhi krega ye ...plzz bta doo

  • @sureshpatel1313
    @sureshpatel1313 6 років тому +17

    Thank Q , GAGAN sir, for your valuable advice on Skoda rapid, diesel automatic transmission. Sir I am a very happy fan you. Thank Q once again.

  • @annakolhe5061
    @annakolhe5061 4 роки тому

    1 Hil hold
    2 Padal shifft
    Konsi kar me hai sir AMT me

  • @probuzz
    @probuzz 3 роки тому

    Jabardast. Very nicely explained. Cleared my dilemma between manual and automatic.thank you.

  • @Mushyyyy1173
    @Mushyyyy1173 4 роки тому

    Sir. Now new creta sx (0) is coming with cvt (ivt) with hil hold assist and paddle shifters.i am thinking of buying this car with petrol.as per your information both the things are there in that car.i ask you is there anything other than this ? If no then i willgk for it

  • @angelopereira4871
    @angelopereira4871 5 років тому +3

    Thanks for the info. Excellent delivery.

  • @waytovijay
    @waytovijay 3 роки тому

    Sir which is beeter in highway automatic and manual?

  • @reetbhat
    @reetbhat 5 років тому +1

    Very well said and well described. Thank you so much.

  • @tsn_7xi
    @tsn_7xi 4 роки тому

    Thank you! Very informative

  • @amarg2199
    @amarg2199 3 роки тому +1

    Jazz cvt got both of them. Hill hold assist.......paddle shift + cruise control. Very good review.

  • @amitagrawal3679
    @amitagrawal3679 6 років тому +1

    Thanks Sir...Very helpful for everyone. Nice N perfect review

  • @gold7771
    @gold7771 6 років тому +1

    Good work, keep it up, Gagan!!

  • @aananthanarayanan8853
    @aananthanarayanan8853 4 роки тому +1

    Very convincing, after listening to you one should not have any confusion .👍👍👍

  • @vipulvasava4289
    @vipulvasava4289 3 роки тому +1

    VERY INFORMATIVE SIR..KEEP ON...

  • @satyapany3231
    @satyapany3231 3 роки тому +1

    Sir, can you please make a video on Braking system of automatic or automated mini SUV, and suggest which one is more effective

  • @manjunath7497
    @manjunath7497 4 роки тому +1

    Hi sir,
    I'm buying tigor XZ 2018 petrol 28k driven ...grey ...with Tata P2P for 5lakh in Bangalore Karnataka.
    Is that reasonable?
    I have seen car , its in good condition.

  • @ImlisunupLemtur
    @ImlisunupLemtur 5 років тому

    is manual gear is less expensive than automatic gear on repairing ?

  • @SkrillexGaming7
    @SkrillexGaming7 6 років тому +1

    Thnx sir,It Helped Us A Lot

  • @krishankr.3935
    @krishankr.3935 4 роки тому

    which should beginners buy automatic or manual ??

  • @dnyaneshpachange6852
    @dnyaneshpachange6852 5 років тому

    Thanks very much for the information

  • @SDkulkarni
    @SDkulkarni 5 років тому +1

    Really very informative video

  • @jazzysinghkhalsa7880
    @jazzysinghkhalsa7880 4 роки тому

    Sirji.. Aapne ek video mein yeh bataya tha ki... Kaun si Accessories humein showroom se hi leni chahiye... So could u help me in that case i wana c it again

  • @Aabraka_dabra326
    @Aabraka_dabra326 3 роки тому +1

    tnx for helping to everyone

  • @pkr7560
    @pkr7560 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks sir i was really confused betwen auto and manual but after watching this video i will ho with manual only

  • @himanshubhardwaj1848
    @himanshubhardwaj1848 5 років тому +3

    Very useful video...👍👍

  • @kunshtiwati2560
    @kunshtiwati2560 3 роки тому

    वेरी नाइस ऑब्जर्वेशन/एनालिसिस।बधाइयां👍

  • @sankalpdhande2432
    @sankalpdhande2432 5 років тому

    konsi car best he amt ya manual

  • @adityadhakne1036
    @adityadhakne1036 5 років тому +1

    Gagan sir superb Explanation 👌 every doubt is cleared Please Expain What PADDLE SHIFTERS And how to use them please sir please

  • @rachit365
    @rachit365 6 років тому +2

    Good information...thnks

  • @nikhilmirchandani2588
    @nikhilmirchandani2588 3 роки тому

    Creta 2020 Diesel Manual or Automatic Which 1 to buy...? @Mycarhelpline

  • @danishpk1
    @danishpk1 5 років тому +76

    I have a automatic car in UAE last 5 years i am using very smooth and easy to drive. Now i buy automatic car in india also. Very easy to drive as usual. But people are started telling why you brought automatic cars why you didn't buy manual something like that. Then i asked them " did you ever drive automatic car " they all used to say "No" someone said " 1 time i drive "
    Thats what they didn't like automatic cars. If someone drive couple of weeks automatic cars. They never buy manual i am damn sure about that....😎😎

    • @halfdreamldn9128
      @halfdreamldn9128 5 років тому +2

      Mere pass bhi uae manual laicens h Pr manual to manual hi h bhai

    • @chars_78
      @chars_78 5 років тому +6

      Manual is always better.

    • @ipraveensemwal
      @ipraveensemwal 5 років тому +8

      Obviously automatic driver will drive automatic like in US where 99% cars are automatic coz they don't know to drive manual but this is India and here AMT is mostly used which is cheapest and worst automatic version or it's basically Manual transmission with AMT kit which is nonsense in driving so Indian people don't like AMT but they like CVT, DCT which are tradition automatic which are used in US.

    • @bsshabbirmemon9139
      @bsshabbirmemon9139 5 років тому

      true says

    • @Countrysideboy247
      @Countrysideboy247 5 років тому +1

      danishpk1 yes ,for some non petrolheads like you!

  • @atikurrahman7024
    @atikurrahman7024 4 роки тому +1

    Very Informative....👍

  • @dm5665
    @dm5665 5 років тому +19

    Thanks for bringing clarity. Automatic is good only when engine is more powerful with paddle shift and HA. Like VW polo, Vento , Hexa etc. Never worry about mileage, else it will be a pain for everyone.

  • @sach_in
    @sach_in 5 років тому +1

    very well said brother....very informative

  • @ilyastahir4285
    @ilyastahir4285 5 років тому +2

    Thanks brother

  • @nithyakarthikeya2590
    @nithyakarthikeya2590 4 роки тому

    I'm confused AMT or MT Sedan or SUV I'm looking petrol variant Hyundai Venue Manual Transmission SUV and Sedan Hyundai AUR AMT which one is good Hyundai MT Clutch is smooth and hard and AMT Is good or bad which one is good please help me

  • @hamidqadeer9389
    @hamidqadeer9389 6 років тому

    What is your take on Honda BR V Automatic or Manual?

  • @kalpeshbharbhidiya5867
    @kalpeshbharbhidiya5867 4 роки тому

    Sir automatic car ak sath kitni km chal sakti hai plz repla

  • @ronaldvinuth7349
    @ronaldvinuth7349 5 років тому +1

    Thank you.

  • @smmehar4021
    @smmehar4021 3 роки тому

    Very nice information in a simple way😊

  • @digantchaudhury175
    @digantchaudhury175 5 років тому +2

    Very nice explanation

  • @Yogesh27797
    @Yogesh27797 3 роки тому

    Are honda cars maintenance costly? 🙄
    If we buy a second hand CNG fitted Amaze 2016, will it worth for around 4 lakhs.

  • @pavinrz8697
    @pavinrz8697 5 років тому

    Ghagan, what car you drive?

  • @damyoutube9991
    @damyoutube9991 3 роки тому +1

    Sir Aaj Kia and venue is giving this ...👍👍👍 salute to your knowledge

  • @digitallearner1798
    @digitallearner1798 5 років тому +4

    Very helpful video👍( now I prefer manual)

  • @ravigangadharcs
    @ravigangadharcs 5 років тому

    Sir ! How about Honda jazz automatic high end

  • @nikhilmirchandani2588
    @nikhilmirchandani2588 3 роки тому

    Creta Diesel Manual or Automatic Which to buy ..?

  • @pankajpande5118
    @pankajpande5118 5 років тому

    Which is better Mt or Amt

  • @sureshpatel1313
    @sureshpatel1313 6 років тому +3

    Thank Q , GAGAN bhai, very detailed explained, for automatic vehicles, I really appreciate and fan of you Sir, can you please suggest me shall I go for Rapid diesel automatic , but there no paddle shifters it will be any problem in city or on Highways, or else suggest me automatic with paddle shifters sedan diesel budget some upward also OK sir.

    • @mycarhelpline
      @mycarhelpline  6 років тому +1

      Hello, Skoda Rapid DSG is advanced and comes with Tiptronic Transmission where you can override using D minus on the gear. Also has sport mode to it to downshift the gear and let the car moves in a higher torque band. No need of any paddle shifts in Rapid. Its the best Automatic to drive in segment

  • @mehtabshaikh84
    @mehtabshaikh84 5 років тому +1

    Nice information 👍

  • @bhavinpatel9901
    @bhavinpatel9901 6 років тому +3

    What about swift dzire automatic review plz

  • @vaibhavchaturvedi4720
    @vaibhavchaturvedi4720 4 роки тому

    Your website and videos are always fantastic. But I guess you can make the videos at a better place.

  • @senthilkumarkckumar8091
    @senthilkumarkckumar8091 5 років тому +3

    I book today swift amt vxi
    your comment i see
    I changed manual swift car vxi
    Thanks to you sir

  • @kshitizgupta4405
    @kshitizgupta4405 4 роки тому +4

    Hello!!
    Your videos are really informative and helpful. You have not talked about dual clutch transmission in this video. Please make a video on dual clutch transmission also.

    • @mycarhelpline
      @mycarhelpline  4 роки тому +4

      Sure the video is 2 years old and that time only handful of cars were there, will consider an update on to it

  • @sunilkuldeepsonu
    @sunilkuldeepsonu 6 років тому +5

    Lekon amt ko manual bhi to chla skte he na

  • @pradeepsharma-fv8pp
    @pradeepsharma-fv8pp 2 роки тому

    Which is best Amy or manual

  • @avhishekroy3045
    @avhishekroy3045 4 роки тому

    Sir please review on sports variant of cars, like swift, EcoSport, or any cars of mahindra

  • @AERight462
    @AERight462 5 років тому +53

    I was confused between AT n MT.... Now I am happy..... I got the answer MT. 😂 😂 😂 😂

  • @naroladangti7697
    @naroladangti7697 4 роки тому

    Very nice detailed info

  • @expectanything8613
    @expectanything8613 6 років тому

    where to get a used tuv 300 amt checked before buying? does tuv AMT has hill hold asst.? is this vehicle advisable or manual?

    • @mycarhelpline
      @mycarhelpline  6 років тому

      Avoid AMT - recommended to go with Manual
      Also before buying check whether Wheel spin issue exists or MLD been added - refer - www.mycarhelpline.com/index.php?option=com_easydiscuss&view=post&id=23498&Itemid=78

  • @KuldeepSingh-cm3oe
    @KuldeepSingh-cm3oe 4 роки тому +3

    Always Manual is Best, it gives the full control on the car for a driver. People who enjoy car driving, manual is the right choice of transmission.

  • @JaiShriRam...108
    @JaiShriRam...108 6 років тому

    Tiago AMT OR Manual transmission main CNG lagwa sakte hai?Sir, I want to buy an AMT car but in near future, i want to shift to CNG. Which AMT cars would be suitable for CNG Conversion. Tiago or ignis?if I purchased tiago manual transmission can I do conversation in cng? Or only Celerio cng option for me....Daily run 45 KM

  • @nagendrabbm
    @nagendrabbm 3 роки тому

    Good information sir 👍

  • @MNIKHAn7
    @MNIKHAn7 4 роки тому

    Automatic mein bhi downshift karne ka options hai use D mein lake +ya- kar sakte hai

  • @abhijitghatak9575
    @abhijitghatak9575 6 років тому +1

    Superb.

  • @Amitphartiyal
    @Amitphartiyal 6 років тому

    really good

  • @suryapratapsingh5580
    @suryapratapsingh5580 6 років тому +1

    sir dealer not allow to buy insurance from outside plz help hwo i can compain agenest dearler please help us. dealer of maruti suzuki is looting us ..dearler offer higher price insurnace and i see coverfox website same insurance in lower price ..what can i do

    • @technoparadise1746
      @technoparadise1746 6 років тому

      oNe WoRlD OnE LiFe u can very well insurance done from outside.either complaint to manager or cancel ur booking