A Dramatic home design | Living Room Inspiration | $15 versus $633

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лип 2022
  • A Dramatic home design | Living Room Inspiration | $15 versus $633
    #homedesign #livingroomdecor #thrifthaul
    Follow me over on Instagram🤍 / sarahs.octoberhome_
    Please let me know which Rug you prefer? Thrifted or New?🤍
    Shop my Favorite Amazon Finds🤍✨
    Sconce🤍amzn.to/3J3LfaC
    Leg Makeup🤍amzn.to/3z4lEKa
    Glass straws🤍amzn.to/3cAGxVC
    Glass jars with Bamboo Lids🤍amzn.to/3Owf3Of

КОМЕНТАРІ • 874

  • @MartinlovesFrances
    @MartinlovesFrances 2 роки тому +65

    Yes start with the nice thrifted one. You can always change it after you lived with it after a while. You might even find another thrifted one like you always do that you like even more than the new one. And you could always wait for a sale on the new. Definitely would not suggest spending on new if you don't completely love it or not sure. Have fun decorating!

  • @stacybohannon6001
    @stacybohannon6001 2 роки тому +38

    The thrifted rug is my pick for your home. It adds charm and pulls all the colors in. Prayers answered and price is awesome. Put room together with each rug and see what you think. 🙏

  • @jadestone8552
    @jadestone8552 2 роки тому +26

    When you unrolled the thrifted rug my first thought was “wow that’s gorgeous.”
    It is a gorgeous rug! But when I saw the muted “faded” looking new rug I thought that would be beautiful in her room.
    Now, it would take a little bit of time, but what I would do is put one rug down, decorate my living room like I wanted with things I have. Take pictures and live with it a week. Second week do the very same thing with the other rug. Take pictures and live with it for a week. Then you will be able to make a better decision on which you love the best and want to live with. The other thing to consider while doing this is long time satisfaction. Because $630 would not be easy to replace if you didn’t like it..the thrifted rug$15 you would not think twice because it was such a good deal.
    I hope these suggestions help you.

  • @josephineh2767
    @josephineh2767 2 роки тому +18

    Love the thrifted rug, the green and tan looks so warm and inviting. The other one looks a little bland to me. For $15 I would keep it, later if you find one you like better, you can change it up. The Lord answered your prayer.

  • @vintagewidow
    @vintagewidow 2 роки тому +34

    My vote is YES on the 15$ rug! Great find!!

  • @donnaendres3235
    @donnaendres3235 2 роки тому +15

    I love the thrifted rug, it is gorgeous! The new one is gorgeous too but $15 is too good to pass up.

  • @eunicenield9631
    @eunicenield9631 2 роки тому +24

    I really like the thrifted rug. I think it looks elegant with your decor. I don’t think I would spend $600 for a rug that looks worn. I would definitely go with the $15 rug. However, you have to decide what you like best.

  • @sundipugh2235
    @sundipugh2235 2 роки тому +30

    The thrifted rug is beautiful! I love the richness of color and it has a grounding aspect for the room.

  • @ellaaltman2137
    @ellaaltman2137 2 роки тому +14

    Personally, I feel rug #2 is more in keeping with the overall look you are trying to achieve. I would clean the $15 rug and place it on FB Marketplace and this will offset the cost of the new even if just a tiny bit and know that it's going to someone who loves it. Thanks for sharing.

    • @janicegardner5027
      @janicegardner5027 2 роки тому

      Great idea! She could get at least 80 - 100 for the thrifted rug and that would take the price down on the new rug~

  • @deniseborchardt4491
    @deniseborchardt4491 2 роки тому +20

    I didn't read the comments to sway my opinion. You have 2 great options! When you laid out the 1st rug, I said to the computer "Put your artwork,etc. next to the rug" and then you did for the 2nd rug. They both look nice. With the 1st rug, all you see is the pretty rug. Your eye is drawn to that. The 2nd rug is almost quieter and let's the accessories share in the limelight. Without seeing everything in place, I would maybe vote for the 2nd one. I know the 1st one is a great deal. For that price, I would probably even just hang onto it.

    • @SarahsOctoberHome
      @SarahsOctoberHome  2 роки тому +1

      Denise, you are correct about the rugs.🥰

    • @mamuklutze6474
      @mamuklutze6474 2 роки тому +1

      I agree that although both are beautiful the Loloi is not overpowering. Whatever you go with will work.
      So praying about a rug may seem silly to us but I don't think so at and I don't believe that our heavenly father thinks so either. Pray about everything nothing is neither too big nor too small for our God. He looks at out heart🙏🏽

  • @cindyschenk6824
    @cindyschenk6824 2 роки тому +10

    I love the new rug, the moss salman color. I can't get over how well your prints and decor go with it. I totally understand the price and wanting the thrifted, but man...that second rug just looks amazing with your room

  • @oldfashiondolls
    @oldfashiondolls 2 роки тому +6

    I love how you prayed specifically for a thrifted rug. I have done that too, and God had answered by providing specific items for a reasonable price at thrift stores. I see it as a way I am honoring him with my money, and God has blessed that.

  • @susancaupp7546
    @susancaupp7546 2 роки тому +8

    I love bargains but my pick is the vintage inspired rug with your decor. It’s a hard choice but I think the thrifted rug looks to fancy for your vintage style, but that’s me. You have to love it! I’m sure you will make the best choice for your space. 😀

  • @chriswydra1144
    @chriswydra1144 2 роки тому +7

    I think that the new more subtle rug blends everything in the room beautifully. The thrifted rug seems to be the focal point in the room. Looking at the rest of your house, you seem to like a quieter touch that emphasizes your special finds. I personally get tired of large areas being the first thing you notice in a room.

  • @ashv.g.8126
    @ashv.g.8126 2 роки тому +12

    i really love the trifted rug, it is bold but gorgeous i think it blends beautifully with your other pieces and will tone some of the boldness down once your other pieces are added.

  • @tammyr6669
    @tammyr6669 2 роки тому +8

    Both rugs look nice, but I feel the thrifted rug gives the room the Wow factor and looks great with your artwork and style. Go bold and embrace it! ❤ I love the rich colors against the white!

  • @rosiev3129
    @rosiev3129 2 роки тому +18

    You have to go with your heart on this decision. I'm also all about saving money but if it were me I would go with the new one. The $15 rug is almost to dramatic in your space in my opinion. If you had darker furniture it would work but against the white it screams to loud.😊❤

  • @CraftOManiac
    @CraftOManiac 2 роки тому +12

    Hey Sarah- I say keep the $15.00 dollar rug as a back up; it was only$15.00 and it can be fun to switch things up at some point, plus it’s beautiful. However, I adore the vintage inspired one more. It really goes with your vibe; and frames/art. I am so anticipating your final living room reveal. xoxo Jen 700NCottage

  • @donniekean1541
    @donniekean1541 2 роки тому +3

    Sarah, I so understand your dilemma. My opinion, I think you will get tired of the thrifted rug a lot sooner. I think the new rug is a classic. Honestly, could you put the thrifted rug somewhere else - family room, dining room? Loan to your sister! If they both cost the same amount, which would you choose? Love what you have done so far, enjoy the little glimpses we are getting. Best to you and your family.

  • @clarefrenette9357
    @clarefrenette9357 2 роки тому +18

    Your prayers were answered. The thrifted rug is beautiful in your living room and wow $15. That was heaven sent!♥🙏♥

  • @sandlappersue01
    @sandlappersue01 2 роки тому +8

    I love, love, love the thrifted rug. The other is more trendy right now. The thrifted is more rich and you can build around it with the money saved. I would put a few gilded pieces to match your frames and it would tie in your rug... also maybe a few velvety pieces....pillows or throw or runner on a table to reflect the rug. I would make the rug work somewhere if not there. 😊❤

  • @kimayres7749
    @kimayres7749 2 роки тому +5

    No brainer! You hit the jackpot, a rug that size for $15!!! It's in perfect condition and is very beautiful! And the price difference! It must be nice to have money to spend, but I would definitely go with the thrifted one!

  • @kathleenwoodbury7491
    @kathleenwoodbury7491 2 роки тому +4

    The first rug is dramatic and beautiful and a heck of a great deal, the 2nd one is quieter and will allow all your gorgeous collected pieces to shine! It would be great to save that $600 but I would go with the second one!

  • @oldmaplehome
    @oldmaplehome 2 роки тому +3

    I actually really do like the thrifted rug! I love rugs with a medallion. It has a sophistication to it that you can totally pull off in your living room! 😘

  • @danielleanderson1341
    @danielleanderson1341 2 роки тому +32

    Both! The thrifted rug is so inexpensive and beautiful. Use it as a seasonal change out to refresh the space. The new rug is just as beautiful with a more vintage look. if you were "willing" to pay for the new rug if you liked it better than you are really getting 2 beautiful rugs for the 600ish dollars and the ability to enjoy both since you like them both so much!

  • @carolynauerswald5239
    @carolynauerswald5239 2 роки тому +3

    The money difference is the hard part, but I love the new one with everything you plan to decorate with. I have been looking at those rugs on Amazon and just bought one on prime days and saved so much money.

  • @rhiannancaraway
    @rhiannancaraway 2 роки тому +4

    I would absolutely go with the thrifted rug. It has a story to tell plus you can save all that money for something else. Plus, you prayed for a rug and I believe the Lord gave you what you asked for ❤️

  • @candicethepastorswife7396
    @candicethepastorswife7396 2 роки тому +1

    Sis , I love love the thrifted rug.. I prayed for walking shoes and God blessed me with a brand new pair of Brooks .. I'm so thankful $2 and poshmark they are 49$ but new in store they are $100. God is so good... love and prayers 🙏 ❤

  • @bethjones8190
    @bethjones8190 2 роки тому +2

    The Lola rug is the best choice!

  • @debiwatters4680
    @debiwatters4680 2 роки тому +2

    I would keep them both....use the softer/muted new one in Spring & Summer, switch to the more dramatic/bolder one in Fall and Winter. (I did this in more than one room in my previous home)...now I've downsized, am re-modeling and no where near (lol) choosing rugs! Your room is lovely and I think you'll make the right choice for you. You have an "eye" for sure.

  • @tammypierce3250
    @tammypierce3250 2 роки тому +3

    Definitely the thrifted rug. It’s gorgeous! It really pops with your neutral and white walls and furnishings. And after all you prayed about it and the Lord delivered. 😊😊

  • @cem8205
    @cem8205 2 роки тому +1

    The second rug (not the thrifted one), is beautiful and my pick :). But you do what makes you happy and what makes financial sense for your family :))!

  • @marianneberry44
    @marianneberry44 2 роки тому +4

    To me the new rug fits with your esthetic and has a vintage look. The thrifted rug is a great bargain and really pretty but has a dated look to it more than a vintage look. I'm all for saving money too, so you could keep the bargain rug and live with it for a while then reorder the new one if you find you're not satisfied with the thrift one. You'd only be out $15. Just my thoughts. You have a great eye and will choose well I'm sure. 😇

  • @hopewebb7437
    @hopewebb7437 2 роки тому +4

    I love your style and everything you do! I feel that the new rug works beautifully with your decor. I would choose the vintage inspired rug.

  • @leeannralston3480
    @leeannralston3480 2 роки тому +3

    I like the new rug better because it’s more muted. With the thrifted rug I feel like when you walk into the room it just screams at you with all the ornate, harsh lines, and colors. Plus it seems to small to me for your room. I’m sure you’ll make the best decision because your house is gorgeous and you have excellent taste!!

  • @themississippicottage9395
    @themississippicottage9395 2 роки тому +2

    That first rug is beautiful but the second made me gasp a little...wow, and how beautiful it goes with those antiques 😍. I always think of rugs being like the 'shoes' of a room. It really makes an impact

  • @rebekahfraserhomedecor1
    @rebekahfraserhomedecor1 2 роки тому

    I LOVE that rug!!! $15 dollars is UNREAL! Wow! I would keep it! Your living room is beautiful!

  • @mummyoli6626
    @mummyoli6626 2 роки тому +2

    The new rug, it does match with the your deco , but follow your heart.

  • @JudyCoggins
    @JudyCoggins 2 роки тому +3

    The thrifted rug gets my vote! It’s gorgeous and rich. For $15 live with it for awhile. If you don’t love it, donate it later.

  • @sandravokes7330
    @sandravokes7330 2 роки тому +2

    I absolutely love the thrifted rug. It is so beautiful and the rich colors give a warm feel to the room.

  • @vivan111
    @vivan111 2 роки тому +3

    Love the Lola rug. It is so calm and has all of your colours for the seasons.

  • @maryohare4141
    @maryohare4141 2 роки тому +1

    That thrifted rug is perfect!

  • @sheilasanders7908
    @sheilasanders7908 2 роки тому +2

    LOVE the thrifted rug! It’s so dramatic and perfect for your new room!! Answered prayers!!

  • @julsknapp7192
    @julsknapp7192 2 роки тому +3

    I have to say the vintage inspired rug is gorgeous and the low key design and color palette allow the rest of the room to shine. I think the thrifted one's design is too bold and contrasted.

  • @susanrouppas8777
    @susanrouppas8777 2 роки тому +2

    The vintage inspired is my choice. The thrifted rug is too "in your face" and detracts from your other pretty decor.

  • @karellarsen939
    @karellarsen939 2 роки тому +2

    Hi I love them both, but I would say yes to the thrifted rug for sure! Keep it at least for a second rug to change up your room. I think the thrifted one is very classy 🙏🏻❤️😊

  • @carolbuchel3011
    @carolbuchel3011 2 роки тому +2

    I love the $15 rug! You can always look for another one later if you don't like it! I love, love, love the blouse you are wearing-you look good in color!!

  • @lisatague305
    @lisatague305 2 роки тому +1

    Sarah I think the vintage inspired rug belongs in your gorgeous space . The thrifted rug is ok ,but in my opinion it isn’t large enough and the pattern is defined . I like an all over pattern . A rug can make or break a room and if you have the money , vintage inspired rug for sure . Good luck sweet Sarah .

  • @annacarmack7698
    @annacarmack7698 2 роки тому +1

    I really like the second rug. It complements your decor.

  • @pollyporter-campbell7493
    @pollyporter-campbell7493 2 роки тому

    Love the thrifted rug. It looks good with your furnishings...especially if you pull both couches up onto it to make it part of the room.

  • @joycewetherington2744
    @joycewetherington2744 2 роки тому +1

    Sarah-You prayed before you left to go to Habitat. The rug was there waiting for you…and a price you can’t beat!Answered prayer. It’s beautiful and the perfect size. Trust the Lord on this one. God bless. 🤍✝️

  • @cindyhancock5261
    @cindyhancock5261 2 роки тому +4

    I love the Lola rug so much!!!!! It’s an investment but worth it!!!♥️

  • @jayyoung8892
    @jayyoung8892 2 роки тому +1

    I love the vintage inspired one it’s beautiful

  • @lindabiddle2081
    @lindabiddle2081 2 роки тому

    I love the thrifted rug! I think it goes so well with your room!!! It definitely makes the room & grounds it! Enjoy!!!

  • @anncarollo9591
    @anncarollo9591 2 роки тому +2

    Definitely, the new one. Love the muted colors! The thrifted rug is too much, it takes away from your beautiful vintage decor.

  • @elainebenham4739
    @elainebenham4739 2 роки тому +2

    I like the vintage looking rug better. The $15 rug is nice but the vintage looking one goes better with your English country theme.

  • @kathryntrapman3917
    @kathryntrapman3917 2 роки тому +1

    I love love the second style and colors of the new rug.

  • @gena6808
    @gena6808 2 роки тому +2

    Love the thrifted rug....Really pretty and seems to go with your beautiful decorating style.

  • @heathermacleod7068
    @heathermacleod7068 2 роки тому +1

    I hate to say it. Because I really liked the thrifted rug. But when you showed the new rug. I fell absolutely in love.

  • @ruthgoddard6539
    @ruthgoddard6539 2 роки тому +1

    That rug is georgious. Oh my word and so clean looking. I vote you keep it. Can not believe it was only 15 dollars. God helped you find it so it was meant to be.

  • @mariataylor6041
    @mariataylor6041 2 роки тому +1

    Sarah, my vote is for the second rug. I like the softer muted colors with your frames. The thrifted rug is nice but it appears to overpower your room. You can always add richer colors with your accessories. Good luck.

  • @susankempczynski8340
    @susankempczynski8340 2 роки тому +1

    New definitely. I think it's more you. I love saving money too. But the new is more cozy vintage.

  • @doloresrose371
    @doloresrose371 2 роки тому +1

    I love the rug from Habitat! The colors are perfect! It really goes well with the sofa and walls. It's looks lush and makes the room cozy! I would use it for awhile and then in the future, you can always switch it to a new rug.

  • @gingermccurley1679
    @gingermccurley1679 2 роки тому

    I think the thrifted rug looks better with your room and decor. And I'm always good with saving money.

  • @wwfarmhouse9055
    @wwfarmhouse9055 2 роки тому

    You have such a keen eye and a gorgeous design aesthetic, you will know which one is right for you. I can’t wait for the final reveal of your living room.

  • @mariahatfield441
    @mariahatfield441 2 роки тому +2

    Definitely the new one. It has the color you're looking for to ground the room but it's also neutral. The thrifted one is very dominating.

  • @kathybruns8404
    @kathybruns8404 2 роки тому +1

    Both. I’m leaning toward the new, but keep the thrifted to change them out when you feel like it!

  • @janicegardner5027
    @janicegardner5027 2 роки тому

    I have to say I love the 2nd one so much better. You won't have to clean it and it is perfect. It is a good idea to keep the thrifted one and sell it to offset some of the cost of your dream rug.

  • @dalallakey2127
    @dalallakey2127 2 роки тому

    I’m all about being thrifty but I sure love the new rug! The rug anchors the room so go with what you can love looking at for the long haul.

  • @lynnstubblefield6663
    @lynnstubblefield6663 2 роки тому

    I LOVE the thrifted rug! It would look beautiful with your room and gallery wall. However, follow your ❤.

  • @hollyashton7009
    @hollyashton7009 2 роки тому

    I didn’t think I would choose the dramatic rug, but I think it’s a real showstopper & love it!!

  • @berniceblundon8215
    @berniceblundon8215 2 роки тому

    I like the thrifted rug better. I think it’s absolutely beautiful and it compliments your decor. The price is just an extra bonus. It was a great find.

  • @adriamorgan121
    @adriamorgan121 2 роки тому +2

    The thrifted rug is beautiful ❤️ It goes so well with the decor. I love it!!

  • @joannfilippi6551
    @joannfilippi6551 2 роки тому +1

    I like the new rug. All of your beautiful things will be the stars and your room will be so mellow

  • @karinratliff4188
    @karinratliff4188 2 роки тому +2

    I like them both. That being said, since they are both beautiful I would go with the $15 thrifted rug because they are equally gorgeous.

  • @denisehill6337
    @denisehill6337 2 роки тому

    My pick is the vintage inspired rug, both are beautiful, but the vintage inspired is more subtle I think it will bring all of the elements you have curated together better🌸

  • @wendya5887
    @wendya5887 2 роки тому +1

    I like new rug…softer with your room. Better suited overall. Tough one, when other one is good deal. But, I’d pay for the new one.

  • @Loveofdolls11
    @Loveofdolls11 2 роки тому

    I love the thrifter rug , it’s such a rich warm colour and compliments everything so lovely . You have a lot of muted colours and I think this pop of stronger colour makes the room warm 💖

  • @avisforbes5563
    @avisforbes5563 2 роки тому

    Keep both. The NEW RUG brings your room UP TO ANOTHER LEVEL, with your pictures. The THRIFTED RUG gives you OPTIONS, if and when you want a change for any of the holidays or large family events.
    BOTH COMPLEMENT YOUR ROOM AND HOME❤

  • @loripowell7654
    @loripowell7654 2 роки тому

    The rug really makes the room pop!!

  • @ntib6489
    @ntib6489 2 роки тому +1

    I vote the "New" vintage rug. The thrifted is nice but the "new vintage rug" appears to match your decor better.

  • @auntiepennylane1958
    @auntiepennylane1958 2 роки тому +1

    Both rugs are very pretty. The thrifted rug seems more formal to me but I don’t know if I could forgo the $15 deal on it !! Personal I liked the muted new rug, it seems more
    “cottagey”, if that is a word . Lol

  • @DestinyFerreira29
    @DestinyFerreira29 2 роки тому

    both. the first is a steal , a great size to ground the space and the second has that sort of faded shabby grandeur look which is lovely... i'm sure you can find a way to incorporate both in a pleasing manner.

  • @suzangriffey8001
    @suzangriffey8001 2 роки тому

    Definitely a great find! I would keep for sure!! It gives the room an old world vibe with soft, muted colors, without being too overwhelming. It most certainly pairs well with your furniture choices. Great find my dear..I would keep!

  • @0JReynolds
    @0JReynolds 2 роки тому +2

    I actually love the thrifted rug. It’s absolutely gorgeous 💕 When you place a coffee table, you will see the center will not stand out as much. If not I will buy the thrifted rug from you. It’s so beautiful ~ Janet 😘

  • @sarahcelt8282
    @sarahcelt8282 2 роки тому

    I love the thrifted rug. It pulls in all the colors in the room. Gorgeous!

  • @charlottewilson4680
    @charlottewilson4680 2 роки тому

    I like it. I have often cleaned my rugs the same way. I put them out on my driveway and washed them. You know the chairs you saw would also look nice with it... if you needed more chairs.

  • @denisecarter5117
    @denisecarter5117 2 роки тому +1

    I am a cheap shopper but I really like the expensive one the best. The green is much more in your face and doesn’t let other things shine.

  • @staciedisotell689
    @staciedisotell689 2 роки тому +1

    The thrifted rug was a great price and pretty but I LOVE that smaller one especially with your wall gallery art 😍but I am sure whichever you go with will be beautiful since you have great taste! Your living room looks beautiful so far and can’t wait to see it finished.

  • @teresadtone8862
    @teresadtone8862 2 роки тому +1

    I think I am team new rug. I like the more subtle pattern on that one and I feel it will hide dirt better which is a plus with children. However...you must go with what makes you 😊

    • @teresadtone8862
      @teresadtone8862 2 роки тому

      I would also keep the thrifted rug....you can't go wrong on a $15 price point!!

  • @margaretrose8105
    @margaretrose8105 2 роки тому

    I think the new rug looks best. I loved those 2 chairs.

  • @lianapalumbo8457
    @lianapalumbo8457 2 роки тому

    I love the first rug, but I prefer richer colours and the fact it's second hand is amazing 😍

  • @caroltomlin8822
    @caroltomlin8822 2 роки тому

    Sometimes it is nice to just splurge on something special. 2nd rug is a great update for the space. The thrifted one could work for winter with coordinating accent pillows & soft chunky green knitted couch throw ... or in another room.

  • @pattil3496
    @pattil3496 2 роки тому

    The thrifted rug is gorgeous!!! From what I've seen on your channel, it looks more like your style.

  • @judithschrim145
    @judithschrim145 2 роки тому +2

    I chose the "smaller rug sample - softer and looks more like what you have repeatedly talked about in your video....the other one - had a great price - wow - but this smaller one make your room flow together. You might consider keeping the other rug for another room -

  • @myhere6603
    @myhere6603 2 роки тому

    Love the $15 green rug in your living room. Looks beautiful and I’m sure you will blend it all together really well.

  • @bonniekalwat1669
    @bonniekalwat1669 2 роки тому

    Both rugs compliment your furniture and the room and, saying that, I would definitely go with the $15 thrifted rug and to put my money on something else on the list that you want for your home.

  • @carolynl.crudup9103
    @carolynl.crudup9103 Рік тому

    Thift rug. I would... put a splash of the green in the decor for accent pillows, throws and greenery on the book shelf. Also can pick another color out from rug to accent living space. Nice 👌

  • @wandablaylock3352
    @wandablaylock3352 2 роки тому

    Keep the rug from habitat! It’s so warm and inviting! I haven’t waited to see the other one but this one looks perfect!

  • @alicianagy6214
    @alicianagy6214 2 роки тому

    I love the colors of the muted vintage rug and it looks amazing next to your art. Rug #2 gets my vote!!