Ranking Pokémon Champions By Strength

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лип 2024
  • hey we're back, in a sequel to my first video, if I said something wrong or you just don't like my opinions feel free to leave yours in the comments. or you can comment about something else that's cool too.
    follow my twitter :)
    ➤ / commadey
    check out my other channel
    ➤ ‪@commaD‬
    here's the tier list
    ➤ tiermaker.com/create/pokemon-...
    Intro 0:00
    Blue 0:47
    Lance 1:49
    Red 3:07
    Kukui 3:52
    Hau 4:39
    Trace 6:01
    Steven 6:46
    Wallace 7:56
    Cynthia 8:29
    Alder 9:17
    N 10:23
    Iris 10:56
    Diantha 11:34
    Leon 12:05
    Mustard 13:32
    Peony 14:39
    Volo 15:44
    Geeta 16:11
    Nemona 16:53
    Tierlist 17:29
    Outro 20:29
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 116

  • @ShadowRealmZ373
    @ShadowRealmZ373 Рік тому +224

    N can talk to Pokémon,but Red can … his way through any battle

  • @craig-machine8137
    @craig-machine8137 Рік тому +117

    I always liked the idea of Red being the strongest too. Also, I always wished that Hilbert/Hilda had a secret battle in BW2 akin to Red's battle in Gen 2.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +21

      Yeah I wanted that too happen so bad as a kid! With the memory link feature they could have literally taken your team from the first game. Or they could have made up a team if they wanted too. At least we got that one Pokémon generations episode.

  • @tomasstargamer6308
    @tomasstargamer6308 Рік тому +38

    For matter of achievements, Leon quite literally might be the one NPC Champion that actually faced off against a Legendary, and won. He matched Eternatus with his full team despite being unable to use GMax and weakened it enough to the point of getting a 3 shakes throw, but Eternatus simply canonically has absurd amounts of energy and regen so his catch didn't quite work.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +16

      Yeah a champion actually going up against a legendary is really uncommon.

    • @HiddenPowerIce
      @HiddenPowerIce 10 місяців тому

      he didn't win, and I'm not sure 3 shakes is better than 2 or 1 if you still didn't capture it.

    • @tomasstargamer6308
      @tomasstargamer6308 10 місяців тому +1

      @@HiddenPowerIce 3 literally means it got weakened and tired far more.

    • @HiddenPowerIce
      @HiddenPowerIce 10 місяців тому

      @@tomasstargamer6308
      But he still didn't capture it.

  • @commaGarbage
    @commaGarbage  Рік тому +16

    Woah new commaG video

  • @tacticalhelix
    @tacticalhelix Рік тому +34

    The one think that I could mention is that because of a lack of connection between Hoenn, Kalos, Galar and Paldea, it's way harder to place them. This is the case unless taking into consideration Raihan's Trainer card. Not taking it as fact but, that he could be a champion in another region, expect Galar and Kanto (due Red being above the rest of champions).

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +10

      I wonder what region they were thinking of when they said he could be a champion in another region

    • @ediakin4993
      @ediakin4993 Рік тому +2

      ​@@commaGarbage paldea

  • @jackzheng507
    @jackzheng507 Рік тому +21

    I remember asking for This video since your rival ranking video, been so excited 😍😍

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +6

      Definitely had your comment in mind when I decided to make the video. Hope you enjoyed!

    • @jackzheng507
      @jackzheng507 Рік тому +3

      @@commaGarbage :’)

  • @rustedbubble4756
    @rustedbubble4756 Рік тому +23

    I don't think bw 1 protagonist lost to iris they left unova to find N

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +11

      Yeah Iris beat Alder not the BW protagonist, that graphic was to show how many people are above alder more than anything

    • @deviousj5868
      @deviousj5868 Рік тому

      Yeah they left

  • @TechnoArpan
    @TechnoArpan Рік тому +20

    Red really do be winning with those protag powers

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +12

      These free to play characters can not compete with this mans plot armour.

    • @Munirakil
      @Munirakil Рік тому +1

      @@commaGarbage you should so a trainers tier list.

  • @RoseSupreme
    @RoseSupreme Рік тому +10

    I'm genuinely shocked to see Diantha in the same tier as Cynthia.
    And I mean that in the most positive way, because I'm so sick of people always constantly praising Cynthia and shitting on Diantha because of how easy XY were. Diantha deserves better imo.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +7

      Yeah I feel you, the whole games easy can’t really put on the blame on her. Though idk if Pokémon can be hard, without making up challenges.

    • @RoseSupreme
      @RoseSupreme Рік тому +5

      @@commaGarbage I have heard that Pokémon Masters did do something with her in the Kalos Villain Arc with her Shiny Diancie Sygna Suit.
      I hope that when XY remakes do come, they pull an ORAS on it and expand upon/reimagine the story. Have her help the player in dealing with Team Flare, raise her team up a few more levels, etc.

  • @matthewroberts198
    @matthewroberts198 Рік тому +19

    Its kind of a shame how people view Wallace cause in the Pokemon Adventures/Special manga, at the League tournament Wallace beat Steven but rejected the position to be a Gym Leader cause he had a thing for Winona (Wallace and Winona had dated at some point)

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +8

      Yeah as someone who has not read that far into the manga, he is not a champion with a high status in my eyes. In Journeys he gets off screened by ash in the background of one episode. Thought it’s not like it would matter for this list if he somehow won the whole masters tournament.

    • @DonoZeek
      @DonoZeek Рік тому

      It's odd. Hoenn had two Pseudo legendaries: Metagross (used by Steven) and Salamence (used by no one. They could have make Wallance's team mixed Water and other types like with Iris but they instead made his team really weak all water types.

    • @NaGa5h
      @NaGa5h Рік тому +1

      ​@@DonoZeek Salamence is used by Drake from the elite 4, but no wonder you forgot about Lance from wish.

    • @DonoZeek
      @DonoZeek Рік тому

      @@NaGa5h i always wonder why they made Drake, especially since there are barely any dragon types back then. Also, why did they give a pseudo pokemone to an elite fourth? It's traditional for the champion to have one.

    • @NaGa5h
      @NaGa5h Рік тому

      @@DonoZeek Because originally, in ruby, the two pseudo legendary pokemon already went to the 2 strongest trainers in the main plotline, Drake and Stephen, and Wallace already had his ace, Milotic. I think they didn't risk changing too much from ruby to emerald.

  • @Makitru
    @Makitru Рік тому +6

    So I could’ve messed up somewhere along the way but these are the level average for their highest leveled teams ever possible: Cynthia[86], Red [85], Iris[81], Diantha[80], Mustard[80], Leon[79], Steven[77], N[75], Peony[74], Blue[73], Lance[71], Nemona[71], Geeta[69], Hau[69], Kukui[68], Trace[66], Alder[63], Wallace[56],
    It’s important to note that this does not consider an empty party slot as a zero.
    And these are the weakest teams you can possibly beat in order to become their region’s champion + N & Nemona
    Diantha[66], Nemona[65], Leon[63], Alder[63], Cynthia[62], Blue[62], Geeta[62], Hau[58], Kukui[57], Wallace[56], Trace[56], Steven[56], Iris[53], N[50], Lance[47]

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +5

      Woah dude, nice breakdown, it’s always funny to me that Diantha has basically the highest levels out of any league champions initial battle.

    • @Makitru
      @Makitru Рік тому +4

      @@commaGarbage I’d attribute that to maybe the introduction of exp share and them not exactly sure on how to balance the leveling? Not sure though. I still find it crazy that they made Cynthia surpass Red.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +3

      @@Makitru Yeah making Diantha have levels that high was definitely because of the new xp share system, Last time I played the game I was still 4-5 levels above her, just casually running the game. They definitely hadn't figure out how to balance properly balance it, I imagine that's part of the reason they stopped letting you turn xp share off. So they only had to balance one way of playing the game

  • @lucasferro6050
    @lucasferro6050 Рік тому +9

    The SMUSUM protags should be here tbh, they're the first official champion of Alola, they defend their title whenever they rematch the E4 (meaning they're the standing champion of Alola) and they were the ones to beat Team RR and U-Necrozma (only the USUM protags tho). Alola is a very special case among all regions bc the protag really is the standing champion, as you never fight anyone in those games with a champion title, and it shouldn't be an issue for this list bc you're not taking levels into account for the most part.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +7

      Yeah I could see that, but if I included them then the Gen 8 champion all of a sudden fits the criteria since Leon retires after you beat him. Then in Paldea all it takes to be champion is beating Geeta so there’s no need to even be a standing champion. Let’s Go is also pretty similar, because after you beat Trace on subsequent runs he challenges you just like the title defence battles in Alola. It’s a slippery slope, the protagonists would just be better suited for their own video imo.

    • @lucasferro6050
      @lucasferro6050 Рік тому +2

      @@commaGarbage The thing that differentiates Alola from the rest imo is that you're the first ever official champion and that's a big deal in the main story as Kukui and Hau don't have champion in their trainer name and the hall of fame says in big colorful letters "First ever Champion of Alola", but I agree that it's a bit of a slippery slope. At least I hope they end up high in the possible future protag tier list, as I've been enjoying how you do these tier lists, prioritizing feats over raw levels and team composition

  • @robmayer9141
    @robmayer9141 Рік тому +7

    Wallace does beat Steven in the manga and takes over as champion, hence the change in emerald, so... technically, yeah.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +7

      Oh that’s cool I didn’t know that, I don’t think that has anything to do with the games though.

    • @robmayer9141
      @robmayer9141 Рік тому +5

      @commaGarbage absolutely fair, but it is interesting nonetheless. Steven is absolutely the better champion

  • @edgarballz
    @edgarballz Рік тому +3

    hey commaG, nice video, you rock.

  • @nishant9289
    @nishant9289 Рік тому +28

    In terms of strength, i.e.purely team composition, assuming that you are using your legendary dragon against N, my list would be:
    Hau

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +9

      Yeah I’ve seen plenty of video talking about their teams, so I wanted to do something a little different, hope you enjoyed!

    • @zachg5856
      @zachg5856 Рік тому +3

      funny thing is i name all my characters red so for me red has beaten all reigons and caught every legendary and mythical i just think of it as red continuing his journey like ash did cause truthfully red definitely would be number one if they didn’t make him stay on a mountain to freeze

  • @DummyThiccCheeseCake
    @DummyThiccCheeseCake Рік тому +5

    Red being at the top tickles my black little fanboy heart

  • @flyingninjafish1558
    @flyingninjafish1558 Рік тому +15

    I would assume that Kukui did defeat the elite 4 in Alola as a way to convince them that he was serious about the league he was creating. After all, every league needs a champion and what better final test for a champion to earn their place then the man who created the league? So he’d have to be above the elite 4, as is proven with his team and time as the Masked Royal. Plus, his loss against Lance was from years ago before he settled back down in Alola and became the Masked Royal. Just arguing for some Kakui love here 😂

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +2

      I can respect repping one of your favourites. As stated by him Kukui didn’t want to be champion of the league he made at the end of the day. So who knows if he even told anyone he planned on challenging the player at the end.

  • @SpecialJess2
    @SpecialJess2 Рік тому +2

    Bro why isn't the top tier called "like no one ever was"

  • @qwertypop0449
    @qwertypop0449 Рік тому +4

    AI Sada/Turo may not have challenged the league, but the original Sada/Turo are actually confirmed to be Champions

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +1

      Do you mean the hall of fame book? That’s just a book to honour students and former who did outstanding things like saving the region (why arven and penny are there) or inventing terastilization or a Time Machine. Geeta is a champion but she’s not in that book.

  • @jmtthepixelmon16
    @jmtthepixelmon16 Рік тому +8

    I agree with the dorito tier list despite it being controversial

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +4

      The Dorito tier list is the most accurate thing in this video imo

  • @proietto0273
    @proietto0273 Рік тому +5

    Lore wise Red May be the strongest, but game wise...man...cynthia Is on a whole other level of difficulty💀.
    If i had to fight Red right now it would be Just a Lot easier for me

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +3

      Yeah it’s nice going back and beating Red and Cynthia easily after all the trouble they caused me as a kid

    • @proietto0273
      @proietto0273 Рік тому

      @@commaGarbage lmao they are still a bit of a Nightmare though👀

  • @lyteabhishek
    @lyteabhishek Рік тому +2

    What is the logic of calling Ethan vs red battle undecided? Ethan beats red same as any player beats any other champion.

  • @Garde_Mystik
    @Garde_Mystik Рік тому +6

    Hau might be in the unfortunate tier. Came very far in Alola but the one person he couldn't beat is technically the most powerful champion in the series by far. Quite possibly the most powerful character in the world at the time. It's been implied that Kukui lost to Lance so there's no such luxury.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +1

      Really what makes the alola player character the most powerful champion in the series? If that’s who you were talking about.

    • @Garde_Mystik
      @Garde_Mystik Рік тому +4

      @@commaGarbage they managed to defeat team rainbow rocket, an evil organization of people who were about to succeed while carrying Pokémon far more powerful than what champions run. They also managed to take on Ultra Necrozma head on.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +6

      @@Garde_Mystik true I think i’d put the legends arceus protagonist above them (especially if they actually are also the DPP protagonist)but yeah the usum did accomplish a lot. Ranking Pokémon protagonist would be cool.

    • @Garde_Mystik
      @Garde_Mystik Рік тому +2

      @@commaGarbage yeah I agree. Any protag highly associated with Arceus would be the only ones above them

    • @ediakin4993
      @ediakin4993 Рік тому

      ​@@Garde_Mystik any gym leader or elite four can beat evil organization

  • @stealthgamer4620
    @stealthgamer4620 Рік тому +5

    i think you forgot to add Volo to the Cheater tier, or even the tier at all and he was in the video. Just pop him right under Red.

  • @JayTeeBeez
    @JayTeeBeez Рік тому +1

    Well the idea of Hau is rather then him being your rival its more like your His rival your the blue in his situation, and hes red coming in for your title to become champion, thats at least the idea I got from hau. Thats probably why it was changed in Ultra

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +1

      Never been a fan of this theory. Feels like every point made about Hau could be said for Trace from Let’s go. And honestly works better for Trace.

  • @babysinclairfan
    @babysinclairfan 3 місяці тому

    It's possible that Lance beat Red. That might be why Red went off to train

  • @plk917
    @plk917 Рік тому +2

    I liked the video, very good concept. But my boy you ranked Alder waaaaaayyy to high xD imo he should have been at the bottom.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +2

      Glad you enjoyed. Honestly I hope he’s the ancient hero, guy could use a big win lol.

    • @TechnoArpan
      @TechnoArpan Рік тому +2

      @@commaGarbage I love Alder man, one of fav champions. Though Leon, Steven and Diantha are still above him. Though game Diantha is a nothing character, as you said, I was fortunate in watching the anime first, lol. Combine that with her design and theme being my fav among the champions and you get one of my top 3

  • @wyattmaldonado-zu5ks
    @wyattmaldonado-zu5ks Рік тому

    Is Cynthia's team in bdsp her rematch team?

  • @alainblandi2885
    @alainblandi2885 Рік тому

    We have no information about Kukui defeating Lance.
    Rumors say that around the time, Lance was defeated by the great Masked Royal.

  • @ryuuronin9852
    @ryuuronin9852 11 місяців тому

    "Can't compare that, we don't know how long everyone else was champion."
    Except for Blue and Trace: champions for only about an hour probably, definitely less than a day.

  • @juandiegotorres9632
    @juandiegotorres9632 9 місяців тому +1

    When did blue visit Kalos? I know he visited Unova.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  9 місяців тому +2

      an NPC mentions meeting someone who said “smell ya later” instead of au revoir” He also says Bonjour during the opening of pokémon masters. It’s not really something that gets outright said

    • @juandiegotorres9632
      @juandiegotorres9632 9 місяців тому +1

      @@commaGarbage oh okay I think I heard of that reference but it's been a while.

  • @lesterism
    @lesterism Рік тому

    Player(Red)
    Cynthia
    Iris

  • @jilliangonzales1446
    @jilliangonzales1446 2 місяці тому

    I love Wallace

  • @Matthew_Cashew
    @Matthew_Cashew Рік тому +1

    I WANT POKEMON B/W/B2/W2 REMAKES. (Specifically Because Black was My First Pokemon Game, And My Brother Won't allow me to play his Black 2.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +1

      Yeah it be nice to play them on the switch we’re probably 2-3 years away from that though.

  • @marinagaleotti
    @marinagaleotti 9 місяців тому

    Arven sada penny and turo are in the hall of dame so they are champions

  • @nishant9289
    @nishant9289 Рік тому +1

    6:57 And I am one of those lol

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +1

      Well I can only hope this changed your mind

  • @celiafrostborn
    @celiafrostborn Рік тому +3

    BDSP Cynthia would be S tier if it was based off of challenge, that alone is enough to put her as my number 1 of all time.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +3

      They did a good job of making it difficult without the difficulty just coming from being underleveled

  • @ZenithintheMaking
    @ZenithintheMaking Рік тому +3

    N
    Cynthia
    Leon
    Mustard
    Iris
    Steven
    Nemona
    Diantha
    This is how I would rank The Very Best tier🙌🙌

  • @Trottskee
    @Trottskee Рік тому +3

    So, the point of the Video... YOU, US, WE are the top champion in Pokemon.

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +3

      Yeah pretty much, though that makes it sound a little too similar to “the real treasure was the friends we made along the way” genre lol

  • @slate4687
    @slate4687 Рік тому +1

    5th gen is cool and underrated

  • @NICOCLASH
    @NICOCLASH 10 місяців тому

    HEY, you can't just put N as trash like Geeta in the thumbnail, that may cause EMOOOOTIONAL DAAAAMAGE 😅😅😅

  • @coconut_tv0564
    @coconut_tv0564 Рік тому +1

    Sada and Turo were champion rank so...

    • @commaGarbage
      @commaGarbage  Рік тому +2

      If you’re talking about the hall of fame book on the second floor, that has nothing to do with being a champion. The player, Nemona, arven and penny get in for saving the region from the Time Machine. Geeta is a champion but isn’t in that book. Sada/Turo are amazing scientists hence why there in the book

  • @Tunasub29
    @Tunasub29 Рік тому

    Bro lance is the champion of kanto and johto do you not watch the anime

  • @darkemperor9581
    @darkemperor9581 Рік тому

    Bruh you have 4 videos and I have over 40 and you already have 1k I call bullshit

  • @makeeeveeacupcake
    @makeeeveeacupcake Рік тому +1

    Red is overrated af

  • @greek1237
    @greek1237 Рік тому +1

    Lets see, the Playable characters than everyone else lol. And yes Kukui mentions his defeat in SM, with the words of that Dragon Trainer was something.