I get that that’s what happens in the book but I HATE when people suggest this. THAT WOULD NOT WORK ON SCREEN. Every single time Aphrodite would show up they would need to say who she was because the audience would have no idea, shifting from different perspectives and then also different actresses would be impossible. I mean how would she have lines if her actress was constantly changing? It makes absolutely no sense and on top of that all the people that fans are suggesting are way too expensive.
@@fewntug3760 hair colour is a fairly big part of appearance and having that many actresses to pay would still be ridiculously expensive, especially considering that most people want to cast famous actresses and then basically only have them on screen for a few seconds. It’s a truly stupid idea.
People have said this before but I think that it'd be a great idea if aphrodite was played by multiple actresses since her appearance changes shape depending on what you consider to be attractive/who you're attracted to. So when Percy meets Aphrodite in Titans curse, he would view her as Annabeth for a quick second since his feelings for Annabeth were developing But I do agree with a lot of the other castings
@@nickmurphy4411 it wasn’t too funny. Not because I care about people calling people bitch, but because Greek canon Hera isn’t anything bitchy like Riordan Hera. Riordan had to make Hera a bitch so that when Zeus has affairs, we don’t feel like he’s such a dick.
@@sladewayne1723 unfortunately as far as we know the series will only cover up until the last olympian. some day perhaps we'll get a HOO series but I'm just grateful for this second chance so I'm not gonna try my luck lol. Hedge does get a name drop in a letter to Grover iirc tho
@@sladewayne1723 Since as far as we know the're only doing it up to TLO, maybe he could play the head saytr of th council of cloven elders? Very minor role, but he is a comedic actor, so he could be comic relief?
Also gonna steal one of my other comments, J think Rdj would also be a good pick for Dionysus. Obviously with all the other Marvel actors they would fit well together when all those gods get together for all the council meetings and such in the series
I think two actresses should play Artemis. One would be a girl of 12-13, for when she’s with the hunters, but the other would be an adult for when she’s with the other gods.
Bro this casting is so cool! Well done compared to some other castings I've seen. Percy Jackson has been my life for 3-4 years now and since I'm a theatre kid, I would love to audition for the show. Btw I've heard that they might upscale The actors age for Percy (like 13-14) but it's just a theory, nothing to serious like that monstrosity of an adaptation.
I'd be totally fine if they casted actors slightly older than what's Canon to the books. As long as they look as if they can pass as twelve. Plus their acting might even be better that way
@@transfemjuniperberries I knew there was a reason Chris Pratt made me sick at my stomach with annoyance. Besides, why would a flaming sanctimonious Christian want to portray a Greek god? He would probably fear eternity in Hades for just thinking about it. As an LGBTQ+ person myself, I would rather not have him involved in this project. He can keep his religious judgment to himself, thanks.
Aphrodite for a momenr resembled Annabeth because thats who Percy _loves_ the most. She takes the form of what you find most attractive, being the goddess of love
Lena Headey maybe? She seems to have that aura of sass and confidence and aristocracy perfectly in the GOT. But she is really talented, this role would not be doing her much justice as an actress' talent... what do you think?
I think you did a good job finding actors/actresses, but I’m not sure about Tom Holland and Apollo though.... I’m also not sure about Hera, I feel like you need to make her younger and prettier.I don’t have an actress in mind for Hera, but maybe Matthew Charles Czucrhy for Apollo?
I agree, From a Greek myth perspective (which Riordan doesn’t really steer away from), none of the gods should look older than mid-30’s or early 40’s. Hera was called “of the white arms” because she epitomized Greek ideas of femininity (not to be confused with “beauty”, though she, Aphrodite, and Athena were considered nearly equal in beauty). Meanwhile, Apollo was considered the ideal in male beauty by the Greeks and Romans alike, later emulated by neo-classical sculptors like Michelangelo. You would almost need to a seriously de-aged Brad Pitt, but ripped as he was for his Achilles role. Not easy to fill.
The actor that was chosen for hades is perfect because he plays Lucifer in the show Lucifer and pulls off the mysterious and slightly evil vibes that Hades would give off
No to Hemsworth and Hiddleston. They belong to the Norse gods now, so should be considered off limits. Also, no Momoa playing Poseidon. It's bad enough that he was miscast as Aquaman (Arthur Curry isn't supposed to look like that). So, Logan Lehrman as Poseidon is the best. Timothy Omundson would be a perfect Zeus! He's played Cain on Supernatural already, and God Johnson on Lucifer. He has a Zeus look. Definitely Jack Black as Dionysius!! Need to hear casting choices for the demigods, Grover, Chiron...what I've heard so far is okay. I just don't like the girl who originally played Annabeth.
@@transfemjuniperberries Liam? Don't know much about him except he's got really bad taste in potential wives, having chosen Miley Cyrus. But I've never seen him act in a movie.
I think its really cool you had the past percy jackson cast play the parents of the upcoming cast (with actual 12 year olds) having logan lerman as poseidon etc.
The films made them into teens and the characters weren’t well written. That’s like casting the first Harry Potter characters as teens who are in collage...doesn’t work does it? No
Personally, I didn’t mind that the films aged up the cast. A lot of stories and series where the characters are children, I can’t really see as realistic. For example, Sailor Moon is suppose to be a middle school girl but I always see her as older than she is to do what she does. Harry Potter was different because the fighting there was just pointing sticks (no shade, I’m a fan but it boils down to that) where as Percy Jackson has a lot of physical fighting that I imagine a lot of CGI will be needed.
DUDE!!!!! this is list is AMAZING!!! most of them are like RIGHT ON POINT!!!! And a great way to bring back some of the older cast, they didn't fit the PJ characters they played but the ones you place them on are like AMAZING!!
Dude. Can someone please send this video to Disney or Rick Riordan!? I think this actors are the perfect ones for the series. Great job dude this is absolutly awsome!!
Jack Black as Dionysus if done correctly could be amazing. I'm just imagining him going from lazy and uninterested to quiet anger really easy. He's also a good enough actor to pull of the characters more complex scenes and attributes from the books
The reason Aphrodite looks like Annabeth to Percy is because she has the ability to magically look like the most beautiful woman to whomever she manifests. If she were to appear to someone else, her physical form would resemble a perfected version of whomever it is they are most attracted to.
Keanu Reeves = Zeus Jason Momoa = Posidon Chris Hemsorth = Apollo Danny DeVito = Gabe Tom Holland = Grover ( He might be a bit old) Tom Cruise = Anabeth's dad Tom Hidleson/Zac Efron= Luke (Maybe) Idris Elba = Chiron Rick Riordan = A random cameo in each ep This will not happen lol
Only reasons i dont agree with u is because i feel as if some of those actors are a bit to old to play the characters (specifically tom holland for grover and ton hiddleston/zac efron for luke)
I actually liked Sean Bean as Zeus and thought that he was one of the few characters who was casted right. However, I could see Jason Mamoa playing Poseidon (lol Aquaman) or maybe Prometheus. I think he should definitely play a Titan, though. Also, even though I love Logan Lerman as an actor, I think the original Percy Jackson is better left where it is, so I would cast Gerard Butler in the role of Poseidon. I think to cut down on the cost of this already expensive project and because I personally don't see him playing Ares, I would actually cast Jensen Ackles in the role because he seems like more of a rage and bloodthirsty war god to me. This is based on how I've seen him act in Supernatural both as a demon with the Mark of Cain and the Archangel Michael. To me, Ares always struck me as the kind of guy who was a grade-A douchebag, but with a certain elegance, and I think that Jensen fits that description. And also to me, the actress who plays Hera looks a little bit too old (especially when compared side-by-side with Jason Mamoa) and I can see her playing Rhea more. For Hera I think it should be Famke Janssen, because she is no stranger to playing a character with a sense of superiority or bitchiness. But other than that, I agreed with a lot of your casting choices.
i saw a fan acc at insta that says sam claflin as apollo and its just perfect! i personally think luke hemmings as apollo but he's a singer, i haven't seen him in acting before.
Is it just me, and I know this isn't a god, but am I the only one who pictured Smelly Gabe being played by Danny DeVito? I swear he'd be perfect for that role!
This was 100% the best fan cast I’ve seen so far. Lucifer with Tom Ellis is an epic show, and Tom Ellis 110% would be an amazing Hades!! Tom Hardy is totally the perfect choice for Ares!! Chris Pratt is perfect for Hermes!! I’ve also been saying forever that Jack Black should play Dionysus! (Tom Ellis has to be favorite one, though)
This would be the most expensive cast, we’ve seen this type of famous casting from Disney before in movies which did not work great at all *mhm Doolittle
Maybe the actress for Aphrodite could be the one who played Margaery Tyrell, or maybe Lena (Cersei's actress) could do Hera... seemed like, good according to what I'd made of them in the books
Lin Manuel Miranda as Hermes Adam Copeland as Ares Jason Mantzoukas as Dionysus / Mr. D Megan Mullally as Alecto / Ms. Dodds Glynn Turman as Chiron / Mr. Brunner Virginia Kull as Sally Jackson Lance Reddick as Zeus Toby Stephens as Poseidon Jay Duplass as Hades Timothy Omundson as Hephaestus
My reactions/opinions on youre desicions: Zeus casting: yes Poseidon casting: nope, I wouldn't prefer him Hades casting: yup Ares casting: yeah Hermes casting: *laugh* mmm-hm (I like it) Aphrodite: def Athena: maybe Hera: PERFECT Demeter: yes Artemis: ABSOLUTELY Apollo:🤭yea Hephaestus: amazing choice Dionysus: OMFG YESSSSSSSS My only comment on this video: What about Hestia?
Actually, i can imagine Jason Momoa as Zeus since he is the Aquaman, especially with his Trisula.... its also hard and dilematic cause he and both with Logan, are the sons of the sea😭😭😭😭😭
Clicking on this video I didn't know what to expect, but these were some damn good castings. I'd like to see Disney go all out for Percy Jackson, at least attempt to rival Harry Potter.
Jack black works better for more comedic characters, where Mr. D would also have that intimidating side. You need someone with more range and that person has got to be Stanley Tucci. If you’ve see movies like the devil wears Prada, the lovely bones, or hunger games; you’ll see Mr. D in all of them.
My Cast Zeus- Hugh Jackman Poseidon- Chris Pine Hades- Gerard Butler Hera- Cate Blanchett OR Julia Roberts Demeter- ? Athena- Keri Russell Ares- tom hardy Hepestus - Alfred Molina? Artemis- ? Apollo- ? Tom Holland Hermes- Nathan Fillion Aphrodite- Scarlet Johanson, Natalie Portman, Grace Fulton, Christina Hendricks, Halie Berry, Elle Fanning. Mr. D- John Goodman Persephone- Emma Watson
Disney NEEDS TO SEE THIS!!! Such a hard toss up between Nathan Fillion & Chris Pratt, though. I honestly think one should be Hermes & one should be Apollo. They would make such great partners in cre the way Hermes & Apollo seem to.
my recasting 2021~ Poseidon: Darren Criss Zeus: Jon Hamm Hades: David Tennant Athena: Dianna Agron Hermes: Chris Colfer Aphrodite: Lea Michele Hera: Idina Menzel Apollo: Henry Cavill or Owen Joyner (older) Annabeth: Lili Reinhart
Casting Lerman and Daddario again would be a big mistake. I think it would be cool to have Lerman cameo several times in smaller roles but he definitely should not be a god. I do like your choices for Dionysus and Aphrodite through. Here is what I would do excluding Dionysus and Aphrodite ... Zeus- Josh Brolin Poseidon- Hugh Jackman Hades- Mads Mikkelson Ares-1st Choice -Dwayne Johnson 2nd Choice- Jon Bernthal Athena- Angelina Jolie Apollo- Sam Claflin Artemis- Raffey Cassidy Hermes- Ewan Mcgregor Hephaestus- Idris Elba Hera- Rachel Weisz
I have Keira Knightley as Hera Margot Robbie as Aphrodite Gal Gadot as Athena Adelaide Kane as Artemis and Elizabeth Gillies as Persephone I have just for the godess, my cast is unreal but you know everyone can dream 🤷♀️
There shouldn't be one actress for Aphrodite, there should be plenty of different actresses.
My picks. Natalie Portman, Grace Fulton, Christina Hendricks, Halie Berry, Elle Fanning.
Margot Robbie should be the main face though
I get that that’s what happens in the book but I HATE when people suggest this. THAT WOULD NOT WORK ON SCREEN. Every single time Aphrodite would show up they would need to say who she was because the audience would have no idea, shifting from different perspectives and then also different actresses would be impossible. I mean how would she have lines if her actress was constantly changing? It makes absolutely no sense and on top of that all the people that fans are suggesting are way too expensive.
@@pineappleunicorn7729 I think if they give her the same outfit and eye color they could make it work, but I definitely see what you mean.
@@fewntug3760 hair colour is a fairly big part of appearance and having that many actresses to pay would still be ridiculously expensive, especially considering that most people want to cast famous actresses and then basically only have them on screen for a few seconds. It’s a truly stupid idea.
People have said this before but I think that it'd be a great idea if aphrodite was played by multiple actresses since her appearance changes shape depending on what you consider to be attractive/who you're attracted to. So when Percy meets Aphrodite in Titans curse, he would view her as Annabeth for a quick second since his feelings for Annabeth were developing
But I do agree with a lot of the other castings
That's a good idea, I like it.
Cast the Kardashians?
this is a great idea
Makes so much sense!
@@etriganthedemon666 Aphrodite has to be attractive.
Did anyone else laugh a lot when he blatantly called Hera a bitch? 😂
Yeah, but I was already laughing at most of the casting choices already.
@@nickschulte3915 Because it's plain bad, amirite.
@@firstnamelastname12344 nah it was pretty funny
@@nickmurphy4411 it wasn’t too funny. Not because I care about people calling people bitch, but because Greek canon Hera isn’t anything bitchy like Riordan Hera. Riordan had to make Hera a bitch so that when Zeus has affairs, we don’t feel like he’s such a dick.
bro my parents were sleeping so i had to hold it in. But damn chill kost
Damn this movie would be an expensive movie
tv show*
I heard somewhere it'll have bigger budget the star wars
Stuart little had 100 million budget
@@annabelecassarole8020 and marvel
I mean it’s disney ;)
if i didnt want Jack Black to play Black Jack, I'd be 100% on board for him as Mr. D. Danny Devito would also be a good fit for the role imo
Danny Devito also can play coach Hedge, because he had the experience playing satyr (Disney Hercules)
@@sladewayne1723 unfortunately as far as we know the series will only cover up until the last olympian. some day perhaps we'll get a HOO series but I'm just grateful for this second chance so I'm not gonna try my luck lol. Hedge does get a name drop in a letter to Grover iirc tho
@@sladewayne1723 Since as far as we know the're only doing it up to TLO, maybe he could play the head saytr of th council of cloven elders? Very minor role, but he is a comedic actor, so he could be comic relief?
I would literally die if Jack Black was Black Jack- the irony HAHA
Noice. I really like Dionysius and Hephaestus’s cast.
Dude same
I love your idea with Logan Lerman like Poseidon and Alexandra Daddario like Athena
Yeah she is what I would’ve casted as Athena
Yup
Alexandra looks more like Athena then annabeth
_Papa Logan Lerman shoulda been playin as Sea Fish Daddy Poseidon_
Unpopular opinion but i’d rather not have a reminder of the (ugh) movies. I’d cast Jude Law as Poseidon and Amanda Seyfried (spelling?) as Athena.
OMFGs Casting Tom Ellis AK freaking A LUCIFER as Hades, if perfect
Also gonna steal one of my other comments, J think Rdj would also be a good pick for Dionysus. Obviously with all the other Marvel actors they would fit well together when all those gods get together for all the council meetings and such in the series
Totally 😈
I KNOW RIGHT
He’s the perfect blend of intimidation and vulnerability that Hades needs!
@@htesofficial2329 Jay Duplass as Hades
Jason Mantzoukas as Dionysus / Mr. D
I would've gone with Cate Blanchett for Hera. That's who I imagine when I read the books.
Oooo yes
SAME
Hela
I've always seen Angelina Jolie as Hera, it doesn't come to mind immediately, but when you look at it, it makes PERFECT sense.
agreed
I think two actresses should play Artemis. One would be a girl of 12-13, for when she’s with the hunters, but the other would be an adult for when she’s with the other gods.
Bro this casting is so cool! Well done compared to some other castings I've seen. Percy Jackson has been my life for 3-4 years now and since I'm a theatre kid, I would love to audition for the show. Btw I've heard that they might upscale The actors age for Percy (like 13-14) but it's just a theory, nothing to serious like that monstrosity of an adaptation.
I'd be totally fine if they casted actors slightly older than what's Canon to the books. As long as they look as if they can pass as twelve. Plus their acting might even be better that way
Mauhahahahaha this means I have a chance at Rachel 😂😂😂 I’ll be 17 before they even get to Titans Curse.... but it’s a chance I’m willing to take
That’s something Rachel would do..... also I’m auditioning to.
@@jacobwragg727 if they ever continue on past percy Jackson, I want to audition for Jason.
I want to audition for Zoë Nightshade
Hermes = Chris pratt. ITS THE BEST THING EVER, you can totally hear the angles sing right?
Oh the choirs is heavenly 😂
Chris Pratt is super homophobic tho, he doesn't deserve to be in an lgbtq friendly series like Percy Jackson
@@transfemjuniperberries how about.... hmmm im still thinkin' though
@@transfemjuniperberries I knew there was a reason Chris Pratt made me sick at my stomach with annoyance. Besides, why would a flaming sanctimonious Christian want to portray a Greek god? He would probably fear eternity in Hades for just thinking about it. As an LGBTQ+ person myself, I would rather not have him involved in this project. He can keep his religious judgment to himself, thanks.
@@kaithorenfawkes8312 exactly, and i loved so many of the characters he played it was sad to find out he was such a shitty person
Aphrodite for a momenr resembled Annabeth because thats who Percy _loves_ the most. She takes the form of what you find most attractive, being the goddess of love
I th9nk Poseidon’s Zeus and Athens cast ideas were perfect
I disagree
@@clubysoda1358 why?
@@rianna6206 I think there should be no connection to the movies that way it is as accurate as possible
@@clubysoda1358 ok I agree
What the heck? Why does hardly anyone know about this? Can someone get this to Uncle Rick somehow?
Sadly, on his website, he said he won’t even make a cameo
The fact that Tom Ellis has played the devil once before, makes it ten times better as a choice.
Yeah
"Once" as if we're not waiting on the last bit of Lucifer.
I think Hera should be more prettier. She is said to be one of the prettiest goddesses.
Yeah. Emma Watson/Angelina Jodie should play her.
Lena Headey maybe? She seems to have that aura of sass and confidence and aristocracy perfectly in the GOT. But she is really talented, this role would not be doing her much justice as an actress' talent... what do you think?
Emilia Clarke as Hera. Then Mamoa and Clark are husband hand wife again only more complex. Additionally they have a great rapport
@@smartwateryttv4610 I'd say Jolie. Emma is too young to play Hera
I think you did a good job finding actors/actresses, but I’m not sure about Tom Holland and Apollo though.... I’m also not sure about Hera, I feel like you need to make her younger and prettier.I don’t have an actress in mind for Hera, but maybe Matthew Charles Czucrhy for Apollo?
I think Cole or Dylan Sprouse (with blond hair of course) for Apollo
Omg yes Matt
Maybe Angelina Jolie as Hera
I agree, From a Greek myth perspective (which Riordan doesn’t really steer away from), none of the gods should look older than mid-30’s or early 40’s. Hera was called “of the white arms” because she epitomized Greek ideas of femininity (not to be confused with “beauty”, though she, Aphrodite, and Athena were considered nearly equal in beauty). Meanwhile, Apollo was considered the ideal in male beauty by the Greeks and Romans alike, later emulated by neo-classical sculptors like Michelangelo. You would almost need to a seriously de-aged Brad Pitt, but ripped as he was for his Achilles role. Not easy to fill.
🤔. Lena Heady would actually make a very good Hera...
The actor that was chosen for hades is perfect because he plays Lucifer in the show Lucifer and pulls off the mysterious and slightly evil vibes that Hades would give off
Yeah
Yeah that's what I thought too !
Jay Duplass as Hades, the god of the underworld.
OMG Chris Pratt and Jack Black would be dream castings
Mario and Bowser
Chris hemsworth (or his brother) has Zues. Jason momoa as Poseidon , and either Tom Ellis or Tom Hiddleston as hades
look up greg berzinski. he's not an actor but he literally looks just like zeus's fan art
No to Hemsworth and Hiddleston. They belong to the Norse gods now, so should be considered off limits. Also, no Momoa playing Poseidon. It's bad enough that he was miscast as Aquaman (Arthur Curry isn't supposed to look like that). So, Logan Lehrman as Poseidon is the best. Timothy Omundson would be a perfect Zeus! He's played Cain on Supernatural already, and God Johnson on Lucifer. He has a Zeus look. Definitely Jack Black as Dionysius!! Need to hear casting choices for the demigods, Grover, Chiron...what I've heard so far is okay. I just don't like the girl who originally played Annabeth.
@@kaithorenfawkes8312 i mean there's always liam hemsworth
@@transfemjuniperberries Liam? Don't know much about him except he's got really bad taste in potential wives, having chosen Miley Cyrus. But I've never seen him act in a movie.
Agreed
Hear me out, Danny devito as Dionysus. It would be beautiful.
No it would be glorious
Maybe gabe...
I think its really cool you had the past percy jackson cast play the parents of the upcoming cast (with actual 12 year olds) having logan lerman as poseidon etc.
Yeah I thought it was a cool idea, some people don’t like it some do not🤷🏽♂️
Tom Holland is one of my all time favourite actors but I need Bradley James as Apollo!
If Hera ain’t Lena Headey, do we even want her?
Hope they cast either Tom Hiddleston, Tom Holland or Tom felton *somewhere* . That's gonna be amazing
I'm really feeling most of these 😍. And why does Chris Pratt as Hermes feel so perfect??,😂
Lin-Manuel Miranda as Hermes
I wish we could get all these famous actors for the series. PLEASE DISNEY.
So you have a cast of mostly superheroes. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
4:55 murdered me. Anyways, I think these are very ambitious castings. A lot of these guys will be very expensive.
Love the content, keep it up!
took you long enough to upload another video
but seriously I'm glad you're back
Yeah sorry, it’s hard with school and everything.
It's fine I completely understand
The films made them into teens and the characters weren’t well written. That’s like casting the first Harry Potter characters as teens who are in collage...doesn’t work does it? No
What?
@@Justaguythatcameby yeah the films suck
Personally, I didn’t mind that the films aged up the cast. A lot of stories and series where the characters are children, I can’t really see as realistic. For example, Sailor Moon is suppose to be a middle school girl but I always see her as older than she is to do what she does. Harry Potter was different because the fighting there was just pointing sticks (no shade, I’m a fan but it boils down to that) where as Percy Jackson has a lot of physical fighting that I imagine a lot of CGI will be needed.
DUDE!!!!! this is list is AMAZING!!! most of them are like RIGHT ON POINT!!!! And a great way to bring back some of the older cast, they didn't fit the PJ characters they played but the ones you place them on are like AMAZING!!
Dude. Can someone please send this video to Disney or Rick Riordan!?
I think this actors are the perfect ones for the series. Great job dude this is absolutly awsome!!
Jack Black as Dionysus if done correctly could be amazing. I'm just imagining him going from lazy and uninterested to quiet anger really easy. He's also a good enough actor to pull of the characters more complex scenes and attributes from the books
I can't speak for the rest of us on here, but I always thought Kyle Gass would be perfect for that.
jack black as dionysus is AMAZING
"Also she looks kinda like a bitch" fuckin killed me
I know that Hestia isn't in the series much but it would still be fun to have her.
The reason Aphrodite looks like Annabeth to Percy is because she has the ability to magically look like the most beautiful woman to whomever she manifests. If she were to appear to someone else, her physical form would resemble a perfected version of whomever it is they are most attracted to.
Keanu Reeves = Zeus
Jason Momoa = Posidon
Chris Hemsorth = Apollo
Danny DeVito = Gabe
Tom Holland = Grover ( He might be a bit old)
Tom Cruise = Anabeth's dad
Tom Hidleson/Zac Efron= Luke (Maybe)
Idris Elba = Chiron
Rick Riordan = A random cameo in each ep
This will not happen lol
Only reasons i dont agree with u is because i feel as if some of those actors are a bit to old to play the characters (specifically tom holland for grover and ton hiddleston/zac efron for luke)
But i do like ur ideas for appolo, zeus and posiedon a lot
And i LOVE the idea of Idris Elba of Chiron and the cameo of rick
One fan idea is that Rick Riordan could play Paul Blofis so it’s like he’s telling Estelle the stories like he told his son the stories irl
@@ihopeicanchangethisnamelat7108 yes perfect! i love it!
Idk why but im vibing with these picks
Aight if tom Holland is cast as Apollo I'd rewatch this so much
I actually liked Sean Bean as Zeus and thought that he was one of the few characters who was casted right. However, I could see Jason Mamoa playing Poseidon (lol Aquaman) or maybe Prometheus. I think he should definitely play a Titan, though. Also, even though I love Logan Lerman as an actor, I think the original Percy Jackson is better left where it is, so I would cast Gerard Butler in the role of Poseidon. I think to cut down on the cost of this already expensive project and because I personally don't see him playing Ares, I would actually cast Jensen Ackles in the role because he seems like more of a rage and bloodthirsty war god to me. This is based on how I've seen him act in Supernatural both as a demon with the Mark of Cain and the Archangel Michael. To me, Ares always struck me as the kind of guy who was a grade-A douchebag, but with a certain elegance, and I think that Jensen fits that description. And also to me, the actress who plays Hera looks a little bit too old (especially when compared side-by-side with Jason Mamoa) and I can see her playing Rhea more. For Hera I think it should be Famke Janssen, because she is no stranger to playing a character with a sense of superiority or bitchiness. But other than that, I agreed with a lot of your casting choices.
If this is a cast for future PJ pruductions I swear the MCU Is gonna have some competition
Bryan Seeker just started his list.
I think the main 3 should be unknown but sunny suljic if he wasn’t so old would make a great Percy 😂
When I saw the image of tom Holland with blonde hair, I honestly thought he looked a lot like peeta
Omg same
i saw a fan acc at insta that says sam claflin as apollo and its just perfect! i personally think luke hemmings as apollo but he's a singer, i haven't seen him in acting before.
Is it just me, and I know this isn't a god, but am I the only one who pictured Smelly Gabe being played by Danny DeVito? I swear he'd be perfect for that role!
Hey man, remember me? I was here at 3 views, glad to see you're growing and doing well. See ya soon.
This was 100% the best fan cast I’ve seen so far. Lucifer with Tom Ellis is an epic show, and Tom Ellis 110% would be an amazing Hades!! Tom Hardy is totally the perfect choice for Ares!! Chris Pratt is perfect for Hermes!! I’ve also been saying forever that Jack Black should play Dionysus! (Tom Ellis has to be favorite one, though)
Dude your Hades casting is ON POINT
Jack Black as Mr D is all that I need in my life
I'm not really sure about everyone else but I love the picks for Mr D and Artemis
I saw Chris Pratt on the thumbnail and I'm desperately hoping he's cast as Hermes.
The part about Hera oh by gosh😂
This would be the most expensive cast, we’ve seen this type of famous casting from Disney before in movies which did not work great at all *mhm Doolittle
Maybe the actress for Aphrodite could be the one who played Margaery Tyrell, or maybe Lena (Cersei's actress) could do Hera... seemed like, good according to what I'd made of them in the books
The reason Percy saw Aphrodite looking like anabeth is be causes she takes the looks of the person the person loves
I love the casting for Poseidon, Athena and Mr. D.
Logan as Poseidon would be amazing, and I really agree with all other castings, especially chris pratt
That'd be one expensive movie
I can't unsee tom Holland as Apollo now. It needs to happen. It just needs to
Marget Robby...hahahahahaah I died
jack black as dionysus is perfect
I enjoyed this video and as a pj fan I really agree with this cast!💙 I also agree with the aphrodiate being played by multiple actresses💯
i also want danny devito so much for dionisus
Lin Manuel Miranda as Hermes
Adam Copeland as Ares
Jason Mantzoukas as Dionysus / Mr. D
Megan Mullally as Alecto / Ms. Dodds
Glynn Turman as Chiron / Mr. Brunner
Virginia Kull as Sally Jackson
Lance Reddick as Zeus
Toby Stephens as Poseidon
Jay Duplass as Hades
Timothy Omundson as Hephaestus
My reactions/opinions on youre desicions:
Zeus casting: yes
Poseidon casting: nope, I wouldn't prefer him
Hades casting: yup
Ares casting: yeah
Hermes casting: *laugh* mmm-hm (I like it)
Aphrodite: def
Athena: maybe
Hera: PERFECT
Demeter: yes
Artemis: ABSOLUTELY
Apollo:🤭yea
Hephaestus: amazing choice
Dionysus: OMFG YESSSSSSSS
My only comment on this video: What about Hestia?
Actually, i can imagine Jason Momoa as Zeus since he is the Aquaman, especially with his Trisula.... its also hard and dilematic cause he and both with Logan, are the sons of the sea😭😭😭😭😭
I don’t agree with some of these, especially for a TV show, but casting someone for Aphrodite that looks like Annabeth was a brilliant point.
If one could dream.. One hundred percent agree with everything
i hope there is more diversity in the disney plus adaptation tho but some of these ideas are really really cool
Dude picked the most Poseidon like actor to be Zeus
As soon as I read percy jackson I thought jack black would be great for dionyusus
the budget gotta be stupid big for this cast
Clicking on this video I didn't know what to expect, but these were some damn good castings. I'd like to see Disney go all out for Percy Jackson, at least attempt to rival Harry Potter.
I agree with ur casting choices, especially Hephaestus
Logan Lerman NEEDs to be Poseidon
Jack black works better for more comedic characters, where Mr. D would also have that intimidating side. You need someone with more range and that person has got to be Stanley Tucci. If you’ve see movies like the devil wears Prada, the lovely bones, or hunger games; you’ll see Mr. D in all of them.
Umm, you should probably know that Stanley Tucci played him in the Sea of Monsters.
@@FindingMomo2317 I know, we should be fair when the movies make 1 correct decision.
Jack black fits with dionysus by looks and jack black kinda has the same humour
I can really see him as dionysus
I love the idea for Logan to play Poseidon
My Cast
Zeus- Hugh Jackman
Poseidon- Chris Pine
Hades- Gerard Butler
Hera- Cate Blanchett OR Julia Roberts
Demeter- ?
Athena- Keri Russell
Ares- tom hardy
Hepestus - Alfred Molina?
Artemis- ?
Apollo- ? Tom Holland
Hermes- Nathan Fillion
Aphrodite- Scarlet Johanson, Natalie Portman, Grace Fulton, Christina Hendricks, Halie Berry, Elle Fanning.
Mr. D- John Goodman
Persephone- Emma Watson
Jon berthal must be Hades
I agree with Pisodieon and Athena because it be a nice bridge and I think all the original should play their parents
Luke Able would be a nice Hermes
Okay but now I’ll be mad if they don’t cast Jack Black as Dionysus.
Disney NEEDS TO SEE THIS!!!
Such a hard toss up between Nathan Fillion & Chris Pratt, though. I honestly think one should be Hermes & one should be Apollo. They would make such great partners in cre the way Hermes & Apollo seem to.
love it!!!!!
I liked all your casting except ares and Hera
Also I need jack black to do the voice of black jack that would be awesome!!🤣
I don’t agree with Tom Holland as Apollo but I don’t have any other ideas. He would fit as Lester though imo.
What if matthew daddario is zeus i mean just think
I'm literally imaginings Alec Lightwood being Zeus and I CAN'T
my recasting 2021~
Poseidon: Darren Criss
Zeus: Jon Hamm
Hades: David Tennant
Athena: Dianna Agron
Hermes: Chris Colfer
Aphrodite: Lea Michele
Hera: Idina Menzel
Apollo: Henry Cavill or Owen Joyner
(older) Annabeth: Lili Reinhart
Casting Lerman and Daddario again would be a big mistake. I think it would be cool to have Lerman cameo several times in smaller roles but he definitely should not be a god. I do like your choices for Dionysus and Aphrodite through. Here is what I would do excluding Dionysus and Aphrodite ...
Zeus- Josh Brolin
Poseidon- Hugh Jackman
Hades- Mads Mikkelson
Ares-1st Choice -Dwayne Johnson 2nd Choice- Jon Bernthal
Athena- Angelina Jolie
Apollo- Sam Claflin
Artemis- Raffey Cassidy
Hermes- Ewan Mcgregor
Hephaestus- Idris Elba
Hera- Rachel Weisz
Jack Black as Dionysus?
- I WILL BE SO HAPPY : )
I have Keira Knightley as Hera
Margot Robbie as Aphrodite
Gal Gadot as Athena
Adelaide Kane as Artemis and
Elizabeth Gillies as Persephone
I have just for the godess, my cast is unreal but you know everyone can dream 🤷♀️
Jack Black as Dionysus? Hell yaaaa
If this franchise had the money this would be the best my fave Tom holland that fits so good
Finally a decent Percy Jackson!!!
The only change I would make, would be Gary old man (Sirius black) as hades