Every Disney Live Action Remake Ranked

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 91

  • @tamartzuman3316
    @tamartzuman3316 Рік тому +46

    Mulan had so much potential as a live action. I was all down for a more mature- action movie about Mulan, but instead we got this shit. Just check out mulan: Rise of a Warrior from 2009.

    • @gailasprey7787
      @gailasprey7787 Рік тому

      Where can you watch it?

    • @tamartzuman3316
      @tamartzuman3316 Рік тому

      @@gailasprey7787 The full movie is on youtube:
      ua-cam.com/video/0ep39N-vgDY/v-deo.html

  • @paarp7855
    @paarp7855 Рік тому +82

    Bruhhhhh....HOW CAN YOU SAYYY that Alice in the Wonderland is a REMAKE and then place it in 10th PLACE! Its not a remake when its clearly stated in the movie that she already was in the Wonderland as a kid (the OG animated movie) and this is her second time in wonderland, she just didn't remember and thought it was a dream before...That movie is a masterpiece...it used to be colorful when she was a CHILD, she is older now and thinks more like adult so everything is dark and melancholic.

    • @Ace-ym3wg
      @Ace-ym3wg Рік тому +16

      A masterpiece? Seriously?

    • @quintenvanuffelen3102
      @quintenvanuffelen3102 Рік тому +15

      Well it was branded as a remake (i've never see the movie)

    • @paarp7855
      @paarp7855 Рік тому +15

      @@quintenvanuffelen3102 it was Re-imagining of the books by Lewis Carroll, not the disney film

    • @quintenvanuffelen3102
      @quintenvanuffelen3102 Рік тому +5

      @@paarp7855 Ohhhhhhhhhhh, thanks man

    • @Inottxim
      @Inottxim Рік тому +8

      its his opinions its what he thinks of the movie

  • @sophieamandaleitontoomey9343
    @sophieamandaleitontoomey9343 Рік тому +15

    While I don’t think Little Mermaid is worse than the Lion King or Pinocchio, I think my hatred of stems from its never ending preaching about “fixing” the old movie’s problems and acting like it knows better than the original. You can just feel it in almost every single frame and it really gets on your nerves.

    • @gailasprey7787
      @gailasprey7787 Рік тому +1

      Yeah like I’m not mad that Eric was the one to save Ariel. She didn’t need to be a ‘girl boss’ because that just wasn’t her character. She was a curious and naive person and used her wit to escape danger in the shark scene. Knowing she couldn’t take it on and swimming off as fast as she could then getting it stuck. She isn’t shown as the most muscular person nor somebody who would have the ability to drive a boat. She is a mermaid after all. And she saves Eric so it only makes sense that Eric saves her. It’s a payoff, almost a way of Eric saying thank you. When I heard she was the one to do it I just sighed to myself.

  • @BrcRosa
    @BrcRosa Рік тому +25

    Agree with a lot of this.
    Don't agree that the singing in the new Little Mermaid does its job. Halle does have a beautiful voice. But these movies are like Broadway musicals. The songs arent supposed to be a break for something pretty. They are part of the story that are necessary.
    Every time I see Halles renditins of any of the songs it takes me out of the story and I see her on a stage in front of a crowd or on American Idol.
    And this could be the fault of the direction. Jodi has said her performance is all because of Howard Ashman.
    Javier Bardem is an amazing actor. In this he's a wood plank as are many of the performances.
    I definitely have more of an emotional childhood attachment to the original so it bothers me more than it probably should when people who did not understand the original story or character motivations are in charge of the remake.
    They create so many issues that werent in the original.

    • @Martin77641
      @Martin77641 Рік тому +1

      I hated it that the actors don´t look like the original. So many iconic chracters are not in these movies.

    • @Apricotwarrior
      @Apricotwarrior Рік тому

      Anyways….

  • @Kittenmax15
    @Kittenmax15 Рік тому +16

    The reason king louey was so big is because he is a gigantopithokus a ancient type of monkey that we’re actually that big

    • @gailasprey7787
      @gailasprey7787 Рік тому

      Would those be around in the setting of Mowgli though?

    • @Kittenmax15
      @Kittenmax15 Рік тому

      I’m honestly not shure but he says that’s what he is in I wana be like you

  • @themanflake
    @themanflake Рік тому +10

    I actually enjoy the live action Alice in Wonderland movie

  • @Depth217
    @Depth217 Рік тому +7

    While The Lion King is second worst (sorry I hate Mulan more), it’s weirdly a way for me to experience the basics of The Lion King. The original movie is so precious to me I can only watch it like once a year because I get so emotional in it. The remake has the same score, which is one of if not my favorite part of the movie, so it’s like listening to the soundtrack (and believe me I HAVE the soundtrack too). So in a weird way I don’t mind having the remake on in the background while I fold laundry or cook.

  • @JeffUni
    @JeffUni Рік тому +4

    No cause if someone says the Cinderella remake is also bad then we pulling up frfr

  • @nilesclifford9704
    @nilesclifford9704 9 місяців тому +1

    I am ready for the sword in the stone, the aristocats, the hunchback of notre dame, hercules, tarzan, home on the range, atlantis the lost empire, brother bear, the black cauldron, pocahontas, and the emperor's new groove, and treasure planet.

  • @SuperMarioEdgar
    @SuperMarioEdgar Рік тому +12

    Mulan > Live action Mulan fr

    • @Phobie_2000
      @Phobie_2000 Рік тому +6

      You could say that for literally any live action remake, tough.

    • @JeffUni
      @JeffUni Рік тому +1

      @@Phobie_2000 Except the Cinderella one

    • @nicolaakuneme9024
      @nicolaakuneme9024 Рік тому +1

      Little mermaid > live action little mermaid

    • @williamstormo2922
      @williamstormo2922 2 місяці тому

      Lion king > Lion king live action

  • @DreamyAlienn07
    @DreamyAlienn07 Рік тому +2

    I think the Cinderella live action needs more recognition, its a pretty good movie and I love the cast. I hate most of the Disney's live action but that one is a masterpiece in comparison with the other ones.
    And yes, Mulan fucking sucks.

  • @caraboo6812
    @caraboo6812 Рік тому +1

    I’m so happy my Cinderella bias has been validated 😭

  • @cartooncentral263
    @cartooncentral263 Рік тому +3

    We all hate Mulan 2020.

  • @lovec4nw00
    @lovec4nw00 Місяць тому

    I wish Mulan 2020 looked as good in the trailers 😢

  • @dragongamerrylucius
    @dragongamerrylucius Рік тому +4

    I personally believe Mulan is THE WORST live-action adaptation out of the rest. Next to The Lion King and following up with the newly release live-action of The Little Mermaid too.

  • @nicloren2220
    @nicloren2220 Рік тому +2

    i loved the 2010 alice sorry but also … glenn as cruella gives me such a viceral and creepy feeling because she was so good at that that i had to scrub through the video so i didn’t see her as cruella she terrified me. yes i am 27.

  • @AllenTheAnimator004
    @AllenTheAnimator004 Рік тому

    The worst thing about this is:
    - Wokes will call us retards for liking the original than the remake because they say that "not supporting live action remakes means you hate humans"
    - It teaches bad lessons to kids. Even some kids gtfo the cinemas because Ariel is black. Not that they're racist,but Ariel being black Doesn't. Fit. At. all.
    - Girlboss... I hate girlbosses that don't show character growth and development(I'm looking at you,Ms. Marvel). I mean i hate when boys underestimates girls,but if girls are so powerful to the point the males are useless,then that's where i reach the last straw. Call me sexist,but if the world goes extinct because boys are on Mars,then don't blame us,you wanna be the bosses of us anyway
    - Somehow people are still supporting this,DESPITE KNOWING THIS IS GONNA SUCK!(except for the live action remake of Cinderella)

  • @droppedcroissant2910
    @droppedcroissant2910 Рік тому +6

    Beauty and the beast remake was good and I’ll die on that hill

    • @pottertheavenger1363
      @pottertheavenger1363 Рік тому +4

      Had the chance to make a dark gothic fantasy and blew it up.

    • @Gabry4777
      @Gabry4777 Рік тому +3

      The film where the Beast became an a-hole?

  • @quintenvanuffelen3102
    @quintenvanuffelen3102 Рік тому +4

    Great vid! Do you have any interests in doing a marvel one?

  • @oklaclarinet
    @oklaclarinet Рік тому +1

    Oh, they absolutely could've made the dogs talk in 1996 if they wanted. After all, Babe came out in 1995.

  • @CatherineJessicaNatof
    @CatherineJessicaNatof Рік тому +1

    I actually saw Mulan (2020) *during the pandemic*

  • @arjunghose7284
    @arjunghose7284 Рік тому +1

    this means that , illumination animated movies are way better than Every Disney Live Action Remake

  • @Simbala-bq5vy
    @Simbala-bq5vy Рік тому +1

    Does Kim possible also counts as a remake? If yes than it should be way down to the list

  • @jcpm1988
    @jcpm1988 Рік тому +6

    101 Dalmatians should be number one

  • @stellaberndtson3406
    @stellaberndtson3406 11 днів тому

    I'm not going to pretend that I like Mulan 2020 because I don't. However the excluding of Mushu was probably for the better. In a live action movie, he'd probably look weird.

  • @gambledork7154
    @gambledork7154 Рік тому

    Was not ready for Sabaton to come out of nowhere

  • @sg6633
    @sg6633 5 місяців тому

    I think, I totally agree with you re the ranking of these movies. I love the live action Cinderella and I've watched it a few times. I don't mind the mice in the original, but I loved the fleshing out of Ella's back story and the Prince. I like The Jungle Book too, but hated their version of King Louie. While the original Lion King and Beauty and the Beast were the best, the live actions were lifeless and one and done for me. Not buying the DVDs of these ever. Aladdin was ok, but Jafar was just too good looking. There didn't seem to be any reason for Jasmine, not to be in to him. Many of the others I have not seen, and will not se because of the casting. And btw, you sure swear a lot for someone who's 7 years less than 21.

  • @mullclan8038
    @mullclan8038 Рік тому +1

    Dang. The f bombs. Im so proud.

  • @user-idontknow984
    @user-idontknow984 Рік тому +2

    Gaston was the only good thing about the live action beauty and the beast

  • @c0mpu73rguy
    @c0mpu73rguy Рік тому

    17:11 I was. It's the one I genuinely enjoyed watching with the Jungle Book

  • @jaygooese4242
    @jaygooese4242 Рік тому +1

    I like The Jungle Book (2016) remake

  • @kotchapakmaneechote2062
    @kotchapakmaneechote2062 Рік тому

    I stupidly watched Mulan remake back in 2020, squash me if you will, I'd rather do that than seeing more Disney LAR getting made.

  • @cartooncentral263
    @cartooncentral263 Рік тому +1

    Don't compare Space Jam 2 while the live action Alice movie. Am I the only one who liked Space Jam 2?

  • @Blazingstudios882
    @Blazingstudios882 Рік тому

    11:44 thank you so much!

  • @bjayroe25
    @bjayroe25 Рік тому

    So if they keep making every Disney movie into a Live Action Remake then that means one day we will get a Live Action Home on the Range. I hope this trend ends before that happens. We don't need realistic cows talking and going on an adventure to save a farm. The animated version was just fine.

  • @DudeitsVero
    @DudeitsVero Рік тому +1

    Dude, your point on mulan were good i see, but i was chill til they basically force mulan with shang , where i thought she rather had more chemistry with the shifter, that irked me. But brsides that???! Dude alice and wonderland, it's version was unique compared to realisticly and bland remakes 😁 you sure you just unease by it being a spooky dark version. You did notice that everything wasnt always dark, everything was colorful WHEN alice was A KID, they showed/told. This was set in when alice is older the idea was pretty cool, story was good, had ye hooked wasnt just Johnny Depp. 🤣
    (I believe i was able to remember that, i got a shty memory, barely noticed someone else disctibing my thoughts 😆 oh well)

  • @LayPie-qj7nq
    @LayPie-qj7nq Рік тому

    Me trying not to get mad when he said all the negatives for the little mermaid (expect flounders design)😂

  • @kylevansteelandt3971
    @kylevansteelandt3971 Рік тому

    My favorite Disney remakes in the modern era are "The Jungle Book," "The Lion King," and "Peter Pand and Wendy." My least favorite modern remakes from Disney are "Pete's Dragon," and "Aladdin."

  • @cardinmalone4974
    @cardinmalone4974 Рік тому +4

    You clearly don't understand proper representation, consistency and being truly faithful to the original films for nostalgia.

  • @LittleJoeTheMoonlightCat
    @LittleJoeTheMoonlightCat Рік тому

    Well I see Alice in Wonderland as more of a Sequel that Follows up on Alice as a Teen or Young Adult as she is Still having those Dreams, And it's not as Cookie Cutter as the others. It Follows up on The Original and is the Sequel we never saw. But You do You.

  • @alysims7104
    @alysims7104 Рік тому +2

    No way you put peter pan at 3

  • @adamjankoleno1133
    @adamjankoleno1133 Рік тому +2

    You don't like Alice in the Wonderland 2010? You don't deserve an opinion. Like man, that thing is better adaptation than Return of the King.

  • @AntAndABat
    @AntAndABat Рік тому

    epic video

  • @cullenbeeson2420
    @cullenbeeson2420 Рік тому

    I’m cool with the movies that actually have enough effort put in to make a different story like Christopher robin. All the others are just lazy

  • @Stunt-Man174
    @Stunt-Man174 Рік тому +1

    I like Pinocchio 2022 and little Marmaid and Lion King

    • @Stunt-Man174
      @Stunt-Man174 Рік тому

      Oh and beauty and the beast ( the live action ones)

    • @Stunt-Man174
      @Stunt-Man174 Рік тому +1

      Put little Marmaid and Pinocchio in 1 and 2

  • @kitsorcerer
    @kitsorcerer Рік тому

    Alice in wonderland was a sequel to the animated movie so its technically not a remake. But is ok.

  • @mateomedinamedina4523
    @mateomedinamedina4523 Рік тому +2

    Bruh can make ranking illumination movie

  • @ruekennedy3316
    @ruekennedy3316 Рік тому

    Aladdin was my favorite but I respect your list. Beauty and the Beast was the worst because of the music…

  • @ozboz-roblox363
    @ozboz-roblox363 Рік тому +3

    Rank illumination movies😂

  • @riftshredder5438
    @riftshredder5438 Рік тому

    Why is The Lion King even in this video? It is not live action, nothing in that movie was live action, it was all animated

  • @Spiritawaysouls
    @Spiritawaysouls Рік тому

    Dislike every remake Disney movie, Mulan was my favorite until it had a remake

  • @mateomedinamedina4523
    @mateomedinamedina4523 Рік тому

    First now wait for years for live action Snow White and lilo stich and moana

  • @Martin77641
    @Martin77641 Рік тому

    Okay decisions but mistakes are in their.
    They had the technology to let the dalmatiners talk. You can see this in the movie babe.
    I hated it that they take complete different actorsa as the original and that so often.
    Captain Hook doesn´t look like the original and Arielle is not Arielle. Where are Arielles sisters?

  • @perdelkin
    @perdelkin Рік тому

    bro looks like eddsworld character

  • @jucamovi1992
    @jucamovi1992 16 днів тому

    The little Mermaid, Pinocchio, Peter Pan are the worst live action remakes ever, Snow White will join them probably.

  • @lilymuncy2365
    @lilymuncy2365 4 місяці тому

    My opinion Lion King 2019 is Disney worst live action remake.Also Jungle book is best Disney live action remake.

  • @LeeroyTheWrathBear
    @LeeroyTheWrathBear Рік тому

    I never cared for Mushu but yes that movie is an inexcusable disgrace to the animated one.

  • @mariosperras2859
    @mariosperras2859 Рік тому

    Where is Maleficenttt

  • @Inottxim
    @Inottxim Рік тому

    in my opinion most of the live actions i never wacthed but some i have and they arent really good but lady and the tramp is my favorite in my opinion cuz the dogs where cute the sets where realistic. little mermaid characters where very different like flounder is nothing like i dont see yellow inside him the colors look dead but sebastians eyes😢😢 but aladin is very nice jafar tho is nothing like he looks in the original he just looks younger like if he was his son or something wearing his clothes but its still a nice movie the jungle book in MY OPINION is kinda boring but also scary and bland but it was good also cinderella is too good like it was sad aswell but the fairy god mother is nice but live actions? There pretty bad, maybe cuz its hard to get something fantasy into real live action like if it where real but i hope they try to make live actions more realistic and fun

  • @onikaconstantine8861
    @onikaconstantine8861 Рік тому +1

    Mulan 2020 sucks.

  • @iasmin8490
    @iasmin8490 Рік тому

    Wait, are u 14?

  • @dallasdiaz2130
    @dallasdiaz2130 Рік тому

    I think the mulan remake is the worst disney remake because it's awful the mulan remake liddetally missed the hole point of the original mulan because the mulan remake has a boring story boring characters and terrible fights scenes and they made mulan in the disney remake so boring

  • @Lolirock971
    @Lolirock971 Рік тому

    Please find YHWH Elohim and keep the commandments in Exodus 20 and Leviticus 11😊
    Please read Exodus 20 and pray for forgiveness
    2nd Corinthians 5:17
    “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here!”
    [37] Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. [38] This is the first and great commandment. [39] And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself. [40] On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets. Matthew 22:37- 40
    Please read the book of Jonah, Matthew, Exodus you'll have the information you need.❤️ ❤️ 💐 💐 🌈 🌈 Exodus 20 Leviticus 11

  • @cartooncentral263
    @cartooncentral263 Рік тому +2

    The live action Little Mermaid movie was terrible. Halle Bailey was a horrible Ariel. and I'm a black person. I hate race swapping. The Little Mermaid was one of my favorite Disney movie and they ruined it was that crappy live action trash.

    • @snatched2348
      @snatched2348 Рік тому +2

      Halle Bailey did amazing as ariel

  • @Muradwalis92
    @Muradwalis92 Рік тому

    Are you blind?