Veteran filmmaker Hassan Muthalib recalls a brutal killing during the May 13 riots | COVER STORY

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 55

  • @TheAgat94
    @TheAgat94 5 років тому +81

    House burning, people screaming , someone is being murdered in front of our own eyes. This is something that I wish never happened in Malaysia, but I remember before GE14, my parents already start to stock up food because we were so afraid that 13th May might come again, but until today we are living in harmony, and this is what we need for our children and our grandchildren, and for the coming generation.

  • @youji8516
    @youji8516 4 місяці тому +8

    It's such a shame how the buku teks sejarah tries to avoid this topic at all costs

  • @jessccy
    @jessccy 5 років тому +54

    How did that 12yr old boy was brought up... Holding a machete and killing an old weak woman. Thinking back. So many innocent lives lost.

    • @hotchocolates3828
      @hotchocolates3828 5 років тому +1

      Ikr

    • @hassanrizal1160
      @hassanrizal1160 Рік тому +4

      i think the amount of patience from the malays being curse and provoke from the chinese are unbearable. just imagine, the chinese at that time are immigrants like bangla today, but then have the guts to curse the malays (indigenous). i think that makes the malays amouk and lose their patience

    • @theallseeingeye9388
      @theallseeingeye9388 Рік тому

      ​@@hassanrizal1160think deeper.
      A 12 year old kid hacking an old woman just because she is of a different race because Malays most their patience spontaneously doesnt make any logical sense.
      A 12 year old kid is a child who doesnt experience or see life as how an adult see's it.
      Even if the child had been brutalised by that old woman before that, children do not deal with that trauma by picking up a machete and hacking the neck of their abuser.
      Not unlesss the child was exposed to something darker over a time period before the incident.
      Which again rubbishes tbe theory Melayu hikang sabar secara spontan dan mengamok.
      Simplistic answers are often sold because we dont know the real reasons or covering up something else.
      Example why were there Malay communists among the rank and file of PKM?.
      Not one or two but regiments.
      Answer is mereka pengkhianat bangsa dan agama.
      I accepted this as an answer when I was in highschool.
      A product of official brainwashing who was programmed to accept what I was told officially as the truth.
      Our biasses tells us subconsciously that people we identify with like our race, our religion or our political party must be telling the truth, wont like and are the good guys so we tend to automatically take what comes from them as the absolute truth.

    • @footballmg884
      @footballmg884 9 місяців тому +9

      @@hassanrizal1160 "the chinese at that time are immigrants like bangla today". Well done! You have a good knowledge of Malaysian History.

    • @fatahmukhriz8919
      @fatahmukhriz8919 8 місяців тому +4

      ​@@footballmg884 betul la tu. Asal usul dulu datang naik tongkang. Samada dibawa British atau melarikan diri dr feudalism di tanah besar. Sejarah tetap sejarah.. Tiada siapa boleh ubahnya

  • @adlansalleh412
    @adlansalleh412 5 років тому +40

    We should learn from this. I guess I didnt learn much from sejarah PMR/SPM. Tau nak hafal je and get thru exams.
    Haha

  • @LepasAnakTidur
    @LepasAnakTidur 2 роки тому +11

    My husband told me this guy is a legend

    • @amenxamin6813
      @amenxamin6813 2 роки тому +3

      Ya dia father of animation malaysia

  • @albertyeoh3147
    @albertyeoh3147 5 років тому +43

    Dlm peristiwa 13 May, semua pihak kalah. Negara kita tumbang. Melayu Cina India semuanya tewas sebab yang matinya rakyat Malaysia! Terutamanya yg xberdosa! Hari tu saudara kita yg ditetak xkira Melayu Cina India darah tumpah semuanya merah. Tulang pun sama warna putih. Kita sama2 org Malaysia jgnlah biarkan negara kita ditumbang lagi kerana politik. Sebab nak bangun lagi tu bukan mudah. Tengok negara yg asyik berperang saudara.

    • @shiryuusama6725
      @shiryuusama6725 5 років тому +12

      Tapi sedih ,politik di negara kita bermain dengan isu kaum.
      Kes Adib (fireman) masih dalam inquest but for how long?

    • @drdrunkenstein8974
      @drdrunkenstein8974 3 роки тому +3

      @Perangkul Tukang Kau nak orang India Dan China bawak orang Dari Negara mereka ke…kau berani sebab kau kaum majoriti.

    • @kingsoonkit9234
      @kingsoonkit9234 3 роки тому +3

      @Perangkul Tukang fikir camni la bwak kpd perkauman, kau rasa kau tu ada "geng" melayu centu, sekaum sebijik. Galakkan perpaduan main ngancam mcm tu. Bodo

    • @catlat3606
      @catlat3606 3 роки тому +2

      @@kingsoonkit9234 sbb org2 mcm dia la negara kite tak maju

    • @mohandave5825
      @mohandave5825 2 роки тому

      @Perangkul Tukang dafaqqq?

  • @jamesbond0077
    @jamesbond0077 Рік тому +5

    Who is the mastermind? No one’s know the killers are innocent too because they get manipulated by upper level.

  • @stargazeronesixseven
    @stargazeronesixseven Рік тому +5

    If only we had Governance that was based on Meritocracy & Multi~Ethnicities Togetherness like under Singaporean Stateman Lee Kuan Yew back in 1969 , this Selfish Politically motivated racial riots would had been reduced & avoided! Looking back , the communist minded groups & the racist minded groups with their childishness & selfishness that caused this unnecessary & regrettable Dark Spot in the 13thMay1969 racial riots in Malaysia history ... 🙏 May the innocent & Departed be Blessed to a Better World & Realm without Religion nor Racial conflicts! ... True God knows Everything! 🕯🌍🕊

  • @azim_animated
    @azim_animated 4 роки тому +13

    Hasan Muthalib my sifu in storytelling !

  • @shiryuusama6725
    @shiryuusama6725 5 років тому +17

    The political agenda is the thing that separate us
    1. School for races
    2. Adib the Bomba case 😭
    3. Biasiswa JPA (pulau pinang) latest
    Etc...

    • @alalalala57
      @alalalala57 Рік тому +4

      4. SBP
      5. UiTM
      etc.

    • @AymanAnual
      @AymanAnual 8 місяців тому +1

      6. SJKC/SJKT
      7. Mandarin speaker as job requirement
      8. Non Native that cannot speak National Language
      Etc, etc

  • @yonghonmun
    @yonghonmun 3 роки тому +9

    Wondering where the 12years boy who hacked the old aunty..karma will serve him.

    • @nalininambiar2316
      @nalininambiar2316 Рік тому +3

      He will have to see his family suffer and he himself will have endless suffering!

  • @nalininambiar2316
    @nalininambiar2316 Рік тому +1

    Some ppl are by nature very violent They can easily murder human beings .They are not very high souls.Even when they become educated, that wicked streak is still evident in the aggressive manner in which they demand respect and how they will not compromise in anything at all.The ppl who killed innocent ppl cannot escape GOD. 's wrath.Spirituall ppl will never harm anybody in thought word or deed!!! Their whole lineage will suffer for sins of their ancestors! No escape!!

  • @alantan7425
    @alantan7425 4 місяці тому

    how did he know the boy was 12 years old?

    • @herman8210
      @herman8210 4 місяці тому

      size of the body. even not 12 years old, maybe 11,13 and maximum 14 years old.

  • @nyk2000m
    @nyk2000m 4 роки тому +2

    This is not a country of multiracial. This had been and still a place where multi races HAPPENED to live tgt...

  • @asnbloxalt7883
    @asnbloxalt7883 5 років тому +7

    The Purge: *Malaysia*
    This is just a joke. Don’t kill me

  • @tajabdullah.malaysia
    @tajabdullah.malaysia 2 роки тому +1

    Critical Race Theory in Malaysia

  • @RUHappyATM
    @RUHappyATM Рік тому

    They do grow them young racists, don't they.

  • @jaylanun3950
    @jaylanun3950 5 років тому +2

    Diversion.

  • @Dancetilldeathdousapart
    @Dancetilldeathdousapart 5 років тому +2

    ⚘⚘

  • @serolsyah5234
    @serolsyah5234 4 роки тому +1

    Kepala hanggukk betoll HM nim

  • @kentyee4138
    @kentyee4138 Рік тому

    Something not right in him when he told us he was 23 by then but know nothing what about things going on.😂. No true but half cook story. SMiLE 😊

  • @retroradfilms
    @retroradfilms 5 років тому

    Ha Ha, I love it.

  • @JosephJohn-bc4iy
    @JosephJohn-bc4iy 2 місяці тому

    DALAM QURAN SUDAH DI SEBUT JANGAN BERBAIK DENGAN ORANG KAFIR BUDDHA , HINDU ATAU CHRISTIAN.