For the record, Christina supported a C#5 in this video, and Ari supported an Eb5. There was NO support for either above that note, so please do not spread misinformation because you watched an uneducated stan vocal channel and instantly pledged your allegiance to believing whatever they say. My unbiased opinion would be that Ari wins, but not by much. Really just because she has a wider more controlled belting range. They actually share a lot of the same falters (tongue tension, high larynx). Ari tips it for me due to her consistent lack of throaty placement. Not to say she never gets throaty, but it's not often enough to warrant considering that a flaw in her singing.
Actually no…. Xtina’s UNDAMAGED voice is actually higher than Ari’s by one level which is why Xtina can sing higher head voice notes but due to damage that Ari doesn’t have, this is why Ari can belt higher but can’t sing vocal runs on the same level as Xtina. In terms of power, Ari will also reign supreme because of the fact her vocal cords are physically larger than Xtina’s.
@@parfumextraitfan7453 and not, Xtina doesn't have the Belt extension better than Ari these days, Ari arrives at Bb5 while Xtina arrives at E5 these days. In terms of head voice, Ari's range is as good as Christina's. Agility is training and creativity, and in this regard Xtina is the best because she takes more risks on melismas than Ari, which is why many of Ari's melismas sound similar. Agility has nothing to do with Ariana's vocal cords being longer than Xtina's. Xtina's voice is much heavier than Ariana's.
Low : Xtina Mid Belt : Xtina Upper Belt : Ari Falsetto : Xtina Head Voice : Ari Whistle : Ari Agility : Xtina Power : Xtina Growl : Xtina Stable : Xtina Tone : Xtina
Runs and agility= Christina Technique = Ariana Stage presence= christina High notes= Ariana Versatility and voice richness= christina For me both are great singers but I choose Christina. She has a natural talent and unic voice. Ariana has a beautiful and angelical voice.
i love both christina’s voice is forever having me shook . especially when she was vocally her best .. buuuuttt ariana has a SUPERIOR technique and i feel like is more pleasant to listen to with a better tone and her belts are just soooo amazing
Their voices are completely different. Aguilera is a mezzo soprano while Grande is a soprano with a very high natural placement. Not a fair comparison.
actually not. if you compare ariana with others mezzo like beyoncé, pink or jojo she would lose, and you know that, because they have better techniques
@@thunderstorm__8147 Christina is a mezzo. A soprano does not possess the depth in their lower range that Christina has. Christina has also had substantial volume on belts as low as F4, which sopranos most certainly do not possess. Christina is an untrained mezzo.
There is no such thing as an unfair comparison. I don't like this misconception. Beyonce is a mezzo that would destroy Ariana. Whereas Bebe Rexha and Camilla Cabelo are two sopranos with just as limited support and ability in their belting as Christina. it's about technique. Not to say Ariana possesses a great technique either. That's why I chose her to compare, because I knew the conversation could evolve beyond just technical aspects since both singers falter greatly in that area.
@@thunderstorm__8147 she doesn't... she has a rich lower register. please do your research before making an analysis of her vocals. She has supported down to D3, and can sing down to B2 live. And yes, she has MANY more examples of her singing low notes with a neutral larynx over a lowered. She does not use a lowered larynx in her midrange, she uses tongue tension and nasality. However, show me a clip of Demi, or Ariana, or any other soprano being able to belt an F4 with significant impact. It's just not possible when ur range doesn't allow ur voice to achieve it.
@@thunderstorm__8147 She supported two E3's in 10 seconds on her Masterclass alone, let alone the many she has supported live. She has at least 8 supported Eb3's i know of, two D3's she did on The Voice.
God issa woman Mariah has belted whistles and did runs with them Mariah belted just as high as them live Mariah and Christina are different vocalist simply cannot compare they are all great in their own way 😩😩😩 just saying and giving facts Mariah has belted just as much as they have they have different voices period
God issa woman Mariah highest live is a A5 and she can probably go higher and it doesn’t matter because Mariah still influenced Ariana and all these other artist at the end of the day like I said they can all hit the same high notes period so idc
@@eggoturtle8574 Mariah can hit her highest mix up to G5 in Daydream Era, All above were playback. A5 in The One 2003 live is obviously lipped but the whistles were very well executed. AND WHISTLE CAN'T BE BELTED!
I feel like high notes are Ari's specialty, the only thing she's exceptional at. She has such ease. She's naturally gifted. Aguilera has a better tone, though, imo
Christina since Young has a full mature soulful voice or unique tone is Out of this world are vocal ability has inspired other young artist like Ariana but none the less let’s be grateful that we have singers who can actually sing not just pop stars or a good in the studio these girls can actually sing their faces off, let’s appreciate the vocal abilities that these two have
Tell me how??? I actually love your channel and your contents but in this video Ari literally beats the hell out of Xtina in every second note when it comes to belting (Xtina has so chance above Eb5 note). Plss judge by their techniques 😭 I don't like when someone says that singer is better just bc that she/he is a legend.
@@mooblink4ever899 it’s their opinion not because Xtina is a legend. I prefer Xtina’s voice tho I know Ari has a way easier time with high notes. I love both of them but I prefer Xtina’s edgier sound.
🔥CHRISTINA AGUILERA🔥 and her E5 from candyman? E5 and Eb5 from Its a mans world? D5 from lady MARMALADE? c5 from ain't No Other Man? F5 from Understand? E5 from Not Myself Tonigh? this is her vocals more powerfull! why are these not there? these are epic!
Both are two of my favourite singers EVER. I'd say Christina has a better agility, better low notes and probably a better falsetto, but Ariana has overall a better control of her voice especially if we talk about belting. Ariana is also better at whistle notes. Ariana has a better technique, so I think she won this "battle", but I really love both💕
Michelle Jarone yeah I agree that breathin was the better pick between it and be my baby because I think a lot of people prefer it and also because since Christina hasn’t done a live bb5, be my baby (specifically sunrise/las Vegas) is out of her league
Well, I'm not going to attack you. Anyone I reply to I'm just trying to combat incorrect information. The entire concept of support as the vocal community deems it, is really just code for a healthy vocal. If you are singing a note at all you are using breath support and an engaged diaphragm. The next step is to allow the flow of air to be uninhibited by issues such as tongue and jaw tension, overly connected vocal cords (chesty) and improper larynx placement. Here Ariana still has tongue tension and a raised larynx. However she is mixing well, and while as far as I have heard she has never carried healthy technique up to E5, her approach to E5's and other upper belts isn't particularly damaging to her voice either as it is light and easy.
i agree, if we were to look at vocals as a whole, including runs, musicality, lower range, falsetto, dynamics and emotive capabilities it would be no contest.
No ariana is better for me if we are talking about falsetto, musicality, creativity, belts, whistles, support, way more relaxed and healthier than her! A better technique and that's a fact!
So How does she win??? Lol Ari literally beats the hell out of Xtina when it comes to belting and in this video Ari destroyed Xtina in every second note ... So you just say that someone is better just bc they're legends? 🙂 pls judge by their techniques. But we know that Xtina would destroy Ari too if we talk about "falsetto" or "low note" you should sit on the fence.
B4: Ariana B4: Christina C5: Ariana C5: Christina C#5: Christina C#5: Christina D5: Christina D5: Ariana Eb5: Christina Eb5: Tie E5: Christina E5: Tie F5: Christina F5: Christina F#5: Tie G5: Christina G#5: Ariana A5: Ariana btw Christina has an A5 Bb5: Ariana automatically B5: Ariana automatically
Ariana of course wins technically, BUT not especially in 2019. Currently Ariana's technical peak was in her early teens. She supported one D5 this year yes, but her consistency still only lies at B4.
@@michellejarone2007 that's actually misinformed. Every night for about the past 20 shows of her tour has supported C5 ( supporting about 55%-60% of C5s) and C#5, she's supported the Fake smile D5 about 4 times now has one supported phrased Eb5 in god is a woman, 2 partially supported E5s in sweetener and has kept a neutral larynx up to F#5 about 3 times now. She's nowhwere near exceptional technique and she's not better than she was in her teens but in 2019 she has made notable improvements and is better than she's been since she became mainstream update yourself
@@adebayoadesupo3931 it's not misinformed. You guys spread this misinformation and then the entire Ariana stan base believes it and it just isn't true. learn to tell the difference between volume/reverb and support
@@abdohgamer2235 Ariana is barely technically superior tho. Christina in her career has supported up to C#5, and Ariana eb5. But for MOST of Ari's career her support has been limited to A4. It's rare even now for her to get to B4, despite having some good D5's. The point is comparing at their VERY BEST you are correct, Ari could be superior. But in the grand scheme Ari shares a lot of the technical shortcomings that Christina has (overbearing tension, high larynx).
You choose ariana's WORST clips Like the G#5 one and the Bb5 one You could've used the focus in amas for G#5 And for Bb5 you could've used a be my baby clip
1) they aren't her worst clips, they just aren't the clips you preferred. 2) those clips get passed around like a sex toy in a frat house. I'm tired of hearing them so I chose unique clips. 3) If you love hearing the same 5 clips in every Ariana video I'm sure there are many channels that can oblige. Dismissed
Christina Aguilera actually has one live A5 belt! Most of Christina's belts from B4 to Eb5 are free. The E5s, F5s, and up are mostly questionable aside from the one F#5 which she is singing "Makes Me Wanna Pray" (although it sounds kind of weird, audio maybe?). Not bad at all though. Most of Ariana's belting range is free. They are both Amazing vocalists! The degradation of either is really not even relevant tbh. #QUEENS!!!
This is my opinion: B4: Ari (Ari's has a bit of resonance) B4: Xtina C5: Ari (the resonance 😍; what's surprising is that Ari was only 14 in this clip) C5: Ari (Colleen looks so annoyed lol 😂) C#5: Xtina C#5: Ari D5: Ari D5: Ari Eb5: Ari Eb5: Ari E5: Ari E5: Ari F5: Ari F5: Ari F#5: Ari G5: Ari G#5: Ari Xtina - 2 Ari - 15 Ari wins!
Base & vocal power in her voice - Christina Vocal flexibility - Christina Vocal technique - Christina Vocal control - Christina Range - Christina Originality & stamping her own style - Christina
Half of these aren't even Christina's best clips though. 🤔 In mans world Christina hit 13 e flat 5s back to back during the liberation tour and lady marmalade and dirrty have her best D5s as well but they weren't used in the video.
no. Just because she hit a lot of eb5's doesnt mean they were well sung. This is about her best TECHNICAL notes. Dirrty D5's are iconic but they are intentionally pushed and strained.
Also thank you to everyone for commenting! If i reply to your comment I promise it's not hostility, I just want to open up further discussion! Please refrain from commenting in a rude way in reference to either singer, or another comment.
@@michellejarone2007 the E5 in just a little bit of your heart was partially supported and had almost 0 tension... so we can say she is able to support up to E5
@@KevinAlmeida it had tension. Actually a fair amount. There is no such thing as partial support. Support indicates an engaged diaphragm, open throat, free of unnecessary tension, a neutral larynx and so on. Support really just means healthy, proper singing. If it's not healthy I don't consider it supported. The note was great, she was more open then normal, had good placement and definitely kept her larynx neutral, but her tongue was tense as it tends to be.
B4: Ariana Grande C5: Ariana Grande C#5: Tie D5: Tie Eb5: Ariana Grande E5: Christina Aguilera F5: Tie F#5: Ariana Grande G5: Ariana Grande G#5: Tie (not good ones) A5: Ariana Grande Bb5: Ariana Grande B5: Ariana Grande (not a good one)
This is like comparing a Phoenix to a humming bird. Both great in their own way but sort of silly. Xtina has one of the most amazing voices of all time Where Ariana sings pretty and is trendy for today’s generation. No competition Xtina wins everything
Omar Santiago are you serious? Most of Christina’s notes sound so throaty and strained. Arianas are much more supported, not strained and some are even resonant
@@horizon6539 Ari only has resonance on her notes from when she was on Broadway. Christina has resonance on none of her notes. Neither should be credited with resonant singing tbf
Oh wow you are ALL so boring saying "ariana has a better technique" is that really all that matters? First of all you dont even know that, and then xtinas tone is so much beautiful and versatil, she has WAY more agility, she has so many different colors and textures in her voice (ariana dont) she is so much powerful, her range is biger.. She is just better. Xtina.
@@samueleemiliani184 Ariana's live range really isnt that much larger than Christina's. Christina has a live range of Bb2-A6. That's a pretty big range. Studio range if Bb2-C#7 which means over 4 octaves. Ariana also has about 4 octaves. Not a huge difference
Michelle Jarone i personally count only the live range.What makes christina’s range that “big” is her falsetto but if we look at the belting range Ariana has easy till Bb5 while Christina struggles to hit an E5 and she usually avoid most of her high notes. Wich is okay to me.
I DON'T THINK CHRISTINA IS A MEZZO-SOPRANO AT ALL. COMPARED TO OTHER MEZZO'S LIKE BRANDY, BEYONCE, P!NK, AND LADY GAGA CHRISTINA'S LOW NOTES SOMETIMES SOUND'S UNNATURAL.
Act tell a difference of every grand a and Christina Aguilera singing Christina Aguilera steps singing it jazz singing With airy grand a hurry music is more hip hop Their style is different
B4 - tie for diff reasons, xtinas is massive in sound, ari's has that supported broadway tone. both good C5 - leaning towards ari for the ease C5 - tie C5 - xtina, ari's was good too but sounded muffled couldve been just the video C#5 - xtina C#5 tie D5 - ari D5 - ari Eb5 - ari because its beautifully sustained though xtinas was good Eb5 - ari again because sustained E5 - ari for ease E5 - ari again F5 - ari F5 - tie F#5 - ari G5 - ari A5-B5 - ari by default. it seems the real result here is ariana has a higher placement she literally floats Eb5-Bb5. Xtina begins to struggle by Eb5 to sustain notes. Xtina has a wider more forward sounds D5 and below though.
I really dislike nearly all the notes Christina sang in these clips. They all sound so throaty and so strained, especially compared to Ariana who has no strain and most of her notes are supported in these clips. (I mean B4-Eb5) Idk my opinion though.
Michelle Jarone yeah her none of her E5s in these clips are supported I was speaking about a different E5 from the SWT which is my mistake and I apologise for that, and a lot of her B4s on the SWT are resonant, for example take Tattooed heart on the SWT (which you included here). Thank you so much for replying though! I don’t really know anything about Christina’s support etc so it’s interesting to learn
@@horizon6539 Christina doesn't have consistent support in any area of her belting range, but most people are surprised when they hear about her technical abilities in almost every other aspect of her singing.
@@mooblink4ever899 Lol i dont need that "better and better". Because for now, she can't beat Christina's melismas. And just so you know, he already became one of the biggest influence in music industry since a decade loongggg before arina grande exist.. :)
@@sigarantang WTF? So you just don't want to accept that she's able to do riffs and runs??? And I swear to God that I didn't say that she's better than Xtina. (I mean she is now better than the past I didn't even compare her to Xtina bc Xtina is always better at doing that and I think everyone knows that but your comment????)
@@sigarantang and you really think that being a legend is incomparable???? No 😂 Ari beats the hell out of Xtina in terms of techniques too and in this video Ari literally beats the hell out of Xtina in every second note😌 Xtina is one of the worst technical singer ever. Her notes are pushed and strained 🙈 sorry at the beginning I think I was so nice but you attacked me first with your shytty comment. 👑🖐️
@@mooblink4ever899 Yesss according to who? accroding to YOU hon 😂 Btw, how old are you? if i'm talking with millennial, or gen z or even younger than that, i can't. Because we're not relate 😂
Comparing any two vocal artist against each other will not change anyone's minds about whom sings better or sounds better if they already have a favorite music artist! These videos are pointless! Someone is bored and makes such videos like these. The fans go at it back and forth. Too funny!
Jajajjjaaj así es ...la gente dice que Christina Aguilera tiene mala técnica, pero no es así, si tuviera mala técnica a 20 años de cantar sus estaría casi muda cómo Mariah Carey....Ariana es la que tiene mala técnica pues ya estuvo operada de sus cuerda vocales por ello
Jajajjajaj comparar a xtina con Esa Ariana es absurdo xtina tiene Mas trayectoria y Mas edad una voz Mas madura y aunque pueda lograr unas increibles notas a Pesar de que segun todos Ella' no tiene technical Buena es algo con Mas razon de admirar asi que cuando ariana tenga la trayectoria y que verdadermente salga de lo basics que hace ahi podra verdadermente ser tomada como real artists hasta ahora solo canta Mas no interpreta
If you had done this like the video of Christina being compared to Beyonce & Mariah at their 20 year marks Christina gets it. The clips you picked for her sucked and there are several from 2018 - 2019 that are better just like in the video I referenced.
The clips i picked are the best representation of her most technically proficient belting. I'm interested to see what you consider better? Besides, there ARE clips from 2019 in this video, and if I were to restrict myself to only using clips from the last two years the battle would only be able to go to Eb5. Also no, Beyonce and Mariah twenty years into their careers were much better than Christina currently is.
Ariana might be able to belt an A5, but Christina can hit the brown note with SUPPORTED technique. Ariana has brought entire stadiums to tears. But has she ever made entire stadiums shit themselves? I think not.
Christina vocal range :G2-G#5-G6-Eb7 Ariana Grande:B2-B5-F#6-Bb7 Supported range: Ariana :F#3-Eb5 e molto raramente E5 Christna:F3-A4 Easy:Ariana Technique :Ariana Tone:Tie Low:tie Mid belt:Christina High belt:Ariana Falsetto:Ariana Whistle :Ariana Il falsetto di Ariana è migliore e non c'è da discutere. È più lineare, cristallino, pulito e corposo
Im SO proud of myself for staning TALENT and not "" "" technique "" ""... I prefer the beast Christina Aguilera. Im so sorry ariana but you have NOTHING on xtina, literally nothing
Ariana is not "technique", what happens is that xtina has a so bad technique that u consider that ariana is "technical singer" lol. I love xtina's voice, i think she is an incredible singer but ariana is ALSO talent
For the record, Christina supported a C#5 in this video, and Ari supported an Eb5. There was NO support for either above that note, so please do not spread misinformation because you watched an uneducated stan vocal channel and instantly pledged your allegiance to believing whatever they say. My unbiased opinion would be that Ari wins, but not by much. Really just because she has a wider more controlled belting range. They actually share a lot of the same falters (tongue tension, high larynx). Ari tips it for me due to her consistent lack of throaty placement. Not to say she never gets throaty, but it's not often enough to warrant considering that a flaw in her singing.
Michelle Jarone actually highest Xtina supported note is A4, maybe Bb4 but nothing higher than that
What about Ariana’s supported E5
Ariana has a lot more videos that are better than these from the SWT.
jomar vazquez she hasn’t supported any E5 because of her tensions
L.A. A.C ua-cam.com/video/TxtuBEGmJF0/v-deo.html
Ari's belt are way more clearer but Xtina has power
But xtina never had any intentions for her belts to be clear she wants it dirrty
Actually no….
Xtina’s UNDAMAGED voice is actually higher than Ari’s by one level which is why Xtina can sing higher head voice notes but due to damage that Ari doesn’t have, this is why Ari can belt higher but can’t sing vocal runs on the same level as Xtina.
In terms of power, Ari will also reign supreme because of the fact her vocal cords are physically larger than Xtina’s.
@@xmantrans4846 ik but I'm just saying
@@parfumextraitfan7453 larger than Christina? The higher the voice, the smaller the vocal folds are. You need to study more anatomy.
@@parfumextraitfan7453 and not, Xtina doesn't have the Belt extension better than Ari these days, Ari arrives at Bb5 while Xtina arrives at E5 these days. In terms of head voice, Ari's range is as good as Christina's. Agility is training and creativity, and in this regard Xtina is the best because she takes more risks on melismas than Ari, which is why many of Ari's melismas sound similar. Agility has nothing to do with Ariana's vocal cords being longer than Xtina's. Xtina's voice is much heavier than Ariana's.
Love Ari’s voice but Xtina got more power so Xtina 🥰🥰🥰🥰
Low : Xtina
Mid Belt : Xtina
Upper Belt : Ari
Falsetto : Xtina
Head Voice : Ari
Whistle : Ari
Agility : Xtina
Power : Xtina
Growl : Xtina
Stable : Xtina
Tone : Xtina
Christina is way better, I agree Ariana has her style and everything, but let's be honest, there is not better voice in this planet than Xtina's!
Nop😂
Melissa Maria Gomez Quesada for u!
I think her voice is very unpleasant *christinas*
Ariana IS QQUUUEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNN
One of the voices that are insanely rare
Runs and agility= Christina
Technique = Ariana
Stage presence= christina
High notes= Ariana
Versatility and voice richness= christina
For me both are great singers but I choose Christina. She has a natural talent and unic voice. Ariana has a beautiful and angelical voice.
@Hei Dinglepop ikr! Her riffs and runs in *save your tears* are amazing 😭
i love both christina’s voice is forever having me shook . especially when she was vocally her best .. buuuuttt ariana has a SUPERIOR technique and i feel like is more pleasant to listen to with a better tone and her belts are just soooo amazing
3:30 i never seen this from xtina !!!!!😱😱😱😱😱💕💕💕💕
its rare unfortunately
@@michellejarone2007 so rare that you picked it from my video omg cute 😂😂😂
Christina is a legend.😊
👑CHRISTINA AGUILERA!👑🔥🔥🔥🔥❤️
Their voices are completely different. Aguilera is a mezzo soprano while Grande is a soprano with a very high natural placement. Not a fair comparison.
actually not. if you compare ariana with others mezzo like beyoncé, pink or jojo she would lose, and you know that, because they have better techniques
@@thunderstorm__8147 Christina is a mezzo. A soprano does not possess the depth in their lower range that Christina has. Christina has also had substantial volume on belts as low as F4, which sopranos most certainly do not possess. Christina is an untrained mezzo.
There is no such thing as an unfair comparison. I don't like this misconception. Beyonce is a mezzo that would destroy Ariana. Whereas Bebe Rexha and Camilla Cabelo are two sopranos with just as limited support and ability in their belting as Christina. it's about technique. Not to say Ariana possesses a great technique either. That's why I chose her to compare, because I knew the conversation could evolve beyond just technical aspects since both singers falter greatly in that area.
@@thunderstorm__8147 she doesn't... she has a rich lower register. please do your research before making an analysis of her vocals. She has supported down to D3, and can sing down to B2 live. And yes, she has MANY more examples of her singing low notes with a neutral larynx over a lowered. She does not use a lowered larynx in her midrange, she uses tongue tension and nasality. However, show me a clip of Demi, or Ariana, or any other soprano being able to belt an F4 with significant impact. It's just not possible when ur range doesn't allow ur voice to achieve it.
@@thunderstorm__8147 She supported two E3's in 10 seconds on her Masterclass alone, let alone the many she has supported live. She has at least 8 supported Eb3's i know of, two D3's she did on The Voice.
I will go for xtina,both are vocal beast,ari can belt very high,but tone, power,versatility,low notes,midbelts,falsetto,runs and emotions,xtina wins
2:10 wtf I've seen this fom herr😍😍😍😍
ARIANA but i looove christina
Both daughters of Mariah
God issa woman Mariah has belted whistles and did runs with them Mariah belted just as high as them live Mariah and Christina are different vocalist simply cannot compare they are all great in their own way 😩😩😩 just saying and giving facts Mariah has belted just as much as they have they have different voices period
God issa woman Mariah highest live is a A5 and she can probably go higher and it doesn’t matter because Mariah still influenced Ariana and all these other artist at the end of the day like I said they can all hit the same high notes period so idc
@@eggoturtle8574 Mariah can hit her highest mix up to G5 in Daydream Era, All above were playback. A5 in The One 2003 live is obviously lipped but the whistles were very well executed. AND WHISTLE CAN'T BE BELTED!
Blagden Butera I said what I said 😐😐
@@eggoturtle8574So I'm talking with the old bricks? Umm, okay, being delusional is the signature of Mariah's fans. "i SAid wHaT i sAiD".
I feel like high notes are Ari's specialty, the only thing she's exceptional at. She has such ease. She's naturally gifted. Aguilera has a better tone, though, imo
Prefer Xtina, soul rawness and depth are more important.
Shes Icon , Ariana's one fave artists too.
im a huge fan of both. ariana's technical is way better but Xtina has a lot of resonance.
She has no resonance because she can't event supports all of notes here :(
Ariana Grande doesn't use belt vocal technique. She uses MIX vocal technique. So in this video Ariana doesn't have belt notes at all.
Christina since Young has a full mature soulful voice or unique tone is Out of this world are vocal ability has inspired other young artist like Ariana but none the less let’s be grateful that we have singers who can actually sing not just pop stars or a good in the studio these girls can actually sing their faces off, let’s appreciate the vocal abilities that these two have
I'd say Ariana range and Christina agility they both win
OMG I CAN'T CHOICE ONE BECAUSE THEY ARE MY TWO IDOL AND THEY ARE SO AMAZING😪🖤
Definitely Christina!! Christina’s voice is so unique and has a lot of emotion. Periodt
Xtina !
Tell me how??? I actually love your channel and your contents but in this video Ari literally beats the hell out of Xtina in every second note when it comes to belting (Xtina has so chance above Eb5 note). Plss judge by their techniques 😭 I don't like when someone says that singer is better just bc that she/he is a legend.
@@mooblink4ever899 it’s their opinion not because Xtina is a legend. I prefer Xtina’s voice tho I know Ari has a way easier time with high notes. I love both of them but I prefer Xtina’s edgier sound.
🔥CHRISTINA AGUILERA🔥
and her E5 from candyman? E5 and Eb5 from Its a mans world? D5 from lady MARMALADE? c5 from ain't No Other Man? F5 from Understand? E5 from Not Myself Tonigh? this is her vocals more powerfull! why are these not there? these are epic!
Both are two of my favourite singers EVER. I'd say Christina has a better agility, better low notes and probably a better falsetto, but Ariana has overall a better control of her voice especially if we talk about belting. Ariana is also better at whistle notes. Ariana has a better technique, so I think she won this "battle", but I really love both💕
u did Ari dirty with the Bb5 clip lmao
? how so? The arianators literally love those Bb5's
Michelle Jarone yes i think with all of the video and your comment i think you jate ariana,thats nit fair lol
Michelle Jarone yeah I agree that breathin was the better pick between it and be my baby because I think a lot of people prefer it and also because since Christina hasn’t done a live bb5, be my baby (specifically sunrise/las Vegas) is out of her league
True
I definitely prefer christina but I enjoy both
4:08 It was supported before the vibrato if I'm not wrong..pls don't attack me
Well, I'm not going to attack you. Anyone I reply to I'm just trying to combat incorrect information. The entire concept of support as the vocal community deems it, is really just code for a healthy vocal. If you are singing a note at all you are using breath support and an engaged diaphragm. The next step is to allow the flow of air to be uninhibited by issues such as tongue and jaw tension, overly connected vocal cords (chesty) and improper larynx placement. Here Ariana still has tongue tension and a raised larynx. However she is mixing well, and while as far as I have heard she has never carried healthy technique up to E5, her approach to E5's and other upper belts isn't particularly damaging to her voice either as it is light and easy.
Vocal emotion Vs. Vocal Trained
Emotion definitely does it for me #xtina #wins
I prefer xtina
Even with Christina signing lower than Ariana...she still out sings her...Ariana is good but xtina is a vocal beast with unpredictable runs
i agree, if we were to look at vocals as a whole, including runs, musicality, lower range, falsetto, dynamics and emotive capabilities it would be no contest.
No ariana is better for me if we are talking about falsetto, musicality, creativity, belts, whistles, support, way more relaxed and healthier than her! A better technique and that's a fact!
@@joseluismedina743 if you say so sis! 🤷🙄
arlo gmez ariana is a vocal beast too 💀
So How does she win??? Lol Ari literally beats the hell out of Xtina when it comes to belting and in this video Ari destroyed Xtina in every second note ... So you just say that someone is better just bc they're legends? 🙂 pls judge by their techniques. But we know that Xtina would destroy Ari too if we talk about "falsetto" or "low note" you should sit on the fence.
I've been to both of their concerts I think they're way too different to compare
B4: Ariana
B4: Christina
C5: Ariana
C5: Christina
C#5: Christina
C#5: Christina
D5: Christina
D5: Ariana
Eb5: Christina
Eb5: Tie
E5: Christina
E5: Tie
F5: Christina
F5: Christina
F#5: Tie
G5: Christina
G#5: Ariana
A5: Ariana btw Christina has an A5
Bb5: Ariana automatically
B5: Ariana automatically
Christina has one A5. But she peaks at it in Lady Marmalade, so it’s not a clear belt. But she touches it
Ariana , better and healthier technique!
techniqually, ariana wins. she has the better technique ESPECIALLY in 2019.
Ariana of course wins technically, BUT not especially in 2019. Currently Ariana's technical peak was in her early teens. She supported one D5 this year yes, but her consistency still only lies at B4.
@@michellejarone2007 that's actually misinformed. Every night for about the past 20 shows of her tour has supported C5 ( supporting about 55%-60% of C5s) and C#5, she's supported the Fake smile D5 about 4 times now has one supported phrased Eb5 in god is a woman, 2 partially supported E5s in sweetener and has kept a neutral larynx up to F#5 about 3 times now. She's nowhwere near exceptional technique and she's not better than she was in her teens but in 2019 she has made notable improvements and is better than she's been since she became mainstream update yourself
@@adebayoadesupo3931 it's not misinformed. You guys spread this misinformation and then the entire Ariana stan base believes it and it just isn't true. learn to tell the difference between volume/reverb and support
Michelle Jarone she has consistent support of C#5 and D5’s. She supported a couple of E5s
@@jomarvazquez2815 No she does not. She barely has consistent support of B4's. Please refrain from spreading clearly false claims.
I prefer xtina for her power and tone. Ariana is too light for my liking
gotta be xtina
B4 - Christina
C5 - Ariana
C#5 - Christina
D5 - Ariana
Eb5 - Ariana
E5 - Ariana
F5 - None
F#5 - Ariana
G5 - None
Anyways, Christina wins
MaryahWatkinsArchives. No way
Srry babe but arianas second B4 is resonant I dont mean to be ride but she is technically superior than miss grande even though I like Christina more
christina wins lmao, that's a joke
@@aritourvocals49 I agree with you you might prefer Christina but telling us she is technically better is the epitome of bias
@@abdohgamer2235 Ariana is barely technically superior tho. Christina in her career has supported up to C#5, and Ariana eb5. But for MOST of Ari's career her support has been limited to A4. It's rare even now for her to get to B4, despite having some good D5's. The point is comparing at their VERY BEST you are correct, Ari could be superior. But in the grand scheme Ari shares a lot of the technical shortcomings that Christina has (overbearing tension, high larynx).
Ariana is just better with all the note here 🥺😭😂
Las dos, muy difícil decision. Pero me quedo por xtina.
Ari 😍
ariana, she has better technique
Ariana literally just hits notes, there is next to no emotion in her voice.
You choose ariana's WORST clips
Like the G#5 one and the Bb5 one
You could've used the focus in amas for G#5
And for Bb5 you could've used a be my baby clip
1) they aren't her worst clips, they just aren't the clips you preferred.
2) those clips get passed around like a sex toy in a frat house. I'm tired of hearing them so I chose unique clips.
3) If you love hearing the same 5 clips in every Ariana video I'm sure there are many channels that can oblige.
Dismissed
@@michellejarone2007 you’re vulgar. You thought u ate that
Christina Aguilera actually has one live A5 belt!
Most of Christina's belts from B4 to Eb5 are free. The E5s, F5s, and up are mostly questionable aside from the one F#5 which she is singing "Makes Me Wanna Pray" (although it sounds kind of weird, audio maybe?). Not bad at all though.
Most of Ariana's belting range is free. They are both Amazing vocalists! The degradation of either is really not even relevant tbh.
#QUEENS!!!
This is my opinion:
B4: Ari (Ari's has a bit of resonance)
B4: Xtina
C5: Ari (the resonance 😍; what's surprising is that Ari was only 14 in this clip)
C5: Ari (Colleen looks so annoyed lol 😂)
C#5: Xtina
C#5: Ari
D5: Ari
D5: Ari
Eb5: Ari
Eb5: Ari
E5: Ari
E5: Ari
F5: Ari
F5: Ari
F#5: Ari
G5: Ari
G#5: Ari
Xtina - 2
Ari - 15
Ari wins!
Base & vocal power in her voice - Christina
Vocal flexibility - Christina
Vocal technique - Christina
Vocal control - Christina
Range - Christina
Originality & stamping her own style - Christina
Let’s not get delusional now. Ariana got technique and flexibility in the bag.
Half of these aren't even Christina's best clips though. 🤔 In mans world Christina hit 13 e flat 5s back to back during the liberation tour and lady marmalade and dirrty have her best D5s as well but they weren't used in the video.
no. Just because she hit a lot of eb5's doesnt mean they were well sung. This is about her best TECHNICAL notes. Dirrty D5's are iconic but they are intentionally pushed and strained.
Ariana can sustain her belts with vibrato. Christina's tone & grit gets me though.
Also thank you to everyone for commenting! If i reply to your comment I promise it's not hostility, I just want to open up further discussion! Please refrain from commenting in a rude way in reference to either singer, or another comment.
Ariana's tone is just prettier... and MUCH LESS strained, aaand she supported up to E5 in this video :')
her E5 was not supported. But i agree, she is less strained
@@michellejarone2007 the E5 in just a little bit of your heart was partially supported and had almost 0 tension... so we can say she is able to support up to E5
@@KevinAlmeida it had tension. Actually a fair amount. There is no such thing as partial support. Support indicates an engaged diaphragm, open throat, free of unnecessary tension, a neutral larynx and so on. Support really just means healthy, proper singing. If it's not healthy I don't consider it supported. The note was great, she was more open then normal, had good placement and definitely kept her larynx neutral, but her tongue was tense as it tends to be.
Just a fan actually she had fully supported E5 in Paris
Ariana Grande the singer of our generation
B4: Ariana Grande
C5: Ariana Grande
C#5: Tie
D5: Tie
Eb5: Ariana Grande
E5: Christina Aguilera
F5: Tie
F#5: Ariana Grande
G5: Ariana Grande
G#5: Tie (not good ones)
A5: Ariana Grande
Bb5: Ariana Grande
B5: Ariana Grande (not a good one)
what's the first christina song name?
Lift Me Up
@@michellejarone2007 oh ok thanks
Ariii
Wow I never thought I would make it to an Eb5 but I did now I can sit at the cool kids table aka with Ari sorry xtina
Bueno mil veces Cristina Aguilera. Esa chica Ariana no le transmite nada al cantar
Ariana grande of course !!!!
1. Christina Aguilera, (B4, C5, C#5, D5, Eb5, E5, F5!!!!, F#5)
2. Ariana Grande (A5, Bb5, B5!!!)
(G5, G#5 Both)
Sr but for me, ariana win
Ariana Grande
Christina voice literally so disturb my ears
Andre Teniwut20 then don’t listen to her
This is like comparing a Phoenix to a humming bird.
Both great in their own way but sort of silly.
Xtina has one of the most amazing voices of all time
Where Ariana sings pretty and is trendy for today’s generation.
No competition Xtina wins everything
Omar Santiago are you serious? Most of Christina’s notes sound so throaty and strained. Arianas are much more supported, not strained and some are even resonant
@@horizon6539 Ari only has resonance on her notes from when she was on Broadway. Christina has resonance on none of her notes. Neither should be credited with resonant singing tbf
@@michellejarone2007 Her b4 was resonant (tattoed heart)
AG_ Slays yep
@@grandevxcals no it wasn't
Oh wow you are ALL so boring saying "ariana has a better technique" is that really all that matters? First of all you dont even know that, and then xtinas tone is so much beautiful and versatil, she has WAY more agility, she has so many different colors and textures in her voice (ariana dont) she is so much powerful, her range is biger.. She is just better. Xtina.
Baby Jane I stan both but Ariana’s range is way bigger than Christina’s.
@@samueleemiliani184 Ariana's live range really isnt that much larger than Christina's. Christina has a live range of Bb2-A6. That's a pretty big range. Studio range if Bb2-C#7 which means over 4 octaves. Ariana also has about 4 octaves. Not a huge difference
Michelle Jarone i personally count only the live range.What makes christina’s range that “big” is her falsetto but if we look at the belting range Ariana has easy till Bb5 while Christina struggles to hit an E5 and she usually avoid most of her high notes. Wich is okay to me.
Also Christina never dimostrated that she can do whistle tones so the studio range doesn’t count at all
AND WHO CARES ABOUT RANGE?
I DON'T THINK CHRISTINA IS A MEZZO-SOPRANO AT ALL. COMPARED TO OTHER MEZZO'S LIKE BRANDY, BEYONCE, P!NK, AND LADY GAGA CHRISTINA'S LOW NOTES SOMETIMES SOUND'S UNNATURAL.
Its cause she changes her tone but her low notes are very easy for her
Act tell a difference of every grand a and Christina Aguilera singing Christina Aguilera steps singing it jazz singing With airy grand a hurry music is more hip hop Their style is different
Christina has a richer stronger voice.. Arianas thin and high
B4 - tie for diff reasons, xtinas is massive in sound, ari's has that supported broadway tone. both good
C5 - leaning towards ari for the ease
C5 - tie
C5 - xtina, ari's was good too but sounded muffled couldve been just the video
C#5 - xtina
C#5 tie
D5 - ari
D5 - ari
Eb5 - ari because its beautifully sustained though xtinas was good
Eb5 - ari again because sustained
E5 - ari for ease
E5 - ari again
F5 - ari
F5 - tie
F#5 - ari
G5 - ari
A5-B5 - ari by default.
it seems the real result here is ariana has a higher placement she literally floats Eb5-Bb5. Xtina begins to struggle by Eb5 to sustain notes. Xtina has a wider more forward sounds D5 and below though.
Xita
Xtina always has a suffering face... Ariana has ease 🤭❤️❤️❤️
Christina sings with feelings she's a soulful singer.
I really dislike nearly all the notes Christina sang in these clips. They all sound so throaty and so strained, especially compared to Ariana who has no strain and most of her notes are supported in these clips. (I mean B4-Eb5) Idk my opinion though.
Ariana's E5 isn't supported. Christina actually supported up to the Reflection C#5 here, and Ari supported to Eb5 here.
Michelle Jarone yeah her none of her E5s in these clips are supported I was speaking about a different E5 from the SWT which is my mistake and I apologise for that, and a lot of her B4s on the SWT are resonant, for example take Tattooed heart on the SWT (which you included here). Thank you so much for replying though! I don’t really know anything about Christina’s support etc so it’s interesting to learn
@@horizon6539 Christina doesn't have consistent support in any area of her belting range, but most people are surprised when they hear about her technical abilities in almost every other aspect of her singing.
Michelle Jarone yeah thank u for informing me!
Christina belts a B5 ?????😒😳
no. she belts up to G#5 here. But i wanted to show both singers entire belting range so i showed Ariana go higher
For runs Christina WINS
Ariana, she is true soprano thats why she has higher voice
Sure! But Ari's riffs and runs are amazing tho. She is getting better and better at it.
@@mooblink4ever899 Lol i dont need that "better and better". Because for now, she can't beat Christina's melismas.
And just so you know, he already became one of the biggest influence in music industry since a decade loongggg before arina grande exist.. :)
@@sigarantang WTF? So you just don't want to accept that she's able to do riffs and runs??? And I swear to God that I didn't say that she's better than Xtina. (I mean she is now better than the past I didn't even compare her to Xtina bc Xtina is always better at doing that and I think everyone knows that but your comment????)
@@sigarantang and you really think that being a legend is incomparable???? No 😂 Ari beats the hell out of Xtina in terms of techniques too and in this video Ari literally beats the hell out of Xtina in every second note😌 Xtina is one of the worst technical singer ever. Her notes are pushed and strained 🙈 sorry at the beginning I think I was so nice but you attacked me first with your shytty comment. 👑🖐️
@@mooblink4ever899 Yesss according to who? accroding to YOU hon 😂
Btw, how old are you? if i'm talking with millennial, or gen z or even younger than that, i can't. Because we're not relate 😂
1:53 :o
Comparing any two vocal artist against each other will not change anyone's minds about whom sings better or sounds better if they already have a favorite music artist! These videos are pointless! Someone is bored and makes such videos like these. The fans go at it back and forth. Too funny!
Xtina
Christina hands hown
Con el mini 2:10 le destroza la carrera a Ariana.
Jajajjjaaj así es ...la gente dice que Christina Aguilera tiene mala técnica, pero no es así, si tuviera mala técnica a 20 años de cantar sus estaría casi muda cómo Mariah Carey....Ariana es la que tiene mala técnica pues ya estuvo operada de sus cuerda vocales por ello
@@pedrodejesusrsmirez8745 esa fue Adele
Jajajjajaj comparar a xtina con Esa Ariana es absurdo xtina tiene Mas trayectoria y Mas edad una voz Mas madura y aunque pueda lograr unas increibles notas a Pesar de que segun todos Ella' no tiene technical Buena es algo con Mas razon de admirar asi que cuando ariana tenga la trayectoria y que verdadermente salga de lo basics que hace ahi podra verdadermente ser tomada como real artists hasta ahora solo canta Mas no interpreta
Muy buen video !!! Acá te dejo el A5 de Christina ua-cam.com/video/vOsh6-APHNQ/v-deo.html
If you had done this like the video of Christina being compared to Beyonce & Mariah at their 20 year marks Christina gets it. The clips you picked for her sucked and there are several from 2018 - 2019 that are better just like in the video I referenced.
The clips i picked are the best representation of her most technically proficient belting. I'm interested to see what you consider better? Besides, there ARE clips from 2019 in this video, and if I were to restrict myself to only using clips from the last two years the battle would only be able to go to Eb5. Also no, Beyonce and Mariah twenty years into their careers were much better than Christina currently is.
Ariana grande vocal queen
This is a joke...ariana doesn't even hold a candle to xtina
Ariana might be able to belt an A5, but Christina can hit the brown note with SUPPORTED technique. Ariana has brought entire stadiums to tears. But has she ever made entire stadiums shit themselves? I think not.
Christina ALL the way... Her power.. Ariana's tone is annoying and always the same.. Never change..
Christina vocal range :G2-G#5-G6-Eb7
Ariana Grande:B2-B5-F#6-Bb7
Supported range:
Ariana :F#3-Eb5 e molto raramente E5
Christna:F3-A4
Easy:Ariana
Technique :Ariana
Tone:Tie
Low:tie
Mid belt:Christina
High belt:Ariana
Falsetto:Ariana
Whistle :Ariana
Il falsetto di Ariana è migliore e non c'è da discutere. È più lineare, cristallino, pulito e corposo
Per il timbro, agilità e falsetto tutta la vita Christina, per il resto Ariana è superiore.
@SLAY MOONLIGHT def no,she barely uses it and not the best part of her range
Im SO proud of myself for staning TALENT and not "" "" technique "" ""... I prefer the beast Christina Aguilera. Im so sorry ariana but you have NOTHING on xtina, literally nothing
Baby Jane I mean she has belts E5 and up on Christina bc Christina can’t do those anymore
Ariana is not "technique", what happens is that xtina has a so bad technique that u consider that ariana is "technical singer" lol. I love xtina's voice, i think she is an incredible singer but ariana is ALSO talent
I don't really think that, ariana's technique is so much better than xtina's