When A Big Watch Is Done Perfectly! - The Fortis B-42 Official Cosmonaut Chronograph Watch Review
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- Today I review an extremely cool Swiss made chronograph from the massively underappreciated but hugely important brand Fortis. This B-42 Automatic (Ref. 6381011M) not only is beautifully designed, robust and excellent quality, it also is the official choice of the Russian Federal Space Agency (Roscosmos). In this video I give an introduction to Fortis and it's most famous watch. Hard as nails and proven on many space missions, it is still standard issue for Cosmonauts to this day. Eat your heart out Omega Speedmaster, theres a new beast in town!
For more information and to get your horological questions answered, join our UGWC community on the Facebook group: / 1503241666636531
Instagram: / theurbangentrychannel
TGV's Tumblr: / tgv83
To contact me please email: theurbangentry@gmail.com
I do not use the messaging system on UA-cam, Facebook or Instagram. Thank you
Jesus Christ, with that amazing intro, Tag Heuer should hire TGV because he knows more about advertising than them.
hahah exactly
Jerry Meng EXACTLY!!! KILLER INTRO
His intros make me want the watches that I don't even think look good LOL
Spot on there
LOL " M.I.R. 97 "... just Mir like in the Mir space station ;-D
In TGV's last 2 reviews of Fortis Cosmonaut Chronograph watches, many questions have been raised over how an automatic watch can function in space WITHOUT gravity. The answer to this question is two-fold:
1. Aboard the ISS at an altitude of 200-250 miles, Earth's gravity is roughly 90% of that on the surface. The "weightlessness" that cosmonauts experience is due to "free fall in a vacuum" and NOT a lack of gravity or mass.
2. Automatic watch rotors are actuated by kinetic energy produced by the wearer's motion. While the watch rotor's mass (a property) is constant, the rotor's weight (a force) is generated by the gravitational attraction of the earth. Since gravity increases the weight of a watch's rotor, this requires more energy to move it. As Fortis previously stated, aboard the ISS with a 10% reduction in gravity, automatic watches actually operate more efficiently than on the surface due to this slight reduction in rotor weight.
Hope this helps everyone.
....and don't forget these are easily hand windable due the lack of a screw down crown.
Gravity doesn't matter. There could be a 100% reduction in gravity. The thing that matters for the rotor is the mass of the rotor. The inertia of the rotor turns it when the watch is moved.
Automatic wrist watches have been flown in space since 1965 (Gemini V), automatic chronographs have been flown in space since 1973 (Skylab-4), Fortis since June 1994 (TM-19)
@@artyomsherwin648exactly.
what i love about your channel is that you know quality watches regardless of the brand…
you are right fortis is very unappreciated. they do not get credit where its due this is a very robust and rugged piece of art. i think it could be a very respected vintage piece down the road. keep up the great work TGV.
Best regards
Joseph
Absolutely Joseph,
I could not agree more, spot on.
Thank you my friend.
Best regards,
TGV
The amount preparation and work that you put into every video is incredible. And, your production values are first-rate. Thanks for all your effort.
Thank you so much Joe, very much appreciated,
Best regards,
TGV
Finally a fortis review.. Love this brand!! 😎👍💪
I have the non chronograph Ti version and absolutely love it. The fact that it was a wedding gift from my wife makes it even more special.
WOW, now that is a classy wedding gift! Enjoy it my friend and wear it with pride!
Thank you Luc,
Best regards,
TGV
I have a handwind V-72 powered Fortis Marinemaster from the 70's. It belonged to my father, so Fortis has a special place in my heart. Thanks for giving some attention to this very underrated company!
Great video! Just want to mention that I owned the non-chronograph version of this watch. The only downside to this watch is the screwed lugs. The tiny screws are extremely fragile and are very very expensive to replace and really hard to find! If you break a screw you can't secure the watch to the band. I would say to only buy this watch is you don't plan to remove the bracelet. Other than this issue, this is a great watch and really offers a great bang for your buck! Thanks TGV! I'm a long time fan of yours!
I have heard there are Casio screw bars that will fit the B42 case and they have much more thread to them thus stronger. I am still looking for the correct part number. I broke a screw bar over tightening it on my Fortis and a new bar cost 20.00 USD from Fortis service here in the States! They are keyed which adds to the cost but the Casio bar will work just fine using 2 screwdrivers.
An excellent review,! For some reason Fortis are a very little known brand in the UK despite being a very high quality product with a rich heritage. While even many with zero interest in watches know about the Omega Speedmaster Professional virtually none know about the space heritage of Fortis (or classic Soviet watches like Sturmanskie and Strela). I love the aesthetic of Fortis, they often have an extremely clear, legible, very clean and functional design which prioritises form over image which I like.
Fortis as well as Tutima don't get the recognition they deserve. Thanks for reviewing a great watch!
An absolute pleasure, and I totally agree.
Thank you,
Best regards,
TGV
It may be heavy, but weightless in space! Amazing watch.
Excellent point!!! I think I just did a Homer style "Doh!" ;-)
Thank you sir,
Best regards,
TGV
You're right for the most part, but inertia is still a factor
But what makes me wonder is not the weight but the fact the Russians chose an automatic, wouldn't it be wiser to choose a manual wind (like NASA did) and benefit the lighter weight, thinner case and in most cases, a more robust manual winding mechanism? I know hand movements is going to turn the rotor, again because of its inertia; but I'm afraid that wouldn't be enough without the help of gravity
Anyway, this is only a speculation, I have yet to search how it actually worked and did the astronauts had to use the manual wind mechanism or not
Why the Russians chose Fortis over other watches is because, I believe, of cost factor. Think about their military hardwares. Maybe crude, is definitely cheap yet effective in its purpose. Just like this Fortis watch that is significantly cheaper than the Omega Speedmaster yet you can manually wind it (just like the Omega) in space if you think there's not enough inertia that can spin the rotors.
The Fortis B42 is a beautiful, utilitarian and underrated watch. So glad you finally did a review on it.
White Knight who is underrating it? Must be mental...
From 200m under sea level to 200km above sea level. I just found my doomsday piece. Thanks for the review TGV.
Seems like someone paid BOTS in India to dislike your video, TGV. No matter what they do, they can't keep you from continuing to be the best Horology channel on UA-cam.
awesome review one thing i do respect is your love for watches as a whole not just mechanical but quartz etc keep up the great work
Great review... I have been singing Fortis Watches praises since coming across the brand in 2008. I have 2 models in my collection: B-42 Flieger and the Cosmo 3 GMT. Beautifully made and precise engineering... I love em and the Fortis site does sell refurbished models at bargain prices!!!
I agree, Fortis Watches are outstanding!!
Terrific review, TGV. I am really glad you got around to this wonderful brand. I experienced these superb watches first-hand at the WatchBuys show last year in San Francisco. The build quality and exectution, as you say, are really first-class. *Very* impressive quality, feel, and fit and finish. The fact that you can buy this watch new for $1640 at WatchBuys makes it one of the most insane value propositions for a watch I can think of. And that intro is insane....
In Spain cost 3230euros ( 3500dolars or more....for this price I bought an omega )
Ordered mine today from watch buys, will arrive tomorrow, i cant wait to open the box
I love contrasting orange seconds hands on any watch for some weird reason. Makes me want to buy them all.
Amazing into! That dial has a great combination of being "busy" but perfectly legible.
I'm surprised and happy you were able to get a clean sample from Fortis.
Thanks for taking time to research the brand's heritage and include the history with this overdue review.
What a great introduction to this underrated brand that some viewers may not have heard of or may not have thought much of it based on 2D photo.
Regarding the titanium case, last I saw in the catalog, it wasn't listed. I hope they bring it back as an option for people who like less mass, but maybe there wasn't enough interest from buyers.
As a note on the B42 series, the case is 42mm. The "dive" bezel is 44mm. Info for this watch will usually list the 42mm csse size which may disappoint a buyer who is expecting a 42mm width and is buying online and can't try it on.
There is a similar model, the classic cosmonautis, with a fixed tachymetre bezel that doesn't overhang the 42mm csse. In fact, it slopes into the crystal and may wear smaller than 42. It's a nice option for smaller wrists or those who just prefer a bit smaller piece.
For those unaware, Fortis also does flieger and a couple dressier types.
Tristano, I absolutely cherish these videos! Irrespective of the brand of the watch, the appreciation you bring to the audience is what makes you the most valuable friend to us. Many thanks, cheers!
Thank you so much Ashwin, your comment makes it all worth it!
Best regards,
TGV
Always a treat to see new video by TGV. I have learned so much from you bro.. thank you for helping me become a gentleman.
Best wishes to you and your family. cheers mate
Thank you so much, I find that deeply inspiring.
Best regards,
TGV
A very tastefully done, task-specific timepiece. Thanks for showing it.
This is the nicest utilitarian sport watch I’ve ever seen, details have been thought of thru-in thruout. Why not it was designed to go in the harshest environment: Space. Thanks to introducing us to this brand watch which is sadly unknown in North America. Wish there were more distributors! That intro. was mighty impressive 👌❤️👍, keep on the good work.
John (from Canada)
Great comments and agree 100 percent.
Fortis are incredible watches.
Bill
Atl
Just got one. And this video was partially responsible for it. I love it, definitely the new "crown jewel" of my little collection.
Thanks for the great info!
I just got my hands on the Fortis Pilot Classic Chronograph and I also visited the factory, and I have to say that it is a fantastic watch!
Fantastic, so glad to hear!
Thank you Piero, enjoy your Fortis and wear it with pride.
Best regards,
TGV
It seems that i watch this Intro every day....i think i got addicted to it. So emotional....
THank you for the great review !
The FORTIS Cosmonauts Chrono is on my list for a long time. Now I need this one...
GOOD LORD IM GOING TO BE HOMELESS
Jajajaja 🤣 me TOO !
My goodness. The intros have reached a whole other level. Great tool watch.
Thank you Ricardo, very kind of you to say. A long time no commentary! I hope you are well and had a good birthday.
Best regards,
TGV
I truly can't complain. Life is good. Can't wait to see what you have been cooking in the lab with Giancarlo with the secret project. My test subject services are always available. 👍
That intro could easily be something Fortis would pay big $$$ for as an officiel promo video!
Seriously, the intros alone are worth the trip in and the videos are always top shelf.
Never thought I'd fall in love with a Timex, I guess you have give every brand a chance!
Haha, difficult not to right! Thank you.
Best regards,
TGV
Excellent review 👍.Thank you 🙏. This watch has been on my radar since watching your upload and now I’ve finally purchased one 😀. So excited to see it when it arrives 🤗.
TGV, that Fortis holds the record for the watch with the most time in space.
Dat intro!! 😍
wow I didn't know that you enjoy watches how cool.
Hey! Been watching you since 2010!
Snazzy Labs Didn't think you would slack here, pretty cool.
TGV is the 🐐 at intros. Stay tuned 📺🚀🌌⌚
Great review as always, TGV! Thanks for teaching us about Fortis. Cool story and cool brand! We'll see you on the next one...
Thank you so much guys.
I hope this finds you well.
Best regards,
TGV
I own this watch and love it. One of my favourite characteristics is the antireflective coating. It appears, as if their is no crystal at all, you see the dial without any reflections. Here Fortis is really the leader. I hate to wear an expensive watch and all you see, especially outdoor, is the reflection of your surroundings.
After picking up a bargain, mint, non chronograph version of this, I knew immediately I just had to get the chrono too. Fantastic watches indeed.
TGV, its almost to the point where I feel these companies should hire you for their promos. This is unbelievably outstanding quality.
Thank you so much, very flattered.
Best regards,
TGV
Loved the review of this watch so much I had to add it to the collection. Really dig your videos. I agree wholeheartedly on the pieces that you tend to gravitate towards, with the exception of the smaller sized watches. I’m a large fellow at 6’1” and 260 with an 8” wrist size. I wish I could pull off the smaller pieces probably as much as the smaller guys would like to wear the larger pieces. Keep up the good work, and maybe in the future see some more of the G-Shocks. Love those watches.
I was ready to pull the trigger on a Sinn 103, but then this video came up. Super impressed with all the little details this watch offers. Too bad it's HUGE!! Now I've got a pro/con list to make.
Thank you Zuker, if size is an issue, honestly I would go for the 103.
Best regards,
TGV
The Urban Gentry
Good advice, Sir. I just ordered my Sinn EZM 3 today. Love the Fortis, no doubt, but simply too big and the dial is just too busy. Getting picky in my old age.
Zuker Gill - Fortis ref 401.21.11 and 402.26.11 are 42mm compared with 41mm of the 103. These reference #s have the same dial layout (with sexier hands and lune though) with a smaller tachymetre bezel instead of the 44mm dive bezel, which overhangs the 42mm case.
Been eyeing this watch and was convinced after this video.
It's an amazing piece solidly built and looks good on my wrist too.It's a space watch but you can go diving with it too and all this without a screw down crown which i prefer.
Truly a value for money.
Outstanding review Tristan!! Glad you're giving some love to larger diameter watches for us folks with larger wrists.
Thank you so much, I had you chaps in mind ;-)
Best regards,
TGV
I’m glad it has that space suit extension, going to need that next time I visit the moon!
Solid introduction my friend!! Worthy of an award!!! Not to mention the cool watch!!! 2 Years in & still very much enjoying the urban gentry!!! BMJ ENGLAND
I bought that watch 11 years ago and wore it exclusively for about 6 years (exept for the occasional Seiko Cocktail dress watch). It is, hands down, the most resilient and robust watch in my collection. Except for some tiny scratches in the anti-glare, this beast looks as new! And I’ve got a 19cm wrist, so it fits quite nicely. But you’re right, it is quite top-heavy, at least when worn loosely. But overall, an amazing watch!
Extremely nice watch. Saving for the alarm version of the same watch. Cheers.
What a piece! I think I've found my grail watch.
Never thought I'd see a Fortis on the channel
Fortis really was smart in lending you their watch for review - I can't think of a better presentation that could have been done. I'm not just being overly ingratiating when I say that you did a great job of maintaining the perspective of it's purpose; which was to be extremely tough, legible, logically laid out and easy for pilot (and cosmonauts), to use. Speaking of legible, I just went to the Watchbuys.com website and saw the Fortis Monolith Cosmonautis, which, I think, is the most legible watch I've seen so far, with a rotating bezel . . and it's under $1,000! Very nice video, TGV.
A desirable watch, no question. I happen to enjoy pilot watches, but they're so big on the wrist. For example, so many of the Breitling watches, though they are beautiful to look at and admire, have such wide case diameters that I'm simply unable to wear them given my slim wrist. But that is the nature of this kind of watch. I might be willing to take a chance on the Fortis B-42.
A mans watch. Something about fortis gives that no nonsense look and still keeps it aesthetic.
Spot on!
Thank you Thomas,
Best regards,
TGV
Always impressed by your command of the history TGV. Really makes s difference in my brand selection.
Thank you so much John, I am flattered.
I just like to talk about what I love, it's really that simply.
Best regards,
TGV
Nice intro!!!! that Fortis is quite a piece, beautiful! i had the sinn 104 as my next objective but this one might make me change my mind. excellent content as usual nice one Tristano!
Thank you Juan, I feel Sinn and Fortis share a lot in common, either way you decide, its win win ;-)
Happy hunting,
Best regards,
TGV
The Urban Gentry dear TGV what would be your strap of choice to pair with this one?
Juan Fernando Pérez Pasquale did you forget who you’re asking? A nato of course lol. Btw I’m currently considering the same 2 watches: Sinn 104 or this... what did you decide? Cheers
B42 now definitely on the must have list... great video!
Oh what a beautiful piece
I have two B-42’s and you are so right about Forts being underrated!! Great tool watch:)
Just the best the b 42
Amazing watch. As a one watch guy this will be my next watch.
Watch brands need to look at your intro's! Another classic!
Solid review on a gorgeous watch. Thanks for introducing this one to me.
Always a pleasure,
Thank you,
Best regards,
TGV
Because of your high quality videos, you can actually see the the inconsistent studder of the chrono second hand...a design characteristic of the 7750
That space shot at the end. 👌🏻
If I had to describe this watch with one word... SOLID comes to mind.
Thank you so much for this! Always been curious about this watch! Wonder why it's not more popular, people love space watches but this one feels so forgotten. In fact, I feel Fortis as a whole gets forgotten way too often, despite having such a rich history...
Fantastic work!
Happy Sunday TGV. As a member of the tiny wrist club(I'm a member as well), you might want to check out the Fortis Flieger Professional. Cheers!
Awesome TGV, have the B42 F4940004 version, it definitely is not just a wonderful watch but every aspect of it is overbuilt!
Brilliant intro mate! I’m sold on the Fortis Cosmonaute!
Magnificent review on the Fortis B-42. You covered most of the positives about this watch. I might add that the design of the solid caseback is the one of the best and the most authentic in its class. Could I suggest a comparison video of this B-42 and the Omega Speedmaster "man on the f**king moon". That would be something interesting to watch. Cheers.
Great coverage of the Fortis - definitely a brand that is underrepresented here in the US. On a side note, have you heard of the seller caliberswiss on EBay? If, what are your thoughts? They claim to see new pieces bought from AD with factory warranty at good prices - high ratings on EBay. Thanks for all you do.
Have more exams tomorrow but love this watch so have to watch it now!
Thank you George, more exams hey?! Good luck my friend.
Best regards,
TGV
+The Urban Gentry thank you tgv must say your videos have really got me into watches and I'm thinking about purchasing the timex your were wearing in this video for a first watch.
All the best.
note to self. stop watching TGV videos and make mortgage repayment ... 😂 you are sending me broke or divorce....
LOL!!!!
Thank you LDW, if it helps at all, I am my own worst enemy too ;-)
Best regards,
TGV
The Urban Gentry I keep looking for the unsubscribe button...... can't seem to locate it ...damn
Luck Ding Wong
Me too! Ordered a Sinn today.
Rick Gordon which sinn?
Awesome review! I would be interested to see one of the new Fliegers on the channel.
Great intro and great review as always, TGV! Massive watch but massive personality. I think the dial is very attractive.
Thank you Katrina, so glad you approve.
Best regards,
TGV
Never stop Tristano. Never stop!
Thank you Alexander, I find that extremely motivating, onwards and upwards!
Best regards,
TGV
I like the triangles next to the day/date window, so that you know which way to turn the crown to set the day and date.
Always love the intros TGV and impeccable narration, thank you for such intriguing videos. I'm impressed Fortis stepped up and sent this piece to you for review. They have gained my respect. I myself and most likely The Gentry Membets would love a narration background on your employment. It would fill in some questions lurking out there, please consider the request. Thank you again for what you do.
Thank you BB, very honoured by your words.
Regarding my employment, I did do a video a long time ago called "my real job" etc, I believe a lot of what I said then still applies but you are right, an update is perhaps over due.
Best regards,
TGV
I purchased the the non chronograph version last week. I love it! The case is smaller at 42mm.
So glad to hear, if I didn't have the Sinn 104 I would get one myself, I love the cleaner look of that one.
Enjoy it Jim, VERY glad to hear from somebody enjoying a Fortis.
Thank you Jim,
Best regards,
TGV
Really nice watch!
Best intros in the business. Great vid T quite a jam packed watch right there.
TGV,
I LIVE for your intros. Seriously awesome.
Keep it up,
colorcolour
Thank you CC, very kind of you to say.
Best regards,
TGV
Great video. Intro and content is as always fantastic. Execution in impeccable. I always love to see a notice of an Urban Gentry video. I am starting to think your talent may be wasted on UA-cam. You might need a much larger venue. World class. Cheers.
Thank you so much Steve :D
Deeply honoured by your words. Onwards and upwards!
Best regards,
TGV
The intro could easily be the official Oris ad👌🏻
I've been waiting for you to review a Fortis chrono!
I absolutely love this piece and Fortis is such a wonderful brand! With it's heritage, you'd almost expect to see more of these on the streets (I think I've seen one on the wrist compared to like 100 Speedmasters). TGV, how do you feel it holds up compared to the Speedmaster? Obviously both were designed for similar jobs. Do you think the Fortis might be a better option for some people over the Speedy?
My B42 Marine Master is essentially the same watch. ( I have both) and it is running flawlessly for 2 years now with plenty of wrist time and water time. Couldn't be happier , for the money they are the best value out there for a man's tool watch.
I want one of these watches now. I wish I had the funds for a collection of every watch model that has been in space.
Amazing Intro And that is an OUSTANDING tool watch
Thank you so much :D
Best regards,
TGV
Was ready to order a BREITLING Chrono Colt Quartz and I saw this amazing review. So I order this guy instead of the Colt. Wait for it, I'm in France and it came from an AD in Italy.... can't wait to receive it. Thanks for the great job on this review....
Great vid production and summary of an often overlooked but superb piece. Would have been nice to see some wrist shots on nato and leather straps.
I’ve the slightly older version, model 638.10.141.3. I love it, it’s probably the best watch I’ve ever owned and I’ve had a few.
I really don’t know much about it though as Fortis are a bit mean when it comes to dishing out information. I’ve no idea the year it was released, I think it’s to remain one of life’s mysteries.
Look closely when he shows the back, it actually says 638.10.141.3 I am not sure what number he is quoting when he talks about it verbally? I have one with this same number as well.
New subscriber your channel is crazy cool thanks. So many brands that I didn't know excited hahaha my collection is about to grow.
That makes it all worth it to hear! Welcome to the best hobby a person can have, enjoy the journey and thank you so much for the comment.
Best regards,
TGV
Great intro! This is a mid time goal for me. Whatta piece with amazing heritage. Cheers.
Superb presentation as always. I am wearing B42 Pilot GMT Chronograph for a few years and I must say it is amazing watch. The only downside I can see is that outer AR coating is getting scratched in time but otherwise amazing piece of a watch.
So did my AR on my 2 year old B42. I haven't been hard on mine. Don't get it. I have tougher antireflective coating on my Momo Design Divemaster that has held up flawlessly for years and is considered one of my outdoor beater watches. But, still love both my B-42's!
This is a great looking watch. It's a real shame it seems to be sold out. I'd love to be able to get my hands on this one.
Hey TGV!
Love the new Timex! I have two that I have owned for over 20 years and they have never failed me.
I am really excited that you are reviewing a Fortis watch. I have read extensively about them and am impressed by what I have learned about them. Unfortunately, I have not had the opportunity to try one on in person :(
The B-42 is very impressive. My favourite feature on this watch is the bracelet. As you mentioned, it can be adjusted with ease. This is personally important to me as I have a small wrist and I tend to have bracelets that are either too tight, or too loose.
Also, the dial is clearly laid-out and is easy to read. My eyesight is not the best and even with glasses or contacts, a scattered dial can make reading a watch difficult. This watch appears to be ready to be used in any circumstance.
Maybe this, or another Fortis, will be the chrono I will purchase! Has to compete with the Speedmaster, however.
Thanks for another great and educational video!
Regards,
Nathan
Actually I prefer smaller sized watches like my Omega Speedmaster Automatic (40 mm)or my Omega Speedmaster Triple Date (40 mm). But you won. After watching this video I had to buy one. It`s really a beauty. Thank you for your work and your enthusiasm. Best wishes from Switzerland
I also own a Speedmaster MK 40 and love it. But somehow I really dig the Fortis B42. Probably it's too big for me. Where did you get yours? What's your wrist size?
I m from switzerland. I bought it used. I always bye my watches used. I personally prefer those kind of watches with a t-shirt or polo shirt. But I will never wear them to a suit or shirt. They are just to big. The size and high ist about my Casio GW 2000. Or you could compare the size with an Citizen Skymaster.
Thats my beloved Omega. Finally I could not sell it.
uhrforum.de/threads/omega-speedmaster-day-date-ref-3520-5000-tripple-date-saphir-aus-august-2014.299321/@@7rslender
@@volkerarminhafner8530 thank you for your insight. I am from Switzerland as well and was just able to pick up the Titanium Verison for a decent price (used of course). It's currently on it's way to me.
I totally understand that you did not want to sell the MK 40. It's a very special watch. It's just incredible how much they packed into this little fella.
Fortis is a prime example of affordable quality Swiss at under $700, recently purchased their Cockpit One (42m), prefer the Fleiger look over the this Chrono. I like the Fortis logo and balance of their dials. I enjoy the historical background of various brands that you touch on in your Royal fashion. Best, JP
That is an awesome watch!! I would love to get my hands on one of those. The dial is magnificent! Great video my friend. They just keep getting better and better! Cheers!
Thank you JC, that means the world to me to hear, especially from you. As for the Fortis, let me see if I can get one for you to borrow ;-)
Best regards,
TGV
The Urban Gentry 😂
hey TGV! could you do a video on the Bulova Moon Watch since you're such an avid speedy fan! its a cheaper quartz alternative with real history!
I just sold mine today at ebay...... I thought for a moment that it was sold because of your video but your video uploaded later ;-)
cbb1987cbb - haha, the infamous "TGV tax" effect of watches being more in demand after his review!