Post Office Inquiry: Alan Bates delivers brutal assessment of bosses

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 кві 2024
  • Today was the moment for the real Alan Bates to stand up, as he was sworn in at the Horizon inquiry, delivering a brutal assessment of the Post Office bosses who hounded him and his colleagues, then tried to cover it up.
    (Subscribe: bit.ly/C4_News_Subscribe)
    But perhaps the most damning thing to come out of today - the accusation from the inquiry's chair that even now the Post Office seems to be attempting to obstruct the entire process.
    -----------------------
    Follow us:
    Facebook - / channel4news
    Twitter - / channel4news
    TikTok - / c4news
    Instagram - / channel4news

КОМЕНТАРІ • 850

  • @quietowl1246
    @quietowl1246 Місяць тому +317

    A total F ing disgrace. The responsible people including Vennels are the ones that should be serving decades in prison. I have no respect for the justice system if we don’t see justice for these postmasters. Absolutely horrific.

    • @stevenclarke5606
      @stevenclarke5606 Місяць тому +18

      An Absolute disgrace of British Justice!

    • @christhomson8924
      @christhomson8924 Місяць тому +1

      free israel!!!!! 🇮🇱
      we have a right to exist!
      we are the victims of the holocaust

    • @normanpearson8753
      @normanpearson8753 Місяць тому +8

      I think prison is unlikely , sadly , decades was never on ,( ditto) , but losing their pension should be a must....if that isn't malfeasance in public office , then what is?! They could only go to court if the P.O. paid costs(!) , .....however , they won't lose their pensions .

    • @davidgidman7561
      @davidgidman7561 Місяць тому +7

      They should be in jail now awaiting trial

    • @wickedwitchoftheeast88
      @wickedwitchoftheeast88 Місяць тому

      ​@@normanpearson8753 I agree with you, as much as I'd love to see Paula Vennells, Angela Van Den Bogerd and everyone else who was involved in and covered this up should be bankrupted, lose their home and sent to prison but it won't happen. Senior managers are never held to account for things like this look at the Lucy Letby case senior managers supported her and bullied and threatened the doctors to back down when their suspicions were later proved to be correct and those managers haven't been charged with anything one was already retired and lets not forget Hillsborough those senior police officers have never been held accoutable for their actions they covered it up for over 20 years and blamed the Liverpool fans when it was their stupidity and utter incompetence that caused it. In the UK its one rule for the little people and a totally different rule to big wigs. Look at Prince Andrew he should be rotting in prison instead he's free to carry on abusing purely because he's royalty.
      When our government finally pays the subpostmasters their money back I guarentee it will be out of our taxes and not from the Post Office, they stole from those people and use it as their profit yet they lose nothing typical British Justice for you the UK is rotten to the core

  • @gorgu08
    @gorgu08 Місяць тому +133

    They really shat the bed when they decided to prosecute such a well educated, confident, articulate, determined and energetic human as Alan Bates, give him a massive payout and either put him in the post office or in the Lords where he can specialise in miscarriages of justice

    • @cherryrotella3714
      @cherryrotella3714 Місяць тому +1

      Yes Mr Bates was never intimidated by them and so became a threat so they had to get rid of him

  • @helmutreichart9081
    @helmutreichart9081 Місяць тому +395

    Why not put Alan Bates in charge of the Post Office? He surely has p,entry of experience, if only there were more like him. A true Hero for ordinary people.

    • @sadjaxx
      @sadjaxx Місяць тому +22

      Terrific idea!

    • @3bebles
      @3bebles Місяць тому +29

      Why not indeed? Excellent suggestion though I am sure poor Alan and his wife must be wishing for some peace and quiet at long last...

    • @sandy7299
      @sandy7299 Місяць тому +30

      Why punish him like that, he seems a decent bloke 😁

    • @pedromorgan99
      @pedromorgan99 Місяць тому +6

      @@sadjaxx Feet up as chairman.. lol

    • @marybusch6182
      @marybusch6182 Місяць тому +14

      He has the expertise of any expert and the persIstence necessary to address issues and resolve them in a timely and deliberate fashion. Nobody would be better thatn he would be.

  • @fatbelly27
    @fatbelly27 Місяць тому +425

    How incompetent do you have to be to leave a paper trail about not leaving a paper trail?

    • @3bebles
      @3bebles Місяць тому +33

      That kind of incompetence is typical precisely because they are total amateurs and grifters!

    • @0xDEAFF00D
      @0xDEAFF00D Місяць тому +14

      Ironically, this is very common. All bureaucracies have to rely on their memos and CYA policies, and they always get found out because of these memos. Those of a certain age might remember the so-called Iran-Contra situation in the US, where these super-secret acronyms and their super-secret plans had to be spelled out and filed in triplicate, and then filed away. Again, whether or not anyone deserving goes to prison over any of these conspiracies is left as an exercise for the reader.

    • @wolcek
      @wolcek Місяць тому +14

      OK, lets hypothetically assume you have asked me to do something I think might be shady. You can bet I will keep a paper trail to cover my behind just in case. And then, if I do not like you any more, of if you do something shady to me, or of I want something from you, I will have a nice way to remind you where your loyalties lie.

    • @morganmajurey5805
      @morganmajurey5805 Місяць тому +11

      With the shown level of incompetence within the Post Office they probably thought that by using emails there would be no 'paper trail' !

    • @thomasneal9291
      @thomasneal9291 Місяць тому +3

      ...and that was in 2013.

  • @jonb3311
    @jonb3311 Місяць тому +295

    Don't forget Fujitsu have been as guilty as the PO during the whole of this conspiracy.

    • @tenkloosterherman
      @tenkloosterherman Місяць тому +10

      True.

    • @kjensen7819
      @kjensen7819 Місяць тому +11

      They are a company founded to make money. PO is paid by tax money and is there to serve the public. Both guilty, but not the same.

    • @cedcol356
      @cedcol356 Місяць тому +6

      They're not Chinese or Russian so it's not an issue

    • @user-zz9gn2dc3l
      @user-zz9gn2dc3l Місяць тому

      Yes and now the government are putting this corporation in charge of the Central Bank Digital Currency they want to force on us all!!!

    • @WildcraftBritain
      @WildcraftBritain Місяць тому +10

      What happened to the money? 💰 I suspect there’s some people out there living the so called high life on this missing cash 😞

  • @michaelhipperson1554
    @michaelhipperson1554 Місяць тому +84

    Alan Bates remains so calm and polite after 23 years of hassle. A brilliant example of how to deal with cheats and liars. Hopefully he will be successful.

  • @dixie5929
    @dixie5929 Місяць тому +214

    Alan Bates is an absolute hero Davey is a Sir when it should be Sir Alan Bates for over 20 years of heroic determination

    • @noelfleming3567
      @noelfleming3567 Місяць тому +6

      👍👏👏

    • @daviddowsett1658
      @daviddowsett1658 Місяць тому +33

      Alan was offered an OBE or CBE or something like that for which he refused and said he would only accept when the matter of compensation and criminal prosecutions against post office management had been competed ... what a dude!!!

    • @janeday9148
      @janeday9148 Місяць тому +19

      Ed Davey is a disgrace

    • @thedr.feelgood
      @thedr.feelgood Місяць тому +4

      ​@@daviddowsett1658 What a bloke his is... Tenacious isn't in it... 20 yrs plus !!!

    • @thedr.feelgood
      @thedr.feelgood Місяць тому +7

      ​@@janeday9148 Yes, appallingly ineffective - sums up his whole political career....

  • @nathanio103
    @nathanio103 Місяць тому +76

    Alan Bates is absolutely formidable! Such an incredible public speaker, so honest and genuine!

  • @alexmac513
    @alexmac513 Місяць тому +115

    I don't understand why the police haven't kicked the doors down and taken the documents they need. Then arrested the Post Office people that did this. People in the Post Office need to spend a time behind bars for this. If I as an individual did this I'd go to prison, I couldn't complain. Its undermining the police and the justice system if they don't go to prison.

    • @robinfoster7597
      @robinfoster7597 Місяць тому

      That's just for us plebs! Clearly, the UK has a two-tier justice system!

    • @willmoore7582
      @willmoore7582 Місяць тому +14

      Probably because those responsible have friends, who have friends and right now they are getting rid of evidence and building their case for damage limitation.

    • @roberthiggins6401
      @roberthiggins6401 Місяць тому

      The police are corporation's.
      They're as bent as the po.
      You can see them not respecting the true rule of law. They're only interested in motorists, assisting evictions etc.

    • @redplanet7163
      @redplanet7163 Місяць тому

      They are too busy kicking down the doors of people who have an opinion on the islamicisation of Britain, for the "crime" of "hate speech."

    • @elliottg.1954
      @elliottg.1954 28 днів тому

      Probably because this corruption and appalling conspiracy carried on for decades, under the auspices of the government. It's a can of worms they don't really want to be fully opened. And after all, considering our hopeless police and our broken Justice system, the slimy executives at the centre of this Stalinist conspiracy can be reasonably confident they'll do no jail time.

  • @jbenn43457
    @jbenn43457 Місяць тому +112

    Suspend the bosses pay until the documents are released.

    • @robinfoster7597
      @robinfoster7597 Місяць тому +7

      or just arrest them and deny them bail as a "flight risk".

    • @jamesskeoch6562
      @jamesskeoch6562 Місяць тому

      They have already banked LOADS to feather their nests! Criminals the entire CORRUPT BOARD!

    • @pauldickinson5316
      @pauldickinson5316 Місяць тому

      The FDA had the same issue releasing the Pf*zer trial data as they said it would take 75 years. That was until a group of professionals including Prof's and Dr's filed a lawsuit and the judge ordered the release within 8 months. Nothing to see here.

    • @jbenn43457
      @jbenn43457 Місяць тому

      @mattbuddyMattBuddyGNN neither will "off with their heads". Just wishful thinking

  • @heathermaich8966
    @heathermaich8966 Місяць тому +82

    Post office executives need to go to jail

  • @MyTv-
    @MyTv- Місяць тому +138

    The Post Office needs to be put into administration. To get to the root of it.

    • @grantwallace1882
      @grantwallace1882 Місяць тому +9

      I have hear some politician saying exactly your point.

    • @MyTv-
      @MyTv- Місяць тому

      @@grantwallace1882 With that level of obstruction, it’s the obvious solution. I would trigger a deep revision of both the post office and the key people involved. This smells of corruption.

    • @chuckoster8221
      @chuckoster8221 Місяць тому

      It’s not the root,it’s the seed that grows into the root,and that is Tony Blair.He signed off the Horizon system,knowing,full well,it was faulty because Harriet Harman told him so.He started the ball rolling,then bankrupted the country.Notice,complete silence from the great interferer,the one that never misses an opportunity to poke his nose in.What a chance for the great mr fixit to come down from his ivory tower and save the world and blame the Conservatives for all of it.

    • @jacksyful
      @jacksyful Місяць тому +1

      the po has no control by its sole shareholders-- the government!! that is wrong wrong wrong!!

  • @johnvaleanbaily246
    @johnvaleanbaily246 Місяць тому +318

    Post Office obfuscation. Should be jailed.

    • @JelMain
      @JelMain Місяць тому +10

      Deliberately. They were warned, deadlines set, and still. It's completely unfair on the witnesses, and cannot but be reflected in the Report's liminatory comments.

    • @andrewgrillet5835
      @andrewgrillet5835 Місяць тому

      There needs to be an investigation into "possible" fraud. The most likely reason for the Post Office management behaviour is that their boots were full of ill-gotten gains.
      Only another enquiry could possibly prove their guilt or innocence.

    • @MrBoggins1234
      @MrBoggins1234 Місяць тому +10

      Not just PO leadership but Fujitsu - European leadership also.

    • @user-rt2ri5ft5v
      @user-rt2ri5ft5v Місяць тому +6

      The PO will have been instructed by government.

    • @JelMain
      @JelMain Місяць тому +2

      @@user-rt2ri5ft5v As seen in Kemi Badenoch's mishandling of Henry Staunton, If it wasn't for Crown Immunity, he'd have a prime case against her for malfeasance. As of now, they've lost the resource of experienced hands from the Corporate Sector, and given Cuymmings' assessment of the Civil Service and the public opinion of the Government, we're in a sorry state.

  • @andrewh2u
    @andrewh2u Місяць тому +104

    We need to see Post Office executives and their lying lawyers and investigators serving jail time for this and heavy compensation for their victims and the families of lost victims.

    • @jjefferyworboys8138
      @jjefferyworboys8138 Місяць тому +2

      Lawyers don't lie but are regularly lied to by their clients.

    • @andrewh2u
      @andrewh2u Місяць тому +8

      @@jjefferyworboys8138 Saying that Lawyers dont lie is never going to be plausible.

    • @mikematthews2750
      @mikematthews2750 Місяць тому +4

      I want to see that awful guy Whitaker in a cell with Big Brutus…

  • @norfolkandchance9298
    @norfolkandchance9298 Місяць тому +100

    Until Paula Vennells is sent to jail, justice will not be done.

    • @Liberty_Freedom_Brotherhood
      @Liberty_Freedom_Brotherhood Місяць тому +14

      Didn’t some of the postmasters commit suicide?
      Jail too soft for Vennels

    • @roberthiggins6401
      @roberthiggins6401 Місяць тому +7

      I would think there are several people at least need to face justice.
      We've seen soooo many cover ups over the years.
      Water companies only ever face a fine and that fine gets passed on to you and I, no one ever faces justice.
      Remember the strangles song, no more heroes?
      Well we do have heroes in the form of whistle blowers, the heroes who have morals.

    • @mirjamwillemsen900
      @mirjamwillemsen900 24 дні тому +1

      And some others, like Angela van den Bogerd

    • @jonathanstone..
      @jonathanstone.. 21 день тому

      Even those in charge today with these delays tactics. Its like they breed this behaviour in the heads of the post office

  • @TheDMG45
    @TheDMG45 Місяць тому +103

    What makes me so angry about this is not just that it happened, its that no expense was spared when they were going after the sub-postmasters - the "justice" system happily threw hundreds of people in jail on incredibly flimsy cases. But then now when the shoe is on the other foot, it doesn't look like anyone is going to be held accountable at all except perhaps a few token resignations.

    • @KiwiCatherineJemma
      @KiwiCatherineJemma Місяць тому +21

      I think the judges (where they are sitting, without a jury) should take at least SOME of the blame. When the entirety of the prosecution case is "Computer says "X" UK pounds has gone missing". Yet there is literally zero other corroborating evidence, and when an examination of the person's lifestyle shows NO "excess money" (NO flashy car or boat purchases, no expensive house, or gambling addictions etc). ...and the person in the dock is saying "I worked honestly, Maybe the computer system, made a mistake"... then the judges involved should at least have considered that possibility. Also any judge before accepting a "guilty plea" should have asked the defendant if they had had, independent legal advice beforehand.

    • @TheDMG45
      @TheDMG45 Місяць тому +7

      ​@@KiwiCatherineJemma Exactly! To me whether its through malice or cheer incompetence they are as bad as the post office for accepting such shoddy evidence and not caring that the accused victims don't even get to give their side of the story

    • @chrisholland7367
      @chrisholland7367 Місяць тому +2

      Let's hope this is more than just a circus

    • @seanhaywood4597
      @seanhaywood4597 Місяць тому

      the post office get to spend £100 million of tax payers money defending the indefencable yet in the
      real world legal aid is means tested and since 2010 the tory party as cut the legal aid budgit by over
      50% leaving the poor unable to get decent legal representation, and dont forget boris who managed
      to run up a legal aid bill of circa £300k for party gate inquiry paid for by the tax payer, its disgusting
      that the tax payer has to keep picking up the bill for this corruption,

    • @johnjc4645
      @johnjc4645 Місяць тому +3

      But the woman in charge has said sorry and handed her medal back isn't that enough

  • @gtek8021
    @gtek8021 Місяць тому +40

    Post Office ltd was able to be Judge, Jury and Executioner. Paula Vennells and all of the senior Executives, Post Office, Fujitsu and Ministers in the know HAVE TO GO TO PRISON for the damage done to innocent peoples lives and the lives that are sadly lost. How does Paula Vennells sleep at night!
    This is a perfect example that "POWER CORRUPTS AND ABSOLUTE POWER CORRUPTS ABSOLUTELY"

  • @neilhobson3624
    @neilhobson3624 Місяць тому +35

    It’s utterly atrocious what the Post Office has done , and is still is doing.

  • @Haberdashery22
    @Haberdashery22 Місяць тому +20

    Alan Bates is a hero for the truth and for seeking justice as he has. He should be knighted at the very least.

  • @peterjackson2625
    @peterjackson2625 Місяць тому +84

    Nobody will ever believe a word from the Post Office. If I had any savings in the Post Office, I would withdraw them.

  • @stephenbarrett8000
    @stephenbarrett8000 Місяць тому +12

    Ed Davey has a Knighthood (as did Paula Vennels) and Alan Bates doesn't.
    That should tell you everything you need to know about the British Establishment.

  • @JohnnyMotel99
    @JohnnyMotel99 Місяць тому +65

    You can bet a billion $$ that the main culprits have all their expensive lawyers beavering away for months if not years working up some impenetrable defence and probably any criminal defence will be funded by the PO.

    • @ChrisM541
      @ChrisM541 Місяць тому +14

      ...funded by the tax payer, unfortunately.

    • @JohnnyMotel99
      @JohnnyMotel99 Місяць тому +4

      @@ChrisM541 eventually

  • @ThisisnotTwitter
    @ThisisnotTwitter Місяць тому +48

    Should not be possible. That post office CEO clearly does not care at all.
    Remove all involved from office. Give it back to the public ownership entirely where it always should have been and then start again.

    • @rbnhd1144
      @rbnhd1144 Місяць тому

      It all started with privatiaztion, who's decesion was that?
      Its big mistake for the British Public, Every basic service should be owned by the general public who use it, otherwise its for Profit, then your prices skyrocket and foreigners control you.

  • @user-qc4mi1dw7n
    @user-qc4mi1dw7n Місяць тому +31

    Absolutely disgusting behaviour by the Post Office.

  • @p0ssiblypossiblynot557
    @p0ssiblypossiblynot557 Місяць тому +37

    This case is a perfect illustration of 'The Banality of Evil"

  • @alanhand503
    @alanhand503 Місяць тому +20

    In other words the Post Office and Fujitsu are checking every document to make sure they don't hand over any incriminating evidence. All those senior Post Office and Fujitsu managers should be prosecuted and jailed, just for holding back evidence, but also be held accountable to pay compensation and jailed for manslaughter.

    • @ritab8663
      @ritab8663 Місяць тому +1

      Am I right in thinking that the PO passed over 73,000 documents out of millions in their keep, I wonder how much more are in the paperwork held back could be incriminating

  • @janeday9148
    @janeday9148 Місяць тому +21

    Alan Bates is amazing & helps to restore hope in humanity because the British publics confidence has been lost in the institutions of this Country

  • @willienelsongonzalez4609
    @willienelsongonzalez4609 Місяць тому +34

    ….. so The Post Office contacted its insurer over the Horizon IT system and its own legal team said it’s only course of action was to instigate a massive cover up. Senior management listened to the lawyers and deliberately pursued a policy of secrecy, silence and scorched earth by blaming the Sub Posters and holding them accountable for the failures of Fujitsu and The Post Office.

  • @dave3130
    @dave3130 Місяць тому +14

    What a national hero. Showed true bulldog spirit 💪🏼

  • @bostonbikebits6539
    @bostonbikebits6539 Місяць тому +10

    They bang on about wanting to comply but their actions show something completely different.

  • @derekgillan7314
    @derekgillan7314 Місяць тому +10

    Well done Sir! Post office bosses = jail. The more they obstruct the more jail time.

  • @user-pq3jm5yc6y
    @user-pq3jm5yc6y Місяць тому +9

    I have nothing but admiration for Mr Bates.

  • @RestoDesignsnando
    @RestoDesignsnando Місяць тому +12

    Wow what a great guy Alan Bates is, standing up against these people.

  • @50_Pence
    @50_Pence Місяць тому +86

    It's late stage capitalism. It's what big business does and you can see it all over the place.

    • @noelfleming3567
      @noelfleming3567 Місяць тому +1

      Ruling d world 😢😢

    • @pacman7959
      @pacman7959 Місяць тому +11

      Late stage? Get buckled in mate. We still have the surprise of pensions to come.

    • @user-zz9gn2dc3l
      @user-zz9gn2dc3l Місяць тому +10

      Not capitalism/free market trading. It's fascism when the government are in bed with corporations - public private partnerships!!

    • @maxxrenn
      @maxxrenn Місяць тому +4

      Its a state owned company. Basically the opposite of capitalism.

  • @1styash
    @1styash Місяць тому +24

    It’s not only post office, most of the organisations in the UK 🇬🇧 do the same. They use their rough HR employees and lawyer who are pathological liars use laws as a mechanism of abuse the law itself.

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Місяць тому

      Is it necessary to label them as pathological liars ? Surely it's just their job ?

  • @Truthseeker1515
    @Truthseeker1515 Місяць тому +34

    What state is Britain in!

    • @pacman7959
      @pacman7959 Місяць тому

      I blame it on the immigrants. Why? Because Farage told me.

  • @angelogiacomazzi6699
    @angelogiacomazzi6699 Місяць тому +11

    Someone in the Fuji organisation ended up pocketing the money.
    They need to be held accountable for the theft of this money.
    Details of the Investigation need to be made public.

  • @getheroutofthetruck
    @getheroutofthetruck Місяць тому +13

    They haven't finished deleting their hard drives or shredding the papers yet.

  • @pamjordan5281
    @pamjordan5281 Місяць тому +11

    Unlike the PO employees Mr Bates has total recall 😊

  • @notquiteoverthehill9576
    @notquiteoverthehill9576 Місяць тому +32

    Post office boss Lies lies lies sack him & shut it down.

    • @jjefferyworboys8138
      @jjefferyworboys8138 Місяць тому +2

      Why would you want to shut down the Post Office ? In many communities the Post Office is very important particularly to the elderly.

  • @aroemaliuged4776
    @aroemaliuged4776 Місяць тому +41

    Ed Davy on a digger
    Is that supposed to be ironic
    Honestly politicians are a different breed

    • @howardosborne8647
      @howardosborne8647 Місяць тому

      Davy is a man with no principles and zero credibility.

    • @grayflight9424
      @grayflight9424 Місяць тому +2

      My question is are there any honest ones about

    • @georgegently3026
      @georgegently3026 Місяць тому

      ​@@grayflight9424no

    • @kayoedowner6711
      @kayoedowner6711 Місяць тому +2

      @@georgegently3026To be fair James Arbuthnot has stood by the sub postmasters throughout.

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Місяць тому +1

      Not breed - they're grown in a Petri dish....

  • @abbiebrown2733
    @abbiebrown2733 Місяць тому +103

    Mr Bates has been treated shockingly. Alan Bates should sue the post office for 1 million pound

    • @lewilewis3944
      @lewilewis3944 Місяць тому +27

      He's meant to get at least that through the compensation scheme just for loss of earnings for the past 20 years. But guess what? Yup. The Post Office bosses are a bunch of thieves.

    • @user-bl8zw4ol1j
      @user-bl8zw4ol1j Місяць тому

      Well said they are THiEVES. Deal with the now through the courts at the PO funds

    • @Hugo97HD
      @Hugo97HD Місяць тому +15

      ​@@lewilewis3944 they are being protected. I don't know their names but I wouldn't be surprised if they are all family or friend with important labour and tory MPs. That's why it's taken so long to do something about it.

    • @nineteen8486
      @nineteen8486 Місяць тому +7

      and more.........

    • @Jackthesmilingblack
      @Jackthesmilingblack Місяць тому +4

      At least.

  • @ysgol3
    @ysgol3 Місяць тому +5

    What a hero this man is. What he's done in the face of such corporate bullying is staggering.
    And the way the horrendous Ed Davey is only concerned with saving his own 'reputation' is disgusting.
    What a contrast between two men.

  • @garrybowers414
    @garrybowers414 Місяць тому +11

    They should be locked up for withholding evidence

  • @findacarbuyer
    @findacarbuyer Місяць тому +10

    police needs to announce their involvement

  • @IrfanAli-qp1gm
    @IrfanAli-qp1gm Місяць тому +10

    Never think the Establishment will do right by the subposters. They will delay, obfuscate and do everything to stop compensation.
    Wasting public money on expensive Enquiry.

  • @aroemaliuged4776
    @aroemaliuged4776 Місяць тому +34

    Call me over the top..
    But this wanting to obey the rules
    Having an air of superiority against the low uns………
    Reminds me of so many historical examples

    • @viewfinder914
      @viewfinder914 Місяць тому +6

      Not over the top. What you are touching upon is British government culture. It is pervasive over time.

  • @Herblay63
    @Herblay63 Місяць тому +10

    Alan Bates is a man of immense honour.... he could have really gone for Ed Davey but instead in his verbal evidence he claims not to remember very much about his meeting with Ed Davey except that he was disappointed with his response to his request for assistance in response to the developing scandal. The inquiry evidence included Ed Davey's briefing note for the meeting prepared by the civil service which is very clear, we know exactly what Ed Davey said in the meeting. Essentially... you won't get any help coming this way, you lot are on your own, don't want to know, don't care, so long. Bye.

  • @LordBikealot
    @LordBikealot Місяць тому +9

    People in power should be held accountable. This whole f'ing situation is DISGUSTING!

    • @VSmithy
      @VSmithy Місяць тому

      And it all happened because Ed Davey, among other Lib Dem members, supported David Cameron's privatization of the Post Office.

  • @JohnJones-wo1bc
    @JohnJones-wo1bc Місяць тому +7

    This is a Magna Carta moment for our generation

  • @peterw4338
    @peterw4338 Місяць тому +6

    It's not just the PO behaving like this; it's nearly every government department and council in the UK

    • @VSmithy
      @VSmithy Місяць тому

      The Post Office was privatized by David Cameron, remember? That's why the fat cats who bought the shares could lie and make lots of money while refusing to investigate how Fujitsu's rubbish system was robbing the subpostmasters.

    • @VSmithy
      @VSmithy Місяць тому

      The Post Office was privatized and sold off under David Cameron's austerity program.

  • @me-un7vq
    @me-un7vq Місяць тому +40

    All power to Alan bates and the wrongly convicted. We are stuck in a toxic tory twisted death spiral. God help us.

    • @alisdairmclean8605
      @alisdairmclean8605 Місяць тому +8

      Yes the Tories plus Starmer who was head of the CPS when some innocents were locked up and Ed Davey. Our political class.

    • @noelfleming3567
      @noelfleming3567 Місяць тому +3

      And d rich get richer who's paying d legal fees in these inquiries

    • @SingWhileYouMay
      @SingWhileYouMay Місяць тому +5

      @@alisdairmclean8605 Starmer and his office had nothing to do with it. The post office itself brought the prosecutions. A wonderful aspect of UK law that such is possible.

    • @howardosborne8647
      @howardosborne8647 Місяць тому

      All the main political parties have had a hand in allowing this travesty to go on for many years longer than it should. None of them come out of this looking good.

    • @TheArgieH
      @TheArgieH Місяць тому

      ​@@alisdairmclean8605Minor detail missing. The PO itself was empowered to bring prosecutions and did so, that's a gruesome part of the whole sorry story. If the CPS had oversight the scandal would likely have been exposed sooner. But the CPS was not involved as it had no locus, nor for that matter was Keir Starmer. Do keep up.

  • @MrGavinBoyd
    @MrGavinBoyd Місяць тому +19

    Will any of those responsible go to prison?

    • @richardroulstone-roberts8598
      @richardroulstone-roberts8598 Місяць тому +1

      Some token sacrifice, I guess.

    • @pacman7959
      @pacman7959 Місяць тому +2

      Just the fall guys. Real culprits are too powerful to prosecute call me a conspiracy loon.

    • @richardjns17
      @richardjns17 Місяць тому +2

      Set up a gofundme for Private prosecutions,I bet they'd raise thousands.

  • @CYCHIATRIC
    @CYCHIATRIC Місяць тому +7

    No executives will suffer consequences. They will go on to live long, happy and affluent lives. The system will not change. The victims will be discarded. This enquiry and its media coverage is theatre to placate the public. Everyone knows this.

  • @mikeharvey9811
    @mikeharvey9811 Місяць тому +5

    All my family worked for the post office, telephone exchange, TV Licences, Posties…..we loved the GPO , we bought postal orders, stamps, dog licences premium bonds, passports….all that love and trust gone. Barb

  • @grahamkearnon6682
    @grahamkearnon6682 Місяць тому +14

    Read with the typical Public school accent, what a surprise!

  • @kitburns1665
    @kitburns1665 Місяць тому +29

    Disclose as little as possible. Privatization.

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Місяць тому

      Nationalization led to such a wonderful blooming of openness and disclosure. Different hats, that's all...

  • @njd2342
    @njd2342 Місяць тому +9

    British Justice is slower than a tortoise but at least the tortoise gets its destination eventually. Will British Justice?

    • @ImNotReallyHereMCFC
      @ImNotReallyHereMCFC Місяць тому +1

      Take money from the government, you watch just fast "justice" can be

  • @22Phantasm
    @22Phantasm Місяць тому +15

    The PO very quickly were able to convict and jail so many innocent working class citizens. The police haven't even started to investigate the guilty, rich, pompous and powerful PO/Fujitsu/Govt officials who were involved in this travesty of justice. That says everything about classist, UK Injustice.

  • @Dean256
    @Dean256 Місяць тому +14

    Once this is all done the post office needs disbanding. It cannot be disbanded now as that will be the post offices get out clause…

    • @ftumschk
      @ftumschk Місяць тому +5

      The central management needs to be overhauled/replaced (if it isn't being done already), but the whole operation doesn't necessarily need to be disbanded.

    • @Dean256
      @Dean256 Місяць тому +2

      @@ftumschk while they have this amount of power the post office needs to be completely overhauled. They have proven they have no morals and it’s a government institution. It needs disbanding and completely changed…

    • @ftumschk
      @ftumschk Місяць тому +2

      @@Dean256 The language I chose was deliberately precise. It's the central management that needs overhauling, not the tens of thousands of good people who work in post office branches throughout the country.

    • @Dean256
      @Dean256 Місяць тому +2

      @@ftumschk I’m sorry but the whole thing needs to change the post office as a single company across the UK cannot continue. I’m not sure how it needs to be changed but it certainly does. They have changed the management structure and it’s made no difference and this ability for them to be able to run investigations without police involvement needs stopping immediately… like tonight…

    • @ftumschk
      @ftumschk Місяць тому +3

      ​@@Dean256 Sort out the central management and IT suppliers by all means - they screwed this up, and they need to carry the can. However, they're not "the whole thing", and I think the thousands of dedicated subpostmasters and their staff have been "overhauled" quite enough for now, don't you?

  • @danburycollins
    @danburycollins Місяць тому +24

    Ed Davey hopes the inquiry holds people to account... Not people like him... But other people... But not him...

  • @eddjordan2399
    @eddjordan2399 Місяць тому +6

    Post office chief exec is a complete A WHOLE.

  • @janeday9148
    @janeday9148 Місяць тому +8

    There has to be Criminal Charges including Corporate Manslaughter

    • @markmcintyre9893
      @markmcintyre9893 Місяць тому

      Unfortunately such charges wouldn’t be made out in law

  • @Cody-zd2ye
    @Cody-zd2ye Місяць тому +4

    What a refreshing human being and god bless him for his courage we need more like him.i wish someone like him would ask why the police didn't investigate the pandemic.bless Mr Bates

  • @davidcolin6519
    @davidcolin6519 Місяць тому +3

    This enquiry demanded these documents literally YEARS ago, yet they're still dragging their ffet.
    "Remarkable" just doesn't come close to how egregious this is.

  • @gnothiseauton8684
    @gnothiseauton8684 Місяць тому +5

    He might want to announce that he’s not suicidal

  • @ftumschk
    @ftumschk Місяць тому +9

    4:26 I thought that was a typo, but there really is a legal firm called "Womble Bond Dickinson". It's nice to see that the Wombles have progressed from picking up litter to picking up litigation.

    • @fatbelly27
      @fatbelly27 Місяць тому +1

      Making good use of the things that they find...

    • @becmiberserker
      @becmiberserker Місяць тому +1

      Or picking up litter to becoming it!

    • @TheDMG45
      @TheDMG45 Місяць тому +1

      The name's Bond. Womble Bond.

  • @steveg7718
    @steveg7718 Місяць тому +4

    What sentence is appropriate for wrecking peoples lives, making them fight all these years for justice, and even now still covering up and slowing down the process... Beyond belief.

  • @XxTheAwokenOnexX
    @XxTheAwokenOnexX Місяць тому +1

    It is unacceptable that the people who own the post office 👑 are not being held to account!

  • @charlesflouvat1829
    @charlesflouvat1829 Місяць тому +12

    Salting the ground for labour, 🤔

    • @noelfleming3567
      @noelfleming3567 Місяць тому

      Definitely going to be a shitshow after d election

  • @jacksyful
    @jacksyful Місяць тому +2

    the executives have got to go --to jail for a long time!!

  • @bobtudbury8505
    @bobtudbury8505 Місяць тому +4

    davey needs to resign and hand his money back

  • @davidmansfield9167
    @davidmansfield9167 Місяць тому +1

    Undermining public confidence in national institutions is a grave mistake with long term implications for society. Prison terms must result.

  • @123JWJWJW
    @123JWJWJW 27 днів тому

    Recently started the program on PBS television in the US. Absolutely shocked and abhorred that after all these years that no justice has been made for these people. How could such corrupt and despicable people still be able to walk free all these years later? It's horrible to try and grasp that something such as this could continue on and on without justice for these poor souls. Blessings and strength to you to continue in the good fight!

  • @dianerichardson3061
    @dianerichardson3061 Місяць тому +1

    If they don't come up with the proof or documents they should automatically be found guilty.

  • @hickster222
    @hickster222 Місяць тому +3

    Life in the clink for everyone involved in this scandal. No chance of parole.

  • @user-ck8zu9tm1o
    @user-ck8zu9tm1o Місяць тому +3

    I am absolutely flummoxed by all of this although, I shouldn't be. Allan Bates is the right man for fight, he is measured, intelligent, articulate and able to co-ordinate those similarly affected . Good on you Mr Bates. 👏

  • @alfieakaronaldog
    @alfieakaronaldog Місяць тому +3

    Paula Vennels will have a bit of a dilemma having to swear an oath to tell the truth if she is as godly as she makes out 😂

    • @Orwic1
      @Orwic1 Місяць тому +1

      I’ve known a number of people who claimed to be christians. Some really were: charitable, empathetic, kindly and overall good people, always willing to help others (I met them in charity work I was involved with). But a few fell below that standard by quite a margin 😢

  • @adrianlloyd6403
    @adrianlloyd6403 Місяць тому +5

    Andrew Parsons....lawyer.......acts and behaves like a lawyer.And lawyers wonder why so many people despise them.

  • @rachelabbott9393
    @rachelabbott9393 Місяць тому +5

    Go Alan Bates! I am sure EVERYONE involved and more are on Mr Bates and the sub post masters and mistresses side 100%

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Місяць тому

      Not so - the hyphae are even now destroying or losing evidence...

    • @getsorted0185
      @getsorted0185 29 днів тому +1

      What an absolute hero Alan bates is
      what do these people think they were doing ruining all these lives appalling

  • @ilokivi
    @ilokivi Місяць тому +2

    Surprised that the public inquiry hasn't yet instructed bailiffs to enter PO premises and seize documents, so that the inquiry can get to the bottom of this promptly. Justice delayed is justice denied.

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Місяць тому

      What documents ? You don't think they still exist do you ?

  • @ataxpayer723
    @ataxpayer723 Місяць тому +1

    The UK Govt needs to sack the current CEO and the entire board, then install a Commissioner.

  • @jonathand.wieand6119
    @jonathand.wieand6119 Місяць тому +2

    What about also holding Fujitsu responsible for for their role in this mess? Is anyone looking into that?

  • @TheStevenWhiting
    @TheStevenWhiting Місяць тому +3

    And just think. He's of the era of "Don't rock the boat", its what I've heard in the past. If he didn't rock the boat and rock it for decades, then none of it would of come out.

  • @KiwiCatherineJemma
    @KiwiCatherineJemma Місяць тому +2

    I think the judges (where they are sitting, without a jury) should take at least SOME of the blame.
    When the entirety of the prosecution case is "Computer says "X" UK pounds has gone missing".
    Yet there is literally zero other corroborating evidence, and when an examination of the person's lifestyle shows NO "excess money" (NO flashy car or boat purchases, no expensive house, or gambling addictions etc).
    ...and the person in the dock is saying "I worked honestly, Maybe the computer system, made a mistake"...
    then the judges involved should at least have considered that possibility.
    Also any judge before accepting a "guilty plea" should have asked the defendant if they had had, independent legal advice beforehand.

  • @richardroulstone-roberts8598
    @richardroulstone-roberts8598 Місяць тому +4

    You can see the final inquiry findings, not white washed , but can well imagine its recommendations totally ignored , Hope Mr Bates follows through, and drags Post office, and fujitsu to court.

  • @happytravelling
    @happytravelling Місяць тому +4

    Mr. Bates should go into politics. Being an MP would be appropriate.

  • @Fairplay-ed6rs
    @Fairplay-ed6rs Місяць тому +2

    The whole country wants Paula Vennells jailed and rightly so, but all the rest, from the branch administrators, the fascist investigators, the Post Office board, the accountants, the Fujitsu operators who made the adjustments, the civil servants and the government ministers (Mandelson prince of the dark arts) also must face a jury trial. There will probably be a need to build a new prison to house them all. Lets also not forget the National Federation of Sub postmasters who are paid by the Post Office and advised their members to just pay up. Shut it down and give the Sub postmasters trade union rights.

  • @Twofiddymill
    @Twofiddymill Місяць тому +3

    The govt and PO will not be held accountable…..even if they have a payout….no person will be held accountable….that’s how the law works. A law for them and a law for the people!!

  • @richardsilljohnson6377
    @richardsilljohnson6377 Місяць тому +2

    Maybe I miss something but Horizon is Fujitsu, they seem to be getting off scot free. Sue them as well as the PO

  • @terrystephens1102
    @terrystephens1102 Місяць тому

    As a retired Executive of our local Post Office (Australia Post), I am appalled at the culture of the POL management. Those responsible for this horrendous travesty of justice need to be prosecuted. This scandal is every bit as bad as our Robodebt case where social security recipients were pursued for erroneously calculated over-payments.

  • @DIYTinkerer
    @DIYTinkerer Місяць тому +2

    Everyone wants Justice for what was done, those in charge need long jail sentences, but we all know that will never happen. 😞

  • @normhanson981
    @normhanson981 Місяць тому

    Wonderful man , this country has had it , people in senior positions have so much to answer for.

  • @stellavarley4130
    @stellavarley4130 Місяць тому +1

    Is it any wonder people take the law into their own hands, when justice isn't carried out.

  • @longsighted
    @longsighted Місяць тому +2

    As an electronics engineer, computer scientist, also trained in commercial matters, I ask where did the digital numbers go (digital numbers = money) GO from the sub post offices returns. Who benefitted by the exercise of changing the digital data being transmitted the the central computer memory. If the digits/money was just discarded then for what purpose was the exercise done. There are a lot of questions not being asked that have a science physical basis. Computer systems carrying and storing financial data are just as physical as the old paper systems. At the moment this whole sad fiasco does not make sense, what was the purpose of altering the raw data returns from the sub post offices before final storage in computer memory. WHO BENEFITED BY THE COMPLETE EXERCISE.

  • @michaeltownsend1719
    @michaeltownsend1719 Місяць тому +1

    Burying their head in documents in the hope that everything goes away

  • @johnbaker2
    @johnbaker2 Місяць тому +1

    It’s not really about compensation it’s about the people at the top of the post office being brought to account and being punished for their lies and wrongdoings.
    Paula Vennells should be in prison

  • @Emma-px1nl
    @Emma-px1nl Місяць тому

    Yes Alan!
    Dogged determination to reveal the truth.
    So respect for you Sir.

  • @ericolthwaite8923
    @ericolthwaite8923 Місяць тому +5

    Where are the police?

    • @ChrisM541
      @ChrisM541 Місяць тому

      The justice system is deeply implicated in this too - they are the ones who convicted these postmasters, and the ones who deliberately buried their heads in the face of the obvious pattern developing. They KNEW 'something' wasn't right!

    • @kumasenlac5504
      @kumasenlac5504 Місяць тому

      The what ? Who is this police you speak of ?

  • @tony-leebrizzell2654
    @tony-leebrizzell2654 Місяць тому +14

    What is the King doing to protect the people : there is a hole in the constitutional arrangement

    • @zetectic7968
      @zetectic7968 Місяць тому

      What an ignorant statement.

    • @meganm1074
      @meganm1074 Місяць тому

      The monarchy does not exist to protect the people.