The split is the process he takes to "bring back [Natsuki Subaru]". In Gluttony IF he kills his friends, reads their books of the dead and obtains their memories so he can become [Natsuki Subaru]. However in the main route he decides against this - instead trying to save his friends regardless, in the process he stumbles upon the reason why he loses his memories and reobtains them.
@@Jakez123 ohh thanks that makes me understand the choice he was supposed to take now That's pretty sad,seems like he never accomplished his goal in this if compared to something like pride if
@@theperson5457 The thing is that his goal was never possible at all. He only ever saw himself from the outside; he only saw Subru the hero, he never saw deep enough to realize how little difference there was between them.
In the right Route, Subaru decided ro face the challenge to recover the "Natsuki Subaru" instead of the idea of killing his friends to red their books (murder becomes a habit). IF route aplit at decisions that fkced sh1t up alot, so its a pivotal ppint
@@notori-di5et Yeah Subaru should have realistically snapped mentally in the sage tower and it makes 100% sense. Unlike the other IF routes, gluttony if totally fits in with Subarus "heroism" he's doing all of this in a vain attempt to save everyone. If he only knew how return by death worked or found his book. Maybe he'll get lucky and satella won't update his check point.
@@Steyr32 I think the idea behind the IF stories is that his checkpoints don't get updated if he isn't actively pushing forwards with his goal of saving Emilia. Since Gluttony ends with Subaru killing everyone he's ever loved, his checkpoint would probably still be back before he wandered off.
That's all of them, except maybe Sloth (Or especially Sloth, if you believe the theory that Slothbaru resets back to the Appa Stand after dying of old age)
Gluttony if is definitely the most tragic story Subaru kills everyone he loves in an effort to try to become somone he isn’t only to end up alone forever
@@jackfelt1983 yes but he doesn't know about the checkpoints and the fact that Louis in him Either way by the time he gets all the people he'll be so far from his original self that his name would get eaten again
The worst part about the outcome, he ends up as a schizophrenic who chose to instead live inside the nostalgia of the past, killing everyone in the present but living with them in happiness, inside his own head.
The real tragedy begins when he finally realizes that he was "the same Subaru" from the start and that he destroyed what Subaru wanted to protect from the start and can't fix it. And tragedy reaches its climax when his dream of collecting all the pieces and returning the original Subaru comes true, only to discover that the person he had imagined as a hero was no different from him from the start, he was not a hero in the first place, he couldn't save anyone, he couldn't save the knights from the white whale or the Beetlejuice, He couldn't save Rem... he couldn't be a hero
When I first read this I felt so empty and depressed. Subaru goes on a journey to find himself but we all know he will never achieve that, he believes that he and ‘Natsuki Subaru’ are completely different people even though they are the same. He kills everyone to find himself so he can help them, he is under the impression that ‘Natsuki Subaru’ can make it all better even though the save point most likely has already updated making his actions irreversible. Gluttony If is definitely the most depressing If story
@@willchalloner6643 unfortunately RBD does not take anyone else into account except Subaru that is why when Rem was taken by gluttony Subaru was not able to go back, so with enough time the save point will update
@@lazerbeamkt9646 I’ve heard the opposite RBD seems to care about Subaru and Emilia Or at least Subaru and some goal related to Emilia, possibly making her the Ruler In the Sloth IF where everyone except Subaru and Rem die Tappei said even after decades the save point never updated from the arc 3 appa stand, and in Pride IF Subaru had a permadeath after getting Emilia to become the ruler Meaning there’s a reason Subaru was brought to this world and his save points won’t allow him to permanently stray from it It definitely seems to be linked from Emilia and Subaru (likely due to a link between Satella, the summoner and Emilia- possibly just them being the same person) as remember in arc 3 when Subaru forced himself to say he can return by death to Emilia and she died instead of him, Tappei stated that effect only occurs with Emilia anyone else and Subaru would die
@@willchalloner6643 true, I have heard of that as well. And that it updates according to Subaru’s goals being achieved. So maybe it didn’t update, even so he will not be Subaru if he does go back to the saved point.
@@lazerbeamkt9646 exactly Honestly it would be interesting seeing how gluttony Subaru would handle arc 6 and 7 once he’s done killing everyone that ever knew him
Yeah Im REALLY hoping for some OVAs between seasons 2&3. Sloth especially. I know there's issues with White Fox atm but, I can't see Kadokawa letting a cash cow like Re:Zero go to waste just because of studio drama.
Otto would be like: I saw that when you attacked just now your eyes moved .5 degrees to the left and you started breathing 0.0001 percent faster when you started moving. I can also see that your arm doesn’t have full range of motion during your attack against us but when i look at your arm i see no injuries so in the three seconds you attacked us I had to think about why you did these things and I came to the Conclusion that you have a scar 3 inches under your left armpit which is your weakness which is how we will defeat you
Even Echidna wasn't able to "sense" Otto or whatever she does to know almost everything. That is why he isn't in the Book of Wisdom. Otto is the final villain lol.
Haha yea I misspoke, what I actually meant was that she didn’t have a goal or anything, she was a blank slate except for having information regarding the watchtower. normally spirits tend to have a goal or purpose (puck protecting Emilia, Beatrice with the library), but echidna had nothing.
This if is so underrated. Its like a beautiful skyscraper gets absolutely smacked to ground right as it gets completed. And when you realize that said skyscrapper will never complete itself and keep trying so as he withers away its just pure pain.
You know I wanted to be spoiled and I thought “how bad could it be I already read up to where regulus was killed” but hearing Julius got his name eaten made me rethink my decision, be back in a bit
Omg tsugihagu is probably my favorite IF story now. Subaru doesnt have the gluttony witch factor in the current story because he didnt defeat that archbishop right? From what i understand you gotta defeat the archbishop to take in their witch factor... Didnt ram defeat lye?
This was the only if story I read thus far and I feel it's very and good. Its also aligned with Subaru character perfectly. So his hair change due to beako past( some things never changes).
@@truckkun4827 to me wrath was also pretty sad. Idk any route where subaru doesn’t do anything on his own bothers me cuz in pride he had help but the man planned and was forced to be involved Although I do enjoy wrath having him become a big man even if he was just a “tool” let allowed to life for his ideology
@@jackfelt1983 mhm yeah but he kinda does also plan on wrath (killing Roswell and kidnapping Emilia) but honestly isn’t the whole series kinda sad, while there are times it’s pretty wholesome. I really enjoyed Subaru becoming the purge king and his two subordinate were probably some of my favorite characters. I do support Else X Subaru ship tho
@@truckkun4827 I think the Gluttony If is the best story so far Because out all the if stories Subaru doesn't rely on or use return by death He accomplished all of his goals with out restarting It also seem that he's using his delusion as some kind of a deduction ability that's pretty resourceful lol Also Shaula x Subaru for the win
so from what i can gather, gluttony if is extremely complicated. Except for the fact that he just wants to become THE subaru and ends up killing everyone
You know what this video let me thinking in this If story Louis Arneb basically completed her goal of making Subaru a different person in order for her steal his body/witch factor
not really, since he didnt read reid book again, they kinda merged together in a weird way resulting in a subaru with influences from louis but he is in control, not her since she is traumatized in his head just like the canon story (after all to kill his friends he rbd a lot too)
@@doublehit9165 and thus Louise being a plot hole in this İF story... And most she became a witch factor because I do not remember anything about merging. And did he even RbD? Even if he did I am sure he didn't after some point.
@@starmegalo1770 to clarify it. Louis has the form of a witch gene and she is inside subaru. But she can pop up and possess him as seen in the main story. Here she doesnt do that because after subaru used rbd a bit of times in order to kill all of his friends in the right order she was traumatized. However her being inside him as a witch gene corrupted his personality just by existing. And we have the disturbed subaur personality of the glottony if
@@starmegalo1770 its not a theory because all of the infos can be acquired from arc6 now that its finished. and yes, its not the witch gene that strictly make him mad, its louis living inside him that influences him. in a similar fashio as anastasia and echidna relationship or roswald 2 personalities and so on
I love how all of the If stories really explore the idea of what happens if a person falls into each sin. Suberu was never satiated and needed to know who he was, which lead him to killing everyone, but if he was contempt with at least still being alive he could’ve saved himself. I think it shows you can never have everything, so trying to ends in corruption.
In the world of Re:Zero, does anyone ever question why Subaru is able to remember people who everyone else completely forgets? Us fans are aware that it is probably because of Return By Death, but does anyone in the world of Re:Zero question that?
Yeah , some people question it but didn't get anywhere with it . And re zero world place is a world where everyone minds there own business 😐. For example:- Arc 6 Ana asked Subaru some serious question, want to know what questions read arc 6 then.
"Subaru, how do you remember people that were erased?" "Sorry, idk." "Oh...dang, alright then." The problem is that Subaru himself doesn't know, so even if they did question him, its not like they could get an answer. Even if he did know, he would probably just brush it off like "Ah don't worry about it"
Its not because of RbD, it's because of Flugel, All Authorities are made by Subaru himself, so as their original owner, their effectives diminishes towards him, because obviously, they belong to him, He can see Sloth's Unseen Hands He can remember Gluttony's Eating Greed is not known but the assumption is that Lion's heart wouldn't work with Subaru His emotions towards Wrath's authority doesn't sync Lust's is also unknown Envy is Himself
@@6601 with lust he didnt get affected by the curse much. And well the first time he met the sin archbishop of wrath he did get affected by her authority. So thats incorrect
maybe its because the sheer amount of knowledge beatrice had from 400 years went into his head in around a few hours causing a large amount of stress and making his hair go white, the best thing i can think of so its most likely
It was because of the stress she was under during those 400 years of solitude. When Subaru finished her book he hit his head repeatedly against a wall causing his left eye to lose its sight.
@@nintendoROX121 your losing color of the hair is also connected with mental stress which can be built with accumulated years of experience, although genetics usually holds the strongest upper hand in this outcome, I'm pretty sure such an extended amount of years like what Betty lived would be more than enough to make his soul and hair as weary and white as could be.
This IF route is imo the most messed up one. He didnt understand the potential of his power. And because of that simple thing it went a completely different route. Im glad Subaru's personality in the main story is different from the IF's Subaru personality
Even if he killed everyone in his plan and found Satella didn't update his save point (meaning he could go back to before he killed everyone) this still won't work...
mhm I feel like a good point to mention for this Subaru is that he actually believed after he patched together and completed 'Natsuki Subaru' he could just use RBD and start over again and now the complete hero Subaru will save everyone.. in a way this kinda at least made him have some logic to why he kills people and doesn't care, its because he Knows complete Subaru will save them after he successfully patches complete Subaru
I’m honestly hoping for a Reinhardt vs Subaru fight in the eventual felt camp arc even if it’s as a joke. Like Reinhardt jokingly attempts to pull his dragon sword while looking at Subaru but to his surprise it is drawn which make Reinhardt now suspicious of Subaru.
I think the first trial is an issue _even if_ you're from Earth. I doubt the average person is a constellation nut like Subaru, so his convenient choice of hobby really helps here. Am I wrong? Let me know if people in your country can identify stars on sight like Subaru. All I know is that Sirius is hot (the star, not the character) and that the North Star points north.
@@RoanoraZoro123 Yes. Jakez claimed the trial would be difficult for someone that wasn't from Earth, my point was that it would be difficult for anyone that isn't _Subaru_ specifically, regardless of wether or not they were born or isekai'd into Re;Zero.
@@TheJoethud22 I doubt it most of the current gen are just smart phone toddlers and pc junkies who would have never spent time looking at the night sky.
@@TheJoethud22 I know Big Dipper, but the trial was about Orion. Even when it comes to the Big Dipper, I only know the name and vaguely recognise ''connect the dots'' shape. I don't recall the backstory or meaning behind the Big Dipper, nor do I remember any of the names of its individual star dots. If you suddenly locked me in a tower without warning, threatened to kill me if I attempted escaping, pop-quizzed me with some riddle with the answer being one of Big Dipper's stars then yeah, I'm confident I would fail that test.
I've only heard/seen bits and pieces of Re:Zero, but the IF stories have been something that really intrigued me. With my limited understanding, I think I might see a parallel between the Gluttony IF and the Pride IF story: both are essentially "missing" when Subaru calls for help from the guards at the very beginning. In the Pride IF, Subaru is too stubborn to call for help and struggles to beat the thugs on his own, and this completely alters his path. In the Gluttony IF, he did call for help, but Subaru's method of "becoming complete" after losing his memory goes astray because the _only_ major character who could have had a memory of this moment in their "book of the dead" was (to my limited knowledge) _Reinhard,_ someone Subaru is unable to kill. Subaru can do as many loops to get as many books of the dead he wants, but without Reinhard's book, he will never regain the memory of the _very first important decision he made_ that went missing from his memory, and without that memory, he will never truly understand the "Subaru" that he is trying to emulate, because this very first action had consequences that reverberated through his entire journey (as seen in the Pride IF). Now, I could be completely wrong because I know so little about the series, but maybe you'll find it interesting?
You are correct, he would also never regain the memory of meeting Emilia because no one remembers that but the original Subaru. The very first loop was also very important when it came to how he felt about Emilia.
mhm this Subaru seems to be actually able to kill reinhard with the help of shaula and the information the tower provided.. and considering his declaration he is absolutely confident he could do it
Let me just tell you bro, no, that is not the reason, it's more of the people that he will kill only saw the Subaru that saves them at the right time, this anomaly. This amnesiac Subaru won't remember the times where he did die and looped back in time, it's where the original Subaru grew the most, the so called "loops" but no one know that except the original "Natsuki Subaru" So this amnesiac Subaru will NEVER complete himself, NEVER. If you have read the original timeline, you will know why ( related to the sin archbishop of gluttony and that no one knows and has knowledge of what the loops are and how Subaru reacted to each of the 23 loops) but I must say, a very great parallel indeed. As an avid fan of the series, I highly approve of it's thought-provokeness. Nonetheless, I do confirm it to be false, the facts are at the top
10/10 IF story easily my favourite out all of them, love the themes, Subaru's character, the tragic acts, everything.. tho I would've like more Character dialogue from other character that's important to subaru like wilhelm
I love your videos. And I don't mind a summary version of spoilers since its not voicelines it exact words so that way I can still get the full effect even if I know most of whats gonna happen.
Ngl re zero is the second anime i never want to be spoiled the first was food wars for the plot and also the "plot" if you know what im saying but still after the first 16 seconds i dipped probs gonna watch this vid in like 4 years after season 4 is out
Yeah, bro. This is a mystery Anime that heavily relies on your first time experience and using your head and digging up evidence from what you've seen.
@@danielantony1882 yup i agree kinda got spoiled for one part of season 2 and regreted it so yeah im gonna wait for the anime to catch up so i can watch this video
wellll the content of arc 5 and 6 which are presented in this video might be adapted into the just confirmed s3, its extremely likely the season will end specifically on where this if story diverged....or you can just read
People are pointing out how his method of revival won’t work as he’s destroying all he valued to regain his values Another flaw is that no matter what he would never be complete, he’ll never be able to gain the critical loops in his character that failed Die to this he’ll only ever see Subaru’s success never the failings that forged them
It's weird that he never came across Natsuki Subarus book of the dead in the pledies watch tower. He's been killing people left and right and searching for their books of the dead, but still can't find his own book of the dead
To this day I still wonder If Reinhard can't get past Sands Time even with his 80 percent Yin Magic Resistance, then wouldn't that mean that Flugel can win against Reinhard by default via placing Reinhard under a spell on the same level as Sands Time like a Tsukuyomi or something
Yes, except that magic doesn't 'activate' in Reinhardt's presence. Check out his abilities, but basically as he's loved by the spirits, all the mana required goes to him. Dude's a walking magic EMP.
@@omnipayne861 I forgot if its divine protection or what, but he is loved by mana itself that all mana around him gets to him. That's why people around him can't use magic
I need to say, i LOVE your voice! And my feelings for gluttony if Is mixed. I really love it my second favorite if story, however i also hate it the most of all if story it's really mixed
It’s interesting how every arc has had an IF route (minus arc 5, but that arc doesn’t have any real points of divergence for Subaru). Will we be getting one for arc 7 in the future? I haven’t caught up to the most recent chapters, but has anyone seen any potential IF route divergence points?
Gladiator island if he had survived Todd attack and didn't rbs to solve everything that probably the divergence. He probably just end up like todd since he was comparing himself with him and he will be terrified of dying plus he will lose all his memories beako will probably die same with Emilia since ceci did not save her
btw. i strongly think Emila turns into Satella by the end. because "Emilia is the only person affected by this penalty of Return By Death, with no explanation to why this is." this is because Satella gave Return by death to Subaru in order to change the past and stop Emilia from turning into Satella. However, Subaru says he will save her instead. so that is why Satella only kills Emilia when he tries to tell her. plus they have the same voice actor. and is said that she is "born from the same cursed blood as the Witch" as well as calling her "the descendant of the Witch". born from the same cursed blood. literally THE SAME BLOOD. the same mother. and the descendant is due to their striking similarity. which is because they are THE SAME PERSON. and something in the story will make Emilia become Satella. And if Subaru is Flugel. then perhaps this has happened before. and Subaru is being "summoned" to the world of rezero over and over. and is every Isekai'ed person in its history, and if a Subaru comes in contact with himself the penalty of Return By Death will kick in. since rezero likes toying with alternate timelines. what if every isekai'ed person is Subaru, reset from coming out of the Convenience store each time. and since black-haired people are "rare". its probably only Subaru's lineage. so basically Elsa is a direct descendant of one of the Subaru's selves. I think im a pretty big brain here. by reading between the lines. we are still missing vital information. but it might have to do with what the witch cult is trying to acomplish. and that vault pandora wanted to open. its all tied to Emilia.
200 IQ those are my thoughts too Except the elsa part thats definitely bigbrain tho But u left a plot hole i don't think the penalty of return by death activates when he meets him self
@@AMR_k400 yeah i too thought that too, it has no basis. but if Al is a version of Subaru or the son of a subaru. why wouldn't he speak up to Subaru since he has black hair.
@@AMR_k400 do you ever think Subaru will return to Earth with his memories intact? by the end. what if in the final confrontation with Satella, she just yeets him away, back to Earth. lol
Tho even if he kills everyone that knows him he still cant get memories that he experienced alone.. His view of point.. So he'll never recover all of his memories
Really interesting what would happen after he dies. It's ultimately up to Satella to decide, but we know fuck all how she does it. Will she be mad at Subaru and move the savepoint out of spite? Or will she keep it in place because that's what Subaru would want?
@@Steyr32Is the green room spirit still there? Maybe that has something to do with it. Or Louis just absorbs his mana. Since beatrice is dead he can use/ contract with other spirits
Im at 21 minutes atm: From what i get from this is that the witchfactor of gluttony makes you feel as if you are never complete, always hungry for more to complete yourself but you are never satiated as gluttony has no limit. Thats pretty fking evil. Since Lye Batenkaitos knows soo many techniques from the people he has eaten im going to guess his form of gluttony is learning/stealing the techniques of the ones he eats. Subaru's (following the same logic) would be the completion of himself.
That subaru wont be completed subaru even tho he kill everyone and live their entire life, he only see the results of his successful route but he will never see the process of died over and over to make it right
This is a great if, but there is something I don't get. Why could Subaru leave the Pleiades Watchtower? I thought he couldn't until he finished the trials. My guess is he did finish the trials somehow and therefore screwed himself because that might have updated his checkpoint depending on what the condition for his checkpoints truly is.
Wait so is the amnesia thing the event that split the path?
The split is the process he takes to "bring back [Natsuki Subaru]". In Gluttony IF he kills his friends, reads their books of the dead and obtains their memories so he can become [Natsuki Subaru]. However in the main route he decides against this - instead trying to save his friends regardless, in the process he stumbles upon the reason why he loses his memories and reobtains them.
@@Jakez123 ohh thanks that makes me understand the choice he was supposed to take now
That's pretty sad,seems like he never accomplished his goal in this if compared to something like pride if
@@theperson5457
The thing is that his goal was never possible at all. He only ever saw himself from the outside; he only saw Subru the hero, he never saw deep enough to realize how little difference there was between them.
This if tory is soo confusing
In the right Route, Subaru decided ro face the challenge to recover the "Natsuki Subaru" instead of the idea of killing his friends to red their books (murder becomes a habit). IF route aplit at decisions that fkced sh1t up alot, so its a pivotal ppint
Man, every IF story is basically if Subaru took a nuclear approach to an already terrible situation.
Sloth and Lust Looks Pretty Decent.
Sloth feels completely different from the original story.
And Lust Is just him having a harem.
@@yuripaelden419 sloth is the rem route and lust is just him bein an isekai protag
@@yuripaelden419 isn't lust if just a prank and not an actual if route
@@yuripaelden419 we never speak of lust if
@@nahthisaintit yeah, it was deleted a day after being posted to fuck with readers.
Imagine anyone else reading subaru's book and trying to keep their sanity.
We are reading it... It's call Re:Zero.
@@charly5245 well his memories arent exactly beamed into our head. Seems a bit differrent.
lmao Gluttony Sin Archbishop cannot even endure 2X death. Imagine someone reads the book of Subaru (Pride if or Greed if version)
that means i get to see the whole re:zero before its written
Funny thing, for each Death, a new book is created.
So Subaru's gonna fill the entire library with his books
It’s actually terrifying how close the main story came to going down this route.
I mean it the best if route and Tappei tweet considering it to make it the main route but just think reader not gonna enjoy how things go
@@notori-di5et Yeah Subaru should have realistically snapped mentally in the sage tower and it makes 100% sense.
Unlike the other IF routes, gluttony if totally fits in with Subarus "heroism" he's doing all of this in a vain attempt to save everyone.
If he only knew how return by death worked or found his book. Maybe he'll get lucky and satella won't update his check point.
@@Steyr32 I think the idea behind the IF stories is that his checkpoints don't get updated if he isn't actively pushing forwards with his goal of saving Emilia. Since Gluttony ends with Subaru killing everyone he's ever loved, his checkpoint would probably still be back before he wandered off.
@@notori-di5et Tbh, it doesn't make sense if Subaru snapped here. Realistically, Subaru would be lost because of what was going on.
@@Steyr32 but killing everyone that loves him isn't realistic
Ah yes, the story that gives you depression after you read it. Definitely one of the best if stories.
how can gives you depression? you get more shaula times :) ( i skip the bad parts since i'm more interested in seeing subaru shaula dinamics explored)
lol
Isn't that just the whole of re zero
That's all of them, except maybe Sloth (Or especially Sloth, if you believe the theory that Slothbaru resets back to the Appa Stand after dying of old age)
@@CABRALFAN27 lmao that'd be funny but considering what happened at the end of pride I'm not too sure though who knows to be honest
Gluttony if is definitely the most tragic story
Subaru kills everyone he loves in an effort to try to become somone he isn’t only to end up alone forever
the problem subaru isn't complete in the first place witch which make this more sad
People have told me he’s doing this to make subaru fix it so he doesn’t understand how his power works
@@jackfelt1983 yes but he doesn't know about the checkpoints and the fact that Louis in him
Either way by the time he gets all the people he'll be so far from his original self that his name would get eaten again
It would probably be greed if for me
The worst part about the outcome, he ends up as a schizophrenic who chose to instead live inside the nostalgia of the past, killing everyone in the present but living with them in happiness, inside his own head.
The real tragedy begins when he finally realizes that he was "the same Subaru" from the start and that he destroyed what Subaru wanted to protect from the start and can't fix it. And tragedy reaches its climax when his dream of collecting all the pieces and returning the original Subaru comes true, only to discover that the person he had imagined as a hero was no different from him from the start, he was not a hero in the first place, he couldn't save anyone, he couldn't save the knights from the white whale or the Beetlejuice, He couldn't save Rem... he couldn't be a hero
True and what's worse is that he won't remember any of the other loops he's been in
I would like to taste some beetlejuice
@@cannibalman8175 I would like to sip some romanae con-tea
I can't imagine how people unironically call Petelgeuse as Beetle Juice.
He's insane, is obessed with a book, travels with a re zero wifu who does whatever he says and has heterochromia. Imaginary Roswaal must be proud.
He's blind in one eye though.
@@CheshireDCat Imaginary Roswaal:"A small price to pay for salvation"
@@CheshireDCat close enough
@@CheshireDCat look cooler
Roswaal is already proud
When I first read this I felt so empty and depressed.
Subaru goes on a journey to find himself but we all know he will never achieve that, he believes that he and ‘Natsuki Subaru’ are completely different people even though they are the same. He kills everyone to find himself so he can help them, he is under the impression that ‘Natsuki Subaru’ can make it all better even though the save point most likely has already updated making his actions irreversible.
Gluttony If is definitely the most depressing If story
Well if Emilia is dead then maybe the save point hasn’t updated like in Sloth?
@@willchalloner6643 unfortunately RBD does not take anyone else into account except Subaru that is why when Rem was taken by gluttony Subaru was not able to go back, so with enough time the save point will update
@@lazerbeamkt9646 I’ve heard the opposite
RBD seems to care about Subaru and Emilia
Or at least Subaru and some goal related to Emilia, possibly making her the Ruler
In the Sloth IF where everyone except Subaru and Rem die Tappei said even after decades the save point never updated from the arc 3 appa stand, and in Pride IF Subaru had a permadeath after getting Emilia to become the ruler
Meaning there’s a reason Subaru was brought to this world and his save points won’t allow him to permanently stray from it
It definitely seems to be linked from Emilia and Subaru (likely due to a link between Satella, the summoner and Emilia- possibly just them being the same person) as remember in arc 3 when Subaru forced himself to say he can return by death to Emilia and she died instead of him, Tappei stated that effect only occurs with Emilia anyone else and Subaru would die
@@willchalloner6643 true, I have heard of that as well. And that it updates according to Subaru’s goals being achieved. So maybe it didn’t update, even so he will not be Subaru if he does go back to the saved point.
@@lazerbeamkt9646 exactly
Honestly it would be interesting seeing how gluttony Subaru would handle arc 6 and 7 once he’s done killing everyone that ever knew him
Subaru has greater potential for evil than he does for good.
All of the If routes can easily be their own OVAs.
Or maybe a spin off series just like how fate adapted their Spin offs
That's probably the plan once the canon story has been completed or covered enough in anime .
@@jadeorbigoso5212 They're not long enough fo spin-offs. Only for OVA's or movies.
Yeah Im REALLY hoping for some OVAs between seasons 2&3. Sloth especially. I know there's issues with White Fox atm but, I can't see Kadokawa letting a cash cow like Re:Zero go to waste just because of studio drama.
Literally the one of the if routes with good endings is the one with rem or the deleted one where re zero gets hentai plot
Betty thinks this video is great, in fact.
Oya Oya
Anatawa
TAIDA DESUNE!!!😀😀😀
かしら
I Suppose
Betty is right, I suppose
@@cannibalman8175 かしら
otto is lowkey the most dangerous person in re zero
Cuz he’s unpredictable. He can turn the tides with in seconds.
Yeah he's one of my favorite Characters
Otto would be like: I saw that when you attacked just now your eyes moved .5 degrees to the left and you started breathing 0.0001 percent faster when you started moving. I can also see that your arm doesn’t have full range of motion during your attack against us but when i look at your arm i see no injuries so in the three seconds you attacked us I had to think about why you did these things and I came to the Conclusion that you have a scar 3 inches under your left armpit which is your weakness which is how we will defeat you
Why
Even Echidna wasn't able to "sense" Otto or whatever she does to know almost everything. That is why he isn't in the Book of Wisdom. Otto is the final villain lol.
Everybody gangster until subaru gets white hair and a byakugan
@Diavolo Jaegar If Subaru had the sharingan he would be op due to the ammount of suffering he endured
@@alinastanescu4430 dude would have fucking mangekyo sharingan version 100000
Pretty sure nobody has memories from before they are born
Reincarnation
Spirits are dead beings usually they have their memory from the time they were still alive
Roswaal has
Its all a matter of perspective
Haha yea I misspoke, what I actually meant was that she didn’t have a goal or anything, she was a blank slate except for having information regarding the watchtower. normally spirits tend to have a goal or purpose (puck protecting Emilia, Beatrice with the library), but echidna had nothing.
This if is so underrated. Its like a beautiful skyscraper gets absolutely smacked to ground right as it gets completed. And when you realize that said skyscrapper will never complete itself and keep trying so as he withers away its just pure pain.
I remember reading this IF Story about 2 years ago or so and I just very empty in the inside after reading it supposedly........
You know I wanted to be spoiled and I thought “how bad could it be I already read up to where regulus was killed” but hearing Julius got his name eaten made me rethink my decision, be back in a bit
Lmao same for me I reached the 2nd trial in the Watchtower
Same had to finish all if arc 6 to come back to this
Here are the timestamps:
0:00 Arc 5/6 Required Information
14:17 Gluttony IF Summary
34:22 Tappei's Trivia for Gluttony IF
Thank you Jake! Seriously, all this is appreciated.
Jakez can you try making a Tappei qna answers that so far turned out false? I think people give way too much credit to qnas.
Omg tsugihagu is probably my favorite IF story now. Subaru doesnt have the gluttony witch factor in the current story because he didnt defeat that archbishop right? From what i understand you gotta defeat the archbishop to take in their witch factor... Didnt ram defeat lye?
Old man ROMs origin
This was the only if story I read thus far and I feel it's very and good. Its also aligned with Subaru character perfectly. So his hair change due to beako past( some things never changes).
The pride route was my personal favorite. I think you’d have some interest
I recommend the wrath route, it is basically my favorite and really dark
@@truckkun4827 to me wrath was also pretty sad. Idk any route where subaru doesn’t do anything on his own bothers me cuz in pride he had help but the man planned and was forced to be involved
Although I do enjoy wrath having him become a big man even if he was just a “tool” let allowed to life for his ideology
@@jackfelt1983 mhm yeah but he kinda does also plan on wrath (killing Roswell and kidnapping Emilia) but honestly isn’t the whole series kinda sad, while there are times it’s pretty wholesome.
I really enjoyed Subaru becoming the purge king and his two subordinate were probably some of my favorite characters.
I do support Else X Subaru ship tho
@@truckkun4827 I think the Gluttony If is the best story so far
Because out all the if stories Subaru doesn't rely on or use return by death
He accomplished all of his goals with out restarting
It also seem that he's using his delusion as some kind of a deduction ability
that's pretty resourceful lol
Also Shaula x Subaru for the win
I wish Tappei would redo the Lust IF story and make it in line with the others.
I have a theory the true Lust story is coming. It's going to be the last test for Subaru.
so from what i can gather, gluttony if is extremely complicated. Except for the fact that he just wants to become THE subaru and ends up killing everyone
Can't wait for you to do the other ifs always loved when other re zero tubers did it now my favorite one is doing it!
"Murder becomes a habit"
Let’s hope this doesn’t get taken down
yeah
Yeah
Yeah
Yeah
@@Eye777-g4i Ayoo my alt self
You know what this video let me thinking in this If story Louis Arneb basically completed her goal of making Subaru a different person in order for her steal his body/witch factor
not really, since he didnt read reid book again, they kinda merged together in a weird way resulting in a subaru with influences from louis but he is in control, not her since she is traumatized in his head just like the canon story (after all to kill his friends he rbd a lot too)
@@doublehit9165 and thus Louise being a plot hole in this İF story... And most she became a witch factor because I do not remember anything about merging.
And did he even RbD? Even if he did I am sure he didn't after some point.
@@starmegalo1770 to clarify it. Louis has the form of a witch gene and she is inside subaru. But she can pop up and possess him as seen in the main story. Here she doesnt do that because after subaru used rbd a bit of times in order to kill all of his friends in the right order she was traumatized. However her being inside him as a witch gene corrupted his personality just by existing. And we have the disturbed subaur personality of the glottony if
@@doublehit9165 is this your theory or confirmed? Because witch factors don't make Subaru mad.
@@starmegalo1770 its not a theory because all of the infos can be acquired from arc6 now that its finished. and yes, its not the witch gene that strictly make him mad, its louis living inside him that influences him. in a similar fashio as anastasia and echidna relationship or roswald 2 personalities and so on
I love how all of the If stories really explore the idea of what happens if a person falls into each sin. Suberu was never satiated and needed to know who he was, which lead him to killing everyone, but if he was contempt with at least still being alive he could’ve saved himself. I think it shows you can never have everything, so trying to ends in corruption.
Great video, I’m glad you put in the extra information so anime only could listen and understand as well
In the world of Re:Zero, does anyone ever question why Subaru is able to remember people who everyone else completely forgets? Us fans are aware that it is probably because of Return By Death, but does anyone in the world of Re:Zero question that?
Yeah , some people question it but didn't get anywhere with it . And re zero world place is a world where everyone minds there own business 😐. For example:- Arc 6 Ana asked Subaru some serious question, want to know what questions read arc 6 then.
"Subaru, how do you remember people that were erased?"
"Sorry, idk."
"Oh...dang, alright then."
The problem is that Subaru himself doesn't know, so even if they did question him, its not like they could get an answer. Even if he did know, he would probably just brush it off like "Ah don't worry about it"
Its not because of RbD, it's because of Flugel, All Authorities are made by Subaru himself, so as their original owner, their effectives diminishes towards him, because obviously, they belong to him,
He can see Sloth's Unseen Hands
He can remember Gluttony's Eating
Greed is not known but the assumption is that Lion's heart wouldn't work with Subaru
His emotions towards Wrath's authority doesn't sync
Lust's is also unknown
Envy is Himself
@@6601 I'd say it's more because Satella ate the witches.
@@6601 with lust he didnt get affected by the curse much. And well the first time he met the sin archbishop of wrath he did get affected by her authority. So thats incorrect
I rewatched this today, still love this IF route so much.
One of the most dangerous Subaru of all time, I love this IF Story
Did Subaru's hair turn white from Beatrice because she had hundreds of years worth of memories?
Is your hair connected to your mind so it's the only thing that ages when you view 400 years worth of memories?
maybe its because the sheer amount of knowledge beatrice had from 400 years went into his head in around a few hours causing a large amount of stress and making his hair go white, the best thing i can think of so its most likely
It was because of the stress she was under during those 400 years of solitude. When Subaru finished her book he hit his head repeatedly against a wall causing his left eye to lose its sight.
@@nintendoROX121 It turned white because of sheer stress. That happens to people occasionally when they are stressed.
@@nintendoROX121 your losing color of the hair is also connected with mental stress which can be built with accumulated years of experience, although genetics usually holds the strongest upper hand in this outcome, I'm pretty sure such an extended amount of years like what Betty lived would be more than enough to make his soul and hair as weary and white as could be.
How many Loli's does Roswall have locked up in His Basement?
Meili is the only one we know about
Well not more than subaru has.
How many breads have you eaten in your life?
@@zeno.7519 flat bread, naan bread Tiger loaf bun, hotdog roll bagels baget hamburger buns pita bread. Split tin rolls. Sour dough.
@Diavolo Jaegar "how many" is asking for number so it isn't really
this was amazingly well written!
I was waiting for this
Thank you very much ❤️
Words cant describe how good you videos are, but numbers can
10/10
Thanks Jake
It was a very entertaining summary
I loved it
This IF route is imo the most messed up one. He didnt understand the potential of his power. And because of that simple thing it went a completely different route. Im glad Subaru's personality in the main story is different from the IF's Subaru personality
Yea somehow being dumbass naive not taking the obvious choice make him better
What a chonker of a video, gluttony IF has to be my top pick keep up the content!
Even if he killed everyone in his plan and found Satella didn't update his save point (meaning he could go back to before he killed everyone) this still won't work...
Thank you for sharing! I learning quite lots this way!
Amazing video. I like how you put Arc 5 - 6 information before the actual if story started. It was refreshing listenig it again after a long time.
mhm I feel like a good point to mention for this Subaru is that he actually believed after he patched together and completed 'Natsuki Subaru' he could just use RBD and start over again and now the complete hero Subaru will save everyone.. in a way this kinda at least made him have some logic to why he kills people and doesn't care, its because he Knows complete Subaru will save them after he successfully patches complete Subaru
Speak of the devil. I was just watching your Flugel X Pandora theory I can't believe I'd be watching another hehe nice vids!
This is actually heartbreaking to watch...
I’m honestly hoping for a Reinhardt vs Subaru fight in the eventual felt camp arc even if it’s as a joke. Like Reinhardt jokingly attempts to pull his dragon sword while looking at Subaru but to his surprise it is drawn which make Reinhardt now suspicious of Subaru.
Reinhard probably knows everything about Subaru.
Reinhardt is not omniscient. Even in pride if Reinhardt still doesn't pull out his sword.
This one is my favorite for sure.
I think the first trial is an issue _even if_ you're from Earth. I doubt the average person is a constellation nut like Subaru, so his convenient choice of hobby really helps here. Am I wrong? Let me know if people in your country can identify stars on sight like Subaru. All I know is that Sirius is hot (the star, not the character) and that the North Star points north.
Subaru was interested in stars because he had the name of a constellation and no other reason.
@@RoanoraZoro123 Yes. Jakez claimed the trial would be difficult for someone that wasn't from Earth, my point was that it would be difficult for anyone that isn't _Subaru_ specifically, regardless of wether or not they were born or isekai'd into Re;Zero.
That depends
What was the trail
Again like I’m sure everyone knows the Big Dipper and that man looking dude
@@TheJoethud22 I doubt it most of the current gen are just smart phone toddlers and pc junkies who would have never spent time looking at the night sky.
@@TheJoethud22 I know Big Dipper, but the trial was about Orion. Even when it comes to the Big Dipper, I only know the name and vaguely recognise ''connect the dots'' shape. I don't recall the backstory or meaning behind the Big Dipper, nor do I remember any of the names of its individual star dots.
If you suddenly locked me in a tower without warning, threatened to kill me if I attempted escaping, pop-quizzed me with some riddle with the answer being one of Big Dipper's stars then yeah, I'm confident I would fail that test.
Thanks so much being so hard-working!!!
Man i love the Design of Tsugihagu Subaru.
Thx if been waiting for the longest time
Great job as usual
Another wonderful video! I'm pissed, despite having you bell notified I didn't get a notification for this video.
I've only heard/seen bits and pieces of Re:Zero, but the IF stories have been something that really intrigued me. With my limited understanding, I think I might see a parallel between the Gluttony IF and the Pride IF story: both are essentially "missing" when Subaru calls for help from the guards at the very beginning. In the Pride IF, Subaru is too stubborn to call for help and struggles to beat the thugs on his own, and this completely alters his path. In the Gluttony IF, he did call for help, but Subaru's method of "becoming complete" after losing his memory goes astray because the _only_ major character who could have had a memory of this moment in their "book of the dead" was (to my limited knowledge) _Reinhard,_ someone Subaru is unable to kill.
Subaru can do as many loops to get as many books of the dead he wants, but without Reinhard's book, he will never regain the memory of the _very first important decision he made_ that went missing from his memory, and without that memory, he will never truly understand the "Subaru" that he is trying to emulate, because this very first action had consequences that reverberated through his entire journey (as seen in the Pride IF). Now, I could be completely wrong because I know so little about the series, but maybe you'll find it interesting?
You are correct, he would also never regain the memory of meeting Emilia because no one remembers that but the original Subaru. The very first loop was also very important when it came to how he felt about Emilia.
mhm this Subaru seems to be actually able to kill reinhard with the help of shaula and the information the tower provided.. and considering his declaration he is absolutely confident he could do it
Let me just tell you bro, no, that is not the reason, it's more of the people that he will kill only saw the Subaru that saves them at the right time, this anomaly. This amnesiac Subaru won't remember the times where he did die and looped back in time, it's where the original Subaru grew the most, the so called "loops" but no one know that except the original "Natsuki Subaru" So this amnesiac Subaru will NEVER complete himself, NEVER. If you have read the original timeline, you will know why ( related to the sin archbishop of gluttony and that no one knows and has knowledge of what the loops are and how Subaru reacted to each of the 23 loops) but I must say, a very great parallel indeed. As an avid fan of the series, I highly approve of it's thought-provokeness. Nonetheless, I do confirm it to be false, the facts are at the top
imagine they walk into the library and there is just 100s of books for subaru
10/10 IF story easily my favourite out all of them, love the themes, Subaru's character, the tragic acts, everything.. tho I would've like more Character dialogue from other character that's important to subaru like wilhelm
Let's hope that all the if storys gonna become animated 😲😲
Unless they start doing OVA's soon. It's honestly doubtful.
I'd certainly love it though, I mean at least manga adaptations would be nice.
I need manga of this route 😞
Thank you sir. For this video. Please do more like this
This one was definitely my favorite to read
Wew, this one was super dark, huh? PEAK FICTION
I love your videos. And I don't mind a summary version of spoilers since its not voicelines it exact words so that way I can still get the full effect even if I know most of whats gonna happen.
So this strays from canon at the one loop where he tries to hide his amnesia?
Yea
... imagine how almost every little shit can effect subaru's decisions and just makes an if story... thats how thin the ice is...
Thank you for the video it was fantastic
I love how this doubles as a summary of arc 5 and 6 lul
Fr as well as an if story its the best ever
Imagine if the main story line is actually "If envy".
It is.
@@Jakez123 Re:Zero is wild
Author has literally confirmed this before if I heard correctly
Reinhart never gets a break huh
Subaru is probably one of the best written character ever
Subaru definitely already meet satella in ancient time and she fell in love with him.
And I thought wrath and pride ifs were sad then this one is just a gut punch to the feelings
Y'all ready for depression
11:28 why was I holding back laughter
Just finished arc 6 and can finally watch this😮💨
Same
the best part is the audio, having audio from steins gate and clips from re zero, great to see the combination of my 2 favorite animes
Love this intro, wish more UA-camrs would account for people who want to have the info without getting it the hard way
Today is my birthday and you made my day
thank you Jakez
Great job :@
This art is amazing ❤❤
I think Otto is like "Hero-Natsuki Subaru"，this Subaru never believe a normal human can be a hero ，the real reason he kill Otto.
Ngl re zero is the second anime i never want to be spoiled the first was food wars for the plot and also the "plot" if you know what im saying but still after the first 16 seconds i dipped probs gonna watch this vid in like 4 years after season 4 is out
Yeah, bro. This is a mystery Anime that heavily relies on your first time experience and using your head and digging up evidence from what you've seen.
@@danielantony1882 yup i agree kinda got spoiled for one part of season 2 and regreted it so yeah im gonna wait for the anime to catch up so i can watch this video
wellll the content of arc 5 and 6 which are presented in this video might be adapted into the just confirmed s3, its extremely likely the season will end specifically on where this if story diverged....or you can just read
People are pointing out how his method of revival won’t work as he’s destroying all he valued to regain his values
Another flaw is that no matter what he would never be complete, he’ll never be able to gain the critical loops in his character that failed
Die to this he’ll only ever see Subaru’s success never the failings that forged them
It's weird that he never came across Natsuki Subarus book of the dead in the pledies watch tower. He's been killing people left and right and searching for their books of the dead, but still can't find his own book of the dead
can't wait for echidnut to do another 5mil budget voice over for it
also thanks for the free arc 5/6 spoilers
bro grabbed a book and decided to kill everyone 😭🤣💀
you're so underrated, I absolutely love your videos
I watched so much I forgot to subscribe
To this day I still wonder
If Reinhard can't get past Sands Time even with his 80 percent Yin Magic Resistance, then wouldn't that mean that Flugel can win against Reinhard by default via placing Reinhard under a spell on the same level as Sands Time like a Tsukuyomi or something
Maybe I mean in pretty sure even arc 4 Betty could beat Reinhard with bfr using al shamac
Yes, except that magic doesn't 'activate' in Reinhardt's presence. Check out his abilities, but basically as he's loved by the spirits, all the mana required goes to him. Dude's a walking magic EMP.
@@christstrife6144 wait really what divine protection was that ?
@@omnipayne861 I forgot if its divine protection or what, but he is loved by mana itself that all mana around him gets to him. That's why people around him can't use magic
@@muhammadalifmulkymurtadha4493 oh yeah that’s what it was I forgot about that
I like the way you summarize.
I need to say, i LOVE your voice! And my feelings for gluttony if Is mixed. I really love it my second favorite if story, however i also hate it the most of all if story it's really mixed
i shouldnt have spoiled myself..
It’s interesting how every arc has had an IF route (minus arc 5, but that arc doesn’t have any real points of divergence for Subaru). Will we be getting one for arc 7 in the future? I haven’t caught up to the most recent chapters, but has anyone seen any potential IF route divergence points?
Gladiator island if he had survived Todd attack and didn't rbs to solve everything that probably the divergence.
He probably just end up like todd since he was comparing himself with him and he will be terrified of dying plus he will lose all his memories beako will probably die same with Emilia since ceci did not save her
Coming back to watch this since season 3 got announced
Murder becomes a habit.
btw. i strongly think Emila turns into Satella by the end. because "Emilia is the only person affected by this penalty of Return By Death, with no explanation to why this is." this is because Satella gave Return by death to Subaru in order to change the past and stop Emilia from turning into Satella. However, Subaru says he will save her instead. so that is why Satella only kills Emilia when he tries to tell her. plus they have the same voice actor. and is said that she is "born from the same cursed blood as the Witch" as well as calling her "the descendant of the Witch". born from the same cursed blood. literally THE SAME BLOOD. the same mother. and the descendant is due to their striking similarity. which is because they are THE SAME PERSON. and something in the story will make Emilia become Satella. And if Subaru is Flugel. then perhaps this has happened before. and Subaru is being "summoned" to the world of rezero over and over. and is every Isekai'ed person in its history, and if a Subaru comes in contact with himself the penalty of Return By Death will kick in. since rezero likes toying with alternate timelines. what if every isekai'ed person is Subaru, reset from coming out of the Convenience store each time. and since black-haired people are "rare". its probably only Subaru's lineage. so basically Elsa is a direct descendant of one of the Subaru's selves. I think im a pretty big brain here. by reading between the lines. we are still missing vital information. but it might have to do with what the witch cult is trying to acomplish. and that vault pandora wanted to open. its all tied to Emilia.
200 IQ those are my thoughts too
Except the elsa part thats definitely bigbrain tho
But u left a plot hole i don't think the penalty of return by death activates when he meets him self
@@AMR_k400 yeah i too thought that too, it has no basis. but if Al is a version of Subaru or the son of a subaru. why wouldn't he speak up to Subaru since he has black hair.
@@AMR_k400 plus i worded my paragraph all weird. also all silver/white haired characters are suspisious. Otto is a sith lord confirmed.
I am your ideals epitomized. Now do you realise how hypocritical they are?
@@AMR_k400 do you ever think Subaru will return to Earth with his memories intact? by the end. what if in the final confrontation with Satella, she just yeets him away, back to Earth. lol
Everyone is Subaru
Tho even if he kills everyone that knows him he still cant get memories that he experienced alone.. His view of point.. So he'll never recover all of his memories
Yeah that’s what I thought too, and that’s probably the saddest part.
Really interesting what would happen after he dies.
It's ultimately up to Satella to decide, but we know fuck all how she does it. Will she be mad at Subaru and move the savepoint out of spite? Or will she keep it in place because that's what Subaru would want?
I'm more concerned on how he's alive without beako absorbing his excess mana.
Maybe shaula can do it? Tappei never explained it.
@@Steyr32Is the green room spirit still there? Maybe that has something to do with it. Or Louis just absorbs his mana. Since beatrice is dead he can use/
contract with other spirits
Otto is secretly.....
BATMAN!
Otto is pandora, she just wants to be best friends with the lolimancer, nothing sinister.
Im at 21 minutes atm: From what i get from this is that the witchfactor of gluttony makes you feel as if you are never complete, always hungry for more to complete yourself but you are never satiated as gluttony has no limit.
Thats pretty fking evil.
Since Lye Batenkaitos knows soo many techniques from the people he has eaten im going to guess his form of gluttony is learning/stealing the techniques of the ones he eats.
Subaru's (following the same logic) would be the completion of himself.
Amazing amazing video
Hollup I read this but meili was in the basement for a year. LITTLE GIRL IN SUBARUS BASEMENT
despicable :'(
i thought he'd just eat good food, wants to eat again so he purposefully dies and then continues to eat again and again
Lol
That subaru wont be completed subaru even tho he kill everyone and live their entire life, he only see the results of his successful route but he will never see the process of died over and over to make it right
Yeah that's why in arc 6 he read books of the dead of himself and gains back his memories
This is a great if, but there is something I don't get. Why could Subaru leave the Pleiades Watchtower? I thought he couldn't until he finished the trials. My guess is he did finish the trials somehow and therefore screwed himself because that might have updated his checkpoint depending on what the condition for his checkpoints truly is.
wait so it wasnt because shaula existed?
It’s weird hearing someone else being called Flugel because I go by Flugel to
Plot twist: You are the sage Flügel and Subaru you just don't know it yet because of time travel