Frankenshoes helped my grandpa feel smart with his suit when he had challenges walking later in life. As such, I conclude they have a positive place for those with feet issues who don't want to give up on brogues.
I work in a story where we sell them. We also have the one on the photo he shows. ( a newer model tho) we sell them mostly to people who are looking for comfort and to older people.
Those shoes are totally designed for a "business casual" look. I work in architecture firms as a consultant and everyone wears them. Especially the men going through mid life crisis. They think it makes them look hip and young instead they look like idiots. Sidebar I'm thrilled your family member can wear them to keep up his style, bravo! My Dad got orthopedic dress shoes that looked like wingtips with an orthopedic sole. You can get these at all types of shoe stores and of course online. They are an excellent alternative to the thin sole shoes. Best wishes!
Always appreciate the clarification of your viewpoint that you are advising on what works better for classic styles and not saying any of the newer trends are "bad" per se like many other classic style guys do. It's so easy to be so immersed in classic styles that you start looking down on what others wear due to comfort or preference - which can be pretty off-putting for a lot of people.
People are so sensitive they can be off put by someone opinion on style. I say they only said the disclaimer because people can't stomach anyone saying they don't think their style looks good.
@@joshmiller7777 Awesome! It's another thing I hope to "master" in hopes of one day getting value out of an entire day. Instead of just throwing on clothes that works for the day, why not put together an outfit that makes me look and feel great, or instead of grabbing a bowl of cereal in the morning, why not make a fully nutritional meal, and ect.
@@lankysquibs9128 So well said - it's a wonderful part of the whole self improvement journey. And putting on some nice clothes really helps start a successful day off! Really great to hear of your interest, and keep it up :)
For anyone who has ever worked at, or perhaps even resided in, a correctional institute, slides are jail shoes. They make the prisoners wear them because they're easy to check for contraband and hard to make into a weapon. That's what I think of when I see someone wearing them. You can pair them up with some faded, baggy sweats to really look the part.
Prisoners also wear pants. Does that mean pants make you look like a criminal? Slides are comfortable and convenient. They might not be stylish, but not everyone is trying to look stylish all the time.
@@MayTheSchwartzBeWithYouYep, people that wear pants, people who eat dehydrated beans and ramen, people with face tattoos, men who shower together, all prisoners. Really it's just meant to be a humorous perspective from my own experience. People should dress and look the way they are comfortable.
@@willj1598 I wear slides around the house. Unfortunately I went through a period of time wearing them out to the store with Adidas sweatpants. I'm doing much better now. Got that bum life out of my system
I've always special ordered all black trainers because I thought they looked the most neutral. I wear them with black slacks at work and I dont like how other people wear striped trainers that draw attention to them.
I have a pair of Cole Haan that I bought a month ago. It belongs to the Frankenshoe category here. Just needed a day for break in and I love every minute that I’m wearing it. Ultracomfortable😃…
Wow you nailed it ! My mother tore me up when I was 10 years old because she wanted me to try on a pair of dress shoes that were on sale . The problem ? They were medium brown and had a gold buckle that looked like I was one of the pilgrims coming on the Mayflower!! I wouldn’t try them on because I wanted to look like James Bond ! Shoes can make or break a suit or any outfit and I’m obsessed with getting them right with what I’m wearing! Thank you for your excellent insight !
Agreed on the Frankenshoes. They strike me as a marketing gimmick aimed at people who don’t realize there are classic smart casual shoes like bucks and loafers that are equally comfortable.
@@michaelm9141 They are comfortable when wearing them in the office and work well in the business casual style of dress that’s required. If you don’t like them then do buy them. Real simple, I’m quite sure some shoes in your collection would frown my face so…
I wholeheartedly have to applaud to your shoe preference! I'm now 59 and saw a lot things come and go, but always wore dress shoes (o.k. sometimes boat shoes) when not being in the gym ore in the woods. I found these always much more comfortable, probably because leather breathes, plastic and rubber does not.
I think society will disagree with the Frankenshoe comment. Some are over the top but the ones with basic white or gum color soles are pretty stylish. I believe they will live on for a long time.
Kyle hits another home run with this video. Love the direct and concise critique of the shoes on today's list. I know these shoes are somewhere between bad and not very good, but hearing the exact details as to WHY, ....really helps. Thank you.
I think that crocs are great if you want to feel that speed. Wearing a pair of Lightning McQueen edition crocs with the strap raised is the ultimate in bringing the unique feeling of "I am Speed"
As a teacher living in a city who doesn't drive, the Frankenshoes are something I couldn't live without. I like the more subtle ones that closely resembles the dress shoes though, not the brown leather upper+white outsole type.
The "Frankenshoes" offended me at first as well, but the right guy can make them look good. Not everyone will be able to pull it off, as they do have the look of orthopedic grandpa shoes by themselves, but with the right outfit they can be a good business casual look. These sort of shoes are new on the scene, so they're going to offend traditionalists, but I think the "Frankenshoes" are here to stay.
You might have included poulaines - the medieval pointed shoes - too, even though they aren't trendy today, but may yet emerge in popularity again. They were supposed to represent the "masculinity" of the wearer. For this reason and for the gaudiness many of them were adorned with, they were despised by the more rigorous members of the clergy. The code of the Knights Templar, for instance, expressly forbade the brother knights from wearing them. In the 1460s, poulaines were outright banned in England, as dandy nobles were going about with absurdly long toes. It offended King Edward IV enough to issue a decree outlawing any toe longer than two inches. Just goes to show the war against bad taste is never ending, and sometimes requires legal action!
9:53 I was wondering whether the Tafts would make an appearance, and I feel compelled to defend them! Their jacquard derbies (the Jack Shoe) are a rare example of modern brands of creating a classic-style shoe that is both extravagant and still eminently wearable - the jacquard works beautifully with the leather, the transition is unobtrusive, it's the only additional piece of "flair" on an otherwise very simple silhouette - it might not be an everyday shoe, but I can imagine it being an absolutely lovely addition to many outfits
I thought the same thing - they're neat looking shoes that I think could be used in some stylish outfits, even if they're less versatile than a solid-colored leather.
Great video. I work a hybrid job and nothing beats wearing crocs, slides, socks, or joggers when working from home. That being said I never would wear them with a suit to the downtown office. I think it’s up for debate which situations, in between work and home, this footwear is appropriate for.
I love my crocs, of course I'd never wear them in public. But late at night, after I'm sure no one will be stopping by, I put them on in place of slippers. They are comfy.
I'm with y'all for nearly all of these. I do wear all-black gym shoes in professional settings (choreographing fights for live theatre) for a clean, professional look where I need athletic shoes, but nothing brightly colored or distracting. I'm a niche case, though, and generally agree with the opinion.
I'd love to see a video dedicated to a full 18th-19th century BRITISH men's wear outfit, where to buy it, how to look like you're actually from the 18th/19th century, etc.
@@alexreiser6325 Well, honestly, as long as I look like a Victorian Era rich Englishman, I don't really care if it's considered cosplay or "dressing nicely", (though I personally wouldn't consider that cosplay).
I think dress shoes are the most comfortable shoes- for me they usually fit the best and feel the nicest on my feet. Not to mention they look fantastic
In fairness I am an older man and hardly a judge of style at the best of times (retired military so I never had to pay attention to it;) but I'd argue against that logic. It may be because I've mainly used sneakers for actual physical training but white ones seem too casual to me. I wouldn't wear black trainers with a suit but if I'm just dressing casually while going out for groceries or to the movies I'll wear monotone (ie no brand stripes) black leather trainers with unfaded blue jeans and a top (polo shirt or windbreaker depending on the weather) in a slightly lighter blue or green. I will admit it can be difficult to find a version with of the trainers without the clunky soles he described elsewhere in the video but it can be done.
OMG I totally agree about the frankenshoes! They are totally disgusting in my opinion. Like some sort of a post modern wingtip with a basketball sole. It also goes with the idea that necks are much more attractive than a tie.
Only two amendments for me: 1) I love certain restrained and subtle unnatural petinas and colours, such as dark blue, green or hints of dark purple; matches with certain outfits, I think they’d look great. However, yes, bright yellow, orange or rainbow is out of the question. 2) I like the fresh idea and look if the sock-shoes; they have their place and context although, at AUD$1,800 for a decent pair of Balenciagas, I wont be buying them soon
Kyle is your Dress shirt and crew neck sweater in the outfit both the same size? Just curious for when I start wearing that combination with my sweaters. Excellent work as always!
9:27 Many dress shoes are defined by having superfluous details. Tassle vs Penny loafers, for example. Or, brogues that haven't had a functional purpose in generations.
If it can help them to realize they could just as well buy a dress shoe in the first place, maybe the serve a purpose. Other than that, I see none indeed.
I must say I agree with everything apart from the Frankenshoe. I think with a pair of chinos with the right jacket and shirt it looks very good indeed. I own a couple from Cole Haan and have always received appreciating comments.
I like how they switch from doing direct hits on concept ideas from fashion houses to glazing back to talking about trends, really shows that this subculture can be very superficial.
I like square toes shoes a lot because I like that its quite interesting in silhouette esp when its a shorter shoe, i like to pair them with dress shorts since i dress in a style very influenced by classic men's wear but also like contemporary shapes so i think it is good for those who want to bring classic mens wear into their lives but also want a unique not so traditional touch
I have to agree with most of your choices. Although, I think a Franken-shoe can work. It shouldn’t be your go to nor worn with a suit ( unless your younger than 22) but it can work with more casual outfits. I would say some are done better than others.
I work as a manager at a warehouse. I have to look semi professional at work but remain comfortable enough to perform like a team member if I need to. "Frankenshoes" are an amazing addition to my shoe rotation. I have two pairs, one in leather and one in a blue knitted fabric. They're a slimmer profile than most sneakers or boots (I also have a couple pairs of boots for work, but they are not comfortable in the summer) but have enough support to be comfortable on my feet all day. I absolutely can't wear dress shoes to work for safety reasons, so frankenshoes are the next best thing.
I'm a fan of Adidas Gazelles, Adidas Superstars, Chucks, and other classic styles as streetwear. I'm a fan of sneakers like Common Projects, Koios, and the like as minimalist sneakers for dressy casual. I'm not a fan of sneakers that try to be dressy casual, but put a stripe or other kind of branding down the side. IMHO, they're too dressy to be streetwear, and too casual to be dressy. There are better options available.
Sock shoes are extremely good for travel. Light weight to store in your backpack and use for long walks. Frankenshoes... Try being a doctor running up and down 10 floors (elevators too slow) for up to 12hrs a day and well see if you find "good fitting" shoes comfortable at the end of the week.
Thanks Kyle I couldn't agree with you more viewing this video reminds me of the time I was eating at a restaurant and my waitress was wearing footwear that were formed to highlight her individual toes need I say more it was definitely not a welcoming sight so hopefully these awful footwear trends will not resurface again appreciate the video.
I have one thought on the square toe... People generally have 4-5 different toe types. Women have to consider what toe type they have to match a great fitting shoe. Could there be an analogy with the square toe shoe with men with roman and square toes? I have a problem with dress shoes/boots. I have my own pairs of Allen Edmonds and others with pointed toes. My Danners work boot are the only shoe/boot that fit me well (they are about 12 yrs old and on the 2nd retread). But they are comfortable because they are squared toes. I also spend 14 hrs in my shoes every day regardless of what Im doing.
Slides are undefeated. I have a pair of Lacoste slides that have refused to degrade over the last 3 years of constant use. It's not formal attire by any means but still looks stylish and shouldn't be relegated to just pool wear.
Some of the comments reminds me of why there's advice to go second in a competition that is one on one(or last if larger), since the audience and judges tend to remember what's more fresh in memory and how it can throw off their ability to perceive accurately to judge the competitors fairly. Even though Kyle included the clarification on the commentary being about how it doesn't fit the classic look the channel is about in the opening of the video, people are still all in their feelings about it like he flat out attacked their preferred way of dressing and said "this is bad and you should feel bad," and he didn't.
Hi, I would very much like to know what your opinion is on the Loro Piana Open and or Summer walks. Even though they might not be considered a trend anymore since they have been around for quite some time now. Also because they have been worn by mostly classically styled men such as Sergio Loro Piana. Keep up the great work!
Only place for square toe is in riding cowboy boots. Many custom made or luxury brand and often extremely high quality cowboy boots have square toe as it’s a very traditional look for a working cowboy or western horseman. I have a pair of very high end working cowboy boots by luccesee that I ride in and they are exquisite; however my black elephant leather dress boots are a nice round toe and pair perfectly with a suit… in Texas that is lol.
I agree with all of your thoughtful advice EXCEPT for your caveat against all-black sneakers. One needs to consider carefully at the lines any shoe lends to the foot regardless of whether the sole contrasts with the upper, and there are plenty of black-on-black sneakers (e.g. the classic all-black leather Converse All-Star low-top) that can serve as a confident and classic minimalist counterpoint adding to a well thought-out and stylish casual ensemble.
@@TheSultan1470 It all just boils down to taste. Sneakers in general are not even in the category of classic menswear, so there aren't really many guidelines to go by. I personally prefer a few different shades of color on my sneakers, much like the ones Kyle was wearing with the brown details breaking up the surface of the shoes.
Honestly I use my slides when I'm home really but I believe it acceptable anytime when it's like over 90 degrees outside,maybe picking up the mail but with jeans,trousers in everyday life it is frustrating to look at.
I love your guy's videos and want to challenge you. If you can, do a video on how to style cowboy boots with a suit please. It's been done for decades or almost a century in America but with almost no good guides and I think it would be interesting to hear how you guys would go about it.
A lot of fair points but there are far less “bad” embellishments then good. Things like prints, caps, studs, crimps, give that little extra flair. Like everything red carpet, it’s the exception, not the majority.
Thank you for saying it! Wonderful content ,as usual. That said, I love my franken shoes. I have the soles painted to look like leather and wear them when I am on rainy walks with my wife. I would never wear them anywhere else. Yes, I have proper rain gear but on lightly raining days my franken shoes sport a nice look and keep my feet dry. Also Black Sneakers have a place for those who work jobs where they would ruin dress shoes and work boots are not practical. Some peoples work require a dress code but the work they do does not pay enough and is too demanding on foot wear to afford a more stylish shoe, here the black sneaker has a home.
Right with you Kyle. My generation has seen platforms and roller coaster soles on shoes as well as brands like Jellies, Crayons, and now Crock’s. Hopefully this latest trend will suffer the same fate. And we’ll look back and future generations will look at pictures and laugh at the ones who wore them.
I dread buying shoes. I'm a cobbler's worst nightmare. I have a wide ball, a high arch, and a narrow heel (I think Mom might've smoked during the pregnancy). I agree with a lot of these points, yet I also have to look with jealous longing at some of the classic shoes so cruelly displayed. ☹
Try Mephisto. Not only do they make probably the best shoes in the world, aka, they're hand made in France, super high quality full grain leathers, super durable, have a cushioning system even in the dress shoes, air-soft tech insole and no synthetic materials, but also they're especially well known for making the shoes adapted to your gait and type of foot too. I have a narrow heel and very high arch. Mephisto offer great stability at the heel and even the loafers and oxfords they make are adapted to all foot types. Hope this helps! P.S. i have the Mephisto Melchior for work and the Thomas in white as a classy sneaker. Both are super comfortable.
I do to prefer minimalistic loafers too. Tassels are a horror imo. I like leather loafers with a woven structure. My favourite model is the Herrera from Magnanni. They're comfy and a piece of art.
A point I'd make about "gaudier" shoes: while bedazzling and gilding never look good (I have cut and removed such decorations from newly-bought shoes before), I have to slightly disagree on the patterned fabric shoes. While it's not a look every one can pull off, it isn't for every occasion, and it's certainly controversial, I actually like the specific shoe you showed at 9:54. It brings to mind baroque Versailles, and as a fashion history nerd I appreciate it 😄 For someone with a more flamboyant style it can work as a statement piece. Much like in feminine fashion, if you wear a statement piece like a big necklace or chunky earrings the rest of your outfit and accessories are more subdued so as not to dilute focus from that statement piece. "Less is more" is a golden rule, but rules can be broken as long as one's deliberate about it and the rest of the outfit communicates the intention that the questionable piece is meant to be there. Funky shoes can be just another accessory to play with in an outfit. But I guess this is where personal style comes into play, and where individuals would decide to bend style guidelines to have fun with their outfits and choose to either stand out or blend in. Because clothes are meant to be practical, but fashion is meant to be fun 🥳
Dress shoes are to men what high heels are to women: stylish, classy designs that many love the classic look of, but that require sacrifices in terms of comfort. I cheat - to and from the office/event, it's Nike, adidas , Saucony etc: ultra comfortable, grippy outsoles for wet/slippery surfaces. But in the office or just before the event, well it's the Crockett & Jones / Carmina / Trickers etc.
Kyle, what would be the best formal shoe for a large set guy which is both stylish and comfortable. I like mon straps and have gotten many compliments on it, but its an uncomfortable nightmare especially if worn long hours. Do you have a recommended brand that is both stylish and comfortable? Thank you and keep up the great work!
Maybe off topic for this video, but one thing I hate are toecaps on a true closed lace Oxford. Toecaps on an open lace blucher or derby is fine, but due to the higher status of oxfords being the correct shoe for more formal wear, I think the toe cap is distracting. The stem of my rant is from spending days online trying to find a closed lace Oxford with no toecap that is not patent leather for a morning suit. Virtually impossible without going bespoke or spending almost as much as bespoke for an off the shelf size.
It sounds like you're searching for a wholecut Oxford - there are several brands that offer them, with a few listed here: www.gentlemansgazette.com/oxford-shoes-guide/?
i agree with most of the topics but i have to disagree with the review of the sock shoes. Yes they look too futuristic for a classy outfit but i believe the comfort + practicality while maintaining a certain level of sobriety in the design (specially the ones that does not have a huge rubber insole strapped onto it) must be one of the greatest additions to futuristic sport outfits lately
I have a rack full of quality dress shoes that fit properly. It's not accurate to say they're as comfortable as something like a pair of Yeezys. I also have a rack full of those. They're excellent for those of us with bad feet.
Allen Edmonds have a few but out of my price range. For a started check into the Dunham brand. They were owned by new balance. Now Rockport ownes them.
I look at current trends in footwear and fashion...and it's just NO from me. Luckily I'm at an age now where i literally don't care anymore what's "hip".
If there's one thing I hate, it's the squishy soled shoes! So disproportionate, especially when I see, tiny Asian girls wearing them, I just think, do you not see yourself 🙄
Frankenshoes helped my grandpa feel smart with his suit when he had challenges walking later in life. As such, I conclude they have a positive place for those with feet issues who don't want to give up on brogues.
I work in a story where we sell them. We also have the one on the photo he shows. ( a newer model tho) we sell them mostly to people who are looking for comfort and to older people.
I agree Frankenshoes should be given an exception for seniors who cannot wear dress shoes anymore, but don‘t want to give up on the style.
Those shoes are totally designed for a "business casual" look. I work in architecture firms as a consultant and everyone wears them. Especially the men going through mid life crisis. They think it makes them look hip and young instead they look like idiots. Sidebar I'm thrilled your family member can wear them to keep up his style, bravo! My Dad got orthopedic dress shoes that looked like wingtips with an orthopedic sole. You can get these at all types of shoe stores and of course online. They are an excellent alternative to the thin sole shoes. Best wishes!
Isnt that the entire point of Frankenshoes?
All black sneakers are also useful for jobs that demand a lot of time on your feet but not distracting. Waiter, security guard, etc.
Always appreciate the clarification of your viewpoint that you are advising on what works better for classic styles and not saying any of the newer trends are "bad" per se like many other classic style guys do. It's so easy to be so immersed in classic styles that you start looking down on what others wear due to comfort or preference - which can be pretty off-putting for a lot of people.
This right here is (and other reasons) are why I've stopped watching many other channels but stay with GG.
M
"There is nothing noble in being superior to others, true nobility is being superior to your former self" - Hemmingway
@@gentlemansgazette a true gentleman mindset
People are so sensitive they can be off put by someone opinion on style. I say they only said the disclaimer because people can't stomach anyone saying they don't think their style looks good.
What I love is that you explain the how and why, without denegrating the shoes themselves nor the people who wear them.
I'm 19, so I'm a sneaker head as much as I love to dress in classic style, but I agree with everything you said.
Classic style is best in the world.
Awesome to see else young who likes classic style :) personally I'm 21!
@@joshmiller7777 Awesome! It's another thing I hope to "master" in hopes of one day getting value out of an entire day. Instead of just throwing on clothes that works for the day, why not put together an outfit that makes me look and feel great, or instead of grabbing a bowl of cereal in the morning, why not make a fully nutritional meal, and ect.
@@lankysquibs9128 So well said - it's a wonderful part of the whole self improvement journey. And putting on some nice clothes really helps start a successful day off! Really great to hear of your interest, and keep it up :)
@@joshmiller7777 you as well, my friend. :)
Always enjoy it when Kyle demolishes questionable (and downright atrocious) fashion trends!
Remember that what you wear was probably once an atrocious fashion trend. Style and fashion are subjective and we shouldn't judge.
@@shawnbogstie2827 For sure. Derbies, sport jackets, etc. have all been super casual sports and hunting clothes/shoes in the 19th century.
For anyone who has ever worked at, or perhaps even resided in, a correctional institute, slides are jail shoes. They make the prisoners wear them because they're easy to check for contraband and hard to make into a weapon. That's what I think of when I see someone wearing them. You can pair them up with some faded, baggy sweats to really look the part.
Prisoners also wear pants. Does that mean pants make you look like a criminal? Slides are comfortable and convenient. They might not be stylish, but not everyone is trying to look stylish all the time.
@@MayTheSchwartzBeWithYouYep, people that wear pants, people who eat dehydrated beans and ramen, people with face tattoos, men who shower together, all prisoners. Really it's just meant to be a humorous perspective from my own experience. People should dress and look the way they are comfortable.
behold the whitest of the white men on earth
@@willj1598 stop judging people who r u god
@@willj1598 I wear slides around the house. Unfortunately I went through a period of time wearing them out to the store with Adidas sweatpants.
I'm doing much better now. Got that bum life out of my system
I've always special ordered all black trainers because I thought they looked the most neutral. I wear them with black slacks at work and I dont like how other people wear striped trainers that draw attention to them.
As long as they're not black Air Force Ones, you're fine.
I have a pair of Cole Haan that I bought a month ago. It belongs to the Frankenshoe category here. Just needed a day for break in and I love every minute that I’m wearing it. Ultracomfortable😃…
Wow you nailed it ! My mother tore me up when I was 10 years old because she wanted me to try on a pair of dress shoes that were on sale . The problem ? They were medium brown and had a gold buckle that looked like I was one of the pilgrims coming on the Mayflower!! I wouldn’t try them on because I wanted to look like James Bond ! Shoes can make or break a suit or any outfit and I’m obsessed with getting them right with what I’m wearing! Thank you for your excellent insight !
Agreed on the Frankenshoes. They strike me as a marketing gimmick aimed at people who don’t realize there are classic smart casual shoes like bucks and loafers that are equally comfortable.
I agree as well, except there is a small amout of choice when it comes to 3E and above.
@@michaelm9141 They are comfortable when wearing them in the office and work well in the business casual style of dress that’s required. If you don’t like them then do buy them. Real simple, I’m quite sure some shoes in your collection would frown my face so…
I wholeheartedly have to applaud to your shoe preference! I'm now 59 and saw a lot things come and go, but always wore dress shoes (o.k. sometimes boat shoes) when not being in the gym ore in the woods. I found these always much more comfortable, probably because leather breathes, plastic and rubber does not.
I love all black trainers. They are my go to colour
I think society will disagree with the Frankenshoe comment. Some are over the top but the ones with basic white or gum color soles are pretty stylish. I believe they will live on for a long time.
Especially when the sole isn't white and they blend in more with the shoe.
Kyle hits another home run with this video. Love the direct and concise critique of the shoes on today's list. I know these shoes are somewhere between bad and not very good, but hearing the exact details as to WHY, ....really helps. Thank you.
I think that crocs are great if you want to feel that speed. Wearing a pair of Lightning McQueen edition crocs with the strap raised is the ultimate in bringing the unique feeling of "I am Speed"
Lolz
As a teacher living in a city who doesn't drive, the Frankenshoes are something I couldn't live without. I like the more subtle ones that closely resembles the dress shoes though, not the brown leather upper+white outsole type.
The "Frankenshoes" offended me at first as well, but the right guy can make them look good. Not everyone will be able to pull it off, as they do have the look of orthopedic grandpa shoes by themselves, but with the right outfit they can be a good business casual look. These sort of shoes are new on the scene, so they're going to offend traditionalists, but I think the "Frankenshoes" are here to stay.
I love my Crocs, and adore my black Kizik's... but... not with a suit or for formal/semi-formal affairs...
You might have included poulaines - the medieval pointed shoes - too, even though they aren't trendy today, but may yet emerge in popularity again. They were supposed to represent the "masculinity" of the wearer. For this reason and for the gaudiness many of them were adorned with, they were despised by the more rigorous members of the clergy. The code of the Knights Templar, for instance, expressly forbade the brother knights from wearing them. In the 1460s, poulaines were outright banned in England, as dandy nobles were going about with absurdly long toes. It offended King Edward IV enough to issue a decree outlawing any toe longer than two inches.
Just goes to show the war against bad taste is never ending, and sometimes requires legal action!
Thank you for the thought provoking information! Tell me does the symbol in your profile pic denote anything specific?
I love all the humor you included in this review. very well done!
9:53 I was wondering whether the Tafts would make an appearance, and I feel compelled to defend them! Their jacquard derbies (the Jack Shoe) are a rare example of modern brands of creating a classic-style shoe that is both extravagant and still eminently wearable - the jacquard works beautifully with the leather, the transition is unobtrusive, it's the only additional piece of "flair" on an otherwise very simple silhouette - it might not be an everyday shoe, but I can imagine it being an absolutely lovely addition to many outfits
I thought the same thing - they're neat looking shoes that I think could be used in some stylish outfits, even if they're less versatile than a solid-colored leather.
*Crocks style is reminiscent of Gardening Shoes.
LOL 😆
I've always felt that Chuck Taylors are some of the best casual shoes ever. Timeless, even. You even see them with formal suits sometimes.
Great video. I work a hybrid job and nothing beats wearing crocs, slides, socks, or joggers when working from home. That being said I never would wear them with a suit to the downtown office. I think it’s up for debate which situations, in between work and home, this footwear is appropriate for.
I love my crocs, of course I'd never wear them in public. But late at night, after I'm sure no one will be stopping by, I put them on in place of slippers. They are comfy.
I'm with y'all for nearly all of these. I do wear all-black gym shoes in professional settings (choreographing fights for live theatre) for a clean, professional look where I need athletic shoes, but nothing brightly colored or distracting. I'm a niche case, though, and generally agree with the opinion.
I'd love to see a video dedicated to a full 18th-19th century BRITISH men's wear outfit, where to buy it, how to look like you're actually from the 18th/19th century, etc.
I'd imagine the place to start would be somewhere in Britain...😜
There's a fine line between dressing nicely and cosplay
@@alexreiser6325 Well, honestly, as long as I look like a Victorian Era rich Englishman, I don't really care if it's considered cosplay or "dressing nicely", (though I personally wouldn't consider that cosplay).
@@Lycos_dae are you at least rich?
@@alexreiser6325 That's debatable xD
Crocs around the house are cool. But never step out in public with them
I think dress shoes are the most comfortable shoes- for me they usually fit the best and feel the nicest on my feet. Not to mention they look fantastic
Go jogging in a pair to see how comfortable they are
@@joecool9739 LOL!
@@joecool9739 Okay now go jogging in classic suites
That definitely hasn't been my experience. I've never worn a dress shoe more comfortable than a sneaker.
@@MayTheSchwartzBeWithYou There will never be a dress shoe as comfortable as a sneaker. Different materials etc.
I agree, especially with all black sneakers. I bought a pair and never worn them because they are really difficult to match with your clothes! Avoid!
In fairness I am an older man and hardly a judge of style at the best of times (retired military so I never had to pay attention to it;) but I'd argue against that logic. It may be because I've mainly used sneakers for actual physical training but white ones seem too casual to me.
I wouldn't wear black trainers with a suit but if I'm just dressing casually while going out for groceries or to the movies I'll wear monotone (ie no brand stripes) black leather trainers with unfaded blue jeans and a top (polo shirt or windbreaker depending on the weather) in a slightly lighter blue or green. I will admit it can be difficult to find a version with of the trainers without the clunky soles he described elsewhere in the video but it can be done.
OMG I totally agree about the frankenshoes! They are totally disgusting in my opinion. Like some sort of a post modern wingtip with a basketball sole. It also goes with the idea that necks are much more attractive than a tie.
I love the original dude, I’m so happy you put a classy black brother on there. The channel even more saucy now!!
I definitely do love to loathe the Croc
Only two amendments for me:
1) I love certain restrained and subtle unnatural petinas and colours, such as dark blue, green or hints of dark purple; matches with certain outfits, I think they’d look great. However, yes, bright yellow, orange or rainbow is out of the question.
2) I like the fresh idea and look if the sock-shoes; they have their place and context although, at AUD$1,800 for a decent pair of Balenciagas, I wont be buying them soon
Kyle is your Dress shirt and crew neck sweater in the outfit both the same size? Just curious for when I start wearing that combination with my sweaters. Excellent work as always!
9:27 Many dress shoes are defined by having superfluous details. Tassle vs Penny loafers, for example. Or, brogues that haven't had a functional purpose in generations.
Genuinely can’t understand why people wear those dress shoes with trainer soles.
If it can help them to realize they could just as well buy a dress shoe in the first place, maybe the serve a purpose. Other than that, I see none indeed.
How do men even find it appropriate to wear CROCS? makes no sense.
Black is just a color and it works well with gray-scale outfits. You gotta stop hating on black.
I must say I agree with everything apart from the Frankenshoe. I think with a pair of chinos with the right jacket and shirt it looks very good indeed. I own a couple from Cole Haan and have always received appreciating comments.
I like how they switch from doing direct hits on concept ideas from fashion houses to glazing back to talking about trends, really shows that this subculture can be very superficial.
I like square toes shoes a lot because I like that its quite interesting in silhouette esp when its a shorter shoe, i like to pair them with dress shorts since i dress in a style very influenced by classic men's wear but also like contemporary shapes so i think it is good for those who want to bring classic mens wear into their lives but also want a unique not so traditional touch
I have to agree with most of your choices. Although, I think a Franken-shoe can work. It shouldn’t be your go to nor worn with a suit ( unless your younger than 22) but it can work with more casual outfits. I would say some are done better than others.
Well done video! Informative and smart! Thanks!
This video is loaded with references from the arts.
I work as a manager at a warehouse. I have to look semi professional at work but remain comfortable enough to perform like a team member if I need to.
"Frankenshoes" are an amazing addition to my shoe rotation. I have two pairs, one in leather and one in a blue knitted fabric. They're a slimmer profile than most sneakers or boots (I also have a couple pairs of boots for work, but they are not comfortable in the summer) but have enough support to be comfortable on my feet all day. I absolutely can't wear dress shoes to work for safety reasons, so frankenshoes are the next best thing.
I'm a fan of Adidas Gazelles, Adidas Superstars, Chucks, and other classic styles as streetwear.
I'm a fan of sneakers like Common Projects, Koios, and the like as minimalist sneakers for dressy casual.
I'm not a fan of sneakers that try to be dressy casual, but put a stripe or other kind of branding down the side. IMHO, they're too dressy to be streetwear, and too casual to be dressy. There are better options available.
Sock shoes are extremely good for travel. Light weight to store in your backpack and use for long walks. Frankenshoes... Try being a doctor running up and down 10 floors (elevators too slow) for up to 12hrs a day and well see if you find "good fitting" shoes comfortable at the end of the week.
Thanks Kyle I couldn't agree with you more viewing this video reminds me of the time I was eating at a restaurant and my waitress was wearing footwear that were formed to highlight her individual toes need I say more it was definitely not a welcoming sight so hopefully these awful footwear trends will not resurface again appreciate the video.
I have one thought on the square toe...
People generally have 4-5 different toe types. Women have to consider what toe type they have to match a great fitting shoe. Could there be an analogy with the square toe shoe with men with roman and square toes?
I have a problem with dress shoes/boots. I have my own pairs of Allen Edmonds and others with pointed toes. My Danners work boot are the only shoe/boot that fit me well (they are about 12 yrs old and on the 2nd retread). But they are comfortable because they are squared toes. I also spend 14 hrs in my shoes every day regardless of what Im doing.
Quality timeless clothes is the way to go attire which will last 20 years and not go out of style.
Slides are undefeated. I have a pair of Lacoste slides that have refused to degrade over the last 3 years of constant use. It's not formal attire by any means but still looks stylish and shouldn't be relegated to just pool wear.
Some of the comments reminds me of why there's advice to go second in a competition that is one on one(or last if larger), since the audience and judges tend to remember what's more fresh in memory and how it can throw off their ability to perceive accurately to judge the competitors fairly. Even though Kyle included the clarification on the commentary being about how it doesn't fit the classic look the channel is about in the opening of the video, people are still all in their feelings about it like he flat out attacked their preferred way of dressing and said "this is bad and you should feel bad," and he didn't.
Crocs can NOW be regarded as turn-of-the-century "classics"
Hi, I would very much like to know what your opinion is on the Loro Piana Open and or Summer walks. Even though they might not be considered a trend anymore since they have been around for quite some time now. Also because they have been worn by mostly classically styled men such as Sergio Loro Piana. Keep up the great work!
Thank goodness you saved me from a bad shoe day
We're here to help! ;)
This speaker educated a lot! Dozens new words for me.
Only place for square toe is in riding cowboy boots. Many custom made or luxury brand and often extremely high quality cowboy boots have square toe as it’s a very traditional look for a working cowboy or western horseman. I have a pair of very high end working cowboy boots by luccesee that I ride in and they are exquisite; however my black elephant leather dress boots are a nice round toe and pair perfectly with a suit… in Texas that is lol.
Avoid those keen and teva sandals unless you are at the beach, hiking or mountain biking. The epitome of Frankenstein sandals.
The only thing croc style shoes are good for is slipping on to run out side to grab something, running recycling to the curb..that's it.
Thank you so much for this video. It was much needed🙏🙏🙏
I agree with all of your thoughtful advice EXCEPT for your caveat against all-black sneakers. One needs to consider carefully at the lines any shoe lends to the foot regardless of whether the sole contrasts with the upper, and there are plenty of black-on-black sneakers (e.g. the classic all-black leather Converse All-Star low-top) that can serve as a confident and classic minimalist counterpoint adding to a well thought-out and stylish casual ensemble.
Agreed. I do think the point was more towards full black attires, but I totally agree that fully black sneakers definitely has their place.
@@TheSultan1470 It all just boils down to taste. Sneakers in general are not even in the category of classic menswear, so there aren't really many guidelines to go by.
I personally prefer a few different shades of color on my sneakers, much like the ones Kyle was wearing with the brown details breaking up the surface of the shoes.
Honestly I use my slides when I'm home really but I believe it acceptable anytime when it's like over 90 degrees outside,maybe picking up the mail but with jeans,trousers in everyday life it is frustrating to look at.
Oh I ain't skippin' them kitchen shoes, they're mad comfortable 😅😂
Frankenshoes make sense if the sole has a heel block made of foam that looks exactly like a heel block dress shoe.
Sliders, not good. With socks? Quick, pass me a bucket!
Agree with all, except the jacquard Taft. I like those.
I love your guy's videos and want to challenge you. If you can, do a video on how to style cowboy boots with a suit please. It's been done for decades or almost a century in America but with almost no good guides and I think it would be interesting to hear how you guys would go about it.
A lot of fair points but there are far less “bad” embellishments then good. Things like prints, caps, studs, crimps, give that little extra flair. Like everything red carpet, it’s the exception, not the majority.
Yes. I own a pair of Crocs. But they are only used for gardening. 🤣
Crocs are goated
Hate crocs
Love a classic Danish clog! Top tier gardening shoe.
Thank you for saying it! Wonderful content ,as usual. That said, I love my franken shoes. I have the soles painted to look like leather and wear them when I am on rainy walks with my wife. I would never wear them anywhere else. Yes, I have proper rain gear but on lightly raining days my franken shoes sport a nice look and keep my feet dry. Also Black Sneakers have a place for those who work jobs where they would ruin dress shoes and work boots are not practical. Some peoples work require a dress code but the work they do does not pay enough and is too demanding on foot wear to afford a more stylish shoe, here the black sneaker has a home.
Right with you Kyle. My generation has seen platforms and roller coaster soles on shoes as well as brands like Jellies, Crayons, and now Crock’s. Hopefully this latest trend will suffer the same fate. And we’ll look back and future generations will look at pictures and laugh at the ones who wore them.
I dread buying shoes.
I'm a cobbler's worst nightmare. I have a wide ball, a high arch, and a narrow heel (I think Mom might've smoked during the pregnancy).
I agree with a lot of these points, yet I also have to look with jealous longing at some of the classic shoes so cruelly displayed.
☹
Try Mephisto. Not only do they make probably the best shoes in the world, aka, they're hand made in France, super high quality full grain leathers, super durable, have a cushioning system even in the dress shoes, air-soft tech insole and no synthetic materials, but also they're especially well known for making the shoes adapted to your gait and type of foot too. I have a narrow heel and very high arch. Mephisto offer great stability at the heel and even the loafers and oxfords they make are adapted to all foot types. Hope this helps! P.S. i have the Mephisto Melchior for work and the Thomas in white as a classy sneaker. Both are super comfortable.
I love the look of espadrilles but I can't wear them. The bridges on my feet are too high up. It's a shame.
All Black Trainers are a MUST if you plan to work to make a living. They are the foundation and precursor to every other type of outfit
I stand by my all-black trainers
I like black-on-black trainers too; where I live, white-soled sneakers are simply impractical, and I don’t find them automatically more stylish.
I wear only loafers and I do not like embellishments. Among the embellishments I don't like are tassels, horse-bits, and penny-loafer straps.
Yup. They look ridiculous.
I do to prefer minimalistic loafers too. Tassels are a horror imo. I like leather loafers with a woven structure. My favourite model is the Herrera from Magnanni. They're comfy and a piece of art.
Very informative. And i agree with almost everything you said.
Would be interesting to know what you think about white sneakers.
A point I'd make about "gaudier" shoes: while bedazzling and gilding never look good (I have cut and removed such decorations from newly-bought shoes before), I have to slightly disagree on the patterned fabric shoes. While it's not a look every one can pull off, it isn't for every occasion, and it's certainly controversial, I actually like the specific shoe you showed at 9:54. It brings to mind baroque Versailles, and as a fashion history nerd I appreciate it 😄 For someone with a more flamboyant style it can work as a statement piece. Much like in feminine fashion, if you wear a statement piece like a big necklace or chunky earrings the rest of your outfit and accessories are more subdued so as not to dilute focus from that statement piece. "Less is more" is a golden rule, but rules can be broken as long as one's deliberate about it and the rest of the outfit communicates the intention that the questionable piece is meant to be there. Funky shoes can be just another accessory to play with in an outfit. But I guess this is where personal style comes into play, and where individuals would decide to bend style guidelines to have fun with their outfits and choose to either stand out or blend in. Because clothes are meant to be practical, but fashion is meant to be fun 🥳
Dress shoes are to men what high heels are to women: stylish, classy designs that many love the classic look of, but that require sacrifices in terms of comfort. I cheat - to and from the office/event, it's Nike, adidas , Saucony etc: ultra comfortable, grippy outsoles for wet/slippery surfaces. But in the office or just before the event, well it's the Crockett & Jones / Carmina / Trickers etc.
Kyle, what would be the best formal shoe for a large set guy which is both stylish and comfortable. I like mon straps and have gotten many compliments on it, but its an uncomfortable nightmare especially if worn long hours. Do you have a recommended brand that is both stylish and comfortable? Thank you and keep up the great work!
Maybe off topic for this video, but one thing I hate are toecaps on a true closed lace Oxford. Toecaps on an open lace blucher or derby is fine, but due to the higher status of oxfords being the correct shoe for more formal wear, I think the toe cap is distracting.
The stem of my rant is from spending days online trying to find a closed lace Oxford with no toecap that is not patent leather for a morning suit. Virtually impossible without going bespoke or spending almost as much as bespoke for an off the shelf size.
It sounds like you're searching for a wholecut Oxford - there are several brands that offer them, with a few listed here: www.gentlemansgazette.com/oxford-shoes-guide/?
i agree with most of the topics but i have to disagree with the review of the sock shoes. Yes they look too futuristic for a classy outfit but i believe the comfort + practicality while maintaining a certain level of sobriety in the design (specially the ones that does not have a huge rubber insole strapped onto it) must be one of the greatest additions to futuristic sport outfits lately
I love this video hard. These shoes don't belong in fashion settings
Cole Haan frankenshoes are great if you want comfort in a business casual type work environment
They are the best. You just can’t beat them for comfort.
Excellent video...spot on...
But when you put the crocs in sport mode you would be zooming
MORE KYLE VIDEOS!
Wouldn't be caught Dead, let alone Alive! In these shoes! No Rockabilly guy would ever wear these! Two tone dress shoes!!
As a classic og sneaker head Gangster... you are 💯 percent right ...
I have a rack full of quality dress shoes that fit properly. It's not accurate to say they're as comfortable as something like a pair of Yeezys. I also have a rack full of those. They're excellent for those of us with bad feet.
It's weird to say that black sneakers are not classic because sneakers in general have only been around for around 150 years
Crocks are popular in the medical/care field as they are easy to clean --and I think that is their proper place...
Why does it bother people what they wear?
Can you post Companies that are wide foot friendly? Plz
Allen Edmonds have a few but out of my price range. For a started check into the Dunham brand. They were owned by new balance. Now Rockport ownes them.
Nothing like a nice pair of formal crocs.
I look at current trends in footwear and fashion...and it's just NO from me. Luckily I'm at an age now where i literally don't care anymore what's "hip".
If there's one thing I hate, it's the squishy soled shoes! So disproportionate, especially when I see, tiny Asian girls wearing them, I just think, do you not see yourself 🙄
Style is subjective. They probably think you're unstylish.
@@MayTheSchwartzBeWithYou That is a fair assumption, and I do agree with you there